2. Focus of Presentation
• Introducing how online learning works for Irish early school
leavers
• The use of authoring tools for reflective practice on
Learning Design
• Considering potential developments to enhance the iScoil
model of online learning
3. Online Learning
Education in which instruction and content are
delivered primarily over the Internet (Watson and Kalmon,
2005)
Blended Learning
Blended learning is any time a student learns at least in
part at a supervised brick-and-mortar location away
from home and at least in part through online delivery
with some element of student control over time, place,
path, and/or pace (Horn and Staker, 2011).
Virtual Learning Environment
A safe and secure learning platform that is reliable,
available online and accessible to a wide user base.
Keywords
4. The Global Picture
USA
• 50/52
States
1.5 million
students
3% of K-12
population
Canada
• All 13
states
200,000
students
3.4% K-12
population
Europe
• 80 Virtual
Schools
across 19
European
countries
Bascisch, 2013
5. iScoil – Early School Leavers
13-16yrs
Studies in interventions using technology emphasise
the ability of online learning environments to provide
a highly individualised and differentiated learning
experience (Archambault et al 2010).
iScoil Wordle
6. iScoil Enrolment 2012-2013
52 Learners
Gender and
Location
• Blended 19 M 2 F
• At-Home 23M 8 F
Reason for
Referral
• Anxiety 17%
• Disaffection 14%
• Behavioural 28%
• School Refusal 34%
• Illness 7%
Progression
Routes
• Solas 18%
• Community Training
Centre 21%
• Youthreach 18%
• Return to School 36%
• Unkown 7%
FETAC Level
3
• 60% achieved
Certification
• 20%Full Award General
Learning
8. Examining the Educational Experience
through the lens of
Community of Inquiry Model for Online Learning
(Garrison and Anderson, 2003)
EDUCATIONAL
EXPERIENCE
Supporting
Discourse
COGNITIVE
PRESENCE
Selecting
Content
TEACHING PRESENCE
Setting
Climate
SOCIAL PRESENCE
9. Cognitive and Teaching Presence –
Reflecting on Lesson Design
Authoring Tool Pedagogical Pattern Collector (Laurillard, 2011)
10. What are the Learning Activities for:
Communications Unit 2 Writing
Total online course material 335 minutes
Read Watch Listen
Practice
Investigate
Produce
14. How the roles support a student through a learning
outcome
Subject
Expert
Student Mentor
Authoring Tool – Open GLM Developed at
University of Vienna
15. Authoring Tool – Open GLM Developed at
University of Vienna
Teaching and Social Presence....
What does the authoring tool tell us
Positive Affirmation
Individual Assessment
Student Paced
Interest Led Content
Feedback Loops
16. iScoil students on the learning experience ….
I really liked that I could log on later in the day and do
the tasks then, My brain works better when I'm fully
awake and when I was in regular schooling I would be
really tired and couldn't concentrate as much because
of it. I also like that I can use the Internet to look up
things I'm not 100% sure about.
Well you’re not stuck in all day from early
morning until night….
Very handy better than
writing or books... I’m
terrible at writing I’d rather
the computer it’s handy.
17. The teachers experience ….
..... like if you do kind of set projects task and previously
you’d only kind of be getting short answers for that and then
you suddenly give them a task about World War Two or
something and you come back and they’re written this big
long essay full of descriptive language and it’s that they
actually have no problems with literacy, just that they weren’t
interested in what you were giving them.......
but sometimes the hard thing is you don’t even get any
feedback from students
If you’ve got a student that’s not engaging you can change our
approach ..you could give them the same content in a different
way …. It gives you that chance of trying
Lots of different things
18. Considering the above within the
framework of a Community of Enquiry
Model
Active Learning
Competency Based
Student Centred Assessment
Flexible
Personalised
SafeConstructivist
Portfolio Assessment Adaptable
Feedback Loops
Positive
19. Video Conferencing for Maths Instruction
Potential for Integrating Social Networking
Interest Led Cross Accredited Short Courses
iScoil model for school settings
Conclusion
Some Developments, Improvements and Further Study for iScoil
The Institute for Prospective Technological Studies identifies
eight encompassing and interconnected dimensions that work
together to design creative learning and innovative pedagogies
using ICT: Content and Curricula, Assessment, Learning
Practices, Teaching Practices Organisation, Leadership and
Values, Connectedness, Infrastructure (Bocconi et al, 2012).
Synchronous Social Presence
Student Online Collaboration
Competency Based Assessment
A model for Prevention
20. References
Archambault, L. et al. (2010). Research Committee issues brief: An
exploration of at-risk learners and online education. Vienna, VA:
International Association for K–12 Online Learning (iNACOL).
