Discussion: Cross fertilisation among tried-out schemes: a useful path toward harmonisation

•

0 likes•202 views

Presented by Antonio Capozza, CESI Ricerca, Italy, at the IEA DSM Programme workshop in Milan, Italy on 22 October 2008.

Presentations & Public Speaking

White Certificates:
the Italian experiences gained in Regulation,
Monitoring & Verification and Electricity Market contexts.
Milano
October 22nd 2008
Discussion
Cross fertilisation among tried-out
schemes: a useful path toward
harmonisation?

2Antonio Capozza
Situation in a ferment:
EC ESD Directive promotes harmonised
EE calculation models
National and international Committees for
standardisation (e.g. CEN/CENELEC)
EU funded projects (e.g. EMEEES)
IEA-DSM new proposed Tasks
World “at work”: harmonisation
concepts cross over Europe
Harmonisation

3Antonio Capozza
EU-wide White Certificate scheme
involves:
extra-national exchange
harmonisation among national EE
evaluation procedures
abandon national targets, replaced by
efficiency commitments referred to the
exchange area
Harmonisation and White Certificates

4Antonio Capozza
Harmonisation: some already pointed out opinions:
IEA-DSM Task XIV: very hard:
Country-dependent criteria for baseline (e.g. local market of
appliances)
Contingent savings accounting; e.g. subjective
overevaluation of certificates when:
• generated in zones with congested grids,
• produced in zones with little capacity of new generation
• driven by social implications (poverty policies)
Energy/environment advantages not transfered with
certificates trading (they remain in the issuing country)
EuroWhiteCert project: similar though less categoric
concerns
Harmonisation and White Certificates

5Antonio Capozza
Can common schemes on White
Certificates foster and drive the process
of harmonisation?
Is a widely shared EU scheme on White
Certificates really so hard to be devised?
Which are the main envisaged
difficulties for a common scheme?
Which are the most effective envisaged
actions to overcome barriers?
Starting points for discussion

The document discusses recent legal challenges before the ECHA Board of Appeal and new regulations regarding data sharing transparency. It summarizes cases related to substance evaluation and compliance checks. It also outlines the new Commission Implementing Regulation 2016/9 which establishes principles for data sharing agreements, including itemizing costs, record keeping requirements, and retroactivity. The document provides templates for calculating data costs, administrative expenses, and letter of access prices according to the new rules.

Rammeverk: Meets programme

Nordisk statistikermøte 2013

The MEETS program aims to modernize European business and trade statistics by reducing costs and increasing relevance. It has four key objectives: review priorities, streamline frameworks, increase efficient production, and modernize Intrastat. It has a budget of 42.5 million euros over five years (2009-2013) to support networks, grants to member states, and procurements. Results include the EuroGroups Register providing infrastructure to measure activities of multinational enterprises and profiling analyses to more efficiently collect data from enterprise groups in a confidential manner. It also provides recommendations to revise statistical unit definitions and increase use of administrative and accounts data in statistical warehouses.

REACH - Enforcement controls / Practical tips

Lorenzo Zullo

This document provides an overview and tips for preparing for an enforcement authority visit regarding REACH regulations in the EU. It discusses the following key points: 1. Industry expects uniform, consistent, and transparent enforcement of REACH across the EU. Sanctions should distinguish between deliberate and accidental non-compliance. 2. The Cefic REACH Enforcement Group shares experiences from company inspections. Inspections are becoming more comprehensive and sometimes lack clarity on scope. Advance notice, relevant experts available, and feedback are most effective. 3. Authority advice includes preparing relevant documentation, clearly understanding obligations, and admitting what you don't know. International companies should appoint local representatives trained by a dedicated REACH team.

REACH - Enforceability of new restrictions

Lorenzo Zullo

Highlights in the IEA Implementing Agreement on Demand Side Management

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

This document summarizes highlights from the Implementing Agreement Demand Side Management. It discusses the IEA DSM Programme's vision of making demand side activities the first choice in energy policy decisions. The document outlines the IEA DSM Programme's mission to provide stakeholders with guidance on crafting and implementing DSM policies and measures. It then provides examples on load shape simplification, case studies of ESCO contracts that achieved both cost and CO2 savings, the role of customers in smart grids, applying behavior change theory in practice, and information on energy efficiency obligations.

