MARKETPLACES: THE PARTY IS NOT OVER
JUNE 2019
 @NOAHConference
 @noah_conference
 @noah-conference
 @NOAHConference
FOLLOW USONSOCIAL
PRIOR INVESTMENTS
2
FOUNDERS
Fabrice Grinda
• Forbes #1 Ranked Angel Investor
LANGUAGES
BACKGROUND
Jose Marin
LANGUAGES
BACKGROUND
3
FOUNDER FOUNDER
Zingy Aucland IG Expansion
IN A NUTSHELL
VENTURE CAPITAL
• Pre-seed / Seed / Series A focus
• Average investment size $400K
• Global strategy: Active in U.S., Europe, LatAm, India
• 80+ investments per year
• 65% new investments + 35% follow-ons
• Do not lead rounds or join boards
• Co-invest with larger funds we know and trust
COMPANY BUILDING
• Build 1-2 businesses from scratch per year
• Invest $2.5M to $5M per company
• Executive chairman role
• Hands-on role in product, marketing, hiring, strategy &
fundraising
• Expertise in scaling using TV advertising
(FJ has bought over $1B of TV ads)
• US focus but have built companies in Europe + Brazil
4
INVESTMENT HEURISTICS
Verticalization of horizontals
Transition to supply pick marketplace
B2B marketplaces
5
Does it meet our thesis?
Storytelling skills
Grit and tenacity
Demonstrated passion
Metrics driven and analytical
Attractive unit economics (actual or theoretical)
$1b+ potential enterprise value
Low disintermediation risk
Market leader potential
Scalable and capital efficient
Growing market
Attractive price relative to team,
traction, and market opportunity
Is the team compelling?
Is the business attractive?
Are the deal terms reasonable?
NET INVESTMENT TRACK RECORD
REALIZED GAINS UNREALIZED GAINS
# OF INVESTMENTS
313
AVG. INVESTMENT
$466K
AVG. HOLDING PERIOD
3.3 Y
IRR
70.9%
INVESTED
$30.8M
As of December 31, 2018. Includes FJ Labs LLC investments. MOIC is based on last round valuations. 6
MOIC
5.7X
CARRYING VALUE
$176.0M
INVESTED
$146.7M
MOIC
2.0X
CARRYING VALUE
$290.9M
AVG. INVESTMENT
$224K
# OF INVESTMENTS
132
AVG. HOLDING PERIOD
2.6 Y
IRR
30.1%
We follow and invest
in the evolution of
marketplace models
MARKETPLACE MODELS AND INVESTMENT THEMES
7
VERTICALIZATION OF THE HORIZONTALS CONTINUES
8
CONTINUED VERTICALIZATION OF HORIZONTALS
9
MOVING FROM DOUBLE COMMIT TO MARKETPLACE PICK
10
B2B MARKETPLACES
Examples
High Margins of
20%+
High Average
Order Value
High
Recurrence
B2B Marketplaces have attractive characteristics that
makes them more resilient
11
Food Models
12
FOOD IS UNDERGOING MASSIVE SHIFT TO OFF PREMISE CONSUMPTION
On Premise Revenues
(grocery shopping & dine-in)
Off Premise Revenues
(pick-up & delivery)
VERTICALIZATION OF ON-DEMAND FOOD
Verticalization happens around discovery,
trust, convenience and priceHorizontals benefit from the growing demand
Managed delivery for
business lunch
Discovery platform for
pick-up
Managed delivery for
authentic food
Discovery platform for
local pizzerias
Discovery platform for
discounted pick-up
NEW MODELS ARE FOCUSING ON OFF PREMISE CONCEPTS
High upfront costs
On-premise experience first
- physical storefront -
Not flexible to changes:
one kitchen, one brand, one menu
In-house customer comes first
Off-premise experience first
- digital storefront -
This Model works as long as
food is still hyper-local and
physical space is needed
This Model works when
cultural habit shifts to
mobile-first world (like China)
Digital presence is needed
Low upfront costs
Out-of-house customer comes first
Flexible to changes:
multiple brands from single kitchen
OFF-PREMISE EMERGING MODELS
16
- Smart industrial kitchens
rented out to restaurants
- High-flexibility and easy
expansion for current brands
- Merit based: Low-cost barrier
