SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Partnership-Powered IT Change
Rhian Davies • Craig Henderson • Mark Ritchie
Partnership Powered IT – Outcomes
1. Understand importance of partnership in
delivering IT change
2. Identify key behaviours for building trust
3. Describe how changing your language can
change your relationship
Mark Ritchie
• Team of 20+ project
managers and business
analysts
• IT and business change
projects
• Responsible for ~13000 IT
project days last year
• Delivering projects at the
University for 20+ years
Influencing the world since 1583
Head of Project Services
Information Services
Mark.Ritchie@ed.ac.uk
Rhian Davies
• Deputy Head of Project
Services since 2012
• Portfolio Manager for
Corporate Services
• Delivering projects and
business change for 10+
years at the University
Influencing the world since 1583
Deputy Head of Project
Services Information Services
Rhian.Davies@ed.ac.uk
Craig Henderson
• Responsible for eCommerce
and efficiency
• Award winning procurement
team
• Sponsoring and leading
business change projects at
University for 20+ years
• Member Scottish
Government eCommerce
Forum
Influencing the world since 1583
Assistant Director of
Procurement
Corporate Services
Craig.Henderson@ed.ac.uk
Procurement Spend at the University
35,000+ students
3 Colleges 22 Schools
13,000+ staff
$450m research income
$1bn + turnover
World Top 50 university
Influencing the world since 1583
Influencing the world since 1583
Our Message
Working
Together
Building Trust
Transforming
Relationships
to Partnerships
Improved Delivery of IT Change
It takes time and effort but it’s worth it!
What is Partnership?
A business entity in which two or more co-owners
contribute resources, share in profits and losses,
and are individually liable for the entity's actions
A relationship between individuals or groups that is
characterized by mutual cooperation and
responsibility, as for the achievement of a
specified goal
Source: The Free Dictionary
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/partnership
So what’s the problem?
Partners can have very different
Backgrounds
and
Experience
Skills and
Talents
Approaches
to Problem
Solving
Views
A Great Partnership - Laurel and Hardy
Where we started
Project Delivery in 2005 – Business View
• It was difficult to work with IT
• IT chose the projects but didn’t understand our
business
• IT provided technology we had to do the rest
• Every project seemed to be managed differently
• It was difficult to find out about project status
• Projects often stalled, took longer and cost more
We blamed IT!
Project Delivery Headlines
Reporting Tool Five
Years to Complete!
System Withdrawn
Following Complaints
from Students
Student Records
Project In Trouble!
Fall Guy! – Business
Lead Knew Nothing
About Project
How was it in 2005 for IT?
• We didn’t work well as a team
• Roles/responsibilities poorly understood
• Projects not well defined
• We struggled to engage effectively with non IT
colleagues – misunderstanding and lack of trust
• Not consulted on decisions with IT implications
• Projects often stalled, took longer and cost more
We felt undervalued
and misunderstood!
Our Journey
Starting to Tackle the Problems
Build
Trust
Improve
Delivery
Established Project Methodology
Standard Approach for Projects
Agreed Roles and Responsibilities
Project
Sponsor
• Owns the business case
• Accountable for the success or failure
of the project
Project
Manager
• Day to day responsibility for running
the project
• Responsible for ensuring that project
produces the required deliverables
Visibility of Project Progress
Resource Allocation
Prioritised Projects Together
Common Estimation Process
Common Estimation Process
SMALL MEDIUM LARGE
Transparent Allocation of IT
Resource
Budgets at
programme
level
Allocated
budgets to
Programme
Owners not IT
Owners could
decide where
IT effort was
used
Owners could
trade within
and between
programmes
Programme owners better understood costs and were
empowered to make decisions about their projects
Changed Language
Changed Language
Customer Partner
We and Us
Because
I and You
Sorry
Dependability
Shared Success
• eProcurement Scotland – implement a country-
wide eProcurement system at UoE
• Scottish Government, UoE, consultants and
supplier all part of on-site team
• Anything other than an effective partnership would
have been a disaster
• Full time project manager from IT
• Co-location in a single team office
• Project was delivered successfully, and has
continued to develop and grow
Shared Success
Track Record of Delivery
5797
6882
8103 8427
10375
9389 9586
12977
13659
12998
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Project Days Delivered
Maturing Partnerships
Co-located Project Teams
Student Systems Partnership
University Web Site Programme
Expanded Partner Role
Embedded Programme Managers
Estates and Buildings (also
Human Resources and IT
Infrastructure)
Multi Year University Projects
Research Administration (also
Scheduling and University
Website CMS)
Agile Project Delivery
• Searchable contract and supplier
database “Buy@Ed”
• Short space of time, small budget,
to deliver but big impact
• Partnership with HE sector partner
• End user requirements sessions –
they were delighted to be asked!
• Successful project – partnership in
action!
Where are we now?
2015 – An IT Perspective
• Working together to prioritise projects
• Well understood methods of delivery
• Confidence in delivery
• Ability to have difficult conversations – and
move forward positively
• Asked for help and advice – not just with
technology!
• Working together to improve e.g. benefits
management
2015 – A Partner Perspective
• It’s no longer them and us
• Buy-in/ownership/trust - honesty
• I don’t buy a service, we deliver projects
together
• End users have become our partners too
• Our solutions and services are better
• Empowered by change to programme
budgets
• It’s more fun than it used to be!
2015 - Project Delivery Headlines
Agile project delivers
hazardous materials
solution
Library Management
System delivered on
time and to budget –
students like it too!
Student Systems
Partnership goes from
strength to strength
University to present on
Partnership at
EDUCAUSE
Conclusions
Build Trust to Improve Delivery
Focus on
to build trust and
improve delivery
Build Trust - Togetherness
• Agree roles and responsibilities
• Prioritise projects together
• Change language and take joint ownership for
delivery
• Share your successes (and your problems)
• Co-locate your project teams
• Identify opportunities to expand your partner
relationships
Build Trust – Consistency
• Introduce standard approach for projects
• Sort out estimation and consider how to manage
resources – do you need Time Tracking?
• Establish a track record for delivery
Build Trust – Transparency
• Agree rules for RAG reporting
• Ensure project status visible to all stakeholders
• Consider developing a Projects Web Site
• Introduce transparent allocation of resources
• Publish (and act on) lessons learned
Leverage your
differences
Changing your
language can
make a big
difference! Customer Partner
Partnership will
power IT change
We do it together!
Any Questions?
@uoe_pmo
@uoe_isapps
www.projects.ed.ac.uk
pmo@ed.ac.uk
Help Us Improve and Grow
Thank you for participating
in today’s session!
We’re very interested in your feedback. Please take
a minute to fill out the session evaluation found within
the conference mobile app, or the online agenda

More Related Content

What's hot

Creating and sustaining an environment for success
Creating and sustaining an environment for successCreating and sustaining an environment for success
Creating and sustaining an environment for success
Association for Project Management
 
PPM Summit San Francisco Hitachi
PPM Summit San Francisco HitachiPPM Summit San Francisco Hitachi
PPM Summit San Francisco Hitachi
Microsoft
 
What's New with Edline?
What's New with Edline?What's New with Edline?
What's New with Edline?
Blackboard
 
Leading High Impact Virtual Teams
Leading High Impact Virtual TeamsLeading High Impact Virtual Teams
Leading High Impact Virtual Teams
Cynthia Clay
 
Accelerate Your Elearning Production and Increase Effectiveness
Accelerate Your Elearning Production and Increase EffectivenessAccelerate Your Elearning Production and Increase Effectiveness
Accelerate Your Elearning Production and Increase Effectiveness
DoceboElearning
 
Integrating Sustainability and Project Management
Integrating Sustainability and Project ManagementIntegrating Sustainability and Project Management
Integrating Sustainability and Project Management
Luca Sabini
 
How to excel at inclusive onboarding and induction
How to excel at inclusive onboarding and induction How to excel at inclusive onboarding and induction
How to excel at inclusive onboarding and induction
AbilityNet
 
Strategies to Manage Conflict in the Virtual Workplace
Strategies to Manage Conflict in the Virtual WorkplaceStrategies to Manage Conflict in the Virtual Workplace
Strategies to Manage Conflict in the Virtual Workplace
Cynthia Clay
 
Keeping the spin – from idea to cash in 6 weeks
Keeping the spin – from idea to cash in 6 weeksKeeping the spin – from idea to cash in 6 weeks
Keeping the spin – from idea to cash in 6 weeks
Jaroslav Procházka
 

What's hot (9)

Creating and sustaining an environment for success
Creating and sustaining an environment for successCreating and sustaining an environment for success
Creating and sustaining an environment for success
 
PPM Summit San Francisco Hitachi
PPM Summit San Francisco HitachiPPM Summit San Francisco Hitachi
PPM Summit San Francisco Hitachi
 
What's New with Edline?
What's New with Edline?What's New with Edline?
What's New with Edline?
 
