SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Welcome to the program on
Resisting Price Increase and
Implementing Cost Improvement
Initiatives
by
H K Varma Varmahk@Gmail.com
98202 62986
22 426 62986
Our Mission
Knowledge + Training
=
Prosperity
Program schedule
• 10.00 – 11.15 Session I
• 11.30 – 1.00 Session II
Lunch break 1.00 to 2.00
• 2.00 – 3.30 Session III
• 3.30 – 4.50 Session IV
• 4.50 – 5.00 Q / A
• 5.00 ----------- Close
Business scenario post GATT ....
• Introduction of GATT ( General Agreement on Tariffs and
trade ) under the WTO in the yr 1995
• reduced trade barriers amongst global players thru’
o Export subsidies ,
o lifting of quantitative restrictions and
o reduction in tariff rates (from 20% -1950 to 3.6% -
2010)
o s How it affected the businesses ! …………
The survival mantra has become
• “Survival of the fittest”
Survival of the best
Cost ,
quality and
the fastest
Inflation and how to beat it
Inflation is a sustained increase in the general price
level of goods and services over a period of time
Inflation occurs due to an imbalance between demand
and supply of money, changes in production and
distribution cost or increase in taxes on products
It could be :
• Negative , or
• Positive
Mfg Cost Var Output at TP Stores cr. 4000
241 3972 +/- in WIP 178
PBIT Misc Output -206
1191 Input Cost
3731 Dir Malt 3000
NOPAT Dir Lab 86
810 Mktg PBIT Sales/Serv 6000 Malt OH 47
929 Cost of Sales 3972 Shop OH 261
ED on Sales 794 PGOH 36
TAX OD Adj Pers Rel Exp 89 Comm Exp 163
EVA 381 -65 T&C 54 Alloc Exp 189
361 Sales Pr Exp 8
Corp alloc NDC 19
86 ODE 63
WACC Estb 31
12% Other Exp 41
Cap Chg MMI 1034
449 Cap Emp WIP 370
3738 Net F Assets FG 53
601 Curr Assets Cust OS 3073
4597 Oth contl A 67
Net WC
3137
Curr Liabilities Vendor Cr 1273
1460 Cust Adv 33
OCL 154
Areas of focus
1. Reduction in Material & labor
costs
2. Reduction the Lead time
3. Reduction in Rejections , Wastage
4. Reduce Working capital
How
an effective
Purchase dept.
can help
improve EVA
Material Cost reduction vs Increase in Profits
55
53.9
52.3
57.5
29.0
28.5
27.6
30.4
13.0
14.8
17.1
19.1
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120
Material Labour O/H Profit
Y1
Y2 –2%
redu in M
Y3 –5%
redu in M
10% Volume
Growth
14% Incr in P
32% Incr in P
47% Incr in P
Rs in Cr
Let us understand thru
major cost elements of a
Product !
• Supply-chain executives
have significant role in the
 operating expenses
 cost of goods sold and
• hence have a major role in
margin management
Performance Measures
qualitative vs quantitative
• When analyzing SC performance, qualitative evaluations
such as
– Good
– Fair
– Adequate and
– Poor
• As a result, quantitative performance measures are often
preferred to such qualitative evaluations.
are vague and difficult to arrive
at any meaningful conclusion.
Performance monitoring of SC partners
Should include :
• Quality
• OTD
• Cost
• Service
Once the performance of the SC operations has been measured
and
performance gaps identified, it becomes important to identify
what activities should be performed to close those gaps
• A team from Focal Organization visits the Vendor and
allocates points against a number of queries in a
questionnaire.
• Actual working of the quality department is audited by
examining records, analysis of the system and talking to
people on the spot.
• Rating should be numeric ... , ... , ... , ....scale
• After determining which factors are critical, a method is
devised that allows the vendor to be judged or rated on
each individual factor.
Vendor Assessment
Vendor Assessment ( Criticality * Rating )
1 = Not
Important
4 = Critical
1 = Poor
4 = High
Vendor
rating
Criteri
a No.
Criteria Importance
(A)
Rating(B) A*B
1 2 3 4
1 Work stn condition 3
2 Maintenance of m/cs 3
3 Productivity 4
4 Safety Initiatives 4
..
20 Quality Systems 4
Vendor ::
Min Score = 20 Max Score = 320Evaluation CFT ……..
Score < 100 Rejected
Max
Score
Weighted
score
1. GENERAL ORGANIZATION: 4 2.9
2. SAFETY 4 2.3
3. INSPECTION 4 3.4
4. DRAWING & REVISION CONTROL 4 2.8
5. PROCUREMENT: INCOMING R M CONTROL 4 2.4
6. MANUFACTURING PROCESSES 4 2.1
7. TOOLINGS & MEASURING INSTRUMENTS 4 3.7
8. QUALITY : QUALITY INDICATORS 4 2.6
9. M/C & TOOLING MAINTENANCE SYSTEM 4 2.5
10. ENVIRONMENT 4 3.2
40 27.9
Supplier Assessment (Summary)
Supplier Assessment score
Overall
Score
Acceptable > 30 Green
Conditional 20 - 29 Orange
Poor
Performer
12 - 19 Yellow
Rejected < 12 Red
Vendors with
low scores are
asked to
overcome the
shortcomings
with focus on
time-bound
improvements
A good supplier helps our organization to be more efficient,
produce higher quality products or services, reduce
costs, and increase profits.
A poor performer can disrupt our operations, make our
organization fail in the eyes of our customers, increase
our costs, and threaten our profits
hence need for Vendor development .........
ISO9000/
TS16949
Costing -
Transparent
Impln.of
Lean &
six sigma
initiatives
Help you
reduce
costs VE
Loaning of
tools, gauges ,
testing equip
etc
Vendor
Training
Negotiation
with
supplier’s
supplier
Partnership
/ JV
Resisting
Price
Increase
Structured
negotiationOn-time
Delivery
Value Engineering (value analysis)
• VE is a systematic and organized approach to provide the
necessary functions of a product / service / process at the
lowest cost.
• Value engineering promotes the substitution of materials and
methods with less expensive alternatives, without sacrificing
functionality.
• These substitutes were often found to reduce costs and
provided equal or better performance.
• Value, as defined, is the ratio of function to cost , V =
F
C
• Alternately : Value = (Performance + Capability)/Cost =
Function/Cost
• Value can therefore be increased by either improving the
function or reducing the cost.
VE (structured thought process to evaluate options as follows)
Gather information
⁻ What is being done now?
⁻ Who is doing it?
⁻ What could it do?
⁻ What must it not do?
Measure
⁻ How will the alternatives be
measured?
Analyze
⁻ What must be done?
⁻ What else can perform the desired
function?
⁻ What does it cost?
Generate
⁻ What else will do the job?
Evaluate
⁻ Which Ideas are the best?
Develop and expand ideas
⁻ What are the impacts?
⁻ What is the cost?
⁻ What is the performance?
Present ideas
‒ Sell alternatives
Vendor development
• Procuring organization forms a team of engineers and
assign it to their suppliers for carrying out the specific
development projects.
• By having the direct support of their client and regular
monitoring of their development
– will be more motivated to carry out the program fully &
– will readily realize that the program is indispensable.
• Points to remember
– Negotiate the Supplier's Entire Volume not only for your
requirement but also for his other customers need.
– The larger the volume , the greater your savings.
– Always Manage The Negotiations.
• You may have the knowledge and technology to
manage the negotiations better than the supplier.
– This also gives you the control on timeline, information on
inputs, etc.
Negotiating on behalf of your subcontractor
to avail lower costs
ISO 9000 / TS 16949 certification ----
• ISO 9000 certification stresses the importance of
compliance on technical specifications and the quality
requirements .
• In fact , some procuring enterprises agree to work with
suppliers only if they are ISO 9000 certified.
• To help subcontractors acquire such certification, main
contractor should assist them with regard to system &
procedures to be adopted for
• documentation control
• product purchasing
………………..
Total quality (zero defects) management
• Detect defective components and diagnose the
causes of such defects
• Reduce waste and reworking
• Build up expertise
• Review the importance of quality in the budget
• Develop a culture centered on the workers’
accountability for quality and
• show them what they can gain in terms of personal
satisfaction and security.
Allowing use of main contractors’ production
facilities by subcontractors …
Subcontractor is an extended partner in your supply chain
He should be allowed to have access to main contractors
facilities such as :
– instruments
– moulds
– prototypes
– patterns
– quality control equipment etc which directly
enhance the quality of products.
Organization of work within the
enterprise
• Internal functioning of an enterprise is important from a
quality viewpoint.
• Thus to gain a better appreciation of overall coordination
the organization would need:
– No barriers between different departments / Sections
(Homogeneity between departments)
– Encourage teamwork
– Organize discussions on working practices and
investigate solutions to problems
Objectives of Vendor rating
– To motivate suppliers to improve performance.
– To apportion orders to deserving vendors for overall
cost reduction.
– To select vendors for further development.
– To reduce the cost of inspection of incoming lots by
modifying sampling plan
Vendo
r
Total
receipt
s
VQR VQR
*50%
Del
Timely
receipt
s
Del
Timely
Rating
