Renewable energy certificates (RECs) represent 1,000 kilowatt-hours of renewable energy generated. RECs can be sold separately from the underlying energy. RECs are purchased by energy suppliers and firms to comply with Renewable Portfolio Standards, which require a portion of energy come from renewable sources. RECs are traded in compliance and voluntary markets, with prices in compliance markets influenced by RPS policies. RECs help develop renewable energy by providing revenue guarantees for generators, connecting demand and supply, and increasing investments in renewable facilities. However, RECs depend heavily on RPS and price volatility poses challenges.
Guarantees of Origin webinar Leonardo Energy 13 November 2017Dirk Van Evercooren
This is the presentation I used in a webinar for Leonardo Energy on 13 November 2017. It's about how Guarantees of Origin work and how they make green energy contracts reliable. Corporate electricity consumers now adopt sustainability strategies, choosing only electricity from renewable sources. Some go further and engage in Renewable Power Purchasing Agreements. In both cases, Guarantees of Origin are instrumental.
The value of Guarantees of Origin: empowering consumers in the energy transitionLeonardo ENERGY
The Guarantee of Origin (GO) is a crucial instrument for the widening business strategy for clean power. The Association of Issuing Bodies (AIB) has created and operates the European Energy Certificate System (EECS) to harmonise the functioning of the GO-systems. The AIB is a ‘not for profit’ membership organisation consisting of national GO issuing bodies. We have also established an electronic Hub for efficiently transferring GOs across the European market. The Hub enables full traceability and transparency and ensures in a cost-effective way, ensuring that there will never be double-selling or double-counting of renewable GOs within this system. There are now already 20 active AIB member countries – all of which are fully EECS compliant.
November 21, 2013 | Next Steps: Financing solar for your business | James Ton...Fresh Energy
For many businesses and property owners, the high upfront cost of solar photovoltaic systems remains the single largest barrier to adoption. The solution? Solar financing. Fresh Energy’s solar financing event, the final installment of a three-part Solar Opportunities Series, will introduce participants to the range of current and emerging solar-financing options available in Minnesota. Learn more at fresh-energy.org/solarseries.
Guarantees of Origin webinar Leonardo Energy 13 November 2017Dirk Van Evercooren
This is the presentation I used in a webinar for Leonardo Energy on 13 November 2017. It's about how Guarantees of Origin work and how they make green energy contracts reliable. Corporate electricity consumers now adopt sustainability strategies, choosing only electricity from renewable sources. Some go further and engage in Renewable Power Purchasing Agreements. In both cases, Guarantees of Origin are instrumental.
The value of Guarantees of Origin: empowering consumers in the energy transitionLeonardo ENERGY
The Guarantee of Origin (GO) is a crucial instrument for the widening business strategy for clean power. The Association of Issuing Bodies (AIB) has created and operates the European Energy Certificate System (EECS) to harmonise the functioning of the GO-systems. The AIB is a ‘not for profit’ membership organisation consisting of national GO issuing bodies. We have also established an electronic Hub for efficiently transferring GOs across the European market. The Hub enables full traceability and transparency and ensures in a cost-effective way, ensuring that there will never be double-selling or double-counting of renewable GOs within this system. There are now already 20 active AIB member countries – all of which are fully EECS compliant.
November 21, 2013 | Next Steps: Financing solar for your business | James Ton...Fresh Energy
For many businesses and property owners, the high upfront cost of solar photovoltaic systems remains the single largest barrier to adoption. The solution? Solar financing. Fresh Energy’s solar financing event, the final installment of a three-part Solar Opportunities Series, will introduce participants to the range of current and emerging solar-financing options available in Minnesota. Learn more at fresh-energy.org/solarseries.
Small Commercial Solar: Grow Your Business With This Untapped Sectorallearthrenewables
Utility-scale solar is booming, and residential solar is on the rise, but the small-commercial solar market is still largely unrealized, despite wide open potential for growth. In this presentation, learn how to grow your business by taking advantage of this untapped sector, which some are calling the next goldmine of the solar industry.
We'll give you an overview of small commercial solar development, taking you through financing opportunities and challenges, diving into how to make small commercial solar more economical through project design and standardization, and giving you tips on how to eliminate hidden project costs and maximize your sales and installation efficiency and capability.
