HOW SUCCESSFUL IS
THE COMBINATION OF
YOUR MAIN AND
ANCILLARY TEXT?
VICKIE HOYLE
THE BRIEF THAT WE CHOSE
A promotion package for the release of
an album, to include a music promo video,
together with two of the following three
options:
 a website homepage for the band
 a cover for its release as part of a digipak
(CD/DVD package);
 a magazine advertisement for the digipak
(CD/DVD package).
THE MAGAZINE
ADVERTISEMENT:RESEARCH
For the magazine advertisement research I
decided to look at previous magazine posters
created by artists from many genres, in order
to see if techniques used vary from genre to
genre.
THE MAGAZINE AD:
RESEARCH
THE MAGAZINE
AD:RESEARCH
THE MAGAZINE
AD:RESEARCH
THE DIGIPAK:RESEARCH
For the digipak research I decided, again, to look
into previous examples by artists, including
looking at examples by the band who performs
our song, Muse.
THE DIGIPAK:RESEARCH
THE DIGIPAK:RESEARCH
THE FINAL PRODUCT:MAGAZINE
AD
THE FINAL PRODUCT:
DIGIPAK
FRONT
COVER
BACK
COVER
THE FINAL PRODUCT:
DIGIPAK
LINKING THE THREE
PRODUCTS:GENRE
Although there are many versions of the song
“feeling good”, we decided to go with the
version by Muse. In this case Feeling good
fits into the rock genre and we wanted to
transpose this rock genre “look” across our
magazine and digipak. We felt that it was
important as it would allow the target
audience to easily identify it from other
genres, for example pop music products
normally feature the band/artist’s face.
AESTHETIC CONVENTIONS OF ROCK
MUSIC GENRE
To be able to do this we had to research into the
aesthetic conventions of the rock genre. These
are;
 Extremes of colour, either very dark or very
bright
 More of a focus on the band name rather
than a picture of band members
 Often an abstract/symbolic image is used
LINKING THE THREE
PRODUCTS:GENRE
THE MAGAZINE ADVERTISEMENT
The magazine advertisement uses many
aesthetic conventions of the rock genre
through colour.
As you can see the tree is filled with bright,
vibrant colours and it is set on a black
background.
The text is in white and multi-coloured
matching the reverse of the tree.
LINKING THE THREE
PRODUCTS:GENRE
THE DIGIPAK
The digipak again meets the aesthetic conventions
of the rock genre through the use of colour. We
have used the same theme as in the poster,
with the bright multi-coloured text set on a
black background.
The leaflet inside the digipak again uses this
contrast of colour, with the black background
and the bright images inside the text.
LINKING THE THREE
PRODUCTS:GENRE
THE MAIN PRODUCT
Our main product contains the song “feeling
good” and is therefore in the rock genre,
although our product doesn't contain generic
conventions of a rock music video.
LINKING THE THREE
PRODUCTS:GENRE
LINKING THE THREE
PRODUCTS:GENRE
WERE WE SUCCESSFUL IN LINKING THE PRODUCTS
THROUGH GENRE?
On one hand I believe that we were successful. This is
because all of our products met the generic aesthetic
conventions of the rock music video genre as shown
through the bright and dark colour contrast across our
products.
However, I do believe that to improve the link through
genre we should have focused more on the band, as
this is often the main focus of a rock music video.
LINKING THE THREE PRODUCTS:
PAST PRODUCTS
WERE WE SUCCESSFUL IN LINKING THE PRODUCTS
THROUGH GENRE?
In terms of mise en scene perhaps we also should have
found a darker location, although the band scene is in
black and white. Extending from this point, the band
members perhaps should have also been older,
again to match the aesthetic conventions of the rock
music genre.
LINKING THE THREE
TEXTS:LYRICS
OUR INSPIRATION
The inspiration for the tree came from the lyrics
in the song “blossom in the trees” and
“scent of the pine”.
We decided that this would be a more intriguing
and provocative way of combining the texts
for the audience.
LINKING THE THREE TEXTS:
LYRICS
WAS LINKING THROUGH THE LYRICS SUCCESSFUL?
