SlideShare a Scribd company logo
AMANPREET KOCHHAR
PORTFOLIO
EDUCATION
Bachelor of Engineering in Mechanical Engineering
(October 2014)
Major: Manufacturing
Ryerson University
Related Course Work: Mechanical design, Sheet metal fabrication and tool engineering,
Engineering graphics and design, Design for manufacturing, Fabrication and tool engineering.
SUMMARY OF QUALIFICATIONS
• More than 2 years of industrial experience in CAD designing and 3D modelling.
• Strong academic training in Mechanical Engineering acquired from 4 years of accredited
university education.
• Hard working, detail oriented and problem solver.
• Excellent computer skills using Microsoft applications, ERP systems.
• Well-developed designing skills using AutoCAD, Solidworks, Civil 3D and primavera.
ENGINEERING DESIGN AND ANALYSIS SOFTWARES
AutoCAD including 3D Civil, Solid works, MasterCAM, DFM& DFMA, Ansys, Primavera, MS
Office 2003-2013 including Access, Project and Visio, Internet Browsers.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Solid works drawings for Forklift for small stores and warehouses
2. Small cogeneration power plant design using different turbines and feed water heater
configurations.
3. Stresses and heat transfer analysis in bars and bridges using ANSYS (Finite element
analysis)
4. Determining root locus and time setting response in control systems using MATLAB
simulation
5. Capstone Conference paper
FORKLIFT DESIGN
3D drawing of Forklift designed for operation in small stores and warehouses
Detailed Drawing of the forklift including all the dimensions
COGENRATION POWERPLANT DESIGN
Power plant design with 1 turbine and zero feed water heater
Power plant design with 4 turbine and 2 feed water heaters
Power plant design with 4 turbine and 3 feed water heaters
Power plant design with 5 turbine and 3 feed water heaters
FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS
Von misses stress in metallic bracket
Original truss configuration with uniform load and point loads applied
Deformed + un-deformed shape of the truss configuration
Displacement of the truss (in inches)
The axial stress values in truss (in psi)
Redesign truss configuration 1 with addition and removal of beam members
The deformed + un-deformed shape for redesign configuration
The deflection in the redesign truss configuration (in inches)
CONTROL SYSTEM ANALYSIS
Root Locus for Transfer function of Path 1
Unit Response for Settling Time < 4 seconds
Root Locus for Transfer Function of Path 2
Alternate Unit Response with 3.83 Second Settling time
5 CAPSTONE CONFERENCE PAPER
CRITICAL DESIGN PARAMETERS PREVENTING FAILURES IN PRESSURE
VESSELS
A. John Hannah B. Bishoy Azmy C. Shiva Sharafian-Jazi D. Amanpreet Kochhar
Supervisor: Dr. Ahmad Varvani Farahani
Abstract
Pressure vessels are containers that handle high
pressure of fluids or gases at different
temperature and pressure conditions. Design of
the containers is critical to enable it resist the
forces associated with high pressure of gases or
liquids. The report will analyze the stresses
created by the liquids or gasses, and the causes
of failure that occurs in pressure vessels.
Pressures vessels normally experience stress
and the most common are compressive, tensile
and thermal. The report will examine the
different types of failure attained in pressure
vessels and several occasions that cause the
vessels to rupture assisting the group in learning
from the mistakes previously made and assist in
the preparation of the design of a safer
container. Most common failures are caused by
cracking, erosion, caustic embrittlement, over-
heating, welding issues among others. The
report focuses on the study of causes of failure
and their attributes and ensuring it does not
appear in the ultimate design of the pressure
vessel. The use of the correct material selection
strategies is critical in the design of pressure
vessels. Materials in the construction selection
are based on the tensile strength, strong
resilience, high ductility and ease in
manufacturability and cost. Steel alloys are
selected for construction of pressure vessels.
The material that will be used in the making the
pressure vessel is the ASTM A516 Grade 70.
Introduction
Pressure vessels are cylindrical containers used
to store volatile chemicals and reactive gasses.
Since the materials stored in the pressure vessel
are in critical state hence the design of pressure
vessel has to be accurate to avoid the failure. In
this project the pressure vessel for storage of
steam is taken into consideration. Steam is state of
water vapors at very high temperature and pressure.
Since the steam is taken into account as storage
material in pressure vessels hence the probability of
failure due to corrosion and erosion factors become
very predominant. The past accidents and the main
reason related to the accidents have been considered
to present a new design such that it does not fail
under such parameters.
The root causes of the accidents are high stress and
fatigue phenomenon. The pressure vessel could fail
either because of Tensile, Compressive or Thermal
stresses. The stresses result in development of the
cracks and the fatigue failure. The above figure
shows the normal and the axial stresses on the
surfaces of the pressure vessels.
Figure 1: Normal & axial Stresses in the pressure
vessels [1]
Since the steam is stored in the pressure vessel the
inside surface of the pressure vessels is expected to
go very hot due to present of some impurities in
quality of the steam the pressure vessels can
experience some variation in temperature hence the
thermal stress could stimulate due to thermal shocks
and pressure vessel are prone to burst and explosion.
The pressure vessel failure due to thermal shock
explosion is shown in the following figure
Figure 2: The surface cracks due to burst [2]
The fatigue phenomenon is also very important
