If you could design a social innovation course that addressed your local community’s wicked problems, what would it look like? For us, we wanted motivated problem-finders. We wanted to use design thinking and sprints to build quickly and often. We wanted to do away with grades. We wanted students to focus only on our course, nothing more. We wanted students who brought disciplinary knowledge to work across majors. So, in Spring 2017, a faculty team from Elon University designed a huge 16-credit-hour “social innovation lab” course with the goal of enacting real social change in the local community. We succeeded, we failed, and we’re ready to share our lessons learned from when we tried to break free from the structures of academia.