Densitometric probe based on non-differential pressure
the technique allowing to follow suspended matter loads at very high concentrations
Department of Water Pollution Control
D. Petrovic, A. Marescaux, J-P. Vanderborght & M. A. Verbanck
IT4water project
Suspended sediment monitoring: no universal technique
FIT
LISST
WTW ViSolid
Advanced optical
probes
Gamma
Alpha
Nuclear probes
UHCM
aDcp
Densitune
Vibrating
device
Acoustic methods Remote Sensing Densitometry
(760 - 900 nm)
Manual
Differential
pressure
Rapid changes in water depth and suspended sediment concentrations (10 to 30 g/L). Surveillance bridge in
Caojiaquan, Lower Yellow River, Northern China.
Rapid changes in water depth and SSC (10 - 30 g/l)
Caojiaquan, Lower Yellow River, Northern China
St Donat-sur-Herbasse, France, 6 Sep 2008
Which sensing method is available to monitor SSC at these high concentrations ?
T°
p
p0
H’
pressure
sensor in air
radar
limnimeter
H
pressure
sensor &
thermometer
Densitometric probe – based of absolute pressure measurements
Proxy method based on combination of four sensors
M. A. Verbanck, D. Petrovic & J-P. Vanderborght
International patent application N° PCT/EP2012/054135
5
rw
(T) =
rw
(T0
)
1+b(T - T0
)
Cv =
rw
(T)
rs
- rw
(T)
p- p0
rw
(T)gH
-1
æ
è
çç
ö
ø
÷÷
suspended sediment volumetric concentration
Densitometric probe – basic principles
p= rL
gH
rL
= (1-Cv)rW
(T)+Cvrs
Observed suspended sediment volumetric concentration versus known suspended
sediment volumetric concentration (relative error less than 9%)
Test in static conditions
 2,5 m deep cylindrical tank
 water level at 2 m
 water temperature & atm
pressure constant
 test of various sensors
Amazon river plume data:
- campaign to test DensiTune instrument (acoustic characterization of sediments)
- Lab "Acoustics and environmental Hydroacoustics”, ULB , June 2012 ,
led by Prof. Hermand
Cv =
rw
(T)
rs
- rw
(T)
p- p0
rw
(T)gH
-C
vsalt
rsalt
- rw
(T)
rw
(T)
-1
æ
è
çç
ö
ø
÷÷
Test in environment with non negligible salt presence
Densitometric probe – validation in natural environment
Ecuador – Jadan river (SSC up to 25g/l)
Jan-Apr 2014 – expected rain season
Results
 application in complex geometry
 use of sensors with regular sensitivity
Difficulties:
 unexpected weather conditions
 influence of air bubbles & floatables
 water level measurement problems
Ecuador – Jadan river (Jan-Apr 2014 )
Densitometric probe – validation in natural environment
Densitometric probe – (potential) new test site
Laval, Draix – French Southern Alps
Monitoring since 1984
 water level:
 before 1997: bulle-à-bulle,
US, ellan & pressure sensor
 presently: US &
conductivity based method
 SSC – sampling + optical device
Hyperconcentrated black marly slurry
800 g/l on Aug 13, 1997
Densitometric probe concept applied on historical data at Laval
maximal SSC in g/l
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
31/07/1990 12:00 1/08/1990 00:00 1/08/1990 12:00 2/08/1990 00:00
SSC(g/l)
SSC by filtration
densitometric probe
Densitometric probe concept applied on historical data at Laval
13
question & issues we would like to discuss
 reliability of water level measurements by pressure sensor
(air bubbles, sediment presence)
 when to turn to another methods?
 best protection from dynamic effects
 search for a new test location – any suggestion?
 high concentrations
& fine sediment particles
SPARE SLIDES
 advantages:
 monitoring high SSC
 continuous real-time monitoring
 dynamical alluvial rivers
 short time scales: local resuspension
 cost reduction
 additional water parameters info
 disadvantages:
 limited sensitivity: not appropriate for low suspended sediment
concentrations
15
Densitometric probe – based of absolute pressure measurements
Gray, J. R., and J. W. Gartner (2009), Technological advances in suspended-sediment surrogate monitoring,
Water Resour.Res., 45, W00D29.