to entry for new brands
- Players provide shared space,
infrastructure, and SaaS
- Brands renting dark kitchens
or using existing underutilized
restaurant space
- Players in the space usually
take charge in providing the
brand, raw-materials,
customer acquisition, and
delivery support
- Cooking-on-the-go
renovated and sold with
healthy margins
- Players in the space
provide well-equipped
vehicle with a cooking
space, and often an app
Dark Kitchens Virtual Restaurants Autonomous Restaurants Fleet
17
Real Estate Models
MULTIPLE SUCCESSFUL MODELS EMERGING IN THE REAL ESTATE SPACE
18
OVERVIEW OF IBUYER MODEL
19
The iBuyer model requires getting involved in every step of the transaction
SUCCESS FACTORS FOR IBUYER MODELS
20
- Mortgage market for buyers
- Debt capital market to fund
homes up to ideally 90%+
- Culture of home ownership
- High broker fees
- High % of transactions going
through brokers
- High complexity transaction
- Long time to close
transaction (90+ days)
- Availability of low priced
assets that can be
renovated and sold with
healthy margin
Every market Efficient markets Inefficient markets
Car Models
21
Ridesharing
EVOLVING CAR MODELS
22
Used New
Own
Access
Used car leasing New car leasing
Allows consumers to sell to
dealerships
FRONTIER CAR GROUP IS BRINGING THE AUTO1 MODEL TO EMERGING MARKETS
Frontier Car Group is bringing the Auto1 model to
emerging markets
Auto1 model has proven successful in Europe
Not clear which
markets are fully
operational
Initial target
markets
SUCCESS FACTORS FOR CAR MODELS
24
Information sources and use
Incumbents
- Absence of wholesale
marketplaces
- Low penetration of largest
incumbents
Financing
- Social acceptance of credit
- Credit scoring system
- Access to credit
Macro factors
- Market size
- High and/or increasing car
ownership
- Price differential across
regions
- Potential for pricing models
built on proprietary data set
Job Marketplace Models
25
SUCCESSFUL JOBS MARKETPLACE MODELS
26
Blue collar
Full Time Jobs Staffing / Gigs Vertical Marketplace Pick
White collar
SUCCESS FACTORS FOR JOB MARKETPLACE MODELS
27
Regulatory
- Employer responsibility for
insurance/pension/sick
leave/…
- Ease of hiring/firing employees
Macro factors
- Industries which require rapid
hiring/firing of large amounts of people
(e.g. ride sharing or oil & gas for
staffing)
- Job churn in the market
- Unemployment rates
Home Services Models
28
VERTICALIZATION OF HOME SERVICES MODELS
29
Horizontal services marketplace
New verticalized and transactional competitorsHorizontals still dominate the bulk of home
services models
Managed marketplace
for home maintenance
and repairs
B2B marketplace for
construction materials
Managed marketplace
for home renovations
Managed marketplace for
restaurant renovations
Lending Models
30
VERTICALIZATION OF LENDING MODELS
31
… followed by a second wave of startups
that address specific client needs
The first wave of fintech challengers brought
significant disruption to the market …
Banking for self-
employed freelancers
Pay-as-you-go smart-
phone purchasing
POS financing for
veterinary clinics
Better returns for
online shopping
Lending for
produce farmers
SUCCESS FACTORS FOR VERTICAL LENDING MODELS
32
Better understanding
of customer needs
• Faster decision
making
• Targeted UI/UX
• Higher approval
rates /lower cost
Better customer
experience
Customer Needs Vertical Fintech Edge Outcome
More business + more data
ProducePay for farmers
ScratchPay for vets
ClearBanc for freelancers
AMAZING THINGS LIE AHEAD!
33
Thank you!
Thank you.
