Net neutrality
                                                               Why it matters to you




             Matthew “Buzzy” Nielsen
             Assistant Director, North Bend Public Library




                  This presentation is licensed under a Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution United
01/07/2011           States license. For more information, visit http://www.creativecommons.org
What is net neutrality?
An analogy: electricity




                      All uses are prioritized equally.




Sources, from top then left: Fir0002/Flagstaffotos (Wikimedia Commons), bisonblog, dullhunk, and John McNab (Flickr)
Applied to the Internet
Applied to the Internet
What is net neutrality?



All content is created equal.
What is net neutrality?



       All platforms are created equal.




E-readers         Computers       Mobile phones
What is net neutrality?



       All users are created equal.




                Companies
Home users                    Business users
                                Image sources: Per Ola Wiberg
The state of regulation


   “ It's here: FCC adopts
       net neutrality (lite)
                             ”
          ~ ars technica, December 21, 2010 ~
The state of regulation



      Wired networks                 Mobile networks
●   No content-blocking         ●   Status quo maintained

●“Reasonable” network           ●Internet Service Providers
management                      can discriminate (or not)

●Some charging for
additional services allowed.
Issue #1
Will there be content discrimination
  and/or “network management?
Content discrimination



Content discrimination:
Making it easier and/or faster to access
certain sources or types of information
over others.




What's considered a neutral
 way to deal with content?
Pay for better access?
Priorities: The Comcast NBC merger
Priorities: The Comcast NBC merger
It's not just academic:
                          Comcast + bittorrent




In 2008, Comcast was detected
   slowing traffic for content
   delivered over BitTorrent.
Double-dipping




$           $

    $
Network management



 Network Management:
 Practices for companies running networks
 that allow them to control types of traffic to
 improve overall network performance.




What's considered a legitimate
network management practice?
Issue #2
Will net neutrality promote or stifle
   innovation and investment?
Two different views


Would allowing discriminatory
pricing models encourage for-
profit companies to invest more
in infrastructure?




                     Would providing for neutrality
                    encourage competition among
                      different content providers?
N
                                    et




                                                               0
                                                                   5
                                                                       10
                                                                            15
                                                                                 20
                                                                                      25
                                                                                                          30
                                                                                                                    35
                                                                                                                              40
                                         he
                                                rla
                                                      nd
                                     D                     s
                                           en
                                Sw               m
                                              ar
                                         it z   k
                                         er
                                            la
                                               nd
                                         K
                                           or
                                               ea
                                      N
                                         or
                               Lu            w
                                   xe          ay
                                      m
                                         bo
                                             ur
                                                g
                                       Ic
                                          el
                                             an
                                                d
                                      Sw
                                           ed
                                               en
                                        Fr
                                           an
                                    G          ce
                          U            er
                            ni
                               te         m
                                  d          an
                                    K           y
                                      in
                                         gd
                                              om
                                      C
                                         an
                                             ad
                                     B          a
                                        el
                             U            gi
                                ni           um
                                   te
                                      d
                                         St
                                            at
                                               es
                                      Fi
                                          nl
                                             an
                                                d
                                                                                                               DSL




                               N                Ja
                                                   p
                                                                                                               Other

                                                                                                               Cable




                                   ew                  an
                                          Ze
                                                al
                                                                                                               Fibre/LAN




                                                      an
                                     A                     d
                                           us
                                                                                                               OECD average




                                                 tr
                                                   al
                                                      ia
                                           A
                                                us
                                                      tr
                                                        ia
                                                Sp
                                                   a   in

                                                  It a
                                                         ly
                                            Ire
                                           an   l
                                   Po           d
                                       rt
                                          ug
                                              al
                                     G
                                        re
                                           ec
                                   H            e
                          C          un
                            ze
                               ch         ga
                                   R          ry
                                     ep
                                        ub
                                             lic
                                                                                           OECD average




