Right From The Start
From Failing Fast to Succeeding Sooner
Alan Albert

marketfit.com

alan@marketfit.com
linkedin.com/in/alanalbert

@a_albert

#values-first
What are our most difficult product challenges?
?
Your job is hard!
I expect my current efforts
will eventually succeed
will ultimately fail
The real problem
Most of the time, we fail
We fail a lot!
More than 80% fail
Startups
Products
Services
Features
We’re not even aware we’re going to fail
There’s a lot of waste
More than $29B spent per year
creating features used rarely or never
Source: Pendo 2019 Feature Adoption Report
We’ve got some serious problems to fix
Product Creation Process
The Process of Design Squiggle by Damien Newman, thedesignsquiggle.com
Two distinct phases
Discovery Optimization
What’s wrong with how we do Discovery?
Too much

time to learn
money to design and build
Too few

leading indicators
signs we’re on the wrong track
These are serious problems to fix
The waste is here…
The Process of Design Squiggle by Damien Newman, thedesignsquiggle.com
What if we could start here?
What if instead of struggling with priorities…
We all agreed
on the same
North Star?
You’re probably skeptical
You may be thinking...
This sounds a lot like waterfall
It probably takes too long
It sounds hard
What if a different approach doesn’t work?
Why am I calling for a new approach?
I’ve been there…
$1B
I’ve been there…and failed, repeatedly
$1B
A story of failure



[ mine ]
“ You're going on an apology tour! ”
Bugs?
Missing features?
Slow performance?
Hard to use?
Discovering where we went wrong
Bugs? No
Missing features? No
Slow performance? No
Hard to use? No
Discovering where we went wrong
What I learned…
sparked the journey that led me here today
Over the last several years, I’ve been exploring...
Why so much waste and failure?
How to fail less, succeed faster?
What do successful teams do?
You can achieve success, faster
Once you gain
tools and skills
We’re on the cusp of another shift
Toyota - Reduce Manufacturing Waste → Quality
Agile - Reduce Coding Waste → Feedback
Lean - Reduce Optimization Waste → Speed
Toyota Manufacturing Waste Quality
Agile Coding Waste Feedback
Lean Optimization Waste Speed
We’re on the cusp of another shift
Toyota - Reduce Manufacturing Waste → Quality
Agile - Reduce Coding Waste → Feedback
Lean - Reduce Optimization Waste → Speed
Toyota Manufacturing Waste Quality
Agile Coding Waste Feedback
Lean Optimization Waste Speed
??? Discovery Waste Success
We have a choice
Are you ready?
How can we improve our 