Leading High Impact Virtual Teams
Leading High Impact Virtual TeamsLeading High Impact Virtual Teams
Leading High Impact Virtual Teams
 
Accelerate Your Elearning Production and Increase Effectiveness
Accelerate Your Elearning Production and Increase EffectivenessAccelerate Your Elearning Production and Increase Effectiveness
Accelerate Your Elearning Production and Increase Effectiveness
 
Integrating Sustainability and Project Management
Integrating Sustainability and Project ManagementIntegrating Sustainability and Project Management
Integrating Sustainability and Project Management
 
How to excel at inclusive onboarding and induction
How to excel at inclusive onboarding and induction How to excel at inclusive onboarding and induction
How to excel at inclusive onboarding and induction
 
Strategies to Manage Conflict in the Virtual Workplace
Strategies to Manage Conflict in the Virtual WorkplaceStrategies to Manage Conflict in the Virtual Workplace
Strategies to Manage Conflict in the Virtual Workplace
 
Keeping the spin – from idea to cash in 6 weeks
Keeping the spin – from idea to cash in 6 weeksKeeping the spin – from idea to cash in 6 weeks
Keeping the spin – from idea to cash in 6 weeks
 

Viewers also liked

Evergreen corporate partnership engagement
Evergreen corporate partnership engagementEvergreen corporate partnership engagement
Evergreen corporate partnership engagement
Stephanie E. Heintzman
 
Presenting the MDE-UMUC/HBMeU cooperative programs
Presenting the MDE-UMUC/HBMeU cooperative programsPresenting the MDE-UMUC/HBMeU cooperative programs
Presenting the MDE-UMUC/HBMeU cooperative programs
Stella Porto
 
Creating Our Own Pathways
Creating Our Own PathwaysCreating Our Own Pathways
Creating Our Own Pathways
CISA-GMU
 
UEDA 2015 Awards of Excellence - Talent Development - Engaging Engineering St...
UEDA 2015 Awards of Excellence - Talent Development - Engaging Engineering St...UEDA 2015 Awards of Excellence - Talent Development - Engaging Engineering St...
UEDA 2015 Awards of Excellence - Talent Development - Engaging Engineering St...
University Economic Development Association
 
Academic partnership
Academic partnershipAcademic partnership
Academic partnershipnevin
 
Corporate Engagement benchmarking study
Corporate Engagement benchmarking studyCorporate Engagement benchmarking study
Corporate Engagement benchmarking studyAmy Lavallee
 
Knowledge translation and transfer program - OMAFRA
Knowledge translation and transfer program - OMAFRAKnowledge translation and transfer program - OMAFRA
Knowledge translation and transfer program - OMAFRA
Institute for Knowledge Mobilization
 
Academic and industry collaboration
Academic and industry collaborationAcademic and industry collaboration
Academic and industry collaboration
Pistoia Alliance
 
ipas-annual-report-2015
ipas-annual-report-2015ipas-annual-report-2015
ipas-annual-report-2015Joe Flynn
 
University Industry Partnership For Innovations
University Industry Partnership For InnovationsUniversity Industry Partnership For Innovations
University Industry Partnership For Innovations
guest5ce3a8
 
Industry-academia collaboration
Industry-academia collaborationIndustry-academia collaboration
Industry-academia collaborationGESSI UPC
 
Better Biotech Innovation by Improving the Ecosystem by Tim Charlebois, VP In...
Better Biotech Innovation by Improving the Ecosystem by Tim Charlebois, VP In...Better Biotech Innovation by Improving the Ecosystem by Tim Charlebois, VP In...
Better Biotech Innovation by Improving the Ecosystem by Tim Charlebois, VP In...
MIT Startup Exchange
 
Integrated Thinking and the Integrated Report
Integrated Thinking and the Integrated ReportIntegrated Thinking and the Integrated Report
Integrated Thinking and the Integrated Report
International Federation of Accountants
 
Promotion of industry academia collaboration
Promotion of industry academia collaborationPromotion of industry academia collaboration
Promotion of industry academia collaboration
Carlos Fosca
 
University-Industry Collaboration by M Iftikhar Anjum
University-Industry Collaboration by M Iftikhar AnjumUniversity-Industry Collaboration by M Iftikhar Anjum
University-Industry Collaboration by M Iftikhar AnjumIftikhar Anjum
 
Collaboration between Industry and Academia – An Opportunity to Drive Efficie...
Collaboration between Industry and Academia – An Opportunity to Drive Efficie...Collaboration between Industry and Academia – An Opportunity to Drive Efficie...
Collaboration between Industry and Academia – An Opportunity to Drive Efficie...
Life Sciences Network marcus evans
 
University support for industry collaboration
University support for industry collaborationUniversity support for industry collaboration
University support for industry collaboration
Peter Lancaster
 

Viewers also liked (18)

USC Stevens Overview
USC Stevens OverviewUSC Stevens Overview
USC Stevens Overview
 
Evergreen corporate partnership engagement
Evergreen corporate partnership engagementEvergreen corporate partnership engagement
Evergreen corporate partnership engagement
 
Presenting the MDE-UMUC/HBMeU cooperative programs
Presenting the MDE-UMUC/HBMeU cooperative programsPresenting the MDE-UMUC/HBMeU cooperative programs
Presenting the MDE-UMUC/HBMeU cooperative programs
 
Creating Our Own Pathways
Creating Our Own PathwaysCreating Our Own Pathways
Creating Our Own Pathways
 
UEDA 2015 Awards of Excellence - Talent Development - Engaging Engineering St...
UEDA 2015 Awards of Excellence - Talent Development - Engaging Engineering St...UEDA 2015 Awards of Excellence - Talent Development - Engaging Engineering St...
UEDA 2015 Awards of Excellence - Talent Development - Engaging Engineering St...
 
Academic partnership
Academic partnershipAcademic partnership
Academic partnership
 
Corporate Engagement benchmarking study
Corporate Engagement benchmarking studyCorporate Engagement benchmarking study
Corporate Engagement benchmarking study
 
Knowledge translation and transfer program - OMAFRA
Knowledge translation and transfer program - OMAFRAKnowledge translation and transfer program - OMAFRA
Knowledge translation and transfer program - OMAFRA
 
Academic and industry collaboration
Academic and industry collaborationAcademic and industry collaboration
Academic and industry collaboration
 
ipas-annual-report-2015
ipas-annual-report-2015ipas-annual-report-2015
ipas-annual-report-2015
 
University Industry Partnership For Innovations
University Industry Partnership For InnovationsUniversity Industry Partnership For Innovations
University Industry Partnership For Innovations
 
Industry-academia collaboration
Industry-academia collaborationIndustry-academia collaboration
Industry-academia collaboration
 
Better Biotech Innovation by Improving the Ecosystem by Tim Charlebois, VP In...
Better Biotech Innovation by Improving the Ecosystem by Tim Charlebois, VP In...Better Biotech Innovation by Improving the Ecosystem by Tim Charlebois, VP In...
Better Biotech Innovation by Improving the Ecosystem by Tim Charlebois, VP In...
 
