The document provides a summary of a presentation on frustration, force majeure, and sanctions clauses. It discusses how these legal concepts can provide relief for unexpected events that make contract performance difficult or impossible. It also provides tips on drafting contracts to allocate risks and define what events would trigger these clauses.
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) [LLB -309] cpjcollege
Alternative Dispute Resolution has become the primary means by which cases are resolved now days, especially commercial, business disputes. It has emerged as the preferred method for resolving civil cases, with litigation as a last resort. Alternative Dispute Resolution provides an overview of the statutory, procedural, and case law underlining these processes and their interplay with litigation. A significant theme is the evolving role of
professional ethics for attorneys operating in non-adversarial settings. Clients and courts increasingly express a preference for attorneys who are skilled not only in litigation but in problem-solving, which costs the clients less in terms of time, money and relationship. The law of ADR also provides an introduction to negotiation and mediation theory.
Describes the essentials of an arbitration agreement and what shall be kept in mind while drafting of an arbitration agreement.R P Dutta & Associates is a Kolkata based law firm specializing in corporate dispute resolution through arbitration .
A form of alternative dispute resolution, a technique to settle disputes outside the court. but here you will find that there are some exceptional cases in which the applicant can apply in court to seek justice.
here powers and duties of arbitrator is well explained also it is important to mention powers of court over arbitration and it's decisions.
(here the 'award' is referred to decision).
With current new amendments and law adding on in the Indian Judiciary, its important to know and be well aware of the statutes. You can consider this subject as 'Grammar of Law'. Teaches you exactly are the statutes made by the Legislative authorities as well. From use of particular language to construction of words this presentation almost includes all the part of how a statute is made, how they are learned and how exactly are the legal maxims used.
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) [LLB -309] cpjcollege
Alternative Dispute Resolution has become the primary means by which cases are resolved now days, especially commercial, business disputes. It has emerged as the preferred method for resolving civil cases, with litigation as a last resort. Alternative Dispute Resolution provides an overview of the statutory, procedural, and case law underlining these processes and their interplay with litigation. A significant theme is the evolving role of
professional ethics for attorneys operating in non-adversarial settings. Clients and courts increasingly express a preference for attorneys who are skilled not only in litigation but in problem-solving, which costs the clients less in terms of time, money and relationship. The law of ADR also provides an introduction to negotiation and mediation theory.
Describes the essentials of an arbitration agreement and what shall be kept in mind while drafting of an arbitration agreement.R P Dutta & Associates is a Kolkata based law firm specializing in corporate dispute resolution through arbitration .
A form of alternative dispute resolution, a technique to settle disputes outside the court. but here you will find that there are some exceptional cases in which the applicant can apply in court to seek justice.
here powers and duties of arbitrator is well explained also it is important to mention powers of court over arbitration and it's decisions.
(here the 'award' is referred to decision).
With current new amendments and law adding on in the Indian Judiciary, its important to know and be well aware of the statutes. You can consider this subject as 'Grammar of Law'. Teaches you exactly are the statutes made by the Legislative authorities as well. From use of particular language to construction of words this presentation almost includes all the part of how a statute is made, how they are learned and how exactly are the legal maxims used.
Code of civil procedure 1908 pleading plaint written statementDr. Vikas Khakare
This explains what is pleading, rules of pleading. Plaint, its contents, when it can be amended. Written Statement, its contents, set off and counter claim.
Alternative dipsute resolution system is informal method of resolving conflicts. there are different modes of ADR viz., negotiations, mediation , conciliation and arbitration etc.
The Specific Relief of Act 1877
The Law of Limitation Act, 1908
ARNAB KUMAR DAS
Port City International University,
Chittagong, Bangladesh.
SID: LLB 00305037
David Quinlan from Pinsent Masons explains the basics of contract law for sport and recreation organisations – from the Sport and the Law Conference 2014.
Code of civil procedure 1908 pleading plaint written statementDr. Vikas Khakare
This explains what is pleading, rules of pleading. Plaint, its contents, when it can be amended. Written Statement, its contents, set off and counter claim.
