This document provides a form for evaluating three papers. The evaluator is asked to rate each paper as excellent, fair, or poor and provide three reasons for the rating. They must also identify the chief strength and weakness of each paper.

1. Paper Evaluation Names: ___________
Directions: Read each paper and then rate each as excellent, fair or poor.
Paper one: Rating_______ Give three reasons for your rating.
1.)
2.)
3.)
Chief strength: Chief weakness:
1.) 1.)
Paper two: Rating_______ Give three reasons for your rating.
1.)
2.)
3.)
Chief strength: Chief weakness:
1.) 1.)
Paper three: Rating_______ Give three reasons for your rating.
1.)
2.)
3.)
Chief strength: Chief weakness:
1.) 1.)