Presented by Steve Nadel, Executive Director, American Council for an Energy Efficient Economy (ACEEE) at the IEA DSM workshop in Washington D.C. on 27 April 2011.
Green Lecture Series: Rethinking Local Energy Choices and CostsCUSP | Univ of Guelph
The document discusses energy choices and costs in Houghton County, Michigan. It provides an overview of the current energy landscape, including utility rates and sources over time. It then analyzes key legislative acts that impacted the system. Looking forward, it discusses rethinking energy at the individual and community level. Houghton County is participating in the Georgetown University Energy Prize competition to increase efficiency and transition to more renewable regional generation by 2040 to support local economic and social sustainability.
The document discusses the benefits of pursuing energy efficiency as a utility system resource and local economic development strategy for municipal utilities. It argues that energy efficiency is much cheaper than producing new energy and provides examples where efficiency programs have saved significant amounts of energy equivalent to large power plants. The document also highlights Burlington Electric Department as an excellent municipal utility example that has achieved substantial energy savings through long-term energy efficiency investments and programs.
Update on the Texas Electric Industry: Preparing for Summeraectnet
This document provides an update on preparations for summer in the Texas electric industry. It discusses how higher temperatures increase electricity consumption and bills. Retail electric providers have launched solutions to address common customer inquiries during the summer, such as providing energy efficiency tips and bill payment assistance options. Generators are prepared for increased demand during heat waves. Hurricane season also begins in June.
The document summarizes recent developments in state-level energy efficiency policies and programs across the United States. It outlines new legislation, efficiency standards, and energy savings targets adopted by many states between 2007-2009. Specifically, it discusses new energy efficiency resource standards, increased utility program spending, and the establishment of independent entities to administer efficiency programs in various states.
The document summarizes recent federal energy policy developments in the US, including provisions in the stimulus bill and proposed legislation. Key points include $30 billion for energy efficiency in the stimulus, a proposed federal Energy Efficiency Resource Standard, appliance standards, building codes, and incentives for home and business retrofits in proposed bills. Analysis finds the policies could reduce US energy use by 5-12% by 2020-2030.
Building energy codes can significantly reduce energy use and greenhouse gas emissions from the building sector by making new buildings more efficient. The Alliance to Save Energy advocates for legislation to set national energy savings targets for building codes. Their proposal would direct states to adopt updated national model building codes or equivalent standards to meet targets, and provide federal support and enforcement to improve state and local compliance. If states and localities fail to meet targets, the federal government would enforce code requirements directly. The proposal aims to fully utilize building energy codes as a cost-effective strategy to address national energy and climate change needs.
State Chambers of Commerce Roundtable - 06052015Tim Rushenberg
This document summarizes information presented by Tim Rushenberg of the State Chamber of Commerce Roundtable on rising electricity costs. It provides an overview of Indiana's major electric utilities and generation sources. It then discusses factors driving up costs such as environmental regulations, aging infrastructure, and the regulatory process. Charts show Indiana's rates have risen 4.31% for industrial customers from 2013 to 2015, below larger increases for other states. Utilities are taking steps like efficiency programs to control costs but future costs remain uncertain due to environmental regulations from the EPA.
This document provides an overview of the electricity industry in Texas, including:
1) It describes the regional transmission organizations and independent system operators that manage different parts of the electric grid across North America, including ERCOT which manages most of Texas.
2) It outlines the steps Texas took to introduce competition to its electricity market in the 1990s and 2000s, including separating generation, transmission, distribution and retail sales between different companies in ERCOT.
3) It shows that retail electricity prices in Texas, particularly for fixed-rate plans in ERCOT, are significantly lower than they were before competition and lower than average national prices.
Green Lecture Series: Rethinking Local Energy Choices and CostsCUSP | Univ of Guelph
The document discusses energy choices and costs in Houghton County, Michigan. It provides an overview of the current energy landscape, including utility rates and sources over time. It then analyzes key legislative acts that impacted the system. Looking forward, it discusses rethinking energy at the individual and community level. Houghton County is participating in the Georgetown University Energy Prize competition to increase efficiency and transition to more renewable regional generation by 2040 to support local economic and social sustainability.
The document discusses the benefits of pursuing energy efficiency as a utility system resource and local economic development strategy for municipal utilities. It argues that energy efficiency is much cheaper than producing new energy and provides examples where efficiency programs have saved significant amounts of energy equivalent to large power plants. The document also highlights Burlington Electric Department as an excellent municipal utility example that has achieved substantial energy savings through long-term energy efficiency investments and programs.
Update on the Texas Electric Industry: Preparing for Summeraectnet
This document provides an update on preparations for summer in the Texas electric industry. It discusses how higher temperatures increase electricity consumption and bills. Retail electric providers have launched solutions to address common customer inquiries during the summer, such as providing energy efficiency tips and bill payment assistance options. Generators are prepared for increased demand during heat waves. Hurricane season also begins in June.
The document summarizes recent developments in state-level energy efficiency policies and programs across the United States. It outlines new legislation, efficiency standards, and energy savings targets adopted by many states between 2007-2009. Specifically, it discusses new energy efficiency resource standards, increased utility program spending, and the establishment of independent entities to administer efficiency programs in various states.
The document summarizes recent federal energy policy developments in the US, including provisions in the stimulus bill and proposed legislation. Key points include $30 billion for energy efficiency in the stimulus, a proposed federal Energy Efficiency Resource Standard, appliance standards, building codes, and incentives for home and business retrofits in proposed bills. Analysis finds the policies could reduce US energy use by 5-12% by 2020-2030.
Building energy codes can significantly reduce energy use and greenhouse gas emissions from the building sector by making new buildings more efficient. The Alliance to Save Energy advocates for legislation to set national energy savings targets for building codes. Their proposal would direct states to adopt updated national model building codes or equivalent standards to meet targets, and provide federal support and enforcement to improve state and local compliance. If states and localities fail to meet targets, the federal government would enforce code requirements directly. The proposal aims to fully utilize building energy codes as a cost-effective strategy to address national energy and climate change needs.