Alternative dipsute resolution system is informal method of resolving conflicts. there are different modes of ADR viz., negotiations, mediation , conciliation and arbitration etc.
The Specific Relief of Act 1877
The Law of Limitation Act, 1908
ARNAB KUMAR DAS
Port City International University,
Chittagong, Bangladesh.
SID: LLB 00305037
David Quinlan from Pinsent Masons explains the basics of contract law for sport and recreation organisations – from the Sport and the Law Conference 2014.
Frustration of contracts in emerging markets
Emerging markets hold opportunities but carry greater risk
Political change
Civil unrest/instability
Supply chain/contractor issues
Sanctions
Immature/unreliable legal system
How does contract law deal with these issues?
Doctrine of frustration
Force majeure clauses
How can you minimise these risks at the contract drafting stage?
Investment structuring
Drafting of contractual provisions
Is COVID-19 a Force Majeure Event? – Legal & Statutory PositionDVSResearchFoundatio
OBJECTIVE
In this webinar, we will understand the meaning and legal basis of a force majeure event. We shall discuss if COVID-19 will trigger a force majeure clause and whether this outbreak is considered by Indian Government as force majeure. Further, statutory relaxations announced by the Government of India in the light of COVID-19 outbreak will be discussed. Finally, the webinar will also cover the practical suggestions if force majeure event is attracted.
Are you concerned when asked “does your daily work ticket provide the right contractual risk transfer language?” The answer is often “yes” because to answer the question will probably cost you billable hours with an attorney. NBIS has successfully defended its clients in claim situations using contract language, even upper tier contracts & MSA’s. During this session, Mr. Smith and Mr. Silva will present basic protocols on why contractual risk transfer is so important and how to position your operation properly. You will learn how IRMI spreads the ‘Top Down Risk Transfer’ message to large construction companies and ways to defend your operation in the event of a claim. Lean on the team of experts from NBIS to ensure your daily work ticket leverages the most defensible terms available.
Speakers: Bill Smith, EVP Claims & Risk Management, NBIS (NationsBuilders Insurance Services, Inc.) Tyrone Silva, Risk Manager, NBIS (NationsBuilders Insurance Services, Inc.)
One of the key challenges for many businesses is to ensure that their cash flow and credit management procedures are working effectively. From developing Terms of Trade and the protection of assets on the PPSA register, through to credit management and debt recovery, this presentation provides an overview of the key issues and how your business can address them.
Negotiating the terms of a buy/sell agreement (i.e. an M&A transaction) requires both knowledge of the law and the “market.” This webinar involves the panelists engaging in mock negotiations of a variety of deal points which commonly arise in M&A transactions. Listen in as buyer’s and seller’s counsel haggle over representations, warranties, indemnification, purchase price payment mechanisms, and a host of other hotly negotiated terms.
Part of the webinar series: M&A BOOT CAMP 2021
See more at https://www.financialpoise.com/webinars/
In this webinar presenation, you will learn practical tips on drafting and understanding commercial agreements. Extract practical insights to drafting and understanding commercial agreements and learn techniques used to allocate or transfer economic risk.
Commercial Disputes – Have you got them covered?watsonburton
Commercial Disputes – Have you got them covered?
Slides from Lockton & Watson Burton
Tuesday 2 July 2013
Richard Palmer & Bal Manak - Watson Burton LLP
Michael Farrell & Anthony Place - Lockton Companies LLP
June 2011 - Business Law & Order - Thomas J. CavalierAnnArborSPARK
Commercial agreements set the ground rules for how you or your business interacts with your, customers, bankers, investors, suppliers, landlord and other third parties with whom you have business dealings. Our panel of experienced attorneys will discuss the basic fundamentals of contracts, also known as commercial agreements. Attorney Joe Lorenz will talk about entering into contracts (why you need contracts and how contracts are formed). Attorney Tom Cavalier will discuss performance of the contract you enter into (what are the important terms and conditions – how do they affect you). Attorney Joe Sgroi will talk about terminating contracts (how can you get out of a bad agreement -- or obtain performance from the other party). And….of course, the entire panel will be available to answer your questions!