This is a business concept proposal for a manufacturing business that will produce very low cost solar panels based on carbon nanotube technology. We will manufacture low cost, very affordable solar panels, to enable very poor households in Africa to access electricity for the first time in their lives. The solar panels are cheaper than any other alternative, yet so robust that no skilled installation or maintenance are required.
Emerging Solar Strategies: How Innovative Companies are Using Solar to Reduce...Sustainable Brands
Photovoltaics and distributed solar generation have
redefined expectations, reduced costs, and rocked the
century-old utility business model. Solar costs have
dropped nearly 50%1 in just the past few years and
customer options are no longer limited to only a few types
of onsite systems.
Is a community solar garden subscription right for your local government?University of Minnesota
Community Solar Gardens can be an excellent opportunity for cities, counties, and other local governments to get involved in solar energy and engage community members. In this webinar, Clean Energy Resource Teams (CERTs) staff provide an overview of community solar and then dig into the details that will help you make decisions. More at http://www.cleanenergyresourceteams.org/blog/webinar-community-solar-garden-subscription-right-your-local-government
Closing the Deal - Selling Solar to Commercial CustomersAlternergy
Presentation by Rajiv Bhatia of Alternergy on how to sell solar PV to commercial customers. UK solar rooftop market, challenges & opportunities, return on investment, selling to the customer, installer success factors.
Solarize Connecticut (Solarize CT) is a pilot program designed to encourage the adoption of residential solar photovoltaic (PV) systems by deploying a coordinated education, marketing and outreach effort, combined with a tiered pricing structure that provides increased savings to homeowners as more people in one community go solar.
2012 Tutorial: Markets for Differentiated Electric Power ProductsSean Meyn
ACC 2012 Tutorial
http://accworkshop12.mit.edu
The talk will review the many services needed in today's grid, and those that will be more important in the future. It will also review recent competitive equilibrium theory for the highly dynamic markets that may emerge in tomorrow's grid. In particular, to combat volatility from increasing penetration of renewable energy resources, there will be greater need for regulation services at various time-scales. There is enormous potential to secure these ancillary services via demand response. However, there is an obsession today with the promotion of real time prices to incentivize demand response. All evidence strongly suggests that this is a bad idea: 1) In 2011, massive price swings in the real-time market generated anger in Texas and New Zealand 2) Our own research shows that this is to be expected: in a completive equilibrium real-time prices will reach the choke up price (which was recently estimated at 1/4 million dollars). With transmission constraints, our research concludes that prices can go much higher. 3) A recent EIA study shows that consumers are scared of smart meters - they do not trust utility companies to experiment with their meters, or their power bills. We must then ask, is there any motivation to focus on markets in a real-time setting? The speaker believes there is none. Explanations will be given, and alternative visions will be proposed.
RPS and RECs – Managing an Increasing Regulatory BurdenCTRM Center
Renewable energy certificates or ‘RECs’ have become the currency of the renewable power industry, allowing power providers to expand their product offerings and offer ‘green’ power irrespective of whether or not they can physically generate it. RECs also assure consumers who opt to buy renewable power, that that power has either come directly from a renewable generator, or if a renewable generator is not servicing their facility, that it is offset in the market by power from a renewable source, such as wind, solar or hydro, in another geographic area.
Small Commercial Solar: Grow Your Business With This Untapped Sectorallearthrenewables
Utility-scale solar is booming, and residential solar is on the rise, but the small-commercial solar market is still largely unrealized, despite wide open potential for growth. In this presentation, learn how to grow your business by taking advantage of this untapped sector, which some are calling the next goldmine of the solar industry.
We'll give you an overview of small commercial solar development, taking you through financing opportunities and challenges, diving into how to make small commercial solar more economical through project design and standardization, and giving you tips on how to eliminate hidden project costs and maximize your sales and installation efficiency and capability.
This is a business concept proposal for a manufacturing business that will produce very low cost solar panels based on carbon nanotube technology. We will manufacture low cost, very affordable solar panels, to enable very poor households in Africa to access electricity for the first time in their lives. The solar panels are cheaper than any other alternative, yet so robust that no skilled installation or maintenance are required.
Emerging Solar Strategies: How Innovative Companies are Using Solar to Reduce...Sustainable Brands
Photovoltaics and distributed solar generation have
redefined expectations, reduced costs, and rocked the
century-old utility business model. Solar costs have
dropped nearly 50%1 in just the past few years and
customer options are no longer limited to only a few types
of onsite systems.