Product Creation process?
Our current Product Creation process
The Process of Design Squiggle by Damien Newman, thedesignsquiggle.com
Two distinct phases
Discovery Optimization
Where do we spend most of our time?
Discovery Optimization
Where do we spend most of our time?
Discovery Optimization
We often never find the right direction
What are we doing here?
What are we doing here?
Design
Build
Measure
Repeat
If this is the best way…
Why does it…
Cost so much time & money?
Fail so often?
Design the wrong thing
Build the wrong thing
Measure to see if it works
Repeat, hoping for better
What kinds of waste happen here?
Not Enough Features
Wrong Features
Broken Features
Doesn’t Work
Doesn’t Solve the Problem
Poor Marketing
Bad Sales Process
Why do products fail?
Not Enough Features
Wrong Features
Broken Features
Doesn’t Work
Doesn’t Solve the Problem
Poor Marketing
Bad Sales Process
Why do products fail?
What do we know at the end?
…that we didn’t know at the start?
Here we know why
Why they were interested
Why they came
Why they tried
Why they bought
Why they recommended
Why they left
?
How do we find our way out of here?
What’s really inside this box?
?
Your customers
What’s really inside this box?
Why not measure your customers directly?
This is not about
Just talking to customers
Asking about their problems
Finding the job to be done
Building what they ask for
Showing your idea, design, or product
Measuring how they react
This is about finding a way to discover
what drives your customers’ decision making
This is about finding a way to discover
the values that drive their decision making
If Henry Ford had...
asked what customers want
“Faster horse”
If Henry Ford had...
asked what customers want discovered what customers value
“Faster horse” “Get me there fast”
“Keep me dry”
“Stop paying for hay”
If Steve Jobs had...
asked what customers want
“Faster CPU, more memory”
“More ports & peripherals”
If Steve Jobs had...
asked what customers want discovered what customers value
“Faster CPU, more memory”
“More ports & peripherals”
“Light enough to carry all day”
“Power that lasts all day”
How can we do better at Discovery?
Not Enough Features
Missing Features
Wrong Features
Doesn’t Work
Doesn’t Solve the Problem
Poor Marketing
Bad Sales Process
Why do products fail?
Not Enough Features
Missing Features
Wrong Features
Doesn’t Work
Doesn’t Solve the Problem
Poor Marketing
Bad Sales Process
Why do products fail?
Not enough customers
find them valuable enough
What makes your product valuable?
?
What makes your product valuable?
Your customers
What makes your product valuable?
Customer
Perception of Value
If they value your product,
then it is valuable
If they don’t value your product,
then it’s not valuable
Understanding Customer Perception of Value
• Definition
• Segmentation
• Value Layers
• Audiences
• Context
• Differentiation
• Lots more…
A very quick tour
For another day
What are customer values?
What people care about in a particular context
The “why” that makes them buy
• Preferences, reasons & criteria
• Motivations, goals & aspirations
• Fears, concerns & worries
• Limits, standards & ideals
People with different values react differently to the same product
The same basic product…
Can be targeted at people with different values
New definition of Market Segment
People who share
the same perception of what’s most valuable
Choose your target market segment
Choose your target market segment carefully
Large audience with shared values
Choose your target market segment carefully
Large audience with shared values
Small audience with shared values
Value Layer
Product or Feature
Solution Type
Problem / 

Job to be Done
Role / Identity
Customer Values exist in different layers
Example: Value Layers for AirBNB
Value Layer Example
Product or Feature Online Apartment Booking
Solution Type Online Marketplace
Problem / 

Job to be Done
Find a Place to Stay
Role / Identity Experiential Traveler
Value Layer Example
Product or Feature Online Apartment Booking
Solution Type Online Marketplace
Problem / 

Job to be Done
Find a Place to Stay
Role / Identity Experiential Traveler
Example: Value Layers for AirBNB
Ways they know it’s great
when they see it
Why they want it
Successful products focus on specific values
Value Layer Example Values
Product or Feature Online Apartment Booking
Accuracy of Description,
Completeness of Photos
Solution Type Online Marketplace
Number of Listings,
Searchability
Problem / 

Job to be Done
Find a Place to Stay Comfort, Price
Role / Identity Experiential Traveler
Local Experiences, 

Low Risk
Value Layers determine how innovative you can be
Value Layer Example
Product or Feature Online Apartment Booking
Solution Type Online Marketplace
Problem / 

Job to be Done
Find a Place to Stay
Role / Identity Experiential Traveler
Incremental Disruptive
Audiences
Each audience perceives value differently
Buyers /
Purchasers
Evaluators Decision Makers
Scouts /
Influencers
Users Approvers
Context
Perception of Value changes throughout the customer journey
Awareness Consideration Purchase Usage Advocacy
Putting it all together
Customer values 

at each layer
drive decisions 

for a specific audience
in a specific segment
in a particular context
Values-First Design for Product-Market Fit
CUSTOMER
VALUES
PRODUCT
VALUES
MARKETING
“PROMISE OF
VALUE”
PRODUCT
- MARKET
FIT
Applying the concepts of 

