SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Mapping the convergence of
Library/Faculty Research in the
Sciences
Molly Higgins, Jennifer DeVito, Robert Tolliver, Sally Stieglitz, &
Clara Tran
Stony Brook University Libraries
Background
Level of collaboration
between librarians and
non-library faculty
Methods
Examining
collaboration
Results: Summary
13 journals
10 years
157 articles
193 librarians
238 faculty
120 institutions
Results: ARL Status
Number of
Institutions
ARL Status
47 ARL Institutions
50 Non-ARL Institutions in the US and
Canada
23 Non-ARL Institutions outside the US
and Canada
Results: Carnegie Classification
Articles Carnegie Classification
74 Doctoral Universities – Highest Research Activity
25 Doctoral Universities – Higher Research Activity
15 Master’s Colleges and Universities – Larger Programs
11 Special Focus Four-Year: Medical Schools & Centers
5 Doctoral Universities – Moderate Research Activity
4 Special Focus Four-Year: Other Health Professions Schools
4 Baccalaureate Colleges: Arts & Sciences Focus
Results: Top Institutions
Articles Institution
10 Vanderbilt University
5 University of Tennessee
5 University of Colorado Denver
4 University of Florida
4 University of Illinois at Chicago
4 Virginia Commonwealth University
Results: Library Journals
Articles Library Journals
63 Journal of the Medical Library Association
27 Health Information and Libraries Journal
15 Medical Reference Services Quarterly
13 Issues in Science and Technology Librarianship
11 Science and Technology Libraries
Results: Library Journals Part 2
Journal Articles % of Total
Articles
Journal of the Medical Library
Association
63 11.7
Science and Technology
Libraries
11 4.8
Medical Reference Services
Quarterly
15 4.2
Issues in Science and
Technology Librarianship
13 3.6
Results: Education Journals
Articles Education Journals
8 Journal of Chemical Education
7 Journal of Nursing Education
4 American Biology Teacher
4 Journal of Engineering Education
2 Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Education
1 The Physics Teacher
1 Teaching and Learning in Medicine
0 Journal of Geoscience Education
Results: Discipline of Articles
114
15
14
8 6
Number of Articles
Health Sciences
Life Sciences
Chemistry
Other Sciences
Engineering
Results: Topics of Articles
76
30
17
10
9
6
6 3
Number of Articles
Instruction/Information Literacy
Libraries and Library Services
Information Resources
Library Users/Information Seeking
Bibliometrics and Citation Analysis
Information and Communication Technologies
Library Resources
Research and Science
Discussion
What did we
learn from this
project?
Discussion
Why do these
patterns exist?
Discussion
Why do these
patterns exist?
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25203078
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25766056
Discussion
How does this
apply to you?
Discussion
What happens
next?
Images (in order of appearance):
• Cengiz SARI
• Nathan Driskell
• Artem Kovyazin
• Berkay Sargin
All images from the Noun Project
Further Reading
Bahr, A. H., & Zemon, M. (2000). Collaborative Authorship in Journal Literature: Perspectives for
Academic Librarians Who Wish to. College & Research Libraries, 61(5), 410.
Cubberley, C. W. (1996). Tenure and Promotion for Academic Librarians. Jefferson, NC: McFarland &
Company, Inc.
Norelli, B., & Harper, T. L. (2013). Collaborative Scholarship in Academic Library Literature: Who,
What, and When. College & Undergraduate Libraries, 20(2), 173-196.
doi:10.1080/10691316.2013.789680
Rethlefsen, M. L., Farrell, A. M., Osterhaus Trzasko, L. C., & Brigham, T. J. (2015). Librarian co-
authors correlated with higher quality reported search strategies in general internal medicine
systematic reviews. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 68(6), 617-626.
doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2014.11.025
Rethlefsen, M. L., Murad, M. H., & Livingston, E. H. (2014). Engaging medical librarians to improve
the quality of review articles. JAMA, 312(10), 999-1000. doi:10.1001/jama.2014.9263
Slutsky, B., & Aytac, S. (2014). Publication Patterns of Science, Technology, and Medical Librarians:
Review of the 2008-2012 Published Research. Science & Technology Libraries, 33(4), 369-382.
doi:10.1080/0194262X.2014.952486
Walters, W. H. (2016). Faculty status of librarians at U.S. research universities. The Journal of
Academic Librarianship, 42(2), 161-171. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.acalib.2015.11.002
Questions?

