Alternative Forages
Allen Gahler, ANR Educator, Sandusky Co.
Gahler.2@osu.edu
Jason Hartschuh, ANR Educator, Crawford Co
Hartschuh.11@osu.edu
Garth Ruff, ANR Educator, Henry Co.
Ruff.72@osu.edu
Analysis worth the $
• Lab Dry Matter
• Crude Protein
• NDF-Lower the better, estimates intake
• NDFd30hr- Amount digested, passage rate
• Ash-Soil typically 6-8% internal samples 10%
Higher Forage Fiber Usually Reduces Feed
Intake
Forage NDF, %
IntakePotential
Grass
Alfalfa
Corn silage
What is my Feedstuff worth?
CP NDF NDFd Ash Fat
12 60 55 9 3
Mcal/kg Mcal/lb Nutrient$ valu
DEcp DEndf DEother DE ME-3X NEL-3x NEL-3x TDN per ton DM
0.62 1.15 0.87 2.33 1.91 1.26 0.57 53.0 265
The value of the sum of its parts: Energy, Protein, Fiber
Nutrient values published every other month in Buckeye Dairy News
Published in the off month in Progressive Dairyman
December values used in this presentation:
Dollar value based on SESAME prices from Dec 2019 Buckeye dairy
news (MP = 0.35, NEL =0.068, NDF = 0.117)
Livestock requirement
• Sheep-
– Maintenance DMI-1.69% TDN-57.69% CP-9.62%
– Lactating DMI-4% TDN-64.52% CP-14.84
• Beef cows (1400lbs)
– Maintenance DMI-1.7% TDN-50 CP-7.1%
– Lactating DMI-2.6% TDN-59% CP-10.6
Selecting Your Crop:Species Grazing Value Harvest Value
Annual Ryegrass Very Good Good
Barley Very Good Very Good
Oats Good Good
Rye Good Fair
Wheat Very Good Good
Sorghum-Sudangrass Very Good Excellent
Mustards Good Poor
Radish/Turnips Good Good
Rapeseed Good Fair
Berseem Clover Excellent Excellent
Cowpea Good Good
Crimson Clover Excellent Excellent
Field Pea Very Good Excellent
Hairy Vetch Good Fair
Red Clover Excellent Excellent
Subterranean Clovers Very Good Very Good
White Clover Excellent Very Good
2019 Cover Crop Forage Trials
Multi-species
1. Corn
2. Soybeans
3. Wheat
4. Rye
5. Oats
6. Sorghum
7. Pearl Millet
8. Peas
9. Teff Grass
• Planted July 2 and July 29
• Great plains no-till drill
• 50 lbs of Urea at planting
• Wheat stubble
• 1 pass with disk and
finishing tool
2019 Efields
Pg. 180
2019 Cover Crop Forage Trials
Multi-species Planting Rates – Pound per acre
1. Corn 25
2. Soybeans 90
3. Wheat 80
4. Rye 80
5. Oats 80
6. Sorghum 30
7. Pearl Millet 15
8. Peas 100
9. Teff Grass 12
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
7/1/2019
7/3/2019
7/5/2019
7/7/2019
7/9/2019
7/11/2019
7/13/2019
7/15/2019
7/17/2019
7/19/2019
7/21/2019
7/23/2019
7/25/2019
7/27/2019
7/29/2019
7/31/2019
8/2/2019
8/4/2019
8/6/2019
8/8/2019
8/10/2019
8/12/2019
8/14/2019
8/16/2019
8/18/2019
8/20/2019
8/22/2019
8/24/2019
8/26/2019
8/28/2019
8/30/2019
9/1/2019
9/3/2019
9/5/2019
9/7/2019
9/9/2019
9/11/2019
9/13/2019
9/15/2019
9/17/2019
9/19/2019
9/21/2019
9/23/2019
9/25/2019
9/27/2019
9/29/2019
Rain Fall in Fremont Ohio
Planting Harvest Precip Total precip 7/29 precip
Normal rain fall 10.2 inches total rain fall 2019 8.6
7/2 planting-6.94 inches
7/29 planting- 5.3 inches
Soybeans