Identifying & Managing Risk In Supply Chain AgreementsQuarles & Brady
This program covered three of the most heavily negotiated provisions in supply chain agreements - warranty, indemnification, and limitation of liability. These provisions are the primary provisions used to allocate risks between the contracting parties. We briefly discussed the purpose of each provision, identified the risks that negotiators should be aware of, and discussed strategies for understanding and managing the risks.
Black's Law Dictionary defines force majeure—French for "superior force"—as an event or effect that can be neither anticipated nor controlled. The term is commonly understood to encompass both acts of nature, such as floods and hurricanes, and acts of man, such as riots, strikes, and wars.
Madaans LLP, Lawyers
https://www.madaanlawyers.ca/
Similar to Frustration of Contracts and Force Majeure clauses (20)
The fourth industrial revolution – Understanding the opportunities and threats
With the speed of change that the new wave of technology represents we will consider the changing impact on business.
Conduct Risk – What Corporates Can Learn From The Financial SectorEversheds Sutherland
Over the last few years the financial services industry has wrestled with the impact of poor conduct. Fines and penalties have soared, franchises have been damaged and the legal and regulatory burden has forced a complete rewriting of business models. As a result there has been a sharpened focus from both a regulatory and governance perspective on “conduct risk” – the pro-active management of anything in which an institution might engage which could impact on customer outcomes, or market integrity. We look into what corporates in other sectors can learn from financial institutions in terms of compliance, culture, governance and ”conduct risk”.
The most significant changes to insurance law in 110 years came into effect in August 2016. The Insurance Act 2015 makes some fundamental changes to what businesses have to do to ensure that their insurance policies are effective and that their claims are paid in full. This webinar looks at the changes that have been made, what businesses need to do in order to comply with new rules on disclosure and how the new remedies for breach are to be applied. The Act applies to all policies governed by the laws of England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland which are taken out, renewed or varied on or after 12 August 2016. Accordingly, it is essential that all UK businesses have a full understanding of the new rules.
How technology and innovative processes can make your legal team more efficientEversheds Sutherland
It has never been a more exciting or challenging time to be an in-house lawyer or delivering legal work in-house. We will explore some of the key challenges and latest trends for delivering in-house legal work including; delivering more for less, increasing strategic focus, risk management, the use of technology, future planning and the increasing demand from the business to demonstrate value.
To address the future separation of UK and EU law, all contracts should now include transitional Brexit and change/divergence of law provisions. This webinar is an update on the key areas including currency risk, customs and trade assumptions.
The implications of State Aid can affect businesses operating within the EU, to protect your business it is vital to understand the risks in terms of both tax and corporate arrangements.
Opportunities and challenges of managing a globally mobile workforceEversheds Sutherland
Exploring the challenges and opportunities of managing a globally mobile workforce as well as guidance on dealing with complex legal requirements and cultural backgrounds.
Getting over ‘Regrexit’ - Post Brexit Real Estate OpportunitiesEversheds Sutherland
On 8 July 2016 Eversheds Head of London Real Estate Bruce Dear led a discussion on the post-Brexit market and emerging real estate opportunities that the market should be aware of. Our panel of in-house experts included Stuart Andrews on infrastructure and housing matters, Mukhtiar Tanda from a development angle, along with Andrew Henderson on an Financial Institutions and constitutional perspective and Ros Kellaway, the head of our EU Competition and Regulatory group.
Measuring value is often seen as a challenging process for the in-house legal team. We will consider some practical approaches that will help you to clarify objectives, improve performance as well as measure value.
Over the last couple of years, EU State Aid rules have been increasingly invoked to overturn tax rulings given by tax authorities to businesses operating in the EU. Although it is the actions of Member States that have been challenged, it is the affected businesses that have paid the cost in the form of multi-million Euro tax bills.
In the current tax climate, it is anticipated that the European Commission will look to apply the State Aid rules more widely. Having a good understanding of the issues and risks is, therefore, essential for business, in terms of both tax and of ther corporate arrangements.
Eversheds recently held a State Aid and Tax discussion which was lead by our tax experts Totis Kotsonis, Ben jones and Giles Salmond who were joined by barrister Kelly Stricklin-Coutinho from 39 Essex Chambers and a representative from HM Treasury who together discussed the implications of State Aid tax challenges for businesses operating in the EU and what might be coming next.