More Related Content

What's hot

Peer review process
Peer review processPeer review process
Peer review process
Athanasia Benekou
 
Scientometric approaches to classification
Scientometric approaches to classificationScientometric approaches to classification
Scientometric approaches to classification
Nees Jan van Eck
 
SES3330 literature searching for research projects and systematic reviews2017
SES3330 literature searching for research projects and systematic reviews2017SES3330 literature searching for research projects and systematic reviews2017
SES3330 literature searching for research projects and systematic reviews2017
JoWilson13
 
Organisational complexity as a challenge to research assessment: a case study...
Organisational complexity as a challenge to research assessment: a case study...Organisational complexity as a challenge to research assessment: a case study...
Organisational complexity as a challenge to research assessment: a case study...
ORCID, Inc
 
Concept map of university of tokyo
Concept map of university of tokyoConcept map of university of tokyo
Concept map of university of tokyoYuji Kawai
 
Internationality of Journals: A Casestudy of LIS Journals
Internationality of Journals: A Casestudy of LIS JournalsInternationality of Journals: A Casestudy of LIS Journals
Internationality of Journals: A Casestudy of LIS JournalsVasantha Raju N
 
Supporting Bibliometrics
Supporting BibliometricsSupporting Bibliometrics
Supporting Bibliometrics
sherif user group
 
Research project
Research projectResearch project
Research project
fisicaenelramiro
 
Getting Articles -- Loansome Doc Etc.: Professional & Clinical Information Sk...
Getting Articles -- Loansome Doc Etc.: Professional & Clinical Information Sk...Getting Articles -- Loansome Doc Etc.: Professional & Clinical Information Sk...
Getting Articles -- Loansome Doc Etc.: Professional & Clinical Information Sk...
University of Michigan Taubman Health Sciences Library
 
Slide share wheretopublish2015
Slide share wheretopublish2015Slide share wheretopublish2015
Slide share wheretopublish2015
BernadetteGargan
 
Trimble 12 12-11
Trimble 12 12-11Trimble 12 12-11
Trimble 12 12-11EUintheUS
 

What's hot (12)

Peer review process
Peer review processPeer review process
Peer review process
 
Scientometric approaches to classification
Scientometric approaches to classificationScientometric approaches to classification
Scientometric approaches to classification
 
SES3330 literature searching for research projects and systematic reviews2017
SES3330 literature searching for research projects and systematic reviews2017SES3330 literature searching for research projects and systematic reviews2017
SES3330 literature searching for research projects and systematic reviews2017
 
Organisational complexity as a challenge to research assessment: a case study...
Organisational complexity as a challenge to research assessment: a case study...Organisational complexity as a challenge to research assessment: a case study...
Organisational complexity as a challenge to research assessment: a case study...
 
Concept map of university of tokyo
Concept map of university of tokyoConcept map of university of tokyo
Concept map of university of tokyo
 
Internationality of Journals: A Casestudy of LIS Journals
Internationality of Journals: A Casestudy of LIS JournalsInternationality of Journals: A Casestudy of LIS Journals
Internationality of Journals: A Casestudy of LIS Journals
 
HNRS 110 Fall 2012
HNRS 110 Fall 2012HNRS 110 Fall 2012
HNRS 110 Fall 2012
 
Supporting Bibliometrics
Supporting BibliometricsSupporting Bibliometrics
Supporting Bibliometrics
 
Research project
Research projectResearch project
Research project
 
Getting Articles -- Loansome Doc Etc.: Professional & Clinical Information Sk...
Getting Articles -- Loansome Doc Etc.: Professional & Clinical Information Sk...Getting Articles -- Loansome Doc Etc.: Professional & Clinical Information Sk...
Getting Articles -- Loansome Doc Etc.: Professional & Clinical Information Sk...
 
Slide share wheretopublish2015
Slide share wheretopublish2015Slide share wheretopublish2015
Slide share wheretopublish2015
 
Trimble 12 12-11
Trimble 12 12-11Trimble 12 12-11
Trimble 12 12-11
 

Similar to Mapping 2

Serving the Biomedical Research Community
Serving the Biomedical Research CommunityServing the Biomedical Research Community
Serving the Biomedical Research Community
Melissa Rethlefsen
 
CrossRef for Researchers & Students
CrossRef for Researchers & StudentsCrossRef for Researchers & Students
CrossRef for Researchers & Students
Carol Anne Meyer
 
Northern Collaboration Conference 2014: The development of bibliometric and c...
Northern Collaboration Conference 2014: The development of bibliometric and c...Northern Collaboration Conference 2014: The development of bibliometric and c...
Northern Collaboration Conference 2014: The development of bibliometric and c...
northerncollaboration
 
