Third- and fourth-
degree tears
RCOG GUIDELINES
Prof Aboubakr Elnashar
Benha university Hospital, Egypt
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
3rd DT:
Any part of anal sphincter complex (ext & internal
sphincters)
3a: <50% of EAS is torn
3b: >50% of EAS is torn
3c: IAS (almost always EAS is completely disrupted)
4th DT: rectal mucosa
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Incidence
Internal anal sphincter incompetence:
insensible faecal incontinence
External anal sphincter incompetence:
faecal urgency.
3rd DT:
PG: 2.8%
MG: 0.4 %
Depend on rates of instrumental delivery.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
New-onset symptoms of faecal incontinence
PG: At 10 months
10% instrumental VD
3% spontaneous VD.
{pudendal neuropathy}
5% emergency CS
very uncommon after elective CS.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Faecal urgency:
{occult anal sphincter damage}
44% five years following instrumental delivery of
their first baby.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
US visible anal sphincter defects:
82%: forceps delivery
48% ventouse deliveries
Most women: infrequent problems
40% after vaginal delivery of their first baby
2/3: asymptomatic.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Important facts:
1. Women are uncomfortable about faecal problems
after childbirth
2. Anal sphincter damage is mainly limited to first
deliveries, whereas pudendal nerve damage can
be cumulative.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
3. US demonstrated lesions
do not translate into confirmed problems of faecal
continence
can be demonstrated in women who were
demonstrated to have an intact anal sphincter at
the time of delivery.
{infection or haematoma formation, or partial
unrecognized sphincter ruptures.}
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
4. Pudendal nerve damage
{during labour as the nerve becomes compressed
and stretched}
Delivery late in the first stage or second stage by CS
does not prevent this.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Risk factors
Cumulative
Primigravida: 2-7
Second stage of labour of >60 minutes(including
passive second stage): 2
Instrumental vaginal delivery: 1.7-7
Midline episiotomy: 5-11
Macrosomia (>4 kg): 2.9
Persistent occipitoposterior position: 1. 7
Epidural analgesia: 1.5
Prior third-degree tear: 4
Induction of labour: 2
Shoulder dystocia: 4
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Repair
Identification of extent of damage
Careful EX
Assess the severity of damage to the perineum,
vagina and rectum.
Diagnose anal sphincter injury.
rectal extension, as small buttonhole tears
can be overlooked and lead to fistula formation.
1. When disrupted, the anal sphincter retracts,
forming a dimple on either side of the anal canal.
2. Rupture of the rectal mucosa will almost always
involve damage to both the internal and external anal
sphincters.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Conduct of the repair
Cochrane review:
overlap technique: lower incidence in
faecal urgency
anal incontinence score
risk of deterioration of anal incontinence symptoms
over 12 months
No difference in:
perineal pain
dyspareunia
flatus incontinence
faecal incontinence
quality of life.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Two subsequent trials:
no differences in outcome.
RCOG guideline:
no evidence to suggest that an overlap technique is
better than end-to-end approximation of the muscle
{A}.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Principles:
Adequate analgesia: regional or general
{local infiltration does not allow sufficient relaxation of
the sphincter to allow a satisfactory repair}.
Adequate lighting
Assistant: repair should be undertaken in the
operating theatre.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Method:
.3a tears:
end-to-end technique {majority of the sphincter fibres
remain intact}.
3b tears:
cutting the remaining fibres to perform an overlap
repair.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Steps & sutures:
Eensure that the muscle is correctly approximated
with long-acting sutures: adequate time to heal.
1. Repair of the rectal mucosa first.
2:0 polyglycolic acid interrupted sutures with the
knots placed on the mucosal side
2. Next, the layers of the internal sphincter should be
replicated across the defect with interrupted sutures
of 2:0 or 3:0 Vicryl or polydioxanone suture (PDS).
3. The torn external sphincter is then repaired.
This should be re-approximated with either three or
four figure-of-eight sutures, or an overlap technique.
A 2.0 or 3.0 PDS is ideal.
Polyglycolic acid is also used.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
A single study comparing the two showed no
difference in outcomes at 12 months [B].
However, the longer tensile retention of PDS and its
monofilament characteristics make it especially
suitable.
Short half-life treated polyglactin sutures (Vicryl
Rapide) are not acceptable as they do not have a
long enough half-life to ensure muscle healing.