The lyrics were a successful way of combining the three
products as it created a more profound meaning for
the audience. However, it could be argued that using a
tree from our actual music video would have been
more successful and could have been easier for the
audience to identify. Therefore linking via text for our
music video may not have been as successful and the
link was not obvious and required analysis on behalf of
the audience.
LINKING THE THREE
PRODUCTS: HOUSE STYLE
COLOUR
We decided to go with a colour scheme of
black, white and multicolour. This is
because we wanted to transpose past Muse
themes into our texts. Both the magazine
advert and the digipak contain the colour
scheme mentioned above. In our main
product however, the colour scheme is
represented to the audience
metaphorically.
LINKING THE THREE
PRODUCTS: HOUSE STYLE
COLOUR
The colour is represented metaphorically in our
main text through the use of semiotics, which
I researched into earlier. The colour black
represents the death of our male
protagonist. The use multicolour
representing the blend of emotions
represented by the mugger, who isn’t just a
hardened criminal.
TARGET AUDIENCE
All three of our texts relate to the past work of
Muse and would therefore appeal to our
target audience. Where Muse used bright
colours in its past magazine posters and
digipaks, we followed the theme. This is
therefore successful because our target
audience would easily identify it.
TARGET AUDIENCE
CONCLUSION
To conclude I believe that there are a number of
ways the combination of our three texts could
have been more successful.
We should have used an image from our music
video of a tree, perhaps from the park where the
mugging occurs.
Our mise en scene could be improved by change of
setting to a darker location for the band
performance as it doesn't match the dark theme in
the ancillary products and the main production
CONCLUSION
Our casting could also be improved, both our
ancillary products fit nicely with the
conventions of the rock music video genre.
The band stands out as not fitting with the
conventions as the band members should
have been older and into their 20s.
CONCLUSION
However, there are also many ways that our
three texts are a successful combination.
There is a running colour scheme across the
three texts whether it be visually or
metaphorically.
The use of the lyrics referring to the tree and
the use of the image of a tree does add
another level of depth to the piece and create
synergy across all three texts.
CONCLUSION
The tree being used across the magazine advertisement
and the digipak will allow the audience to easily
identify the products as being connected, therefore it
will be more noticeable in shops.
We have also displayed the logo on both the magazine
advertisement and the digipak. We kept the logo very
similar to the original so again it will be easily
identifiable. However perhaps the logo should have
been shown at the beginning of our music video to
create further synergy.

question 2

  • 1.
    HOW SUCCESSFUL IS THECOMBINATION OF YOUR MAIN AND ANCILLARY TEXT? VICKIE HOYLE
  • 2.
    THE BRIEF THATWE CHOSE A promotion package for the release of an album, to include a music promo video, together with two of the following three options:  a website homepage for the band  a cover for its release as part of a digipak (CD/DVD package);  a magazine advertisement for the digipak (CD/DVD package).
  • 3.
    THE MAGAZINE ADVERTISEMENT:RESEARCH For themagazine advertisement research I decided to look at previous magazine posters created by artists from many genres, in order to see if techniques used vary from genre to genre.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
    THE DIGIPAK:RESEARCH For thedigipak research I decided, again, to look into previous examples by artists, including looking at examples by the band who performs our song, Muse.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
    LINKING THE THREE PRODUCTS:GENRE Althoughthere are many versions of the song “feeling good”, we decided to go with the version by Muse. In this case Feeling good fits into the rock genre and we wanted to transpose this rock genre “look” across our magazine and digipak. We felt that it was important as it would allow the target audience to easily identify it from other genres, for example pop music products normally feature the band/artist’s face.
  • 14.
    AESTHETIC CONVENTIONS OFROCK MUSIC GENRE To be able to do this we had to research into the aesthetic conventions of the rock genre. These are;  Extremes of colour, either very dark or very bright  More of a focus on the band name rather than a picture of band members  Often an abstract/symbolic image is used LINKING THE THREE PRODUCTS:GENRE
  • 15.
    THE MAGAZINE ADVERTISEMENT Themagazine advertisement uses many aesthetic conventions of the rock genre through colour. As you can see the tree is filled with bright, vibrant colours and it is set on a black background. The text is in white and multi-coloured matching the reverse of the tree. LINKING THE THREE PRODUCTS:GENRE
  • 16.
