ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
ANDITS ROLE IN SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Four essential requirement for sustainable development are
Environmental harmony,
Economic efficiency and Endogenous
choices and equity, Social justice
The achievement of sustainable development demands the
integration of environment and development. To achieve
sustainable development requires a close collaboration and
cooperation between environmentalists and the decision- makers.
3.
IMPACT ASSESSMENT
(EIA)
EIA isan activity design for the systematic
identification and evaluation of the potential impacts
(effects) of proposed projects, plans, programs, or
legislative actions relative to physical-chemical,
biological, cultural and socioeconomic components
of the total environment
EIA is a major instrument in
•
•
•
•
For appropriate Decision making
For measurement of sustainability in the context of
regional carrying capacity
Siting of new industries
Siting of urban settlements and town planning
4.
An Environmental Impact
Assessmentshould contain:
•
•
•
A determination of the initial reference state
An estimate of future state without action
An estimate of future state with action
•
•
The level of details in EIA:
The sensitivity of the local environment
The scale of proposed development and its
potential effects
• The social value placed nationally or
locally on preventing or
enhancing environmental quality
• The resources scientific expertise of the country
5.
For New ProjectEIA is necessary
• Examination of merits and demerits
of alternative sites
• Investigation of meteorological
and topographical studies
• Study on emission
• Analysis of every operation process by
HAZOP
• Analysis of availability and
suitability of land for burial of wastes
6.
What an EIAshould do:
Describe the proportions as well as alternative
•
• of the
likely
•
Estimate the nature and
magnitude environmental changes
Identify the relevant human concerns
• Define the criteria to be used in measuring the
significance of environmental changes including the
relative weighting to be assigned in comparing
different type of changes
• Estimate the significance of the predicted
environmental changes
• Make recommendation : Acceptance, remedial
action, a acceptance of one or more alternatives,
reflections
7.
- Economic andoccupational status
- Social pattern or life style
- Social amenities and relationships
- Health
- Security
- Religion and traditional belief.
- Public and private services
- Aesthetics and cultural values
AREA OF HUMAN CONCERN
8.
SCOPING AND BASELINESTUDIES
SCOPING is a process of identifying significant issues to be
considered in an EIA.
•
• Ecological Scoping : Determination of changes in the
physico-chemical biological environment.
Physical-Chemical : Water, air, noise, land
•
•
•
Biological Species and Population, habitat and communities
Aesthetic : Land, air, water, flora and fauna.
Social Scoping : It involves determination of these values
based on social and economic criteria. This involves
– Human Health and Safety
BASELINE STUDIES :
• Description of conditions existing at a point in time against
which subsequent changes can be detected through
monitoring.
9.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Preamble
ProjectDescription : Process Description, Production Capacity, Raw
Material, Description of Environment.
Scope of EIA
Methodology for EIA
Air Environment
Water
Noise
Biological
Land
Socio-economic environment
Baseline Environmental Status
Identification of Impacts
Air, water, noise, biological, land, socioeconomic environment
Prediction of Impact
Evaluation of Impact
Environmental Impact Statement
Environmental Management Plan
Post project operation
Post project monitoring
Disaster Management Plan
10.
List of ProjectsRequiring Environment Clearance from the
Central Government
•
•
•
•
• Nuclear power and related projects such as heavy water plants, nuclear
fuel complex, rare earths.
River valley projects including hydel power, major irrigation and their
combination including flood control.
Ports, harbours, airports (except minor ports and harbours).
Petroleum refineries including crude and product pipelines
Chemical fertilizers (nitrogenous and phosphatic other than single
superphosphate)
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Pesticides (Technical)
Petrochemical complexes (both olefinic and aromatic) and petro-chemical
intermediates such as DMT, Caprolactam, LAB etc. and production of basic
plastics such as LDPE, HDPE, PP, PVC.
Bulk drugs and pharmaceuticals.
Exploration for oil and gas and their production, transportation and storage
Synthetic rubber
Asbestos and asbestos products.
Hydrocyanic acid and its derivatives.
(a) Primary metallurgical industries (such as production of iron and steel,
aluminium, copper, zinc, lead an d ferro alloys).
11.
GUIDELINES FOR STATELEVEL
SCREENING
Project site should not be in conflict with existing
legislations.