Non-absorbable sutures should not be used in the
acute setting as these can form a focus for infection,
requiring removal.
The knots should be buried beneath the superficial
perineal muscles, to minimize knot migration.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
4. The remainder of the perineal repair is undertaken
as for second-degree trauma.
5. Retention of urine secondary to the anaesthesia or
repair is common and a urinary catheter should be
inserted until spontaneous voiding is achieved.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Post-operative precautions
It is common practice after delayed anal sphincter
repair to use a constipating regimen to allow the
repair to heal before stools are passed. This is
difficult in recently delivered women who have very
different needs from those of the surgical patient.
Constipative regimens have been compared with
stool-softening regimens. It is concluded that
constipative management leads to more pain and a
longer post-operative stay compared to stool-
softening regimens, but with no difference in repair
success.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
1. Lactulose and a bulk agent, such as Fybogel: for
5-10 days.
2. Broad-spectrum antibiotic.
cover anaerobic e.g. metronidazole. prescribed orally
rather than per rectum.
3. Oral analgesia:
Paracetamol, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs
and opioid.
opioids used alone can exacerbate constipation, and
thus the former should be used first.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Before the woman goes home,
· Analgesia and stool softeners;
· Advise on perineal hygiene;
· counsel that 60-80% of women will be
asymptomatic following healing of the repair;
· make an initial plan for short-term management with
a physiotherapist;
· counsel that sutures occasionally migrate and
fragments may be passed per vaginum or,
occasionally, per rectum;
· give an appointment for follow up.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Follow up
A team approach
Physiotherapy should include augmented
biofeedback {improve continence}.
At 6-12 weeks, a full evaluation of the degree of
symptoms:
Questioning with regard to faecal and urinary
symptoms. A standard questionnaire
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
1. Symptomatic women:
Investigation: endoanal ultrasound and manometry.
2. Asymptomatic women with low squeeze pressures
and a demonstrable sphincter defect of more than a
quadrant should be counselled regarding the pros
and cons of future deliveries.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
3. Women with ongoing severe symptoms should be
considered for secondary surgery.
As pudendal neuropathy can take at least six months
to improve, any further surgical intervention is best
deferred until at least this time; however,
in exceptional cases in which sphincter disruption is
demonstrated and faecal incontinence is debilitating,
surgery may be required earlier.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
4. Women with mild symptoms
avoid gas-producing foods and bulking agents,
constipating agents and biofeedback offered.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
Counseling about subsequent
delivery
1. Previous third/fourth-degree tear, no
ongoing symptoms:
4% risk of further anal sphincter damage in a
subsequent vaginal delivery. canot predicted
antenatalIy.
Women who were transiently incontinent after their
first delivery are particularly at risk of worsening of
symptoms, and 17-24% may develop worsening
symptoms after subsequent delivery
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
When women opt for subsequent vaginal delivery,
-every effort to avoid instrumental vaginal delivery.
-No evidence that episiotomy prevents muscle
damage, and most women appreciate an intact
perineum if that can be achieved.
-The second stage should not be prolonged.
Where anal sphincter damage does not occur, new-
onset symptoms are usually attributable to pudendal
neuropathy, which usually improves with time.
Transient flatus incontinence is reported by 10% of
women delivered without further sphincter damage.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
2. Women who continue to be
symptomatic
The majority of these women will have a
demonstrable defect on ultrasound.
There is a risk of worsening of symptoms, which may
then make life much more difficult.
Women should be carefully counselled with regard to
additional effects of worsening pudendal damage and
small risk of further muscle damage.
The majority of women in this group may opt for
caesarean section, but for choosing vaginal delivery,
every effort should be made avoid operative vaginal
delivery and lengthy second stage.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
3. Women who have undergone a
secondary anal sphincter repair
should be delivered by , cesarean section [E].
However, there are no data to advise women who
wish to try for a vaginal delivery.
Again, instrumental delivery and long second stage
should be avoided where possible.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
4. Women who are asymptomatic, but
have demonstrable anal sphincter
defects or abnormal manometry on
testing
These women are at risk of new symptoms following
subsequent delivery.
Those at most risk appear to be women with a full
quadrant defect, and these women may wish to
choose caesarean section next ,time [C]
The plan for delivery must be clearly documented in
the case notes.