Planted 7/2, 64 days Planted 7/29, 60 days
Yield 1.5 ton/ac 1.6 ton/ac
Protein 13.5% 12.6%
TDN 50.9 16.6 (ASH 46%)
Corn
Planted 7/2, 64 days Planted 7/29, 60 days
Yield 3.5 ton/ac 1.7 ton/ac
Protein 5.1% 10.3%
TDN 55.1 47.4
Wheat
Planted 7/2, 64 days Planted 7/29, 60 days
Yield 0.0 ton/ac 0.0 ton/ac
Protein n/a n/a
TDN n/a n/a
Peas
Planted 7/2, 64 days Planted 7/29, 60 days
Yield 1.2 ton/ac 0.7 ton/ac
Protein 11.2% 16.6%
TDN 33.5 45.3
Oats
Planted 7/2, 64 days Planted 7/29, 60 days
Yield 1.35 ton/ac 1.2 ton/ac
Protein 8.9% 17.2%
TDN 40.3 (Ash 16%) 42.7 (ASH 21%)
Rye
Planted 7/2, 64 days Planted 7/29, 60 days
Yield 0.0 ton/ac 0.0 ton/ac
Protein n/a n/a
TDN n/a n/a
Sorghum
Planted 7/2, 64 days Planted 7/29, 60 days
Yield 2.4 ton/ac 2.2 ton/ac
Protein 5.1% 13.7%
TDN 42.5 (ASH 15.3) 46.4 (ASH 18.5)
Pearl Millet
Planted 7/2, 64 days Planted 7/29, 60 days
Yield 0.7 ton/ac 1.6 ton/ac
Protein 6.1% 9.6%
TDN 46.9 (ASH 15.3) 43.5 (ASH 22.7)
Teff Grass
Planted 7/2, 64 days Planted 7/29, 60 days
Yield 1.15 ton/ac 1.71 ton/ac
Protein 6.9% 8.3%
TDN 39.2 34.6
Statewide Forage crop Survey
TDN
Tons/Acre Crude Protein Range
Range Average Range Average Max Min Average
Oats 0.45-1.37 0.88 6.4-26.2 15.9 55.9 40.3 50.0
Oats/Peas 0.36-0.76 0.59 21.3-23.5 22.5 62.8 59.9 61.2
Oats/Radish 0.27-1.1 0.73 11.5-16.4 13.5 57.3 52.9 54.9
Oats/Rye/Turnip 0.70-0.87 0.80 21.7-23.8 22.6 65.6 62.9 64.4
Spring Triticale 1.02-1.19 1.11 10.2-12.3 11.3 48.4 46.9 47.6
Wheat 0.80-1.11 1.51 15.2 55.8 55.8 55.8
Cereal Rye 0.33-1.09 0.66 17.6-18.3 18.0 53.0 51.9 52.4
Teff 1.15-2.49 1.93 6.6-9.6 9.0 48.4 34.6 42.8
Italian Ryegrass 0.81-0.89 0.85 11.9 11.9 53.9 52.7 53.3
Corn 1.78-14.29 7.40 5.1-10.3 6.8 63.8 47.5 57.4
Statewide Forage crop Survey
2019 eFields-Pgs. 156, 159,160-162,170-179
TDN
Tons/Acre Crude Protein Range
Range Average Range Average Max Min Average
Forage Sorghum 2.2-3.24 3.07 5.1-13.7 8.1 50.3 42.5 46.3
BMR Sorghum Sudan 1.14-4.07 1.96 6.8-10.8 9.2 53.9 48.6 51.9
Sorghum Sudan 0.99-4.6 2.50 5.2-11.7 8.1 57.6 47.9 53.0
Millet 0.56-2.57 0.94 6.1-9.6 7.5 58.7 43.5 50.8
Corn/Soybean 0.54-3.46 1.50 10.9-18.4 13.8 67.1 59.8 63.3
Soybean 1.05-3.04 1.94 12.6-28.6 24.4 65.6 16.6 56.7
Peas 0.72-1.15 1.13 11.2-16.6 14.3 55.8 33.5 44.9
12 Way Mix 0.18-0.36 0.29 12.1-28.3 17.6 62.9 42.5 53.9
Barley/Rye 0.39-0.80 0.55 16.1-1.5 17.6 60.7 59.1 60.0
Crimson Clover 0.15-0.70 0.31 15.9-23.7 20.4 69.8 62.2 66.6
Crimson Clover, Radish, Turnip 0.13-0.98 0.47 10.3-20.5 15.5 73.2 49.0 61.4
Statewide Forage crop survey
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
1800
2000
DollarsperAcre
* Values have not been corrected for DMI
**Values are on a DM Basis not AF Basis
Per Acre value to July planted forage cover crops 47-102 days of growth
All harvested in Vegetative stage
MixCool Season Winter annual Warm season
Statewide Forage crop survey
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Yield of July Planted Forage crops 47-102 days of