Areas that we covered included:
- an overview of how State Aid operates and its application to -tax
- what tax areas may be at risk of State Aid challenge
- what are the potential costs of a State Aid challenge and how could these costs be mitigated?
- how can businesses operating in the EU assess their risk of challenge and prepare for any such challenge?
- what is the reaction of the UK Government to such challenges and is the UK itself at risk of challenge?
Intellectual property is an important business asset and needs to be properly protected. We will consider the issues that businesses need to be aware of when operating globally and how to develop a strategy for managing and protecting your Intellectual Property portfolios.
Join this webinar to hear the latest developments, including how businesses are addressing their human rights impacts and are reporting progress, for example, in accordance the Modern Slavery Act and UN Guiding Principles on business and human rights. We will also share the results of our comprehensive survey of General Counsels. The survey addresses their involvement in human rights risks and management, as well as providing practical insight into their challenges and priorities.
AIMA Hedge Fund Manager Training, 13th April 2016. Hosted by Mike Booth and Andrew Henderson this session was focused towards portfolio managers, dealers and compliance teams. We had 70+ hedge fund managers register and we covered topics including:
• The FCA’s rules applicable for front office controls
• The lessons that can be learned from the recent front office controls fines
• The respective roles of compliance and front office teams
• What firms are doing in practice
• A brief overview of the new MAD II / MiFID II rules in the context of front office controls
Eversheds CREATE Workshop #1: Real estate holding structuresEversheds Sutherland
Corporate Real Estate Academy Training at Eversheds (CREATE) is a series of workshops designed to further your knowledge of indirect real estate and corporatised real estate transactions.
CREATE Workshop #1: Real Estate Holding Structures explored:
• typical structures used for holding real estate and real estate joint ventures
• why each structure is used and by whom
• trends and how the status quo is changing
Data Security Breach – knowing the risks and protecting your businessEversheds Sutherland
The impact of a breach in data security can be far reaching, with the risk of reputation damage affecting companies of any size. We will consider how to manage a security breach, its wider impact and building an effective cyber security for your infrastructure.
Each year, student teams are assigned a “Project of Worth”. Their task is to create an innovative startup solving a real problem in legal education or practice. Here is a list of the 2016 Projects of Worth.
Eversheds 'Spotlight on the Cloud' - headline results presentation and key sp...Eversheds Sutherland
Eversheds 'Spotlight on the Cloud' headline results presentation and key speaker commentary. Eversheds held its Cloud Computing survey (in conjunction with The Lawyer) launch event in London on Tuesday 8 March. Headline results were presented by Charlotte Walker-Osborn, Global Head of Technology, Media and Telecoms and Paula Barrett, Global Head of Privacy and Information Law. Industry speakers included Alastair McAulay, Director of Disruptive IT, PA Consulting Group and Olivier Wolf, TMT Sector Head, EY Transaction Advisory Services.
Neill Blundell provides an update of recent bribery activity around the world and discusses whether it is a real issue for business or merely an overstated problem.
Managing and retaining talent is one of the biggest challenges facing management, particularly in terms of attracting and retaining the right people, building high performance teams, as well as dealing with the risks associated with compliance and employment regulation. Our webinar will consider these issues and strategies you can develop to manage them.
A "File Trademark" is a legal term referring to the registration of a unique symbol, logo, or name used to identify and distinguish products or services. This process provides legal protection, granting exclusive rights to the trademark owner, and helps prevent unauthorized use by competitors.
Visit Now: https://www.tumblr.com/trademark-quick/751620857551634432/ensure-legal-protection-file-your-trademark-with?source=share
Car Accident Injury Do I Have a Case....Knowyourright
Every year, thousands of Minnesotans are injured in car accidents. These injuries can be severe – even life-changing. Under Minnesota law, you can pursue compensation through a personal injury lawsuit.