- Ratio
* 20
Del
Qty
Receip
ts
Delive
ry
Rating
% * 20
Servic
e
out of
10%
A 100 90 45 18.4 84 16.8 8
B 60 80 40 48 16 52 17.3 7
C 50 70 35 41 16.4 17.6 6
Vendor Composite Rating
with weight ages for Quality , Delivery & Service (Subjective)
With
Improveme
nts
NOS. PECENTAGE
GREEN 72 54
Orange 34 26
Yellow 23 17
Red 4 3
133 100
After Improvement program
Quantum jump in Vendor profile
Earlier NOS.
PECENTA
GE
GREEN 68 48 acceptable
Orange 32 23 conditional
Yellow 26 18 poor perf
Red 15 11 rejected
141 100
Supplier reward program
• There are two sides of performance improvement
motivation:
– Rewarding the suppliers who perform well so
they will aspire to continue performing well ,
and
– Correcting Poor Performance : taking
corrective action with those suppliers whose
performance does not meet our expectations.
• It would never be safe to assume that switching
supplier eliminates problems
• With focus on shrunken vendor base ,
• Consolidation with limited few vendors is encouraged
called tier 1 suppliers who in turn take responsibility
for quality of tier 2/3 suppliers
• Suppliers are assured of long term commitments and
cooperative relationship
• Buyers work along with suppliers to develop cost
reduction for both firms
• Suppliers are even allowed to keep certain portion of
the profits thru these joint efforts
Vendor consolidation
Supplier Relationship model (SRM)
Unilateral
“Make the best part”
Interactive
“Together develop better spec”
Collaborative
“Supplier teams make the best
system or process.”
Higher
Supplier
Involvement
Higher
Value
Addition
1. To improve supplier performance. On cost reduction , OTD ,
Zero defect , Reduced W/C , prompt service .
2. To reduce risk. . Ensure continuity of supply in the face of
unexpected disruption to the operations of one or more
suppliers from natural disasters, political upheavals, and
other events
3. To provide flexibility and agility to the organization thru’ a
healthy vendor base
4. To save money
Strategic Sourcing Goals of Material department
0
100000
200000
300000
400000
500000
600000
700000
20000 40000 60000 80000 100000 120000
Cost of Buying(5) Cost of Mkg I/H
Cost of buying
Cost of Making I/H
Time for demanding
Volume discount.
Conference Compromise
ConferenceConference
Negotiation
Negotiation is therefore a process involving a
conference whereby skillful maneuvering &
compromise are used to achieve an agreement
The time
invested on
negotiation
should yield
tangible results
Ensure early Purchasing Involvement
• Suppliers try to woo the Internal customers to get
insight to the decision making process & other
important information .
• Purchasing professionals are typically trained to uphold
high ethical standards and will ensure that these tactics
are not successfully used by suppliers.
• Purchasing professionals are experts in evaluating the
overall supplier capabilities wrt to financial(Z-score )
,Quality, Technical & Mfg excellence .
• A passion for risk management which other wise may
get ignored ( Succession plan , Tax and duty structure
,overall low cost etc )
Effective Negotiation skills
preparation & planning
• Prepare in details for conducting a successful
negotiation
• Bring in more transparency to the process for a long
term relationship
• Remember you’re the expert
• A good negotiation should cover all terms : price,
warranty, delivery, payment terms, etc.
• What often happens is that one supplier offers the
best price, 2nd offers the best warranty, a third offers
the best delivery, etc.
Should A Manager Join A Negotiation In Late
Stages?
While some managers feel their jumping in at a later stage will
squeeze another 5% out of the supplier, the fact is that their
actions result in companies getting worse deals, not better.
• Actually, the supplier may welcome another counterpart -
that way he can play "divide and conquer" and get the
manager to agree to concessions that the buyer would not.
•
• If past history compels a supplier to predict that a manager
will join a negotiation in its late stages,
• will the supplier ever give its best deal to the buyer ? No -
the supplier will withhold it so that it has something to
offer the manager later.
Product Costing
• Product Cost
• Direct Cost
» Direct Mfg Cost
1. Direct Labour
2. Direct Material
• Indirect Cost
» Non-Mfg Costs
1. Variable overheads
2. Fixed overheads
3. Selling Costs
4. Administrative costs
Component Cost
Nett Wt (grams) …… (Volume * Density) 105
Charge Wt (Grams) 120
Rate/Kg (Rs) after MODVAT 87
RM Cost/Pc (Rs) 10.44
ICC at 3% 0.31
Cycle Time (Sec) 380
Available time (7hrs) = 7*60*60 sec 25200
Output / Shift ( 1 Cav Mold ) 66
Molding cost per piece (Shift rate / Output - 558/66) 8.42
Post molding opr.(Rs 220/shift , Output 380 nos) 0.66
Inspn Cost ( Rs 5000 pm - 500pc/shift) 0.40
Pkg/Forwarding 0.43
Sub-total 20.66
O/H ( 12%) 2.48
Profit (10% on L) 0.99
Total rate / Unit 24.13
Zero based costing
Apportions all costs ( Direct , Indirect and overheads )
on total production
Needs to take on overall view on expenses to keep
O/H at minimum
Improve the productivity , M/c utilization
Increase production levels in order to spread the
total expenses on larger volumes
Ensure alt. product is ready for offloading as per Product
life cycle
Cost of Quality
Cost of
Quality
Cost of good
quality
Cost of poor
quality
=
+
Cost of Quality Failure of Vendor to meet quality
• Complaints
• Warranties
• Repairing goods
•Loss due to sales
reductions
• Checking & Testing
Purchased costs
• In-process and Final
Inspection Testing
• Field Testing
• Product , Process
and Service Audits
• Calibration
•Scrap
•Rework
•Re-testing
•Delays
•Shortages
•Supplier Evaluation
• Error Proofing
• Quality Improvement
projects
• ISO
• Quality Education and
Training
• Quality planning
• New Product Review
Preservat
ion Costs
Internal
Failure
costs
External
Failure
Costs
Appraisal
costs
Costofservicingdefects
PreventionandAppraisalCost
Your focus
Leads to
Striking a balance
Economic
conformance
point
Cost of Quality Management vs Cost of servicing defects
Low Quality High
LowCostHigh
Minimum
cost of
Quality
Total
cost of
Quality
Cost of
Service
defects
Where
you want
to be
Cost of
Quality
Manageme
nt
The Lean-Six Sigma philosophy
Cost of Quality Management vs Cost of servicing defectsLowCostHigh
Prevention
and
Appraisal
cost
𝟒𝝈
𝟓𝝈
𝟔𝝈
Economic
conformance
point
Hold Suppliers More Accountable For the Quality of
their Products
Drive performance improvement thru’ CFTs to manage quality
across entire spectrum of suppliers
⁻ Non-Conformances / Corrective and Preventive Action
(NC/CAPA)
⁻ Complaint Handling
⁻ Statistical Process Control (SPC) – to get Real-time visibility
of supplier quality metrics through web-based portal
• Real-time visibility of manufacturing data helps OEMs
eliminate the black box effect of outsourcing critical
components.
• It also eliminates surprises on the receiving nonconforming
materials.
Process Yield & First time Yield
• Traditionally , Yield is the proportion of
• Lots accepted out of total lots received
• Yield = 79/80 = 98.75%
In
80
Out
79
Yield = 98.75%
Vendor
Receipts
Lots
Returned
1
Deliveries
From Vendor ”A”
80 - Lots
Received
79 – Lots
Ultimately
accepted
Inspection
Yield
=
(80-72)/80
=
90% - FTY
The hidden factory of in-process inspection and
rework accounts for 98.75% - 90.0% = 8.75%
The
Hidden
factory is due
to
The inability to
correctly
comply with
required
specifications
the first time
FTY & The Hidden Factory
Hidden
Factory
=
8.75%
The extra efforts put to
get these 7 lots
accepted is
HIDDEN FACTORYUltimate Yield = 98.8%
Lots
Rej. & returned -1
Rejn. - 8
An effective Purchase departments
helps to build Vendor Flexibility
&
provide Agility to our organization
Flexibility
• Supply chain flexibility is defined as “the ability to quickly
respond to changes in demand while achieving your
objectives of
– customer service,
– shorter lead time ,
– cost,
– inventory and
– return on assets (ROA)
F-Flexibility measures
• Volume flexibility (Fv ) : measures the proportion of demand
that can be met profitably by the supply chain system
• Delivery flexibility (Fd ) :
– The ability to move planned delivery dates forward .
– This ability allows the supply chain to accommodate rush
orders and special orders, and will be described as delivery
flexibility.
– Delivery flexibility is expressed as the percentage of slack
time by which the delivery time can be reduced
• Mix flexibility (Fm ) : the response time between product mix
changes.
• New product flexibility (Fn): is defined as the ease with which
new products are introduced , the time or cost required to add
new products to existing production operations
Period
(t)
Deman
d
volume
(units)
Period
(t)
Deman
d
volume
(units)
Period
(t)
Deman
d
volume
(units)
Period
(t)
Deman
d
volume
(units)
1 16 9 12 17 38 25 24
2 21 10 43 18 19 26 17
3 32 11 8 19 29 27 36
4 5 12 29 20 12 28 11
5 18 13 33 21 34 29 28
6 26 14 39 22 50 30 23
7 40 15 7 23 16 31 32
8 31 16 15 24 30 32 17
Volume flexibility (𝐹𝑣) Contd.
𝐷 =
𝒅 𝒕