    THE DIGIPAK The digipakagain meets the aesthetic conventions of the rock genre through the use of colour. We have used the same theme as in the poster, with the bright multi-coloured text set on a black background. The leaflet inside the digipak again uses this contrast of colour, with the black background and the bright images inside the text. LINKING THE THREE PRODUCTS:GENRE
  • 17.
    THE MAIN PRODUCT Ourmain product contains the song “feeling good” and is therefore in the rock genre, although our product doesn't contain generic conventions of a rock music video. LINKING THE THREE PRODUCTS:GENRE
  • 18.
    LINKING THE THREE PRODUCTS:GENRE WEREWE SUCCESSFUL IN LINKING THE PRODUCTS THROUGH GENRE? On one hand I believe that we were successful. This is because all of our products met the generic aesthetic conventions of the rock music video genre as shown through the bright and dark colour contrast across our products. However, I do believe that to improve the link through genre we should have focused more on the band, as this is often the main focus of a rock music video.
  • 19.
    LINKING THE THREEPRODUCTS: PAST PRODUCTS WERE WE SUCCESSFUL IN LINKING THE PRODUCTS THROUGH GENRE? In terms of mise en scene perhaps we also should have found a darker location, although the band scene is in black and white. Extending from this point, the band members perhaps should have also been older, again to match the aesthetic conventions of the rock music genre.
  • 20.
    LINKING THE THREE TEXTS:LYRICS OURINSPIRATION The inspiration for the tree came from the lyrics in the song “blossom in the trees” and “scent of the pine”. We decided that this would be a more intriguing and provocative way of combining the texts for the audience.
  • 21.
    LINKING THE THREETEXTS: LYRICS WAS LINKING THROUGH THE LYRICS SUCCESSFUL? The lyrics were a successful way of combining the three products as it created a more profound meaning for the audience. However, it could be argued that using a tree from our actual music video would have been more successful and could have been easier for the audience to identify. Therefore linking via text for our music video may not have been as successful and the link was not obvious and required analysis on behalf of the audience.
  • 22.
    LINKING THE THREE PRODUCTS:HOUSE STYLE COLOUR We decided to go with a colour scheme of black, white and multicolour. This is because we wanted to transpose past Muse themes into our texts. Both the magazine advert and the digipak contain the colour scheme mentioned above. In our main product however, the colour scheme is represented to the audience metaphorically.
  • 23.
    LINKING THE THREE PRODUCTS:HOUSE STYLE COLOUR The colour is represented metaphorically in our main text through the use of semiotics, which I researched into earlier. The colour black represents the death of our male protagonist. The use multicolour representing the blend of emotions represented by the mugger, who isn’t just a hardened criminal.
  • 24.
    TARGET AUDIENCE All threeof our texts relate to the past work of Muse and would therefore appeal to our target audience. Where Muse used bright colours in its past magazine posters and digipaks, we followed the theme. This is therefore successful because our target audience would easily identify it.
  • 25.
  • 26.
    CONCLUSION To conclude Ibelieve that there are a number of ways the combination of our three texts could have been more successful. We should have used an image from our music video of a tree, perhaps from the park where the mugging occurs. Our mise en scene could be improved by change of setting to a darker location for the band performance as it doesn't match the dark theme in the ancillary products and the main production
  • 27.
    CONCLUSION Our casting couldalso be improved, both our ancillary products fit nicely with the conventions of the rock music video genre. The band stands out as not fitting with the conventions as the band members should have been older and into their 20s.
  • 28.
    CONCLUSION However, there arealso many ways that our three texts are a successful combination. There is a running colour scheme across the three texts whether it be visually or metaphorically. The use of the lyrics referring to the tree and the use of the image of a tree does add another level of depth to the piece and create synergy across all three texts.
  • 29.
    CONCLUSION The tree beingused across the magazine advertisement and the digipak will allow the audience to easily identify the products as being connected, therefore it will be more noticeable in shops. We have also displayed the logo on both the magazine advertisement and the digipak. We kept the logo very similar to the original so again it will be easily identifiable. However perhaps the logo should have been shown at the beginning of our music video to create further synergy.