Integrated Thinking and the Integrated Report
Integrated Thinking and the Integrated ReportIntegrated Thinking and the Integrated Report
Integrated Thinking and the Integrated Report
 
Promotion of industry academia collaboration
Promotion of industry academia collaborationPromotion of industry academia collaboration
Promotion of industry academia collaboration
 
University-Industry Collaboration by M Iftikhar Anjum
University-Industry Collaboration by M Iftikhar AnjumUniversity-Industry Collaboration by M Iftikhar Anjum
University-Industry Collaboration by M Iftikhar Anjum
 
Collaboration between Industry and Academia – An Opportunity to Drive Efficie...
Collaboration between Industry and Academia – An Opportunity to Drive Efficie...Collaboration between Industry and Academia – An Opportunity to Drive Efficie...
Collaboration between Industry and Academia – An Opportunity to Drive Efficie...
 
University support for industry collaboration
University support for industry collaborationUniversity support for industry collaboration
University support for industry collaboration
 

Similar to EDUCAUSE 2015 - Partnership Powered IT Change

Project Value Delivery methodology and interventions
Project Value Delivery methodology and interventionsProject Value Delivery methodology and interventions
Project Value Delivery methodology and interventions
Jeremie Averous
 
Information Services Project Management Change Theme Update May 2017
Information Services Project Management Change Theme Update May 2017Information Services Project Management Change Theme Update May 2017
Information Services Project Management Change Theme Update May 2017
Mark Ritchie
 
Educause_2013_OIT+Virtual+PMO+Presentation+1032013.pptx
Educause_2013_OIT+Virtual+PMO+Presentation+1032013.pptxEducause_2013_OIT+Virtual+PMO+Presentation+1032013.pptx
Educause_2013_OIT+Virtual+PMO+Presentation+1032013.pptx
ssuserf016f4
 
Piloting Major Business Change: Worktribe Research Management at the Universi...
Piloting Major Business Change: Worktribe Research Management at the Universi...Piloting Major Business Change: Worktribe Research Management at the Universi...
Piloting Major Business Change: Worktribe Research Management at the Universi...
Mark Ritchie
 
Estimating agile projects and the role of the project manager
Estimating agile projects and the role of the project managerEstimating agile projects and the role of the project manager
Estimating agile projects and the role of the project manager
TerkelTolstrup
 
Sustainability for Project-Based Collaborative Work: Leveraging Service Level...
Sustainability for Project-Based Collaborative Work: Leveraging Service Level...Sustainability for Project-Based Collaborative Work: Leveraging Service Level...
Sustainability for Project-Based Collaborative Work: Leveraging Service Level...
Franny Gaede
 
EDUCAUSE 2015 - Partnership Powered IT and Business Change Presentation and S...
EDUCAUSE 2015 - Partnership Powered IT and Business Change Presentation and S...EDUCAUSE 2015 - Partnership Powered IT and Business Change Presentation and S...
EDUCAUSE 2015 - Partnership Powered IT and Business Change Presentation and S...
Mark Ritchie
 
Skills and tools for project success
Skills and tools for project successSkills and tools for project success
Skills and tools for project success
SivaramAthmakuri1
 
Adaptive courseware vendor selection and engagement
Adaptive courseware vendor selection and engagementAdaptive courseware vendor selection and engagement
Adaptive courseware vendor selection and engagement
Karen Vignare
 
Prospective Student Web Content Team - University of Edinburgh intro session
Prospective Student Web Content Team - University of Edinburgh intro sessionProspective Student Web Content Team - University of Edinburgh intro session
Prospective Student Web Content Team - University of Edinburgh intro session
Neil Allison
 
Overview of Project Services at University of Edinburgh
Overview of Project Services at University of EdinburghOverview of Project Services at University of Edinburgh
Overview of Project Services at University of Edinburgh
Mark Ritchie
 
Pre-application good practice
Pre-application good practicePre-application good practice
Pre-application good practice
PAS_Team
 
Responsible project management
Responsible project managementResponsible project management
Responsible project management
Association for Project Management
 
Educate 2017: Enhancing edtech - why together is better
Educate 2017: Enhancing edtech - why together is better Educate 2017: Enhancing edtech - why together is better
Educate 2017: Enhancing edtech - why together is better
Learnosity
 
How the Met Office delivers extraordinary impact and benefit through beautifu...
How the Met Office delivers extraordinary impact and benefit through beautifu...How the Met Office delivers extraordinary impact and benefit through beautifu...
How the Met Office delivers extraordinary impact and benefit through beautifu...
Association for Project Management
 
Project Management Competency Guide for Digital Transformation
Project Management Competency Guide for Digital TransformationProject Management Competency Guide for Digital Transformation
Project Management Competency Guide for Digital Transformation
John Macasio
 
Planning and Redesigning a Social Intranet from The Intranet Global Forum 2015
Planning and Redesigning a Social Intranet from The Intranet Global Forum 2015Planning and Redesigning a Social Intranet from The Intranet Global Forum 2015
Planning and Redesigning a Social Intranet from The Intranet Global Forum 2015
Prescient Digital Media
 
Share point governance webinar 1 how to build (ron charity) - draft 3102013
Share point governance webinar 1   how to build (ron charity) - draft 3102013Share point governance webinar 1   how to build (ron charity) - draft 3102013
Share point governance webinar 1 how to build (ron charity) - draft 3102013Ron Charity
 
En pm in_the_cloud_intro_v0.1
En pm in_the_cloud_intro_v0.1En pm in_the_cloud_intro_v0.1
En pm in_the_cloud_intro_v0.1
Henk van der Tweel
 
NickRoberts CV 280815 LI
NickRoberts CV 280815 LINickRoberts CV 280815 LI
NickRoberts CV 280815 LINick Roberts
 

Similar to EDUCAUSE 2015 - Partnership Powered IT Change (20)

Project Value Delivery methodology and interventions
Project Value Delivery methodology and interventionsProject Value Delivery methodology and interventions
Project Value Delivery methodology and interventions
 
Information Services Project Management Change Theme Update May 2017
Information Services Project Management Change Theme Update May 2017Information Services Project Management Change Theme Update May 2017
Information Services Project Management Change Theme Update May 2017
 
Educause_2013_OIT+Virtual+PMO+Presentation+1032013.pptx
Educause_2013_OIT+Virtual+PMO+Presentation+1032013.pptxEducause_2013_OIT+Virtual+PMO+Presentation+1032013.pptx
Educause_2013_OIT+Virtual+PMO+Presentation+1032013.pptx
 
Piloting Major Business Change: Worktribe Research Management at the Universi...
Piloting Major Business Change: Worktribe Research Management at the Universi...Piloting Major Business Change: Worktribe Research Management at the Universi...
Piloting Major Business Change: Worktribe Research Management at the Universi...
 
Estimating agile projects and the role of the project manager
Estimating agile projects and the role of the project managerEstimating agile projects and the role of the project manager
Estimating agile projects and the role of the project manager
 
Sustainability for Project-Based Collaborative Work: Leveraging Service Level...
Sustainability for Project-Based Collaborative Work: Leveraging Service Level...Sustainability for Project-Based Collaborative Work: Leveraging Service Level...
Sustainability for Project-Based Collaborative Work: Leveraging Service Level...
 
EDUCAUSE 2015 - Partnership Powered IT and Business Change Presentation and S...
EDUCAUSE 2015 - Partnership Powered IT and Business Change Presentation and S...EDUCAUSE 2015 - Partnership Powered IT and Business Change Presentation and S...
EDUCAUSE 2015 - Partnership Powered IT and Business Change Presentation and S...
 