State Chambers of Commerce Roundtable - 06052015Tim Rushenberg
This document summarizes information presented by Tim Rushenberg of the State Chamber of Commerce Roundtable on rising electricity costs. It provides an overview of Indiana's major electric utilities and generation sources. It then discusses factors driving up costs such as environmental regulations, aging infrastructure, and the regulatory process. Charts show Indiana's rates have risen 4.31% for industrial customers from 2013 to 2015, below larger increases for other states. Utilities are taking steps like efficiency programs to control costs but future costs remain uncertain due to environmental regulations from the EPA.
This document provides an overview of the electricity industry in Texas, including:
1) It describes the regional transmission organizations and independent system operators that manage different parts of the electric grid across North America, including ERCOT which manages most of Texas.
2) It outlines the steps Texas took to introduce competition to its electricity market in the 1990s and 2000s, including separating generation, transmission, distribution and retail sales between different companies in ERCOT.
3) It shows that retail electricity prices in Texas, particularly for fixed-rate plans in ERCOT, are significantly lower than they were before competition and lower than average national prices.
A Presentation on the Regulatory Regime for Renewable Energy Projects in Andh...electricitygovernance
The document summarizes the regulatory regime for renewable energy projects in Andhra Pradesh. It outlines the state commission's role in promoting renewable generation under the Electricity Act of 2003. Key points include a renewable purchase obligation of 5% for distribution licensees from 2005-2008, with 0.5% reserved for wind. Tariffs were determined in 2004 and incentives were provided, like banking privileges for mini-hydel and wind projects. The order rationalized tariffs for various renewable technologies.
The document summarizes key aspects of Thailand's Energy Industry Act regarding renewable energy (RE). It outlines the Act's objectives to promote adequate and secure energy, protect consumers, promote competition and fairness, and promote efficient industry operations and RE like solar and wind. It describes the government's duties to establish energy policy, procure energy meeting demand at reasonable prices, and emphasize RE development. It also outlines the Energy Regulatory Commission's duties like promoting economical and efficient energy use and RE.
Energy Efficiency Resource Standards: The New Kid on the BlockGlenn Klith Andersen
An Energy Efficiency Resource Standard (EERS) sets energy savings targets for utilities, requiring documented savings in accordance with regulator-established evaluation rules, often with a market-based trading system. EERS policies have been adopted in several states and countries and have achieved substantial energy and emissions savings. Analysis shows that a federal EERS could reduce US energy consumption by 4.6% in 2020 through cost-effective efficiency investments equivalent to a 40 mpg CAFE standard. Key design issues for EERS policies include which entities are covered, eligible efficiency measures, appropriate savings targets and timeframes, and relationships with other policies.
Energy Efficiency in Energy Legislation, Waxman-Markey, and Stimulus:Update ...Alliance To Save Energy
The document provides an overview and update on federal energy and climate legislation, the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (stimulus), and energy efficiency programs and funding. It discusses the Waxman-Markey climate bill that passed the House, the climate provisions being developed in the Senate, and highlights of energy efficiency policies in the bills. It also reviews the $65 billion for energy efficiency in the stimulus and the slow rollout of funding, with less than 1% awarded so far. Key energy efficiency programs like the State Energy Program and Weatherization Assistance Program are outlined.
This document summarizes a project analyzing where Missouri ranks compared to other states in renewable energy and energy efficiency policies. It finds that Missouri currently ranks 43rd according to the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE). The ACEEE scoring is based on several criteria where Missouri scores poorly, including utility programs, transportation policies, building codes, and state government initiatives. The document recommends Missouri adopt stricter building energy codes to improve its ranking, similar to codes adopted in Illinois. It also notes Missouri could improve through increased utility budgets for code compliance and state building energy use benchmarks.
China energy and environmental challengesYibo Yang
- China faces enormous challenges in meeting its growing energy demand while addressing serious environmental and health impacts from air pollution. Electricity demand is growing at 15% annually while GDP grows at 10% per year.
- China's policies emphasize energy efficiency and environmental protection but it still lags targets to reduce energy intensity and emissions by 2010. New policies promote energy efficiency power plants, differential pricing, and environmental dispatch.
- China is considering how to better integrate energy and environmental policies and structure the power sector to address climate change, similar to issues facing other countries. Regulators from the US will visit to discuss these challenges.
This document provides an overview of the electricity market in Texas, including:
- The roles of different organizations like ERCOT, transmission and distribution utilities, retail electric providers, and generation companies.
- How electricity competition was introduced through legislation in 1995 and 1999.
- How the competitive retail electric market operates within ERCOT compared to regulated areas outside of ERCOT.
- Evidence that average electricity prices in Texas today are lower than before competition, and Texas has a better national price ranking.
ScottMadden recently joined industry leaders as a sponsor and presenter at Infocast’s 19th Annual Transmission Summit. Here, Todd Williams, partner and fossil practice co-leader at ScottMadden, reviewed the generation landscape and the impacts of the Clean Power Plan.
To learn more, please visit www.scottmadden.com.
The document discusses the UK's experience with clean energy including renewables like biofuels, nuclear power, and carbon capture and storage. It notes that in 2006 renewables generated about 5.5% of electricity while nuclear generated 19%. Strengths included early commitment to renewables and political support, but weaknesses included a lack of coordination between policy, planning, and regulation. Support mechanisms for renewables also lacked effectiveness and led to an uncoordinated growth of small wind farms causing public dissatisfaction.
Distributed energy resources (DERs) can provide net benefits to the electric system (e.g., congestion relief) and broader society (e.g., emission reductions). However, despite these advantages, the deployment of high penetrations of DER has proved challenging. Against this backdrop, the electric utility is often singled out as a fundamental barrier to deployment of DER assets. To overcome the perceived electric utility shortcomings, many stakeholders conclude that a completely new model is needed for the electric industry.