FABRICE GRINDA
fabrice@fjlabs.com
JOSE MARIN
jose@fjlabs.com
19 W 24th Street, 10th Floor, New York, NY
www.FJLabs.com
34
Selected Completed NOAH Transactions
Focus on Leading European Internet companies
Covering over 400 companies across 25 online
verticals, a broad range of over 500 investors as
well as 100+ online-focused corporates
Deep understanding of industry dynamics
Ability to add value beyond banking advice
Facilitates overall process and minimizes
management distraction
NOAH Advisors is globally well connected
and has direct access to virtually all key
players in the industry
Knowledge of and strong relationships with
potential buyers’ key decision makers
Proactively finds and unlocks attractive
investment opportunities for leading investors
Annual NOAH Conference in its 10th year
Over 40 years of combined relevant M&A experience
Routine execution of M&A and financing transactions
with sizes of several billion euros
30 successfully completed NOAH Advisors transactions
underline successful transfer of M&A competencies to
the Internet sector
Entrepreneurial mind-set, focused on growing the
business and establishing a reputation for excellence
Ability to deliver top results in short time frames
Highly success-based compensation structures align
interests of clients and NOAH Advisors, and demonstrate
conviction to deliver top results
Creative deal solutions
Unique Industry Know-How
Unmatched Network and Relationships
Strong Investment Banking Competence
Full Commitment - We Are Entrepreneurs!
EUROPE’S LEADING INTERNET
CORPORATE FINANCE BOUTIQUE®
The NOAH Advisors Core Banking Team
Marco Rodzynek
Managing Director & Founder
Jan Brandes
Managing Director
Nikhil Parmar
Director
Olek Skwarczek
Associate
Lukas Schlund
Analyst
December 2014 October 2014
Sale of 100% of
for $800m to
Exclusive Financial Advisor to
Fotolia and the Selling Shareholders
Sale of 100% of
for €80m to
Exclusive Financial Advisor to
Trovit and its Shareholders
October 2016
Investment in
Exclusive Financial Advisor to KäuferPortal
and its Shareholders
by
84% Ownership
December 2016
August 2017
Financial Advisor to Silver Lake
Financial Advisor to EMK Capital
Investment in
Acquisition of a Majority Stake in
by
by
at a valuation of $200m
November 2019 July 2019
September 2018
Financial Advisor to MagicLab
Financial Advisor to AU10TIX
and its shareholders
Financial Advisor to 10bis
and its shareholders
Acquisition of a 79% stake in $60m Investment in
Sale of 100% in
by
at a valuation of ~$3 billion
at a valuation of $260m by
for €135m to
10Bis

FJ Labs - NOAH19 Berlin

  • 1.
    MARKETPLACES: THE PARTYIS NOT OVER JUNE 2019
  • 2.
     @NOAHConference  @noah_conference @noah-conference  @NOAHConference FOLLOW USONSOCIAL
  • 3.
  • 4.
    FOUNDERS Fabrice Grinda • Forbes#1 Ranked Angel Investor LANGUAGES BACKGROUND Jose Marin LANGUAGES BACKGROUND 3 FOUNDER FOUNDER Zingy Aucland IG Expansion
  • 5.
    IN A NUTSHELL VENTURECAPITAL • Pre-seed / Seed / Series A focus • Average investment size $400K • Global strategy: Active in U.S., Europe, LatAm, India • 80+ investments per year • 65% new investments + 35% follow-ons • Do not lead rounds or join boards • Co-invest with larger funds we know and trust COMPANY BUILDING • Build 1-2 businesses from scratch per year • Invest $2.5M to $5M per company • Executive chairman role • Hands-on role in product, marketing, hiring, strategy & fundraising • Expertise in scaling using TV advertising (FJ has bought over $1B of TV ads) • US focus but have built companies in Europe + Brazil 4
  • 6.
    INVESTMENT HEURISTICS Verticalization ofhorizontals Transition to supply pick marketplace B2B marketplaces 5 Does it meet our thesis? Storytelling skills Grit and tenacity Demonstrated passion Metrics driven and analytical Attractive unit economics (actual or theoretical) $1b+ potential enterprise value Low disintermediation risk Market leader potential Scalable and capital efficient Growing market Attractive price relative to team, traction, and market opportunity Is the team compelling? Is the business attractive? Are the deal terms reasonable?
  • 7.
