FM3 Small Scale Research Project

      Developing Research Skills
The Project
• Primary importance is the development of
  broad ranging research skills
• Avoid questions as answers close down your
  research
• Develop a critical approach to the topic
A journey
Finding an area for investigation
• What are you interested in? What do you
  want to find out?
• Consider the resources available and what is
  potentially available
• Seek advice from tutors, peers, experts
• Draw up a research plan. Plan the feasible
  and the unfeasible
• Be extra critical – is it really possible to
  complete?
Types of research
Primary Research
• Research that is directly generated by you and
  is not mediated by anyone else

Secondary Research
• Research that has been undertaken or
  ‘filtered’ by another and is simply being used
  or referenced by you (the researcher)
Primary Research
Includes:
  – Learning conversations – name of person, place, date
  – Interviews
  – Questionnaires
  – Own notes from reviewing films and associated
    material
  – Empirical experiment (practical research with
    considered confines
  – Action research (research through carrying out a role)
  – Observational research (watching others performing
    an action or undertaking a task)
Secondary Research
Includes:
  – Internet
  – Books
  – DVD Extras
  – Television programmes
  – Radio programmes
  – Archives
  – Magazines
  – Conferences
  – Trade Shows
Mixed Methods – the ideal
Primary Research              Secondary Research
Notes from Focus film           Internet Sites
Notes from supporting films     Several books
Interview with Art Director     Some magazine articles
Practical experiment in         A DVD Extra (making of)
Mise-en-scene                   A TV Documentary
Discussion with tutor           A conference paper
Mixed Methods – The ideal
Quantitative data
• Research that produces numbers, percentages, data
  that can be numerically assessed – useful for
  comparative analysis (number of films made, box
  office gross, times nominated for oscar etc)
Qualitative data
• Research that is more opinion based, and which
  often looks at the reasons behind points of view,
  responses, processes, actions etc
Research referencing
• Harvard Referencing for Books, Magazines etc
http://www.le.ac.uk/oerresources/ssds/harvard/
• Full URL and date accessed for all internet
  sites
• Location and date of interviews and other
  primary research activities (such as empirical
  research)
Tools to help

• Neil’s Toolbox

• Harvard Generator

• Cite this for me
Assessing the value of Research items
• How much does the item relate to or inform
  the area of investigation
• Does it provide simple background content or
  does it present new knowledge or an
  argument?
• Does it have validity (peer reviewed, primary
  source, or user-generated and unassessed)
• How current is the item (not how new, but has
  it been disproved or made invalid by later
  material)?
Annotating the catalogue
• Items can be assessed for:
• Reliability (of method/ source)
• Validity (of method, or media, of source)
• Currency (current, respected, serious)
• Recency (older = more likely to have been
  challenged)
• Accuracy (of content – proved with data and
  with method
• Relevance (to the area of investigation, to the
  thrust of the argument being presented)
Wikipedia
Not reliable as it is user-generated.

Check end references on an entry to assess this.

Go to the bottom of the page as there may be
some useful external sources.
Final Advice
• Youtube clips of a film cannot count as
  additional to the film
• IMDb pages clustered around a film or
  individual should be considered as a single
  source (much like individual pages of a book)
• Images can be a research resource, but offer
  more than simple illustration
• Primary research must be backed up with
  other sources
The Presentation Script
(extract from The Principal Moderators Report)

• Marks are for the script provided, not a
  presentation given
• Direct reference to catalogue material is a
  requirement
• The chosen framework should be evident
  throughout – balanced with the topic.
• An area of investigation – exploratory rather
  than answering a question.

Fm3 small scale research project

  • 1.
    FM3 Small ScaleResearch Project Developing Research Skills
  • 2.
    The Project • Primaryimportance is the development of broad ranging research skills • Avoid questions as answers close down your research • Develop a critical approach to the topic
  • 3.
  • 4.
    Finding an areafor investigation • What are you interested in? What do you want to find out? • Consider the resources available and what is potentially available • Seek advice from tutors, peers, experts • Draw up a research plan. Plan the feasible and the unfeasible • Be extra critical – is it really possible to complete?
  • 5.
    Types of research PrimaryResearch • Research that is directly generated by you and is not mediated by anyone else Secondary Research • Research that has been undertaken or ‘filtered’ by another and is simply being used or referenced by you (the researcher)
  • 6.
    Primary Research Includes: – Learning conversations – name of person, place, date – Interviews – Questionnaires – Own notes from reviewing films and associated material – Empirical experiment (practical research with considered confines – Action research (research through carrying out a role) – Observational research (watching others performing an action or undertaking a task)
  • 7.
    Secondary Research Includes: – Internet – Books – DVD Extras – Television programmes – Radio programmes – Archives – Magazines – Conferences – Trade Shows
  • 8.
    Mixed Methods –the ideal Primary Research Secondary Research Notes from Focus film Internet Sites Notes from supporting films Several books Interview with Art Director Some magazine articles Practical experiment in A DVD Extra (making of) Mise-en-scene A TV Documentary Discussion with tutor A conference paper
  • 9.
    Mixed Methods –The ideal Quantitative data • Research that produces numbers, percentages, data that can be numerically assessed – useful for comparative analysis (number of films made, box office gross, times nominated for oscar etc) Qualitative data • Research that is more opinion based, and which often looks at the reasons behind points of view, responses, processes, actions etc
  • 10.
    Research referencing • HarvardReferencing for Books, Magazines etc http://www.le.ac.uk/oerresources/ssds/harvard/ • Full URL and date accessed for all internet sites • Location and date of interviews and other primary research activities (such as empirical research)
  • 11.
    Tools to help •Neil’s Toolbox • Harvard Generator • Cite this for me
  • 12.
    Assessing the valueof Research items • How much does the item relate to or inform the area of investigation • Does it provide simple background content or does it present new knowledge or an argument? • Does it have validity (peer reviewed, primary source, or user-generated and unassessed) • How current is the item (not how new, but has it been disproved or made invalid by later material)?
  • 13.
    Annotating the catalogue •Items can be assessed for: • Reliability (of method/ source) • Validity (of method, or media, of source) • Currency (current, respected, serious) • Recency (older = more likely to have been challenged) • Accuracy (of content – proved with data and with method • Relevance (to the area of investigation, to the thrust of the argument being presented)
  • 14.
    Wikipedia Not reliable asit is user-generated. Check end references on an entry to assess this. Go to the bottom of the page as there may be some useful external sources.
  • 15.
    Final Advice • Youtubeclips of a film cannot count as additional to the film • IMDb pages clustered around a film or individual should be considered as a single source (much like individual pages of a book) • Images can be a research resource, but offer more than simple illustration • Primary research must be backed up with other sources
  • 16.
    The Presentation Script (extractfrom The Principal Moderators Report) • Marks are for the script provided, not a presentation given • Direct reference to catalogue material is a requirement • The chosen framework should be evident throughout – balanced with the topic. • An area of investigation – exploratory rather than answering a question.