UK: A Market-led Response to Energy Efficiency

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

This document summarizes the UK's Energy Efficiency Commitment (EEC) policy, which places obligations on domestic energy suppliers to improve energy efficiency. It discusses that the EEC has gradually increased targets and scope since 2002. Suppliers must meet energy savings targets, with at least 50% in low-income groups. The market approach allows suppliers flexibility in measures. Most suppliers met EEC2 targets. The policy has effectively improved housing efficiency but further work is needed on more expensive measures and electricity use. The new Carbon Emissions Reduction Target doubles previous targets but maintains the market approach.

Italian White Certificates Market: Main Results and Experience Gained

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Smart Metering, Load Control and Customer Behaviour – Task 15 - IEA DSM Progr...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

The document discusses energy service company (ESCo) business models and market development. It makes the following key points: 1. The two basic ESCo business models are energy performance contracting (EPC) and energy supply contracting (ESC). ESC makes up around 90% of the German ESCo market, which is worth approximately 1.6 billion Euros per year. 2. ESC focuses on renewable energy supply and is well-suited for applications like CHP, while EPC guarantees energy savings but makes up a smaller share of the market due to higher transaction costs. 3. An emerging "integrated energy contracting" model combines the strengths of ESC and EPC to provide both energy supply and savings.

Demand Side Management (DSM) A renewed tool for sustainable development A sur...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? The EU's energy efficiency policies scrutinise...

Leonardo ENERGY

The European Court of Auditors (ECA) promotes accountability and transparency, and acts as the independent guardian of the financial interests of the EU citizens. ECA recently published two reports about EU energy efficiency policies (about appliances and buildings). This webinar will present ECA’s role in the EU policy process, how it relates to evaluation, and the main conclusions from the two recent reports.

Market Mechanisms for White Certificates

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

John Ketchell

Standardization2010

1. The document discusses the fragmented European standards landscape for ICT and calls for better integration between standards organizations, research programs, and industry consortia to support innovation. 2. It analyzes challenges like lack of resources, poor coordination between parallel efforts, and barriers to SME participation. 3. The author proposes closer collaboration where standards bodies provide interoperability for consortium technologies through flexible and fast processes, while tapping their national networks.

Best Practices in Policies and Regulations in Europe

Cleanslides

The document summarizes best practices in policies and regulations for renewable energy and energy efficiency in Europe. It outlines the key drivers for policies, including high import dependency on fossil fuels and environmental goals. Major targets have been set for 2020 and 2030, including reducing CO2 emissions by 40% and increasing the renewable energy share to 27% by 2030. Lessons learned are that purely market-based approaches have limited success, while regulation and programs that reduce the need for consumer action, like standards and home automation, tend to be more effective. Overall results show progress towards targets, though some larger countries still struggle and transformation to real-world projects is needed alongside aggregated goals and regulations.

WSB14 - Session 111-1 CEN presentation: overview Rules and Regulations and EN...

Chris Hamans

Presentation in session 111 during the World Sustainable Building Conference 2014 in Barcelona (28-30th .Oct. 2014) The theme of the WSB14 was: "Sustainability. Are we moving as quickly as we should? It is up to us!" Session 111 (out of 144 sessions) had to answer the question: "Are we moving in the same direction?" This presentation by CEN-CENELEC standardisation gave an overview of EU's rules, regulations and policies and the role of EN standards with regard to this. This presentation was one out of the 5 from this session 111. After a questioning, answering and discussion with the audience the session concluded: "No, we are not moving in the same direction!" see WSB14-Sessions 111-0 to 111-4

Options for a White Certificates scheme in the Netherlands

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Viewers also liked

White Certificates: the Italian experiences gained in Regulation, Monitoring ...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Energy Efficiency Programs – International Experiences with State Energy Effi...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Some Consideration about the White Certificates Mechanisms

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Energy Efficiency Resource Standards in the U.S. – A National Overview

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

The “White Certificates” scheme – Examples of Monitoring &Verification Processes

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Reducing Standby Power in Networked Appliances

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Consumer Electronics Labeling Program to Address Standby Power in India prese...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

LA CONVENTION DU 14 MAI 2014 relative à l’indemnisation du chômage Présentati...

