Presentation to the Information LIteracy Spaces research team about the barriers and opportunities for librarian leadership in education in New Zealand
10. 6 Ts of Transformation
“Ongoing mutual process
where leaders and followers
inspire each other and raise
each other to high ethical and
motivational levels.”
“Transformational leaders
connect and work
collaboratively towards
higher goals.”(Burns, 1978; 1998)
12. Providing valid evidence for
Minister of Education + relevant government
departments about vital role librarians play in
student AND teacher learning outcomes
What’s next?
13. References:
Baker, S. (2016). From teacher to school librarian leader and
instructional partner: A proposed transformation framework for
educators of preservice school librarians. School Libraries
Worldwide, 22(1), 143-159
Calvert, P. (2016). School libraries in New Zealand as technology
hubs: Enablers and barriers to school librarians becoming
technology leaders. School Libraries Worldwide, 22(2), 51-62.
Clephane, S. (2014). New Zealand school librarians: Technology
leaders? School Libraries Worldwide, 20(2), 14-27.
Editor's Notes
This is a culmination of:
The last three years of working with Information Literacy Spaces
Readings for Mind Lab postgrad and now Masters of Contemporary Education
NZEI Scholarship looking at collaborative practice
Libraries mean different things to people
learning more about that now that I’m in the public sector
in education and schools though, they are often perceived ….. And they’re all about the books!
Librarian is an equally charged word where it often means different things to people.
Often, there is a misunderstanding about what a librarian does or what skills they have
Disparity in those who are either teacher aides or library technicians vs those with wide experience, training or qualifications
Library is the physical resource
Librarian is the teaching and learning resource
Often when reading about something “the library” does - when it’s actually the librarian who makes it happen
This came through in our survey responses – and they were predominantly from teachers who actually USE and VALUE libraries
My understanding about this in terms of the place of libraries in schools has been deepened and cemented
Leadership is pivotal to success, growth and sustainability
Clephane 2014 - 21st Century Learning Reference Group recommended: “school librarians could take a stronger leadership role in using digital technology to target achievement outcomes.”
The current education structure makes the NZ model of school library staffing so variable across the country
Example of Melbourne school
Calvert 2016 - enablers are: people and interpersonal relationships - institutional structures - personal considerations and commitments - intellectual and pychosocial characteristics
I would strongly argue there is.
Librarian leadership needs to be fluid, flexible, both proactive and reactive - and without a doubt – collaborative
However, librarians can be their own worst enemy – where they can be apologetic about perceived interruptions – and not prepared or not able to step up or step forward
Quote from a teacher on working with a librarian on ILS
Calvert (2016) - limited vision - lack of positive relationships with principal - not seeing themselves as leaders OUTSIDE the library - organisational place in the school (support staff) - weak position to facilitate change - current NZ situation
Barriers of time, funding and staffing - even worse in primary schools
But even with all of this fantastic work in the project - there are limitations as to how sustainable we can make these transformations without the role of librarians in education being considered and addressed
While this is an American model - it provides a framework to think about what’s important
Consistent in other T models is Tools, Teamwork, Training and Trust
The key considerations here are: that school librarian leadership is at the centre with the principal and leadership surrounding this – the other important aspect is the larger circle of context. And this is where is gets tricky. If the principal or leadership choose NOT to do this, there is nothing within MoE guidelines that prompt them to revisit this
Talking about our successes, reflecting on the work and striving TOGETHER to make it even better next time.
Sharing what makes the difference with colleagues
Highlighting it in a visible way
in department reports – ERO reports – staff meetings
staffing choices – instead of viewing a librarian leaving as a chance to save money, use it to invest in the learning of ALL students and staff
Finally - even though no longer working in schools sector - remain passionate about education - which is why I’m working towards a Masters of Contemporary Education. Invite everyone to help on the journey. senga@ilibrary.co.nz 032111773