Team Guardian
Counter commercial UAV threats
Team Guardian
Protection against commercial off the shelf drones
Number of Stakeholders Spoken to: 15
Total Number of Stakeholders Spoken to: 97
Activities last week:
Participation in AWG Demo-Day
Prototyping sensing / classification system
Project: Countering Asymmetric Drone Activities
Military Liaisons: John and Scott
Interview dashboard
Week 7 Total to
date
Users 4 21
Buyers 5 27
Experts 6 41
Total 15 97
Major Activities During
the Trip
Fort A.P. Hill VA
1.Promoting Guardian and H4D among
majors government stakeholders in
countering UAV landscape: AWG,
REF,I2WD,CTTSO, JIDA,USMC…
2.Watching live demos of existing
systems
Guardian: Customer Discovery
Hypothesis:
• Current capability gap is automatic threat classification
• Current Radar system in FOB can do real time tracking of drones
• Current camera system in FOB can lock on a moving object and have the
capability to zoom in
Experiments:
• Mirrored our proposed API(Application Program Interface) system to five
existing contractors
• Develop classification prototype
Results:
• Add-on system is preferred than entire new system
• Automation is preferred, but need to place human in the loop
• Pivot to build a platform (Detail Later)
Actions:
• Better understand the device capability in the FOB
• Direct engineering focus on: classification / sensing + classification /
classification + countermeasure / all three
MVP Demo Video
https://youtu.be/4Gi-__dRdxo
MVP Feature 1: Classification and Threat
Analysis
Analyzing
signals from
multiple
technologies
Characteristics Action
Manufacture: 3DR Model: SA11A
Payload: camera
Last seen: 7 days ago
Warning in effects: non
Threat level: low
Keep tracking
Manufacture: DJI Model: Phantom 3
Payload: non
Last seen: 3 hours ago
Warnings in effect: popular model
Threat level: low
Keep tracking
Manufacturer: CyPhy's Model: LVL 1
Carries: unknown object
Last seen: 2 week ago
Warning in effect: known to be
possessed by local terrorists group
Threat level : High
1) Evacuate
Facility
2) Activate
counterme
asure
MVP Feature 2: Exact Real-Time
location to Assist Interception /
Countermeasure
Real time tracking
CyPhy's LVL 1
Carries: unknown object
Known to be possessed by local
terrorists - Potential Risk !
Accurate Dynamic
state tracking:
Position (x,y,z)
Speed (Vx,Vy,Vz)
Countermeasure Systems:
Laser
jammer
Kinetic solution
Proof of Concept Experiment: Camera/no
Camera Classification
Detection and Classification Module camera / no camera
Machine learning algorithm
97% accuracy
One Example of Using Guardian’s API to
Enhance Existing Systems:
● Limitations of Cyber Rifle
● Benefits of implementing our API
● Analogy to some other existing
systems in other fields
Guardian: Mission Model Canvas
Requirements Engineering
Understanding of FOB
scenarios and capability gaps
- Concept definition
System design
- System and components
engineering
- Reverse engineering on
commercial drones
- U.S. Army Asymmetric Warfare
Group
- REF
- Ground forces
- Commercial drone
manufacturers (e.g. DJI)
- Other agencies working on the
same problem:
- JIDA
- DHS
- CTTSO
- I2WD (Intelligence and
Information Warfare Directorate)
- US Marine Corps
- Other companies working on
countermeasures and detection:
- ELTA
- Skyview
- VERUS
- Battelle
- Blacksage Technologies
FOBs: (1)
● Lieutenant/Captain in
charge on FOB protection
● Private at guard tower
(front line)
● Technician in Control
Center
Air Force personnel in control
center surveilling the air space (2)
Program Manager, concept
generator, requirement writer in
U.S Army Asymmetric Warfare
Group (3)
Countermeasure
provider/manufacturer (alerting,
jamming, kinetic)
- Effective countering regardless of
specific drone
- Classify and counter
reconnaissance
- Bring drone down without crashing
- Provide modular solution to escalate
the situation proportionally to the
threat (sequential)
- Gain intelligence while mitigating
threat
- Scalability for swarms
- Low training need, easy to use
- Symmetric solution: costs of
countering is symmetric to cost of
attack
- Geolocalizing operator
Current focus: classification - identify
type of drone, payload and potential