                          Sl         Po
                             ov
                                ak        la
                                             nd
                                   R
                                     ep
                                         ub
                                             l ic
                                        C
                                           hi
                                              le
                                     M
                                        ex
                                            ic
                                                o
                                      Tu
                                          rk
                                             ey
                                                                                                                                   OECD Fixed (wired) broadband subscriptions per 100 inhabitants, by technology




Source: OECD, June 2010
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   US broadband = pathetic
20000
                                                                                                            40000
                                                                                                                       60000
                                                                                                                               80000
                                                                                                                                       100000
                                                                                                                                                                               120000




                                                                     0
                                                 M
                                                      ex
                                                         i   co          2 5 14
                                                    Ire
                                    Lu                  l   an
                                         xe                      d          6 0 88
                                           m
                                                     bo




                                                                                                                                                Median
                                                            ur
                                                              g                   1 0 457
                                                    Tu
                                                         rk
                                                            e    y                10 473
                                             B
                                                    el
                                                       g    iu
                                                               m                  10 825                                                        download speed, kbit/s*
                                                     Sp
                                                        a     in                   12 800
                                  U
                                                                                                                                                Average advertised broadband




                                      ni                 It a
                                           te                   ly                   14 336
                                                d
                                                    St
                                                         at
                                                              es                     14 619
                                                 G
                                                      re
                                                         e    ce                      15 945
                                            G
                                                er
                                                  m
                                                            an
                                                                 y                    16 033
                                                Ic
                                    N                 el
                                                         a
                                        ew                   nd                        17 774
                                                Ze
                                                      al
                                                            an
                                                                 d                      1 7 807
                                                N
                                                     or
                                                       w
                                                              ay                        18 000
                             C                  Fi
                                 ze                  nl
                                      ch                    an
                                            R                  d                        18 384
                                                ep
                                                       ub
                                                              lic                        18 788
                                                C
                                                     an
                                                            ad
                                                               a                            19 567
                             U                   Po
                                 ni
                                   te               l
                                        d                   an
                                                                 d
                                            K                                               19 675
                                                in
                                                     gd
                                      Sw                    om                              19 681
                                            it z
                                                    er
                                                      la
                                                             nd                             20 073
                                            D
                                                en
                                                       m
                                                            ar
                                            A                 k                                20 397
                                                us
                                                       tr
                                                         al
                                                              ia                               21 823
                                                Sw
                                                       ed
                                                             en                                  23 693
                                                                                                                                                                                        Average advertised broadband download speed, by country, kbit/s, October 2009




                             Sl                 A
                                o   va               us
                                      k                     tr
                                            R                 ia                                  25 519
                                                ep
                                                       ub
                                                              lic                                  26 939
                                             H
                                                 un
                                               ga
                                                 ry                                                27 542
                                             O
                                    N          EC
                                      et
                                         he       D                                                     30 550
                                            rla
                                                nd
                                                   s                                                      33 679
                                                     K
                                                         or
                                                           ea                                                       52 772
                                                    Fr
                                                      an
                                                     ce                                                              54 551
                                             Po
                                                rt
                                                   ug
                                                                                                                                                     10 3 71
                                                      al                                                                                                                 8
                                               Ja
                                                   pa
                                                      n                                                                                                       107 72
                                                                                                                                                                               5
Source: OECD, October 2009
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        US broadband = pathetic
Issue #3
What about the mobile Internet?
Mobile data: The future of the Web
        OECD wireless broadband subscriptions per 100 inhabitants, by technology

100
                     Dedicated mobile data
90                   subscriptions
                      Standard mobile broadband
                     subscriptions
80
                     Terrestrial fixed wireless
                     Satellite
70


60


50


40


30


20


10


 0          Fi ny



             un l
                    ay




      ak ce y




          B ary




                                                         M ey
                      d




           m nd




    te ep d




            or d
                    en

           N an




                      n
                      d




                      g




              rl e
           Sw ea




                                                                o
           er ds
           in lic




                                                         Tu le




                                                                                an c
      Sw St a




                   um




                                                                              ep a



                                                                                     a
   U Au ark



                    es




                   om




          H ga
                    al




                                                                                   li
                   ai
                   ur
                  an

         D lan



                    li




         R an




          P an




                                                                             R tri



                                                                                  ad
         he nc




                                                             ic
                                                            hi
                 ub




