DR. ARUNDHATI DIWAN
A DEATH TEACHING MANY
LESSONS
PATIENT PRESENTATION
 Mr. Misal Santosh, 40 years old
male
 Brought in Emergency Department
at 9:30 Hrs by relatives
 History of unknown bite at around
8:00hrs at Velu ,Bhor while
working in the paddy field. (exact
site of bite not known)
 Patient had told the incident to his co-
workers and complained of giddiness
 when he collapsed infront of the coworkers
EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT
 09:30hrs
 Patient was brought in unresponsive state
 profuse sweating
 frothing from the mouth
 with involuntary passage of urine.
 On Examination:
Pulse- 108/min (regular in rhythm,
normal as well as equal in volume)
All peripheral pulses felt
Blood Pressure - 130/90 mmHg
Respiratory Rate- 20/min
Saturation on room air - 92%
Afebrile
No obvious bite mark
Examination
 Neurological Examination done in
Emergency department
 Not responding to verbal stimuli.
 Spontaneous movements of only right
upper and lower limb , no movements on
left side of the body
 Facial asymmetry noted
 Right pupil of 3mm while left pupil 4mm
both sluggishly reacting to light
 bilateral extensor plantar response
 No signs of meningitis
10:30 hrs; As the Glasgow Coma Scale was
7/15, patient was intubated by Rapid sequence
Induction.
UNKNOWN BITE
ACUTE
HEMIPLEGIA
 More than 200,00
snake bites are
reported in India and
an estimated 35,000 to
50,000 people die each
year due to snake
envenomation.
Course in Hospital
11:30hrs ,Patient shifted for Brain imaging
ensuring stability during transport.
Treatment given in Emergency Department
 Midazolam 4+4+2+2+2+2 during
intubation
 Propofol 100mg
 Mannitol 100ml
 Hydrocort 100mg
 Levera 1gm
CT BRAIN +MR DIFFUSION
12:15hrs
Patient shifted to ICU for further management
On CT images there is loss of grey-white matter differentiation
and hypodense (dark) areas in right fronto – temporo-parietal
region.
MSCT BRAIN AND MR DIFFUSION
On FLAIR images there is loss on flow void in right MCA.
DAY 1(21/6/18)
 12:30hrs In ICU, patient was taken on
mechanical ventilator support
XRAY-CHEST
ECG
ABG
Pressure AC mode, FiO2-
100%
 Ph-7.40
 PCO2-24.9
 PO2-166
 HCO3-18.1
 Anion gap-16.8
 Lac-5.7
s/o metabolic acidosis with
respiratory alkalosis with
high lactates
 While taking 2nd IV access it was noticed
 That there was excessive bleeding from IV
site.
 Meanwhile blood investigations revealed
1:00 pm
PARAMETERS OBSERVED
VALUES
NORMAL RANGE
Hb 13.9g/dl 11-15g/dl
TLC 14300/cumm 4000-10000/cumm
Platelet 1.34L/cumm 1.5-4.6L/cumm
PT >180sec 10.3-13.2 sec
APTT >180sec 25.4-34.6sec
INR >15
PARAMETERS RESULT RANGE
Serum Sodium 138 mEg/L 130-145mEg/L
Serum Potassium 3.9 mEq/L 3.5-4.5mEg/L
Blood Urea 37 mg/dl 10-45 mg/dl
Serum creatinine 1.27 mg/dl 0.6-1.2 mg/dl
SGOT 122 iu/l 5-40iu/L
SGPT 131 IU/L 5-40iu/L
S. BILIRUBIN (Total) 1.79 Mg/dl 0.2-1.0 mg/dl
s. BILIRUBIN
(direct)
0.54 mg/dl 0.1-0.3 mg/dl
AT THIS TIME…key points
h/o unknown bite ?snake bite
Right Middle Cerebral Artery territory
infarct with left hemiplegia with
unresponsiveness ?post-ictal
Associated with Coagulopathy
“20 MINUTES WHOLE BLOOD CLOTTING
TEST”
 20min Whole Blood Clot test was done and
blood did not clot after 20Min.