𝑇
𝑡=1
𝑻
= 24.69
𝑆 𝐷 =
(𝒅 𝒕 − 𝒅) 𝟐𝑇
𝑡=1
𝑻 − 𝟏
= 11.35
Summarize Fv
Group 1 2 3 4 5
Std Dev 11.33 11.33 11.10 10.50 7.73
Avg 24.5 24.5 21.16 28.22 28.53
Min 5 9 9 9 9
Max 49 42 42 42 42
Fv 0.70 0.29 1.27 0.84 1.27
Fv
comes
down as
range is
narrowe
d down
Fv rises with
Avg out put
coming down.
NO Flexibility
with lower
output
Lower
variation
clubbed
with Higher
output
improves Fv
Further
reduction
in variation
improves
Fv
Supplier is geared up
to give Higher
volumes
consistently ( Lower
std dev) leading to
higher volumes +
Flexibility
Delivery flexibility (Fd)
• Delivery dates change regularly and costs are associated
with not meeting the delivery dates
• The ability to move planned delivery dates forward may be
important in supply chain management.
• This ability allows the supply chain to accommodate
rush orders and special orders, and is described as delivery
flexibility.
• Delivery flexibility is expressed as the percentage of slack
time by which the delivery time can be reduced/advanced
Delivery flexibility (Fd ) Summary
Existing Time
–T period –
Week No
Lj Ej - Gr 1 Ej - Gr 2 Ej – Gr 3 Ej – Gr 4
23 36 33 31 30 29
23 45 41 39 38 37
23 37 32 31 30 29
23 41 38 35 34 33
23 47 42 41 40 38
Fd 22.0 31.9 37.4 44.0
Further increase means adding resources 2X , 3X
, 4X ... , Reduction in C/O time .
However there is limit to increase beyond
certain levels due to inherent processing time
Agility
Impro
veme
nt
NOPA
T
Current
assets
Curr
Liability
Current
ratio
Fixed
Asset
(Depreciation)
Total Cap
employed
ROCE Capital
Charge
@ 12%
EVA
810 4597 1460 3.1 601 3738 21.7 449 361
1 810 4137 1460 2.8 601 3278 24.7 393 417
2 810 3724 1460 2.6 601 2865 28.3 344 466
3 810 3351 1460 2.3 601 2492 32.5 299 511
4 810 3016 1460 2.1 601 2157 37.6 259 551
5 810 2714 1460 1.9 601 1855 43.7 223 587
YoY 10% redu
in Inventory
1. Working capital (Inventory) control
Six Sigma
• Every mistake an organization or person makes ultimately has
a cost,
– the need to do a certain task over again,
– the part that has to be replaced,
– time or material wasted
• You consume additional resources to correct a problem
before it's delivered to the customer
• Six Sigma is a scientific problem solving tool for
– meeting your customer's needs (Time , speed , Quality )
– minimizing wasted resources (Errors , rework , Hidden
factory , variations +/-)
– maximizing profit in the process ,thru’ disciplined data
collection and analysis to determine best solutions
Six Sigma focus
• The goal of Six Sigma is to inject
– disciplined control,
– predictability, and
– consistency of results
so that the product comes off the production line absolutely
consistently.
• The methodology of Six Sigma was first applied in a
manufacturing company, but is extensively used in service
and transactional companies (like banks and hospitals),
• Six Sigma initiatives and projects have a direct measurable
financial focus eg OFR , Quality , Lead time , OTD ,IT , ROI etc
Higher Process Sigma – lower Rejection
• A low process sigma means that a significant part of the
tail of the distribution is extending past the specification
limit. More defects.
• So the higher the process sigma score Z , the fewer the
defects
1. 2σ = 30.8% Rej
2. 3σ = 6.68% Rej
3. 3.4σ = 3% Rej
4. 4σ = 0.62% Rej
5. 5σ = 0.0223% Rej
6. 6σ = 0.0003% Rej
} Most of Indian Industries are here
This is the journey we have
to undertake
2 approaches to Improvement
DMAIC DFSS
• Six Sigma offers two approaches for improvement
1. Improve the process so that chances of defects are
reduced ,ie reduce the standard deviation (increase Z
score) thru’ DMAIC
2. Change the design (DFSS) so that product can
accommodate process variations
• A Six Sigma process should not generate any flaws , but
since , over the long run (Lt Std Dev) , every process shifts
Process capability
of a process or characteristic to meet its specifications (VOC/VOP)
1. Capability : Ability to match the voice of your process-VOP
to the voice of your customer-VOC
2. The simplest capability index is called Cp.
3. It compares the width of a two-sided specification to the
effective short term width of the process.
USL - LSL represents
the VOC-voice of the
customer's
requirements and
6σst represents the
inherent voice of the
process -VOP
Cp =
( USL-LSL )
6σst
Effective process width
under Six Sigma = 99.7%
In this example ,
Process capability = 1
LSL
USL
Cp
• Cp is known as measure of process capability .
• It is the number of times the spread of the
process fits into the tolerance width.
• The higher the value of Cp, the better the
process.
Control
• A solution that isn’t sustained over the long term has little
value
• Control charts are two-dimensional graph plotting the
– performance of a process on Y axis, and
– time or the sequence of data samples on X axis.
• They are basically a type of Run chart with control limits
Why Control chart
– It shows nature of variation in the process over time
– Helps in detecting changes in the process
– Helps in controlling the process
• Specs : USL/LSL vs UCL/LCL
– CONTROL is also capability , 𝐂 𝐩 - Process Capability
Why Controls
1. Process behavior is complex and fragile and that hard-
earned gains slip away if the process is left to itself.
2. The Control phase helps you make sure the problem stays
fixed, and, if done properly, provides you with additional
data to make further improvements to the process.
3. A well designed process exhibits inherent self control, but..
4. A poorly designed process requires frequent external
control and adjustment to meet requirements.
5. A process with well built-in control acts like the heating and
cooling system in a house: The system automatically
maintains a comfortable temperature at all times.
Variable Control Charts
• Variable Control charts are used to monitor measurable
quality characteristics of a process eg Temperature ,
dimension , weight , viscosity etc
• Variable charts can monitor only one quality characteristic at
a time .
• For more than one characteristic, a chart for each
characteristic needs to be created
• Variable Control charts help to monitor both process mean
and process variability
• Hence it becomes necessary to use minimum 2 control charts
to study the process. Ie
– Range or Std Deviation
– Process mean , with UCL & LCL
Variable Control Chart - contd
– R Chart / X Chart or
– X / S chart or
– MR / X chart
• An X chart is the most widely used control chart which
monitors the sample variability
• The R chart is used when sample size is less than 10
• S chart is used when sample size is greater than 10.
• For quality characteristic with sample size one , moving
range needs to be established and hence a MR chart is
used.
• As a thumb rule 20 to 25 samples should be selected for
analysis with sample size of 4 to 5 .
Working Capital Cycle
Cash
FG
Purchase of
Raw Matl
Receivables/
Collection
1 Months
2 Months
Production
0.5 Month
1 W/C Cycle ??
No of Cycles/ Yr = 2.4
Target ……
0.5 Month
Balance Sheet model of a Firm
Current Assets
-Receivables
-Inventories
Current Liabilities or
Short Term Debt-Payables
Fixed Assets
1.Tangible Fixed Assets
(M/c ,Equipments ,Land)
2.Intangible Assets
( Patents, Trade mark,
Quality of Management)
Long Term Debt
Shareholder’s
equity
Assets Liabilities
Service % MMI in Rs L Sigma level
99.9996 100 6.00
99.998 95 5.80
99.994 90 5.30
99.990 85 5.27
99.966 80 5.00
99.874 75 4.45
99.78 70 4.30
99.7 65 4.15
99.5 60 4.10
99.1 55 3.90
98.6 50 3.66
98 45 3.45
97 40 3.40
96 35 3.20
6 sigma
3 Sigma
4 Sigma
5 Sigma
Sigma level Production hold-ups due to non-
availability of Material
2 Most of the time
3 25-40%
4 15-25%
5 1-15%
6 < 1%
Service level V/S Matl Non-availability
Sum-up
• Last but not least :
• You’ve got to make sure your suppliers understand how you
define Quality and OTD.
– Avoiding this step appears negatively in your cost , and
second
– Your relationship with suppliers is important. You have to
treat them more like partners than suppliers.
The success mantra for getting quality products and
maximizing cost reductions is by working
harmoniously with suppliers as if they’re a trusted
partner
Establish (KPIs) of all related processes and
actions to Accelerate Operational Excellence
• It's crucial to identify a specific set of KPIs that will
help you measure progress and identify areas for
adjustment.
• Equally important to having these measures, however,
is a related system of communication procedures,
processes around the KPIs to ensure that they are
being accurately measured, interpreted,
communicated, and acted upon.
Purchasing Ethics
• I believe that the position of Purchase Engineer is
important , honorable , worthy , responsible , and calls
forth the highest ethical principles in relationship and
dealing with men.
• I believe in the ‘square deal’ towards the company I
represent and towards the men with whom I do business
.
• I believe it is my duty to refuse and renounce gifts or
perquisites from those with whom I transact business.
Thank
you
H K Varma
9820262986
Varmahk@Gmail.com

