High Tech-High Touch RPO:
What the Doctor Ordered
for Boehringer Ingelheim
SERVICE DELIVERY: SD1
Presented by: Corry Ioli and Sue Marks
About Our Presenters
Corry Ioli

Sue Marks

Executive Director of
Talent Management and Talent Acquisition

CEO

Boehringer Ingelheim
@corryioli

Pinstripe & Ochre House
@SueMarks
#TalentMindset
Today’s Agenda
•
•
•
•
•

About Boehringer Ingelheim
Business and HR Strategic Plans
BI’s Talent Solutions Journey
Driving Decisions With Data
Addressing Your Questions & Comments
Value Through Innovation
Aligning Talent Strategies
to the Strategic Plan
Boehringer Ingelheim

BI Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Ridgefield, CT
(Prescription Medicines,
Consumer Health Care,
Research & Development)

BI Vetmedica, Inc.
St. Joseph, MO
(Animal Health)

BI Fremont, Inc.
Fremont, CA
(Biopharmaceuticals)

BI Roxane, Inc.
Roxane Laboratories
Columbus, OH
(Generics and Distribution)

Ben Venue Laboratories, Inc.
Bedford Laboratories™
Bedford, OH
(Sterile Injectables)
Trust, Fairness, Development: Together with our employees,
we are creating the future of Boehringer Ingelheim
Talent management
•We foster ongoing employee development through our global talent
management approach
•Integration of Learning Agility from selection to succession

Leadership development
•Our global leadership development programs will develop leaders
who set direction, lead innovation, lead and manage change, lead
people & deliver results to ensure the sustained growth and
independence of the company
•To deliver on our talent management goals, leaders have to be
committed to developing and coaching employees and focusing on
identifying, growing and developing future leaders

Diversity and inclusion
•We believe that diversity in our workforce fosters innovation,
supports decision-making and increases our attractiveness as an
employer
•Diversity represents the differences and similarities between people,
inclusion brings together diversity to make the company better and
stronger because of each employee
BI’s Talent Solutions Journey
Overcoming Common Misperceptions
MYTH:
RPO providers are only
good at high volume
hiring solutions.
REALITY:
BI & Pinstripe created
a customized solution
equipped to deal
with complexity.
Roles in Partnership Scope
• Science: Research,
Development and Medicine
• Sales and Marketing
• Validation
• Environmental Health & Safety
• Regulatory Affairs
• Quality
• Clinical Research/Affairs
• Supply Chain/Logistics
• Sourcing/Purchasing
• PR, Governmental Affairs/
Communications

•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

Manufacturing/Production
Legal
IT
HR
Engineering/Site Services
Business
Development/Services
Administrative
Ethics and Compliance
Accounting/Finance
Consumer Health Care
BI Executive Director,
Talent Management & Acquisition (1)
BI Talent Acquisition Operations Management (3)
Pinstripe Client Service Management (2)
Enabling
Functions

Pharma/
Commercial
Model

Science –
R, D & M

Technical/
Manufacturing

BI TA
Manager

BI TA
Manager

BI TA
Manager

BI TA
Manager

Pinstripe
Recruiters
(3)

Pinstripe
Recruiters
(6)

Pinstripe
Recruiters
(7)

Pinstripe
Recruiters
(6)

Pinstripe Talent Acquisition Coordinators (12)
Pinstripe Reporting & Compliance Analyst (1)

College & Diversity Recruitment Team (Pinstripe 2)

BI (1)
MYTH:
RPO providers are
transactional vendors
chosen to cut recruitment
costs.
REALITY:
BI & Pinstripe were eager
to form a consultative
partnership.
Maturity of RPO Partnerships
MYTH:
It is the sole job of the
buyer to drive change
efforts.
REALITY:
Pinstripe brought BI
experience driving
successful change
& transitioning
between RPO providers.
Basic Transition Checklist
 Clearly define expectations of incumbent provider, new provider
and internal organization.
 Inform incumbent provider of transition.
 Create Interim Recruiting Contingency Plan.
 Host transition meeting with all parties.
 Catalog all “knowledge transfer” from incumbent.
 Take or transfer ownership of database and third-party
tools/partnerships.
 Incentivize incumbent provider to continue performing.
 Continually assess progress and adjust as necessary.
Successful Change Management
Stabilization