20 min whole blood clotting test
 Neurophysician opinion
 10 vials of ASV and 6 FFP.
 With Monitoring of 6hrly PT/APTT
LYOPHILIZED ASV (in powder form)
Repeat coagulation profile at 1:00am
PT- 15.5
APTT- 21.1
INR- 1.35
 The 20 minute whole blood clotting test was
repeated
 The repeat 20min WBCT showed that the blood got
clotted 12:00 am
REPEAT 20min WBCT
Day 2 (22/6/18)
 Patient on ventilator support
 On Fentanyl and Midazolam infusion @ 4ml/hr
 Pulse- 80/min
 BP- 130/80mmHg
 I/O- 2485/2350ml
 RS- AEBE
 CVS- S1s2 +
 PA- soft, bowel sound +
 GCS- E2VtM2
DAY 2 Coagulation profile
2:00 am 9:00 am 3:00 pm 9:00 pm
PT 15.5 16 12.6 15.6
APTT 21.1 26.4 25.9 27.1
INR 1.35 1.39 1.09 1.36
INVESTIGATIONS (22/6/18) RESULTS
Urine routine RBC-15-20
Pus- occasional
Epithelial cells- occasional
USG (abdomen + pelvis) Minimal free fluid is seen in the pelvis
XRAY Chest Lung fields clear
Day 3 (23/6/18)
 7:00 am ;Patient on ventilator support
 On Fentanyl infusion @ 5ml/hr
 Pulse- 76/min
 BP- 140/90mmHg
 Output @ 150ml/hr
 RS- AEBE
 CVS-s1s2 +
 CNS- E2M2Vt
 3:00 pm
 Patient BP dropped to 90/50mmHg
(started on noradrenaline infusion)
 Pulse rate- 140/min
 RS- new onset B/L crepts+
 CVS- S1S2 +
 CNS- E1M1Vt
ECGS
 4:00 pm; Repeat Brain imaging done.
 5:45pm; Neurosurgery reference taken
Advised to continue conservative line of
management. No surgical intervention.
 At 19:30 hrs patient had brady
arrest.
 CPR was started according to ACLS
protocol
 CPR continued for 20mins
 ROSC not attained
 Pulse not palpable, BP not
recordable, dolls eye reflex absent
 ECG- no electrical activity
 Patient declared dead at 19:52 hrs
BODY SENT FOR POST MORTEM
UPON REFLECTION
? REPEAT DOSE OF ASV
? ROLE OF NEOSTIGMINE
DISCUSSION
1. SNAKE BITE AND STROKE
2. TREATMENT
3. ASV DOSE
MAJOR FAMILIES OF POISONOUS SNAKES
 Common Cobra
 King Cobra
 Common Krait
 Russell Viper
 Saw-scaled Viper
 Pit Viper
 Sea Snakes
SNAKES
 The viper venom is a mixture of
numerous enzymes some of which appear
to have opposing effects
 Some enzymes causes
hypofibrinogenemia,
hypopothrombinemia, thrombocytopenia
and fibrinolysis
 There are potent proteases (arginine
esterase hydrolase) acting as activators of
clotting factors X and V thereby
promoting coagulation.
 The net effect of these enzymes is the
activation of intrincsic coagulation pathway
which leads to consumptive coagulopathy
 These leads to small and even large vessels
occlusion due to microthrombi formed
resulting in cerebral infarct
NEUROTOXIC MANIFESTATIONS
 Ptosis
 Opthalmoplegia
 Diplopia
 Dysphagia
 Respiratory paralysis
VASCULOTOXIC MANIFESTATIONS
 Gangrene
 Local swelling
 Blistering, necrosis
 A pre existing pro coagulant state due to
mutation in factor V, deficiency of Protein C
or S, antithrombin 3 and antiphospholipid
antibodies could account tendency towards
thrombosis in large vessels
 Special test for pre existing coagulant state
could not be done in this patient.
