Learning with shared Videos

  Recent findings on usage, production and
publication of online videos and implications for
                 at-risk learners

                                          Klaus Rummler
                                     University of Bremen

                                London, 12 January 2012
                            London Metropolitan University
Adolescents use Video
Adolescents have access to Cameras
Mobiles with Cam




Compact Cam


Camcorder


DSLR

System-Cam
Framework „draufhaber.tv“
    The online video community for young learners
●   «Draufhaber»: he/she’s got it; having a dab hand at something


●   Aimed at learners at the transition
    from school to vocational education.
●   Share resources, present skills & expertises,
●   Shoot and edit videos:
    ●   Show mastery of skills and crafting (performance videos),
    ●   Explain them to others (instructional videos),
    ●   Tools for video editing and annotating (create re-mixes).
Research question

 What meaning do online video platforms like
  YouTube and their archived, shared and user-
   generated videos have for the formal and
informal learning of adolescents and especially
              for at-risk learners?
At-Risk learners in Europe
●   Consider at-risk learners as a lifestyle segment
    characterised by passively facing risks and
    actively risky behaviour
●   Risk groups identified by PISA studies (= boys,
    migration backgrouds)
●   NEET & NET
    (Not in Education, Employment or Training)
●   Marginalised groups, digital divide, socio-
    economic inequality, ...
Specific for At-Risk learners
Patterns of media usage – Opportunities for Media Education
Survey on online-videos
Bremen survey on usage, production and publication of online-videos
●   Half standardised paper based questionnaire, 30 items
●   n=249:
    ●   Year 8: general public schools in Bremen (ISCED 2B)
        Real-und Hauptschule, Gesamtschule, Oberschule
    ●   Years 10, 12 & 13 public grammar schools in Bremen (ISCED 3A)
        Gymnasien
●   Embedded in workshops on video production
●   Dimensions: video platforms, contents of videos, production of
    videos, learning with videos, sharing of videos
Theories on learning with videos
●   Observational learning (see Bruner)
●   Learning by reflection and analysis
    (e.g. Roy Pea)
●   Learning by designing and teaching
    (see Martin; Papert; Kafai)

●   Collaborative learning, mobile learning, learning
    in social and networked communities,...
Bloom's Revised Digital Taxonomy
Structure of the Results
●   Reception
    ●   Video platforms and preferred genres of platforms
    ●   Video genres & learning activities
●   Production & editing of videos
    ●   How do adolescents take videos?
    ●   What do adolescents film?
●   Publication & sharing
    ●   Where do adolescents publish?
    ●   Explanations for non-usage.
Bloom's Revised Digital Taxonomy
2. Production


3. Sharing,

Commenting,

(Editing)



1. Reception
Preferred video platforms



50 platforms

 n=71 (31%)
     →
83 accounts
Preferred platform genres
  Video platforms by genres besides the
type of YouTube. Keyword „Videos“ deleted
Preferred contents
Preferred videos for learning - by genres (Part 1)
●   Sports videos
    ●football, horse riding, dancing, fitness,
     skating, martial arts, wakeboard, pen
     spinning,...
●   Making music
    ● piano, keyboard, guitarre, notations, lyrics,...
●   Styling and fashion
    ●   beauty, make-up, hair styles and styling,...
Preferred videos for learning - by genres (Part 2)
●   Life practice (coping with everyday challenges)
    ●   Documentations and magazines: similar to TV,
        reality-formats
    ●   Games / eSports: Walktrouths, “Glitches”,
        Gameplay
    ●   Computer: Tricks, Tutorials, Screencasts
    ●   Cooking: Pizzatricks, cocktails, recipies
    ●   Help videos: Knots videos, origami, magical tricks,
        rolling cigarettes, doing a tie, doing shoe laces,
        repair guides, ...
Preferred videos for learning - by genres (Part 3)
●   Social learning:
    ●   “that it's about trust, when you're in love“
    ●   “that you can miss someone”


Compare with results on reception of soap operas:
Götz, M. (Hrsg.). (2002). Alles Seifenblasen? Die
 Bedeutung von Daily Soaps im Alltag von
 Jugendlichen. München: kopaed.
Preferred video genres for School learning
             Results from our Survey
●   Subjects: Biology, Physics, Economy, Politics,
    English, Geography, Chemistry and Maths
●   62% of the pupils use videos to prepare for
    exams, presentations and papers
●   Subject-matters: photosynthesis, nitrogen
    cycle, chromosomes, immunology, atom power,
    ...
Teachers encourage the use of videos for preparation

Theachers foster the bridging of Everyday-life and school
Production and Editing of videos




                             About one third
                             produce or edit
                                 videos
Publication and sharing of videos
●   Publication of videos
    ●   ca. 12 % (18 % boys; 14-19 years)
    ●   YouTube, Facebook, SchülerVZ
●   Notify each other about videos
    ●   Activity wall on online networks
    ●   Instant Messenger
    ●   Email
●   Offline _ Commonly looking at photos or
    watching videos with friends or family
Non-Usage
●   Juristical barriers, objections
    ●   „This video is not available in your country“
●   Technology
    ●   Videos do not load
    ●   Advertisements
    ●   Too many (fuzzy) results
●   Contants
    ●   Disappointment about the content
    ●   Fear about the content
    ●   Fear about the comments & results apart from the video
END