ScottMadden disagrees with this assessment and instead believes electric utilities maintain natural advantages that can be leveraged to deploy renewables and DER assets as well or better than some models being offered. In our 51st Phase II Roadmap, ScottMadden proposes leveraging the natural advantages of the electric utility in order to accelerate the deployment and penetration of DER assets.
For more information, please visit www.scottmadden.com.
The document discusses the Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Partnership (REEEP), a global partnership launched in 2002 to accelerate the uptake of renewable energy and energy efficiency. REEEP comprises over 200 government, business, and NGO partners and is funded by several governments. It supports projects through regional secretariats and networks like the Sustainable Energy Regulation Network (SERN). SERN works to transfer regulatory best practices and supports REEEP's goal of improving access to reliable and sustainable energy.
Before we kick-off a new line-up of insightful studies and conversations on energy this 2021, we take a snapshot of the previous working papers which were featured last year.
These studies were produced under the Access to Sustainable Energy Programme-Clean Energy Living Laboratories (ASEP-CELLs) project implemented by the Ateneo School of Government (ASOG), and funded by the European Union.
To receive updates on our latest events and publications, please subscribe to our mailing list through this link: http://bit.ly/ASEPCELLsMailingList
Promotion of Clean Energy, Energy Efficiency and DSM by Maharasthra Electrici...electricitygovernance
The document summarizes initiatives by the Maharashtra Electricity Regulatory Commission (MERC) to promote clean energy, energy efficiency and demand-side management in the state of Maharashtra, India. Key initiatives discussed include issuing tariff orders to promote grid-connected renewable energy, establishing renewable purchase obligations, building capacity for energy efficiency programs, implementing time-of-day tariffs and load management directives, and overcoming challenges like changing utility mindsets and developing the energy efficiency market.
This document discusses transportation electrification in Vermont. It provides an overview of electric vehicle (EV) market status and economics, outlines opportunities and case studies to accelerate EV adoption, and examines policies and programs to promote electrification. Key points include:
- Transportation is a major source of emissions in Vermont, and increased EV adoption is part of the state's plan to meet climate goals.
- Incentive programs aim to reduce the cost of EVs and charging infrastructure to encourage purchases. Combined incentives can lower EV costs by over $10,000.
- Case studies from Norway show that setting ambitious EV requirements and adopting comprehensive policies like fees on gas vehicles can lead to over 50% of new car sales being electric.
The document summarizes Ontario's energy plan to invest $87 billion over 20 years to replace and build energy supply. It aims to create 50,000 green jobs through expanding renewable energy like wind and solar to 10,700 MW by 2018. The Green Energy Act supports this by providing contracts through the FIT program and requiring 25-60% domestic content in renewable projects to boost the provincial economy. The plan establishes targets for conservation and expanding the transmission system to accommodate more renewable sources.
The document discusses the prospects for federal energy efficiency policy and legislation in 2010. It outlines various proposed bills focusing on jobs creation, energy, and climate change. It also summarizes key energy efficiency provisions being considered, such as home retrofit programs, appliance standards, building codes, and an energy efficiency resource standard. Overall, some provisions may pass in a jobs bill, while comprehensive energy and climate legislation faces challenges due to political opposition.
Barriers to Low-Income Uptake of Energy Efficiency and Beneficial Electrifica...EAN-VT
The document discusses barriers to energy efficiency and electrification programs for low-income households in Vermont's Northeast Kingdom region and provides recommendations to increase participation. It finds the Northeast Kingdom has higher poverty rates and energy burdens than the rest of Vermont. Barriers include upfront costs, transaction costs of programs, psychological factors, rural challenges, old housing stock, and lack of energy committees. Recommendations are to create an advisory committee, streamline programs, conduct outreach, explore financing options, and increase funding to improve energy access for low-income residents in the Northeast Kingdom.
Presented by Theresa Gross, Manager Energy Efficiency Programs, Public Utility Commission of Texas, at the IEA DSM Programme workshop in Washington D.C. on 27 April 2011.
Presented by the Operating Agent of Task 15, Dr David Crossley, Energy Futures Australia Pty. Ltd., at the IEA DSM Workshop in Stockholm Sweden on 6 October 2010.
A Presentation on the Regulatory Regime for Renewable Energy Projects in Andh...electricitygovernance
The document summarizes the regulatory regime for renewable energy projects in Andhra Pradesh. It outlines the state commission's role in promoting renewable generation under the Electricity Act of 2003. Key points include a renewable purchase obligation of 5% for distribution licensees from 2005-2008, with 0.5% reserved for wind. Tariffs were determined in 2004 and incentives were provided, like banking privileges for mini-hydel and wind projects. The order rationalized tariffs for various renewable technologies.
The document summarizes key aspects of Thailand's Energy Industry Act regarding renewable energy (RE). It outlines the Act's objectives to promote adequate and secure energy, protect consumers, promote competition and fairness, and promote efficient industry operations and RE like solar and wind. It describes the government's duties to establish energy policy, procure energy meeting demand at reasonable prices, and emphasize RE development. It also outlines the Energy Regulatory Commission's duties like promoting economical and efficient energy use and RE.
Energy Efficiency Resource Standards: The New Kid on the BlockGlenn Klith Andersen
An Energy Efficiency Resource Standard (EERS) sets energy savings targets for utilities, requiring documented savings in accordance with regulator-established evaluation rules, often with a market-based trading system. EERS policies have been adopted in several states and countries and have achieved substantial energy and emissions savings. Analysis shows that a federal EERS could reduce US energy consumption by 4.6% in 2020 through cost-effective efficiency investments equivalent to a 40 mpg CAFE standard. Key design issues for EERS policies include which entities are covered, eligible efficiency measures, appropriate savings targets and timeframes, and relationships with other policies.
