EVALUATION Q.2
HOW DOES YOUR
MEDIA PRODUCT
REPRESENT PARTICULAR
SOCIAL GROUPS?
AUDIENCE
Primary audience:
Class:
Income bracket: C2-D
Race:
White (British)
Age:
15-24
Gender:
Males and Females
Sexuality:
Heterosexuals
Secondary audience:
Class:
 Income bracket: B-C2
Race:
 White (British)
Age:
 25-34
Gender:
 Males and Females
Sexuality:
 Heterosexuals
CLASS
(INCOME BRACKET)
• Our main protagonist, Anna is very similar to our primary audience
as she is a working class woman within the C2-D income bracket as
the audience. Within the main film narrative, we have mentioned
that she is a university student which confirms the modern
stereotype that working class people are hard workers, which would
be represented in the film. Her unstable income helps to create an
empathetic link with the audience as they then struggle together as
they have either had or are having the same experience concerning
the limits and setbacks that low incomes result in. The theory of
uses and gratifications can be applied here. For instance, personal
identity with Anna as she is a university student, much like many of
our 15-24 primary mass audience, however it can also be applied
referencing back to the ‘empathetic link’ which would help to
create personal identity but also social interaction as it would
encourage them to interact with other viewers or fans about what
they thought of the characters circumstances/ situation being
similar to theirs.
RACE
• Anna is British and stereotypically white, which is the same race as the
audience we are targeting which helps to gain personal identity as they are
of the same nationality. This would then appeal to our secondary audience
as they are more traditional and take pride in nationalism. A common
representation of white/British is that they are ambitious and more affluent
than others, however this is challenged by Anna as she has thrown away
any ambition except to survive. It can also be seen that she subverts the
affluent stereotype as she is isolated in a simplistic tent with nothing but a
torch – further emphasising her distance from any urban civilisation.
• Our antagonist is also White, creating a more challenging representation
that enemy’s are not always of a separate race or origin (foreign) – which is
a preferred ideology of the mass market as that would make the ideology
that the British are better than the enemy; and will always win/prevail – but
rather connoting anyone could be an attacker and doesn’t discriminate on
race or religion.
AGE
• The age of the primary audience is 15-24 which is the same category that Anna
falls into at the age of 19. According to the hierarchy of needs, people within this
age group look towards media product to satisfy their needs for safety or love
and belonging, however our film rejects both as Anna runs away from her
dangers and the violence, to a tent that provides no protection. Similarly the
look for love and belonging is also rejected as Anna was with her friends and
family, however even that has been taken away from her against her will. This
may create personal identity with those in the audience who may have had their
loved ones taken by death.
• This age group would also be considered digital natives however even this is
taken away from Anna, placing her into a secluded world where even the oldest
of technologies are know where to be found. This only acts to highlight how she
has been separated from urban society.
• The obvious age difference between the antagonist and protagonist highlights
the representations of age presented. For example as the man is older, this
represents the stereotype that it is old men who prey on the younger, vulnerable
women as they are outgoing due to the young age, but easy to deceive and
trick.
GENDER
• As Anna is a female, this will create personal identity with the
female half of the audience. She would also create a link to the
male audience as she is the stereotypical ‘Damsel in distress’ that
needs saving.
• The antagonist confirms the male stereotype as he is strong,
powerful and has dominance over Anna. His violent and aggressive
personality also represents that of a working class man as his
behaviour also connotes that he only kills people for pleasure.
When he picks up the knife, we can see that it represents a phallic
symbol showing sexual imagery. This only further connotes and
confirms the stereotype that only men are rapists.
• The use of Anna's red clothing connotes her femininity where as
the antagonist dark brown and black clothing only further
highlights his stereotypical masculinity and threat.
SEXUALITY
• As only a single man and a single woman are featured within
our production, only heterosexuals would find any identity or
connection as they are of the same sexuality.
• Furthermore, the heterosexual relationship between all of the
group of friends from the whole film narrative help to develop
ideologies that relationships should only be between man and
woman as they are the only types of relationships featured.