Expectations

Partnership Evolution

Early Stage

Performance
Rhythm

*

“Raving Fans”
Leading &
Differentiated
Solution

*

6+
Months

3-6
Months
Responsiveness &
Correction

*

0-3
Months
• Four week post-launch
correction
• Learning Curve
• Address Applicant Flow
• Hiring Manager Assimilation
• Correct Process Assumptions
• Tweak Service Delivery Model

• Achieve Productivity &
Quality of Hire SLA targets
• Technology Productivity
• Differentiated Local Marketing
& Candidate pipelining
• Continuous Improvement

• Competitive Edge for
Candidates
• Employment Brand
Differentiation
• Leading Social Media Strategy
• Beating Hiring Managers
expectations for performance
Communicate, Communicate, Communicate.
• Identify and customize communications for each
stakeholder group.
• Clearly define expectations: 30-, 60- and 90-day.
• Tap a representative sample for voice-ofcustomer sessions; satisfied, unsatisfied, active and inactive
hiring managers.

• Provide several methods for questions and
feedback, but one central internal contact.
• Include host in all communications between
providers.
• Document and share all conversations, meetings
and agreement exchanges.
MYTH:
Using an RPO provider
dilutes your employment
brand.
REALITY:
Pinstripe brought BI a
renewed focus on
Candidate & Hiring
Manager experience.
Impression Center
• Enhances BI’s employer brand in the
communities they serve.
• Augments dedicated recruitment teams.
• Creates positive candidate and hiring manager
experiences through:
• Immediate availability.
• Single call resolution.
• Unprecedented responsiveness.

• Eliminates candidate black hole.
The Impression Center

"I have done a lot of phone
interviews in the last month and
you have the best candidate
experience. You really make me
feel like I am a human being by
giving me that extra time."
Bridge Team
• Manages the gap between an accepted offer and
the candidate’s first day.
• Background checks.
• Drug screens.
• Reference checking.
• Onboarding.
• Clearly defined approach ensures compliance and
mitigates risk.
• Acts as central point of contact for all candidate,
hiring manager and vendor management.
• Ensures high-touch candidate experience.
Hiring Manager Surveys
• 707 Hiring Manager surveys sent out – August 2013
• Previous Survey November 2012 (6 months after
Pinstripe engaged)
• No previous metrics
• 58% Response rate (412)
• Improved ~ 10% from 9 months previous in every
recruitment area!
• Planning & Administration
• Execution of Recruitment Plans
• Candidate Quality & Diversity
MYTH:
RPO providers only perform
transactional recruitment.
REALITY:
Together, BI and Pinstripe
consider end-to-end Talent
Acquisition & Management.
Building the BI Brand & U.S. EVP
•
•
•

Created microsites across all business areas and the BI Cares Foundation
US EVP team focused on the “Employee Experience” : Culture, Learning
& Career Development, Total Rewards & Meaningful Work
US aligned with global EVP and Corporate Brand
Diversity Recruiting & Unconscious Bias
MYTH:
Achieving SLAs are
the only goal of an RPO
provider.
REALITY:
BI and Pinstripe are
committed to shared
leadership accountability
Transactional to Transformational
Traits of a Shared Accountability Partnership
• Moving beyond SLAs
• Complete Transparency
• Mutual Respect
• Access to Senior Leadership
MYTH:
RPO providers are tied to
specific technologies.
REALITY:
Pinstripe helped BI choose
best-in-class technologies
and implement transparent
analytics.
Talent Relationship Management
Technology Platform
Taleo Technology Implementation Results

No, 23%

ATS was easy to use
Yes, 81%

4% point increase in Satisfaction
Employee Referral Program Re-launch
Goal
Increase hires from
Employee Referrals to
decrease of costly
sources of hire and an
increase of employee
retention.
Driving Decisions With Data
Driving Diversity Though Social Recruiting

Sharing
your
Employment
Brand and
Company
Culture

Building an
Engaged
Talent
Community

Candidate
Communication
& Customer
Service
Understanding the Labor Market

Data-driven conversations around skill,
demographics and availability.
Using Predictive Indices
Oncology Launch Project
Launch
Meeting
20MAY
2013