Moser and Riutta - Partnerships for Student Learning
Moser and Riutta - Partnerships for Student LearningMoser and Riutta - Partnerships for Student Learning
Moser and Riutta - Partnerships for Student Learning
oxfordcollegelibrary
 
HN313 Library Lecture Jan 26
HN313 Library Lecture Jan 26HN313 Library Lecture Jan 26
HN313 Library Lecture Jan 26
jamieduic
 
Open Access: an introduction
Open Access: an introductionOpen Access: an introduction
Open Access: an introduction
Elizabeth Yates
 
Creation, Transformation, Dissemination and Preservation: Advocating for Scho...
Creation, Transformation, Dissemination and Preservation: Advocating for Scho...Creation, Transformation, Dissemination and Preservation: Advocating for Scho...
Creation, Transformation, Dissemination and Preservation: Advocating for Scho...
NASIG
 
Charleston Conference: VIVO, libraries, and users.
Charleston Conference: VIVO, libraries, and users.Charleston Conference: VIVO, libraries, and users.
Charleston Conference: VIVO, libraries, and users.
Ellen Cramer
 
Are Health Sciences Librarians Taking the EBM Challenge?
Are Health Sciences Librarians Taking the EBM Challenge?Are Health Sciences Librarians Taking the EBM Challenge?
Are Health Sciences Librarians Taking the EBM Challenge?
Lin Wu
 
Librarian consultations: supporting student researchers in the hybrid world -...
Librarian consultations: supporting student researchers in the hybrid world -...Librarian consultations: supporting student researchers in the hybrid world -...
Librarian consultations: supporting student researchers in the hybrid world -...
IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
 
e-Books: Putting Librarians And Researchers 'In The Know'
e-Books: Putting Librarians And Researchers 'In The Know'e-Books: Putting Librarians And Researchers 'In The Know'
e-Books: Putting Librarians And Researchers 'In The Know'
tulipbiru64
 
Searching and Critiquing the EvidenceBring to mind the various.docx
Searching and Critiquing the EvidenceBring to mind the various.docxSearching and Critiquing the EvidenceBring to mind the various.docx
Searching and Critiquing the EvidenceBring to mind the various.docx
edmondpburgess27164
 
Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...
Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...
Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...
Susan Ariew, Vera Lux, & Matt Torrence
 
21st Century Research Landscape
21st Century Research Landscape21st Century Research Landscape
21st Century Research Landscape
Growth Canvas Consulting LLC
 
Publishing and impact Wageningen University IL for PhD 20141202
Publishing and impact  Wageningen University IL for PhD 20141202Publishing and impact  Wageningen University IL for PhD 20141202
Publishing and impact Wageningen University IL for PhD 20141202Hugo Besemer
 
Undergraduate Research Fundamentals: Empowering Students (March 2020)
Undergraduate Research Fundamentals: Empowering Students (March 2020)Undergraduate Research Fundamentals: Empowering Students (March 2020)
Undergraduate Research Fundamentals: Empowering Students (March 2020)
ALAeLearningSolutions
 
Research to Publication
Research to PublicationResearch to Publication
Research to Publication
Trish Groves
 
Teaching In A Tea House For Sl 9 13 07 Edited
Teaching In A Tea House For Sl 9 13 07 EditedTeaching In A Tea House For Sl 9 13 07 Edited
Teaching In A Tea House For Sl 9 13 07 Edited
Esther Grassian
 
Understanding the Twitter Usage of Science Citation Index (SCI) Journals
Understanding the Twitter Usage of Science Citation Index (SCI) JournalsUnderstanding the Twitter Usage of Science Citation Index (SCI) Journals
Understanding the Twitter Usage of Science Citation Index (SCI) Journals
Aravind Sesagiri Raamkumar
 
231109 rm-v.j.-review of literature
231109 rm-v.j.-review of literature231109 rm-v.j.-review of literature
231109 rm-v.j.-review of literatureVivek Vasan
 

Similar to Mapping 2 (20)

Serving the Biomedical Research Community
Serving the Biomedical Research CommunityServing the Biomedical Research Community
Serving the Biomedical Research Community
 
CrossRef for Researchers & Students
CrossRef for Researchers & StudentsCrossRef for Researchers & Students
CrossRef for Researchers & Students
 
Northern Collaboration Conference 2014: The development of bibliometric and c...
Northern Collaboration Conference 2014: The development of bibliometric and c...Northern Collaboration Conference 2014: The development of bibliometric and c...
Northern Collaboration Conference 2014: The development of bibliometric and c...
 