in case of pressure vessel design. The fatigue
life of the material changes due to presence of
overheating, corrosion or high loading. The
effect of the discussed parameters is shown in
the following figures.
Figure3: Change in fatigue life due to
overloading [3]
Figure4: Change in fatigue life due to
corrosion [3]
The Pressure Vessel material is generally
chosen to be ductile as the cracks are easily
identifiable in ductile material as compared to
the brittle material. In the ductile materials the
material stretches to show the necking before
breaking hence the cracking is easy to
identifiable in ductile material as compared to
the brittle material. The brittle and the ductile
cracking is shown in the following figure
Figure5: Brittle and Ductile Fracture [4]
The above discussed factors lead to many failures
and accidents. Some commonly occurring accidents
are discussed and the design against these failures is
presented.
Some of the common accidents are
• Deaerator cracking due to presence of
dissolved oxygen and gasses in steam
• Uncontrolled surface temperature due to
overheating resulting in thermal shocks
• Failures due to corrosion are big problem
in steam pressure vessels corrosion
generally results in weakening of the
material which eventually results in the
burst or explosion. The main type of the
corrosion failures in the pressure vessels
are stress corrosion cracking, Caustic
embrittlement which tends to make the
surface brittle hence crack identification
becomes difficult, corrosion fatigue etc.
• There are several other accidents such as
erosion, rupture, improper fabrication and
welding of the surfaces resulting in stress,
the improper material selection and poor
design could also equal contributors in the
failure of the pressure vessels
Some of the discussed failures are shown in the
following figures
Figure 6: Salt deposition on surface
resulting in corrosion [5]
Figure 7: Faulty welding [6]
Failure elimination strategies
Since the causes of the failures were studied so
the failure elimination strategies were
formulated and a design model was presented
according to the strategies. The outline of the
strategies is discusses as following
• Material selection strategies: The material
for pressure vessels was selected on the
basis of design for strength against the
failure. The appropriate performance index
was plotted on the material selection chart
for the strength vs density chart and Steel
alloys were selected as appropriate material
for the pressure vessels AISI 5160 Steel
was finalized for construction.
• The crack identification is also very
important phenomenon to prevent the
failure in the pressure vessels. The crack
identification techniques are proposed for
identification of the cracks is Wet
fluorescent magnetic particle testing,
Brinell hardness test etc.
• The stress is mainly present at the welded
surface because when metals are welded
then their material properties change and
strength is decreased. In order to reduce
failure due to welding MIG (Gas Metal
Arc) welding is recommended because the weld
joints are uniform and deposition rates are
higher giving a strong and continuous weld
joint
• Finite element Analysis: The pressure vessel
calculations were performed for AISI 5160
steel and finite element analysis was
performed for the given pressure and
temperature parameters as recommended by
ASME handbooks. The maximum stress in the
pressure vessel by applying the maximum
pressure of 2.75 MPa came out to be 170 MPa,
when the pressure was doubled and the stress
value increased to 339 MPa. The material has
ultimate tensile stress of 705 MPa hence it is
suitable for pressure vessels against any type
of failure.
The finite element analysis for the stress values
is shown in the following figures
Figure8: Von Misses stress at 2.75 MPa
Figure9: Von Misses stress at 5.50 MPa
Conclusions and Recommendations
The main reason for the failure of pressure
vessels with steam as carrier is due to stresses
and fatigue. The stress and fatigue can get
enhanced due to factors such as corrosion,
erosion and overheating etc. The material
selection strategies and engineering design is
very important in avoiding the failure in the
pressure vessels. AISI 5160 Steel alloys were
selected for the construction of pressure vessels
and the ring and the body were welded using
the MIG welding. The cost of constructing the
pressure vessel came out to be $36,570.28 since
the material is good to perform without failing
at the double than the recommended pressure
hence it can cut the maintenance costs by
substantial amount.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Faculty of
Mechanical and Industrial Engineering for
providing the opportunity and resources to work
on the project. A special thanks to Dr. Vincent
Chan for assigning the Supervisor professors
and proving the guidelines for various
components of the project. Sincere thanks to
Dr. Ahmad Varvani- Farahani for the valuable
guidance and timely feedback. A special credit
to Ryerson library department for sustaining
wide variety of the books and research material
without their support the ultimate goal could
not have been accomplished.
References
Annaratone, D. (2007). Pressure vessel design.
Berlin: Springer Mannan, S. & Lees, F. P.
(2005). Lees' loss prevention in the process
industries. Amsterdam:Elsevier Butterworth-
Heinemann.
[1] Craig R.R. (2011) Mechanics of Material
3th ed USA John Wiley and Sons Inc.
[2] Gere G.M., Timoshenko S.P. (1997)
Mechanics of Material 4th ed Boston PWS Pub
Co
[3] 11]Varvani A (2013).MTL 700, Failure
Analysis
[4]Budnyas R.G., Nisbett J.K.(2011)
Mechanical Engineering Design New York,NY;
McGraw Hill
[5]. Boiler system failures retrieved from
[6] http://www.lincolnelectric.com/en-
ca/support/process-and-
theory/Pages/minimizing-risk-offshore-saw.aspx