More Related Content

Similar to Procurement : Resisting price increase

Six Sigma- Define & Measure_Sudhanshu.pdf
Six Sigma- Define & Measure_Sudhanshu.pdfSix Sigma- Define & Measure_Sudhanshu.pdf
Six Sigma- Define & Measure_Sudhanshu.pdf
SudhanshuMittal20
 
Training Prog :: Vendor quality Management system-Vendor development
Training Prog :: Vendor quality Management system-Vendor developmentTraining Prog :: Vendor quality Management system-Vendor development
Training Prog :: Vendor quality Management system-Vendor development
Varmahk
 
TQM
TQMTQM
TQM
Target
 
Costof quality
Costof qualityCostof quality
Costof quality
Omnex Inc.
 
cost of quality
cost of qualitycost of quality
cost of quality
Mr.Ramesh Chandra Panda
 
Managing quality ppt @ bec doms
Managing quality ppt @ bec domsManaging quality ppt @ bec doms
Managing quality ppt @ bec doms
Babasab Patil
 
Quality Management and Statistical Process Control
Quality Management and Statistical Process ControlQuality Management and Statistical Process Control
Quality Management and Statistical Process Control
Mahmudul Hasan
 
Total quality management (tqm) final
Total quality management (tqm) finalTotal quality management (tqm) final
Total quality management (tqm) final
Nur Athirah Tuan Yaacob
 
BBA008 -total quality management.pdf
BBA008  -total quality management.pdfBBA008  -total quality management.pdf
BBA008 -total quality management.pdf
Yuvarajvadivelan
 
Lean vs six sigma -jk
Lean vs six sigma  -jkLean vs six sigma  -jk
Lean vs six sigma -jk
Julian Kalac P.Eng
 
Tools and Ways of Improving Quality.pptx
Tools and Ways of Improving Quality.pptxTools and Ways of Improving Quality.pptx
Tools and Ways of Improving Quality.pptx
AbiolaOgunsanwo
 
CFW - Understanding Your Costs / Open Book Costing Models
CFW - Understanding Your Costs / Open Book Costing ModelsCFW - Understanding Your Costs / Open Book Costing Models
CFW - Understanding Your Costs / Open Book Costing Models
Rae Davies
 
Total quality control
Total quality controlTotal quality control
Total quality control
Aakash Bhongade
 
Lean In Manufacturing
Lean In ManufacturingLean In Manufacturing
Lean In Manufacturing
Yogendra Totla
 
Performance Measures for Supply Chain Management.pptx
Performance Measures for  Supply Chain Management.pptxPerformance Measures for  Supply Chain Management.pptx
Performance Measures for Supply Chain Management.pptx
ZahidColdstone
 
Standardization(work study & measurement)
Standardization(work study & measurement)Standardization(work study & measurement)
Standardization(work study & measurement)
Nisarg Shah
 
Quality Slides
Quality SlidesQuality Slides
Quality Slides
RobbieA
 
module I_TQM_18ME734.pptx
module I_TQM_18ME734.pptxmodule I_TQM_18ME734.pptx
module I_TQM_18ME734.pptx
RoopaDNDandally
 
Key steps in transforming a calibration program slideshare
Key steps in transforming a calibration program slideshareKey steps in transforming a calibration program slideshare
Key steps in transforming a calibration program slideshare
John Cummins, CPIP
 
Quality Slides
Quality SlidesQuality Slides
Quality Slides
RobbieA
 

Similar to Procurement : Resisting price increase (20)

Six Sigma- Define & Measure_Sudhanshu.pdf
Six Sigma- Define & Measure_Sudhanshu.pdfSix Sigma- Define & Measure_Sudhanshu.pdf
Six Sigma- Define & Measure_Sudhanshu.pdf
 
Training Prog :: Vendor quality Management system-Vendor development
Training Prog :: Vendor quality Management system-Vendor developmentTraining Prog :: Vendor quality Management system-Vendor development
Training Prog :: Vendor quality Management system-Vendor development
 
TQM
TQMTQM
TQM
 
Costof quality
Costof qualityCostof quality
Costof quality
 
cost of quality
cost of qualitycost of quality
cost of quality
 
Managing quality ppt @ bec doms
Managing quality ppt @ bec domsManaging quality ppt @ bec doms
Managing quality ppt @ bec doms
 
Quality Management and Statistical Process Control
Quality Management and Statistical Process ControlQuality Management and Statistical Process Control
Quality Management and Statistical Process Control
 
Total quality management (tqm) final
Total quality management (tqm) finalTotal quality management (tqm) final
Total quality management (tqm) final
 
BBA008 -total quality management.pdf
BBA008  -total quality management.pdfBBA008  -total quality management.pdf
BBA008 -total quality management.pdf
 
Lean vs six sigma -jk
Lean vs six sigma  -jkLean vs six sigma  -jk
Lean vs six sigma -jk
 
Tools and Ways of Improving Quality.pptx
Tools and Ways of Improving Quality.pptxTools and Ways of Improving Quality.pptx
Tools and Ways of Improving Quality.pptx
 
CFW - Understanding Your Costs / Open Book Costing Models
CFW - Understanding Your Costs / Open Book Costing ModelsCFW - Understanding Your Costs / Open Book Costing Models
CFW - Understanding Your Costs / Open Book Costing Models
 
Total quality control
Total quality controlTotal quality control
Total quality control
 
Lean In Manufacturing
Lean In ManufacturingLean In Manufacturing
Lean In Manufacturing
 
Performance Measures for Supply Chain Management.pptx
Performance Measures for  Supply Chain Management.pptxPerformance Measures for  Supply Chain Management.pptx
Performance Measures for Supply Chain Management.pptx
 
Standardization(work study & measurement)
Standardization(work study & measurement)Standardization(work study & measurement)
Standardization(work study & measurement)
 
Quality Slides
Quality SlidesQuality Slides
Quality Slides
 
module I_TQM_18ME734.pptx
module I_TQM_18ME734.pptxmodule I_TQM_18ME734.pptx
module I_TQM_18ME734.pptx
 
Key steps in transforming a calibration program slideshare
Key steps in transforming a calibration program slideshareKey steps in transforming a calibration program slideshare
Key steps in transforming a calibration program slideshare
 
Quality Slides
Quality SlidesQuality Slides
Quality Slides
 

Recently uploaded

2. Operations Strategy in a Global Environment.ppt
2. Operations Strategy in a Global Environment.ppt2. Operations Strategy in a Global Environment.ppt
2. Operations Strategy in a Global Environment.ppt
PuktoonEngr
 
Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...
Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...
Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...
IJECEIAES
 
Manufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptx
Manufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptxManufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptx
Manufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptx
Madan Karki
 
Embedded machine learning-based road conditions and driving behavior monitoring
Embedded machine learning-based road conditions and driving behavior monitoringEmbedded machine learning-based road conditions and driving behavior monitoring
Embedded machine learning-based road conditions and driving behavior monitoring
IJECEIAES
 
Swimming pool mechanical components design.pptx
Swimming pool  mechanical components design.pptxSwimming pool  mechanical components design.pptx
Swimming pool mechanical components design.pptx
yokeleetan1
 