CONSTRUCTIONIST
THEORY
The constructionist theory can be applied to any representation as it is made
up of three things: opinion of the producer/ reality/ social content.
• Women are physically and mentally weaker than men.
• Opinion: women are physically weaker than men as they cannot do what men do.
• Reality: women are biologically built differently to men, with less capability to build
muscle mass.
• Social content: Traditionally, women were weaker than men as they were stay-at-home
housewives, where as the men would do the heavy lifting and be the bread-winner.
Although many people in todays society have accepted that men and women are of
the same status. Emotionally speaking, women have learnt to give voice to their
opinions and emotions, where as men stereotypical have not – remaining silent and
don’t share their feelings.
• Yes, women are beginning to have more a voice, but there is still an evident difference
between men and women that still promotes this ideology. The fact that women are
seen as having a ‘voice’ now, could be argued to further promote the ideology of them
being mentally weaker as it’s the idea that they should just be able to cope and get on
with it (like men who don’t stereotypically share their feelings)
HEGEMONIC IDEOLOGIES
• A hegemonic ideology is a message that seems to be positive but is actually negative and
acts to keep the lower classes in their place.
• An example of this would be the ideology that you should spend lots of money on
expensive trips, of travel e.g. go camping. This seems like a negative message as it makes
the lower classes spend their money. nonetheless, Anna and her group try to attempt to go
on a camping holiday without spending money, and just relying on the pure basics. Anna is
being punished for not spending enough money on camping equipment/a nice hotel
room, which is then telling the audience to spend their money on get-a-ways as they may
encounter hardships such as this within the narrative if they don’t . This ideology keeps the
working class community below those who are in the modern upper/higher classes as it
makes them spend the money that they have earnt, encouraging them to then go back to
work to earn more money as they have spend most of it.
• Another hegemonic ideology would be that as Anna was able to survive, despite being
separated and secluded from urban civilisation, this promotes a positive ideology that it is
okay to become over-reliant on technology as it wouldn’t effect our chances of survival.
However the underlying negative ideology would make us over reliant on technology,
urging us to buy more - satisfying shops and sellers – resulting in the population becoming
lazy, fat and unable to fight against those of the higher class who control everything.
FEMALE REPRESENTATION
• We are able to apply Mulvey's male gaze to Anna’s character as she is objectified
through the eyes of the male antagonist. This is because he sees here merely as
‘prey’ and himself the ‘predator’. This de-humanises Anna to an animal, taking away
her femininity and instead sexualises her.
• Instead, however, we are able to apply Janice Winship’s notion of complicity. This is
because even though Anna is running away from the male antagonists, she is
attracting him even more due to her bright red clothing. As Anna is wearing the
colour red, red connotes romance an pleasure, however this can be changed into
connoting a dangerous sexual desire from the antagonists male perspective. This
then further connotes she is being punished by the man for displaying any signs of
her sexuality/desire.
• On the other hand we could apply Gauntlett's empowered female as Anna is
represented as a strong, brave and independent woman when she uses her own
initiative to save her self – without relying on anyone else. Even more so, when Anna
escapes by herself and survives, this connotes the power of woman and how they an
accomplish things even without the help of men – as stereotypically women were
seen to be weak and reliant on males.
• Barthes striptease theory cannot be applied as Anna is wearing thick clothing,
connoting that she is controlling her sexuality, further shown as she doesn't take it
off, and doesn’t attempt to sexualise herself, even in the presence of a male.
DO THEY SUIT OUR
INSTITUTION?
• I think our representations that we have included within our production is
not conventional for independent companies as representations are usually
challenging, as they appeal to the older sophisticated audience, however in
terms of our primary and secondary audience, I think we were able to use
all the appropriate representations that would appeal to both our primary
and secondary audience. We should have provided more thought
provoking ideologies and challenge more stereotypes as this would have
been more conventional for our independent production.
• More explicitly, although we are quite conventional, this can still suit our
institution mainly because of the genre that our production is as it means
we have a primary mass audience - as independents tend to make horrors
for their cost effective revenue returns.
