Streets as Places –  Chicago, 15 th  2007
 
48 U.S. States, 6 Canadian Provinces 26 Countries 2000 Communities 2 Million visitors to our web sites (2006) 24,000 people get our electronic newsletter 32 years of Placemaking
William H. (Holly) Whyte The Organization Man, 1956 The Exploding Metropolis,  1958 The Last Landscape,  1968 Plan for the City of New York,  1969 The Social Life of Small Urban Spaces,  1980 City: Rediscovering the Center,  1988
Outline of Presentation Community/Neighborhood Planning Placemaking…What is it Why do we build our Cities around cars? Best Cities/Best Examples Qualities of Great Streets New York Campaign Transportation Paradigm Shift Placemaking Process Developing a Campaign
Designing neighborhoods with vibrant community  centers Creating shared-use streets  Providing quality public spaces that serve community needs Neighborhoods First Planning includes-
Vision for neighborhood planning … creating great public spaces Placemaking is the foundation of creating livable communities.
Vision for neighborhood planning … revitalizing centers
Vision for neighborhood planning … reshaping streets and boulevards
Environment Civic Engagement Public Health and Obesity Local Economy   Smart Growth CITIES/ PLACES Sustainable Communities Transportation Livability Historic Preservation Convergence of Community Goals
evening use volunteerism property values rent levels transit usage traffic  data mode splits parking usage patterns pedestrian activity building conditions environmental data sanitation rating crime  statistics street life social networks land-use patterns retail sales PLACE sociability local business ownership number of women,  children & elderly Cooperative Neighborliness Diversity Stewardship Pride Friendly Interactive  Welcoming Continuity Proximity Connectedness Walkable Convenient Accessible  Readability Charm Attractive Historic Spiritual Sittable Walkable Safe Clean “ Green” Sustainable Celebrations Indigenous Special Real Useful Fun Active Vital What Makes a Place Great? access & linkage comfort & image uses & activities key attributes intangibles measurements
Thoreau said “there is no value in life except what you choose to place upon it and no  happiness in any place except what you bring to it yourself.” In this light, Placemaking is a dynamic human function: it is an act of liberation, of staking claim, and of beautification; it is true human empowerment. What is Placemaking?
Placemaking is turning a neighborhood, town or city from a place you can’t wait to get through to one you never want to leave. Placemaking is creating for everybody Placemaking is the process of giving space a story that is shared by many. What is Placemaking?
New Haven: Chapel Street
 
 
 
 
If you plan for cars and traffic… you get more cars and traffic.
The erosion of cities by automobiles proceeds as a kind of nibbling. Small nibbles at first but eventually hefty bites. A street is widened here, another is straightened there, a wide avenue is converted to one way flow and more land goes into parking. No one step in this process is in itself crucial but  cumulatively the effect is enormous .   Jane Jacobs, 1954
 
 
A study of three generations of 9 year olds found that by 1990, the radius around the home that children were allowed to play had sunken to a ninth of what it had been in 1970. Richard Louv
 
© Will McWhinney, Paths of Change Storied Cultures Clustered Cultures
 
 
When you design your community  around people … you get more people.
 
London BEFORE AFTER Trafalgar Square 100 Public Spaces Program
Public Transit Enhancements Street Improvements Kensington High Street Kensington High Street Oxford Street London
ACCESS: Makes pedestrian movement safer IDENTITY: A  civic element  COMFORT: Reduces the negative impact of traffic on the surrounding communities Champs Elysees, Paris, France The Benefits of Boulevards
Barcelona-A City of Boulevards
Barcelona-A City of Boulevards
Paris-A City of Boulevards
Paris From Congested to Shared Streets in 5 years - Sidewalks widened - Buffered bike lanes  - Dedicated bus lanes
Paris-Champs Elysees
Paris-Champs Elyees
Paris-Boulevard du Montparnasse
Paris-Boulevard du Montparnasse
Paris-Side/Cross Streets
Paris-Side/Cross Streets
Paris-Sidewalk Cafe
Case Study: Paris Plage
 