Customer Perception of Value
To get to the top of a market segment
We try to excel at satisfying all our target customers’ values
We must be sub-par at something
But we can’t excel at everything
If we choose to be sub-par at less important values
If we choose to be sub-par at less important values
We save time & money and reduce waste
We can excel at satisfying our customers’ top values
This is what winning companies do
Deliver a tightly focused set of values to a large market
More features ≠ more value
Adding features often reduces value
Disruptive innovations omit “essential” features 

to deliver exceptional value
No EvidenceNo TaxiNo HotelNo Keyboard No Gas Engine
You can create value by amplifying 

customers’ shared top values
Get fit at home
Find community
Energy
Stamina
Help me look good
Find my next job
Or you can create value by minimizing 

customers’ shared negative values
Less Fat Zero Calories No Tears
The top 1 - 3 values drive most customer decisions
Safety PerformanceEconomy
Being Green
But not so fast!
Don’t guess at your customers’ values
You’ll likely be wrong
Discovering customer values is hard
How can we do it reliably?
Some ways we’ve tried to do Discovery
Surveys
Talk to customers
Focus groups
Anthropological research
Product testing
A/B tests
Product analytics
We need a different approach,
focused on
Customer Perception of Value
Value Discovery Research
To discover customer values, we can’t just guess
We must get better at asking questions
…and get better at listening
We must focus exclusively on discovering values
one audience at a time…
Buyers /
Purchasers
Evaluators Decision Makers
Scouts /
Influencers
Users Approvers
We must focus exclusively on discovering values
one context at a time
Awareness Consideration Purchase Usage Advocacy
Interviewing for Customer Perception of Value
1. Ask them to describe their past behavior in your chosen context
2. Then ask about their thinking throughout that part of the journey
Interviewing for Customer Perception of Value
1. Ask them to describe their past behavior in your chosen context
2. Then ask about their thinking throughout that part of the journey
• Listen for how they made their decision, which values mattered most
• Don’t mention any features or your ideas
• Focus on discovering why. Don’t ask “why” or mention “values”
Value Discovery Interviewing Tips
Don’t pay interviewees Talk only to people who care
Use surveys to screen interviewees Gain insight with live interviews
Let them use their own words Avoid yes/no, a/b or forced choices
Don’t mention your product or feature Learn what they care about
Quantify the intensity of their values Learn which values matter most
Don’t disagree, prove or sell Learn what they think
Customer Perception of Value Mini-Workshop
1. Ask a neighbour to name a recent considered purchase
2. Ask them to describe their buying behavior in detail, start to finish
Ask only about the past — not the present or future
3. Ask about their thinking along the journey they described
Listen
What led them to do the things that they did?
How did they go about evaluating and arriving at their final decision?
Listen carefully for their values and be empathetic!
Your insights into Perception of Value
You have new tools & skills
Congratulations!
What have we learned?
Values first!
Values are discoverable
You don’t need a product, feature,
wireframe or even an idea
It’s actually better if you don’t
Traditional Discovery vs. Value Discovery
Instead of We can now
Instead of trying to excel at everything
We can excel at satisfying our customers’ top values
Measuring our progress
Instead of We can now
Design → Build → Measure Measure values first 

Design → Build → Measure
Maximizing Customer Perception of Value
A North Star
we can all
focus on
We’re not done yet...
How can you make this work at work?
Starting with value discovery
Start small
Be curious
Collaborate
Reduce bias
Iterate
Sharing your experience
What works
What doesn’t
Questions
Answers
We’re on a journey
Toyota Manufacturing Waste → Quality
Agile Coding Waste → Feedback
Lean Optimization Waste → Speed
Values First Discovery Waste → Success
Remember...
Your job is hard!
You now have new values-first tools and skills
Your job is great!
Right From The Start
From Failing Fast to Succeeding Sooner
Alan Albert

marketfit.com

alan@marketfit.com
linkedin.com/in/alanalbert

@a_albert

#values-first

Right from the Start : From Failing Fast to Succeeding Sooner - Alan Albert at ProductCamp Portland 2020