• I think we could have improved this if we had incorporated more
conventional representations and ideologies that challenged or subverted
stereotypes as it would have made us a more conventional independent
production.

Evaluation Question 2

  • 1.
    EVALUATION Q.2 HOW DOESYOUR MEDIA PRODUCT REPRESENT PARTICULAR SOCIAL GROUPS?
  • 2.
    AUDIENCE Primary audience: Class: Income bracket:C2-D Race: White (British) Age: 15-24 Gender: Males and Females Sexuality: Heterosexuals Secondary audience: Class:  Income bracket: B-C2 Race:  White (British) Age:  25-34 Gender:  Males and Females Sexuality:  Heterosexuals
  • 3.
    CLASS (INCOME BRACKET) • Ourmain protagonist, Anna is very similar to our primary audience as she is a working class woman within the C2-D income bracket as the audience. Within the main film narrative, we have mentioned that she is a university student which confirms the modern stereotype that working class people are hard workers, which would be represented in the film. Her unstable income helps to create an empathetic link with the audience as they then struggle together as they have either had or are having the same experience concerning the limits and setbacks that low incomes result in. The theory of uses and gratifications can be applied here. For instance, personal identity with Anna as she is a university student, much like many of our 15-24 primary mass audience, however it can also be applied referencing back to the ‘empathetic link’ which would help to create personal identity but also social interaction as it would encourage them to interact with other viewers or fans about what they thought of the characters circumstances/ situation being similar to theirs.
  • 4.
    RACE • Anna isBritish and stereotypically white, which is the same race as the audience we are targeting which helps to gain personal identity as they are of the same nationality. This would then appeal to our secondary audience as they are more traditional and take pride in nationalism. A common representation of white/British is that they are ambitious and more affluent than others, however this is challenged by Anna as she has thrown away any ambition except to survive. It can also be seen that she subverts the affluent stereotype as she is isolated in a simplistic tent with nothing but a torch – further emphasising her distance from any urban civilisation. • Our antagonist is also White, creating a more challenging representation that enemy’s are not always of a separate race or origin (foreign) – which is a preferred ideology of the mass market as that would make the ideology that the British are better than the enemy; and will always win/prevail – but rather connoting anyone could be an attacker and doesn’t discriminate on race or religion.
  • 5.
    AGE • The ageof the primary audience is 15-24 which is the same category that Anna falls into at the age of 19. According to the hierarchy of needs, people within this age group look towards media product to satisfy their needs for safety or love and belonging, however our film rejects both as Anna runs away from her dangers and the violence, to a tent that provides no protection. Similarly the look for love and belonging is also rejected as Anna was with her friends and family, however even that has been taken away from her against her will. This may create personal identity with those in the audience who may have had their loved ones taken by death. • This age group would also be considered digital natives however even this is taken away from Anna, placing her into a secluded world where even the oldest of technologies are know where to be found. This only acts to highlight how she has been separated from urban society. • The obvious age difference between the antagonist and protagonist highlights the representations of age presented. For example as the man is older, this represents the stereotype that it is old men who prey on the younger, vulnerable women as they are outgoing due to the young age, but easy to deceive and trick.
  • 6.
    GENDER • As Annais a female, this will create personal identity with the female half of the audience. She would also create a link to the male audience as she is the stereotypical ‘Damsel in distress’ that needs saving. • The antagonist confirms the male stereotype as he is strong, powerful and has dominance over Anna. His violent and aggressive personality also represents that of a working class man as his behaviour also connotes that he only kills people for pleasure. When he picks up the knife, we can see that it represents a phallic symbol showing sexual imagery. This only further connotes and confirms the stereotype that only men are rapists. • The use of Anna's red clothing connotes her femininity where as the antagonist dark brown and black clothing only further highlights his stereotypical masculinity and threat.
  • 7.
    SEXUALITY • As onlya single man and a single woman are featured within our production, only heterosexuals would find any identity or connection as they are of the same sexuality. • Furthermore, the heterosexual relationship between all of the group of friends from the whole film narrative help to develop ideologies that relationships should only be between man and woman as they are the only types of relationships featured.
  • 8.
