1. “Vaginal Progesterone decreases PTB &
Neonatal Morbidity & Mortality in women w/
TWIN GESTATION & SHORT CERVIX:
an updated Meta-Analysis of Individual Patient
Data”
Roberto Romero, MD, Kypros Nicolaides, et al.
Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2017; 49: 303-314
Published online in Wiley Onlne Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com). DOI:
10.1002/UOG.17397
Presented by : Maricar G. Chua
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14. Further research is needed before any
conclusive recommendation regarding use of
vaginal progesterone in twin gestation at
midtrimester with a short cervix due to certain
limitations of the study.
There has been increasing prevalence of twin births in developed countries over the last decade
Twins are at increased risk of maternal, perinatal & infant m/m as well as long term neurodevelopmental disability
moreover its significant impact on healthcare cost & qlty of life for both parents and children.
The most serious complication of MFG is PTB. When compared to singletons the risk increases 8-9 fold.
PTB is the most important factor determining neonatal m/m and long term disability.
Births occurring b4 37th week are considered PT.
In preparation for birth, cervix thins & shortens prematurely as early as the 4-5th month of pregnancy.
A short cervix(traditionally described as CL <=2.5cm in the midtrimester) is an important RF for SPTB
& is considered the strongest & most consistent predictors of PTB in Asx women w/ singleton
Current evidence revealed that vaginal progesterone in Asx women w/ singleton who have a sonographically short CL
decreased risk of PTB & neonatal m/m.
According to a Journal published last 2012 by the same group of researchers
“Vaginal Progesterone In Women With An Asymptomatic Sonographic Short Cervix In The Midtrimester Decreases Preterm Delivery And Neonatal Morbidity: A Systematic Review And Meta-Analysis Of Individual Patient Data”
There have been very few studies re: The efficacy of vaginal progesterone in women w/ twin gestation and a short CL
in the mid trimester
Thus the objective of the paper was to update on the previous IPD-meta-analysis
on the efficacy of vag progesterone in Asx women w/ twin gestation & a sono short CL in midtrimester for preventing PTB & Neonatal m/m.
1. Internet DATA SEARCH
2. STUDY SELECTION inclusion/exclusion narrowed the search from 213 6 records
This meta analysis included 6 studies, encompassing 303 women women w/ twins, all had CL <= 25mm in mid trimester.
Of which 144 was assigned to placebo while159 was given vaginal progesterone.
Effect of vaginal progesterone on:
PTB – SIGINICANTLY LOWERED in <33wks, < 35,34,32,30 weeks
SPTB – in <33, 34 weeks
NNT = 6-12
3. Adverse perinatal outcomes slide 11
Of these 159 women rcvd vaginal progesterone and 144 rcvd placebo
Women who rcvd vaginal progesterone were 31 % less likely to deliver b4 33 weeks vs 43 % who did’nt
Vaginal progesterone significantly reduced the PTD rate before 32 wks and 34 wks
Significantly lowered neonatal death,
perinatal death,
composite neonatal m/m,
RDS,
BW<1500g,
MV use
NNT 6-8
NO Effect seen w/ NEC, IVH, ROP, Fdeath, BW<2500g, NICU Adm, neonatal sepsis
Effect on long term neurodevelopmental outcome:
no significant difference in developmental delay/performance at 4-5 yrs
with respect to death, cong malformations, growth, global health status
no detrimental effects on long term neurodevelopmental outcome
but rather a potential long term benefit related to prenatal exposure acting as a neuroprotectant for brain d/o
… an issue that deserves further investigation
Effect on adverse maternal events:
Discharge & pruritus related to intrahepatic cholestasis no significant difference
This updated IPD meta-analaysis indicates that :
Administration of vaginal progesterone to
Asx women w/ twin gestation & sonographically short Cx in the Mid trimester
Reduces risk of PTB occurring at <30 to <35 gestational weeks, Neonatal mortality & morbidity
w/o any deleterious effects on childhood neurodevelopment
This is the 1st intervention to successfully reduce both PTB and NDeath
STRENGTHS:
Use of patient level data vs study level analysis
Minimal heterogeniety
With low risk of bias
Baseline balance in prognostic factors -- ?
LIMITATIONS – most pooled effect was provided by 1 study w/ moderate risk bias THUS a MODERATE qlty GRADE
= there is some confidence that our results approach TRUE IMPACT of progesterone on PTB & adverse neonatal outcomes
-Sample size mainly obtained from just 1 study(74%)
-only 2 trials designed to assess the efficacy of vaginal progesterone on women with twin and short CL
RECOMMENDATIONS
-need further research before conclusive advice can be provided re benefits of using vaginal progesterone in twin gestation + short CL