Moser and Riutta - Partnerships for Student Learning
Moser and Riutta - Partnerships for Student LearningMoser and Riutta - Partnerships for Student Learning
Moser and Riutta - Partnerships for Student Learning
 
HN313 Library Lecture Jan 26
HN313 Library Lecture Jan 26HN313 Library Lecture Jan 26
HN313 Library Lecture Jan 26
 
Open Access: an introduction
Open Access: an introductionOpen Access: an introduction
Open Access: an introduction
 
Creation, Transformation, Dissemination and Preservation: Advocating for Scho...
Creation, Transformation, Dissemination and Preservation: Advocating for Scho...Creation, Transformation, Dissemination and Preservation: Advocating for Scho...
Creation, Transformation, Dissemination and Preservation: Advocating for Scho...
 
Charleston Conference: VIVO, libraries, and users.
Charleston Conference: VIVO, libraries, and users.Charleston Conference: VIVO, libraries, and users.
Charleston Conference: VIVO, libraries, and users.
 
Are Health Sciences Librarians Taking the EBM Challenge?
Are Health Sciences Librarians Taking the EBM Challenge?Are Health Sciences Librarians Taking the EBM Challenge?
Are Health Sciences Librarians Taking the EBM Challenge?
 
Librarian consultations: supporting student researchers in the hybrid world -...
Librarian consultations: supporting student researchers in the hybrid world -...Librarian consultations: supporting student researchers in the hybrid world -...
Librarian consultations: supporting student researchers in the hybrid world -...
 
e-Books: Putting Librarians And Researchers 'In The Know'
e-Books: Putting Librarians And Researchers 'In The Know'e-Books: Putting Librarians And Researchers 'In The Know'
e-Books: Putting Librarians And Researchers 'In The Know'
 
Searching and Critiquing the EvidenceBring to mind the various.docx
Searching and Critiquing the EvidenceBring to mind the various.docxSearching and Critiquing the EvidenceBring to mind the various.docx
Searching and Critiquing the EvidenceBring to mind the various.docx
 
Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...
Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...
Proving Your Value: The Librarians’ Contribution to the Promotion and Tenure ...
 
21st Century Research Landscape
21st Century Research Landscape21st Century Research Landscape
21st Century Research Landscape
 
Publishing and impact Wageningen University IL for PhD 20141202
Publishing and impact  Wageningen University IL for PhD 20141202Publishing and impact  Wageningen University IL for PhD 20141202
Publishing and impact Wageningen University IL for PhD 20141202
 
Undergraduate Research Fundamentals: Empowering Students (March 2020)
Undergraduate Research Fundamentals: Empowering Students (March 2020)Undergraduate Research Fundamentals: Empowering Students (March 2020)
Undergraduate Research Fundamentals: Empowering Students (March 2020)
 
Research to Publication
Research to PublicationResearch to Publication
Research to Publication
 
Teaching In A Tea House For Sl 9 13 07 Edited
Teaching In A Tea House For Sl 9 13 07 EditedTeaching In A Tea House For Sl 9 13 07 Edited
Teaching In A Tea House For Sl 9 13 07 Edited
 
Understanding the Twitter Usage of Science Citation Index (SCI) Journals
Understanding the Twitter Usage of Science Citation Index (SCI) JournalsUnderstanding the Twitter Usage of Science Citation Index (SCI) Journals
Understanding the Twitter Usage of Science Citation Index (SCI) Journals
 
231109 rm-v.j.-review of literature
231109 rm-v.j.-review of literature231109 rm-v.j.-review of literature
231109 rm-v.j.-review of literature
 