More Related Content

What's hot

ASME B31.3 Training Course
ASME B31.3 Training CourseASME B31.3 Training Course
ASME B31.3 Training Course
Meena Rezkallah
 
Pressure vessel manufacturing
Pressure vessel manufacturingPressure vessel manufacturing
Pressure vessel manufacturing
physics101
 

What's hot (16)

Blow Hole Defect Analysis in Die Casting
Blow Hole Defect Analysis in Die CastingBlow Hole Defect Analysis in Die Casting
Blow Hole Defect Analysis in Die Casting
 
Investigation on the Rate of Solidification and Mould Heating in the Casting ...
Investigation on the Rate of Solidification and Mould Heating in the Casting ...Investigation on the Rate of Solidification and Mould Heating in the Casting ...
Investigation on the Rate of Solidification and Mould Heating in the Casting ...
 
Analysis of a thin and thick walled pressure vessel for different materials
Analysis of a thin and thick walled pressure vessel for different materialsAnalysis of a thin and thick walled pressure vessel for different materials
Analysis of a thin and thick walled pressure vessel for different materials
 
ASME B31.3 Training Course
ASME B31.3 Training CourseASME B31.3 Training Course
ASME B31.3 Training Course
 
Investigation of surface roughness in machining of aisi 1040 steel
Investigation of surface roughness in machining of aisi 1040 steelInvestigation of surface roughness in machining of aisi 1040 steel
Investigation of surface roughness in machining of aisi 1040 steel
 
EVALUATION OF PROCESSES PARAMETER AND MECHANICAL PROPERTIES IN FRICTION STIR ...
EVALUATION OF PROCESSES PARAMETER AND MECHANICAL PROPERTIES IN FRICTION STIR ...EVALUATION OF PROCESSES PARAMETER AND MECHANICAL PROPERTIES IN FRICTION STIR ...
EVALUATION OF PROCESSES PARAMETER AND MECHANICAL PROPERTIES IN FRICTION STIR ...
 