Responsibilities of the office bearers while registering multi-state cooperat...Finlaw Consultancy Pvt Ltd
Introduction-
The process of register multi-state cooperative society in India is governed by the Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002. This process requires the office bearers to undertake several crucial responsibilities to ensure compliance with legal and regulatory frameworks. The key office bearers typically include the President, Secretary, and Treasurer, along with other elected members of the managing committee. Their responsibilities encompass administrative, legal, and financial duties essential for the successful registration and operation of the society.
Defending Weapons Offence Charges: Role of Mississauga Criminal Defence LawyersHarpreetSaini48
Discover how Mississauga criminal defence lawyers defend clients facing weapon offence charges with expert legal guidance and courtroom representation.
To know more visit: https://www.saini-law.com/
Guide on the use of Artificial Intelligence-based tools by lawyers and law fi...Massimo Talia
This guide aims to provide information on how lawyers will be able to use the opportunities provided by AI tools and how such tools could help the business processes of small firms. Its objective is to provide lawyers with some background to understand what they can and cannot realistically expect from these products. This guide aims to give a reference point for small law practices in the EU
against which they can evaluate those classes of AI applications that are probably the most relevant for them.
Lifting the Corporate Veil. Power Point Presentationseri bangash
"Lifting the Corporate Veil" is a legal concept that refers to the judicial act of disregarding the separate legal personality of a corporation or limited liability company (LLC). Normally, a corporation is considered a legal entity separate from its shareholders or members, meaning that the personal assets of shareholders or members are protected from the liabilities of the corporation. However, there are certain situations where courts may decide to "pierce" or "lift" the corporate veil, holding shareholders or members personally liable for the debts or actions of the corporation.
Here are some common scenarios in which courts might lift the corporate veil:
Fraud or Illegality: If shareholders or members use the corporate structure to perpetrate fraud, evade legal obligations, or engage in illegal activities, courts may disregard the corporate entity and hold those individuals personally liable.
Undercapitalization: If a corporation is formed with insufficient capital to conduct its intended business and meet its foreseeable liabilities, and this lack of capitalization results in harm to creditors or other parties, courts may lift the corporate veil to hold shareholders or members liable.
Failure to Observe Corporate Formalities: Corporations and LLCs are required to observe certain formalities, such as holding regular meetings, maintaining separate financial records, and avoiding commingling of personal and corporate assets. If these formalities are not observed and the corporate structure is used as a mere façade, courts may disregard the corporate entity.
Alter Ego: If there is such a unity of interest and ownership between the corporation and its shareholders or members that the separate personalities of the corporation and the individuals no longer exist, courts may treat the corporation as the alter ego of its owners and hold them personally liable.
Group Enterprises: In some cases, where multiple corporations are closely related or form part of a single economic unit, courts may pierce the corporate veil to achieve equity, particularly if one corporation's actions harm creditors or other stakeholders and the corporate structure is being used to shield culpable parties from liability.
Matthew Professional CV experienced Government LiaisonMattGardner52
As an experienced Government Liaison, I have demonstrated expertise in Corporate Governance. My skill set includes senior-level management in Contract Management, Legal Support, and Diplomatic Relations. I have also gained proficiency as a Corporate Liaison, utilizing my strong background in accounting, finance, and legal, with a Bachelor's degree (B.A.) from California State University. My Administrative Skills further strengthen my ability to contribute to the growth and success of any organization.
In 2020, the Ministry of Home Affairs established a committee led by Prof. (Dr.) Ranbir Singh, former Vice Chancellor of National Law University (NLU), Delhi. This committee was tasked with reviewing the three codes of criminal law. The primary objective of the committee was to propose comprehensive reforms to the country’s criminal laws in a manner that is both principled and effective.
The committee’s focus was on ensuring the safety and security of individuals, communities, and the nation as a whole. Throughout its deliberations, the committee aimed to uphold constitutional values such as justice, dignity, and the intrinsic value of each individual. Their goal was to recommend amendments to the criminal laws that align with these values and priorities.
Subsequently, in February, the committee successfully submitted its recommendations regarding amendments to the criminal law. These recommendations are intended to serve as a foundation for enhancing the current legal framework, promoting safety and security, and upholding the constitutional principles of justice, dignity, and the inherent worth of every individual.