growth
Harvest at maximum vegetative growth
Statewide Forage crop survey
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
PercentCrudeProtienDMBasis
July Planted Forage Cover Crop 47-102 days of growth
Harvested Vegetative stage - Crude Protien
Crude Protien Sheep CP Maintenance Sheep lactating Beef Mid Gestation Beef Lactating
Statewide forage crop survey
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
TDN of July Planted forage crops harvested at 47-102 days
Nutrient requirements of Beef and Sheep
TDN Sheep Maintenance Sheep Lactation Beef Mid gestation Beef Lactation
A
A
B
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
92 46 0
TonsPerAcre
Nitrogen Rates Per Acre
Summer Annual Forage Oats Yield
Pg. 164
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
92 46 0
Nitrogen Rate
July 15th planted Oats-Crude Protein
Harvested at 45 and 60 days
45 days 60 days
B
C
A
A
A
AB
A
B
B
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
45 days 60 days
July 15th Oats harvested at 45 or 60 days
TDN
92 46 0
Mean separation N rate by only for individual harvest days
not between days
A
A
BC
AB
ABC
C
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
92T 46T 0T 92U 46U 0U
TonsperacreDry
Nitrogen Rate and Fungicide Treatment
CV=26.83
July 29th planted Oats Yield
Pg. 166
Pg. 166
B
B
A
A
C
AB
AB
AB
C
AB
CD
CD
A
AB
BC
BC
BC
B
D
CD
C
AB
D
D
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
CP NDF TDN ME
Crude protien-CV-8.8 NDF- CV-3.31 TDN- CV- 6.14 ME-3x -CV- 8.66
July 29th Oats 60 Day harvest quality
92T 46T 0T 92U 46U 0U
Pg. 166
AB
BC
C
A
C
C
215
220
225
230
235
240
245
250
255
92T 46T 0T 92U 46U 0U
Dollarspertondry
Nitrogen rate and Fungicide treatment
CV- 2.41
Nutrient Value on a dry matter basis
Oats – Planted 7/15 at 76 days
Not treated Treated with fungicide
Oats – Planted 7/15 at 76 days
Not treated Treated with fungicide
Harvest Considerations
• Primarily looking at grass crops!
• Roll creates a crushing action
• Impeller creates a stripping
action
• Impeller has greater capacity
• Impeller tends to have higher
losses
• Roll with rotary mower will
leave strips in light crops
(Limited air through rear of
machine)
Harvest Considerations
• Primarily looking at grass crops!
• Proper DM is essential: 40-55%
– 30-40% DM = Caramelization
• Make tight bales
• Wrap quickly (immediate is best)
• Use enough (~ 4 wraps of 1.5 mil plastic)
• Size bales correctly (feedout rate and moving)
• Rotate stock (plastic has limited lifespan)
Forage Storage and Preservation - Baleage
Helpful Information
OSU Extension, Sandusky County
– Allen Gahler 419-334-6340 gahler.2@osu.edu
OSU Extension, Crawford County
– Jason Hartschuh 419-562-8731
hartschuh.11@osu.edu
OSU Extension, Henry County
- Garth Ruff 419-592-0806
ruff.72@osu.edu
beef.osu.edu
Forages.osu.edu
Digitalag.osu.edu

Garth Ruff - Alternative Forages

  • 1.