Design & Stress Analysis of a Cylinder with Closed ends using ANSYS
Design & Stress Analysis of a Cylinder with Closed ends using ANSYSDesign & Stress Analysis of a Cylinder with Closed ends using ANSYS
Design & Stress Analysis of a Cylinder with Closed ends using ANSYS
 
Pressure vessel manufacturing
Pressure vessel manufacturingPressure vessel manufacturing
Pressure vessel manufacturing
 
B31.3 process piping course 02 metallic pipe &amp; fitting selection
B31.3 process piping course   02 metallic pipe &amp; fitting selectionB31.3 process piping course   02 metallic pipe &amp; fitting selection
B31.3 process piping course 02 metallic pipe &amp; fitting selection
 
IRJET- Study on the Behaviour of Cold Formed Steel Frames Hollow Section
IRJET-  	  Study on the Behaviour of Cold Formed Steel Frames Hollow SectionIRJET-  	  Study on the Behaviour of Cold Formed Steel Frames Hollow Section
IRJET- Study on the Behaviour of Cold Formed Steel Frames Hollow Section
 
Pipe Fittings Manufacturing Process
Pipe Fittings Manufacturing ProcessPipe Fittings Manufacturing Process
Pipe Fittings Manufacturing Process
 
fundamentals of Piping engineering
fundamentals of Piping engineeringfundamentals of Piping engineering
fundamentals of Piping engineering
 
Htha literature
Htha literatureHtha literature
Htha literature
 
Research into Properties of Spot Welded Steel Sheets
Research into Properties of Spot Welded Steel SheetsResearch into Properties of Spot Welded Steel Sheets
Research into Properties of Spot Welded Steel Sheets
 
Mechanical Seal for Negative Temperature Hydrocarbon Services
Mechanical Seal for Negative Temperature Hydrocarbon ServicesMechanical Seal for Negative Temperature Hydrocarbon Services
Mechanical Seal for Negative Temperature Hydrocarbon Services
 
Industrial Spherical pressure vessel design & analysis using FEA
Industrial Spherical pressure vessel design & analysis using FEAIndustrial Spherical pressure vessel design & analysis using FEA
Industrial Spherical pressure vessel design & analysis using FEA
 

Viewers also liked

Déclaration vote budget 2013 ps
Déclaration vote budget 2013 psDéclaration vote budget 2013 ps
Déclaration vote budget 2013 ps
akli mellouli
 
Les socialiste au travail tribune septembre
Les socialiste au travail tribune septembreLes socialiste au travail tribune septembre
Les socialiste au travail tribune septembre
akli mellouli
 
La cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligente
La cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligenteLa cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligente
La cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligente
akli mellouli
 
La cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligente
La cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligenteLa cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligente
La cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligente
akli mellouli
 
Licencia creative commons
Licencia creative commonsLicencia creative commons
Licencia creative commons
Jason Tituaña
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Epa of cogen
Epa of cogenEpa of cogen
Epa of cogen
 
interwiew mehdi akli
interwiew mehdi akli interwiew mehdi akli
interwiew mehdi akli
 
Déclaration vote budget 2013 ps
Déclaration vote budget 2013 psDéclaration vote budget 2013 ps
Déclaration vote budget 2013 ps
 
Les socialiste au travail tribune septembre
Les socialiste au travail tribune septembreLes socialiste au travail tribune septembre
Les socialiste au travail tribune septembre
 
La cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligente
La cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligenteLa cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligente
La cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligente
 
Bbb
BbbBbb
Bbb
 
La cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligente
La cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligenteLa cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligente
La cure d amaigrissement ou la relance intelligente
 
jamies CV
jamies CVjamies CV
jamies CV
 
Caricaturas de várias figuras públicas
Caricaturas de várias figuras públicasCaricaturas de várias figuras públicas
Caricaturas de várias figuras públicas
 