Project site should not conflict with potentially
desirable land use, e.g. location on prime agricultural
land.
Project site should be compatible with supportive
capacity.
•
•
•
•
List of ProjectsRequiring Environment Clearance from the
Central Government
an elevation of more than 1000 metres with
investments of more than Rs. 5 crore.
Thermal power plants.
Mining projects (major minerals) with leases more than 5 hectares.
Highway projects
Tarred roads in Himalyas and/or forest areas.
Distilleries.
Raw skins and hides
Pulp, paper and newsprint.
Dyes
Cement
Foundaries
Electroplating.
•
16.
ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGES
Soil
Air
Water
Quality (depthstructure, fertility, degree of
salination or acidification, stability.
Quality, climatic changes
Quantity, quality, seasonability, area of man
made lakes, Extent of irrigation canal.
Biota Abundance/ scarcity of species of genetic
resource
Extent of crops ecosystem
Vegetation and forests
Diversity of species
Extent of provision of resting ground, etc.
for migration of species
Pest and disease organism
Noise Residential, shop floor, industrial
17.
Preliminary scan ofexisting
environment
Preliminary scan of
Proposed project
Select environmental
indicators
Describe environmental
setting
Project initiation
Assess adequacy of
Environmental setting
Finalize environmental setting
Evaluate impacts
Prepare environmental
Impact statement
Transfer information
To other project
Team members
Propose mitigative
measures
Descrip-
tion of
proposed
project
and
alternative
Field surveys
& sampling
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT WORK FLOW DIAGRAM
STEPS IN AIRENVIRONMENT
IMPACT ANALYSIS
Step 1: Identification of air quality impacts of proposed
Project
Step 2: Preparation of description of existing air
environment conditions
Step 3: Procurement of relevant air standards
and/or guide lines
Step 4: Impact prediction
Step 5: Assessment of impact significance
Step 6: Identification and incorporation of
mitigation measures
20.
QUALITY
Influencing elements andtheir potential effects
W i n d : directions and speed
Will the project modify the local wind behavior?
Precipitation/humidity
Will the project have an impact upon the local precipitation /humidity
pattern?
Will the project be sited in a “high risk” area?
Temperature
Will the project have an impact upon the local temperature pattern?
A i r Quality
21.
CLIMATE AND AIRQUALITY
Sub element Potential Impact(s) Required Information
Wind: directions and
speed
Will the project modify
the local wind behaviour
Wind speeds and
directions, including
unusual conditions.
Height of
structures.
Precipitation/
humidity
Will the project have an Precipitation/humidity
Temperature
impact upon the local
precipitation/humidity
pattern?
Will the project have an
impact upon the local
temperature pattern?
data including unusual
conditions-flash floods,
etc.
Temperature data,
including the extremes.
Air Quality Will the project generate
and disperse
atmospheric pollutants?
Will the project generate
any intense odours?
Estimate of atmospheric
emissions from point,
area and line sources,
fugitive emissions
22.
STEPS IN SURFACEWATER
ENVIRONMENT IMPACT ANALYSIS
Step 1: Identification of surface water quality
impacts of proposed Project
Step 2: Preparation of description of existing
surface water environment conditions
Step 3: Procurement of relevant surface water
standards and/or guide lines
Step 4: Impact prediction
Step 5: Assessment of impact significance
Step 6: Identification and incorporation of
mitigation measures
23.
AND/OR GROUNDWATER
ENVIRONMENT IMPACT
ANALYSIS
Step1: Identification of soil and/or groundwater quality
impacts of proposed Project
Step 2: Preparation of description of existing soil
and/or groundwater environment conditions
Step 3: Procurement of relevant soil and/or
groundwater water standards and/or guide lines
Step 4: Impact prediction
Step 5: Assessment of impact significance
Step 6: Identification and incorporation of
mitigation measures
24.
Sub element
WATER
Potential Impact(s)Required Information
Hydrological
balance
Will the project alter the
hydrological balance?
Ground water
regime
Will the project affect the
ground water regime, e.g. in
Sedimentation
Flooding
terms of quality, quantity,
depth/gradient of water table
and direction of flow?
Will the project induce a
major sediment influx in the
water bodies?
Will there be risk to life and
materials due to flooding?