Mapping 2

  • 1. Mapping the convergence of Library/Faculty Research in the Sciences Molly Higgins, Jennifer DeVito, Robert Tolliver, Sally Stieglitz, & Clara Tran Stony Brook University Libraries
  • 2.
  • 3. Background Level of collaboration between librarians and non-library faculty
  • 5. Results: Summary 13 journals 10 years 157 articles 193 librarians 238 faculty 120 institutions
  • 6. Results: ARL Status Number of Institutions ARL Status 47 ARL Institutions 50 Non-ARL Institutions in the US and Canada 23 Non-ARL Institutions outside the US and Canada
  • 7. Results: Carnegie Classification Articles Carnegie Classification 74 Doctoral Universities – Highest Research Activity 25 Doctoral Universities – Higher Research Activity 15 Master’s Colleges and Universities – Larger Programs 11 Special Focus Four-Year: Medical Schools & Centers 5 Doctoral Universities – Moderate Research Activity 4 Special Focus Four-Year: Other Health Professions Schools 4 Baccalaureate Colleges: Arts & Sciences Focus
  • 8. Results: Top Institutions Articles Institution 10 Vanderbilt University 5 University of Tennessee 5 University of Colorado Denver 4 University of Florida 4 University of Illinois at Chicago 4 Virginia Commonwealth University
  • 9. Results: Library Journals Articles Library Journals 63 Journal of the Medical Library Association 27 Health Information and Libraries Journal 15 Medical Reference Services Quarterly 13 Issues in Science and Technology Librarianship 11 Science and Technology Libraries
  • 10. Results: Library Journals Part 2 Journal Articles % of Total Articles Journal of the Medical Library Association 63 11.7 Science and Technology Libraries 11 4.8 Medical Reference Services Quarterly 15 4.2 Issues in Science and Technology Librarianship 13 3.6
  • 11. Results: Education Journals Articles Education Journals 8 Journal of Chemical Education 7 Journal of Nursing Education 4 American Biology Teacher 4 Journal of Engineering Education 2 Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Education 1 The Physics Teacher 1 Teaching and Learning in Medicine 0 Journal of Geoscience Education
  • 12. Results: Discipline of Articles 114 15 14 8 6 Number of Articles Health Sciences Life Sciences Chemistry Other Sciences Engineering
  • 13. Results: Topics of Articles 76 30 17 10 9 6 6 3 Number of Articles Instruction/Information Literacy Libraries and Library Services Information Resources Library Users/Information Seeking Bibliometrics and Citation Analysis Information and Communication Technologies Library Resources Research and Science
  • 14. Discussion What did we learn from this project?
  • 16. Discussion Why do these patterns exist? www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25203078 www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25766056
  • 19. Images (in order of appearance): • Cengiz SARI • Nathan Driskell • Artem Kovyazin • Berkay Sargin All images from the Noun Project
  • 20. Further Reading Bahr, A. H., & Zemon, M. (2000). Collaborative Authorship in Journal Literature: Perspectives for Academic Librarians Who Wish to. College & Research Libraries, 61(5), 410. Cubberley, C. W. (1996). Tenure and Promotion for Academic Librarians. Jefferson, NC: McFarland & Company, Inc. Norelli, B., & Harper, T. L. (2013). Collaborative Scholarship in Academic Library Literature: Who, What, and When. College & Undergraduate Libraries, 20(2), 173-196. doi:10.1080/10691316.2013.789680 Rethlefsen, M. L., Farrell, A. M., Osterhaus Trzasko, L. C., & Brigham, T. J. (2015). Librarian co- authors correlated with higher quality reported search strategies in general internal medicine systematic reviews. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 68(6), 617-626. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2014.11.025 Rethlefsen, M. L., Murad, M. H., & Livingston, E. H. (2014). Engaging medical librarians to improve the quality of review articles. JAMA, 312(10), 999-1000. doi:10.1001/jama.2014.9263 Slutsky, B., & Aytac, S. (2014). Publication Patterns of Science, Technology, and Medical Librarians: Review of the 2008-2012 Published Research. Science & Technology Libraries, 33(4), 369-382. doi:10.1080/0194262X.2014.952486 Walters, W. H. (2016). Faculty status of librarians at U.S. research universities. The Journal of Academic Librarianship, 42(2), 161-171. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.acalib.2015.11.002

Editor's Notes

  1. One objective of our study is to examine the level of collaboration between librarian and non-library faculty in the fields of science, technology and health sciences Between the years 2005-2014 Culture and expectation of research and collaboration yields more research and collaboration Benefits of collaboration: May result in greater chance of being published Distribution of workload Opportunity for networking and outreach Opportunity for presentation and publication, particularly important for junior librarians Increased access to grants and funding
  2. Selected group of peer-reviewed journals (science, technology and health) Science & Tech (8) and Health Sciences (5) Identified articles with multiple authors where at least one was a librarian and one a faculty member Non-librarian collaborator couldn’t be a student, tech/ed staff, LIS faculty, high school teachers, clinical faculty, NLM employees, professional researchers Collected details of publication (title, date, volume, issue), librarian author(s)’ name(s) and faculty author(s)’ names and affiliation(s) Examined notable characteristics of articles Year of collaboration Type of institution ARL affiliation Carnegie classification Number of collaborators per article Discipline/field of faculty author(s) Job title(s) and subject specialty of librarian(s) if identifiable Discipline and subject specialties of collaborative article Geographic locations of the participants’ institutions Collaborations are intra- or inter-institutional