Energy Efficiency in Energy Legislation, Waxman-Markey, and Stimulus:Update ...Alliance To Save Energy
The document provides an overview and update on federal energy and climate legislation, the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (stimulus), and energy efficiency programs and funding. It discusses the Waxman-Markey climate bill that passed the House, the climate provisions being developed in the Senate, and highlights of energy efficiency policies in the bills. It also reviews the $65 billion for energy efficiency in the stimulus and the slow rollout of funding, with less than 1% awarded so far. Key energy efficiency programs like the State Energy Program and Weatherization Assistance Program are outlined.
This document summarizes a project analyzing where Missouri ranks compared to other states in renewable energy and energy efficiency policies. It finds that Missouri currently ranks 43rd according to the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE). The ACEEE scoring is based on several criteria where Missouri scores poorly, including utility programs, transportation policies, building codes, and state government initiatives. The document recommends Missouri adopt stricter building energy codes to improve its ranking, similar to codes adopted in Illinois. It also notes Missouri could improve through increased utility budgets for code compliance and state building energy use benchmarks.
China energy and environmental challengesYibo Yang
- China faces enormous challenges in meeting its growing energy demand while addressing serious environmental and health impacts from air pollution. Electricity demand is growing at 15% annually while GDP grows at 10% per year.
- China's policies emphasize energy efficiency and environmental protection but it still lags targets to reduce energy intensity and emissions by 2010. New policies promote energy efficiency power plants, differential pricing, and environmental dispatch.
- China is considering how to better integrate energy and environmental policies and structure the power sector to address climate change, similar to issues facing other countries. Regulators from the US will visit to discuss these challenges.
This document provides an overview of the electricity market in Texas, including:
- The roles of different organizations like ERCOT, transmission and distribution utilities, retail electric providers, and generation companies.
- How electricity competition was introduced through legislation in 1995 and 1999.
- How the competitive retail electric market operates within ERCOT compared to regulated areas outside of ERCOT.
- Evidence that average electricity prices in Texas today are lower than before competition, and Texas has a better national price ranking.
ScottMadden recently joined industry leaders as a sponsor and presenter at Infocast’s 19th Annual Transmission Summit. Here, Todd Williams, partner and fossil practice co-leader at ScottMadden, reviewed the generation landscape and the impacts of the Clean Power Plan.
To learn more, please visit www.scottmadden.com.
The document discusses the UK's experience with clean energy including renewables like biofuels, nuclear power, and carbon capture and storage. It notes that in 2006 renewables generated about 5.5% of electricity while nuclear generated 19%. Strengths included early commitment to renewables and political support, but weaknesses included a lack of coordination between policy, planning, and regulation. Support mechanisms for renewables also lacked effectiveness and led to an uncoordinated growth of small wind farms causing public dissatisfaction.
Distributed energy resources (DERs) can provide net benefits to the electric system (e.g., congestion relief) and broader society (e.g., emission reductions). However, despite these advantages, the deployment of high penetrations of DER has proved challenging. Against this backdrop, the electric utility is often singled out as a fundamental barrier to deployment of DER assets. To overcome the perceived electric utility shortcomings, many stakeholders conclude that a completely new model is needed for the electric industry.
ScottMadden disagrees with this assessment and instead believes electric utilities maintain natural advantages that can be leveraged to deploy renewables and DER assets as well or better than some models being offered. In our 51st Phase II Roadmap, ScottMadden proposes leveraging the natural advantages of the electric utility in order to accelerate the deployment and penetration of DER assets.
For more information, please visit www.scottmadden.com.
The document discusses the Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Partnership (REEEP), a global partnership launched in 2002 to accelerate the uptake of renewable energy and energy efficiency. REEEP comprises over 200 government, business, and NGO partners and is funded by several governments. It supports projects through regional secretariats and networks like the Sustainable Energy Regulation Network (SERN). SERN works to transfer regulatory best practices and supports REEEP's goal of improving access to reliable and sustainable energy.
Before we kick-off a new line-up of insightful studies and conversations on energy this 2021, we take a snapshot of the previous working papers which were featured last year.
These studies were produced under the Access to Sustainable Energy Programme-Clean Energy Living Laboratories (ASEP-CELLs) project implemented by the Ateneo School of Government (ASOG), and funded by the European Union.
To receive updates on our latest events and publications, please subscribe to our mailing list through this link: http://bit.ly/ASEPCELLsMailingList
Promotion of Clean Energy, Energy Efficiency and DSM by Maharasthra Electrici...electricitygovernance
The document summarizes initiatives by the Maharashtra Electricity Regulatory Commission (MERC) to promote clean energy, energy efficiency and demand-side management in the state of Maharashtra, India. Key initiatives discussed include issuing tariff orders to promote grid-connected renewable energy, establishing renewable purchase obligations, building capacity for energy efficiency programs, implementing time-of-day tariffs and load management directives, and overcoming challenges like changing utility mindsets and developing the energy efficiency market.
This document discusses transportation electrification in Vermont. It provides an overview of electric vehicle (EV) market status and economics, outlines opportunities and case studies to accelerate EV adoption, and examines policies and programs to promote electrification. Key points include:
- Transportation is a major source of emissions in Vermont, and increased EV adoption is part of the state's plan to meet climate goals.
- Incentive programs aim to reduce the cost of EVs and charging infrastructure to encourage purchases. Combined incentives can lower EV costs by over $10,000.
- Case studies from Norway show that setting ambitious EV requirements and adopting comprehensive policies like fees on gas vehicles can lead to over 50% of new car sales being electric.
The document summarizes Ontario's energy plan to invest $87 billion over 20 years to replace and build energy supply. It aims to create 50,000 green jobs through expanding renewable energy like wind and solar to 10,700 MW by 2018. The Green Energy Act supports this by providing contracts through the FIT program and requiring 25-60% domestic content in renewable projects to boost the provincial economy. The plan establishes targets for conservation and expanding the transmission system to accommodate more renewable sources.