threat:
- Autonomous
- Provides data essential for
interception / jamming
- Scalable (part of a large air-
control system)
- Provide counter-drone capabilities to FOBs within 2 years
- Provide a platform for existing and future countermeasure
- Demonstration day in Florida
(mid June)
- Modification (based on testing
results)
After initial contract:
- Limited User Assessment
- Train field operators by AWG
Fixed:
Variable
- Purchase equipment for testing including drones(DJI + Micro)
- Purchase jamming equipment and power attenuators
- Access to relevant ground
forces to define relevant
scenarios
- U.S. Army Asymmetric Warfare
Group to define relevant set of
capabilities
- Other agencies working on the
same problem
- Hardware to test
Asymmetric Warfare Group using
RDT&E (from REF): single
contract from concept to
deployment (initial funding -
maximum 2-years)
- SBIR
Military VC:
+ onpoint
+ iqt
Beneficiaries
Mission Achievement
Mission Budget/Costs
Buy-In/Support
Deployment
Value PropositionKey Activities
Key Resources
Key Partners
Value Proposition Canvas
Products & Services
- Sensor fusion
- Classification capabilities
- Threat analysis system
- Data from multiple sensing
technologies
Customer
Jobs
Provide UAV
countermeasures
(alerting, kinetic,
jamming)
- no existing localization capabilities
- no existing classification capabilities
- detection is inaccurate and unreliable
- no existing automatic threat analysis
Countermeasure Manufacturer
Gains
Pains
Gain Creators
Pain Relievers
- Accurate real-time UAV location
- Threat classification and
characterization
- Large and dynamic sensing
range
- Accurate location
- Differentiation between UAV and
other low-altitude flying objects
- API
- API for the following
features:
+ tracking target
+ target
information
+ threat analysis
Value Proposition Canvas
Products &
Services
- Countering with basic training
- Countering regardless of
specific drone
- Layered solution, countering
multiple threats posed by
commercial drones
Customer
Jobs
Protect FOB:
frontline protection
responsible on a
specific section
- Threats( Reconnaissance, weaponized,
swarms…)
- No easy way to take down next gen
UAVs
- No existing solution tailored for off-the-
shelf drone threat
Private in guard tower
Gains
Pain
s
Gain Creators
Pain Relievers
- Can react to threat with
easy to use equipment
- Can act rapidly and
efficiently
- Reduce mission irritation from
drones
- Mitigate threat
- Minimal training, easy to use
- Drone counter
measure
- Drone Classification
Value Proposition Canvas
Products &
Services -Countering without
crashing
- Highly autonomous
system
-Classification capability
- Fast reaction period
Custome
r Jobs
Protect FOB
- Surveillance
- Unresolved threat
Lieutenant/Captain
Gains
Pains
Gain Creators
Pain Relievers
- Focus on mission without worrying
about surveillance, or by spending less
time on threats posed by commercial
drones
- Capturing the drone without crashing
provides the opportunity to exploit the
drone and trace back to origin for further
mission
- Reduce mission irritation from
drones
- Mitigate threat
- Drone counter
measure
- Drone Classification
Value Proposition Canvas
Products &
Services Gain capability:
1. Countering drone without crashing
and potentially exploiting data from it
2. Scalability: countering swarm of
drones
3. Classification of drone threats
4. Solution can be deployed within 2
years
Customer
Jobs
Bridge capability gaps in
asymmetric warfare
against for US forces
- Unresolved emerging threat
Asymmetric warfare
group(Program
Manager/Concept
Generator/Requirement
Writer…)
Gains
Pain
s
Gain Creators
Pain Relievers
- Provide counter-drone
capability to US forces
-Fill in capability gaps between
current technologies
-Mitigate threat
- Drone counter measure
- Drone classification
Beneficiary Mission Achievement
Captain in FOB Increase Effectiveness of FOB
Drone Countermeasure
Technician in FOB Control Center Provide a system to identify drone
threats automatically
Countermeasure Manufacturers (Alerting,
Electronic Warfare, Kinetic)
Provide necessary information for
countermeasuring
Mission Achievement

Guardian Week 7 H4D Stanford 2016

  • 1.