Licencia creative commons
Licencia creative commonsLicencia creative commons
Licencia creative commons
 
Metodo de caudal del sds
Metodo de caudal del sdsMetodo de caudal del sds
Metodo de caudal del sds
 
Comunicación
ComunicaciónComunicación
Comunicación
 
Obra de alcantarillado
Obra de alcantarilladoObra de alcantarillado
Obra de alcantarillado
 
Introduction of Electricity
Introduction of ElectricityIntroduction of Electricity
Introduction of Electricity
 
Saba Power Plant
Saba Power Plant Saba Power Plant
Saba Power Plant
 
Métodos para calcular el caudal aportante a un sistema de drenaje vial superf...
Métodos para calcular el caudal aportante a un sistema de drenaje vial superf...Métodos para calcular el caudal aportante a un sistema de drenaje vial superf...
Métodos para calcular el caudal aportante a un sistema de drenaje vial superf...
 
Visita ao Palácio da Justiça do Porto
Visita ao Palácio da Justiça do PortoVisita ao Palácio da Justiça do Porto
Visita ao Palácio da Justiça do Porto
 
Esculturas variadas em locais espalhados pelo mundo
Esculturas variadas em locais espalhados pelo mundoEsculturas variadas em locais espalhados pelo mundo
Esculturas variadas em locais espalhados pelo mundo
 
Esculturas em papel
Esculturas em papel Esculturas em papel
Esculturas em papel
 
4.1 boiler
4.1 boiler4.1 boiler
4.1 boiler
 

Similar to PF Final

Performance Evaluation of a Low Cost Creep Testing Machine
Performance Evaluation  of a Low Cost Creep Testing MachinePerformance Evaluation  of a Low Cost Creep Testing Machine
Performance Evaluation of a Low Cost Creep Testing Machine
Adib Bin Rashid
 
PROC 2076 Assignment Report, Pipeline
PROC 2076 Assignment Report, PipelinePROC 2076 Assignment Report, Pipeline
PROC 2076 Assignment Report, Pipeline
Syafiq Dan
 
Cost Effective Solutions
Cost Effective SolutionsCost Effective Solutions
Cost Effective Solutions
drlamberth
 
Extrusion process and parameters involved in the experimental and numerical i...
Extrusion process and parameters involved in the experimental and numerical i...Extrusion process and parameters involved in the experimental and numerical i...
Extrusion process and parameters involved in the experimental and numerical i...
IJERD Editor
 
Dollet journal publication
Dollet journal publicationDollet journal publication
Dollet journal publication
Dollet Rapheal
 

Similar to PF Final (20)

CRACKS IN STEEL CASTING FOR VOLUTE CASING OF A PUMP
 CRACKS IN STEEL CASTING FOR VOLUTE CASING OF A PUMP CRACKS IN STEEL CASTING FOR VOLUTE CASING OF A PUMP
CRACKS IN STEEL CASTING FOR VOLUTE CASING OF A PUMP
 
Design and Stress Analysis of High Pressure Accumulator
Design and Stress Analysis of High Pressure AccumulatorDesign and Stress Analysis of High Pressure Accumulator
Design and Stress Analysis of High Pressure Accumulator
 
Pankaj 161616
Pankaj 161616Pankaj 161616
Pankaj 161616
 
Contact Pressure Validation of Steam Turbine Casing for Static Loading Condition
Contact Pressure Validation of Steam Turbine Casing for Static Loading ConditionContact Pressure Validation of Steam Turbine Casing for Static Loading Condition
Contact Pressure Validation of Steam Turbine Casing for Static Loading Condition
 
Performance Evaluation of a Low Cost Creep Testing Machine
Performance Evaluation  of a Low Cost Creep Testing MachinePerformance Evaluation  of a Low Cost Creep Testing Machine
Performance Evaluation of a Low Cost Creep Testing Machine
 
Zeng2016
Zeng2016Zeng2016
Zeng2016
 
PROC 2076 Assignment Report, Pipeline
PROC 2076 Assignment Report, PipelinePROC 2076 Assignment Report, Pipeline
PROC 2076 Assignment Report, Pipeline
 