Frustration of Contracts and Force Majeure clauses
1. Frustration, Force Majeure and Sanctions:
A practical guide for in-house counsel
Richard Little
David Savage
Conor Redmond
Eversheds LLP
26th
March 2015
2. Frustration, Force Majeure and
Sanctions
Today’s speakers
David Savage
Senior Associate
Financial Services Disputes
and Investigations
Richard Little
Partner
Commercial Dispute
Resolution
Conor Redmond
Associate
Commercial Dispute
Resolution
4. Poll on key risk factors
Which of these risks do you most frequently
manage for your business?
•Political unrest and/or armed conflict
•Changes to a relevant legal system
•Commodity price or currency fluctuations
•Natural disasters
•Supply chain issues
•Imposition of economic sanctions
5. Introduction
What could possibly go wrong?
• Man-made and natural events may make
contracts difficult, more expensive or
impossible to perform
• Think: Arab Spring, 9/11, Eyjafjallajökull*,
Tsunami 2011, ISIS, sanctions, coups,
Argentinian oil industry nationalisation, etc.
• How does the law relate to unexpected,
sometimes catastrophic, events?
• How can a contract deal with such events?
6. Introduction
Libya: pariah, friend, enemy, failed state
1982 – US sanctions imposed, targeting oil imports
1992 – UN air/arms/ oil equipment embargo
1996 – Iran-Libya Sanctions Act passed in US
1999 – UN sanctions suspended
2003 – UN sanctions ended
2004 – Many US sanctions lifted
2011 – Military intervention and fall of Qaddafi
2012 – NTC hands power to newly elected GNC
2014 – Central government collapses
9. Frustration
• General rule - if performance of a contract
becomes difficult or even impossible, the party
who fails to perform it is liable in damages
• The doctrine of frustration can provide an
exception to this general rule
• The doctrine provides that a contract is
automatically discharged if a frustrating event
occurs
• The doctrine is very narrow and of limited/
uncertain application
Role at common law
10. Frustration
What is a frustrating event?
• A frustrating event is one which:
– occurs after the contract is formed;
– strikes at the very root of the contract;
– is not due to the fault of either party;
– was entirely beyond the parties’ contemplation
when they entered into the contract; and
– renders further performance impossible or
illegal or makes it radically different from what
was contemplated when entering into the
contract.
11. Frustration
Examples of frustrating events
• Destruction of the subject matter of a contract
(Taylor v Caldwell)
• Unavailability of the subject matter (Re Shipton,
Anderson & Co)
• Supervening illegality of performance, e.g. a
subsequent change in the law or circumstances
(Denny Mott v James B Fraser)
• Cancellation of an expected event (Krell v Henry)
12. Frustration
Where frustration has not been available
• Express provision in the contract
• An alternative method of performance is possible
(Tsakiroglou v Noblee and Thorl)
• The contract is merely more expensive to
perform (Tsakiroglou v Noblee and Thorl)
• The seller is let down by its own supplier
• Changes in economic conditions
• It is self-induced
13. • Contract automatically discharged and the
parties are excused from their future obligations
• No one party is at fault so neither party may
claim damages for the other's non-performance
• “Loss lies where it falls" so no claim can be made
for the value of a partially completed contract
(Appleby v Myers) unless there has been a total
failure of consideration (Fibrosa v Fairbairn)
• If a party incurred obligations before the time of
frustration, it remains bound to perform them
Frustration
Consequences under common law
14. Frustration
Consequences under the Law Reform (Frustrated
Contracts) Act 1943
• The 1943 Act applies to most commercial contracts
• Monies paid before the frustrating event can be
recovered
• Monies due before the frustrating event, but not in
fact paid, cease to be payable
• Expenses can be recovered with the courts
permission
• Those who gain a valuable benefit prior to frustration
may be required to pay a “just” sum for it
• If the contract is one to which the 1943 Act does not
apply, the parties must rely on the common law rules
15. Frustration
Tips for managing risk
• Plan ahead - do not rely on the doctrine of
frustration!