Is a community solar garden subscription right for your local government?University of Minnesota
Community Solar Gardens can be an excellent opportunity for cities, counties, and other local governments to get involved in solar energy and engage community members. In this webinar, Clean Energy Resource Teams (CERTs) staff provide an overview of community solar and then dig into the details that will help you make decisions. More at http://www.cleanenergyresourceteams.org/blog/webinar-community-solar-garden-subscription-right-your-local-government
Closing the Deal - Selling Solar to Commercial CustomersAlternergy
Presentation by Rajiv Bhatia of Alternergy on how to sell solar PV to commercial customers. UK solar rooftop market, challenges & opportunities, return on investment, selling to the customer, installer success factors.
Solarize Connecticut (Solarize CT) is a pilot program designed to encourage the adoption of residential solar photovoltaic (PV) systems by deploying a coordinated education, marketing and outreach effort, combined with a tiered pricing structure that provides increased savings to homeowners as more people in one community go solar.
2012 Tutorial: Markets for Differentiated Electric Power ProductsSean Meyn
ACC 2012 Tutorial
http://accworkshop12.mit.edu
The talk will review the many services needed in today's grid, and those that will be more important in the future. It will also review recent competitive equilibrium theory for the highly dynamic markets that may emerge in tomorrow's grid. In particular, to combat volatility from increasing penetration of renewable energy resources, there will be greater need for regulation services at various time-scales. There is enormous potential to secure these ancillary services via demand response. However, there is an obsession today with the promotion of real time prices to incentivize demand response. All evidence strongly suggests that this is a bad idea: 1) In 2011, massive price swings in the real-time market generated anger in Texas and New Zealand 2) Our own research shows that this is to be expected: in a completive equilibrium real-time prices will reach the choke up price (which was recently estimated at 1/4 million dollars). With transmission constraints, our research concludes that prices can go much higher. 3) A recent EIA study shows that consumers are scared of smart meters - they do not trust utility companies to experiment with their meters, or their power bills. We must then ask, is there any motivation to focus on markets in a real-time setting? The speaker believes there is none. Explanations will be given, and alternative visions will be proposed.
RPS and RECs – Managing an Increasing Regulatory BurdenCTRM Center
Renewable energy certificates or ‘RECs’ have become the currency of the renewable power industry, allowing power providers to expand their product offerings and offer ‘green’ power irrespective of whether or not they can physically generate it. RECs also assure consumers who opt to buy renewable power, that that power has either come directly from a renewable generator, or if a renewable generator is not servicing their facility, that it is offset in the market by power from a renewable source, such as wind, solar or hydro, in another geographic area.
Introduction to the Renewable Energy Certificate (REC) MechanismSpark Network
Renewable Energy Certificate (REC) Mechanism issued by Ministry of New & Renewable Energy of India to facilitate interstate transactions of Renewable Energy and to promote RE based projects. This report covers all the basic aspects of REC Mechanism along with the Operational Framewokr of the same.
Battery storage: The next disruptive technology in the power sectorCluster TWEED
Storage prices are dropping much faster than anyone expected, due to the growing market for consumer electronics and demand for electric vehicles (EVs). Major players in Asia, Europe, and the United States are all scaling up lithium-ion manufacturing to serve EV and other power applications. No surprise, then, that battery-pack costs are down to less than $230 per kilowatt-hour in 2016, compared with almost $1,000 per kilowatt-hour in 2010.
Short Listed Paper in the Category of World Bank Conference on Making Growth ...UPES Dehradun
The World Bank through its Competitive Industries (CI) Global Practice had organized a high-level conference on
"Making Growth Happen: Implementing Policies for Competitive Industries” for which it invited submissions that would set the grounds for policy discussions on the topic of the implementation of structural transformation.
The following paper was selected in the Short Listed Papers Category on “Making Growth Happen: Implementing Policies for Competitive Industries” by the World Bank, held on 16th -17th October, 2013 in Washington DC, USA.
CFA Institute Research Challenge Hosted in Spokane, .docxcravennichole326
CFA Institute Research Challenge
Hosted in
Spokane, Washington
Eastern Washington University
Daniel Goodman, Danielle Good, Leah Robinson, and Sandra Jeffries
1
Eastern Washington University Student Research
This report is published for educational purposes only by
students competing in The CFA Institute Research Challenge
Electric & Gas Utilities, Utilities Industry
New York Stock Exchange (NYSE)
Avista Corp
Date: 1/9/2014
Ticker: AVA
Current Price: $35.48
Dividend Yield: 3.6%
Recommendation: SELL
Target Price: $25.11
Investment Highlights
We have a sell recommendation of the stock, based on target price of $25.11.
