The document summarizes lessons learned from a multi-year DCS migration project at the Total Port Arthur Refinery. It discusses the background of the refinery and reasons for the DCS migration. It also covers key aspects of managing the project such as developing the scope, selling the program to management, project staffing, and handling unexpected issues discovered during implementation.
This is an overview of the concept of Telecom Performance Management System for Tier-1 and Tier-2 operators.
The main features of this concept are:
- full coverage of all TMN model layers
- the ability for extension to full FCAPS model
- integration with any third-party systems
- distributed and fault-tolerant database model optimized for very large data volumes
Darwin Logerot of ProSys presented an Alarm Rationalization Workshop - Tips, Tricks and Tracks at ISA Automation Week 2012 Contact us at prosys.com or 225-291-9591 x225 if you have any questions.
When developing data center energy-use estimations, engineers must account for all sources of energy use in the facility. Most energy consumption is obvious: computers, cooling plant and related equipment, lighting, and other miscellaneous electrical loads. Designing efficient and effective data centers is a top priority for consulting engineers. Cooling is a large portion of data center energy use, second only to the IT load. Although there are several options to help maximize HVAC efficiency and minimize energy consumption, data centers come in many shapes, sizes, and configurations. By developing a deep understanding of their client’s data center HVAC requirements, consulting engineers can help maintain the necessary availability level of mission critical applications while reducing energy consumption.
Data Center Checklist for Infrastructure Best Practices (SlideShare)SP Home Run Inc.
http://DataCenterLeadGen.com Data Center Checklist for Infrastructure Best Practices (SlideShare). Want a data center checklist for your rental or colocation facility? Use these items for a best practices workout to see if anything’s missing. Copyright (C) SP Home Run Inc. All worldwide rights reserved.
Helping Industrial OEMs improve asset uptime and service profitability through end-to-end M2M design and deployment support, remote monitoring, data management, prognostics and in depth analytics
This is an overview of the concept of Telecom Performance Management System for Tier-1 and Tier-2 operators.
The main features of this concept are:
- full coverage of all TMN model layers
- the ability for extension to full FCAPS model
- integration with any third-party systems
- distributed and fault-tolerant database model optimized for very large data volumes
Darwin Logerot of ProSys presented an Alarm Rationalization Workshop - Tips, Tricks and Tracks at ISA Automation Week 2012 Contact us at prosys.com or 225-291-9591 x225 if you have any questions.
When developing data center energy-use estimations, engineers must account for all sources of energy use in the facility. Most energy consumption is obvious: computers, cooling plant and related equipment, lighting, and other miscellaneous electrical loads. Designing efficient and effective data centers is a top priority for consulting engineers. Cooling is a large portion of data center energy use, second only to the IT load. Although there are several options to help maximize HVAC efficiency and minimize energy consumption, data centers come in many shapes, sizes, and configurations. By developing a deep understanding of their client’s data center HVAC requirements, consulting engineers can help maintain the necessary availability level of mission critical applications while reducing energy consumption.
Data Center Checklist for Infrastructure Best Practices (SlideShare)SP Home Run Inc.
http://DataCenterLeadGen.com Data Center Checklist for Infrastructure Best Practices (SlideShare). Want a data center checklist for your rental or colocation facility? Use these items for a best practices workout to see if anything’s missing. Copyright (C) SP Home Run Inc. All worldwide rights reserved.
Helping Industrial OEMs improve asset uptime and service profitability through end-to-end M2M design and deployment support, remote monitoring, data management, prognostics and in depth analytics
Application framework (ofen called TAM) is Application component of TM Forum frameworx. TAM maps with Business Process framework (aka eTOM) and Information Framework (aka SID).
Top 10 Network Operation Center Best Practices
In this free ebook you'll find tips
and best practices related to:
5 Essential tools NOC must have:
1. How to develop and maintain team knowledge and skills
2. Training new NOC Team
3. Improving communication and collaboration within and outside the NOC
4. Escalating, prioritizing, and handling problems
John Day developed a proactive maintenance process in 1978 and manage maintenance and engineering at Alumax Mt. Holly and later at Alcoa Mt Holly for over 20 years. These are the slides he presented at the 1997 SMRP Conference. Great slides with great information. If you would like the slides and not PDF send me an email at rsmith@maintenancebestpractices.com. I worked for John Day back in the early 1980s which started my journey in Proactive Maintenance.