Extent of project. Importance of
ground water in maintaining area
rivers, streams, lakes
Source of water supply; ground
conditions-permeability,
percolation, water table
Erosion potential of site soils
Direction of runoff flow, & slope
on site
Extent of project; 100-year flood
plan
25.
CONCEPTUAL APPROACH FOR
ADDRESSINGBIOLOGICAL IMPACTS
•
•
Identification of biological impact of proposed
project
Preparation of description of existing
biological
•
•
•
•
conditions and considerations enlarged or
threatened species and critical habitat, flora & fauna
species
Procurement of relevant laws, regeneration or
criteria related to impacts or condition
Impact prediction
Assessment of impact
Identification and
incorporation of
migration
measures
26.
ECOLOGY
Sub element
Species checklist
PotentialImpact(s)
Are there rare/endangered
species which require
protection? Are there any
species which are
particularly susceptible to
human activities?
Required Information
Species checklists-unusual,
rare or endangered
species; species providing
food and cover for wild
life
Productivity Will project activities
impair natural productivity?
Biogeochemical/nutrient
cycling
Will project activities
disrupt nutrient materials
flow, e.g. selective
concentration/dilution of
substances?
Extent of project
productivity of land on site
and surrounding area.
Extent of project;
disturbance of natural
communities; soils type and
erodability; annual
precipitation
27.
SOIL
Sub element PotentialImpact(s) Required Information
Erosion (wind and water)
Liquefaction
Will there be a
substantial loss of soil
due to construction
or operational
practices?
Will the project cause
Extent of site; ground
conditions; wind patterns;
slope angles; receiving
waters.
Project location; general
seismic data; evidence of
liquefaction;
Bearing capacity Loading; dead or live load
ratio; ground conditions;
Soil structure
or be exposed to
liquefaction of soils in
slopes or
foundations?
Will there be risk to
life or structures
because of sudden
failure?
Will the project
modify the properties
of impacted soils?
Site location, soil
characteristic data.
28.
ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE AREAS
RequiredInformation
Land use & land capability
Future agricultural needs
Location of project
Location of forests on or
near site
Future forestry need
Location of wet land on or
near site.
Location of abandoned,
active or planned landfill,
solid/toxic waste disposal
sites.
Sub element
Prime agricultural
land
Potential Impact(s)
Will the project be located on or
near the prime agricultural
land?
Forestry land Will the project be located on or
near forestry land?
Wet lands/ estuarine
land
Landfills, solid/toxic
Will the project impair existing
wetlands through filling, dredging,
waste discharges?
Will the project perturb
abandoned, existing or planned
landfills, solid/toxic waste disposal
sites?
29.
LAND USE ANDLAND CAPABILITY
Sub element
Land use
Potential Impact(s)
Will the project conflict
with existing or
proposed land use?
Required Information
Location of project
Land use classification
on or near site
Land capability Will the project degrade
land capability types?
Land capability
classification on or near
site
30.
ARCHAEOLOGICAL, HISTORIC AND
CULTURALELEMENTS
Sub element Potential Impact(s) Required Information
Archaeological
structures
sites
Will the project conflict with
structures and sites of
archeological interest and
value?
Will the existing and desirable
future patterns of access be
disrupted?
Location of project.
Amenity use patterns of
surrounding population
Historic/cultural
structures, sites and
areas
Will the project conflict with
structures, sites and areas of
historic/cultural interest and
values?
Knowledge of regional and
local historic/cultural sites
and patterns of visiting and
use by elements within the
surrounding population.
31.
STEPS IN NOISEENVIRONMENT
IMPACT ANALYSIS
Step 1: Identification of noise impacts of proposed
Project
Step 2: Preparation of description of existing noise
Environment conditions
Step 3: Procurement of relevant noise standards
and/or guide lines
Step 4: Impact prediction
Step 5: Assessment of impact significance
Step 6: Identification and incorporation of
mitigation measures
32.
NOISE AND VIBRATION
Subelement Potential Impact(s) Required Information
Internal noise
External noise
Will the internal noise levels
present a potential risk to
the hearing of workers?
Will the project create noise
levels which will cause
annoyance, discomfort to
nearby properties?
Estimates of external noise
levels due to
transportation
and operation at properties
in the vicinity. Existence of
noise sensitive land users
within one mile of the
development
Vibration Will the project cause
damage to structures
(natural and man-made)
Estimates of internal
vibration levels and
employee exposure
33.