 
 
Copenhagen Parking Lots Removed Gammel Strand 1988 Gammel Strand 1996
Copenhagen
Berlin
Düsseldorf-Koenigsalle
Düsseldorf-Koenigsalle
Vienna
Qualities of Great Streets Attractions & Destinations Identity & Image Active Edge Uses Amenities Management:  Central to the Solution Seasonal Strategy Diverse User Groups Traffic, Transit & the Pedestrian Blending of uses and modes Protects Neighborhoods
Attractions & Destinations Curiosity, chaos, choices, with special places, rest spots, - the art of the path.
Attractions & Destinations Clustered activity points of interest. 10+ Destinations – including food and markets, local retail, art, play, education, health/recreation .
Active Edge Uses  Active building bases
Amenities Public and private seating options Triangulation to support use – clusters of street amenities
Management -  Central to the Solution Programming – daily activity generators/cultural, civic and seasonal celebrations
Draws diverse user groups  No one group or use dominates
Traffic, Transit & the Pedestrian Walkable – Places to go Range of transportation options
New York City Street Renaissance
Donald Appleyard, UC Berkeley Professor of Urban Design, quantified the impact of traffic on social ties. HEAVY TRAFFIC 16,000 vehicles per day MEDIUM TRAFFIC 8,000 vehicles per day LIGHT TRAFFIC 2,000 vehicles per day 0.9 friends per person 3.1 acquaintances per person 1.3 friends per person 4.1 acquaintances per person 3 friends per person 6.3 acquaintances per person Broken Streets
Broken Streets I keep my  windows shut I spend more time in the back of my house I forbid my children to play in the streets I go out on the street less often LIGHT TRAFFIC STREET MEDIUM TRAFFIC STREET HEAVY TRAFFIC STREET New Yorkers deal with traffic in the following ways: 7.7% 26.0% 52.2% 56.5% 18.5% 5.1% 7.4% 21.7% 0.0% 2.6% 7.4% 43.5%
The Truth About Traffic 6% Only 6% of shopping below 59 th  Street in Manhattan involves a car. 6% DRIVE 69% WALK 24%  USE TRANSIT Shoppers Are Walkers
New York City-Herald Square
New York City-Mulry Square Fixing an Unsafe Intersection BEFORE TEST PERIOD: 1996 – 2001 AFTER: TEST MADE PERMANENT
Broadway Connecting Great Destinations Union Square Madison Square Herald Square Times Square
 
Astor Place A void between two great neighborhoods…
Astor Place … can support and showcase the best of NYC.
A funnel for downtown traffic.. Finn Square
...can be a defining space for Tribeca. Finn Square
Kenmare Square An unused square and roadway…
Kenmare Square … can become a major amenity for shoppers and residents.
West Broadway Where a shopping street fizzles…
West Broadway … it can be brought back to life.
Spring Street New York’s most successful neighborhoods…
Spring Street … can better serve the pedestrians that bring their success.
Grand Street Car storage space…
Grand Street … can become the most valuable space in the neighborhood.
Transportation paradigm shift Old Paradigm New Paradigm Large area planning Arterials Access to malls Retail market area - large Single family bedroom communities Big roads, wide intersections, and parking lots Big solutions (interstates/bypasses) Standards-based (Green Book) Performance is about mobility Small area planning Boulevards Access to corner markets Retail Market area - small Mixed residential/office/services with local businesses  Bike paths, sidewalks, narrow streets, and transit Small solutions (road connectivity, context sensitivity) Place-based  Performance is about access and sense of place
The community is the expert You are creating a place not just a design You can’t do it alone They always say it can’t be done You can see a lot just by observing Develop a placemaking vision Power of 10/Triangulation Form supports function Start with the petunias Money is not the issue You are never finished Principles of Creating Great Places Translating Ideas Into Action Implementation Planning & Outreach Techniques Underlying Ideas
Project/Discipline Driven Approach Place  Driven Development Approach
Creating Great Places/Destinations  The   Power of 10 Chicago   needs  10+   major places/destinations. Each neighborhood/downtown   needs   10+   places/destinations. Each   place/destination   must have   10+   things to do. Connect  places   to create   a  district with  100 -1000   things to do. Triangulate   or layer uses to create synergy among   multiple points of interest and diverse activities.
In Conclusion…. Good places breed  healthy activity . People attract people  attract people . When you focus on place,  you do everything differently . It takes many  disciplines and skills   to create a place . It takes a place to create a community, and a  community to create a place .  Amenities  that make a place comfortable are critical.  You can’t know what you are going to end up with. Each place has its own  identity . You can’t have anything less than  excellence You have to have  zealous nuts .
Building Communities   through “Placemaking”  Figure what you want to become Create your vision Where your primary and secondary destinations are/power of 10 Then figure out how to connect each place with another
It has to be a Campaign Develop a vision Become great communicators Search for impediments Organize a strong team Attack Complacency Produce  short term wins Take on  bigger  challenges Connect change to the culture of the  community People Who Make Dramatic Change  By John Kotter
When you come  to a fork in the road, take it.    – Yogi Berra BE BOLD!
www.pps.org Making Places  Newsletter Training & Conferences Publications & Resources
 