Naphtha catalytic reforming process is the key process in oil refining to meet the demands of gasoline fuel specifications and hydrogen gas for hydrotreating and isomerization units. But one bottleneck of high aromatics content in gasoline may restrict the naphtha reforming process due to strict environmental regulations.
Review of TIA-942 data standards and some of the best practices surrounding a data center.
Sri Chalasani (Plante & Moran) is available to provide consulting on data center and infrastructure solutions.
Creating a Culture of Operational Discipline that leads to Operational Excell...Wilson Perumal and Company
As the world becomes more complex, the best companies and leaders are beginning to realize that improving culture is their greatest lever for achieving Operational Excellence. Complex systems require a different kind of culture—one with a specific set of guiding principles. In order to instill these principles in your organization, it is necessary to learn what the current culture is and what people think it ought to be like, establish the guiding principles necessary to be successful, align them to every level of the organization, and develop and sustain them through committed leadership and integration into key management system processes.
Wilson Perumal & Company has a long track record of helping companies in all industries transform their cultures and dramatically improve operational results. In this Vantage Point, we will share the most important lessons we have learned through our research and experience working directly with High-Reliability Organizations (HROs) and our clients as they pursue Operational Excellence.
In order to provide reliable, safe and secure Data Centre and mission critical facilities, certain practices must be instituted and enforced. This document establishes basic standards and procedures centrally managed Data Centre for any of private organization both owned and leased, along with other mission critical support facilities. These procedures apply to all authorized employees as well as authorized business partners.
VLE Data - Selection and Use
0 INTRODUCTION/PURPOSE
1 SCOPE
2 FIELD OF APPLICATION
3 DEFINITIONS
4 DIAGRAMMATIC REPRESENTATION OF IDEAL
AND NON-IDEAL SYSTEMS
4.1 Ideal Mixtures
4.2 Non-Ideal Mixtures
5 REVIEW OF VLE MODELS
5.1 Ideal Behavior in Both Phases
5.2 Liquid Phase Non-Idealities
5.3 High Pressure Systems
5.4 Special Models
6 SETTING UP A VLE MODEL
6.1 Define Problem
6.2 Select Data
6.3 Select Correlation(s)
6.4 Produce Model
7 AVOIDING PITFALLS
7.1 Experimental Data is Better than Estimates
7.2 Check Validity of Fitted Model
7.3 Check Limitations of Estimation Methods
7.4 Know Your System
7.5 Appreciate Errors and Effects
7.6 If in Doubt – Ask
8 A CASE STUDY
8.1 The Problem
8.2 The System
8.3 Data Available
8.4 Selected Correlation
8.5 Simulation
8.6 Selection of Model
9 RECOMMENDED READING
10 VLE EXPERTS IN GBHE
APPENDICES
A USE OF EXTENDED ANTOINE EQUATION
B USE OF WILSON EQUATION
C USEFUL METHODS OF ESTIMATING
D EQUATIONS OF STATE FOR VLE CALCULATIONS
TABLES
1 SUMMARY OF VLE METHODS
2 LIST OF USEFUL REFERENCES
FIGURES
1 VAPOR-LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM - IDEAL SOLUTION
BEHAVIOR
2 VAPOR-LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM - A GENERALISED
Y-X DIAGRAM
3 VAPOR-LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM - MINIMUM BOILING
AZEOTROPE
4 VAPOR-LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM - MAXIMUM BOILING
AZEOTROPE
5 VAPOR-LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM - MINIMUM BOILING
AZEOTROPE -TWO LIQUID PHASES
6 SENSITIVITY TO ERROR IN VLE DATA (BASED ON FENSKE EQUATION)
7(a) FITTING WILSON 'A' VALUES TO VLE DATA - CASE A
7(b) FITTING WILSON 'A' VALUES TO VLE DATA - CASE B
7(c) FITTING WILSON 'A' VALUES TO VLE DATA - CASE C
enhanced Telecommunication Operating Model (e-TOM) is part of TM Frameworx. The eTOM is a comprehensive standard business processes framework. It is industry standard best practices and recommends for all business processes and or rules to support Business Support Systems (BSS) /Operation Support Systems (OSS) for communications Service providers (CSP) space. Please visit the TM Forum site for details:
https://www.tmforum.org/business-process-framework/
Endress+Hauser : Overview & Innovation in W&WWTP Instrumentationyann lafforgue
Presentation done during the Franc-Waret Seminar in Belgium Wallonie 23/02/2016:
How is measurement equipment adapted to requirements of
Water &WasteWater applications ?