    Alternative Forages Allen Gahler,ANR Educator, Sandusky Co. Gahler.2@osu.edu Jason Hartschuh, ANR Educator, Crawford Co Hartschuh.11@osu.edu Garth Ruff, ANR Educator, Henry Co. Ruff.72@osu.edu
  • 2.
    Analysis worth the$ • Lab Dry Matter • Crude Protein • NDF-Lower the better, estimates intake • NDFd30hr- Amount digested, passage rate • Ash-Soil typically 6-8% internal samples 10%
  • 3.
    Higher Forage FiberUsually Reduces Feed Intake Forage NDF, % IntakePotential Grass Alfalfa Corn silage
  • 4.
    What is myFeedstuff worth? CP NDF NDFd Ash Fat 12 60 55 9 3 Mcal/kg Mcal/lb Nutrient$ valu DEcp DEndf DEother DE ME-3X NEL-3x NEL-3x TDN per ton DM 0.62 1.15 0.87 2.33 1.91 1.26 0.57 53.0 265 The value of the sum of its parts: Energy, Protein, Fiber Nutrient values published every other month in Buckeye Dairy News Published in the off month in Progressive Dairyman December values used in this presentation: Dollar value based on SESAME prices from Dec 2019 Buckeye dairy news (MP = 0.35, NEL =0.068, NDF = 0.117)
  • 5.
    Livestock requirement • Sheep- –Maintenance DMI-1.69% TDN-57.69% CP-9.62% – Lactating DMI-4% TDN-64.52% CP-14.84 • Beef cows (1400lbs) – Maintenance DMI-1.7% TDN-50 CP-7.1% – Lactating DMI-2.6% TDN-59% CP-10.6
  • 6.
    Selecting Your Crop:SpeciesGrazing Value Harvest Value Annual Ryegrass Very Good Good Barley Very Good Very Good Oats Good Good Rye Good Fair Wheat Very Good Good Sorghum-Sudangrass Very Good Excellent Mustards Good Poor Radish/Turnips Good Good Rapeseed Good Fair Berseem Clover Excellent Excellent Cowpea Good Good Crimson Clover Excellent Excellent Field Pea Very Good Excellent Hairy Vetch Good Fair Red Clover Excellent Excellent Subterranean Clovers Very Good Very Good White Clover Excellent Very Good
  • 8.
    2019 Cover CropForage Trials Multi-species 1. Corn 2. Soybeans 3. Wheat 4. Rye 5. Oats 6. Sorghum 7. Pearl Millet 8. Peas 9. Teff Grass • Planted July 2 and July 29 • Great plains no-till drill • 50 lbs of Urea at planting • Wheat stubble • 1 pass with disk and finishing tool 2019 Efields Pg. 180
  • 9.
    2019 Cover CropForage Trials Multi-species Planting Rates – Pound per acre 1. Corn 25 2. Soybeans 90 3. Wheat 80 4. Rye 80 5. Oats 80 6. Sorghum 30 7. Pearl Millet 15 8. Peas 100 9. Teff Grass 12
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Soybeans Planted 7/2, 64days Planted 7/29, 60 days Yield 1.5 ton/ac 1.6 ton/ac Protein 13.5% 12.6% TDN 50.9 16.6 (ASH 46%)
  • 12.
    Corn Planted 7/2, 64days Planted 7/29, 60 days Yield 3.5 ton/ac 1.7 ton/ac Protein 5.1% 10.3% TDN 55.1 47.4
  • 13.
    Wheat Planted 7/2, 64days Planted 7/29, 60 days Yield 0.0 ton/ac 0.0 ton/ac Protein n/a n/a TDN n/a n/a
  • 14.
    Peas Planted 7/2, 64days Planted 7/29, 60 days Yield 1.2 ton/ac 0.7 ton/ac Protein 11.2% 16.6% TDN 33.5 45.3
  • 15.
    Oats Planted 7/2, 64days Planted 7/29, 60 days Yield 1.35 ton/ac 1.2 ton/ac Protein 8.9% 17.2% TDN 40.3 (Ash 16%) 42.7 (ASH 21%)
  • 16.
