Hindawi presentation by Paul Peters at the ORCID Outreach Meeting in Oxford, May 23, 2013

1. Hindawi’s ORCID
Integration
Paul Peters
Chief Strategy Officer
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
paul.peters@hindawi.com

2. Outline
• Why We Embraced ORCID
• What We Have Done so Far
• Challenges That We Have Faced
• The Road Ahead

3. Outline
• Why We Embraced ORCID
• What We Have Done so Far
• Challenges That We Have Faced
• The Road Ahead

4. Everything We Do Is
Driven By Data

5. So We Need Reliable
Author Identifiers

6. But There Are No
Reliable Author
Identifiers

7. And There Can Be No
Reliable Author
Identifiers Without
ORCID

8. Outline
• Why We Embraced ORCID
• What We Have Done so Far
• Challenges That We Have Faced
• The Road Ahead

9. Technical Integration

14. Deposited ORCIDs
With CrossRef for
>2,000 Articles

16. Now the Hard Part

17. 10 Editorial Staff

18. We Have Contacted
~250,000 Authors,
Editors, and Reviewers

19. ~20% of These (44,000)
Researchers Have
Registered an ORCID

21. Outline
• Why We Were so Eager to Embrace ORCID
• What We Have Done so Far
• Challenges That We Have Faced
• The Road Ahead

22. Researchers Are
Reluctant to Register

23. “I do not find this a good idea for a number of reasons. First, there
is no name ambiguity problem concerning (name) and (name).”

24. “I would prefer not to have a profile with my e-mail to be shared
with commercial interests.”

25. “I really do not like such bureaucratic procedures. I must not and
shall not be obliged to write about my academic work or my
biography. If you want an example or examples of my works, you
can usually find them on the Internet.”

26. “F@&# off. Go home and f@&# yourself.”

27. Researchers Don’t
Always Understand
ORCID

28. “I remembered that I have registered for an ORCID ID for
another publisher a month ago with the ID number "0000-0002-
xxxx-xxxx". Now my question is: Must my ORCID ID for Hindawi
be the same?”

29. “It is the same because we are twins, colleagues and brothers.”

30. There Are Still Technical
Bugs

31. “I tried to register in ORCID but I am having problems in
registering. After filling all the information and when I press
register, it does not move further. It stays in the same page.”

32. “This crap shows:
Notice:
{constraints.fieldmatch}
What the hell is this?”

33. “I suppose that you are working in India where I have felt
that infrastructure of logistics and IT are very very
premature… Please contact me again when your site is ready
for international accesses.”

34. April Fool’s...

35. “I have tried to log into the webpage you described, but it is all
Greek to me, as I don't understand the language shown in the page
at all.”

36. “The link takes me to a website in German.... it looks very
suspicious please advise.”

37. “I was redirected to the following website
https://orcid.org/oauth/signin
containing Polish texts etc. (e.g. Jom't lavi am eJ? Rigeztir)
I don't think this is serious anymore. Please remove me as an
Associate Editor of your journal as soon as possible.”

38. Ensuring the Quality of
Metadata Hasn’t Been
Easy

39. ORCID
Surname
ORCID
Given Name
MTS
Surname
MTS Given
Name
G.P. Senthilkumar Senthilkumar G.P.
Renga Thavasi Thavasi Thavasi Rengathavasi
Mala
Dr Tariq
Ahmed
Mala Tariq Ahmed

40. ORCID
Surname
ORCID
Given Name
MTS
Surname
MTS Given
Name
Qin Yu Yi Shuhua
Hong Xianpei Zhang Huaige
Delogu Mauro Cotti Claudia

41. Outline
• Why We Were so Eager to Embrace ORCID
• What We Have Done so Far
• Challenges That We Have Faced
• The Road Ahead

42. Continuing to Ask Our
Authors, Editors, and
Reviewers to Register

43. Encouraging Those
With ORCIDs to Add
Profile Information

44. Linking ORCIDs With
Other Author
Identifiers

45. FundRef

46. We Have Deposited
~60 Articles with
FundRef Data, ~20 of
Which Have ORCIDs

47. ThankYou
Paul Peters
Chief Strategy Officer
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
paul.peters@hindawi.com