ASV administration criteria
 Evidence of coagulopathy
 Evidence of neurotoxicity
 Cardiovascular abnormality
 Persistent and severe vomiting, per abdominal pain
 Severe local swelling
 Rapid extension of swelling
ASV ADMINISTRATION
 Total required dose will be approximately around
10 vials to 30 vials
 Each vial neutralises 6mg of viper venom
 Not all victim requires 10 vials as some may be
injected less than 63mg
 Decision of the treating physician is of utmost
importance because guidelines may not be useful for
all patients
ANTI SNAKE VENOM DOSE
 INITIAL DOSE
mild envenomation (systemic symptoms manifest
>3 hrs after bite) neurotoxic/hemotoxic 8-10 vials
severe envenomation (systemic symptoms
manifest < 3 hrs after bite) neurotoxic or hemotoxic 8
vials
Each vial is 10ml of reconstituted ASV.
 FURTHER DOSES
It will depend on the response to the initial dose.
ASV should be administered either as intravenous
infusion (5-10ml/kg body weight) or as slow
intravenous injection i.e 2ml/min)
ASV should be administered over 1 hour at constant
speed and patient should be closely monitored.
IMPORTANT POINT TO REMEMBER
 After initial ASV dose, no additional ASV should be
given until the next clotting test at 6 hours.
 This is due to the inability of the liver to replace
clotting factors in less than 6 hours
 The ASV regime for neurotoxic envenomation is not
clear. After 1-2 hrs of initial dose, patient should be
reassessed and if symptoms have worsened or have
not improved, a second dose of ASV should be give.
REFERENCES
 1. JAPI, management of snake bite in India, Aug
2016, vol64
 2. Journal of The Indian Academy of
Geriatrics, Vol 7, no. 1, March, 2011, K
Krishna, AG Diwan, N Mendiratta, S Jadhav,
S Reddy
 3. Snake bite: Indian Guidelines and protocol, Surjit
singh, Gagandip Singh
 4. API textbook of Medicine, 10th edition, vol2
T H A N K Y O U

DEATH AUDIT.pptx

  • 1.
    DR. ARUNDHATI DIWAN ADEATH TEACHING MANY LESSONS
  • 3.
    PATIENT PRESENTATION  Mr.Misal Santosh, 40 years old male  Brought in Emergency Department at 9:30 Hrs by relatives  History of unknown bite at around 8:00hrs at Velu ,Bhor while working in the paddy field. (exact site of bite not known)
  • 4.
     Patient hadtold the incident to his co- workers and complained of giddiness  when he collapsed infront of the coworkers
  • 5.
    EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT  09:30hrs Patient was brought in unresponsive state  profuse sweating  frothing from the mouth  with involuntary passage of urine.
  • 6.
     On Examination: Pulse-108/min (regular in rhythm, normal as well as equal in volume) All peripheral pulses felt Blood Pressure - 130/90 mmHg Respiratory Rate- 20/min Saturation on room air - 92% Afebrile No obvious bite mark
  • 7.
    Examination  Neurological Examinationdone in Emergency department
  • 8.
     Not respondingto verbal stimuli.  Spontaneous movements of only right upper and lower limb , no movements on left side of the body  Facial asymmetry noted  Right pupil of 3mm while left pupil 4mm both sluggishly reacting to light  bilateral extensor plantar response  No signs of meningitis
  • 9.
    10:30 hrs; Asthe Glasgow Coma Scale was 7/15, patient was intubated by Rapid sequence Induction.
  • 10.
    UNKNOWN BITE ACUTE HEMIPLEGIA  Morethan 200,00 snake bites are reported in India and an estimated 35,000 to 50,000 people die each year due to snake envenomation.
  • 11.
    Course in Hospital 11:30hrs,Patient shifted for Brain imaging ensuring stability during transport. Treatment given in Emergency Department  Midazolam 4+4+2+2+2+2 during intubation  Propofol 100mg  Mannitol 100ml  Hydrocort 100mg  Levera 1gm
  • 12.
    CT BRAIN +MRDIFFUSION 12:15hrs Patient shifted to ICU for further management
  • 13.
    On CT imagesthere is loss of grey-white matter differentiation and hypodense (dark) areas in right fronto – temporo-parietal region. MSCT BRAIN AND MR DIFFUSION
  • 16.
    On FLAIR imagesthere is loss on flow void in right MCA.