    Rye Planted 7/2, 64days Planted 7/29, 60 days Yield 0.0 ton/ac 0.0 ton/ac Protein n/a n/a TDN n/a n/a
  • 17.
    Sorghum Planted 7/2, 64days Planted 7/29, 60 days Yield 2.4 ton/ac 2.2 ton/ac Protein 5.1% 13.7% TDN 42.5 (ASH 15.3) 46.4 (ASH 18.5)
  • 18.
    Pearl Millet Planted 7/2,64 days Planted 7/29, 60 days Yield 0.7 ton/ac 1.6 ton/ac Protein 6.1% 9.6% TDN 46.9 (ASH 15.3) 43.5 (ASH 22.7)
  • 19.
    Teff Grass Planted 7/2,64 days Planted 7/29, 60 days Yield 1.15 ton/ac 1.71 ton/ac Protein 6.9% 8.3% TDN 39.2 34.6
  • 20.
    Statewide Forage cropSurvey TDN Tons/Acre Crude Protein Range Range Average Range Average Max Min Average Oats 0.45-1.37 0.88 6.4-26.2 15.9 55.9 40.3 50.0 Oats/Peas 0.36-0.76 0.59 21.3-23.5 22.5 62.8 59.9 61.2 Oats/Radish 0.27-1.1 0.73 11.5-16.4 13.5 57.3 52.9 54.9 Oats/Rye/Turnip 0.70-0.87 0.80 21.7-23.8 22.6 65.6 62.9 64.4 Spring Triticale 1.02-1.19 1.11 10.2-12.3 11.3 48.4 46.9 47.6 Wheat 0.80-1.11 1.51 15.2 55.8 55.8 55.8 Cereal Rye 0.33-1.09 0.66 17.6-18.3 18.0 53.0 51.9 52.4 Teff 1.15-2.49 1.93 6.6-9.6 9.0 48.4 34.6 42.8 Italian Ryegrass 0.81-0.89 0.85 11.9 11.9 53.9 52.7 53.3 Corn 1.78-14.29 7.40 5.1-10.3 6.8 63.8 47.5 57.4
  • 21.
    Statewide Forage cropSurvey 2019 eFields-Pgs. 156, 159,160-162,170-179 TDN Tons/Acre Crude Protein Range Range Average Range Average Max Min Average Forage Sorghum 2.2-3.24 3.07 5.1-13.7 8.1 50.3 42.5 46.3 BMR Sorghum Sudan 1.14-4.07 1.96 6.8-10.8 9.2 53.9 48.6 51.9 Sorghum Sudan 0.99-4.6 2.50 5.2-11.7 8.1 57.6 47.9 53.0 Millet 0.56-2.57 0.94 6.1-9.6 7.5 58.7 43.5 50.8 Corn/Soybean 0.54-3.46 1.50 10.9-18.4 13.8 67.1 59.8 63.3 Soybean 1.05-3.04 1.94 12.6-28.6 24.4 65.6 16.6 56.7 Peas 0.72-1.15 1.13 11.2-16.6 14.3 55.8 33.5 44.9 12 Way Mix 0.18-0.36 0.29 12.1-28.3 17.6 62.9 42.5 53.9 Barley/Rye 0.39-0.80 0.55 16.1-1.5 17.6 60.7 59.1 60.0 Crimson Clover 0.15-0.70 0.31 15.9-23.7 20.4 69.8 62.2 66.6 Crimson Clover, Radish, Turnip 0.13-0.98 0.47 10.3-20.5 15.5 73.2 49.0 61.4
  • 22.
    Statewide Forage cropsurvey 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000 DollarsperAcre * Values have not been corrected for DMI **Values are on a DM Basis not AF Basis Per Acre value to July planted forage cover crops 47-102 days of growth All harvested in Vegetative stage MixCool Season Winter annual Warm season
  • 23.
    Statewide Forage cropsurvey 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Yield of July Planted Forage crops 47-102 days of growth Harvest at maximum vegetative growth
  • 24.