New techniques for characterising damage in rock slopes.pdf
New techniques for characterising damage in rock slopes.pdfNew techniques for characterising damage in rock slopes.pdf
New techniques for characterising damage in rock slopes.pdf
wisnuprabawa3
 
CHINA’S GEO-ECONOMIC OUTREACH IN CENTRAL ASIAN COUNTRIES AND FUTURE PROSPECT
CHINA’S GEO-ECONOMIC OUTREACH IN CENTRAL ASIAN COUNTRIES AND FUTURE PROSPECTCHINA’S GEO-ECONOMIC OUTREACH IN CENTRAL ASIAN COUNTRIES AND FUTURE PROSPECT
CHINA’S GEO-ECONOMIC OUTREACH IN CENTRAL ASIAN COUNTRIES AND FUTURE PROSPECT
jpsjournal1
 
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
thanhdowork
 
Modelagem de um CSTR com reação endotermica.pdf
Modelagem de um CSTR com reação endotermica.pdfModelagem de um CSTR com reação endotermica.pdf
Modelagem de um CSTR com reação endotermica.pdf
camseq
 
Properties Railway Sleepers and Test.pptx
Properties Railway Sleepers and Test.pptxProperties Railway Sleepers and Test.pptx
Properties Railway Sleepers and Test.pptx
MDSABBIROJJAMANPAYEL
 
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine LearningUnderstanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
SUTEJAS
 
A review on techniques and modelling methodologies used for checking electrom...
A review on techniques and modelling methodologies used for checking electrom...A review on techniques and modelling methodologies used for checking electrom...
A review on techniques and modelling methodologies used for checking electrom...
nooriasukmaningtyas
 
ACRP 4-09 Risk Assessment Method to Support Modification of Airfield Separat...
ACRP 4-09 Risk Assessment Method to Support Modification of Airfield Separat...ACRP 4-09 Risk Assessment Method to Support Modification of Airfield Separat...
ACRP 4-09 Risk Assessment Method to Support Modification of Airfield Separat...
Mukeshwaran Balu
 
IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems Society as a Graduate Student Member
IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems Society as a Graduate Student MemberIEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems Society as a Graduate Student Member
IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems Society as a Graduate Student Member
VICTOR MAESTRE RAMIREZ
 
Series of visio cisco devices Cisco_Icons.ppt
Series of visio cisco devices Cisco_Icons.pptSeries of visio cisco devices Cisco_Icons.ppt
Series of visio cisco devices Cisco_Icons.ppt
PauloRodrigues104553
 
PPT on GRP pipes manufacturing and testing
PPT on GRP pipes manufacturing and testingPPT on GRP pipes manufacturing and testing
PPT on GRP pipes manufacturing and testing
anoopmanoharan2
 
BPV-GUI-01-Guide-for-ASME-Review-Teams-(General)-10-10-2023.pdf
BPV-GUI-01-Guide-for-ASME-Review-Teams-(General)-10-10-2023.pdfBPV-GUI-01-Guide-for-ASME-Review-Teams-(General)-10-10-2023.pdf
BPV-GUI-01-Guide-for-ASME-Review-Teams-(General)-10-10-2023.pdf
MIGUELANGEL966976
 
basic-wireline-operations-course-mahmoud-f-radwan.pdf
basic-wireline-operations-course-mahmoud-f-radwan.pdfbasic-wireline-operations-course-mahmoud-f-radwan.pdf
basic-wireline-operations-course-mahmoud-f-radwan.pdf
NidhalKahouli2
 
KuberTENes Birthday Bash Guadalajara - K8sGPT first impressions
KuberTENes Birthday Bash Guadalajara - K8sGPT first impressionsKuberTENes Birthday Bash Guadalajara - K8sGPT first impressions
KuberTENes Birthday Bash Guadalajara - K8sGPT first impressions
Victor Morales
 
International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...
International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...
International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...
gerogepatton
 

Recently uploaded (20)

2. Operations Strategy in a Global Environment.ppt
2. Operations Strategy in a Global Environment.ppt2. Operations Strategy in a Global Environment.ppt
2. Operations Strategy in a Global Environment.ppt
 
Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...
Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...
Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...
 
Manufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptx
Manufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptxManufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptx
Manufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptx
 
Embedded machine learning-based road conditions and driving behavior monitoring
Embedded machine learning-based road conditions and driving behavior monitoringEmbedded machine learning-based road conditions and driving behavior monitoring
Embedded machine learning-based road conditions and driving behavior monitoring
 
Swimming pool mechanical components design.pptx
Swimming pool  mechanical components design.pptxSwimming pool  mechanical components design.pptx
Swimming pool mechanical components design.pptx
 
New techniques for characterising damage in rock slopes.pdf
New techniques for characterising damage in rock slopes.pdfNew techniques for characterising damage in rock slopes.pdf
New techniques for characterising damage in rock slopes.pdf
 
CHINA’S GEO-ECONOMIC OUTREACH IN CENTRAL ASIAN COUNTRIES AND FUTURE PROSPECT
CHINA’S GEO-ECONOMIC OUTREACH IN CENTRAL ASIAN COUNTRIES AND FUTURE PROSPECTCHINA’S GEO-ECONOMIC OUTREACH IN CENTRAL ASIAN COUNTRIES AND FUTURE PROSPECT
CHINA’S GEO-ECONOMIC OUTREACH IN CENTRAL ASIAN COUNTRIES AND FUTURE PROSPECT
 
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
RAT: Retrieval Augmented Thoughts Elicit Context-Aware Reasoning in Long-Hori...
 
Modelagem de um CSTR com reação endotermica.pdf
Modelagem de um CSTR com reação endotermica.pdfModelagem de um CSTR com reação endotermica.pdf
Modelagem de um CSTR com reação endotermica.pdf
 
Properties Railway Sleepers and Test.pptx
Properties Railway Sleepers and Test.pptxProperties Railway Sleepers and Test.pptx
Properties Railway Sleepers and Test.pptx
 
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine LearningUnderstanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
 
A review on techniques and modelling methodologies used for checking electrom...
A review on techniques and modelling methodologies used for checking electrom...A review on techniques and modelling methodologies used for checking electrom...
A review on techniques and modelling methodologies used for checking electrom...
 
ACRP 4-09 Risk Assessment Method to Support Modification of Airfield Separat...
ACRP 4-09 Risk Assessment Method to Support Modification of Airfield Separat...ACRP 4-09 Risk Assessment Method to Support Modification of Airfield Separat...
ACRP 4-09 Risk Assessment Method to Support Modification of Airfield Separat...
 
IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems Society as a Graduate Student Member
IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems Society as a Graduate Student MemberIEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems Society as a Graduate Student Member
IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems Society as a Graduate Student Member
 
Series of visio cisco devices Cisco_Icons.ppt
Series of visio cisco devices Cisco_Icons.pptSeries of visio cisco devices Cisco_Icons.ppt
Series of visio cisco devices Cisco_Icons.ppt
 
PPT on GRP pipes manufacturing and testing
PPT on GRP pipes manufacturing and testingPPT on GRP pipes manufacturing and testing
PPT on GRP pipes manufacturing and testing
 
BPV-GUI-01-Guide-for-ASME-Review-Teams-(General)-10-10-2023.pdf
BPV-GUI-01-Guide-for-ASME-Review-Teams-(General)-10-10-2023.pdfBPV-GUI-01-Guide-for-ASME-Review-Teams-(General)-10-10-2023.pdf
BPV-GUI-01-Guide-for-ASME-Review-Teams-(General)-10-10-2023.pdf
 
basic-wireline-operations-course-mahmoud-f-radwan.pdf
basic-wireline-operations-course-mahmoud-f-radwan.pdfbasic-wireline-operations-course-mahmoud-f-radwan.pdf
basic-wireline-operations-course-mahmoud-f-radwan.pdf
 
KuberTENes Birthday Bash Guadalajara - K8sGPT first impressions
KuberTENes Birthday Bash Guadalajara - K8sGPT first impressionsKuberTENes Birthday Bash Guadalajara - K8sGPT first impressions
KuberTENes Birthday Bash Guadalajara - K8sGPT first impressions
 
International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...
International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...
International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...
 