  • 2.
    Team Guardian Protection againstcommercial off the shelf drones Number of Stakeholders Spoken to: 15 Total Number of Stakeholders Spoken to: 97 Activities last week: Participation in AWG Demo-Day Prototyping sensing / classification system Project: Countering Asymmetric Drone Activities Military Liaisons: John and Scott Interview dashboard Week 7 Total to date Users 4 21 Buyers 5 27 Experts 6 41 Total 15 97
  • 3.
    Major Activities During theTrip Fort A.P. Hill VA 1.Promoting Guardian and H4D among majors government stakeholders in countering UAV landscape: AWG, REF,I2WD,CTTSO, JIDA,USMC… 2.Watching live demos of existing systems
  • 4.
    Guardian: Customer Discovery Hypothesis: •Current capability gap is automatic threat classification • Current Radar system in FOB can do real time tracking of drones • Current camera system in FOB can lock on a moving object and have the capability to zoom in Experiments: • Mirrored our proposed API(Application Program Interface) system to five existing contractors • Develop classification prototype Results: • Add-on system is preferred than entire new system • Automation is preferred, but need to place human in the loop • Pivot to build a platform (Detail Later) Actions: • Better understand the device capability in the FOB • Direct engineering focus on: classification / sensing + classification / classification + countermeasure / all three
  • 5.
  • 6.
    MVP Feature 1:Classification and Threat Analysis Analyzing signals from multiple technologies Characteristics Action Manufacture: 3DR Model: SA11A Payload: camera Last seen: 7 days ago Warning in effects: non Threat level: low Keep tracking Manufacture: DJI Model: Phantom 3 Payload: non Last seen: 3 hours ago Warnings in effect: popular model Threat level: low Keep tracking Manufacturer: CyPhy's Model: LVL 1 Carries: unknown object Last seen: 2 week ago Warning in effect: known to be possessed by local terrorists group Threat level : High 1) Evacuate Facility 2) Activate counterme asure
  • 7.
    MVP Feature 2:Exact Real-Time location to Assist Interception / Countermeasure Real time tracking CyPhy's LVL 1 Carries: unknown object Known to be possessed by local terrorists - Potential Risk ! Accurate Dynamic state tracking: Position (x,y,z) Speed (Vx,Vy,Vz) Countermeasure Systems: Laser jammer Kinetic solution
  • 8.
    Proof of ConceptExperiment: Camera/no Camera Classification Detection and Classification Module camera / no camera Machine learning algorithm 97% accuracy
  • 9.
    One Example ofUsing Guardian’s API to Enhance Existing Systems: ● Limitations of Cyber Rifle ● Benefits of implementing our API ● Analogy to some other existing systems in other fields
  • 10.