  • 17.
    DAY 1(21/6/18)  12:30hrsIn ICU, patient was taken on mechanical ventilator support
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
    ABG Pressure AC mode,FiO2- 100%  Ph-7.40  PCO2-24.9  PO2-166  HCO3-18.1  Anion gap-16.8  Lac-5.7 s/o metabolic acidosis with respiratory alkalosis with high lactates
  • 21.
     While taking2nd IV access it was noticed  That there was excessive bleeding from IV site.
  • 22.
     Meanwhile bloodinvestigations revealed
  • 23.
    1:00 pm PARAMETERS OBSERVED VALUES NORMALRANGE Hb 13.9g/dl 11-15g/dl TLC 14300/cumm 4000-10000/cumm Platelet 1.34L/cumm 1.5-4.6L/cumm PT >180sec 10.3-13.2 sec APTT >180sec 25.4-34.6sec INR >15
  • 24.
    PARAMETERS RESULT RANGE SerumSodium 138 mEg/L 130-145mEg/L Serum Potassium 3.9 mEq/L 3.5-4.5mEg/L Blood Urea 37 mg/dl 10-45 mg/dl Serum creatinine 1.27 mg/dl 0.6-1.2 mg/dl SGOT 122 iu/l 5-40iu/L SGPT 131 IU/L 5-40iu/L S. BILIRUBIN (Total) 1.79 Mg/dl 0.2-1.0 mg/dl s. BILIRUBIN (direct) 0.54 mg/dl 0.1-0.3 mg/dl
  • 25.
    AT THIS TIME…keypoints h/o unknown bite ?snake bite Right Middle Cerebral Artery territory infarct with left hemiplegia with unresponsiveness ?post-ictal Associated with Coagulopathy
  • 26.
    “20 MINUTES WHOLEBLOOD CLOTTING TEST”
  • 27.
     20min WholeBlood Clot test was done and blood did not clot after 20Min.
  • 28.
    20 min wholeblood clotting test
  • 29.
     Neurophysician opinion 10 vials of ASV and 6 FFP.  With Monitoring of 6hrly PT/APTT
  • 30.
    LYOPHILIZED ASV (inpowder form)
  • 31.
    Repeat coagulation profileat 1:00am PT- 15.5 APTT- 21.1 INR- 1.35
  • 32.
     The 20minute whole blood clotting test was repeated  The repeat 20min WBCT showed that the blood got clotted 12:00 am
  • 33.
  • 34.
    Day 2 (22/6/18) Patient on ventilator support  On Fentanyl and Midazolam infusion @ 4ml/hr  Pulse- 80/min  BP- 130/80mmHg  I/O- 2485/2350ml  RS- AEBE  CVS- S1s2 +  PA- soft, bowel sound +  GCS- E2VtM2
  • 35.
    DAY 2 Coagulationprofile 2:00 am 9:00 am 3:00 pm 9:00 pm PT 15.5 16 12.6 15.6 APTT 21.1 26.4 25.9 27.1 INR 1.35 1.39 1.09 1.36
  • 36.
    INVESTIGATIONS (22/6/18) RESULTS Urineroutine RBC-15-20 Pus- occasional Epithelial cells- occasional USG (abdomen + pelvis) Minimal free fluid is seen in the pelvis XRAY Chest Lung fields clear
  • 37.
    Day 3 (23/6/18) 7:00 am ;Patient on ventilator support  On Fentanyl infusion @ 5ml/hr  Pulse- 76/min  BP- 140/90mmHg  Output @ 150ml/hr  RS- AEBE  CVS-s1s2 +  CNS- E2M2Vt
  • 38.
     3:00 pm Patient BP dropped to 90/50mmHg (started on noradrenaline infusion)  Pulse rate- 140/min  RS- new onset B/L crepts+  CVS- S1S2 +  CNS- E1M1Vt
  • 39.
  • 40.
     4:00 pm;Repeat Brain imaging done.
  • 42.
     5:45pm; Neurosurgeryreference taken Advised to continue conservative line of management. No surgical intervention.
  • 43.