1st Hire Date
18MAR 2013

Kick-Off Call
3DEC 2012

Position
Posted
10DEC 2012

2nd Hire Date
8APRIL 2013

Areas of Focus
•Sales experience
•College education
•Previous choice employers
•Source of hire – direct source focus
•Competitive salary – reduction in agency spend
Hiring Activity Dashboard
Year

Opens

Fills

TTF

*2012

2,797

2,840

46.7

2013

1,707

1,368

58.6

From 2012 to 2013, the following
sources of hire increased:
Direct Sourcing- 53%
Career Fairs- 40%
University Recruiting- 15%
Quality of Hire and ROI on Source of Hire
• Track new hire data annually to identify key trends in quality of
hires based on the source of the hire

Metrics include
performance and
retention rates for the
1st year and adding in
potential after the 2nd
year with the
company
What’s Next?
Talent Acquisition ABCDs
Achievements

Benefits

• Scaled and ramped as needed to support changing

• Talent Acquisition RPO Model can successfully scale
up/down…quickly!
As we continue to hire versatile talent and cross train staff,
we’ll increase depth and subject-matter expertise across
the team.
Solid partnership with TAMs – increasing engagement with
HRBPs.

volumes and priorities throughout 1st year of partnership.
Continuing to stabilize and optimize
Seeing improvements across the board with regard to
Overall solid HM feedback from 2012 Satisfaction Surveys
Successfully supported PM launches and expansions
Added key hires across the account

•
•
•
•
•
• Strong performance against agency competition. Proving

we can fill them just as fast if not faster and much cheaper.

Do Next

Concerns

• Hiring Manager “complacency”/lack of urgency
• Team retention – no flags but always on watch to
make sure we’re retaining top talent.
• Regional Challenges to identifying talent – need
more intel and targeted/customized/creative
sourcing solutions.

•
•
•
•
•
•
•

Diversity focus
Targeted recruitment plans
Enhanced communications
Hiring Manager/New Hire Surveys
Recruiter Scorecards
Establish standardized reporting
Talent Analytics Function
Continuing the Journey
Q&A
Thank You & Contact Us!
Corry Ioli
corry.ioli@boehringer-ingelheim.com
@corryioli
Sue Marks
smarks@pinstripe.com
@SueMarks