The document discusses the prospects for federal energy efficiency policy and legislation in 2010. It outlines various proposed bills focusing on jobs creation, energy, and climate change. It also summarizes key energy efficiency provisions being considered, such as home retrofit programs, appliance standards, building codes, and an energy efficiency resource standard. Overall, some provisions may pass in a jobs bill, while comprehensive energy and climate legislation faces challenges due to political opposition.
Barriers to Low-Income Uptake of Energy Efficiency and Beneficial Electrifica...EAN-VT
The document discusses barriers to energy efficiency and electrification programs for low-income households in Vermont's Northeast Kingdom region and provides recommendations to increase participation. It finds the Northeast Kingdom has higher poverty rates and energy burdens than the rest of Vermont. Barriers include upfront costs, transaction costs of programs, psychological factors, rural challenges, old housing stock, and lack of energy committees. Recommendations are to create an advisory committee, streamline programs, conduct outreach, explore financing options, and increase funding to improve energy access for low-income residents in the Northeast Kingdom.
Presented by Theresa Gross, Manager Energy Efficiency Programs, Public Utility Commission of Texas, at the IEA DSM Programme workshop in Washington D.C. on 27 April 2011.
Presented by the Operating Agent of Task 15, Dr David Crossley, Energy Futures Australia Pty. Ltd., at the IEA DSM Workshop in Stockholm Sweden on 6 October 2010.
This document summarizes highlights from the Implementing Agreement Demand Side Management. It discusses the IEA DSM Programme's vision of making demand side activities the first choice in energy policy decisions. The document outlines the IEA DSM Programme's mission to provide stakeholders with guidance on crafting and implementing DSM policies and measures. It then provides examples on load shape simplification, case studies of ESCO contracts that achieved both cost and CO2 savings, the role of customers in smart grids, applying behavior change theory in practice, and information on energy efficiency obligations.
This document summarizes the UK's Energy Efficiency Commitment (EEC) policy, which places obligations on domestic energy suppliers to improve energy efficiency. It discusses that the EEC has gradually increased targets and scope since 2002. Suppliers must meet energy savings targets, with at least 50% in low-income groups. The market approach allows suppliers flexibility in measures. Most suppliers met EEC2 targets. The policy has effectively improved housing efficiency but further work is needed on more expensive measures and electricity use. The new Carbon Emissions Reduction Target doubles previous targets but maintains the market approach.
Presented by P.C. Incalcaterra, "White Certificates Evaluation Team", ENEA, Italy, at the IEA DSM Programme workshop in Milan, Italy on 22 October 2008.
Presented by Dr. Alan Meier, Senior Scientist, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, USA at the IEA DSM Programme workshop in New Delhi, India on 2 April 2008.
Presented by Paolo Bertoldi and Silvia Rezessy, European Commission, Directorate General JRC, Institute for Energy, at the IEA DSM Programme workshop in Milan, Italy on 22 October 2008.
The document discusses energy service company (ESCo) business models and market development. It makes the following key points:
1. The two basic ESCo business models are energy performance contracting (EPC) and energy supply contracting (ESC). ESC makes up around 90% of the German ESCo market, which is worth approximately 1.6 billion Euros per year.
2. ESC focuses on renewable energy supply and is well-suited for applications like CHP, while EPC guarantees energy savings but makes up a smaller share of the market due to higher transaction costs.
3. An emerging "integrated energy contracting" model combines the strengths of ESC and EPC to provide both energy supply and savings.
This document summarizes recent federal energy policy developments in the United States. It discusses provisions in the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act stimulus bill related to energy efficiency, including billions of dollars allocated for weatherization, state energy programs, and smart grid development. It also outlines proposed energy legislation being considered by Congress, including establishing an energy efficiency resource standard requiring utilities to achieve annual efficiency savings targets. The document provides details on funding opportunities through the Department of Energy to support various efficiency programs and initiatives.
In her panel, 'Energy Efficiency: Greatest New Resource", Callahan looks at the chief forcing mechanisms - regulations and financial incentives - that have effectively accelerated the deployment of energy efficieny in the U.S. Her presentation covers the recent history of energy efficiency in U.S. policy, marked by President Obama's energy platform and FY2010 budget, as well as his recent overhaul of corporate average fuel economy standards. Callahan also examines the wealth of energy efficiency funding included in the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, and the potential for carbon emissions reductions in the House of Representative's American Clean Energy and Security Act of 2009.
Michigan Energy Forum - May 1, 2014 - Renewable Portfolio StandardAnnArborSPARK
The document summarizes a presentation on renewable portfolio standards given at the Michigan Energy Forum, including analysis showing that increasing renewable energy to 25% by 2025 would increase average residential electricity rates by around $192 per year but reduce carbon emissions substantially. Options for designing renewable energy policies and their potential impacts on costs and emissions are discussed.
Energy Efficiency Target Setting for Public BuildingsAnnie Gilleo
The document summarizes considerations for setting energy savings targets for public buildings. It discusses framing the goal in terms of metrics, timeline, baseline, and scope of buildings included. Examples are provided from Colorado, Oregon, and New Hampshire of targets set at the state level. Additional policy considerations are outlined to help meet goals, such as guidelines for new construction and existing buildings, coordinating with utility programs, and making financing accessible. Resources are listed for target setting, implementation, and technical assistance.
Energy Efficiency Lifestyle Four: Major Ingredients. Presented by Kateri Callahan, President of the Alliance to Save Energy at the International Symposium on Climate Change in Tokyo, Japan on November 17, 2008
The IEA Energy Efficiency Market report - What it means for DSMLeonardo ENERGY
The Energy Efficiency Market Report is the IEA’s flagship report on energy efficiency trends around the world.
Questions addressed in this year’s report include: Are we improving energy efficiency fast enough to achieve our climate goals? Which countries and policies are having the greatest impact and what is the secret to their success? How much is being invested in energy efficiency globally, in specific regions and in the main energy-consuming sectors? How are low energy prices impacting energy efficiency investments? What are the multiple benefits of energy efficiency for the climate, energy security and public budgets? What are the market trends for energy efficiency services and financing?