  • 1.
    Right From TheStart From Failing Fast to Succeeding Sooner Alan Albert marketfit.com alan@marketfit.com linkedin.com/in/alanalbert @a_albert #values-first
  • 2.
    What are ourmost difficult product challenges? ?
  • 3.
  • 4.
    I expect mycurrent efforts will eventually succeed will ultimately fail
  • 5.
    The real problem Mostof the time, we fail
  • 6.
    We fail alot! More than 80% fail Startups Products Services Features
  • 7.
    We’re not evenaware we’re going to fail
  • 8.
    There’s a lotof waste More than $29B spent per year creating features used rarely or never Source: Pendo 2019 Feature Adoption Report
  • 9.
    We’ve got someserious problems to fix
  • 10.
    Product Creation Process TheProcess of Design Squiggle by Damien Newman, thedesignsquiggle.com
  • 11.
  • 12.
    What’s wrong withhow we do Discovery? Too much time to learn money to design and build Too few leading indicators signs we’re on the wrong track
  • 13.
    These are seriousproblems to fix
  • 14.
    The waste ishere… The Process of Design Squiggle by Damien Newman, thedesignsquiggle.com
  • 15.
    What if wecould start here?
  • 16.
    What if insteadof struggling with priorities… We all agreed on the same North Star?
  • 17.
  • 18.
    You may bethinking...
  • 19.
    This sounds alot like waterfall
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
    What if adifferent approach doesn’t work?
  • 23.
    Why am Icalling for a new approach?
  • 24.
  • 25.
    I’ve been there…andfailed, repeatedly $1B
  • 26.
    A story offailure
 