http://www.pinstripetalent.com/resources/case-studies/

High Tech-High Touch RPO: What the Doctor Ordered for Boehringer Ingelheim

  • 1.
    High Tech-High TouchRPO: What the Doctor Ordered for Boehringer Ingelheim SERVICE DELIVERY: SD1 Presented by: Corry Ioli and Sue Marks
  • 2.
    About Our Presenters CorryIoli Sue Marks Executive Director of Talent Management and Talent Acquisition CEO Boehringer Ingelheim @corryioli Pinstripe & Ochre House @SueMarks #TalentMindset
  • 3.
    Today’s Agenda • • • • • About BoehringerIngelheim Business and HR Strategic Plans BI’s Talent Solutions Journey Driving Decisions With Data Addressing Your Questions & Comments
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
    Boehringer Ingelheim BI Pharmaceuticals,Inc. Ridgefield, CT (Prescription Medicines, Consumer Health Care, Research & Development) BI Vetmedica, Inc. St. Joseph, MO (Animal Health) BI Fremont, Inc. Fremont, CA (Biopharmaceuticals) BI Roxane, Inc. Roxane Laboratories Columbus, OH (Generics and Distribution) Ben Venue Laboratories, Inc. Bedford Laboratories™ Bedford, OH (Sterile Injectables)
  • 7.
    Trust, Fairness, Development:Together with our employees, we are creating the future of Boehringer Ingelheim Talent management •We foster ongoing employee development through our global talent management approach •Integration of Learning Agility from selection to succession Leadership development •Our global leadership development programs will develop leaders who set direction, lead innovation, lead and manage change, lead people & deliver results to ensure the sustained growth and independence of the company •To deliver on our talent management goals, leaders have to be committed to developing and coaching employees and focusing on identifying, growing and developing future leaders Diversity and inclusion •We believe that diversity in our workforce fosters innovation, supports decision-making and increases our attractiveness as an employer •Diversity represents the differences and similarities between people, inclusion brings together diversity to make the company better and stronger because of each employee
  • 8.
    BI’s Talent SolutionsJourney Overcoming Common Misperceptions
  • 9.
    MYTH: RPO providers areonly good at high volume hiring solutions.
  • 10.
    REALITY: BI & Pinstripecreated a customized solution equipped to deal with complexity.
  • 11.
    Roles in PartnershipScope • Science: Research, Development and Medicine • Sales and Marketing • Validation • Environmental Health & Safety • Regulatory Affairs • Quality • Clinical Research/Affairs • Supply Chain/Logistics • Sourcing/Purchasing • PR, Governmental Affairs/ Communications • • • • • • • • • • Manufacturing/Production Legal IT HR Engineering/Site Services Business Development/Services Administrative Ethics and Compliance Accounting/Finance Consumer Health Care
  • 12.
    BI Executive Director, TalentManagement & Acquisition (1) BI Talent Acquisition Operations Management (3) Pinstripe Client Service Management (2) Enabling Functions Pharma/ Commercial Model Science – R, D & M Technical/ Manufacturing BI TA Manager BI TA Manager BI TA Manager BI TA Manager Pinstripe Recruiters (3) Pinstripe Recruiters (6) Pinstripe Recruiters (7) Pinstripe Recruiters (6) Pinstripe Talent Acquisition Coordinators (12) Pinstripe Reporting & Compliance Analyst (1) College & Diversity Recruitment Team (Pinstripe 2) BI (1)
  • 13.
    MYTH: RPO providers are transactionalvendors chosen to cut recruitment costs.
  • 14.
    REALITY: BI & Pinstripewere eager to form a consultative partnership.
  • 15.
    Maturity of RPOPartnerships
  • 16.
    MYTH: It is thesole job of the buyer to drive change efforts.
  • 17.
    REALITY: Pinstripe brought BI experiencedriving successful change & transitioning between RPO providers.
  • 18.
    Basic Transition Checklist Clearly define expectations of incumbent provider, new provider and internal organization.  Inform incumbent provider of transition.  Create Interim Recruiting Contingency Plan.  Host transition meeting with all parties.  Catalog all “knowledge transfer” from incumbent.  Take or transfer ownership of database and third-party tools/partnerships.  Incentivize incumbent provider to continue performing.  Continually assess progress and adjust as necessary.
  • 19.
    Successful Change Management Stabilization Expectations PartnershipEvolution Early Stage Performance Rhythm * “Raving Fans” Leading & Differentiated Solution * 6+ Months 3-6 Months Responsiveness & Correction * 0-3 Months • Four week post-launch correction • Learning Curve • Address Applicant Flow • Hiring Manager Assimilation • Correct Process Assumptions • Tweak Service Delivery Model • Achieve Productivity & Quality of Hire SLA targets • Technology Productivity • Differentiated Local Marketing & Candidate pipelining • Continuous Improvement • Competitive Edge for Candidates • Employment Brand Differentiation • Leading Social Media Strategy • Beating Hiring Managers expectations for performance
  • 20.
    Communicate, Communicate, Communicate. •Identify and customize communications for each stakeholder group. • Clearly define expectations: 30-, 60- and 90-day. • Tap a representative sample for voice-ofcustomer sessions; satisfied, unsatisfied, active and inactive hiring managers. • Provide several methods for questions and feedback, but one central internal contact. • Include host in all communications between providers. • Document and share all conversations, meetings and agreement exchanges.