Learning with shared Videos

  • 1.
    Learning with sharedVideos Recent findings on usage, production and publication of online videos and implications for at-risk learners Klaus Rummler University of Bremen London, 12 January 2012 London Metropolitan University
  • 2.
  • 3.
    Adolescents have accessto Cameras Mobiles with Cam Compact Cam Camcorder DSLR System-Cam
  • 4.
    Framework „draufhaber.tv“ The online video community for young learners ● «Draufhaber»: he/she’s got it; having a dab hand at something ● Aimed at learners at the transition from school to vocational education. ● Share resources, present skills & expertises, ● Shoot and edit videos: ● Show mastery of skills and crafting (performance videos), ● Explain them to others (instructional videos), ● Tools for video editing and annotating (create re-mixes).
  • 5.
    Research question Whatmeaning do online video platforms like YouTube and their archived, shared and user- generated videos have for the formal and informal learning of adolescents and especially for at-risk learners?
  • 6.
    At-Risk learners inEurope ● Consider at-risk learners as a lifestyle segment characterised by passively facing risks and actively risky behaviour ● Risk groups identified by PISA studies (= boys, migration backgrouds) ● NEET & NET (Not in Education, Employment or Training) ● Marginalised groups, digital divide, socio- economic inequality, ...
  • 7.
    Specific for At-Risklearners Patterns of media usage – Opportunities for Media Education
  • 8.
    Survey on online-videos Bremensurvey on usage, production and publication of online-videos ● Half standardised paper based questionnaire, 30 items ● n=249: ● Year 8: general public schools in Bremen (ISCED 2B) Real-und Hauptschule, Gesamtschule, Oberschule ● Years 10, 12 & 13 public grammar schools in Bremen (ISCED 3A) Gymnasien ● Embedded in workshops on video production ● Dimensions: video platforms, contents of videos, production of videos, learning with videos, sharing of videos
  • 9.
    Theories on learningwith videos ● Observational learning (see Bruner) ● Learning by reflection and analysis (e.g. Roy Pea) ● Learning by designing and teaching (see Martin; Papert; Kafai) ● Collaborative learning, mobile learning, learning in social and networked communities,...
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Structure of theResults ● Reception ● Video platforms and preferred genres of platforms ● Video genres & learning activities ● Production & editing of videos ● How do adolescents take videos? ● What do adolescents film? ● Publication & sharing ● Where do adolescents publish? ● Explanations for non-usage.
  • 12.
    Bloom's Revised DigitalTaxonomy 2. Production 3. Sharing, Commenting, (Editing) 1. Reception
  • 13.
    Preferred video platforms 50platforms n=71 (31%) → 83 accounts
  • 14.
    Preferred platform genres Video platforms by genres besides the type of YouTube. Keyword „Videos“ deleted
  • 15.
  • 16.
    Preferred videos forlearning - by genres (Part 1) ● Sports videos ●football, horse riding, dancing, fitness, skating, martial arts, wakeboard, pen spinning,... ● Making music ● piano, keyboard, guitarre, notations, lyrics,... ● Styling and fashion ● beauty, make-up, hair styles and styling,...
  • 17.
    Preferred videos forlearning - by genres (Part 2) ● Life practice (coping with everyday challenges) ● Documentations and magazines: similar to TV, reality-formats ● Games / eSports: Walktrouths, “Glitches”, Gameplay ● Computer: Tricks, Tutorials, Screencasts ● Cooking: Pizzatricks, cocktails, recipies ● Help videos: Knots videos, origami, magical tricks, rolling cigarettes, doing a tie, doing shoe laces, repair guides, ...
  • 18.
    Preferred videos forlearning - by genres (Part 3) ● Social learning: ● “that it's about trust, when you're in love“ ● “that you can miss someone” Compare with results on reception of soap operas: Götz, M. (Hrsg.). (2002). Alles Seifenblasen? Die Bedeutung von Daily Soaps im Alltag von Jugendlichen. München: kopaed.
  • 19.
    Preferred video genresfor School learning Results from our Survey ● Subjects: Biology, Physics, Economy, Politics, English, Geography, Chemistry and Maths ● 62% of the pupils use videos to prepare for exams, presentations and papers ● Subject-matters: photosynthesis, nitrogen cycle, chromosomes, immunology, atom power, ...
  • 20.
    Teachers encourage theuse of videos for preparation Theachers foster the bridging of Everyday-life and school
  • 21.
    Production and Editingof videos About one third produce or edit videos
  • 22.
    Publication and sharingof videos ● Publication of videos ● ca. 12 % (18 % boys; 14-19 years) ● YouTube, Facebook, SchülerVZ ● Notify each other about videos ● Activity wall on online networks ● Instant Messenger ● Email ● Offline _ Commonly looking at photos or watching videos with friends or family
  • 23.
    Non-Usage ● Juristical barriers, objections ● „This video is not available in your country“ ● Technology ● Videos do not load ● Advertisements ● Too many (fuzzy) results ● Contants ● Disappointment about the content ● Fear about the content ● Fear about the comments & results apart from the video
  • 24.