Stock is not attractive with a low historical ROE.
Stock is inflated due to zero-interest rate environment and the temporary increase in demand from
investors seeking higher yielding securities.
Heightened operational risk due to recent acquisition of a company in new geographic area.
The current winter season has had low precipitation (low snowfall), which may impact 2015 hydro-
electricity generation.
Avista Stock Information
Price (1/9/15 Closing Date) $35.48
52-Week Price Range $27.99 - $37.37
Beta (β) 0.83
Dividend 1.27 (3.70%)
Dividend Payout Ratio 40%
Book Value Per Share 23.75
ROE (ttm) 9.08 %
P/E (ttm) 11.29
EPS (ttm) 3.13
Sustainable Growth Rate 3.99%*
Source: Yahoo! Finance, Team Calculation*
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
5
-J
a
n
-0
9
5
-M
a
r-
0
9
5
-M
a
y
-0
9
5
-J
u
l-
0
9
5
-S
e
p
-0
9
5
-N
o
v-
0
9
5
-J
a
n
-1
0
5
-M
a
r-
1
0
5
-M
a
y
-1
0
5
-J
u
l-
1
0
5
-S
e
p
-1
0
5
-N
o
v-
1
0
5
-J
a
n
-1
1
5
-M
a
r-
1
1
5
-M
a
y
-1
1
5
-J
u
l-
1
1
5
-S
e
p
-1
1
5
-N
o
v-
1
1
5
-J
a
n
-1
2
5
-M
a
r-
1
2
5
-M
a
y
-1
2
5
-J
u
l-
1
2
5
-S
e
p
-1
2
5
-N
o
v-
1
2
5
-J
a
n
-1
3
5
-M
a
r-
1
3
5
-M
a
y
-1
3
5
-J
u
l-
1
3
5
-S
e
p
-1
3
5
-N
o
v-
1
3
5
-J
a
n
-1
4
5
-M
a
r-
1
4
5
-M
a
y
-1
4
5
-J
u
l-
1
4
5
-S
e
p
-1
4
5
-N
o
v-
1
4
A
v
is
ta
S
to
ck
P
ri
ce
Date
Avista's Monthly Closing Stock Price for the Last 5 Years (2009-2014)
CFA Institute Research Challenge 1/12/2014
2
Business Description
Avista Corp (AVA) is a producer and distributor of electric and natural gas
energy services to residential and commercial customers located in eastern
Washington, northern Idaho, portions of Oregon, and portions of Alaska.
Originally founded as The Washington Water Power Company, Avista established
its roots in the Inland Northwest in 1889. The company’s innovative business
practices led to the development of the first Spokane River hydroelectric
generator and state-of-the-art wind turbines on the Palouse Hills of eastern
Washington. Avista takes pride in its commitment to philanthropic practices that
enrich the communities in which the company conducts business in.
Avista consists of two business segments, Avista Utilities and th ...
What is a PPA (Power Purchase Agreement) ?
A Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) often refers to a long-term electricity supply agreement between two parties, usually between a power producer and a customer (an electricity consumer or trader). The PPA defines the conditions of the agreement, such as the amount of electricity to be supplied, negotiated prices, accounting, and penalties for non-compliance.
Since it is a bilateral agreement, a PPA can take many forms and is usually tailored to the specific application. Electricity can be supplied physically or on a balancing sheet. PPAs can be used to reduce market price risks, which is why they are frequently implemented by large electricity consumers to help reduce investment costs associated with planning or operating renewable energy plants.
Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA Power Purchase Agreement PPA
1. Tyuleubekov Sabyrzhan
Renewable energy certificates
Renewable energy certificates (RECs) are issued by renewable energy generators when
they produce 1000 kilowatt - hours. Renewable energy certificates may be sold with (so-
called bundled) or without (unbundled) underlying green energy itself. How it can be
done and what are these certificates for I will try to explain in this paper.