Skills and tools for project success
Skills and tools for project successSkills and tools for project success
Skills and tools for project success
 
Adaptive courseware vendor selection and engagement
Adaptive courseware vendor selection and engagementAdaptive courseware vendor selection and engagement
Adaptive courseware vendor selection and engagement
 
Prospective Student Web Content Team - University of Edinburgh intro session
Prospective Student Web Content Team - University of Edinburgh intro sessionProspective Student Web Content Team - University of Edinburgh intro session
Prospective Student Web Content Team - University of Edinburgh intro session
 
Overview of Project Services at University of Edinburgh
Overview of Project Services at University of EdinburghOverview of Project Services at University of Edinburgh
Overview of Project Services at University of Edinburgh
 
Pre-application good practice
Pre-application good practicePre-application good practice
Pre-application good practice
 
Responsible project management
Responsible project managementResponsible project management
Responsible project management
 
Educate 2017: Enhancing edtech - why together is better
Educate 2017: Enhancing edtech - why together is better Educate 2017: Enhancing edtech - why together is better
Educate 2017: Enhancing edtech - why together is better
 
How the Met Office delivers extraordinary impact and benefit through beautifu...
How the Met Office delivers extraordinary impact and benefit through beautifu...How the Met Office delivers extraordinary impact and benefit through beautifu...
How the Met Office delivers extraordinary impact and benefit through beautifu...
 
Project Management Competency Guide for Digital Transformation
Project Management Competency Guide for Digital TransformationProject Management Competency Guide for Digital Transformation
Project Management Competency Guide for Digital Transformation
 
Planning and Redesigning a Social Intranet from The Intranet Global Forum 2015
Planning and Redesigning a Social Intranet from The Intranet Global Forum 2015Planning and Redesigning a Social Intranet from The Intranet Global Forum 2015
Planning and Redesigning a Social Intranet from The Intranet Global Forum 2015
 
Share point governance webinar 1 how to build (ron charity) - draft 3102013
Share point governance webinar 1   how to build (ron charity) - draft 3102013Share point governance webinar 1   how to build (ron charity) - draft 3102013
Share point governance webinar 1 how to build (ron charity) - draft 3102013
 
En pm in_the_cloud_intro_v0.1
En pm in_the_cloud_intro_v0.1En pm in_the_cloud_intro_v0.1
En pm in_the_cloud_intro_v0.1
 
NickRoberts CV 280815 LI
NickRoberts CV 280815 LINickRoberts CV 280815 LI
NickRoberts CV 280815 LI
 

More from Mark Ritchie

UCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE Environment
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE EnvironmentUCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE Environment
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE Environment
Mark Ritchie
 
UCISA Toolkit - Effective Benefits Management for Business Change and IT Proj...
UCISA Toolkit - Effective Benefits Management for Business Change and IT Proj...UCISA Toolkit - Effective Benefits Management for Business Change and IT Proj...
UCISA Toolkit - Effective Benefits Management for Business Change and IT Proj...
Mark Ritchie
 
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing a PMO in an HE Environment
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing a PMO in an HE Environment UCISA Toolkit - Establishing a PMO in an HE Environment
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing a PMO in an HE Environment
Mark Ritchie
 
UCISA Toolkit - Effective Risk Management for Business Change and IT Projects
UCISA Toolkit - Effective Risk Management for Business Change and IT Projects UCISA Toolkit - Effective Risk Management for Business Change and IT Projects
UCISA Toolkit - Effective Risk Management for Business Change and IT Projects
Mark Ritchie
 
UCISA Major Projects Governance Assessment Toolkit
UCISA Major Projects Governance Assessment ToolkitUCISA Major Projects Governance Assessment Toolkit
UCISA Major Projects Governance Assessment Toolkit
Mark Ritchie
 
Managing Project Dependencies on the University of Edinburgh Projects Web Site
Managing Project Dependencies on the University of Edinburgh Projects Web SiteManaging Project Dependencies on the University of Edinburgh Projects Web Site
Managing Project Dependencies on the University of Edinburgh Projects Web Site
Mark Ritchie
 
Compliance IT Project Categories
Compliance IT Project CategoriesCompliance IT Project Categories
Compliance IT Project Categories
Mark Ritchie
 
UCISA Project and Change Management Group Toolkits
UCISA Project and Change Management Group Toolkits  UCISA Project and Change Management Group Toolkits
UCISA Project and Change Management Group Toolkits
Mark Ritchie
 
Overview of Project Services in Information Services at the University of Edi...
Overview of Project Services in Information Services at the University of Edi...Overview of Project Services in Information Services at the University of Edi...
Overview of Project Services in Information Services at the University of Edi...
Mark Ritchie
 
Programme or project plan on a single slide (with RAG status)
Programme or project plan on a single slide (with RAG status)Programme or project plan on a single slide (with RAG status)
Programme or project plan on a single slide (with RAG status)
Mark Ritchie
 
Simple Programme Gantt Chart with RAG Status
Simple Programme Gantt Chart with RAG StatusSimple Programme Gantt Chart with RAG Status
Simple Programme Gantt Chart with RAG Status
Mark Ritchie
 
Effective Project Communication
Effective Project CommunicationEffective Project Communication
Effective Project Communication
Mark Ritchie
 
Project Stakeholder Engagement
Project Stakeholder EngagementProject Stakeholder Engagement
Project Stakeholder Engagement
Mark Ritchie
 
UCISA Major Project Governance Assessment Toolkit
UCISA Major Project Governance Assessment ToolkitUCISA Major Project Governance Assessment Toolkit
UCISA Major Project Governance Assessment Toolkit
Mark Ritchie
 

More from Mark Ritchie (14)

UCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE Environment
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE EnvironmentUCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE Environment
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing Process Improvement Capability in an HE Environment
 
UCISA Toolkit - Effective Benefits Management for Business Change and IT Proj...
UCISA Toolkit - Effective Benefits Management for Business Change and IT Proj...UCISA Toolkit - Effective Benefits Management for Business Change and IT Proj...
UCISA Toolkit - Effective Benefits Management for Business Change and IT Proj...
 
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing a PMO in an HE Environment
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing a PMO in an HE Environment UCISA Toolkit - Establishing a PMO in an HE Environment
UCISA Toolkit - Establishing a PMO in an HE Environment
 
UCISA Toolkit - Effective Risk Management for Business Change and IT Projects
UCISA Toolkit - Effective Risk Management for Business Change and IT Projects UCISA Toolkit - Effective Risk Management for Business Change and IT Projects
UCISA Toolkit - Effective Risk Management for Business Change and IT Projects
 
UCISA Major Projects Governance Assessment Toolkit
UCISA Major Projects Governance Assessment ToolkitUCISA Major Projects Governance Assessment Toolkit
UCISA Major Projects Governance Assessment Toolkit
 
Managing Project Dependencies on the University of Edinburgh Projects Web Site
Managing Project Dependencies on the University of Edinburgh Projects Web SiteManaging Project Dependencies on the University of Edinburgh Projects Web Site
Managing Project Dependencies on the University of Edinburgh Projects Web Site
 
Compliance IT Project Categories
Compliance IT Project CategoriesCompliance IT Project Categories
Compliance IT Project Categories
 
UCISA Project and Change Management Group Toolkits
UCISA Project and Change Management Group Toolkits  UCISA Project and Change Management Group Toolkits
UCISA Project and Change Management Group Toolkits
 
Overview of Project Services in Information Services at the University of Edi...
Overview of Project Services in Information Services at the University of Edi...Overview of Project Services in Information Services at the University of Edi...
Overview of Project Services in Information Services at the University of Edi...
 