• Identify, assess and allocate the risks associated
with any contract
• Consider including a clause to deal with a default
caused by certain events outside of the parties’
control
• For example, a force majeure clause
17. Force Majeure
Introduction
• A potential method of dealing with a volatile
world and addressing the shortcomings of
frustration doctrine
• General principle: a party should be relieved
from liability for a failure to perform, or delay in
performing, caused by unexpected events or
circumstances outside its control
• Examples include Acts of God, war, terrorism,
relevant changes in law and extreme weather
conditions
• Difference of approach between common/civil
law
18. Force Majeure
Role at civil law: Italy
• Definition of Force Majeure under Italian
legislation aims to protect a party from liability
where a contract is not performed due to the
occurrence of an event that was neither within
that party’s control nor attributable to that party
• Advisable in Italy to include general wording at
end of Force Majeure clause such as “and any
other Force Majeure causes beyond the control
of the parties”.
• Courts will then decide case by case if an event
can be interpreted as a force majeure event
19. • Under French law a Force Majeure event is an
event (and set of consequences) which could not
be predicted and avoided even if all normal and
appropriate measures had been taken
• The exemption is only effective for so long as the
force majeure event lasts, unless the parties
decide to terminate the contract
• Any party may claim exemption under Force
Majeure, even if there is no Force Majeure clause
• Advisable to include Force Majeure clause
regardless
Force Majeure
Role at civil law: France
20. Force majeure
• No concept of Force Majeure at common law
• Force Majeure has evolved by contract to fill the
gap left by the uncertainties of frustration
• The term “Force Majeure” derives from French
law and has no established meaning under
English law.
• It must, therefore, always be defined in
common law contracts.
Role at common law
21. Force Majeure clauses
The rationale
• Form part of the allocation of risk under a
contract
• Should be considered and negotiated in this
context alongside other risk allocation provisions
• Remember: if one party is relieved from liability
for a failure due to something beyond its control,
result is that the other party bears the
consequences of that failure
• Issue of risk allocation: Who is in the best
position to manage the risk?
• Fact dependent
22. Force Majeure
How to define
• Can be defined as something which is beyond
the reasonable control of the affected party
• A wide concept which can lead the court to
impose an obligation to take reasonable
preventative measures
• A more tailored approach preferable-consider the
contractual context
23. Force Majeure
Customer v Supplier-definition priorities
• Customers should:
– limit the definition to a list of specified events;
anything not on the list will not constitute FM
and will not afford relief from liability
– provides additional certainty
• A supplier should:
– consider whether it is aware of anything which
could prevent it from fulfilling the contract
– define these things expressly as FM events
– consider whether to make reference to specific
events relevant to the supplier’s industry
24. Burden of proof
• A party relying upon a Force Majeure clause must
prove that
– one of the events referred to in the clause has
occurred and the clause has been triggered;
– he has been prevented, hindered or delayed from
performing the contract by reason of that event;
– non-performance was due to circumstances
beyond his control; and
– no reasonable steps could have been taken to
avoid or mitigate the event or its consequences
Key elements
25. Force Majeure
Planning ahead
• Consider the role of business continuity or disaster
recovery plans
• Put contractual obligation on supplier to prepare
and implement a contingency plan
• A failure to devise or implement such a plan
should not absolve the supplier from liability under
the FM clause
• If a supplier prepares and implements a plan
which complies with its contractual obligations but
an unforeseen disaster occurs, it may be
reasonable for this disaster to come within the
scope of a FM event
26. Force Majeure
When an event occurs
• Affected party should only be relieved from
liability to perform if there is a causal connection
between the occurrence of the force majeure
event and the inability to perform
• Affected party should be required to give notice
to the other party if a Force Majeure event
occurs
• Consider the extent to which the affected party
must mitigate the effects of the force majeure
event and try to perform in alternative ways.
27. Force Majeure
Termination
• Key to avoid situation where performance of
contract is suspended indefinitely by occurrence
of FM event
• Include right to terminate where FM event
continues for longer than a specified period
• Consider if:
– termination should be triggered simply by FM
event continuing beyond the specified time or
only if the event has a sufficiently significant
impact on performance of the contract
– only non-affected party has the right to
terminate or if the affected party should too
28. Force Majeure
Consequences of termination
• When a contract terminates due to the
occurrence of FM event, options include:
– for the contract to terminate without liability
(bar antecedent breaches);
– monies paid for goods/services that are not
supplied are reimbursed;
– materials provided are paid for; and
– part deliveries are returned.