Solidairnet Chomactif

Reports of National Standby Power Consumption and Targeted Policies - United ...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Smart Metering: A driver for creating energy efficiency for households. Smart...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

European Experience on Tradable Certificates for Energy Savings (White Certif...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

International approach - Smart Grid and DSM: Issues and Activities

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Consumer Electronics & Appliance Industry in India

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Diaporama présentation chomactifSolidairnet Chomactif

ESCo market development: Business models, innovations and lessons learned

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Demand Side Management (DSM) A renewed tool for sustainable development A sur...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Viewers also liked (16)

White Certificates: the Italian experiences gained in Regulation, Monitoring ...

Energy Efficiency Programs – International Experiences with State Energy Effi...

Some Consideration about the White Certificates Mechanisms

Energy Efficiency Resource Standards in the U.S. – A National Overview

The “White Certificates” scheme – Examples of Monitoring &Verification Processes

Reducing Standby Power in Networked Appliances

Consumer Electronics Labeling Program to Address Standby Power in India prese...

LA CONVENTION DU 14 MAI 2014 relative à l’indemnisation du chômage Présentati...

Reports of National Standby Power Consumption and Targeted Policies - United ...

Smart Metering: A driver for creating energy efficiency for households. Smart...

European Experience on Tradable Certificates for Energy Savings (White Certif...

International approach - Smart Grid and DSM: Issues and Activities

Consumer Electronics & Appliance Industry in India

Diaporama présentation chomactif

ESCo market development: Business models, innovations and lessons learned

Demand Side Management (DSM) A renewed tool for sustainable development A sur...

Similar to Discussion: Cross fertilisation among tried-out schemes: a useful path toward harmonisation

Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? The EU's energy efficiency policies scrutinise...

Leonardo ENERGY

Market Mechanisms for White Certificates

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

John Ketchell

Standardization2010

Best Practices in Policies and Regulations in Europe

Cleanslides

WSB14 - Session 111-1 CEN presentation: overview Rules and Regulations and EN...

Chris Hamans

Options for a White Certificates scheme in the Netherlands

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

A policy perspective on Building Automation and Control Systems (BACS)

Leonardo ENERGY

Improved management of technical building systems (TBS) can offer a cost-effective potential to reduce building energy consumption, improve the quality of life of occupants and facilitate the integration of renewable energy systems by providing flexibility to the connected energy grids. Multiple policy initiatives related to BACS currently exist or are under development. This presentation will give an overview and some examples of European policy tools and/or local implementations. The most relevant policy tools that can help contribute accessing these savings potentials are the Energy Performance in Buildings Directive (EPBD), the Energy Efficiency Directive (EED), Ecodesign Directive (ED) and Energy Labelling Regulation (ELR). Some examples of existing policy will be given and reference will be made to the recently completed Smart Readiness Indicator study and the ongoing Ecodesign BACS preparatory study.

Bonafede aeeg ev_recharging_infrastructure_in_italy_2010 oct-19th_milano_mobi...

Dabon

2016 jun16 msp european catalogue

Rodolphe Wouters

Patrik Kolar, Head of Department B (LIFE and Horizon 2020 Energy, Environment...

ARC research group

This document discusses the EU's support for improving building energy performance assessment and certification. It provides context on the Clean Energy for All Europeans package and its goals to create jobs, cut emissions, and ensure energy security. It outlines the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive and related policies. It describes the European Commission's Executive Agency for SMEs and its management of energy efficiency programs under Horizon 2020. It highlights several projects that develop innovative approaches to building renovation. It discusses upcoming Horizon 2020 funding topics focused on developing the next generation of energy performance assessment and certification to make the processes more reliable, cost-effective, and compliant with standards.