Speaker for this webinar: Tyler Bryant
The IEA Energy Efficiency Market report - What it means for DSMLeonardo ENERGY
The Energy Efficiency Market Report is the IEA’s flagship report on energy efficiency trends around the world.
Questions addressed in this year’s report include: Are we improving energy efficiency fast enough to achieve our climate goals? Which countries and policies are having the greatest impact and what is the secret to their success? How much is being invested in energy efficiency globally, in specific regions and in the main energy-consuming sectors? How are low energy prices impacting energy efficiency investments? What are the multiple benefits of energy efficiency for the climate, energy security and public budgets? What are the market trends for energy efficiency services and financing?
Speaker for this webinar: Tyler Bryant
The International Energy Agency’s Efficient World ScenarioLeonardo ENERGY
The International Energy Agency (IEA) has developed an Efficient World Scenario (EWS) to highlight the benefits to the global energy system from the adoption of cost-effective energy efficiency measures. This presentation will provide an overview of the EWS, which was published in the IEA’s Energy Efficiency 2018 report, and include an examination the potential efficiency gains in the transport, buildings and industry sectors and the policy measures needed to realise this potential.
The International Energy Agency’s Efficient World ScenarioLeonardo ENERGY
The International Energy Agency (IEA) has developed an Efficient World Scenario (EWS) to highlight the benefits to the global energy system from the adoption of cost-effective energy efficiency measures. This presentation will provide an overview of the EWS, which was published in the IEA’s Energy Efficiency 2018 report, and include an examination the potential efficiency gains in the transport, buildings and industry sectors and the policy measures needed to realise this potential.
Energy Management Strategies for Operational Excellence @ ARC's 2011 Industry...ARC Advisory Group
Energy Management Strategies for Operational Excellence @ ARC's 2011 Industry Forum by Dick Hill.
10 Energy Optimization Recommendations
1.Secure Management‟s Full Support
2.Plant-level Energy Teams –Include Automation
3.Build an Energy Strategic Plan
4.Perform Energy Audits –Current Reality
5.Establish Energy Metrics
6.Benchmark: Other Plants & Other Companies
7.Energy KPIs –Not just for Management
8.On-Line Energy Measurements –Fill Gaps
9.Automate to Optimize
10.Empower the Worker
The document summarizes progress toward sustainable energy goals in Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC) based on the Global Tracking Framework 2015. It finds that LAC has near universal electricity access but slower progress on clean cooking. Energy intensity is relatively low but improvement rates are mixed. LAC has high shares of renewable energy but increases are limited as many countries are near capacity. The report outlines regional trends, country data, and targets to double energy efficiency and renewable energy. It also outlines plans to involve regional groups in the 2017 Global Tracking Framework report.
Speaking to participants of the Asia Pacific Research Center's Peer Review on Energy Efficiency, Castelli offered a status update on energy efficiency in the U.S., and the ways that energy efficiency programs are financed, monitored and measured there. After briefing the audience on the history of energy legislation in the U.S., Castelli introduced them to the energy efficiency provisions of the recently passed American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009.
Executive VP of Programs and Development Brian Castelli traveled to Mexico City to present at EXPO INCYTAM 2008, where he offered energy efficiency solutions for Latin American cities burdened by the effects of pollution and global climate change.
Annie Levenson-Falk with the Legislative Energy Commission presents about the 2025 Minnesota Energy Action Plan at four CERTs regional events to engage people about the state's energy future. Learn more at http://www.cleanenergyresourceteams.org/blog/weigh-minnesota-2025-energy-action-plan.
Brian Castelli, Executive VP of Programs and Development at the Alliance to Save Energy presented at the Commonwealth of Virginia’s Energy and Sustainability Conference. In his presentation Generating Energy Through Efficiency, he discussed the many ways in which the Commonwealth of Virginia can harness the economic and environmental benefits of energy efficiency – for example, through utility programs, public benefit funds and state-administered appliance standards, to name a few areas. Looking at the big picture, Virginia’s actions today could help strengthen tomorrow’s national plan for energy efficiency.
Building America’s Green Economy: A Foundation of Energy Efficiency, A Future...Alliance To Save Energy
The document discusses the importance of energy efficiency and renewable energy in building a green economy and outlines President Obama's plans to promote them. It summarizes that energy efficiency is the cheapest way to reduce energy demand, buy time to develop renewables, and can work synergistically with renewables. It also outlines Obama's goals like improving appliance standards and funding for efficiency programs and renewables research.
Todd Williams, partner and fossil practice co-leader at ScottMadden, recently presented at the EnergyHub GenForum on the EPA’s CPP, one of the most significant environmental mandates in U.S. history. Here, he gave an overview of the requirements and impacts of the CPP. He also recapped events now unfolding in CPP litigation, politics, and legislation. Where are the battle lines drawn? Who is on what side? And, what are states doing to prepare their compliance plans?
For more information, please visit www.scottmadden.com.
Leaders from MN’s Division of Energy Resources, the MN Pollution Control Agency, and the energy sector discuss regional solutions to cut emissions from existing power plants.
Implementing an on-site energy strategy requires a solution to the barrier of upfront cost. The unique energy financing program known as Property Assessed Clean Energy can make launching an on-site solution project cash flow positive immediately!
Energy efficiency trends in the EU: Have we got off track?Diedert Debusscher
What has been the overall trend in final energy consumption and by sector in the EU since 2000? What are the main drivers of the energy consumption variation since 2000, and what has been the impact of energy savings? What are the trends in energy efficiency at the country level?
These are the key questions that will guide you through this webinar analysing energy efficiency trends in the EU for the period 2000-2019.
