Highways Supplier
Relationship Development
         (SRD)

     Local Transport Today
      9th November 2011
Agenda
• SRD
  – Principles
  – Who has been involved
  – Approach
  – Change in Emphasis
• Overview of Best Practice findings
  – Conway clients
  – Volker clients
• Comments

                                       2
SRD - Principles
• To analyse the relationships between
  buying and supplying organisations to
  identify scope for greater efficiencies
  – It’s a two-way process
  – Opportunities to improve performance –
    smarter contract behaviors
  – Opportunities to implement cost savings for
    mutual benefit


                                                  3
Who has been involved
Conway Clients
Volker Clients
                                                                               Enfield



                                                           Barnet

                                    Harrow                                   Haringey
                                                                                                       Redbridge
                                                                                           Waltham
                                                                                           Forest
                                                                                                                               Havering
                                                 Brent
                                                                Camden
                                                                                                                  Barking &
                                                                                                     Newham       Dagenham
                                                                                          Tower
                     Hillingdon        Ealing                                   City     Hamlets



                                                                                                      Greenwich
                                  Hounslow                                                                            Bexley

                                                           Wandsworth
                                        Richmond                                           Lewisham



                                                             Merton

                                                Kingston
                                                                                                        Bromley

                                                                    Sutton
     Participating       6                                                        Croydon

     Participating       5




                                                                                                                                          4
SRD – Approach
•   Series of Briefings and Meetings
•   Create initial SRD Strategy via
    - Market Information
    - Common Assessment Framework
    - Project Manager Visits
•   Appoint Negotiation Team
•   Negotiation Sessions – best practice
    identification
•   SRD Strategy document

You and Your Contractor –
www.capitalambition.gov.uk/srdbestpractice
SRD White Paper -
 www.capitalambition.gov.uk/srdwhitepaper
The “SRD toolkit” –
www.capitalambition.gov.uk/srdtoolkit
                                             Negotiation
                                              Meetings 5
Max.




    Max.
                    VOLKER HIGHWAYS                                                         F M CONWAY




    Current
                                                                      Current
                                                                                Service Delivery Manager (Co-




    7
    1
                                                                       6
              Drainage Products




                                                                      16
                                                                                Located)

                                                                                Formally Integrated Team -




    7
    7
                                                                       2
              Recycled Materials




                                                                      16
                                                                                Partnering Charter

              Footway Specification                                             Early Contractor Involvement




    7
    7
                                                                      16
                                                                      16




                                         Materials Specifications &
              Alteration                                                        (Walk and Build)

                                                                                Intelligent KPIs - financial




    7
    2
              Sliding Scale Discount




                                                                       4
                                                                      16
                                                                                implications

              Discount for up front                                             Partially Managed Service -




    7
    0
                                                                       3
                                                                      16
              payment                                                           Safety Inspections

                                                                                Partially Managed Service -




    7
    0
                                         Discounts for Turnover
              Fixed Spending & Profile
                                                                       7
                                                                                                                   Best Practice




                                                                      16
                                                                                Scheme Design

              Joint Completed Works                                             Partially Managed Service -Full




    7
    1
                                                                       1
                                                                      16



              Inspection - Large jobs                                           Scheme Implementation (design,
                                                                                consultation and construction)
              Joint Completed Works




    7
    0
                                                                       7




                                                                                Lump Sum / Early Payment
                                                                      16




              Inspection - small jobs
                                         Best Practice




              Remote Monitoring of




    7
    0
                                                                                Volume Discounts - Sliding Scale
                                                                       3
                                                                      16




              Street Lighting
                                                                                Discount

              Temp. Make-safe of


    7
    2
                                                                                Fixed Spending Profile and
                                             Operational Mangement
                                                                       5
                                                                      16




              damaged gully grates
                                                                                payment

              Find & Fix approach to
    7
    2


              potholes

              Standadised approach to
    7
    7
                                                                                                                                   Overview of Findings




              procurement (e.g PQQ,
              CHAS, PAS91)