GRT Gaz

Mark Peterson

This document discusses the future design of the EU gas market. It outlines the key elements of the European Commission's Clean Energy package and its potential impacts. These include measures that could increase gas demand and promote renewable gas production, as well as those that favor electricity for heating and mobility. The Commission is exploring how to "mirror" gas market regulations based on the electricity market design. A study will evaluate different gas market scenarios, such as trading regions and a single market with zero tariffs at interconnection points. Overall, the document considers the tradeoffs between different gas market models and the practical challenges of transitioning between models.

E invoicing, e invoicing standardization in europe

Friso de Jong

CEN has a long history of working on eInvoicing standardization through its eInvoicing Workshop. The Workshop has produced 3 phases of work including recommendations to update the EDI framework, standardized invoice contents, and a framework for an emerging European invoice operator network. CEN will continue this work and enhance it in line with recommendations from the EU Expert Group, including developing user guidelines for adopting the UN/CEFACT Cross Industry Invoice in Europe. Multiple CEN workshops contribute to the overall standardization landscape, and awareness and participation are key to successful implementation.

Data collection and monitoring

DataChallenges

The Joint Research Centre provides scientific and technical support to the European Commission and supports the Covenant of Mayors initiative. The Covenant of Mayors requires cities to develop Sustainable Energy Action Plans (SEAPs) to reduce CO2 emissions 20% by 2020. Developing accurate SEAPs and monitoring progress requires reliable energy consumption data collected through baseline and monitoring emission inventories. However, data collection presents challenges as data is organized differently between countries and sectors. Energy audits and energy management systems can help cities develop better SEAPs and improve data quality for monitoring.

Internal electricity market (dir 2009/72/EC) and progress reports on internal...

Leonardo ENERGY

The document discusses progress reports on the internal electricity market in the European Union. It focuses on the multilevel approach laid out in Directive 2009/72/EC to achieve an internal energy market. This includes a top-down and bottom-up approach involving various bodies like ACER, ENTSO-E, and regional initiatives. Four target models were established for the electricity market: market coupling, cross-border intraday trading, long-term transmission rights, and capacity calculation. The document also discusses ACER and CEER's annual market monitoring report, which assesses competition in European energy markets and identifies barriers.

ETIP PV conference: 'Photovoltaics: centre-stage in the power system

Cluster TWEED

This document summarizes the keynote speech given by Jeroen Schuppers from the European Commission on the Energy Union and the Strategic Energy Technology Plan (SET Plan). The SET Plan aims to accelerate the development and market deployment of low-carbon energy technologies. A new governance model for the SET Plan emphasizes strengthened cooperation between member states, stakeholders, and the European Commission. It includes setting targets, selecting research and innovation actions, identifying joint actions between countries, and flagships projects to demonstrate new technologies. Working groups composed of experts and government representatives will develop implementation plans to achieve the SET Plan's goals.

The White Certificates system in Italy: results and perspectives

Daniele Russolillo

Challenges in adoption of international model of consumer protection in india...

Balasubramanya Chandrashekariah

The document discusses challenges in adopting international models of consumer protection for large-scale rollout of smart energy meters in India. It summarizes the status of smart metering in European countries based on a survey. Key findings include: definitions of smart metering vary between countries and energies; main drivers for rollout are energy efficiency, frequent meter readings, and peak load management; cost-benefit analyses have been conducted in some countries but more work is needed on definitions, interoperability, and analysis methodology.

Multi-Country Experiences and Plans for Energy Efficiency Resource Standards ...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

CHP in Europe: today and tomorrow

COGEN Europe

SMART METERS Draft standardisation mandate

livemetering

Similar to Discussion: Cross fertilisation among tried-out schemes: a useful path toward harmonisation (20)

Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? The EU's energy efficiency policies scrutinise...