Procurement : Resisting price increase

  • 1.
  • 2. Welcome to the program on Resisting Price Increase and Implementing Cost Improvement Initiatives by H K Varma Varmahk@Gmail.com 98202 62986 22 426 62986
  • 3. Our Mission Knowledge + Training = Prosperity
  • 4. Program schedule • 10.00 – 11.15 Session I • 11.30 – 1.00 Session II Lunch break 1.00 to 2.00 • 2.00 – 3.30 Session III • 3.30 – 4.50 Session IV • 4.50 – 5.00 Q / A • 5.00 ----------- Close
  • 5. Business scenario post GATT .... • Introduction of GATT ( General Agreement on Tariffs and trade ) under the WTO in the yr 1995 • reduced trade barriers amongst global players thru’ o Export subsidies , o lifting of quantitative restrictions and o reduction in tariff rates (from 20% -1950 to 3.6% - 2010) o s How it affected the businesses ! …………
  • 6. The survival mantra has become • “Survival of the fittest” Survival of the best Cost , quality and the fastest
  • 7. Inflation and how to beat it Inflation is a sustained increase in the general price level of goods and services over a period of time Inflation occurs due to an imbalance between demand and supply of money, changes in production and distribution cost or increase in taxes on products It could be : • Negative , or • Positive
  • 8. Mfg Cost Var Output at TP Stores cr. 4000 241 3972 +/- in WIP 178 PBIT Misc Output -206 1191 Input Cost 3731 Dir Malt 3000 NOPAT Dir Lab 86 810 Mktg PBIT Sales/Serv 6000 Malt OH 47 929 Cost of Sales 3972 Shop OH 261 ED on Sales 794 PGOH 36 TAX OD Adj Pers Rel Exp 89 Comm Exp 163 EVA 381 -65 T&C 54 Alloc Exp 189 361 Sales Pr Exp 8 Corp alloc NDC 19 86 ODE 63 WACC Estb 31 12% Other Exp 41 Cap Chg MMI 1034 449 Cap Emp WIP 370 3738 Net F Assets FG 53 601 Curr Assets Cust OS 3073 4597 Oth contl A 67 Net WC 3137 Curr Liabilities Vendor Cr 1273 1460 Cust Adv 33 OCL 154 Areas of focus 1. Reduction in Material & labor costs 2. Reduction the Lead time 3. Reduction in Rejections , Wastage 4. Reduce Working capital How an effective Purchase dept. can help improve EVA
  • 9. Material Cost reduction vs Increase in Profits 55 53.9 52.3 57.5 29.0 28.5 27.6 30.4 13.0 14.8 17.1 19.1 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 Material Labour O/H Profit Y1 Y2 –2% redu in M Y3 –5% redu in M 10% Volume Growth 14% Incr in P 32% Incr in P 47% Incr in P Rs in Cr Let us understand thru major cost elements of a Product !
  • 10. • Supply-chain executives have significant role in the  operating expenses  cost of goods sold and • hence have a major role in margin management
  • 11. Performance Measures qualitative vs quantitative • When analyzing SC performance, qualitative evaluations such as – Good – Fair – Adequate and – Poor • As a result, quantitative performance measures are often preferred to such qualitative evaluations. are vague and difficult to arrive at any meaningful conclusion.
  • 12. Performance monitoring of SC partners Should include : • Quality • OTD • Cost • Service Once the performance of the SC operations has been measured and performance gaps identified, it becomes important to identify what activities should be performed to close those gaps
  • 13. • A team from Focal Organization visits the Vendor and allocates points against a number of queries in a questionnaire. • Actual working of the quality department is audited by examining records, analysis of the system and talking to people on the spot. • Rating should be numeric ... , ... , ... , ....scale • After determining which factors are critical, a method is devised that allows the vendor to be judged or rated on each individual factor. Vendor Assessment
  • 14. Vendor Assessment ( Criticality * Rating ) 1 = Not Important 4 = Critical 1 = Poor 4 = High Vendor rating Criteri a No. Criteria Importance (A) Rating(B) A*B 1 2 3 4 1 Work stn condition 3 2 Maintenance of m/cs 3 3 Productivity 4 4 Safety Initiatives 4 .. 20 Quality Systems 4 Vendor :: Min Score = 20 Max Score = 320Evaluation CFT …….. Score < 100 Rejected
  • 15. Max Score Weighted score 1. GENERAL ORGANIZATION: 4 2.9 2. SAFETY 4 2.3 3. INSPECTION 4 3.4 4. DRAWING & REVISION CONTROL 4 2.8 5. PROCUREMENT: INCOMING R M CONTROL 4 2.4 6. MANUFACTURING PROCESSES 4 2.1 7. TOOLINGS & MEASURING INSTRUMENTS 4 3.7 8. QUALITY : QUALITY INDICATORS 4 2.6 9. M/C & TOOLING MAINTENANCE SYSTEM 4 2.5 10. ENVIRONMENT 4 3.2 40 27.9 Supplier Assessment (Summary)
  • 16. Supplier Assessment score Overall Score Acceptable > 30 Green Conditional 20 - 29 Orange Poor Performer 12 - 19 Yellow Rejected < 12 Red Vendors with low scores are asked to overcome the shortcomings with focus on time-bound improvements
  • 17. A good supplier helps our organization to be more efficient, produce higher quality products or services, reduce costs, and increase profits. A poor performer can disrupt our operations, make our organization fail in the eyes of our customers, increase our costs, and threaten our profits hence need for Vendor development .........
  • 18. ISO9000/ TS16949 Costing - Transparent Impln.of Lean & six sigma initiatives Help you reduce costs VE Loaning of tools, gauges , testing equip etc Vendor Training Negotiation with supplier’s supplier Partnership / JV Resisting Price Increase Structured negotiationOn-time Delivery
  • 19. Value Engineering (value analysis) • VE is a systematic and organized approach to provide the necessary functions of a product / service / process at the lowest cost. • Value engineering promotes the substitution of materials and methods with less expensive alternatives, without sacrificing functionality. • These substitutes were often found to reduce costs and provided equal or better performance. • Value, as defined, is the ratio of function to cost , V = F C • Alternately : Value = (Performance + Capability)/Cost = Function/Cost • Value can therefore be increased by either improving the function or reducing the cost.
  • 20. VE (structured thought process to evaluate options as follows) Gather information ⁻ What is being done now? ⁻ Who is doing it? ⁻ What could it do? ⁻ What must it not do? Measure ⁻ How will the alternatives be measured? Analyze ⁻ What must be done? ⁻ What else can perform the desired function? ⁻ What does it cost? Generate ⁻ What else will do the job? Evaluate ⁻ Which Ideas are the best? Develop and expand ideas ⁻ What are the impacts? ⁻ What is the cost? ⁻ What is the performance? Present ideas ‒ Sell alternatives
  • 21. Vendor development • Procuring organization forms a team of engineers and assign it to their suppliers for carrying out the specific development projects. • By having the direct support of their client and regular monitoring of their development – will be more motivated to carry out the program fully & – will readily realize that the program is indispensable.
  • 22. • Points to remember – Negotiate the Supplier's Entire Volume not only for your requirement but also for his other customers need. – The larger the volume , the greater your savings. – Always Manage The Negotiations. • You may have the knowledge and technology to manage the negotiations better than the supplier. – This also gives you the control on timeline, information on inputs, etc. Negotiating on behalf of your subcontractor to avail lower costs
  • 23. ISO 9000 / TS 16949 certification ---- • ISO 9000 certification stresses the importance of compliance on technical specifications and the quality requirements . • In fact , some procuring enterprises agree to work with suppliers only if they are ISO 9000 certified. • To help subcontractors acquire such certification, main contractor should assist them with regard to system & procedures to be adopted for • documentation control • product purchasing ………………..
  • 24. Total quality (zero defects) management • Detect defective components and diagnose the causes of such defects • Reduce waste and reworking • Build up expertise • Review the importance of quality in the budget • Develop a culture centered on the workers’ accountability for quality and • show them what they can gain in terms of personal satisfaction and security.
  • 25. Allowing use of main contractors’ production facilities by subcontractors … Subcontractor is an extended partner in your supply chain He should be allowed to have access to main contractors facilities such as : – instruments – moulds – prototypes – patterns – quality control equipment etc which directly enhance the quality of products.
  • 26. Organization of work within the enterprise • Internal functioning of an enterprise is important from a quality viewpoint. • Thus to gain a better appreciation of overall coordination the organization would need: – No barriers between different departments / Sections (Homogeneity between departments) – Encourage teamwork – Organize discussions on working practices and investigate solutions to problems
  • 27. Objectives of Vendor rating – To motivate suppliers to improve performance. – To apportion orders to deserving vendors for overall cost reduction. – To select vendors for further development. – To reduce the cost of inspection of incoming lots by modifying sampling plan