Dragana densitometry 2nd-behydroday_v2

  • 1.
    Densitometric probe basedon non-differential pressure the technique allowing to follow suspended matter loads at very high concentrations Department of Water Pollution Control D. Petrovic, A. Marescaux, J-P. Vanderborght & M. A. Verbanck IT4water project
  • 2.
    Suspended sediment monitoring:no universal technique FIT LISST WTW ViSolid Advanced optical probes Gamma Alpha Nuclear probes UHCM aDcp Densitune Vibrating device Acoustic methods Remote Sensing Densitometry (760 - 900 nm) Manual Differential pressure
  • 3.
    Rapid changes inwater depth and suspended sediment concentrations (10 to 30 g/L). Surveillance bridge in Caojiaquan, Lower Yellow River, Northern China. Rapid changes in water depth and SSC (10 - 30 g/l) Caojiaquan, Lower Yellow River, Northern China St Donat-sur-Herbasse, France, 6 Sep 2008 Which sensing method is available to monitor SSC at these high concentrations ?
  • 4.
    T° p p0 H’ pressure sensor in air radar limnimeter H pressure sensor& thermometer Densitometric probe – based of absolute pressure measurements Proxy method based on combination of four sensors M. A. Verbanck, D. Petrovic & J-P. Vanderborght International patent application N° PCT/EP2012/054135
  • 5.
    5 rw (T) = rw (T0 ) 1+b(T -T0 ) Cv = rw (T) rs - rw (T) p- p0 rw (T)gH -1 æ è çç ö ø ÷÷ suspended sediment volumetric concentration Densitometric probe – basic principles p= rL gH rL = (1-Cv)rW (T)+Cvrs
  • 6.
    Observed suspended sedimentvolumetric concentration versus known suspended sediment volumetric concentration (relative error less than 9%) Test in static conditions  2,5 m deep cylindrical tank  water level at 2 m  water temperature & atm pressure constant  test of various sensors
  • 7.
    Amazon river plumedata: - campaign to test DensiTune instrument (acoustic characterization of sediments) - Lab "Acoustics and environmental Hydroacoustics”, ULB , June 2012 , led by Prof. Hermand Cv = rw (T) rs - rw (T) p- p0 rw (T)gH -C vsalt rsalt - rw (T) rw (T) -1 æ è çç ö ø ÷÷ Test in environment with non negligible salt presence
  • 8.
    Densitometric probe –validation in natural environment Ecuador – Jadan river (SSC up to 25g/l) Jan-Apr 2014 – expected rain season
  • 9.
    Results  application incomplex geometry  use of sensors with regular sensitivity Difficulties:  unexpected weather conditions  influence of air bubbles & floatables  water level measurement problems Ecuador – Jadan river (Jan-Apr 2014 ) Densitometric probe – validation in natural environment
  • 10.
    Densitometric probe –(potential) new test site Laval, Draix – French Southern Alps Monitoring since 1984  water level:  before 1997: bulle-à-bulle, US, ellan & pressure sensor  presently: US & conductivity based method  SSC – sampling + optical device
  • 11.
    Hyperconcentrated black marlyslurry 800 g/l on Aug 13, 1997 Densitometric probe concept applied on historical data at Laval maximal SSC in g/l
  • 12.
    0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 31/07/1990 12:00 1/08/199000:00 1/08/1990 12:00 2/08/1990 00:00 SSC(g/l) SSC by filtration densitometric probe Densitometric probe concept applied on historical data at Laval
  • 13.
    13 question & issueswe would like to discuss  reliability of water level measurements by pressure sensor (air bubbles, sediment presence)  when to turn to another methods?  best protection from dynamic effects  search for a new test location – any suggestion?  high concentrations & fine sediment particles
  • 14.
  • 15.
     advantages:  monitoringhigh SSC  continuous real-time monitoring  dynamical alluvial rivers  short time scales: local resuspension  cost reduction  additional water parameters info  disadvantages:  limited sensitivity: not appropriate for low suspended sediment concentrations 15 Densitometric probe – based of absolute pressure measurements
  • 17.
    Gray, J. R.,and J. W. Gartner (2009), Technological advances in suspended-sediment surrogate monitoring, Water Resour.Res., 45, W00D29.