Bascish, P. (2013) Theory of Benchmarking for e-Learning
A Top-Level Literature Review www.virtualschoolsandcolleges.info
Bocconi, S., Kampylis, P., and Punie, Y. (2012). Innovating Teaching and
Learning Practices: Key Elements for Developing Creative Classrooms in
Europe. Elearningeuropa.info
Garrison, D.R. & Anderson, T. (2003). E-Learning in the 21st Century.
London: RoutledgeFalmer.
Laurillard D. & Ljubojevic D. (2011). Evaluating learning
designs through the formal representation of pedagogical
patterns. In Investigations of E-Learning Patterns: Context
Factors, Problems and Solutions (eds J.W. Kohls & C.
Kohls), pp. 86–105. IGI Global, Hershey, PA.
Luis P. Prieto et al. (2013). Learning design Rashomon II: exploring one
lesson through multiple tools. Research in Learning Technology Vol. 21
Editor's Notes
Overview of how an online learning community works to re-engage young early school leavers by
introducing the model of online learning used
Taking a close look at the design for learning using two authoring tools
Identifying gaps in the model and potential for future developments and research
Huge growth in online learning in the last 5-10 years. To establish exactly what it means in this study. Yes there can be misconceptions of transferring distance education or resource sharing via the internet but the difference is in the delivery of instruction and the platform used to facilitate the support and interaction required to establish a true sense of learning community. Blended learning combines online and face to face. Emphasis Tool not a panacea. D’Arcy Elamp project importance of teaching support.
Placing Ireland in the Global picture. Rise in the States primary and secondary. Australia New Zealand. Difference in Europe is that virtual schools tend not to be integrated into mainstream education but instead address educational disadvantage or facilitate ill children or transient families – Visced.
Who we are. Short background Notschool/Stephen Heppell. 2007 pilot Notschool Ireland 2009 iScoil. Funded by Presentation Sisters. An EU statistic is quite staggering ‘to reduce the average European early school leaving rate by just 1 percentage point would provide the European economy each year with nearly half a million additional qualified potential young employees’. European Commission p3. (COM 2011).
Since 2009 worked with approximately 130 young people. 45-50 students in a year. Geographical spread.
Referral Process. NEWB Partnership. Reason for referral-range of reason. The development and growth of blended centres Locations Division in reason for referral between blended and at-home learners. FETAC level 3 – continous assessment/portfolios. Certification growing each year as we learn and develop strategies for engagement and design of curriculum and content.
Moodle Student Centred Design Personalised Individual Learning Plan Self Paced Open 9am-8pm Interest Led Roles on iScoil
Learning Plan refreshed at least once a day Core subjects 6 modules Weekly reports
How does it work? Grown organically in response to needs. It works in practice how does it work in theory. What is the learning experience made up of? Examine closely through lens of COI. Dewey and Peirce model for scientific investigation Garrison/Anderson Canada to provide conceptual order and a good practice tool for use of computer mediated communication in supporting an educational experience. Constitutes three channels essential to an educational transaction – Cognitive/Social/Teaching Presence
Briefly what the elements within these channels are/mean
Using Authoring tools normally used in the advance planning of courses to reflect on the design of lessons. Based on study by Prieto et al. Pedagogical Pattern Collector analyses the learning types used. Communications Module Unit 2 Writing Learning outcomes skills based … Draft at least 3 pieces of writing …. Use writing to discuss learning aims/plans/tasks. Places the lesson design and how the activities break down into a framework
What we want to see is how the learning types are used
The balance of Learning Types in the iScoil core curriculum for Communications Feedback from Subject Specialists. Communication
Feedback from Subject Experts Communications v Maths Difference in what works for a subject Teaching of concepts and understanding Ability to give feedback Synchronous v asynchronous What are gaps? – Instructional element to maths Synchronous Interaction
Revisiting the roles to expore how they work together.
Open GLM authoring tool that maps the roles and what they do OpenGLM …. an application allowing the graphical design of IMS Learning Design compliant learning and teaching flows by capturing the complexity of the IMS LD specification in a coherent interface Mapping the flow of progression and interaction
Teaching and Social Presence Refer back to COI Elements of good practice identified along the learning path What are the gaps Synchronous communication Student feedback and interaction
Stories …
Stories…..
Some teachers miss meeting the students however some prefer the sense of equality
COI model revisited with the outcomes of how the learning experience works from the analysis using the authoring tools and feedback from students and teachers.
Identified elements of Good practice. Now what are the gaps and what could be improved
ICT as the tool to design creative learning and innovative pedagogies ….
Gaps identified and potential developments