29. • A contractual remedy for unexpected events
• Not all such events can be catered for- the
“unknown unknowns”
• Further contractual protection may be required in
certain circumstances
• Excusable delay, illegality of performance and
sanctions clauses becoming increasingly
important in this regard
Force Majeure clauses
Limitations
31. Excusable Delay
Excusable Delay
•For contracts where actions have to be performed
within a proscribed period
•Events which are not traditional “force majeure”,
but are outside the control of the parties
•Aim of the clause is to give the parties additional
time to fulfil their obligations
•Of particular importance if the contract contains
LD provisions
•Contain a long stop provision
33. Illegality
• Defence of illegality excuses a party of its
obligations under a contract
• Courts are caught between enforcing the rights
of parties and upholding law
• Defence only succeeds where depriving
claimant’s rights is a proportionate response
• Some statutes prohibit certain types of
contract, others prescribe criminal or regulatory
penalties
Invalidity of contracts
34. Illegality
• A contract that cannot be performed without an
illegal act will be void
• An innocent party, who did not know the other
would perform the contract in an illegal way, will
be able to enforce the contract
• If both parties are complicit in the illegality,
defence still available if a proportionate response
• Illegality defence may apply where neither party
has pleaded it through the court’s duty to uphold
the law
Consequences
35. Illegality
• A contract entered
into by parties may
subsequently contain
illegal provisions
• It may be possible to
sever the illegal part
of the contract, and
enforce the rest
Severance
36. Illegality
• Example of a severance clause:
“1.1 If any provision or part-provision of this agreement is or becomes invalid,
illegal or unenforceable, it shall be deemed modified to the minimum extent
necessary to make it valid, legal and enforceable. If such modification is not
possible, the relevant provision or part-provision shall be deemed deleted. Any
modification to or deletion of a provision or part-provision under this clause
shall not affect the validity and enforceability of the rest of this agreement.
1.2 If [one party gives notice to the other of the possibility that] any provision
or part-provision of this agreement is invalid, illegal or unenforceable, the
parties shall negotiate in good faith to amend such provision so that, as
amended, it is legal, valid and enforceable, and, to the greatest extent
possible, achieves the intended commercial result of the original provision.”
Severance
40. • Introduction of sanctions may make
contractual performance illegal or
impossible
• Particular difficulties may arise where
sanctions are imposed in one jurisdiction
with extraterritorial effect, but not enforced
in another jurisdiction
• Go beyond Force Majeure/frustration
clauses
• Wording of clause will vary depending on
nature of contract
Sanctions
Effect on contracts
41. • Are sanctions really Force Majeure?
• Can include in definition of Force
Majeure, e.g.
“an act of God including but not limited to
fire, flood, earthquake, windstorm or
other natural disaster; act of any
sovereign including but not limited to …
imposition of government sanction,
embargo or similar action; or acts of
terrorism.”
Sanctions
Nature of sanctions clauses
42. • express agreement that the activities dealt with
by the contract are not the subject of sanctions
• provides either party with the right to cancel
upon the imposition of sanctions
• such imposition should make performance
under the contract either impossible or illegal
• requires each party to notify the other
immediately upon an activity becoming
sanctionable
• include appropriate warranties and indemnities
for breach
• stipulate, if possible, alternative methods of
performance, payment, etc
Sanctions
What should sanctions clauses contain
43.
44. David Savage
Senior Associate
Financial Services Disputes and
Investigations
Direct dial: 0845 497 0524
E-mail:
davidsavage@eversheds.com
Richard Little
Partner
Commercial Dispute
Resolution
Direct dial: 0845 497 0602
E-mail:
richardlittle@Eversheds.com
Conor Redmond
Associate
Commercial Dispute
Resolution
Direct dial: 0845 497 4710
E-mail:
conorredmond@eversheds.com