    Statewide Forage cropsurvey 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 PercentCrudeProtienDMBasis July Planted Forage Cover Crop 47-102 days of growth Harvested Vegetative stage - Crude Protien Crude Protien Sheep CP Maintenance Sheep lactating Beef Mid Gestation Beef Lactating
  • 25.
    Statewide forage cropsurvey 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 TDN of July Planted forage crops harvested at 47-102 days Nutrient requirements of Beef and Sheep TDN Sheep Maintenance Sheep Lactation Beef Mid gestation Beef Lactation
  • 26.
    A A B 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 92 46 0 TonsPerAcre NitrogenRates Per Acre Summer Annual Forage Oats Yield Pg. 164
  • 27.
    0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 92 46 0 NitrogenRate July 15th planted Oats-Crude Protein Harvested at 45 and 60 days 45 days 60 days B C A
  • 28.
    A A AB A B B 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 45 days 60days July 15th Oats harvested at 45 or 60 days TDN 92 46 0 Mean separation N rate by only for individual harvest days not between days
  • 29.
    A A BC AB ABC C 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 92T 46T 0T92U 46U 0U TonsperacreDry Nitrogen Rate and Fungicide Treatment CV=26.83 July 29th planted Oats Yield Pg. 166
  • 30.
    Pg. 166 B B A A C AB AB AB C AB CD CD A AB BC BC BC B D CD C AB D D 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 CP NDFTDN ME Crude protien-CV-8.8 NDF- CV-3.31 TDN- CV- 6.14 ME-3x -CV- 8.66 July 29th Oats 60 Day harvest quality 92T 46T 0T 92U 46U 0U
  • 31.
    Pg. 166 AB BC C A C C 215 220 225 230 235 240 245 250 255 92T 46T0T 92U 46U 0U Dollarspertondry Nitrogen rate and Fungicide treatment CV- 2.41 Nutrient Value on a dry matter basis
  • 32.
    Oats – Planted7/15 at 76 days Not treated Treated with fungicide
  • 33.
    Oats – Planted7/15 at 76 days Not treated Treated with fungicide
  • 34.
    Harvest Considerations • Primarilylooking at grass crops! • Roll creates a crushing action • Impeller creates a stripping action • Impeller has greater capacity • Impeller tends to have higher losses • Roll with rotary mower will leave strips in light crops (Limited air through rear of machine)
  • 35.
    Harvest Considerations • Primarilylooking at grass crops!
  • 36.
    • Proper DMis essential: 40-55% – 30-40% DM = Caramelization • Make tight bales • Wrap quickly (immediate is best) • Use enough (~ 4 wraps of 1.5 mil plastic) • Size bales correctly (feedout rate and moving) • Rotate stock (plastic has limited lifespan) Forage Storage and Preservation - Baleage
  • 37.
    Helpful Information OSU Extension,Sandusky County – Allen Gahler 419-334-6340 gahler.2@osu.edu OSU Extension, Crawford County – Jason Hartschuh 419-562-8731 hartschuh.11@osu.edu OSU Extension, Henry County - Garth Ruff 419-592-0806 ruff.72@osu.edu beef.osu.edu Forages.osu.edu Digitalag.osu.edu

Editor's Notes

  • #11 Early July planting may have lost more total nitrogen decreasing Protien
  • #13 Much denser stand on 7/2 than 7/29
  • #22 21 different species or mixed with yield and quality data
  • #23 Nutrient value per ton average times tons per acre average. Warm season crops on average preformed better the cool season when planted in July in blue Cool Season crops in Orange normal planting early spring Winter annuals in red Mixes in yellow
  • #25 Lower Green Line beef CP requirement early gestation upper green line Beef lactating CP needs Lower Red Line Sheep CP requirement maintenance upper Peach line Sheep lactating CP needs Some Feeds may require supplementation to meet our live stocks needs
  • #26 Lower red line sheep Maintenance upper lactation 2 lambs Lower Blue line beef early gestation upper lactation Many forages may need supplemented with energy
  • #28 Quality of early planted oats declines rapidly
  • #29 Quality declines from 45 to 60 days
  • #31 92 pounds of nitrogen Increased protein and energy. Fungicide also improved energy.