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR

THIRD AND FOURTH DEGREE TEARS

  • 1.
    Third- and fourth- degreetears RCOG GUIDELINES Prof Aboubakr Elnashar Benha university Hospital, Egypt ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 2.
    3rd DT: Any partof anal sphincter complex (ext & internal sphincters) 3a: <50% of EAS is torn 3b: >50% of EAS is torn 3c: IAS (almost always EAS is completely disrupted) 4th DT: rectal mucosa ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 3.
    Incidence Internal anal sphincterincompetence: insensible faecal incontinence External anal sphincter incompetence: faecal urgency. 3rd DT: PG: 2.8% MG: 0.4 % Depend on rates of instrumental delivery. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 4.
    New-onset symptoms offaecal incontinence PG: At 10 months 10% instrumental VD 3% spontaneous VD. {pudendal neuropathy} 5% emergency CS very uncommon after elective CS. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 5.
    Faecal urgency: {occult analsphincter damage} 44% five years following instrumental delivery of their first baby. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 6.
    US visible analsphincter defects: 82%: forceps delivery 48% ventouse deliveries Most women: infrequent problems 40% after vaginal delivery of their first baby 2/3: asymptomatic. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 7.
    Important facts: 1. Womenare uncomfortable about faecal problems after childbirth 2. Anal sphincter damage is mainly limited to first deliveries, whereas pudendal nerve damage can be cumulative. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 8.
    3. US demonstratedlesions do not translate into confirmed problems of faecal continence can be demonstrated in women who were demonstrated to have an intact anal sphincter at the time of delivery. {infection or haematoma formation, or partial unrecognized sphincter ruptures.} ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 9.
    4. Pudendal nervedamage {during labour as the nerve becomes compressed and stretched} Delivery late in the first stage or second stage by CS does not prevent this. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 10.
    Risk factors Cumulative Primigravida: 2-7 Secondstage of labour of >60 minutes(including passive second stage): 2 Instrumental vaginal delivery: 1.7-7 Midline episiotomy: 5-11 Macrosomia (>4 kg): 2.9 Persistent occipitoposterior position: 1. 7 Epidural analgesia: 1.5 Prior third-degree tear: 4 Induction of labour: 2 Shoulder dystocia: 4 ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 11.
    Repair Identification of extentof damage Careful EX Assess the severity of damage to the perineum, vagina and rectum. Diagnose anal sphincter injury. rectal extension, as small buttonhole tears can be overlooked and lead to fistula formation. 1. When disrupted, the anal sphincter retracts, forming a dimple on either side of the anal canal. 2. Rupture of the rectal mucosa will almost always involve damage to both the internal and external anal sphincters. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 12.
    Conduct of therepair Cochrane review: overlap technique: lower incidence in faecal urgency anal incontinence score risk of deterioration of anal incontinence symptoms over 12 months No difference in: perineal pain dyspareunia flatus incontinence faecal incontinence quality of life. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 13.
    Two subsequent trials: nodifferences in outcome. RCOG guideline: no evidence to suggest that an overlap technique is better than end-to-end approximation of the muscle {A}. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 14.
    Principles: Adequate analgesia: regionalor general {local infiltration does not allow sufficient relaxation of the sphincter to allow a satisfactory repair}. Adequate lighting Assistant: repair should be undertaken in the operating theatre. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 15.
    Method: .3a tears: end-to-end technique{majority of the sphincter fibres remain intact}. 3b tears: cutting the remaining fibres to perform an overlap repair. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 16.
    Steps & sutures: Eensurethat the muscle is correctly approximated with long-acting sutures: adequate time to heal. 1. Repair of the rectal mucosa first. 2:0 polyglycolic acid interrupted sutures with the knots placed on the mucosal side 2. Next, the layers of the internal sphincter should be replicated across the defect with interrupted sutures of 2:0 or 3:0 Vicryl or polydioxanone suture (PDS). 3. The torn external sphincter is then repaired. This should be re-approximated with either three or four figure-of-eight sutures, or an overlap technique. A 2.0 or 3.0 PDS is ideal. Polyglycolic acid is also used. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 17.