Identity & Image Showcases local assets Businesses, pedestrians, drivers, raise their behavior to this vision – sense of place.
Active Edge Uses  Active year around uses Connections from both sides of street
Seasonal Strategies
Traffic, Transit & the Pedestrian Range of transportation options
Flexibility – blending uses & modes Ground floors and retail that blur public and private space
Protects neighborhoods Good transitions to local communities and desired street character

Project for Public Spaces - Streets as Places

  • 1.
    Streets as Places– Chicago, 15 th 2007
  • 2.
  • 3.
    48 U.S. States,6 Canadian Provinces 26 Countries 2000 Communities 2 Million visitors to our web sites (2006) 24,000 people get our electronic newsletter 32 years of Placemaking
  • 4.
    William H. (Holly)Whyte The Organization Man, 1956 The Exploding Metropolis, 1958 The Last Landscape, 1968 Plan for the City of New York, 1969 The Social Life of Small Urban Spaces, 1980 City: Rediscovering the Center, 1988
  • 5.
    Outline of PresentationCommunity/Neighborhood Planning Placemaking…What is it Why do we build our Cities around cars? Best Cities/Best Examples Qualities of Great Streets New York Campaign Transportation Paradigm Shift Placemaking Process Developing a Campaign
  • 6.
    Designing neighborhoods withvibrant community centers Creating shared-use streets Providing quality public spaces that serve community needs Neighborhoods First Planning includes-
  • 7.
    Vision for neighborhoodplanning … creating great public spaces Placemaking is the foundation of creating livable communities.
  • 8.
    Vision for neighborhoodplanning … revitalizing centers
  • 9.
    Vision for neighborhoodplanning … reshaping streets and boulevards
  • 10.
    Environment Civic EngagementPublic Health and Obesity Local Economy Smart Growth CITIES/ PLACES Sustainable Communities Transportation Livability Historic Preservation Convergence of Community Goals
  • 11.
    evening use volunteerismproperty values rent levels transit usage traffic data mode splits parking usage patterns pedestrian activity building conditions environmental data sanitation rating crime statistics street life social networks land-use patterns retail sales PLACE sociability local business ownership number of women, children & elderly Cooperative Neighborliness Diversity Stewardship Pride Friendly Interactive Welcoming Continuity Proximity Connectedness Walkable Convenient Accessible Readability Charm Attractive Historic Spiritual Sittable Walkable Safe Clean “ Green” Sustainable Celebrations Indigenous Special Real Useful Fun Active Vital What Makes a Place Great? access & linkage comfort & image uses & activities key attributes intangibles measurements
  • 12.
    Thoreau said “thereis no value in life except what you choose to place upon it and no happiness in any place except what you bring to it yourself.” In this light, Placemaking is a dynamic human function: it is an act of liberation, of staking claim, and of beautification; it is true human empowerment. What is Placemaking?
  • 13.
    Placemaking is turninga neighborhood, town or city from a place you can’t wait to get through to one you never want to leave. Placemaking is creating for everybody Placemaking is the process of giving space a story that is shared by many. What is Placemaking?
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
    If you planfor cars and traffic… you get more cars and traffic.
  • 20.
    The erosion ofcities by automobiles proceeds as a kind of nibbling. Small nibbles at first but eventually hefty bites. A street is widened here, another is straightened there, a wide avenue is converted to one way flow and more land goes into parking. No one step in this process is in itself crucial but cumulatively the effect is enormous . Jane Jacobs, 1954