 [ mine ]
  • 27.
    “ You're goingon an apology tour! ”
  • 28.
    Bugs? Missing features? Slow performance? Hardto use? Discovering where we went wrong
  • 29.
    Bugs? No Missing features?No Slow performance? No Hard to use? No Discovering where we went wrong
  • 30.
    What I learned… sparkedthe journey that led me here today
  • 31.
    Over the lastseveral years, I’ve been exploring... Why so much waste and failure? How to fail less, succeed faster? What do successful teams do?
  • 32.
    You can achievesuccess, faster Once you gain tools and skills
  • 33.
    We’re on thecusp of another shift Toyota - Reduce Manufacturing Waste → Quality Agile - Reduce Coding Waste → Feedback Lean - Reduce Optimization Waste → Speed Toyota Manufacturing Waste Quality Agile Coding Waste Feedback Lean Optimization Waste Speed
  • 34.
    We’re on thecusp of another shift Toyota - Reduce Manufacturing Waste → Quality Agile - Reduce Coding Waste → Feedback Lean - Reduce Optimization Waste → Speed Toyota Manufacturing Waste Quality Agile Coding Waste Feedback Lean Optimization Waste Speed ??? Discovery Waste Success
  • 35.
    We have achoice
  • 36.
  • 37.
    How can weimprove our 
 Product Creation process?
  • 38.
    Our current ProductCreation process The Process of Design Squiggle by Damien Newman, thedesignsquiggle.com
  • 39.
  • 40.
    Where do wespend most of our time? Discovery Optimization
  • 41.
    Where do wespend most of our time? Discovery Optimization
  • 42.
    We often neverfind the right direction
  • 43.
    What are wedoing here?
  • 44.
    What are wedoing here? Design Build Measure Repeat
  • 45.
    If this isthe best way… Why does it… Cost so much time & money? Fail so often?
  • 46.
    Design the wrongthing Build the wrong thing Measure to see if it works Repeat, hoping for better What kinds of waste happen here?
  • 47.
    Not Enough Features WrongFeatures Broken Features Doesn’t Work Doesn’t Solve the Problem Poor Marketing Bad Sales Process Why do products fail?
  • 48.
    Not Enough Features WrongFeatures Broken Features Doesn’t Work Doesn’t Solve the Problem Poor Marketing Bad Sales Process Why do products fail?
  • 49.
    What do weknow at the end? …that we didn’t know at the start?
  • 50.
    Here we knowwhy Why they were interested Why they came Why they tried Why they bought Why they recommended Why they left
  • 51.
    ? How do wefind our way out of here?
  • 52.
  • 53.
  • 54.
    Why not measureyour customers directly?
  • 55.
    This is notabout Just talking to customers Asking about their problems Finding the job to be done Building what they ask for Showing your idea, design, or product Measuring how they react
  • 56.
    This is aboutfinding a way to discover what drives your customers’ decision making
  • 57.
    This is aboutfinding a way to discover the values that drive their decision making
  • 58.
    If Henry Fordhad... asked what customers want “Faster horse”
  • 59.
    If Henry Fordhad... asked what customers want discovered what customers value “Faster horse” “Get me there fast” “Keep me dry” “Stop paying for hay”
  • 60.
    If Steve Jobshad... asked what customers want “Faster CPU, more memory” “More ports & peripherals”
  • 61.
    If Steve Jobshad... asked what customers want discovered what customers value “Faster CPU, more memory” “More ports & peripherals” “Light enough to carry all day” “Power that lasts all day”
  • 62.
    How can wedo better at Discovery?
  • 63.
    Not Enough Features MissingFeatures Wrong Features Doesn’t Work Doesn’t Solve the Problem Poor Marketing Bad Sales Process Why do products fail?
  • 64.
    Not Enough Features MissingFeatures Wrong Features Doesn’t Work Doesn’t Solve the Problem Poor Marketing Bad Sales Process Why do products fail? Not enough customers find them valuable enough
  • 65.
    What makes yourproduct valuable? ?
  • 66.
    What makes yourproduct valuable? Your customers
  • 67.
    What makes yourproduct valuable? Customer Perception of Value If they value your product, then it is valuable If they don’t value your product, then it’s not valuable
  • 68.
    Understanding Customer Perceptionof Value • Definition • Segmentation • Value Layers • Audiences • Context • Differentiation • Lots more… A very quick tour For another day
  • 69.
    What are customervalues? What people care about in a particular context The “why” that makes them buy • Preferences, reasons & criteria • Motivations, goals & aspirations • Fears, concerns & worries • Limits, standards & ideals
  • 70.
    People with differentvalues react differently to the same product
  • 71.
    The same basicproduct…
  • 72.
    Can be targetedat people with different values
  • 73.
    New definition ofMarket Segment People who share the same perception of what’s most valuable
  • 74.
    Choose your targetmarket segment
  • 75.
    Choose your targetmarket segment carefully Large audience with shared values
  • 76.
    Choose your targetmarket segment carefully Large audience with shared values Small audience with shared values
  • 77.
    Value Layer Product orFeature Solution Type Problem / 
 Job to be Done Role / Identity Customer Values exist in different layers
  • 78.
    Example: Value Layersfor AirBNB Value Layer Example Product or Feature Online Apartment Booking Solution Type Online Marketplace Problem / 
 Job to be Done Find a Place to Stay Role / Identity Experiential Traveler
  • 79.
    Value Layer Example Productor Feature Online Apartment Booking Solution Type Online Marketplace Problem / 
 Job to be Done Find a Place to Stay Role / Identity Experiential Traveler Example: Value Layers for AirBNB Ways they know it’s great when they see it Why they want it
  • 80.
    Successful products focuson specific values Value Layer Example Values Product or Feature Online Apartment Booking Accuracy of Description, Completeness of Photos Solution Type Online Marketplace Number of Listings, Searchability Problem / 