E+H provides a complete portfolio with the right instrument for the right application.
Application framework (ofen called TAM) is Application component of TM Forum frameworx. TAM maps with Business Process framework (aka eTOM) and Information Framework (aka SID).
Top 10 Network Operation Center Best Practices
In this free ebook you'll find tips
and best practices related to:
5 Essential tools NOC must have:
1. How to develop and maintain team knowledge and skills
2. Training new NOC Team
3. Improving communication and collaboration within and outside the NOC
4. Escalating, prioritizing, and handling problems
John Day developed a proactive maintenance process in 1978 and manage maintenance and engineering at Alumax Mt. Holly and later at Alcoa Mt Holly for over 20 years. These are the slides he presented at the 1997 SMRP Conference. Great slides with great information. If you would like the slides and not PDF send me an email at rsmith@maintenancebestpractices.com. I worked for John Day back in the early 1980s which started my journey in Proactive Maintenance.
Naphtha catalytic reforming process is the key process in oil refining to meet the demands of gasoline fuel specifications and hydrogen gas for hydrotreating and isomerization units. But one bottleneck of high aromatics content in gasoline may restrict the naphtha reforming process due to strict environmental regulations.
Review of TIA-942 data standards and some of the best practices surrounding a data center.
Sri Chalasani (Plante & Moran) is available to provide consulting on data center and infrastructure solutions.
Creating a Culture of Operational Discipline that leads to Operational Excell...Wilson Perumal and Company
As the world becomes more complex, the best companies and leaders are beginning to realize that improving culture is their greatest lever for achieving Operational Excellence. Complex systems require a different kind of culture—one with a specific set of guiding principles. In order to instill these principles in your organization, it is necessary to learn what the current culture is and what people think it ought to be like, establish the guiding principles necessary to be successful, align them to every level of the organization, and develop and sustain them through committed leadership and integration into key management system processes.
Wilson Perumal & Company has a long track record of helping companies in all industries transform their cultures and dramatically improve operational results. In this Vantage Point, we will share the most important lessons we have learned through our research and experience working directly with High-Reliability Organizations (HROs) and our clients as they pursue Operational Excellence.
In order to provide reliable, safe and secure Data Centre and mission critical facilities, certain practices must be instituted and enforced. This document establishes basic standards and procedures centrally managed Data Centre for any of private organization both owned and leased, along with other mission critical support facilities. These procedures apply to all authorized employees as well as authorized business partners.
VLE Data - Selection and Use
0 INTRODUCTION/PURPOSE
1 SCOPE
2 FIELD OF APPLICATION
3 DEFINITIONS
4 DIAGRAMMATIC REPRESENTATION OF IDEAL
AND NON-IDEAL SYSTEMS
4.1 Ideal Mixtures
4.2 Non-Ideal Mixtures
5 REVIEW OF VLE MODELS
5.1 Ideal Behavior in Both Phases
5.2 Liquid Phase Non-Idealities
5.3 High Pressure Systems
5.4 Special Models
6 SETTING UP A VLE MODEL
6.1 Define Problem
6.2 Select Data
6.3 Select Correlation(s)
6.4 Produce Model
7 AVOIDING PITFALLS
7.1 Experimental Data is Better than Estimates
7.2 Check Validity of Fitted Model
7.3 Check Limitations of Estimation Methods
7.4 Know Your System
7.5 Appreciate Errors and Effects
7.6 If in Doubt – Ask
8 A CASE STUDY
8.1 The Problem
8.2 The System
8.3 Data Available
8.4 Selected Correlation
8.5 Simulation
8.6 Selection of Model
9 RECOMMENDED READING
10 VLE EXPERTS IN GBHE
APPENDICES
A USE OF EXTENDED ANTOINE EQUATION
B USE OF WILSON EQUATION
C USEFUL METHODS OF ESTIMATING
D EQUATIONS OF STATE FOR VLE CALCULATIONS
TABLES
1 SUMMARY OF VLE METHODS
2 LIST OF USEFUL REFERENCES
FIGURES
1 VAPOR-LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM - IDEAL SOLUTION
BEHAVIOR
2 VAPOR-LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM - A GENERALISED
Y-X DIAGRAM
3 VAPOR-LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM - MINIMUM BOILING
AZEOTROPE
4 VAPOR-LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM - MAXIMUM BOILING
AZEOTROPE
5 VAPOR-LIQUID EQUILIBRIUM - MINIMUM BOILING
AZEOTROPE -TWO LIQUID PHASES
6 SENSITIVITY TO ERROR IN VLE DATA (BASED ON FENSKE EQUATION)
7(a) FITTING WILSON 'A' VALUES TO VLE DATA - CASE A
7(b) FITTING WILSON 'A' VALUES TO VLE DATA - CASE B
7(c) FITTING WILSON 'A' VALUES TO VLE DATA - CASE C
enhanced Telecommunication Operating Model (e-TOM) is part of TM Frameworx. The eTOM is a comprehensive standard business processes framework. It is industry standard best practices and recommends for all business processes and or rules to support Business Support Systems (BSS) /Operation Support Systems (OSS) for communications Service providers (CSP) space. Please visit the TM Forum site for details:
https://www.tmforum.org/business-process-framework/
Endress+Hauser : Overview & Innovation in W&WWTP Instrumentationyann lafforgue
Presentation done during the Franc-Waret Seminar in Belgium Wallonie 23/02/2016:
How is measurement equipment adapted to requirements of
Water &WasteWater applications ?