  • 28. Vendo r Total receipt s VQR VQR *50% Del Timely receipt s Del Timely Rating - Ratio * 20 Del Qty Receip ts Delive ry Rating % * 20 Servic e out of 10% A 100 90 45 18.4 84 16.8 8 B 60 80 40 48 16 52 17.3 7 C 50 70 35 41 16.4 17.6 6 Vendor Composite Rating with weight ages for Quality , Delivery & Service (Subjective)
  • 29. With Improveme nts NOS. PECENTAGE GREEN 72 54 Orange 34 26 Yellow 23 17 Red 4 3 133 100 After Improvement program Quantum jump in Vendor profile Earlier NOS. PECENTA GE GREEN 68 48 acceptable Orange 32 23 conditional Yellow 26 18 poor perf Red 15 11 rejected 141 100
  • 30. Supplier reward program • There are two sides of performance improvement motivation: – Rewarding the suppliers who perform well so they will aspire to continue performing well , and – Correcting Poor Performance : taking corrective action with those suppliers whose performance does not meet our expectations. • It would never be safe to assume that switching supplier eliminates problems
  • 31. • With focus on shrunken vendor base , • Consolidation with limited few vendors is encouraged called tier 1 suppliers who in turn take responsibility for quality of tier 2/3 suppliers • Suppliers are assured of long term commitments and cooperative relationship • Buyers work along with suppliers to develop cost reduction for both firms • Suppliers are even allowed to keep certain portion of the profits thru these joint efforts Vendor consolidation
  • 32. Supplier Relationship model (SRM) Unilateral “Make the best part” Interactive “Together develop better spec” Collaborative “Supplier teams make the best system or process.” Higher Supplier Involvement Higher Value Addition
  • 33. 1. To improve supplier performance. On cost reduction , OTD , Zero defect , Reduced W/C , prompt service . 2. To reduce risk. . Ensure continuity of supply in the face of unexpected disruption to the operations of one or more suppliers from natural disasters, political upheavals, and other events 3. To provide flexibility and agility to the organization thru’ a healthy vendor base 4. To save money Strategic Sourcing Goals of Material department
  • 34. 0 100000 200000 300000 400000 500000 600000 700000 20000 40000 60000 80000 100000 120000 Cost of Buying(5) Cost of Mkg I/H Cost of buying Cost of Making I/H Time for demanding Volume discount.
  • 35. Conference Compromise ConferenceConference Negotiation Negotiation is therefore a process involving a conference whereby skillful maneuvering & compromise are used to achieve an agreement The time invested on negotiation should yield tangible results
  • 36. Ensure early Purchasing Involvement • Suppliers try to woo the Internal customers to get insight to the decision making process & other important information . • Purchasing professionals are typically trained to uphold high ethical standards and will ensure that these tactics are not successfully used by suppliers. • Purchasing professionals are experts in evaluating the overall supplier capabilities wrt to financial(Z-score ) ,Quality, Technical & Mfg excellence . • A passion for risk management which other wise may get ignored ( Succession plan , Tax and duty structure ,overall low cost etc )
  • 37. Effective Negotiation skills preparation & planning • Prepare in details for conducting a successful negotiation • Bring in more transparency to the process for a long term relationship • Remember you’re the expert • A good negotiation should cover all terms : price, warranty, delivery, payment terms, etc. • What often happens is that one supplier offers the best price, 2nd offers the best warranty, a third offers the best delivery, etc.
  • 38. Should A Manager Join A Negotiation In Late Stages? While some managers feel their jumping in at a later stage will squeeze another 5% out of the supplier, the fact is that their actions result in companies getting worse deals, not better. • Actually, the supplier may welcome another counterpart - that way he can play "divide and conquer" and get the manager to agree to concessions that the buyer would not. • • If past history compels a supplier to predict that a manager will join a negotiation in its late stages, • will the supplier ever give its best deal to the buyer ? No - the supplier will withhold it so that it has something to offer the manager later.
  • 39. Product Costing • Product Cost • Direct Cost » Direct Mfg Cost 1. Direct Labour 2. Direct Material • Indirect Cost » Non-Mfg Costs 1. Variable overheads 2. Fixed overheads 3. Selling Costs 4. Administrative costs
  • 40. Component Cost Nett Wt (grams) …… (Volume * Density) 105 Charge Wt (Grams) 120 Rate/Kg (Rs) after MODVAT 87 RM Cost/Pc (Rs) 10.44 ICC at 3% 0.31 Cycle Time (Sec) 380 Available time (7hrs) = 7*60*60 sec 25200 Output / Shift ( 1 Cav Mold ) 66 Molding cost per piece (Shift rate / Output - 558/66) 8.42 Post molding opr.(Rs 220/shift , Output 380 nos) 0.66 Inspn Cost ( Rs 5000 pm - 500pc/shift) 0.40 Pkg/Forwarding 0.43 Sub-total 20.66 O/H ( 12%) 2.48 Profit (10% on L) 0.99 Total rate / Unit 24.13
  • 41. Zero based costing Apportions all costs ( Direct , Indirect and overheads ) on total production Needs to take on overall view on expenses to keep O/H at minimum Improve the productivity , M/c utilization Increase production levels in order to spread the total expenses on larger volumes Ensure alt. product is ready for offloading as per Product life cycle
  • 42. Cost of Quality Cost of Quality Cost of good quality Cost of poor quality = +
  • 43. Cost of Quality Failure of Vendor to meet quality • Complaints • Warranties • Repairing goods •Loss due to sales reductions • Checking & Testing Purchased costs • In-process and Final Inspection Testing • Field Testing • Product , Process and Service Audits • Calibration •Scrap •Rework •Re-testing •Delays •Shortages •Supplier Evaluation • Error Proofing • Quality Improvement projects • ISO • Quality Education and Training • Quality planning • New Product Review Preservat ion Costs Internal Failure costs External Failure Costs Appraisal costs Costofservicingdefects PreventionandAppraisalCost Your focus Leads to Striking a balance Economic conformance point
  • 44. Cost of Quality Management vs Cost of servicing defects Low Quality High LowCostHigh Minimum cost of Quality Total cost of Quality Cost of Service defects Where you want to be Cost of Quality Manageme nt
  • 45. The Lean-Six Sigma philosophy Cost of Quality Management vs Cost of servicing defectsLowCostHigh Prevention and Appraisal cost 𝟒𝝈 𝟓𝝈 𝟔𝝈 Economic conformance point
  • 46. Hold Suppliers More Accountable For the Quality of their Products Drive performance improvement thru’ CFTs to manage quality across entire spectrum of suppliers ⁻ Non-Conformances / Corrective and Preventive Action (NC/CAPA) ⁻ Complaint Handling ⁻ Statistical Process Control (SPC) – to get Real-time visibility of supplier quality metrics through web-based portal • Real-time visibility of manufacturing data helps OEMs eliminate the black box effect of outsourcing critical components. • It also eliminates surprises on the receiving nonconforming materials.
  • 47. Process Yield & First time Yield • Traditionally , Yield is the proportion of • Lots accepted out of total lots received • Yield = 79/80 = 98.75% In 80 Out 79 Yield = 98.75% Vendor Receipts Lots Returned 1
  • 48. Deliveries From Vendor ”A” 80 - Lots Received 79 – Lots Ultimately accepted Inspection Yield = (80-72)/80 = 90% - FTY The hidden factory of in-process inspection and rework accounts for 98.75% - 90.0% = 8.75% The Hidden factory is due to The inability to correctly comply with required specifications the first time FTY & The Hidden Factory Hidden Factory = 8.75% The extra efforts put to get these 7 lots accepted is HIDDEN FACTORYUltimate Yield = 98.8% Lots Rej. & returned -1 Rejn. - 8
  • 49. An effective Purchase departments helps to build Vendor Flexibility & provide Agility to our organization
  • 50. Flexibility • Supply chain flexibility is defined as “the ability to quickly respond to changes in demand while achieving your objectives of – customer service, – shorter lead time , – cost, – inventory and – return on assets (ROA)
  • 51. F-Flexibility measures • Volume flexibility (Fv ) : measures the proportion of demand that can be met profitably by the supply chain system • Delivery flexibility (Fd ) : – The ability to move planned delivery dates forward . – This ability allows the supply chain to accommodate rush orders and special orders, and will be described as delivery flexibility. – Delivery flexibility is expressed as the percentage of slack time by which the delivery time can be reduced • Mix flexibility (Fm ) : the response time between product mix changes. • New product flexibility (Fn): is defined as the ease with which new products are introduced , the time or cost required to add new products to existing production operations
  • 52. Period (t) Deman d volume (units) Period (t) Deman d volume (units) Period (t) Deman d volume (units) Period (t) Deman d volume (units) 1 16 9 12 17 38 25 24 2 21 10 43 18 19 26 17 3 32 11 8 19 29 27 36 4 5 12 29 20 12 28 11 5 18 13 33 21 34 29 28 6 26 14 39 22 50 30 23 7 40 15 7 23 16 31 32 8 31 16 15 24 30 32 17 Volume flexibility (𝐹𝑣) Contd. 𝐷 = 𝒅 𝒕 𝑇 𝑡=1 𝑻 = 24.69 𝑆 𝐷 = (𝒅 𝒕 − 𝒅) 𝟐𝑇 𝑡=1 𝑻 − 𝟏 = 11.35