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
    A study ofthree generations of 9 year olds found that by 1990, the radius around the home that children were allowed to play had sunken to a ninth of what it had been in 1970. Richard Louv
  • 24.
  • 25.
    © Will McWhinney,Paths of Change Storied Cultures Clustered Cultures
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
    When you designyour community around people … you get more people.
  • 29.
  • 30.
    London BEFORE AFTERTrafalgar Square 100 Public Spaces Program
  • 31.
    Public Transit EnhancementsStreet Improvements Kensington High Street Kensington High Street Oxford Street London
  • 32.
    ACCESS: Makes pedestrianmovement safer IDENTITY: A civic element COMFORT: Reduces the negative impact of traffic on the surrounding communities Champs Elysees, Paris, France The Benefits of Boulevards
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35.
    Paris-A City ofBoulevards
  • 36.
    Paris From Congestedto Shared Streets in 5 years - Sidewalks widened - Buffered bike lanes - Dedicated bus lanes
  • 37.
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
  • 42.
  • 43.
  • 44.
  • 45.
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 48.
    Copenhagen Parking LotsRemoved Gammel Strand 1988 Gammel Strand 1996
  • 49.
  • 50.
  • 51.
  • 52.
  • 53.
  • 54.
    Qualities of GreatStreets Attractions & Destinations Identity & Image Active Edge Uses Amenities Management: Central to the Solution Seasonal Strategy Diverse User Groups Traffic, Transit & the Pedestrian Blending of uses and modes Protects Neighborhoods
  • 55.
    Attractions & DestinationsCuriosity, chaos, choices, with special places, rest spots, - the art of the path.
  • 56.
    Attractions & DestinationsClustered activity points of interest. 10+ Destinations – including food and markets, local retail, art, play, education, health/recreation .
  • 57.
    Active Edge Uses Active building bases
  • 58.
    Amenities Public andprivate seating options Triangulation to support use – clusters of street amenities
  • 59.
    Management - Central to the Solution Programming – daily activity generators/cultural, civic and seasonal celebrations
  • 60.
    Draws diverse usergroups No one group or use dominates
  • 61.
    Traffic, Transit &the Pedestrian Walkable – Places to go Range of transportation options
  • 62.
    New York CityStreet Renaissance
  • 63.
    Donald Appleyard, UCBerkeley Professor of Urban Design, quantified the impact of traffic on social ties. HEAVY TRAFFIC 16,000 vehicles per day MEDIUM TRAFFIC 8,000 vehicles per day LIGHT TRAFFIC 2,000 vehicles per day 0.9 friends per person 3.1 acquaintances per person 1.3 friends per person 4.1 acquaintances per person 3 friends per person 6.3 acquaintances per person Broken Streets
  • 64.
    Broken Streets Ikeep my windows shut I spend more time in the back of my house I forbid my children to play in the streets I go out on the street less often LIGHT TRAFFIC STREET MEDIUM TRAFFIC STREET HEAVY TRAFFIC STREET New Yorkers deal with traffic in the following ways: 7.7% 26.0% 52.2% 56.5% 18.5% 5.1% 7.4% 21.7% 0.0% 2.6% 7.4% 43.5%
  • 65.
    The Truth AboutTraffic 6% Only 6% of shopping below 59 th Street in Manhattan involves a car. 6% DRIVE 69% WALK 24% USE TRANSIT Shoppers Are Walkers
  • 66.
  • 67.
    New York City-MulrySquare Fixing an Unsafe Intersection BEFORE TEST PERIOD: 1996 – 2001 AFTER: TEST MADE PERMANENT
  • 68.
    Broadway Connecting GreatDestinations Union Square Madison Square Herald Square Times Square
  • 69.
  • 70.
    Astor Place Avoid between two great neighborhoods…
  • 71.
    Astor Place …can support and showcase the best of NYC.
  • 72.
    A funnel fordowntown traffic.. Finn Square
  • 73.