    CONSTRUCTIONIST THEORY The constructionist theorycan be applied to any representation as it is made up of three things: opinion of the producer/ reality/ social content. • Women are physically and mentally weaker than men. • Opinion: women are physically weaker than men as they cannot do what men do. • Reality: women are biologically built differently to men, with less capability to build muscle mass. • Social content: Traditionally, women were weaker than men as they were stay-at-home housewives, where as the men would do the heavy lifting and be the bread-winner. Although many people in todays society have accepted that men and women are of the same status. Emotionally speaking, women have learnt to give voice to their opinions and emotions, where as men stereotypical have not – remaining silent and don’t share their feelings. • Yes, women are beginning to have more a voice, but there is still an evident difference between men and women that still promotes this ideology. The fact that women are seen as having a ‘voice’ now, could be argued to further promote the ideology of them being mentally weaker as it’s the idea that they should just be able to cope and get on with it (like men who don’t stereotypically share their feelings)
  • 9.
    HEGEMONIC IDEOLOGIES • Ahegemonic ideology is a message that seems to be positive but is actually negative and acts to keep the lower classes in their place. • An example of this would be the ideology that you should spend lots of money on expensive trips, of travel e.g. go camping. This seems like a negative message as it makes the lower classes spend their money. nonetheless, Anna and her group try to attempt to go on a camping holiday without spending money, and just relying on the pure basics. Anna is being punished for not spending enough money on camping equipment/a nice hotel room, which is then telling the audience to spend their money on get-a-ways as they may encounter hardships such as this within the narrative if they don’t . This ideology keeps the working class community below those who are in the modern upper/higher classes as it makes them spend the money that they have earnt, encouraging them to then go back to work to earn more money as they have spend most of it. • Another hegemonic ideology would be that as Anna was able to survive, despite being separated and secluded from urban civilisation, this promotes a positive ideology that it is okay to become over-reliant on technology as it wouldn’t effect our chances of survival. However the underlying negative ideology would make us over reliant on technology, urging us to buy more - satisfying shops and sellers – resulting in the population becoming lazy, fat and unable to fight against those of the higher class who control everything.
  • 10.
    FEMALE REPRESENTATION • Weare able to apply Mulvey's male gaze to Anna’s character as she is objectified through the eyes of the male antagonist. This is because he sees here merely as ‘prey’ and himself the ‘predator’. This de-humanises Anna to an animal, taking away her femininity and instead sexualises her. • Instead, however, we are able to apply Janice Winship’s notion of complicity. This is because even though Anna is running away from the male antagonists, she is attracting him even more due to her bright red clothing. As Anna is wearing the colour red, red connotes romance an pleasure, however this can be changed into connoting a dangerous sexual desire from the antagonists male perspective. This then further connotes she is being punished by the man for displaying any signs of her sexuality/desire. • On the other hand we could apply Gauntlett's empowered female as Anna is represented as a strong, brave and independent woman when she uses her own initiative to save her self – without relying on anyone else. Even more so, when Anna escapes by herself and survives, this connotes the power of woman and how they an accomplish things even without the help of men – as stereotypically women were seen to be weak and reliant on males. • Barthes striptease theory cannot be applied as Anna is wearing thick clothing, connoting that she is controlling her sexuality, further shown as she doesn't take it off, and doesn’t attempt to sexualise herself, even in the presence of a male.
  • 11.
    DO THEY SUITOUR INSTITUTION? • I think our representations that we have included within our production is not conventional for independent companies as representations are usually challenging, as they appeal to the older sophisticated audience, however in terms of our primary and secondary audience, I think we were able to use all the appropriate representations that would appeal to both our primary and secondary audience. We should have provided more thought provoking ideologies and challenge more stereotypes as this would have been more conventional for our independent production. • More explicitly, although we are quite conventional, this can still suit our institution mainly because of the genre that our production is as it means we have a primary mass audience - as independents tend to make horrors for their cost effective revenue returns. • I think we could have improved this if we had incorporated more conventional representations and ideologies that challenged or subverted stereotypes as it would have made us a more conventional independent production.