This presentation deck was used during the 9th webinar in the Odyssee-Mure on Energy Efficiency Academy on 25 June 2020. Recordings are available on https://www.youtube.com/user/LeonardoENERGY/videos?view=0&sort=dd&flow=grid
The webinar is an approximately 45 min presentation, followed by a live Q&A session with the panellists.
Similar to Energy Efficiency Resource Standards in the U.S. – A National Overview (20)
Presented by Prof. Dr. Carlos Àlvarez, Instituto de Ingenería Energética, Universidad Politécnica de Valencia, Spain, at the IEA DSM Programme workshop in Madrid, Spain on 19 October 2005.
Presented by Arturo Rodríguez-Garcia, Director General, General Manager, Visual Tools, Spain, at the IEA DSM Programme workshop in Madrid, Spain on 19 October 2005.
Presented by Wolfgang Irrek, Research group "Energy Transport and Climate Policy" Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy, Germany at the IEA DSM Programme workshop in Copenhagen, Denmark on 19 April 2006.
The document summarizes the findings of the AID-EE project, which evaluated 20 energy efficiency policies across Europe. Key lessons learned include: objectives should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound to guide policy; the impact of individual policies is difficult to isolate as most use packages with interacting instruments; and monitoring and evaluation have been a low priority, despite being important to determine policy effects and efficiency. A policy theory approach that defines clear objectives, indicators and expected relationships can help design, monitor and evaluate policies.
Presented by Ulrich Bang Termansen, the Association of Danish Energy Companies, Denmark at the IEA DSM workshop in Copenhagen, Denmark on 19 April 2006.
Presented by Nicolai Zarganis, Head of Division, Danish Energy Authority, denmark, at the IEA DSM Programme workshop in Copenhagen, Denmark on 19 April 2006.
Presented by Marcella Pavan, head, Energy Efficiency Policy Division, Italian Regulatory Authority for Electricity and Gas, Italy, at the IEA DSM Programme workshop in Copenhagen, Denmark on 19 April 2006.
Oxxio is rolling out the largest smart metering project in the Netherlands to differentiate itself and enhance customer processes. Over 30,000 smart meters have been installed, allowing remote reading and providing customers insight into energy consumption. While installation has faced some difficulties, the technology is proven. Oxxio aims to leverage the smart meters to launch new energy saving services for customers, focusing on added value through reduced costs and sustainability. In 2007, Oxxio will continue launching personalized advice, monitoring, and contract products utilizing the smart meter data and system.
Presented by Vlasis Oikonomou, SOM Research Institute, Department of Economics, University of Groningen, Netherlands, at the IEA DSM Programme workshop in Maastricht, the Netherlands on 11 October 2006.
Australia has abundant coal and gas resources but is becoming a net importer of liquid fuels. Greenhouse gas emissions are high per capita due to the energy-intensive economy. Key programs to improve energy efficiency include the National Framework for Energy Efficiency, Energy Efficiency Opportunities Act, and Minimum Energy Performance Standards. Smart metering and continued electricity market reforms aim to enable time-varying pricing and demand-side management, but regulators may not allow innovative tariffs. While on track to meet short-term climate targets, further energy efficiency and demand-side management policies are still needed to reduce emissions beyond 2010.
The document summarizes USA activities related to demand-side management (DSM), including demand response and energy efficiency. It notes there has been strong, renewed interest in these areas in the US after a decade of reduced focus. It provides an overview of the US electricity system and regulatory structure. It then discusses the status of demand response and energy efficiency programs and policies in the US, including key reports and initiatives. Barriers to greater adoption are also mentioned.
More from IEA DSM Implementing Agreement (IA) (20)
2. Share of Maryland Electricity Sales
That Can Be Met by Efficiency Policies
-
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
70,000
80,000
2007
2009
2011
2013
2015
2017
2019
2021
2023
2025
ElectricityDemand(GWh)
CHP
Building Codes
RD&D Initiative
Appliance
Standards
State and Utility
Programs
15% reduction in
forecasted consumption
by 2015
29% reduction in
forecasted
consumption by 2025
3. Levelized Utility Cost of Electricity Resources
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
Energy
Efficiency
Wind Biomass Natural
Gas
Combined
Cycle
Pulverized
Coal
Nuclear Coal
IGCC
Range
of
Levelized
Costs
(cents
per
kWh)
Note:
The
green
bars
represent
the
lower
end
while
the
blue
bars
reflect
the
upper
end
of
costs.
average = 2.5¢
---------------
Sources: ACEEE 2009 for EE, Lazard 2008 for others
4. Energy Efficiency Resource
Standards
Analogous to a Renewable Portfolio Standard
Electric and/or gas savings targets for utilities
• Includes end-use efficiency and sometimes
combined heat & power (CHP) and codes/
standards
• Targets generally start low and increase over time
Savings must be documented in accordance with
evaluation rules established by regulators
5. Why an EERS?
Achieve substantial energy and emissions
savings
Performance based – emphasizes savings,
not spending
Can be easier to legislate savings targets
than spending amounts
Can start programs quickly, without many
years of study (but targets should be
based on cost-effective opportunities)