              Minimised Numbers of
    7
    2




              Invoices

              Early Contractor
    7
    7




              Involvement
                                         Contract Operations




6




              Contractor undertakes
    7
    0




              Design
Some comments
• Difficulty (reluctance from contractor) in
  getting savings amounts
• Contractor can do more than is being asked
  of them.
  – Have provided indications of future service
    developments – e.g. Design,
• “Thin client” model
  – How far can you/do you go?
• Varying exploitation of Highways Systems
  – Mobile
  – Accuracy of Asset Inventory
  – Sometimes hampered by local IT
                                                  7
Thank you




            8

Philip Snowling, Highways Supplier Relationship Development

  • 1.
    Highways Supplier Relationship Development (SRD) Local Transport Today 9th November 2011
  • 2.
    Agenda • SRD – Principles – Who has been involved – Approach – Change in Emphasis • Overview of Best Practice findings – Conway clients – Volker clients • Comments 2
  • 3.
    SRD - Principles •To analyse the relationships between buying and supplying organisations to identify scope for greater efficiencies – It’s a two-way process – Opportunities to improve performance – smarter contract behaviors – Opportunities to implement cost savings for mutual benefit 3
  • 4.
    Who has beeninvolved Conway Clients Volker Clients Enfield Barnet Harrow Haringey Redbridge Waltham Forest Havering Brent Camden Barking & Newham Dagenham Tower Hillingdon Ealing City Hamlets Greenwich Hounslow Bexley Wandsworth Richmond Lewisham Merton Kingston Bromley Sutton Participating 6 Croydon Participating 5 4
  • 5.
    SRD – Approach • Series of Briefings and Meetings • Create initial SRD Strategy via - Market Information - Common Assessment Framework - Project Manager Visits • Appoint Negotiation Team • Negotiation Sessions – best practice identification • SRD Strategy document You and Your Contractor – www.capitalambition.gov.uk/srdbestpractice SRD White Paper - www.capitalambition.gov.uk/srdwhitepaper The “SRD toolkit” – www.capitalambition.gov.uk/srdtoolkit Negotiation Meetings 5
  • 6.
    Max. Max. VOLKER HIGHWAYS F M CONWAY Current Current Service Delivery Manager (Co- 7 1 6 Drainage Products 16 Located) Formally Integrated Team - 7 7 2 Recycled Materials 16 Partnering Charter Footway Specification Early Contractor Involvement 7 7 16 16 Materials Specifications & Alteration (Walk and Build) Intelligent KPIs - financial 7 2 Sliding Scale Discount 4 16 implications Discount for up front Partially Managed Service - 7 0 3 16 payment Safety Inspections Partially Managed Service - 7 0 Discounts for Turnover Fixed Spending & Profile 7 Best Practice 16 Scheme Design Joint Completed Works Partially Managed Service -Full 7 1 1 16 Inspection - Large jobs Scheme Implementation (design, consultation and construction) Joint Completed Works 7 0 7 Lump Sum / Early Payment 16 Inspection - small jobs Best Practice Remote Monitoring of 7 0 Volume Discounts - Sliding Scale 3 16 Street Lighting Discount Temp. Make-safe of 7 2 Fixed Spending Profile and Operational Mangement 5 16 damaged gully grates payment Find & Fix approach to 7 2 potholes Standadised approach to 7 7 Overview of Findings procurement (e.g PQQ, CHAS, PAS91) Minimised Numbers of 7 2 Invoices Early Contractor 7 7 Involvement Contract Operations 6 Contractor undertakes 7 0 Design
  • 7.
    Some comments • Difficulty(reluctance from contractor) in getting savings amounts • Contractor can do more than is being asked of them. – Have provided indications of future service developments – e.g. Design, • “Thin client” model – How far can you/do you go? • Varying exploitation of Highways Systems – Mobile – Accuracy of Asset Inventory – Sometimes hampered by local IT 7
  • 8.