    A single studycomparing the two showed no difference in outcomes at 12 months [B]. However, the longer tensile retention of PDS and its monofilament characteristics make it especially suitable. Short half-life treated polyglactin sutures (Vicryl Rapide) are not acceptable as they do not have a long enough half-life to ensure muscle healing. Non-absorbable sutures should not be used in the acute setting as these can form a focus for infection, requiring removal. The knots should be buried beneath the superficial perineal muscles, to minimize knot migration. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 18.
    4. The remainderof the perineal repair is undertaken as for second-degree trauma. 5. Retention of urine secondary to the anaesthesia or repair is common and a urinary catheter should be inserted until spontaneous voiding is achieved. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 19.
    Post-operative precautions It iscommon practice after delayed anal sphincter repair to use a constipating regimen to allow the repair to heal before stools are passed. This is difficult in recently delivered women who have very different needs from those of the surgical patient. Constipative regimens have been compared with stool-softening regimens. It is concluded that constipative management leads to more pain and a longer post-operative stay compared to stool- softening regimens, but with no difference in repair success. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 20.
    1. Lactulose anda bulk agent, such as Fybogel: for 5-10 days. 2. Broad-spectrum antibiotic. cover anaerobic e.g. metronidazole. prescribed orally rather than per rectum. 3. Oral analgesia: Paracetamol, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and opioid. opioids used alone can exacerbate constipation, and thus the former should be used first. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 21.
    Before the womangoes home, · Analgesia and stool softeners; · Advise on perineal hygiene; · counsel that 60-80% of women will be asymptomatic following healing of the repair; · make an initial plan for short-term management with a physiotherapist; · counsel that sutures occasionally migrate and fragments may be passed per vaginum or, occasionally, per rectum; · give an appointment for follow up. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 22.
    Follow up A teamapproach Physiotherapy should include augmented biofeedback {improve continence}. At 6-12 weeks, a full evaluation of the degree of symptoms: Questioning with regard to faecal and urinary symptoms. A standard questionnaire ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 23.
    1. Symptomatic women: Investigation:endoanal ultrasound and manometry. 2. Asymptomatic women with low squeeze pressures and a demonstrable sphincter defect of more than a quadrant should be counselled regarding the pros and cons of future deliveries. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 24.
    3. Women withongoing severe symptoms should be considered for secondary surgery. As pudendal neuropathy can take at least six months to improve, any further surgical intervention is best deferred until at least this time; however, in exceptional cases in which sphincter disruption is demonstrated and faecal incontinence is debilitating, surgery may be required earlier. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 25.
    4. Women withmild symptoms avoid gas-producing foods and bulking agents, constipating agents and biofeedback offered. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 26.
    Counseling about subsequent delivery 1.Previous third/fourth-degree tear, no ongoing symptoms: 4% risk of further anal sphincter damage in a subsequent vaginal delivery. canot predicted antenatalIy. Women who were transiently incontinent after their first delivery are particularly at risk of worsening of symptoms, and 17-24% may develop worsening symptoms after subsequent delivery ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 27.
    When women optfor subsequent vaginal delivery, -every effort to avoid instrumental vaginal delivery. -No evidence that episiotomy prevents muscle damage, and most women appreciate an intact perineum if that can be achieved. -The second stage should not be prolonged. Where anal sphincter damage does not occur, new- onset symptoms are usually attributable to pudendal neuropathy, which usually improves with time. Transient flatus incontinence is reported by 10% of women delivered without further sphincter damage. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 28.
    2. Women whocontinue to be symptomatic The majority of these women will have a demonstrable defect on ultrasound. There is a risk of worsening of symptoms, which may then make life much more difficult. Women should be carefully counselled with regard to additional effects of worsening pudendal damage and small risk of further muscle damage. The majority of women in this group may opt for caesarean section, but for choosing vaginal delivery, every effort should be made avoid operative vaginal delivery and lengthy second stage. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 29.
    3. Women whohave undergone a secondary anal sphincter repair should be delivered by , cesarean section [E]. However, there are no data to advise women who wish to try for a vaginal delivery. Again, instrumental delivery and long second stage should be avoided where possible. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 30.
    4. Women whoare asymptomatic, but have demonstrable anal sphincter defects or abnormal manometry on testing These women are at risk of new symptoms following subsequent delivery. Those at most risk appear to be women with a full quadrant defect, and these women may wish to choose caesarean section next ,time [C] The plan for delivery must be clearly documented in the case notes. ABOUBAKR ELNASHAR
  • 31.