Programme or project plan on a single slide (with RAG status)
Programme or project plan on a single slide (with RAG status)Programme or project plan on a single slide (with RAG status)
Programme or project plan on a single slide (with RAG status)
 
Simple Programme Gantt Chart with RAG Status
Simple Programme Gantt Chart with RAG StatusSimple Programme Gantt Chart with RAG Status
Simple Programme Gantt Chart with RAG Status
 
Effective Project Communication
Effective Project CommunicationEffective Project Communication
Effective Project Communication
 
Project Stakeholder Engagement
Project Stakeholder EngagementProject Stakeholder Engagement
Project Stakeholder Engagement
 
UCISA Major Project Governance Assessment Toolkit
UCISA Major Project Governance Assessment ToolkitUCISA Major Project Governance Assessment Toolkit
UCISA Major Project Governance Assessment Toolkit
 

Recently uploaded

Case Analysis - The Sky is the Limit | Principles of Management
Case Analysis - The Sky is the Limit | Principles of ManagementCase Analysis - The Sky is the Limit | Principles of Management
Case Analysis - The Sky is the Limit | Principles of Management
A. F. M. Rubayat-Ul Jannat
 
Oprah Winfrey: A Leader in Media, Philanthropy, and Empowerment | CIO Women M...
Oprah Winfrey: A Leader in Media, Philanthropy, and Empowerment | CIO Women M...Oprah Winfrey: A Leader in Media, Philanthropy, and Empowerment | CIO Women M...
Oprah Winfrey: A Leader in Media, Philanthropy, and Empowerment | CIO Women M...
CIOWomenMagazine
 
W.H.Bender Quote 65 - The Team Member and Guest Experience
W.H.Bender Quote 65 - The Team Member and Guest ExperienceW.H.Bender Quote 65 - The Team Member and Guest Experience
W.H.Bender Quote 65 - The Team Member and Guest Experience
William (Bill) H. Bender, FCSI
 
Senior Project and Engineering Leader Jim Smith.pdf
Senior Project and Engineering Leader Jim Smith.pdfSenior Project and Engineering Leader Jim Smith.pdf
Senior Project and Engineering Leader Jim Smith.pdf
Jim Smith
 
Founder-Game Director Workshop (Session 1)
Founder-Game Director  Workshop (Session 1)Founder-Game Director  Workshop (Session 1)
Founder-Game Director Workshop (Session 1)
Amir H. Fassihi
 
TCS AI for Business Study – Key Findings
TCS AI for Business Study – Key FindingsTCS AI for Business Study – Key Findings
TCS AI for Business Study – Key Findings
Tata Consultancy Services
 
一比一原版杜克大学毕业证(Duke毕业证)成绩单留信认证
一比一原版杜克大学毕业证(Duke毕业证)成绩单留信认证一比一原版杜克大学毕业证(Duke毕业证)成绩单留信认证
一比一原版杜克大学毕业证(Duke毕业证)成绩单留信认证
gcljeuzdu
 
Leadership Ethics and Change, Purpose to Impact Plan
Leadership Ethics and Change, Purpose to Impact PlanLeadership Ethics and Change, Purpose to Impact Plan
Leadership Ethics and Change, Purpose to Impact Plan
Muhammad Adil Jamil
 
Training- integrated management system (iso)
Training- integrated management system (iso)Training- integrated management system (iso)
Training- integrated management system (iso)
akaash13
 
SOCIO-ANTHROPOLOGY FACULTY OF NURSING.....
SOCIO-ANTHROPOLOGY FACULTY OF NURSING.....SOCIO-ANTHROPOLOGY FACULTY OF NURSING.....
SOCIO-ANTHROPOLOGY FACULTY OF NURSING.....
juniourjohnstone
 

Recently uploaded (10)

Case Analysis - The Sky is the Limit | Principles of Management
Case Analysis - The Sky is the Limit | Principles of ManagementCase Analysis - The Sky is the Limit | Principles of Management
Case Analysis - The Sky is the Limit | Principles of Management
 
Oprah Winfrey: A Leader in Media, Philanthropy, and Empowerment | CIO Women M...
Oprah Winfrey: A Leader in Media, Philanthropy, and Empowerment | CIO Women M...Oprah Winfrey: A Leader in Media, Philanthropy, and Empowerment | CIO Women M...
Oprah Winfrey: A Leader in Media, Philanthropy, and Empowerment | CIO Women M...
 
W.H.Bender Quote 65 - The Team Member and Guest Experience
W.H.Bender Quote 65 - The Team Member and Guest ExperienceW.H.Bender Quote 65 - The Team Member and Guest Experience
W.H.Bender Quote 65 - The Team Member and Guest Experience
 
Senior Project and Engineering Leader Jim Smith.pdf
Senior Project and Engineering Leader Jim Smith.pdfSenior Project and Engineering Leader Jim Smith.pdf
Senior Project and Engineering Leader Jim Smith.pdf
 
Founder-Game Director Workshop (Session 1)
Founder-Game Director  Workshop (Session 1)Founder-Game Director  Workshop (Session 1)
Founder-Game Director Workshop (Session 1)
 
TCS AI for Business Study – Key Findings
TCS AI for Business Study – Key FindingsTCS AI for Business Study – Key Findings
TCS AI for Business Study – Key Findings
 
一比一原版杜克大学毕业证(Duke毕业证)成绩单留信认证
一比一原版杜克大学毕业证(Duke毕业证)成绩单留信认证一比一原版杜克大学毕业证(Duke毕业证)成绩单留信认证
一比一原版杜克大学毕业证(Duke毕业证)成绩单留信认证
 
Leadership Ethics and Change, Purpose to Impact Plan
Leadership Ethics and Change, Purpose to Impact PlanLeadership Ethics and Change, Purpose to Impact Plan
Leadership Ethics and Change, Purpose to Impact Plan
 
Training- integrated management system (iso)
Training- integrated management system (iso)Training- integrated management system (iso)
Training- integrated management system (iso)
 
SOCIO-ANTHROPOLOGY FACULTY OF NURSING.....
SOCIO-ANTHROPOLOGY FACULTY OF NURSING.....SOCIO-ANTHROPOLOGY FACULTY OF NURSING.....
SOCIO-ANTHROPOLOGY FACULTY OF NURSING.....
 