Market Mechanisms for White Certificates

John Ketchell

Best Practices in Policies and Regulations in Europe

WSB14 - Session 111-1 CEN presentation: overview Rules and Regulations and EN...

Options for a White Certificates scheme in the Netherlands

A policy perspective on Building Automation and Control Systems (BACS)

Bonafede aeeg ev_recharging_infrastructure_in_italy_2010 oct-19th_milano_mobi...

2016 jun16 msp european catalogue

Patrik Kolar, Head of Department B (LIFE and Horizon 2020 Energy, Environment...

GRT Gaz

E invoicing, e invoicing standardization in europe

Data collection and monitoring

Internal electricity market (dir 2009/72/EC) and progress reports on internal...

ETIP PV conference: 'Photovoltaics: centre-stage in the power system

The White Certificates system in Italy: results and perspectives

Challenges in adoption of international model of consumer protection in india...

Multi-Country Experiences and Plans for Energy Efficiency Resource Standards ...

CHP in Europe: today and tomorrow

SMART METERS Draft standardisation mandate

More from IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Converting Demand Side Operation in to an Accurate Tool for the Transmission ...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Customer Organizations

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Consumer's Services Companies

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Utilities Industry & the Capital Market - Under Pressure - Utilities Global S...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Practical experiences with internal and external energy performance contracti...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Efficiency Valuation: Fine Tuning M&V for Business Transactions

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

From theory based policy evaluation to smart policy design: lessons learned f...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

The document summarizes the findings of the AID-EE project, which evaluated 20 energy efficiency policies across Europe. Key lessons learned include: objectives should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound to guide policy; the impact of individual policies is difficult to isolate as most use packages with interacting instruments; and monitoring and evaluation have been a low priority, despite being important to determine policy effects and efficiency. A policy theory approach that defines clear objectives, indicators and expected relationships can help design, monitor and evaluate policies.

Registration and validation in Denmark – the principles and the chosen solutions

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

The New Structure for PSO Activities in Denmark – Goals and Overall Set-up

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Measuring and verifying energy savings within the Energy Fund Model in Norway

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

The Italian white certificates market and the measurement and verification of...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Energy Efficiency Obligations - the UK Practical Experience on Validating & E...

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

EU Directive on Energy End-Use and Services

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Automatic meter management – A customer's perspective

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Oxxio is rolling out the largest smart metering project in the Netherlands to differentiate itself and enhance customer processes. Over 30,000 smart meters have been installed, allowing remote reading and providing customers insight into energy consumption. While installation has faced some difficulties, the technology is proven. Oxxio aims to leverage the smart meters to launch new energy saving services for customers, focusing on added value through reduced costs and sustainability. In 2007, Oxxio will continue launching personalized advice, monitoring, and contract products utilizing the smart meter data and system.

Energy services in practice – Saving energy and directly earn money

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Monitoring information for EU reporting

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Australian Energy Efficiency and Demand Side Management Activities

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

Australia has abundant coal and gas resources but is becoming a net importer of liquid fuels. Greenhouse gas emissions are high per capita due to the energy-intensive economy. Key programs to improve energy efficiency include the National Framework for Energy Efficiency, Energy Efficiency Opportunities Act, and Minimum Energy Performance Standards. Smart metering and continued electricity market reforms aim to enable time-varying pricing and demand-side management, but regulators may not allow innovative tariffs. While on track to meet short-term climate targets, further energy efficiency and demand-side management policies are still needed to reduce emissions beyond 2010.

USA Activities on DSM (Demand Response & Energy Efficiency)

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

The document summarizes USA activities related to demand-side management (DSM), including demand response and energy efficiency. It notes there has been strong, renewed interest in these areas in the US after a decade of reduced focus. It provides an overview of the US electricity system and regulatory structure. It then discusses the status of demand response and energy efficiency programs and policies in the US, including key reports and initiatives. Barriers to greater adoption are also mentioned.

The Current Status and Prospect of Distributed Generation in Korea

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

ESCO and Thermal Energy Storage for DSM in Korea

IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA)

More from IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA) (20)