  • 53. Summarize Fv Group 1 2 3 4 5 Std Dev 11.33 11.33 11.10 10.50 7.73 Avg 24.5 24.5 21.16 28.22 28.53 Min 5 9 9 9 9 Max 49 42 42 42 42 Fv 0.70 0.29 1.27 0.84 1.27 Fv comes down as range is narrowe d down Fv rises with Avg out put coming down. NO Flexibility with lower output Lower variation clubbed with Higher output improves Fv Further reduction in variation improves Fv Supplier is geared up to give Higher volumes consistently ( Lower std dev) leading to higher volumes + Flexibility
  • 54. Delivery flexibility (Fd) • Delivery dates change regularly and costs are associated with not meeting the delivery dates • The ability to move planned delivery dates forward may be important in supply chain management. • This ability allows the supply chain to accommodate rush orders and special orders, and is described as delivery flexibility. • Delivery flexibility is expressed as the percentage of slack time by which the delivery time can be reduced/advanced
  • 55. Delivery flexibility (Fd ) Summary Existing Time –T period – Week No Lj Ej - Gr 1 Ej - Gr 2 Ej – Gr 3 Ej – Gr 4 23 36 33 31 30 29 23 45 41 39 38 37 23 37 32 31 30 29 23 41 38 35 34 33 23 47 42 41 40 38 Fd 22.0 31.9 37.4 44.0 Further increase means adding resources 2X , 3X , 4X ... , Reduction in C/O time . However there is limit to increase beyond certain levels due to inherent processing time
  • 56. Agility Impro veme nt NOPA T Current assets Curr Liability Current ratio Fixed Asset (Depreciation) Total Cap employed ROCE Capital Charge @ 12% EVA 810 4597 1460 3.1 601 3738 21.7 449 361 1 810 4137 1460 2.8 601 3278 24.7 393 417 2 810 3724 1460 2.6 601 2865 28.3 344 466 3 810 3351 1460 2.3 601 2492 32.5 299 511 4 810 3016 1460 2.1 601 2157 37.6 259 551 5 810 2714 1460 1.9 601 1855 43.7 223 587 YoY 10% redu in Inventory 1. Working capital (Inventory) control
  • 57. Six Sigma • Every mistake an organization or person makes ultimately has a cost, – the need to do a certain task over again, – the part that has to be replaced, – time or material wasted • You consume additional resources to correct a problem before it's delivered to the customer • Six Sigma is a scientific problem solving tool for – meeting your customer's needs (Time , speed , Quality ) – minimizing wasted resources (Errors , rework , Hidden factory , variations +/-) – maximizing profit in the process ,thru’ disciplined data collection and analysis to determine best solutions
  • 58. Six Sigma focus • The goal of Six Sigma is to inject – disciplined control, – predictability, and – consistency of results so that the product comes off the production line absolutely consistently. • The methodology of Six Sigma was first applied in a manufacturing company, but is extensively used in service and transactional companies (like banks and hospitals), • Six Sigma initiatives and projects have a direct measurable financial focus eg OFR , Quality , Lead time , OTD ,IT , ROI etc
  • 59. Higher Process Sigma – lower Rejection • A low process sigma means that a significant part of the tail of the distribution is extending past the specification limit. More defects. • So the higher the process sigma score Z , the fewer the defects 1. 2σ = 30.8% Rej 2. 3σ = 6.68% Rej 3. 3.4σ = 3% Rej 4. 4σ = 0.62% Rej 5. 5σ = 0.0223% Rej 6. 6σ = 0.0003% Rej } Most of Indian Industries are here This is the journey we have to undertake
  • 60. 2 approaches to Improvement DMAIC DFSS • Six Sigma offers two approaches for improvement 1. Improve the process so that chances of defects are reduced ,ie reduce the standard deviation (increase Z score) thru’ DMAIC 2. Change the design (DFSS) so that product can accommodate process variations • A Six Sigma process should not generate any flaws , but since , over the long run (Lt Std Dev) , every process shifts
  • 61. Process capability of a process or characteristic to meet its specifications (VOC/VOP) 1. Capability : Ability to match the voice of your process-VOP to the voice of your customer-VOC 2. The simplest capability index is called Cp. 3. It compares the width of a two-sided specification to the effective short term width of the process. USL - LSL represents the VOC-voice of the customer's requirements and 6σst represents the inherent voice of the process -VOP Cp = ( USL-LSL ) 6σst Effective process width under Six Sigma = 99.7% In this example , Process capability = 1 LSL USL
  • 62. Cp • Cp is known as measure of process capability . • It is the number of times the spread of the process fits into the tolerance width. • The higher the value of Cp, the better the process.
  • 63. Control • A solution that isn’t sustained over the long term has little value • Control charts are two-dimensional graph plotting the – performance of a process on Y axis, and – time or the sequence of data samples on X axis. • They are basically a type of Run chart with control limits Why Control chart – It shows nature of variation in the process over time – Helps in detecting changes in the process – Helps in controlling the process • Specs : USL/LSL vs UCL/LCL – CONTROL is also capability , 𝐂 𝐩 - Process Capability
  • 64. Why Controls 1. Process behavior is complex and fragile and that hard- earned gains slip away if the process is left to itself. 2. The Control phase helps you make sure the problem stays fixed, and, if done properly, provides you with additional data to make further improvements to the process. 3. A well designed process exhibits inherent self control, but.. 4. A poorly designed process requires frequent external control and adjustment to meet requirements. 5. A process with well built-in control acts like the heating and cooling system in a house: The system automatically maintains a comfortable temperature at all times.
  • 65. Variable Control Charts • Variable Control charts are used to monitor measurable quality characteristics of a process eg Temperature , dimension , weight , viscosity etc • Variable charts can monitor only one quality characteristic at a time . • For more than one characteristic, a chart for each characteristic needs to be created • Variable Control charts help to monitor both process mean and process variability • Hence it becomes necessary to use minimum 2 control charts to study the process. Ie – Range or Std Deviation – Process mean , with UCL & LCL
  • 66. Variable Control Chart - contd – R Chart / X Chart or – X / S chart or – MR / X chart • An X chart is the most widely used control chart which monitors the sample variability • The R chart is used when sample size is less than 10 • S chart is used when sample size is greater than 10. • For quality characteristic with sample size one , moving range needs to be established and hence a MR chart is used. • As a thumb rule 20 to 25 samples should be selected for analysis with sample size of 4 to 5 .
  • 67. Working Capital Cycle Cash FG Purchase of Raw Matl Receivables/ Collection 1 Months 2 Months Production 0.5 Month 1 W/C Cycle ?? No of Cycles/ Yr = 2.4 Target …… 0.5 Month
  • 68. Balance Sheet model of a Firm Current Assets -Receivables -Inventories Current Liabilities or Short Term Debt-Payables Fixed Assets 1.Tangible Fixed Assets (M/c ,Equipments ,Land) 2.Intangible Assets ( Patents, Trade mark, Quality of Management) Long Term Debt Shareholder’s equity Assets Liabilities
  • 69. Service % MMI in Rs L Sigma level 99.9996 100 6.00 99.998 95 5.80 99.994 90 5.30 99.990 85 5.27 99.966 80 5.00 99.874 75 4.45 99.78 70 4.30 99.7 65 4.15 99.5 60 4.10 99.1 55 3.90 98.6 50 3.66 98 45 3.45 97 40 3.40 96 35 3.20 6 sigma 3 Sigma 4 Sigma 5 Sigma
  • 70. Sigma level Production hold-ups due to non- availability of Material 2 Most of the time 3 25-40% 4 15-25% 5 1-15% 6 < 1% Service level V/S Matl Non-availability
  • 71.
  • 72. Sum-up • Last but not least : • You’ve got to make sure your suppliers understand how you define Quality and OTD. – Avoiding this step appears negatively in your cost , and second – Your relationship with suppliers is important. You have to treat them more like partners than suppliers. The success mantra for getting quality products and maximizing cost reductions is by working harmoniously with suppliers as if they’re a trusted partner
  • 73. Establish (KPIs) of all related processes and actions to Accelerate Operational Excellence • It's crucial to identify a specific set of KPIs that will help you measure progress and identify areas for adjustment. • Equally important to having these measures, however, is a related system of communication procedures, processes around the KPIs to ensure that they are being accurately measured, interpreted, communicated, and acted upon.
  • 74. Purchasing Ethics • I believe that the position of Purchase Engineer is important , honorable , worthy , responsible , and calls forth the highest ethical principles in relationship and dealing with men. • I believe in the ‘square deal’ towards the company I represent and towards the men with whom I do business . • I believe it is my duty to refuse and renounce gifts or perquisites from those with whom I transact business.