First of all, what are RECs? As written above, it is the statement of the renewable energy
generator that 1000 kilowatt-hours of green energy were produced and placed into the
grid. RECs are sold to energy suppliers, firms or households who want and/or need to
claim that they use renewable energy sources. The incentive for households to buy such
certificates is obvious – it is their desire to use green energy. But the reason why energy
suppliers or firms buy such certificates needs to be explained. When firm buys RECs, this
firm can claim all environmental, social, and other non-power qualities of renewable
electricity generation. In the United States, there is such regulation as Renewable
Portfolio Standard (RPS). RPS requires energy suppliers to have some fraction of their
energy to be produced from renewable energy sources. Since it is not easy for energy
suppliers to produce green energy itself, they can buy RECs and use them in order to
comply with the regulation. It is convenient for the energy suppliers, because they do
not need to produce green energy itself, this would require additional investments for
building new facilities. Some may say that it is kind of cheating. It is not, because RECs
are backed by 1000 kilowatt-hours and in the location of RECs’ issuer 1000 kilowatt-
hours of green energy are in fact used, but since electrons are indistinguishable no one
can claim that he uses pure green energy unless all energy in the grid is from renewable
energy sources (free-rider problem is discussed in later section). Likewise, RECs are
expired once they are claimed, for example, if the firm claims to the regulators that some
share of their energy is from renewable energy sources and used REC as a proof, this
certificate cannot be used again. At the point of issuance (i.e. 1000 kilowatt-hours of
green energy produced) each certificate is assigned with an identification number,
renewable fuel source (wind power, solar power etc.), geographic location of the
generator and etc. One more point, once REC is expired it cannot be sold.
Now I will explain how RECs are traded. There are two types of markets for RECs:
compliance market and voluntary market.
Compliance market is primarily for energy suppliers that need RECs in order to comply
with the regulation, by the way RPS is different in each state. Thereby, the demand in
such market will always be dependent from RPS, so the demand is inflated. Compliance
markets are created by RPS policies. In compliance markets mostly wholesale REC
transactions are involved.
2. Pricing in compliance markets depends on various factors. For instance, on RPS policy,
since there are different RPS policies in each state prices differ as well. For example, in
some states RPS policy allows RECs that are only from new renewable generators, i.e.
the facility was built after 2010 etc. such policies are implemented in order to incentivize
construction of new facilities. Furthermore, RPS may require some share of renewable
energy come from solar energy only; such regulations are implemented in order to
diversify renewable energy sources. RPS may require REC to be only from its state, so
no import of RECs is allowed. Liquidity and prices are dependent from RPS requirements
regarding the time validity of RECs. For example, RPS may require RECs to be issued not
more than one year ago, so holding RECs in the states with such RPS is lowering their
price. Magnitude of penalties for noncompliance affect prices as well, but the effect is
not big, since penalties do not vary much. Now penalties across the states vary around
50 $/MWh.
The size of compliance market in terms of energy produced is directly depends on RPS
policies in each state, but it is very likely to increase, since RPS in going to be more and
more strict. As for the size in terms of money it is more complicated to forecast the
development of the market, since prices for RECs appeared to be volatile (this issue is
addressed in the lower sections)
Voluntary market is the market where households or firms buy RECs just because they
want to use green energy. In contradistinction to compliance market, here we have
“natural” demand, which may be lower than in compliance market.
As a consequence of inflated demand in compliance market, prices in voluntary market
are lower.
In order to prevent room for issuers to cheat there are different tracking systems.
Tracking systems are verifying that into the grid 1000 kilowatt-hours of green energy
were placed. It can be even placed into the grid, which is not interconnected with the
grid of the end-user of the certificate. Since each REC has its own identification number,
the certificate is tracked by the system from the point of issuance up until the moment
of expiration, so one certificate cannot be used more than one time (by usage – claim of
using green energy is meant, certificate can be resold multiple times if it is not used). In
addition, audit can be applied in order to verify the certificate.
How do RECs contribute into the development of renewable energy generation?
First of all, via RPS investors get guarantees that RECs will be sold, since energy suppliers
give guarantees that they will buy bundled or unbundled RECs (or they may be forced to
give guarantees by RPS)
Secondly, RECs connect demand with supply, so even if in the location of the generating
facility there are no customers who would like to use and support green energy, the
3. generating facility can deliver energy into the grid, notwithstanding that customers who
will claim that they use the green energy will not actually use it.