Steel Structure Design (Study Report).pptx
Steel Structure Design (Study Report).pptxSteel Structure Design (Study Report).pptx
Steel Structure Design (Study Report).pptx
 
Design and Analysis of Composite Cylinder
Design and Analysis of Composite CylinderDesign and Analysis of Composite Cylinder
Design and Analysis of Composite Cylinder
 
Internship Report
Internship ReportInternship Report
Internship Report
 
Cost Effective Solutions
Cost Effective SolutionsCost Effective Solutions
Cost Effective Solutions
 
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design lecture note
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design lecture noteChemical Engineering Apparatus Design lecture note
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design lecture note
 
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design lecture note
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design lecture noteChemical Engineering Apparatus Design lecture note
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design lecture note
 
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design Lecture note.pdf
Chemical Engineering  Apparatus Design Lecture note.pdfChemical Engineering  Apparatus Design Lecture note.pdf
Chemical Engineering Apparatus Design Lecture note.pdf
 
Sectionclassificationforcold formedchannelsteel
Sectionclassificationforcold formedchannelsteelSectionclassificationforcold formedchannelsteel
Sectionclassificationforcold formedchannelsteel
 
Ethylene oxide reactor failure pvp 2011 paper china
Ethylene oxide reactor failure pvp 2011 paper chinaEthylene oxide reactor failure pvp 2011 paper china
Ethylene oxide reactor failure pvp 2011 paper china
 
Extrusion process and parameters involved in the experimental and numerical i...
Extrusion process and parameters involved in the experimental and numerical i...Extrusion process and parameters involved in the experimental and numerical i...
Extrusion process and parameters involved in the experimental and numerical i...
 
An optimal design approach for adamite hot rolling mill roll
An optimal design approach for adamite hot rolling mill rollAn optimal design approach for adamite hot rolling mill roll
An optimal design approach for adamite hot rolling mill roll
 
Dollet journal publication
Dollet journal publicationDollet journal publication
Dollet journal publication
 
TEK.FS.MED.004-M 1.docx
TEK.FS.MED.004-M 1.docxTEK.FS.MED.004-M 1.docx
TEK.FS.MED.004-M 1.docx
 