EDUCAUSE 2015 - Partnership Powered IT Change

  • 1. Partnership-Powered IT Change Rhian Davies • Craig Henderson • Mark Ritchie
  • 2. Partnership Powered IT – Outcomes 1. Understand importance of partnership in delivering IT change 2. Identify key behaviours for building trust 3. Describe how changing your language can change your relationship
  • 3. Mark Ritchie • Team of 20+ project managers and business analysts • IT and business change projects • Responsible for ~13000 IT project days last year • Delivering projects at the University for 20+ years Influencing the world since 1583 Head of Project Services Information Services Mark.Ritchie@ed.ac.uk
  • 4. Rhian Davies • Deputy Head of Project Services since 2012 • Portfolio Manager for Corporate Services • Delivering projects and business change for 10+ years at the University Influencing the world since 1583 Deputy Head of Project Services Information Services Rhian.Davies@ed.ac.uk
  • 5. Craig Henderson • Responsible for eCommerce and efficiency • Award winning procurement team • Sponsoring and leading business change projects at University for 20+ years • Member Scottish Government eCommerce Forum Influencing the world since 1583 Assistant Director of Procurement Corporate Services Craig.Henderson@ed.ac.uk
  • 6. Procurement Spend at the University
  • 7. 35,000+ students 3 Colleges 22 Schools 13,000+ staff $450m research income $1bn + turnover World Top 50 university Influencing the world since 1583
  • 9. Our Message Working Together Building Trust Transforming Relationships to Partnerships Improved Delivery of IT Change It takes time and effort but it’s worth it!
  • 10. What is Partnership? A business entity in which two or more co-owners contribute resources, share in profits and losses, and are individually liable for the entity's actions A relationship between individuals or groups that is characterized by mutual cooperation and responsibility, as for the achievement of a specified goal Source: The Free Dictionary http://www.thefreedictionary.com/partnership
  • 11. So what’s the problem?
  • 12. Partners can have very different Backgrounds and Experience Skills and Talents Approaches to Problem Solving Views
  • 13. A Great Partnership - Laurel and Hardy
  • 15. Project Delivery in 2005 – Business View • It was difficult to work with IT • IT chose the projects but didn’t understand our business • IT provided technology we had to do the rest • Every project seemed to be managed differently • It was difficult to find out about project status • Projects often stalled, took longer and cost more We blamed IT!
  • 16. Project Delivery Headlines Reporting Tool Five Years to Complete! System Withdrawn Following Complaints from Students Student Records Project In Trouble! Fall Guy! – Business Lead Knew Nothing About Project
  • 17. How was it in 2005 for IT? • We didn’t work well as a team • Roles/responsibilities poorly understood • Projects not well defined • We struggled to engage effectively with non IT colleagues – misunderstanding and lack of trust • Not consulted on decisions with IT implications • Projects often stalled, took longer and cost more We felt undervalued and misunderstood!
  • 19. Starting to Tackle the Problems Build Trust Improve Delivery
  • 22. Agreed Roles and Responsibilities Project Sponsor • Owns the business case • Accountable for the success or failure of the project Project Manager • Day to day responsibility for running the project • Responsible for ensuring that project produces the required deliverables
  • 28. Transparent Allocation of IT Resource Budgets at programme level Allocated budgets to Programme Owners not IT Owners could decide where IT effort was used Owners could trade within and between programmes Programme owners better understood costs and were empowered to make decisions about their projects
  • 30. Changed Language Customer Partner We and Us Because I and You Sorry
  • 32. Shared Success • eProcurement Scotland – implement a country- wide eProcurement system at UoE • Scottish Government, UoE, consultants and supplier all part of on-site team • Anything other than an effective partnership would have been a disaster • Full time project manager from IT • Co-location in a single team office • Project was delivered successfully, and has continued to develop and grow
  • 34. Track Record of Delivery 5797 6882 8103 8427 10375 9389 9586 12977 13659 12998 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Project Days Delivered
  • 36. Co-located Project Teams Student Systems Partnership University Web Site Programme
  • 37. Expanded Partner Role Embedded Programme Managers Estates and Buildings (also Human Resources and IT Infrastructure) Multi Year University Projects Research Administration (also Scheduling and University Website CMS)
  • 38. Agile Project Delivery • Searchable contract and supplier database “Buy@Ed” • Short space of time, small budget, to deliver but big impact • Partnership with HE sector partner • End user requirements sessions – they were delighted to be asked! • Successful project – partnership in action!
  • 39. Where are we now?
  • 40. 2015 – An IT Perspective • Working together to prioritise projects • Well understood methods of delivery • Confidence in delivery • Ability to have difficult conversations – and move forward positively • Asked for help and advice – not just with technology! • Working together to improve e.g. benefits management
  • 41. 2015 – A Partner Perspective • It’s no longer them and us • Buy-in/ownership/trust - honesty • I don’t buy a service, we deliver projects together • End users have become our partners too • Our solutions and services are better • Empowered by change to programme budgets • It’s more fun than it used to be!
  • 42. 2015 - Project Delivery Headlines Agile project delivers hazardous materials solution Library Management System delivered on time and to budget – students like it too! Student Systems Partnership goes from strength to strength University to present on Partnership at EDUCAUSE
  • 44. Build Trust to Improve Delivery Focus on to build trust and improve delivery
  • 45. Build Trust - Togetherness • Agree roles and responsibilities • Prioritise projects together • Change language and take joint ownership for delivery • Share your successes (and your problems) • Co-locate your project teams • Identify opportunities to expand your partner relationships
  • 46. Build Trust – Consistency • Introduce standard approach for projects • Sort out estimation and consider how to manage resources – do you need Time Tracking? • Establish a track record for delivery
  • 47. Build Trust – Transparency • Agree rules for RAG reporting • Ensure project status visible to all stakeholders • Consider developing a Projects Web Site • Introduce transparent allocation of resources • Publish (and act on) lessons learned
  • 49. Changing your language can make a big difference! Customer Partner
  • 50. Partnership will power IT change We do it together!
  • 52. Help Us Improve and Grow Thank you for participating in today’s session! We’re very interested in your feedback. Please take a minute to fill out the session evaluation found within the conference mobile app, or the online agenda