Thirdly, RECs increase investments into facilities among households and firms. Since,
generating facilities get money without actually selling the energy itself in most cases
(unbundled RECs), so it sells the energy separately, but without emphasizing of its
source. Sale of unbundled RECs is a good stimulus to households. Because they can
install a small generating facility, for example solar panels on the roof, and use the
energy generated for their needs and also sell RECs, in case with solar panels SREC. A 10
kW facility generates around 12 SRECs annually. Actually, households are installing
mostly solar panels, since prices for SRECs are the highest. Therefore, some households
can even take loans for the installation and repay them using revenues from sold RECs.
Nevertheless, the price fluctuation is the risk, which must be estimated.
Nonetheless, RECs are very dependent on RPS. If Renewable Portfolio Standard will be
ones dropped, compliance market will disappear. Compliance market is the major
market for RECs. However, I do not think it is possible. In addition, volatile prices of RECs,
and SRECs specifically, decrease investments among households into solar panels. Prices
for SRECs fell drammatically (in August 2009 price was 690$ per SREC, and in July 2011
price plummeted to the level of 151$ per SREC) and investors had problems with
repaying loans for the panels, since now it would take them longer to repay the loan.
The price fall of SRECs explained by increased installations of solar panels among large
energy suppliers, so amount of SRECs increased and this decreased their price. On one
hand, we can see that in fact amount of installed solar panels increased, but on other
hand, it revealed volatility of prices for RECs. And we know that assets with high price
volatility are not wanted by investors.
One of the remedies for financing renewable energy projects are long-term contracts
with governmental organizations, universities or some corporations. Whereas long-term
contracts are preferred by investors, since such contracts give a form of security of
future cash flows, they are not preferred by the signees, since if prices fall, signees will
be locked with uncompetitive prices. In fact, in some states there are regulations to sign
only long term contracts for bundled/unbundled RECs if they are used in order to comply
with RPS, for example in Colorado duration of the contract must be at least 20 years, in
Nevada – 10 years.
One more problem with RECs is that they are not easy to understand, so direct
advertisement is inefficient. The whole system must be explained and marketers must
invest into it more intensively.
Another problem is that there is no established national wide market for RECs and
transations are mostly done in the regional markets. National wide market will
significantly increase liquidity in RECs market. The problem of national wide market is
different RPS policies in different states. Most states are protecting their market, by
4. imposing restrictions on import of RECs. For instance, RPS of some state can count
certificate only if it is from local facility. Likewise, in voluntary markets consumers tend
to buy local RECs, because they probably want to support local facilities and to enjoy
environmental benefits in fact.
However, free-rider problem appears. Because when people in some part of the state
are buying RECs from another part, or even another state, they do not directly get the
benefits of renewable energy, fossil-fuel plants can still be located nearby and pollute
the air, whilst, people without buying RECs, but living near the renewable energy
facilities are directly benefiting from clean air etc. Moreover, RECs conception heavily
relies on tracking systems, so in the states without tracking systems it is very difficult to
implement RECs, issue of verification is crucial. This free-rider problem is resolved by the
imposition of restrictions on importing, which in turn creates obstacles for national wide
market. The free-rider problem can be resolved more effectively by relaxing the
restriction on import. The state may allow import of RECs only with the underlying
energy, so this energy will displace the energy created by fossil-fuel plants (not displace
in fact, but the fossil-fuel plants will need to produce less energy).
To summarize, we explained what are RECs: the main purpose of RECs is compliance
with RPS. RECs are traded on two markets: voluntary and compliance. We found what
affects prices for RECs: mostly RPS policy, and obviously the amount of certificates in the
market. Then we discussed how RECs can be controlled against double-counting: by
tracking systems and/or audit. Then we discussed how RECs contribute into the
development of renewable energy generation: (1) form of guarantee for investors, (2)
matching demand and supply, (3) increased investments among households. Finally, we
discussed problems of RECs: (1) almost complete dependence from RPS, (2) difficult
concept of RECs, (3) weak national-wide market for RECs, (4) free-rider problem.
References:
- Emerging Markets for Renewable Energy Certificates: Opportunities and Challenges –
Ed Holt and Lori Bird; National Renewable Energy Laboratory NREL/TP-620-37388,
January 2005
- Solar panel investors upset as SREC values drop – Rebecca Forand; NJ.com, October
2011
- http://www.srectrade.com/srec_markets/introduction
- http://www.epa.gov/greenpower/gpmarket/tracking.htm
- http://www.epa.gov/greenpower/documents/gpp_basics-recs.pdf