“Learning to be Relevant”
Course Recommendations for
Shivani Rao
Senior Software Engineer,
Learning Relevance, LinkedIn
Learning Relevance Team
Sachin Rajendra
Shivani Rao
Deepak Kumar
(Senior Manager)
Dhritiman Das
Mahesh JoshiKonstantin Salomatin
Ashish Bhutani
Vladislav Tcheprasov
Christopher Lloyd
(New york)
Vinayak Shukl
Fares Hedayati
India
Bay Area, CA
Gungor Polatkan
(Manager)
The Problem of Skills-gap is Real
Need for Lifelong Learning
• Learning does not stop after school.
• Students and professionals need to:
• Find a job by acquiring relevant skills
• Keep a job: Re-skilling to staying relevant in a
dynamic job market
• Grow in their career or transition to their dream
role/ job
Rise of Online Education
Research on Online
Education has also
increased in the past
few years
www.lynda.com
▪ LinkedIn acquired
Lynda.com in April
2015 to about $1.5B
▪ Subscription based
business- once you
subscribe
(monthly/yearly), all of
the content is
unlimited.
▪ LinkedIn’s mission:
Provide economic
opportunity for
everyone.
www.linkedin.com/learning
▪ In September 2016
we launched
LinkedIn Learning
for members
(consumer) and
enterprises
▪ Provide Economic
Opportunity for
everyone via
learning
Goal
• Learn about the algorithms that power
Course Recommendation Algorithms for an
Online Education platform
• Learn about new and upcoming problems in
the online education space
Cold-Start Models
Member to Course Recommendations
Used for the offline email flows
-LiL Desktop/Mobile
-Flagship Neptune/Voyager/Titan Feed
-Self/Non-Self/Public Profile
-Enterprise
Skill Affinity Based Course
Recommendations
LinkedIn Confidential ©2016 All Rights Reserved
Member to Skill Mapping
Only 30% of the members
have explicit skills in their
profile.
Use member’s inferred title and the
most distinct skills associated with it
based on member’s cohort
Coverage is doubled, +10% in Feed
Impressions, +6.2% improvement in
Feed-CTR
Course to Skill Mapping
• Only 2% of the skills
are covered by
manual tagging
• Solution: Learn a
supervised model
using the manual
tags as labels
Supervised Course to Skill Mapping
LinkedIn Confidential ©2016 All Rights Reserved
Offline Results
LinkedIn Confidential ©2016 All Rights Reserved
Human
Taxonomy
Supervised
Original
Denoised
Supervised
Recall of the high precision
human labeled positives by
the supervised models.
Improves both Feed
Impressions and CTR
by 5%.
Context
Annotations
• Trending in
your
title/industry/co
mpany/
globally
• Because of the
skill you
have/followed LinkedIn Confidential ©2016 All Rights Reserved
During Launch
Online Skill Follow Based
Recommendations
Reminder: Course Offline Recommendations
Warm-Start Models
Supervised Offline Model Training
Features
Demography
Job seeker
subscription
titles
skills
industry
Location
Author
category
CTR
Type
skills
Skill
Overlap
Impressions/
Engagement
Engagements
with similar
course
Scoring Pipeline: Generating Course
Recommendations
+10% CTR over skill-overlap based models
Collaborative Filtering
Feed Click Data
LinkedIn Learning
Engagements
Completed/ Watched
Courses
Tracking
Data
User-
Course
Matrix
• ALS
• Co-occurence Matrix
• 8% Improvement in Send to
Click Rate in Weekly Emails
• 8% Improvement in learner
engagement
Carousel Ranking
24
-70 -60 -50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40
BECAUSE YOU WATCHED
EDITORS PICKS
FEATURED LEARNINGPATHS
INFLUENCER
NEW COURSES
RECOMMENDATIONS ALL
SHORT RELEVANT
SIMILAR TO BOOKMARKED
SKILLS EXISTING
SKILLS NEW
TITLE RECOMMENDATIONS
TRENDING INDUSTRY
TRENDING TITLE
Not all carousels are created equal
Carousel Ranking Contd’
• Order the carousel based
on a member’s CTR
25
+0.6 % Improvement in
Engagement compared to
static ordering of carousels
Micro-content for Micro-learning
Why Micro-content
(or bite-sized content)?
• Serving videos to
learners led to 10.4%
increase in engagement
Just-in-time learning vs Just-in-
case learning
Ongoing Projects
• Identifying Micro-content: Stand-alone Video
classifier
• Identifying skills associated with Micro-content
Concluding Thoughts
Future of Online Education?
“I do not have any formal training for the position, but I have read
all the relevant Wikipedia articles”
Thank You
Questions?
Email: sirao@linkedin.com

Ggd talk_Shivani Rao