    Guardian: Mission ModelCanvas Requirements Engineering Understanding of FOB scenarios and capability gaps - Concept definition System design - System and components engineering - Reverse engineering on commercial drones - U.S. Army Asymmetric Warfare Group - REF - Ground forces - Commercial drone manufacturers (e.g. DJI) - Other agencies working on the same problem: - JIDA - DHS - CTTSO - I2WD (Intelligence and Information Warfare Directorate) - US Marine Corps - Other companies working on countermeasures and detection: - ELTA - Skyview - VERUS - Battelle - Blacksage Technologies FOBs: (1) ● Lieutenant/Captain in charge on FOB protection ● Private at guard tower (front line) ● Technician in Control Center Air Force personnel in control center surveilling the air space (2) Program Manager, concept generator, requirement writer in U.S Army Asymmetric Warfare Group (3) Countermeasure provider/manufacturer (alerting, jamming, kinetic) - Effective countering regardless of specific drone - Classify and counter reconnaissance - Bring drone down without crashing - Provide modular solution to escalate the situation proportionally to the threat (sequential) - Gain intelligence while mitigating threat - Scalability for swarms - Low training need, easy to use - Symmetric solution: costs of countering is symmetric to cost of attack - Geolocalizing operator Current focus: classification - identify type of drone, payload and potential threat: - Autonomous - Provides data essential for interception / jamming - Scalable (part of a large air- control system) - Provide counter-drone capabilities to FOBs within 2 years - Provide a platform for existing and future countermeasure - Demonstration day in Florida (mid June) - Modification (based on testing results) After initial contract: - Limited User Assessment - Train field operators by AWG Fixed: Variable - Purchase equipment for testing including drones(DJI + Micro) - Purchase jamming equipment and power attenuators - Access to relevant ground forces to define relevant scenarios - U.S. Army Asymmetric Warfare Group to define relevant set of capabilities - Other agencies working on the same problem - Hardware to test Asymmetric Warfare Group using RDT&E (from REF): single contract from concept to deployment (initial funding - maximum 2-years) - SBIR Military VC: + onpoint + iqt Beneficiaries Mission Achievement Mission Budget/Costs Buy-In/Support Deployment Value PropositionKey Activities Key Resources Key Partners
  • 11.
    Value Proposition Canvas Products& Services - Sensor fusion - Classification capabilities - Threat analysis system - Data from multiple sensing technologies Customer Jobs Provide UAV countermeasures (alerting, kinetic, jamming) - no existing localization capabilities - no existing classification capabilities - detection is inaccurate and unreliable - no existing automatic threat analysis Countermeasure Manufacturer Gains Pains Gain Creators Pain Relievers - Accurate real-time UAV location - Threat classification and characterization - Large and dynamic sensing range - Accurate location - Differentiation between UAV and other low-altitude flying objects - API - API for the following features: + tracking target + target information + threat analysis
  • 12.
    Value Proposition Canvas Products& Services - Countering with basic training - Countering regardless of specific drone - Layered solution, countering multiple threats posed by commercial drones Customer Jobs Protect FOB: frontline protection responsible on a specific section - Threats( Reconnaissance, weaponized, swarms…) - No easy way to take down next gen UAVs - No existing solution tailored for off-the- shelf drone threat Private in guard tower Gains Pain s Gain Creators Pain Relievers - Can react to threat with easy to use equipment - Can act rapidly and efficiently - Reduce mission irritation from drones - Mitigate threat - Minimal training, easy to use - Drone counter measure - Drone Classification
  • 13.
    Value Proposition Canvas Products& Services -Countering without crashing - Highly autonomous system -Classification capability - Fast reaction period Custome r Jobs Protect FOB - Surveillance - Unresolved threat Lieutenant/Captain Gains Pains Gain Creators Pain Relievers - Focus on mission without worrying about surveillance, or by spending less time on threats posed by commercial drones - Capturing the drone without crashing provides the opportunity to exploit the drone and trace back to origin for further mission - Reduce mission irritation from drones - Mitigate threat - Drone counter measure - Drone Classification
  • 14.
    Value Proposition Canvas Products& Services Gain capability: 1. Countering drone without crashing and potentially exploiting data from it 2. Scalability: countering swarm of drones 3. Classification of drone threats 4. Solution can be deployed within 2 years Customer Jobs Bridge capability gaps in asymmetric warfare against for US forces - Unresolved emerging threat Asymmetric warfare group(Program Manager/Concept Generator/Requirement Writer…) Gains Pain s Gain Creators Pain Relievers - Provide counter-drone capability to US forces -Fill in capability gaps between current technologies -Mitigate threat - Drone counter measure - Drone classification
  • 15.
    Beneficiary Mission Achievement Captainin FOB Increase Effectiveness of FOB Drone Countermeasure Technician in FOB Control Center Provide a system to identify drone threats automatically Countermeasure Manufacturers (Alerting, Electronic Warfare, Kinetic) Provide necessary information for countermeasuring Mission Achievement