Socioeconomic Impact Outlinesof the Basic
Steps in Performing Assess.
• Discussion of implications of Description of
the socioeconomic environment setting:
• Identification of the critical socioeconomic
factors:
• Identification of those socioeconomic
impacted area that Represents critical items
relative to the human Environment.
• Prediction of changes in socioeconomic
factors:
• Quantitative or
at description of
changes.
least qualitative
34.
MAJOR TYPES OFRISK ASSESSMENT AND THEIR
FOCUS
Safety Risks
Low probability, high consequence, accidents, acute (human safety focus)
Fatalaities, injuries, lost workdays
Property damage
Lost production and sales
Health Risks
High probability, low consequences, ongoing, chronic (human safety
focus)
Incremental cancer cases (all types of cancer)
Non-cancer hazards (e.g. respiratory, neurological, reproductive effects)
Ecological / Environmental Risks
Subtle changes, complex interactions, long latency, macro-impacts
(habitat/ecosystem focus)
Species abundance and diversity
Habitat and ecosystem quality
Natural resource damage (NRD)
35.
MAJOR TYPES OFRISK ASSESSMENT
AND THEIR FOCUS
Public Welfare/Goodwill Risks
Perceptions, property-value concerns, aesthetics (value focus)
Resource use restrictions (e.g., groundwater)
Nuisance odors, visibility impairment, aesthetics
Property values
Financial Risks
Business viability, liability, insurance, investment returns
(economic focus)
Insurance (costs, recoverability)
Liability (short and long-term)
Revenues (consumer franchise)
36.
Steps in arisk assessment
no yes
Define scope
Identify hazards
Identify how hazards
could be realized
Estimate consequences
if hazards were
realized
Estimate the probability that
hazards will be realized
Calculate risk
Assess the significance
of the risk
Choice of more
exhaustive
examination
MEASUREMENT OF AIRQUALITY
•
•
•
Ambient Air Quality
Measurement of Emission
Meteorological Measurement
Pollution Parameter
Dust fall
Equipment
Dust Fall Jar
High Volume Sampler,
Inertial collectors,
Suspended
Particulates
Respira
ble Dust Sampler
Lead Candle
Total Sulfur
Compounds
Sulphur Dioxide
Hydrogen Sulphide
Oxides of Nitrogen
Wind Direction
Wind Velocity
Air Sampling Kit
Air Sampling Kit
Air Sampling Kit
Recording Vane
Wind Velocity
Meter
Temperature and Humidity Whirling Psychrometer
42.
WATER QUALITY IMPACTANALYSIS
Water Quality Criteria: The level of specific concentrations of Constituents
which are expected, if not exceeded to assure the suitability of water for
specific use.
Water Quality Standards: These are legal regulations established by the states
limiting the concentration of various constituents in water.
Stream Quality Standards: Ambient water ways .
Effluent Standards: Discharge of liquid effluents into those water ways
The overall Plan for water quality survey
•Detail plan of sample collection
•Provision of laboratory analysis
•Description of the methods to be used for data
The Plan must address
•Location of sampling point
•Parameters to be analysed
•Time Schedule including time of Day, time of year and frequency
CONSERVATIVE SAMPLES: Concentration of conservative material changes
with time .e.g Chlorides, Total solids, heavy metals etc.
NONCONSERVATIVE SAMPLES: Concentration of non conservative material
do not change with time BOD, COD, Temp. etc.
43.
BIOLOGICAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTANALYSIS
( VEGETATION AND WILD LIFE IMPACT ANALYSIS)
Environment: complex interaction of many factors and change in one aspect of environment
will affect changes of entire system. Vegetation and wild life are important features of the
environment
NATURAL ENVIRONMENT
topography, soil ,
minerals, geological,
shtantum
Physical non living Biotic (biological)
(abiotic)
Energy, water, air, Living (plants &
animal), Flora, Fauna
Flora: Trees, shrubs, grass, crops, micro floras, aquatic plant, enlarged
species, barriers.
Fauna: Birds, land animals, fish, shell fish, benthic organism, insects, micro
fauna, enlarged species.
IMPACT:
Direct Impact: Those that destroy, displace adversely affects plants and
animals.