                                                                                 ub
                an
                 at
                  w




       te tra




                   a




                                                           rk
                 or

                ed

                  p




                  a




                                                          ex
                 It
               Sp




                tu

                 g

                gi
               gd
              bo
                m




                                                                                us
       et a




                                                        C
               m
               ol




                rl




                 l




               nl
               Ja

              or



               e
              K




     N Fr




             el
     Lu ze
           en

              s
            Ir
             P




                                                                              A



                                                                              C
            I
          d

         it




         K




         G
        xe




                                                                               ch
       d
     ni




                                                                            ze
  ov

 ni




                                                                           C
Sl

U




                                                                    Countries with partial data


                                                                    Source: OECD, June 2010
Investment is happening




                   Samsung GALAXY Tab
HTC EVO
But will we be nickel & dimed?

$                                                $
RSS                                              News



       $
      Music

                                         $
                                      Shopping


               $
             Social
           networking

                                  $
                                 Games
Issue #4
       Should the government be
involved in regulating the Internet at all?
Regulation and innovation

Television               Highly regulated


Radio                    Highly regulated

Film                        Self-regulated


Print                    Lightly-regulated



Internet                 Lightly-regulated
Is Internet sufficiently competitive?



Your broadband choices
in Coos County. If you're
   fortunate enough to
        have them.
The gist:
How content is treated on the Web will affect
what services are available in the future, how
  they're accessed, and the quality of the
    network on which they're delivered,
Questions?




                        View this presentation on slideshare:
                        http://www.slideshare.net/nbpl/net-neutrality-6478880


This presentation was made using open source software.



Fedora Linux         OpenOffice           Chromium        GIMP            Shutter             Android
Operating system      Impress             Web browser   Image editor   Screenshot utility   Mobile operating
                   Presentation program                                                         system