PF Final

  • 1. AMANPREET KOCHHAR PORTFOLIO EDUCATION Bachelor of Engineering in Mechanical Engineering (October 2014) Major: Manufacturing Ryerson University Related Course Work: Mechanical design, Sheet metal fabrication and tool engineering, Engineering graphics and design, Design for manufacturing, Fabrication and tool engineering. SUMMARY OF QUALIFICATIONS • More than 2 years of industrial experience in CAD designing and 3D modelling. • Strong academic training in Mechanical Engineering acquired from 4 years of accredited university education. • Hard working, detail oriented and problem solver. • Excellent computer skills using Microsoft applications, ERP systems. • Well-developed designing skills using AutoCAD, Solidworks, Civil 3D and primavera. ENGINEERING DESIGN AND ANALYSIS SOFTWARES AutoCAD including 3D Civil, Solid works, MasterCAM, DFM& DFMA, Ansys, Primavera, MS Office 2003-2013 including Access, Project and Visio, Internet Browsers.
  • 2. TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Solid works drawings for Forklift for small stores and warehouses 2. Small cogeneration power plant design using different turbines and feed water heater configurations. 3. Stresses and heat transfer analysis in bars and bridges using ANSYS (Finite element analysis) 4. Determining root locus and time setting response in control systems using MATLAB simulation 5. Capstone Conference paper
  • 3. FORKLIFT DESIGN 3D drawing of Forklift designed for operation in small stores and warehouses
  • 4. Detailed Drawing of the forklift including all the dimensions
  • 5. COGENRATION POWERPLANT DESIGN Power plant design with 1 turbine and zero feed water heater Power plant design with 4 turbine and 2 feed water heaters
  • 6. Power plant design with 4 turbine and 3 feed water heaters Power plant design with 5 turbine and 3 feed water heaters
  • 7. FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS Von misses stress in metallic bracket Original truss configuration with uniform load and point loads applied
  • 8. Deformed + un-deformed shape of the truss configuration Displacement of the truss (in inches)
  • 9. The axial stress values in truss (in psi) Redesign truss configuration 1 with addition and removal of beam members
  • 10. The deformed + un-deformed shape for redesign configuration The deflection in the redesign truss configuration (in inches)
  • 11. CONTROL SYSTEM ANALYSIS Root Locus for Transfer function of Path 1 Unit Response for Settling Time < 4 seconds
  • 12. Root Locus for Transfer Function of Path 2 Alternate Unit Response with 3.83 Second Settling time
  • 13. 5 CAPSTONE CONFERENCE PAPER CRITICAL DESIGN PARAMETERS PREVENTING FAILURES IN PRESSURE VESSELS A. John Hannah B. Bishoy Azmy C. Shiva Sharafian-Jazi D. Amanpreet Kochhar Supervisor: Dr. Ahmad Varvani Farahani Abstract Pressure vessels are containers that handle high pressure of fluids or gases at different temperature and pressure conditions. Design of the containers is critical to enable it resist the forces associated with high pressure of gases or liquids. The report will analyze the stresses created by the liquids or gasses, and the causes of failure that occurs in pressure vessels. Pressures vessels normally experience stress and the most common are compressive, tensile and thermal. The report will examine the different types of failure attained in pressure vessels and several occasions that cause the vessels to rupture assisting the group in learning from the mistakes previously made and assist in the preparation of the design of a safer container. Most common failures are caused by cracking, erosion, caustic embrittlement, over- heating, welding issues among others. The report focuses on the study of causes of failure and their attributes and ensuring it does not appear in the ultimate design of the pressure vessel. The use of the correct material selection strategies is critical in the design of pressure vessels. Materials in the construction selection are based on the tensile strength, strong resilience, high ductility and ease in manufacturability and cost. Steel alloys are selected for construction of pressure vessels. The material that will be used in the making the pressure vessel is the ASTM A516 Grade 70. Introduction Pressure vessels are cylindrical containers used to store volatile chemicals and reactive gasses. Since the materials stored in the pressure vessel are in critical state hence the design of pressure vessel has to be accurate to avoid the failure. In this project the pressure vessel for storage of steam is taken into consideration. Steam is state of water vapors at very high temperature and pressure. Since the steam is taken into account as storage material in pressure vessels hence the probability of failure due to corrosion and erosion factors become very predominant. The past accidents and the main reason related to the accidents have been considered to present a new design such that it does not fail under such parameters. The root causes of the accidents are high stress and fatigue phenomenon. The pressure vessel could fail either because of Tensile, Compressive or Thermal stresses. The stresses result in development of the cracks and the fatigue failure. The above figure shows the normal and the axial stresses on the surfaces of the pressure vessels. Figure 1: Normal & axial Stresses in the pressure vessels [1] Since the steam is stored in the pressure vessel the inside surface of the pressure vessels is expected to go very hot due to present of some impurities in quality of the steam the pressure vessels can experience some variation in temperature hence the thermal stress could stimulate due to thermal shocks and pressure vessel are prone to burst and explosion. The pressure vessel failure due to thermal shock explosion is shown in the following figure