Indirect Impact: Those that destroy or disrupt habitat, ecosystem or other
physical and biological facts upon which a species depends.
44.
•LCA is anapproach for assessing the
environmental impact of any project and provides a
frame work, approach and methods for identifying
and evaluating environmental burdens associated
with life cycle of the material which is from cradle-
to- grave.
•Life
cycle
assessment is both a concept and
for evaluating the environmental
methodology
performance
of a product process or
activity
through its entire existence from raw material
acquisition to ultimate disposal through recycling ,
incineration , land filling or composting
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT
45.
ISO 14040 LifeCycle Assessment,
Principles and framework
Life cycle assessment framework
Goal
and scope
definition
Inventory
analysis
Impact
assessment
Inter-
pretation
Direct applications:
- Product development
and improvement
- Strategic planning
- Public policy making
- Marketing
- Other
46.
COMPARISION OF EIAAND LCA
Various authors have stated that Environmental Impact
Assessment (EIA) differs fundamentally from product Life
Cycle Assessment (LCA) (Arnold Tukker, 2000).
EIA is often regarded as a synonym for a local, point-source
oriented evaluation of environmental impacts, which takes
into account time-related aspects, the specific local
geographic situation.
This approach is often regarded as contradictory to the one
adopted in LCA, with its emphasis on a time and Location-
independent assessment of potential impacts in relation to
an entire production system .
47.
ASSESSMENT AND CHOICEOF SYSTEM BOUNDARIES
IN EIA
EIAs concentrate on the possible environmental
effects of a project, typically an industrial plant.
48.
IMPACT ASSESSMENT ANDSYSTEM CHOICE IN
LCA
LCA is an environmental management tool for assessing all
(potential) environmental impacts related to the fulfillment of a
product’s function over its whole life cycle.
49.
LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT(LCA)
•Life Cycle Assessment establishes a link between the
environmental impact, operation and economics of the
process.
PHASES OF LCA
LCA RESULTS ANDIMPACTED
AREA
Impacted Category
Final Results
Normalised LCIA Results
Global Warming
Ozone Depletion
Global
Global
Resource Depletion
Photochemical Smog
Acidification
Human Health
Global
Regional
Regional
Regional
Terrestrial Toxicity Local
Aquatic Toxicity Local
Land Use
Local
53.
EMISSIONS TRADING
•Emissions tradinginvolves a system in which excess quotas for CO2 emissions are
traded among companies.
•Emission permits represent ‘rights to emit’ and these rights can be
produced by some party abating more than it is required to do, or
undertaking some abatement when not required to do so.
EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EUETS)
•Any person or company can register to trade.
•Allocation allowances will be ‘traded’
•Allowances equal to emissions for the previous year are allocated and
then surrendered the following year.
•When performance is better than allowances can be traded.
•With a below performance allowances need to be purchased. When
performance is better than allowances can be traded.
•With a below performance allowances need to be purchased
•By abating more, the lower cost region creates ‘rights to emit,’
or emission permits, which it can sell to the higher cost region.
54.
• Convention wasadopted at the United Nations Headquarters, New
York on the 9 May 1992
• It was open for signature at the Rio de Janeiro from 4 to 14 June
1992, and thereafter at the United Nations Headquarters, New York,
from 20 June 1992 to 19 June 1993. By that date the Convention had
received 166 signatures.
• The Convention entered into force on 21 March 1994.
• It contains information concerning dates of signature and ratification
received from the Secretary-General of the United Nations, as
Depository of the Convention as at 29 May 1997. The dates in the
column entitled "date of ratification" are those of the receipt of the
instrument of ratification (R), acceptance (At), approval (Ap)
or accession
(Ac).
KYOTO PROTOCOL TO THE UNITED NATIONS
FRAMEWORK CONVENTION ON CLIMATE CHANGE
55.
CONCLUSION
• HUMAN ACTIVITIESARE HAVING AN
INCREASING IMPACT ON INTEGRITY
OF ECOSYSTEMS THAT PROVIDE
ESSENTIAL RESOURCES AND
SERVICES FOR HUMAN WELL-BEING
AND ECONOMIC ACTIVITIES THE
CURRENT TREND IN NATURAL
RESOURCE DEGRADATION MUST BE
REVERSED AS SOON AS POSSIBLE.