Net neutrality

  • 1.
    Net neutrality Why it matters to you Matthew “Buzzy” Nielsen Assistant Director, North Bend Public Library This presentation is licensed under a Creative Commons 3.0 Attribution United 01/07/2011 States license. For more information, visit http://www.creativecommons.org
  • 2.
    What is netneutrality?
  • 3.
    An analogy: electricity All uses are prioritized equally. Sources, from top then left: Fir0002/Flagstaffotos (Wikimedia Commons), bisonblog, dullhunk, and John McNab (Flickr)
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
    What is netneutrality? All content is created equal.
  • 7.
    What is netneutrality? All platforms are created equal. E-readers Computers Mobile phones
  • 8.
    What is netneutrality? All users are created equal. Companies Home users Business users Image sources: Per Ola Wiberg
  • 9.
    The state ofregulation “ It's here: FCC adopts net neutrality (lite) ” ~ ars technica, December 21, 2010 ~
  • 10.
    The state ofregulation Wired networks Mobile networks ● No content-blocking ● Status quo maintained ●“Reasonable” network ●Internet Service Providers management can discriminate (or not) ●Some charging for additional services allowed.
  • 11.
    Issue #1 Will therebe content discrimination and/or “network management?
  • 12.
    Content discrimination Content discrimination: Makingit easier and/or faster to access certain sources or types of information over others. What's considered a neutral way to deal with content?
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
    It's not justacademic: Comcast + bittorrent In 2008, Comcast was detected slowing traffic for content delivered over BitTorrent.
  • 17.
  • 18.
    Network management NetworkManagement: Practices for companies running networks that allow them to control types of traffic to improve overall network performance. What's considered a legitimate network management practice?
  • 19.
    Issue #2 Will netneutrality promote or stifle innovation and investment?
  • 20.
    Two different views Wouldallowing discriminatory pricing models encourage for- profit companies to invest more in infrastructure? Would providing for neutrality encourage competition among different content providers?
  • 21.
    N et 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 he rla nd D s en Sw m ar it z k er la nd K or ea N or Lu w xe ay m bo ur g Ic el an d Sw ed en Fr an G ce U er ni te m d an K y in gd om C an ad B a el U gi ni um te d St at es Fi nl an d DSL N Ja p Other Cable ew an Ze al Fibre/LAN an A d us OECD average tr al ia A us tr ia Sp a in It a ly Ire an l Po d rt ug al G re ec H e C un ze ch ga R ry ep ub lic OECD average Sl Po ov ak la nd R ep ub l ic C hi le M ex ic o Tu rk ey OECD Fixed (wired) broadband subscriptions per 100 inhabitants, by technology Source: OECD, June 2010 US broadband = pathetic
  • 22.
    20000 40000 60000 80000 100000 120000 0 M ex i co 2 5 14 Ire Lu l an xe d 6 0 88 m bo Median ur g 1 0 457 Tu rk e y 10 473 B el g iu m 10 825 download speed, kbit/s* Sp a in 12 800 U Average advertised broadband ni It a te ly 14 336 d St at es 14 619 G re e ce 15 945 G er m an y 16 033 Ic N el a ew nd 17 774 Ze al an d 1 7 807 N or w ay 18 000 C Fi ze nl ch an R d 18 384 ep ub lic 18 788 C an ad a 19 567 U Po ni te l d an d K 19 675 in gd Sw om 19 681 it z er la nd 20 073 D en m ar A k 20 397 us tr al ia 21 823 Sw ed en 23 693 Average advertised broadband download speed, by country, kbit/s, October 2009 Sl A o va us k tr R ia 25 519 ep ub lic 26 939 H un ga ry 27 542 O N EC et he D 30 550 rla nd s 33 679 K or ea 52 772 Fr an ce 54 551 Po rt ug 10 3 71 al 8 Ja pa n 107 72 5 Source: OECD, October 2009 US broadband = pathetic
  • 23.
    Issue #3 What aboutthe mobile Internet?
  • 24.
    Mobile data: Thefuture of the Web OECD wireless broadband subscriptions per 100 inhabitants, by technology 100 Dedicated mobile data 90 subscriptions Standard mobile broadband subscriptions 80 Terrestrial fixed wireless Satellite 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 Fi ny un l ay ak ce y B ary M ey d m nd te ep d or d en N an n d g rl e Sw ea o er ds in lic Tu le an c Sw St a um ep a a U Au ark es om H ga al li ai ur an D lan li R an P an R tri ad he nc ic hi ub ub an at w te tra a rk or ed p a ex It Sp tu g gi gd bo m us et a C m ol rl l nl Ja or e K N Fr el Lu ze en s Ir P A C I d it K G xe ch d ni ze ov ni C Sl U Countries with partial data Source: OECD, June 2010
  • 25.
    Investment is happening Samsung GALAXY Tab HTC EVO
  • 26.
    But will webe nickel & dimed? $ $ RSS News $ Music $ Shopping $ Social networking $ Games
  • 27.
    Issue #4 Should the government be involved in regulating the Internet at all?
  • 28.
    Regulation and innovation Television Highly regulated Radio Highly regulated Film Self-regulated Print Lightly-regulated Internet Lightly-regulated
  • 29.
    Is Internet sufficientlycompetitive? Your broadband choices in Coos County. If you're fortunate enough to have them.
  • 30.
    The gist: How contentis treated on the Web will affect what services are available in the future, how they're accessed, and the quality of the network on which they're delivered,
  • 31.
    Questions? View this presentation on slideshare: http://www.slideshare.net/nbpl/net-neutrality-6478880 This presentation was made using open source software. Fedora Linux OpenOffice Chromium GIMP Shutter Android Operating system Impress Web browser Image editor Screenshot utility Mobile operating Presentation program system