    ...can be adefining space for Tribeca. Finn Square
  • 74.
    Kenmare Square Anunused square and roadway…
  • 75.
    Kenmare Square …can become a major amenity for shoppers and residents.
  • 76.
    West Broadway Wherea shopping street fizzles…
  • 77.
    West Broadway …it can be brought back to life.
  • 78.
    Spring Street NewYork’s most successful neighborhoods…
  • 79.
    Spring Street …can better serve the pedestrians that bring their success.
  • 80.
    Grand Street Carstorage space…
  • 81.
    Grand Street …can become the most valuable space in the neighborhood.
  • 82.
    Transportation paradigm shiftOld Paradigm New Paradigm Large area planning Arterials Access to malls Retail market area - large Single family bedroom communities Big roads, wide intersections, and parking lots Big solutions (interstates/bypasses) Standards-based (Green Book) Performance is about mobility Small area planning Boulevards Access to corner markets Retail Market area - small Mixed residential/office/services with local businesses Bike paths, sidewalks, narrow streets, and transit Small solutions (road connectivity, context sensitivity) Place-based Performance is about access and sense of place
  • 83.
    The community isthe expert You are creating a place not just a design You can’t do it alone They always say it can’t be done You can see a lot just by observing Develop a placemaking vision Power of 10/Triangulation Form supports function Start with the petunias Money is not the issue You are never finished Principles of Creating Great Places Translating Ideas Into Action Implementation Planning & Outreach Techniques Underlying Ideas
  • 84.
    Project/Discipline Driven ApproachPlace Driven Development Approach
  • 85.
    Creating Great Places/Destinations The Power of 10 Chicago needs 10+ major places/destinations. Each neighborhood/downtown needs 10+ places/destinations. Each place/destination must have 10+ things to do. Connect places to create a district with 100 -1000 things to do. Triangulate or layer uses to create synergy among multiple points of interest and diverse activities.
  • 86.
    In Conclusion…. Goodplaces breed healthy activity . People attract people attract people . When you focus on place, you do everything differently . It takes many disciplines and skills to create a place . It takes a place to create a community, and a community to create a place . Amenities that make a place comfortable are critical. You can’t know what you are going to end up with. Each place has its own identity . You can’t have anything less than excellence You have to have zealous nuts .
  • 87.
    Building Communities through “Placemaking” Figure what you want to become Create your vision Where your primary and secondary destinations are/power of 10 Then figure out how to connect each place with another
  • 88.
    It has tobe a Campaign Develop a vision Become great communicators Search for impediments Organize a strong team Attack Complacency Produce short term wins Take on bigger challenges Connect change to the culture of the community People Who Make Dramatic Change By John Kotter
  • 89.
    When you come to a fork in the road, take it. – Yogi Berra BE BOLD!
  • 90.
    www.pps.org Making Places Newsletter Training & Conferences Publications & Resources
  • 91.
  • 92.
    Identity & ImageShowcases local assets Businesses, pedestrians, drivers, raise their behavior to this vision – sense of place.
  • 93.
    Active Edge Uses Active year around uses Connections from both sides of street
  • 94.
  • 95.
    Traffic, Transit &the Pedestrian Range of transportation options
  • 96.
    Flexibility – blendinguses & modes Ground floors and retail that blur public and private space
  • 97.
    Protects neighborhoods Goodtransitions to local communities and desired street character