Editor's Notes

  1. <Mark> Thanks for coming to our presentation this morning on partnership-powered IT Change We’re from Edinburgh University in Scotland We’ve come a long way, and not just geographically, to be able to present this to you! There may be some challenges with accents and terminology We’ll do our best to speak more slowly but please forgive us if we get over-excited Establishing effective partnerships is always a challenge for IT and even more so within complex and highly devolved organisations such as Universities. Its clear that finding ways to work across campus that produce better outcomes for our students and staff is high on everyone’s agenda. We think that partnership for IT is an idea whose time has come – a recent Gartner paper “The Politics of Powerful Partnerships” certainly suggest so. Our presentation is based on work done within Information Services at the University of Edinburgh going back more than 10 years. We hope that you find ideas in our presentation that will help you. We’ll leave time for questions at the end but we’re more than happy to stay around afterwards. <Next Slide Mark>
  2. <Mark> Reads points from slide <Next Slide Mark>
  3. <Mark> Before we get started a few introductions are in order. I’m Head of Project Services in Information Services I’ve worked at the University for more than 20 years in various IT roles I’m responsible for a team of >20 Project Managers and Business Analysts We deliver IT and business change projects Approximately 13000 IT days (70 person years) last year <Pause> I’m delighted my colleagues Rhian Davies and Craig Henderson are with me today Rhian, my Deputy, has been the architect of much of our work on partnership and at the heart of Project Services for more than 10 years Craig has been a colleague and friend for almost 20 years Between the three of us we’ve worked over half a century at the University! <Next Slide Rhian>
  4. <Rhian> I’m Deputy Head of Project Services I’m also Portfolio Manager for Corporate Services A key element of my role is to maintain effective relationships which deliver benefits for the University As part of this work I’ve played a leading role in developing our partnership model <Pause> Craig Henderson from our Procurement (Purchasing) Team is one of my partners in Corporate Services Craig is a genuine business person and absolutely not an IT professional – be gentle with him! <Next Slide Craig>
  5. <Craig> I’m Assistant Director of Procurement I’m responsible for eCommerce systems including eSourcing, eTendering and eOrdering Our Procurement team has been consistently recognised as one of the most effective in Scotland I’ve worked in project and service delivery at the University for more than 20 years, in both Finance and Procurement I’m also a Member of the Scottish Government eCommerce Strategic Forum – this gives me the opportunity to influence strategic direction and policy at government level. My background in Finance– started in management accounting – definitely not an IT professional! <Next Slide Craig>
  6. <Craig> The University places in excess of 110,000 orders per year and spends over $300million annually on goods and services. This represents a growth of over 20% since 2011 Typically our staffing resources have not grown in line with external spending, so we need to be as efficient as possible. <Next Slide is Mark>
  7. <Mark> Thanks Craig An overview of the University will be helpful to place our presentation in context. The University is based in Edinburgh in Scotland Sixth oldest in the English speaking world – but only the fourth oldest in Scotland! This gives some idea of the historical strength of education in Scotland! We have 35000 students mainly on campus around Edinburgh We also have a strong research focus Consistently rated in the top 50 universities in the world – something we’re very proud of We have many beautiful historical buildings across campus This is Old College at the heart of the University <Next Slide Mark>
  8. <Mark> In the midst of all of this history and romance it’s easy to forget that Universities are large and complex businesses. Businesses which operate in an increasingly dynamic environment and require effective management of business and IT change. The University of Edinburgh is no different. This is the high level organisation chart for the University showing our three Colleges and three Support Groups. We’ll come back to these Colleges and Support Groups later in the context of our project portfolios. <Next Slide Mark>
  9. <Mark> We believe partnership is, by some distance, the most effective way to deliver change in Higher Education The typical University is a highly devolved organisation with many centres of power and influence. IT solutions which fail to take into account the impact on people or business processes are even more likely to fail in a University environment. Only by working in close harmony with colleagues across the campus will IT start to build the trust essential for building partnerships and improving the delivery of change. We’ve learned this the hard way – we have the scars to prove it! Partnership takes time and effort – but we believe that your investment will be repaid many times over <Next Slide Mark>
  10. <Mark> In an effective partnership each partner: Takes ownership Contributes resources Works together positively Takes responsibility for and shares in the outcomes – both good or bad Sadly this is not the most common model for delivering IT change in Higher Education. Instead we more commonly encounter: unclear objectives disputed ownership organisation silos under-resourcing a pervasive blame culture which makes it better to try to avoid all responsibility for change It’s tough! <Next Slide Mark>
  11. <Mark> IT cannot deliver change on its own and must work effectively across the campus. This demands different skills of empathy and communication that take us far outside our comfort zone. On a major project it was said to me that IT was from Mars and our business partner, in this case our Research Office, was from Venus. We simply didn’t understand or communicate well with each other. I was advised that we had to work harder to build this relationship if the project was to succeed. This turned out to be very good advice! In truth I haven’t yet read John Gray’s book but maybe I should! <Next Slide Mark>
  12. <Mark> So how can we build effective partnerships? Perhaps the first thing we need to do is accept that successful partnership does not require “group think” Our colleagues across campus probably don’t see things exactly the same way as we do But these differences are an essential part of understanding each other and enable us to work together more effectively We need to recognise that our differences are often in fact our essential professional contributions to the partnership For IT these professional contributions might include: Structured approaches in areas such as project management Technology skills Specialist knowledge Experience of similar work done previously Great partnerships leverage their differences so that the whole is greater than the sum of the parts. <Next Slide Mark>
  13. <Mark> If we’re looking for some evidence of constructive differences in a partnership let’s consider these two – Laurel and Hardy The greatest comedy double act ever! This partnership didn’t just have differences – it celebrated them! The contrast in physical appearance The different ties The hats – one too small one too large The too tight and too loose jackets All of these can be seen in any photograph – a compelling study of difference But what they did - they did together - and didn’t they do it well! An unlikely model perhaps but we hope an inspiring one for IT and our colleagues across campus <Next Slide Mark>
  14. <Mark> Sadly however this peak of effective partnership represented by Laurel and Hardy is not exactly where we were in 2005 Craig – how was it for you back then? <Next Slide Craig>
  15. <Craig> Not great to be honest. Up to 2005 - IT projects were very difficult to work on We felt that IT largely chose the projects and set the priorities IT gave us some hardware, put the software on it, and largely left us to it. To be honest, we were quite happy with that. We felt that IT knew little about our business and preferred to do as much as we could ourselves, so when they offered us a project manager or business analyst, we were sceptical and usually declined . Similarly, we knew what the real end users wanted - sometimes because we’d asked them, but not always! Partnership wasn’t something that we were actively seeking Together we were inefficient, ineffective and ultimately infamous, offering endless opportunities for finger-pointing and blame <Next Slide Craig>
  16. I don’t think anyone’s going to thank me for sharing this, but here are few examples to illustrate… A reporting project that took 5 years to complete - it was poorly defined and inaccurately estimated, due to a lack of trust A new system was withdrawn for re-design after go-live due to complaints from students. It didn’t do what they needed and no-one had asked them. A Student Records project entirely staffed by Student Administration staff needed to be recovered by IT after running over budget and missing several major deadlines A business lead turned up for a meeting to discuss the scope of a project - but he hadn’t been told what the project was about! <Next Slide Mark>
  17. <Mark> Ouch! Thanks Craig – I’m glad you got that off your chest! To be fair to Craig though he’s right and it was scarcely any better for IT All out projects managers were doing things differently IT roles and responsibilities were not clearly defined We struggled to engage effectively with our colleagues like Craig Projects, and particularly benefits, were not well understood There were misunderstandings and a general lack of trust We needed to improve our delivery and find ways to establish more effective relationships Thankfully we had Rhian! <Next Slide Rhian>
  18. <Rhian> I realised that better relationships would enable us to more consistently deliver successful solutions for the University. How would we achieve this? This was the start of our journey. Rhian highlights “Partnership Powered IT Change Card” <Next Slide Rhian>
  19. <Rhian> We started to progress under what we subsequently recognised as these three main themes: Togetherness – the basic elements of working together and communication Consistency – adopting standard approaches which were easier to understand and engage with Transparency – sharing and openness about projects - no hidden information We’ll use these signposts for the remainder of the presentation. <Next Slide Mark>
  20. <Mark> Thanks Rhian. This is the first milestone in our journey. We recognised that the lack of standardisation in our project processes was a significant barrier to progress. Thankfully however it was something that we could do something about A number of our staff had good experience of project methodologies gained in their previous roles. Others had certification in things like PRINCE a projects management methodology developed originally in the UK So we decided to introduce a project methodology <Next Slide Rhian>
  21. <Rhian> A project methodology is a roadmap for your project and it helped us in a number of ways. It meant that we now had a standard approach to how we delivered our projects, so if Craig was working with 3 different project managers they would all be working in the same way. Our roadmap introduced standard checkpoints across the life of the project for ourselves and our partners, and other standards which together had a demonstrable improvement on the quality of what we were doing. Once you have a roadmap for your project you can see how your project is progressing, making it much easier for our colleagues to see what was happening– warts and all! <Next Slide Rhian>
  22. <Rhian> Agreeing roles and responsibilities for us and our colleagues helped everyone to understand what was expected This didn’t mean that they did it – but it was a start! It began to bring in a sense of shared responsibility for project delivery <Next Slide Rhian>
  23. <Rhian> We organised our projects into programmes – largely organisational based The example used here is for Estates and Buildings These programme made it easier for IT and project stakeholders to view project status This change also encouraged project ownership at the organisational level Use of Red Amber Green (RAG) status also helped us focus on what projects were going well and what projects needed our attention Project status information was shared at least monthly with stakeholders <Next Slide Mark>
  24. <Mark> Thanks Rhian. This is our second milestone. The Project Methodology introduced previously was starting to make a real difference However we still needed to bring a greater sense of reality to our project delivery We didn’t have unlimited resources and needed to ensure that there was a greater engagement with project prioritisation and resource management We’d introduced Time Tracking for IT staff in 1999 Time Tracking would prove an incredibly valuable enabler for our next steps <Next Slide Mark>