  • 21.
    MYTH: Using an RPOprovider dilutes your employment brand.
  • 22.
    REALITY: Pinstripe brought BIa renewed focus on Candidate & Hiring Manager experience.
  • 23.
    Impression Center • EnhancesBI’s employer brand in the communities they serve. • Augments dedicated recruitment teams. • Creates positive candidate and hiring manager experiences through: • Immediate availability. • Single call resolution. • Unprecedented responsiveness. • Eliminates candidate black hole.
  • 24.
    The Impression Center "Ihave done a lot of phone interviews in the last month and you have the best candidate experience. You really make me feel like I am a human being by giving me that extra time."
  • 25.
    Bridge Team • Managesthe gap between an accepted offer and the candidate’s first day. • Background checks. • Drug screens. • Reference checking. • Onboarding. • Clearly defined approach ensures compliance and mitigates risk. • Acts as central point of contact for all candidate, hiring manager and vendor management. • Ensures high-touch candidate experience.
  • 26.
    Hiring Manager Surveys •707 Hiring Manager surveys sent out – August 2013 • Previous Survey November 2012 (6 months after Pinstripe engaged) • No previous metrics • 58% Response rate (412) • Improved ~ 10% from 9 months previous in every recruitment area! • Planning & Administration • Execution of Recruitment Plans • Candidate Quality & Diversity
  • 27.
    MYTH: RPO providers onlyperform transactional recruitment.
  • 28.
    REALITY: Together, BI andPinstripe consider end-to-end Talent Acquisition & Management.
  • 29.
    Building the BIBrand & U.S. EVP • • • Created microsites across all business areas and the BI Cares Foundation US EVP team focused on the “Employee Experience” : Culture, Learning & Career Development, Total Rewards & Meaningful Work US aligned with global EVP and Corporate Brand
  • 30.
    Diversity Recruiting &Unconscious Bias
  • 31.
    MYTH: Achieving SLAs are theonly goal of an RPO provider.
  • 32.
    REALITY: BI and Pinstripeare committed to shared leadership accountability
  • 33.
    Transactional to Transformational Traitsof a Shared Accountability Partnership • Moving beyond SLAs • Complete Transparency • Mutual Respect • Access to Senior Leadership
  • 34.
    MYTH: RPO providers aretied to specific technologies.
  • 35.
    REALITY: Pinstripe helped BIchoose best-in-class technologies and implement transparent analytics.
  • 36.
  • 37.
    Taleo Technology ImplementationResults No, 23% ATS was easy to use Yes, 81% 4% point increase in Satisfaction
  • 38.
    Employee Referral ProgramRe-launch Goal Increase hires from Employee Referrals to decrease of costly sources of hire and an increase of employee retention.
  • 39.
  • 40.
    Driving Diversity ThoughSocial Recruiting Sharing your Employment Brand and Company Culture Building an Engaged Talent Community Candidate Communication & Customer Service
  • 41.
    Understanding the LaborMarket Data-driven conversations around skill, demographics and availability.
  • 42.
  • 43.
    Oncology Launch Project Launch Meeting 20MAY 2013 1stHire Date 18MAR 2013 Kick-Off Call 3DEC 2012 Position Posted 10DEC 2012 2nd Hire Date 8APRIL 2013 Areas of Focus •Sales experience •College education •Previous choice employers •Source of hire – direct source focus •Competitive salary – reduction in agency spend
  • 44.
    Hiring Activity Dashboard Year Opens Fills TTF *2012 2,797 2,840 46.7 2013 1,707 1,368 58.6 From2012 to 2013, the following sources of hire increased: Direct Sourcing- 53% Career Fairs- 40% University Recruiting- 15%
  • 45.
    Quality of Hireand ROI on Source of Hire • Track new hire data annually to identify key trends in quality of hires based on the source of the hire Metrics include performance and retention rates for the 1st year and adding in potential after the 2nd year with the company
  • 46.
  • 47.
    Talent Acquisition ABCDs Achievements Benefits •Scaled and ramped as needed to support changing • Talent Acquisition RPO Model can successfully scale up/down…quickly! As we continue to hire versatile talent and cross train staff, we’ll increase depth and subject-matter expertise across the team. Solid partnership with TAMs – increasing engagement with HRBPs. volumes and priorities throughout 1st year of partnership. Continuing to stabilize and optimize Seeing improvements across the board with regard to Overall solid HM feedback from 2012 Satisfaction Surveys Successfully supported PM launches and expansions Added key hires across the account • • • • • • Strong performance against agency competition. Proving we can fill them just as fast if not faster and much cheaper. Do Next Concerns • Hiring Manager “complacency”/lack of urgency • Team retention – no flags but always on watch to make sure we’re retaining top talent. • Regional Challenges to identifying talent – need more intel and targeted/customized/creative sourcing solutions. • • • • • • • Diversity focus Targeted recruitment plans Enhanced communications Hiring Manager/New Hire Surveys Recruiter Scorecards Establish standardized reporting Talent Analytics Function
  • 48.
  • 49.
  • 50.
    Thank You &Contact Us! Corry Ioli corry.ioli@boehringer-ingelheim.com @corryioli Sue Marks smarks@pinstripe.com @SueMarks http://www.pinstripetalent.com/resources/case-studies/