 Job to be Done Find a Place to Stay Comfort, Price Role / Identity Experiential Traveler Local Experiences, Low Risk
  • 81.
    Value Layers determinehow innovative you can be Value Layer Example Product or Feature Online Apartment Booking Solution Type Online Marketplace Problem / 
 Job to be Done Find a Place to Stay Role / Identity Experiential Traveler Incremental Disruptive
  • 82.
    Audiences Each audience perceivesvalue differently Buyers / Purchasers Evaluators Decision Makers Scouts / Influencers Users Approvers
  • 83.
    Context Perception of Valuechanges throughout the customer journey Awareness Consideration Purchase Usage Advocacy
  • 84.
    Putting it alltogether Customer values at each layer drive decisions for a specific audience in a specific segment in a particular context
  • 85.
    Values-First Design forProduct-Market Fit CUSTOMER VALUES PRODUCT VALUES MARKETING “PROMISE OF VALUE” PRODUCT - MARKET FIT
  • 86.
    Applying the conceptsof 
 Customer Perception of Value
  • 87.
    To get tothe top of a market segment We try to excel at satisfying all our target customers’ values
  • 88.
    We must besub-par at something But we can’t excel at everything
  • 89.
    If we chooseto be sub-par at less important values
  • 90.
    If we chooseto be sub-par at less important values We save time & money and reduce waste
  • 91.
    We can excelat satisfying our customers’ top values
  • 92.
    This is whatwinning companies do Deliver a tightly focused set of values to a large market
  • 93.
    More features ≠more value Adding features often reduces value
  • 94.
    Disruptive innovations omit“essential” features 
 to deliver exceptional value No EvidenceNo TaxiNo HotelNo Keyboard No Gas Engine
  • 95.
    You can createvalue by amplifying 
 customers’ shared top values Get fit at home Find community Energy Stamina Help me look good Find my next job
  • 96.
    Or you cancreate value by minimizing 
 customers’ shared negative values Less Fat Zero Calories No Tears
  • 97.
    The top 1- 3 values drive most customer decisions Safety PerformanceEconomy Being Green
  • 98.
    But not sofast! Don’t guess at your customers’ values You’ll likely be wrong
  • 99.
    Discovering customer valuesis hard How can we do it reliably?
  • 100.
    Some ways we’vetried to do Discovery Surveys Talk to customers Focus groups Anthropological research Product testing A/B tests Product analytics We need a different approach, focused on Customer Perception of Value
  • 101.
  • 102.
    To discover customervalues, we can’t just guess
  • 103.
    We must getbetter at asking questions
  • 104.
    …and get betterat listening
  • 105.
    We must focusexclusively on discovering values one audience at a time… Buyers / Purchasers Evaluators Decision Makers Scouts / Influencers Users Approvers
  • 106.
    We must focusexclusively on discovering values one context at a time Awareness Consideration Purchase Usage Advocacy
  • 107.
    Interviewing for CustomerPerception of Value 1. Ask them to describe their past behavior in your chosen context 2. Then ask about their thinking throughout that part of the journey
  • 108.
    Interviewing for CustomerPerception of Value 1. Ask them to describe their past behavior in your chosen context 2. Then ask about their thinking throughout that part of the journey • Listen for how they made their decision, which values mattered most • Don’t mention any features or your ideas • Focus on discovering why. Don’t ask “why” or mention “values”
  • 109.
    Value Discovery InterviewingTips Don’t pay interviewees Talk only to people who care Use surveys to screen interviewees Gain insight with live interviews Let them use their own words Avoid yes/no, a/b or forced choices Don’t mention your product or feature Learn what they care about Quantify the intensity of their values Learn which values matter most Don’t disagree, prove or sell Learn what they think
  • 110.
    Customer Perception ofValue Mini-Workshop 1. Ask a neighbour to name a recent considered purchase 2. Ask them to describe their buying behavior in detail, start to finish Ask only about the past — not the present or future 3. Ask about their thinking along the journey they described Listen What led them to do the things that they did? How did they go about evaluating and arriving at their final decision? Listen carefully for their values and be empathetic!
  • 111.
    Your insights intoPerception of Value
  • 112.
    You have newtools & skills Congratulations!
  • 113.
    What have welearned?
  • 114.
    Values first! Values arediscoverable You don’t need a product, feature, wireframe or even an idea It’s actually better if you don’t
  • 115.
    Traditional Discovery vs.Value Discovery Instead of We can now
  • 116.
    Instead of tryingto excel at everything
  • 117.
    We can excelat satisfying our customers’ top values
  • 118.
    Measuring our progress Insteadof We can now Design → Build → Measure Measure values first 
 Design → Build → Measure
  • 119.
    Maximizing Customer Perceptionof Value A North Star we can all focus on
  • 120.
  • 121.
    How can youmake this work at work?
  • 122.
    Starting with valuediscovery Start small Be curious Collaborate Reduce bias Iterate
  • 123.
    Sharing your experience Whatworks What doesn’t Questions Answers
  • 124.
    We’re on ajourney Toyota Manufacturing Waste → Quality Agile Coding Waste → Feedback Lean Optimization Waste → Speed Values First Discovery Waste → Success
  • 125.
  • 126.
  • 127.
    You now havenew values-first tools and skills
  • 128.
  • 129.
    Right From TheStart From Failing Fast to Succeeding Sooner Alan Albert marketfit.com alan@marketfit.com linkedin.com/in/alanalbert @a_albert #values-first