6. Energy Efficiency Resource Standards
26 States – April 2011
Standard
Voluntary Goal
Pending Standard
Combined RES/EERS
7. State EERS Adoption
PA, NY
MD, OH
NM, MICO, MN,
VA, IL, NC
WA
CT, NVCA, HI
VTTX
IA, DE,
IN, AZ, HI
MA, FL, ME,
AR, WI, OR
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
#ofStateswithEERS
8. Vermont 27%
New York 26%
Massachusetts 26%
Maryland 25%
Delaware 25%
Arizona 22%
Connecticut 18%
Illinois 18%
Minnesota 17%
Iowa 16%
Indiana 14%
Rhode Island 14%
Hawaii 14%
Wisconsin 13.5%
Maine 13.5%
California 13%
Ohio 12%
Colorado 12%
Washington 12%
Michigan 11%
Oregon 10%
Pennsylvania 10%
2020 Cumulative Electricity Savings
Targets by State
9. State EERS Policies
0.00%
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
20.00%
25.00%
30.00%
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Year
CumulativeSavingsas%ofRetailSales
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Hawaii
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Nevada
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
Ohio
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
Texas
Vermont
Washington
Wisconsin
10. Texas
• First state to establish an EERS
• Initially 10% of load growth but increased by
legislature to 20% and by commission to 30% of
load growth
• Utilities have not had difficultly meeting and
exceeding targets
11. Vermont – Raising Efficiency
to a New Level
Source: Efficiency Vermont
12. What Markets Do We Work In?
Existing
Businesses Equipment
Replacement
Business New
Construction
New Homes
Efficient
Products
Existing
Homes
Low-Income
Target Sub-Markets:
• Colleges and Universities
• Municipal Waste and Water
• K-12 Schools
• Industrial Process
• State Buildings
• Farms
• Hospitals
• Ski Areas
13. Implementation of EERS Policies in 2010
• Thirteen of the twenty states with EERS policies in place for
over two years are achieving 100% or more of their goals as of
2010
• Only three states are realizing savings below 70% of their goals
but all 3 are still ramping up
0.00%
0.50%
1.00%
1.50%
2.00%
2.50%
CaliforniaVerm
ontNevada*
W
ashington
Connecticut
M
assachusetts
Rhode
Island*
Iowa*Hawaii
M
innesota*Colorado
O
hio
Illinois
New
M
exicoM
arylandNew
York
PennsylvaniaM
ichigan*
Texas
State
PercentSavingsComparedtoRetail
Sales
Annual % Goal
% Achieved
*Reference year for savings is 2009
14. EERS Implementation:
Observations
• Utilities generally meeting targets for increased
energy efficiency savings, regardless of prior
experience with energy efficiency programs.
• Available data indicates benefits outweigh
costs
• Ramping-up savings requires programmatic
excellence
• Tried & true programs work initially, but innovative
programs reaching all sectors necessary to reach
deeper savings
15. EERS Implementation:
Observations
• Regulation must be clear and fair
• Gradual target ramp-ups
• Clarity on evaluation methods
• All parties must be committed to meeting
targets
• Utilities devote resources needed to meet goals
• Commissions approving sufficient levels of funding
and complementary policies such as performance
incentives/decoupling
16. States with Combined EERS & RES
Pennsylvania: EE in RPS tier 2, but target too
low to get any savings; in 2008 established
separate EERS
Nevada: EE can be 25% of total and utilities now
exceeding this level
Hawaii: Can do unlimited EE; EE been ~40% of
total; EE will be separate as of 2015 with
~32% savings by 2030 target
North Carolina: EE can be 25% of total to start,
40% as of 2021; just getting started
17. Federal EERS Bills in Last
Congress
• Waxman-Markey as passed House
• Includes 20% RES with 5-8% EE
• Senate Energy Committee bill
• 15% RES with efficiency up to 4% EE
• Bills with 15% electric savings and 10%
gas savings by 2020 introduced by
Schumer and Markey
18. White Certificates and
Trading
• Most states do not have trading
• Enough EE that each utility can meet on
own
• CT had white certificates thru 2010, have
not set new goals
• Trading allowed in old PA program but
didn t need any new resources
• NV also allows 3rd party participation
19. Clean Energy Standard (CES)
• Includes renewables, efficiency, nuclear,
carbon capture and storage
• Examples – Lugar and Graham bills,
Obama included in State of the Union
• Issues:
• Include efficiency, no cap
• Numbers – Obama proposed 80% by 2035
• Include natural gas for partial credit?
20. Savings Grow Over Time Under Markey
and Schumer Bills
Electric Natural Gas
Annual Cumulative Annual Cumulative
2011 0.33% 0.3% 0.25% 0.3%
2012 0.67% 1.0% 0.50% 0.8%
2013 1.00% 2.0% 0.75% 1.5%
2014 1.25% 3.3% 1.00% 2.5%
2015 1.25% 4.5% 1.00% 3.5%
2016 1.50% 6.0% 1.25% 4.8%
2017 1.50% 7.5% 1.25% 6.0%
2018 2.50% 10.0% 1.25% 7.3%
2019 2.50% 12.5% 1.25% 8.5%
2020 2.50% 15.0% 1.50% 10.0%
Note: Savings count from date of passage
21. Impacts of a Federal EERS
(10% electric; savings over and above existing state
EERS s)
• Peak demand savings of ~33,000 MW
(110 power plants, 300 MW each)
• CO2 emissions down 74 MMT in 2020
(equivalent to taking 14 million vehicles
off the road for a year)
• 76,000 net jobs created
• Cumulative net savings of $66 billion (B/
C ~3:1)
Source: ACEEE analysis using the methodology from Furrey, Laura.
2009. Laying the Foundation for Implementing a Federal Energy
Efficiency Resource Standard. Washington, DC: ACEEE.
22. How Does a Federal EERS Affect States
that Already Have a State EERS?
States can implement federal and state
EERS simultaneously – same/similar
utility filings, meet higher targets
States can set higher targets to gain
additional savings
States with targets greater than the federal
targets also benefit from savings in
nearby states
- Emission reductions
- Impacts on energy prices
23. Issues for an EERS or CES
Which providers covered? (LSE s vs. Disco s?
Size cap? Public utilities? Gas utilities?)
Which measures eligible? (CHP? T&D?)
Appropriate targets
Any caps on EE?
Trading for EE? (in PA and CT)
Cost caps? (in IL and NC)
Industrial self-direct option? (as in OH & MI)
Monitoring and verification rules?
Relationship to other policies? (PBFs, stimulus
funds, regulatory incentives)
24. For More Information
State utility policies:
http://www.aceee.org/topics/utility-regulation-and-policy
EERS:
http://www.aceee.org/topics/eers
Steven Nadel, snadel@aceee.org
202-507-4000