  • 14. Figure 2: The surface cracks due to burst [2] The fatigue phenomenon is also very important in case of pressure vessel design. The fatigue life of the material changes due to presence of overheating, corrosion or high loading. The effect of the discussed parameters is shown in the following figures. Figure3: Change in fatigue life due to overloading [3] Figure4: Change in fatigue life due to corrosion [3] The Pressure Vessel material is generally chosen to be ductile as the cracks are easily identifiable in ductile material as compared to the brittle material. In the ductile materials the material stretches to show the necking before breaking hence the cracking is easy to identifiable in ductile material as compared to the brittle material. The brittle and the ductile cracking is shown in the following figure Figure5: Brittle and Ductile Fracture [4] The above discussed factors lead to many failures and accidents. Some commonly occurring accidents are discussed and the design against these failures is presented. Some of the common accidents are • Deaerator cracking due to presence of dissolved oxygen and gasses in steam • Uncontrolled surface temperature due to overheating resulting in thermal shocks • Failures due to corrosion are big problem in steam pressure vessels corrosion generally results in weakening of the material which eventually results in the burst or explosion. The main type of the corrosion failures in the pressure vessels are stress corrosion cracking, Caustic embrittlement which tends to make the surface brittle hence crack identification becomes difficult, corrosion fatigue etc. • There are several other accidents such as erosion, rupture, improper fabrication and welding of the surfaces resulting in stress, the improper material selection and poor design could also equal contributors in the failure of the pressure vessels Some of the discussed failures are shown in the following figures
  • 15. Figure 6: Salt deposition on surface resulting in corrosion [5] Figure 7: Faulty welding [6] Failure elimination strategies Since the causes of the failures were studied so the failure elimination strategies were formulated and a design model was presented according to the strategies. The outline of the strategies is discusses as following • Material selection strategies: The material for pressure vessels was selected on the basis of design for strength against the failure. The appropriate performance index was plotted on the material selection chart for the strength vs density chart and Steel alloys were selected as appropriate material for the pressure vessels AISI 5160 Steel was finalized for construction. • The crack identification is also very important phenomenon to prevent the failure in the pressure vessels. The crack identification techniques are proposed for identification of the cracks is Wet fluorescent magnetic particle testing, Brinell hardness test etc. • The stress is mainly present at the welded surface because when metals are welded then their material properties change and strength is decreased. In order to reduce failure due to welding MIG (Gas Metal Arc) welding is recommended because the weld joints are uniform and deposition rates are higher giving a strong and continuous weld joint • Finite element Analysis: The pressure vessel calculations were performed for AISI 5160 steel and finite element analysis was performed for the given pressure and temperature parameters as recommended by ASME handbooks. The maximum stress in the pressure vessel by applying the maximum pressure of 2.75 MPa came out to be 170 MPa, when the pressure was doubled and the stress value increased to 339 MPa. The material has ultimate tensile stress of 705 MPa hence it is suitable for pressure vessels against any type of failure. The finite element analysis for the stress values is shown in the following figures Figure8: Von Misses stress at 2.75 MPa Figure9: Von Misses stress at 5.50 MPa Conclusions and Recommendations
  • 16. The main reason for the failure of pressure vessels with steam as carrier is due to stresses and fatigue. The stress and fatigue can get enhanced due to factors such as corrosion, erosion and overheating etc. The material selection strategies and engineering design is very important in avoiding the failure in the pressure vessels. AISI 5160 Steel alloys were selected for the construction of pressure vessels and the ring and the body were welded using the MIG welding. The cost of constructing the pressure vessel came out to be $36,570.28 since the material is good to perform without failing at the double than the recommended pressure hence it can cut the maintenance costs by substantial amount. Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank Faculty of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering for providing the opportunity and resources to work on the project. A special thanks to Dr. Vincent Chan for assigning the Supervisor professors and proving the guidelines for various components of the project. Sincere thanks to Dr. Ahmad Varvani- Farahani for the valuable guidance and timely feedback. A special credit to Ryerson library department for sustaining wide variety of the books and research material without their support the ultimate goal could not have been accomplished. References Annaratone, D. (2007). Pressure vessel design. Berlin: Springer Mannan, S. & Lees, F. P. (2005). Lees' loss prevention in the process industries. Amsterdam:Elsevier Butterworth- Heinemann. [1] Craig R.R. (2011) Mechanics of Material 3th ed USA John Wiley and Sons Inc. [2] Gere G.M., Timoshenko S.P. (1997) Mechanics of Material 4th ed Boston PWS Pub Co [3] 11]Varvani A (2013).MTL 700, Failure Analysis [4]Budnyas R.G., Nisbett J.K.(2011) Mechanical Engineering Design New York,NY; McGraw Hill [5]. Boiler system failures retrieved from [6] http://www.lincolnelectric.com/en- ca/support/process-and- theory/Pages/minimizing-risk-offshore-saw.aspx