Sarah, feeling unimportant in her family, often escapes to the local library. There, the librarian Mr. Hushbaum warns her against reading a mysterious book called "The Always Changing Story". Defying his warning, Sarah takes the book home one night. Strange events begin occurring, and Sarah is terrified. She returns to the library begging Mr. Hushbaum to take the book back, but he refuses and sends her to an elderly woman for help. However, the elderly woman refuses to get involved due to her own traumatic past experiences with the book.