  25. <Rhian> We have an annual planning process where our partners submit project proposals, they are prioritised, and a red line is drawn when all the resources are allocated – if your project is below that line it will not happen. Craig said he felt IT prioritised the projects Finding a way to do this together was a key element of building trust. We did it by establishing portfolios for each of major areas of activity i.e. Corporate Services, the Colleges and our other Support Groups. Each portfolio had a clear owner – before that we just had a large list of project proposals and no overall ownership The Portfolio Owner was a senior person in administration within the area Working with our Portfolio Owners we were able to prioritise projects based on the needs of the portfolio, a much more successful approach! <Next Slide Rhian>
  26. <Rhian> During the planning process, we had very limited information about each proposal. It made estimating how much of our effort would be required difficult, we did the best we could but often ended up with very exact sounding estimates like 158 days or 203 days. Such an exact figure gave our partners the impression that we really understood what was required. Once the project started, the estimate would quickly change as we found out more and our partners would feel frustrated and assume we had just got it wrong. We needed to find a way of communicating that it was not an exact science. <Next Slide Rhian>
  27. <Rhian> We decided to create a scale – small, medium, and large. 0-50 = Small (50 days in plan), 50-100 = Medium (100 days in plan) 100-200 = Large (200 days in plan) >200 = Need a more detailed estimate This made it easier to understand that it was a ballpark figure and ensured a sensible number of days was included in the plan! We could also compare the project to something we had done before, and that really helped us to agree on size We now ask our partners to estimate their time on the same scale. <Next Slide Rhian>
  28. <Mark> We decided to build on the programmes introduced earlier Each project had always had an estimate and the improved estimation techniques meant that these were now more reliable We decided to use these estimates to create a programme level budget For example if a programme had three projects each with a 100 day estimate then we’d allocate a 300 budget for the programme We allocated these budget to the Programme Owners Programme Owners could then decide where to use the available IT effort within the programme e.g. to add scope to one project and reduce IT effort in another Programme Owners could also get together to trade IT effort between programmes This had the benefit of highlighting costs and empowering programme owners Where scope increases were previously the norm we started to have more informed conversations about the costs and value of change <Next Slide Mark>
  29. <Mark> This is our third milestone. By now we’d made a lot of progress on project delivery But IT was not yet an equal player and this was affecting both our internal relationships and our project outcomes So we made a conscious decision to change our language <Next Slide Rhian>
  30. <Rhian> We typically referred to colleagues that we worked with as our customers, but this was reinforcing our dysfunctional relationships. As a customer you are seen as having higher status in relationships – we often hear people say the customer is always right. Our colleagues were not even the customer – the actual customer was the end user who could have been staff, student, or alumni. What was actually happening was that we were partnering with our colleagues to deliver services for these end users, so we stopped calling them our customers and started calling them our partners. We stopped apologising and started explaining. We started talking about we and us. These might seem like small changes, but it is actually a pretty significant shift, not least in our minds and our approach. <Next Slide Mark>
  31. <Mark> Thanks Rhian. This is our fourth milestone. By now our positive progress had started to increase trust in IT Increasing confidence in IT led to us being asked to lead a major University wide procurement project – eProcurement Scotland We worked closely with Craig on this project so he can tell us more about it. <Next Slide Craig>
  32. <Craig> In 2007 the University took the decision to implement a new eProcurement system, as part of a Scottish Government initiative to deliver a country-wide, public sector eProcurement system. This was a high-profile, politically sensitive project - “Failure was not an option” An on-site team was put together including representatives from the Scottish government, the supplier, management consultants and the University. Many different perspectives, with different drivers, but all sharing the same ultimate goal. It was decided that a dedicated, full-time project manager was essential for the success of the project, and that the newly developed project methodology should be followed. Rhian was the project manager appointed to the project, and was seconded to the team full time. The whole project team was located in one office, and remained consistent throughout the project. This allowed us to build cohesion and trust. There were some competing priorities within the group, but the project structure - user group, project board, consistent reporting of risks and issues – helped ensure that successful delivery of the project wasn’t compromised. Together, we delivered a successful project which still continues to deliver significant benefits to the University. And just in case anyone has forgotten about my finance credentials, here are some more numbers. <Next Slide Craig>
  33. <Craig> Project was delivered successfully, and the service has continued to develop and grow Since completion of our project in 2008 volumes of eProcurement orders have grown significantly year on year Saving approximately $11 per order in process costs for a fully electronic purchase order, this represents an important annual efficiency benefit to the University of around $700K <Next Slide Mark>
  34. <Mark> Thanks Craig. Alongside successful delivery of individual projects it was important that we were successful right across our programmes and portfolios This chart shows the growth in project days delivered between 2005 and 2015 – a greater than 100% increase across this period! These days are funded either by the University of directly by Project Sponsors Increased days reflects the University growing confidence in our delivery and increased trust <Next Slide Mark>
  35. <Mark> This is our final milestone and brings us up to where we are today. We really are starting to see the benefits Partners trust us more and want us to help them with other challenges Our increased confidence in delivery also means that we are much more likely to suggest new collaborative approaches Let’s have a look at some of these <Next Slide Mark>
  36. <Mark> We now have several teams co-located with our partners in different parts of the University. We have 10 staff working as part of our partner led Student Systems Team. This is a semi-permanent arrangement. Where once our Student Systems partner would have hired their own IT staff they now work closely with us We also have 5 staff co-located in our Web Team delivering a new University web site based on the Drupal Web Content Management System <Next Slide Mark>
  37. <Mark> Partners increasingly recognise the value of project management and have requested that we provide staff to help them deliver their programmes of IT and non IT projects In Estates All IT activities not just projects Supplier/vendor management Developing an IT strategy In HR supporting mainly non IT projects In ITI providing a framework to enable them to mange and deliver their own projects We’ve led several multi-year projects in areas like Scheduling and Research Administration For Scheduling the University wide Project Board worked together successfully for more than three years to implement an effective solution Over the last few years we’ve also successfully adopted agile methodologies but I’ll let Craig tell you more about that. <Next Slide Craig>
  38. <Craig> As the ultimate step in partnership in practice, we now undertake some projects using the agile project methodology. In 2013 we undertook a project to deliver a simple, easy-to-use searchable database of all of our current contracts and suppliers. Perfect for agile delivery - it needed to be delivered quickly, within a very limited budget, but would have a big impact for the rest of the University. We worked in partnership with an HE representative body who held most of the data we needed, and we set out to seek the end-user requirements at an early stage. The users were keen to participate, and delighted to have been asked what they thought. The solution – Buy@Ed – has been well received and used, and allows us to deliver an improved service with limited resources. This project is typical of one which would have been too small, and deemed to unimportant to have been given priority under our old working practices. <Next Slide Mark>
  39. <Mark> Thanks Craig. We’re reaching the end of the presentation but not the end of our journey. So where have we got to now? Rhian what’s your view. <Next Slide Rhian>
  40. <Rhian> Our trust relationship has allowed us to completely change how we work together. We now prioritise projects together based on what the university needs. We have confidence in our ability to deliver projects and we all understand and respect the processes that we have in place to do so. When things go wrong or become difficult, we can talk about it. That doesn't mean it's always easy, but the big difference is that we now decide what to do together.  Our partners value our knowledge and experience, involving us in early discussions and seeking our support with non IT change. They support our ongoing improvement activities. For example, last month we invited our partners to attend a seminar with us on benefits realisation. People like Craig were keen to attend - a complete shift from 2005 when they didn't even want to talk about benefits. It really does feel like partnership! <Next Slide Craig>
  41. <Craig> I can only agree! Gone is the them and us approach where we had established a way of anticipating failure and apportioning blame before we even started. It’s been replaced by a trust relationship which allows honest, if sometimes difficult, conversations to be had, making problem solving much easier. The partnership approach has helped improve the service that my business support team provide to our end users. Having been involved in partnership powered projects, and seen the successful outcomes, they naturally adopt that approach. We work better with other programme owners too! The simple change to programme budgets has opened up the option to discuss redistribution of budgets based on need, thus encouraging even more communication and sharing of resources. We encourage the rest of the Procurement department to take this active, partnership approach on procurement projects to buy goods and services. This has led to improvements in both engagement and compliance. We all enjoy the inclusive nature, and are happy and proud to be part of successful projects. <Next Slide Mark>
  42. <Mark> The headlines have improved too! Here are some examples. All in all we’ve made real and sustained progress. We’re far from perfect but we’ve made a difference across campus Something that we’re really proud of <Next Slide Mark>
  43. <Mark> This has been a long journey. I’d like to leave you with some quick takeaways <Next Slide Mark>
  44. <Mark> Building trust will encourage partnership and improve your delivery – perhaps more than any single other process or technology change. Focus on Togetherness, Consistency and Transparency <Mark>
  45. <Mark> Here are our suggestions for improving TOGETHERNESS. <Next Slide Mark>
  46. <Mark> Here are our suggestions for improving CONSISTENCY. <Next Slide Mark>
  47. <Mark> Here are our suggestions for improving TRANSPARENCY <Next Slide Mark>
  48. <Mark> Remember Laurel and Hardy! Differences are good and a basis for successful partnership Our differences should be signs of professional competence not a source of partnership problems <Next Slide Mark>
  49. <Mark> Your unconscious language may be revealing more than you realise Changing it could make all the difference! <Next Slide Mark>
  50. <Mark> This last one is easy! IT in HE is challenging - but we have great people – possibly the best in the world It will be much easier and so much more successful if we work together <Next Slide Mark>
  51. <Mark> <Next Slide Mark>
  52. <Mark>