    NET INVESTMENT TRACKRECORD REALIZED GAINS UNREALIZED GAINS # OF INVESTMENTS 313 AVG. INVESTMENT $466K AVG. HOLDING PERIOD 3.3 Y IRR 70.9% INVESTED $30.8M As of December 31, 2018. Includes FJ Labs LLC investments. MOIC is based on last round valuations. 6 MOIC 5.7X CARRYING VALUE $176.0M INVESTED $146.7M MOIC 2.0X CARRYING VALUE $290.9M AVG. INVESTMENT $224K # OF INVESTMENTS 132 AVG. HOLDING PERIOD 2.6 Y IRR 30.1%
  • 8.
    We follow andinvest in the evolution of marketplace models MARKETPLACE MODELS AND INVESTMENT THEMES 7
  • 9.
    VERTICALIZATION OF THEHORIZONTALS CONTINUES 8
  • 10.
  • 11.
    MOVING FROM DOUBLECOMMIT TO MARKETPLACE PICK 10
  • 12.
    B2B MARKETPLACES Examples High Marginsof 20%+ High Average Order Value High Recurrence B2B Marketplaces have attractive characteristics that makes them more resilient 11
  • 13.
  • 14.
    FOOD IS UNDERGOINGMASSIVE SHIFT TO OFF PREMISE CONSUMPTION On Premise Revenues (grocery shopping & dine-in) Off Premise Revenues (pick-up & delivery)
  • 15.
    VERTICALIZATION OF ON-DEMANDFOOD Verticalization happens around discovery, trust, convenience and priceHorizontals benefit from the growing demand Managed delivery for business lunch Discovery platform for pick-up Managed delivery for authentic food Discovery platform for local pizzerias Discovery platform for discounted pick-up
  • 16.
    NEW MODELS AREFOCUSING ON OFF PREMISE CONCEPTS High upfront costs On-premise experience first - physical storefront - Not flexible to changes: one kitchen, one brand, one menu In-house customer comes first Off-premise experience first - digital storefront - This Model works as long as food is still hyper-local and physical space is needed This Model works when cultural habit shifts to mobile-first world (like China) Digital presence is needed Low upfront costs Out-of-house customer comes first Flexible to changes: multiple brands from single kitchen
  • 17.
    OFF-PREMISE EMERGING MODELS 16 -Smart industrial kitchens rented out to restaurants - High-flexibility and easy expansion for current brands - Merit based: Low-cost barrier to entry for new brands - Players provide shared space, infrastructure, and SaaS - Brands renting dark kitchens or using existing underutilized restaurant space - Players in the space usually take charge in providing the brand, raw-materials, customer acquisition, and delivery support - Cooking-on-the-go renovated and sold with healthy margins - Players in the space provide well-equipped vehicle with a cooking space, and often an app Dark Kitchens Virtual Restaurants Autonomous Restaurants Fleet
  • 18.
  • 19.
    MULTIPLE SUCCESSFUL MODELSEMERGING IN THE REAL ESTATE SPACE 18
  • 20.
    OVERVIEW OF IBUYERMODEL 19 The iBuyer model requires getting involved in every step of the transaction
  • 21.
    SUCCESS FACTORS FORIBUYER MODELS 20 - Mortgage market for buyers - Debt capital market to fund homes up to ideally 90%+ - Culture of home ownership - High broker fees - High % of transactions going through brokers - High complexity transaction - Long time to close transaction (90+ days) - Availability of low priced assets that can be renovated and sold with healthy margin Every market Efficient markets Inefficient markets
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Ridesharing EVOLVING CAR MODELS 22 UsedNew Own Access Used car leasing New car leasing Allows consumers to sell to dealerships
  • 24.
    FRONTIER CAR GROUPIS BRINGING THE AUTO1 MODEL TO EMERGING MARKETS Frontier Car Group is bringing the Auto1 model to emerging markets Auto1 model has proven successful in Europe Not clear which markets are fully operational Initial target markets
  • 25.
    SUCCESS FACTORS FORCAR MODELS 24 Information sources and use Incumbents - Absence of wholesale marketplaces - Low penetration of largest incumbents Financing - Social acceptance of credit - Credit scoring system - Access to credit Macro factors - Market size - High and/or increasing car ownership - Price differential across regions - Potential for pricing models built on proprietary data set
  • 26.