     At 19:30hrs patient had brady arrest.  CPR was started according to ACLS protocol  CPR continued for 20mins  ROSC not attained  Pulse not palpable, BP not recordable, dolls eye reflex absent  ECG- no electrical activity  Patient declared dead at 19:52 hrs
  • 44.
    BODY SENT FORPOST MORTEM
  • 45.
    UPON REFLECTION ? REPEATDOSE OF ASV ? ROLE OF NEOSTIGMINE
  • 46.
    DISCUSSION 1. SNAKE BITEAND STROKE 2. TREATMENT 3. ASV DOSE
  • 47.
    MAJOR FAMILIES OFPOISONOUS SNAKES  Common Cobra  King Cobra  Common Krait  Russell Viper  Saw-scaled Viper  Pit Viper  Sea Snakes
  • 48.
  • 49.
     The vipervenom is a mixture of numerous enzymes some of which appear to have opposing effects  Some enzymes causes hypofibrinogenemia, hypopothrombinemia, thrombocytopenia and fibrinolysis  There are potent proteases (arginine esterase hydrolase) acting as activators of clotting factors X and V thereby promoting coagulation.
  • 50.
     The neteffect of these enzymes is the activation of intrincsic coagulation pathway which leads to consumptive coagulopathy  These leads to small and even large vessels occlusion due to microthrombi formed resulting in cerebral infarct
  • 51.
    NEUROTOXIC MANIFESTATIONS  Ptosis Opthalmoplegia  Diplopia  Dysphagia  Respiratory paralysis
  • 52.
    VASCULOTOXIC MANIFESTATIONS  Gangrene Local swelling  Blistering, necrosis
  • 53.
     A preexisting pro coagulant state due to mutation in factor V, deficiency of Protein C or S, antithrombin 3 and antiphospholipid antibodies could account tendency towards thrombosis in large vessels  Special test for pre existing coagulant state could not be done in this patient.
  • 54.
    ASV administration criteria Evidence of coagulopathy  Evidence of neurotoxicity  Cardiovascular abnormality  Persistent and severe vomiting, per abdominal pain  Severe local swelling  Rapid extension of swelling
  • 55.
    ASV ADMINISTRATION  Totalrequired dose will be approximately around 10 vials to 30 vials  Each vial neutralises 6mg of viper venom  Not all victim requires 10 vials as some may be injected less than 63mg  Decision of the treating physician is of utmost importance because guidelines may not be useful for all patients
  • 56.
    ANTI SNAKE VENOMDOSE  INITIAL DOSE mild envenomation (systemic symptoms manifest >3 hrs after bite) neurotoxic/hemotoxic 8-10 vials severe envenomation (systemic symptoms manifest < 3 hrs after bite) neurotoxic or hemotoxic 8 vials Each vial is 10ml of reconstituted ASV.
  • 57.
     FURTHER DOSES Itwill depend on the response to the initial dose. ASV should be administered either as intravenous infusion (5-10ml/kg body weight) or as slow intravenous injection i.e 2ml/min) ASV should be administered over 1 hour at constant speed and patient should be closely monitored.
  • 58.
    IMPORTANT POINT TOREMEMBER  After initial ASV dose, no additional ASV should be given until the next clotting test at 6 hours.  This is due to the inability of the liver to replace clotting factors in less than 6 hours  The ASV regime for neurotoxic envenomation is not clear. After 1-2 hrs of initial dose, patient should be reassessed and if symptoms have worsened or have not improved, a second dose of ASV should be give.
  • 59.
    REFERENCES  1. JAPI,management of snake bite in India, Aug 2016, vol64  2. Journal of The Indian Academy of Geriatrics, Vol 7, no. 1, March, 2011, K Krishna, AG Diwan, N Mendiratta, S Jadhav, S Reddy  3. Snake bite: Indian Guidelines and protocol, Surjit singh, Gagandip Singh  4. API textbook of Medicine, 10th edition, vol2
  • 60.
    T H AN K Y O U

Editor's Notes

  • #16 Areas of restricted diffusion are noted involving right fronto-parieto-temporal lobes, right lentiform, caudate nuclei and part of right occipital lobe.