  • 27.
    SUCCESSFUL JOBS MARKETPLACEMODELS 26 Blue collar Full Time Jobs Staffing / Gigs Vertical Marketplace Pick White collar
  • 28.
    SUCCESS FACTORS FORJOB MARKETPLACE MODELS 27 Regulatory - Employer responsibility for insurance/pension/sick leave/… - Ease of hiring/firing employees Macro factors - Industries which require rapid hiring/firing of large amounts of people (e.g. ride sharing or oil & gas for staffing) - Job churn in the market - Unemployment rates
  • 29.
  • 30.
    VERTICALIZATION OF HOMESERVICES MODELS 29 Horizontal services marketplace New verticalized and transactional competitorsHorizontals still dominate the bulk of home services models Managed marketplace for home maintenance and repairs B2B marketplace for construction materials Managed marketplace for home renovations Managed marketplace for restaurant renovations
  • 31.
  • 32.
    VERTICALIZATION OF LENDINGMODELS 31 … followed by a second wave of startups that address specific client needs The first wave of fintech challengers brought significant disruption to the market … Banking for self- employed freelancers Pay-as-you-go smart- phone purchasing POS financing for veterinary clinics Better returns for online shopping Lending for produce farmers
  • 33.
    SUCCESS FACTORS FORVERTICAL LENDING MODELS 32 Better understanding of customer needs • Faster decision making • Targeted UI/UX • Higher approval rates /lower cost Better customer experience Customer Needs Vertical Fintech Edge Outcome More business + more data ProducePay for farmers ScratchPay for vets ClearBanc for freelancers
  • 34.
    AMAZING THINGS LIEAHEAD! 33 Thank you!
  • 35.
    Thank you. FABRICE GRINDA fabrice@fjlabs.com JOSEMARIN jose@fjlabs.com 19 W 24th Street, 10th Floor, New York, NY www.FJLabs.com 34
  • 36.
    Selected Completed NOAHTransactions Focus on Leading European Internet companies Covering over 400 companies across 25 online verticals, a broad range of over 500 investors as well as 100+ online-focused corporates Deep understanding of industry dynamics Ability to add value beyond banking advice Facilitates overall process and minimizes management distraction NOAH Advisors is globally well connected and has direct access to virtually all key players in the industry Knowledge of and strong relationships with potential buyers’ key decision makers Proactively finds and unlocks attractive investment opportunities for leading investors Annual NOAH Conference in its 10th year Over 40 years of combined relevant M&A experience Routine execution of M&A and financing transactions with sizes of several billion euros 30 successfully completed NOAH Advisors transactions underline successful transfer of M&A competencies to the Internet sector Entrepreneurial mind-set, focused on growing the business and establishing a reputation for excellence Ability to deliver top results in short time frames Highly success-based compensation structures align interests of clients and NOAH Advisors, and demonstrate conviction to deliver top results Creative deal solutions Unique Industry Know-How Unmatched Network and Relationships Strong Investment Banking Competence Full Commitment - We Are Entrepreneurs! EUROPE’S LEADING INTERNET CORPORATE FINANCE BOUTIQUE® The NOAH Advisors Core Banking Team Marco Rodzynek Managing Director & Founder Jan Brandes Managing Director Nikhil Parmar Director Olek Skwarczek Associate Lukas Schlund Analyst December 2014 October 2014 Sale of 100% of for $800m to Exclusive Financial Advisor to Fotolia and the Selling Shareholders Sale of 100% of for €80m to Exclusive Financial Advisor to Trovit and its Shareholders October 2016 Investment in Exclusive Financial Advisor to KäuferPortal and its Shareholders by 84% Ownership December 2016 August 2017 Financial Advisor to Silver Lake Financial Advisor to EMK Capital Investment in Acquisition of a Majority Stake in by by at a valuation of $200m November 2019 July 2019 September 2018 Financial Advisor to MagicLab Financial Advisor to AU10TIX and its shareholders Financial Advisor to 10bis and its shareholders Acquisition of a 79% stake in $60m Investment in Sale of 100% in by at a valuation of ~$3 billion at a valuation of $260m by for €135m to 10Bis