E+H provides a complete portfolio with the right instrument for the right application.
DCS replacement in a 24/7 Critical District Energy Facility. Pepco Energy Services (customer) partnered with Thermo Systems, a Rockwell Automation Solution Partner, to design, build, deploy and commission a turnkey replacement of its aging DCS system serving the district energy system in Midtown Atlantic City. The successful migration included zero customer downtime, ease of service, increased operational efficiency, billing accuracy, and expansion possibilities moving forward.
Everybody has taken a selfie with their smartphone. But have you thought of taking a selfie for marketing your business or personal brand? Here are 10 tips on creating your own perfect marketing selfie, with photo instruction to take your marketing to the next level with smartphone photography!
For a free Chapter of my upcoming book, Visual Marketing Secrets, How to Use Smartphone Photography to Engage Online and Attract More Customers, sign up at
http://saywowmarketing.com/email
Scenic royal kingdom of rajasthan tour itarnary for 9 Nights 10 DaysRakesh Jaswal
Customized Rajasthan Holidays Tour Packages at Low Rates. Rajasthan Tour Packages at 25% Offer. Book your package now! Are you planning your next holiday trip to Rajasthan? Then wait and look over the Rajasthan Tour Itinerary & Customize your trip with our experts :)
As test managers, we face challenging situations that require us to draw on our past experiences, principles, and good practices in order to have any chance at all for success. Michael Wasielczyk faced this challenge immediately after joining T. Rowe Price. He started his new job, responsible for managing the testing effort on a mission-critical data warehouse, and he had no experience managing a data warehouse testing effort. In addition, Michael found there were no formal practices for software development or testing. In fact, the establishment of an independent test team was a foreign concept to the corporate culture. A team of on-shore and off-shore testers arrived at the same time as Michael. Development was underway. A delivery date for the project had been communicated and could not be missed. So, how did he possibly succeed? Michael describes the challenges he faced over the following 205 days, the guiding principles he used, and the key decisions he made along the way. He shares the value of management support, tailoring best practices to the situation at hand, and understanding what battles are worth fighting for. Join Michael to learn how you can better prepare yourself when faced with a similar situation.
An explanation of how Release, Change, Configuration, and Project Management work together to coordinate multiple implementations into test and production environments while reducing risk and business impact.
Electrical engineer with vast experience in energy conservation and utilities process equipment. Successful implementation of energy reduction initiatives and energy awareness program. Root cause analysis techniques to eliminate causal factors. Improve equipment reliability.
Engineering DevOps Right the First TimeMarc Hornbeek
Companies with high-performing IT organizations are twice as likely to exceed their profitability, market share and productivity goals. These are impressive results which every business would like to accomplish before competitors beat them to it. Only a minority of enterprises are achieving high-performance DevOps implementations. Many are struggling to realize DevOps at all, at the level of business units and enterprise. An engineering approach for businesses and enterprises to implement DevOps, at the business or enterprise level meets specific business transformation goals in the fastest time with the least cost and without false starts. An engineering approach which leads to DevOps success quickly and without false starts will be presented. A unique one-of-a-kind physical model of an electro-mechanical DevOps machine and results of DevOps pipeline software simulations will be displayed and used to demonstrate the principles of DevOps stage optimizations.
GLOC 2018: Automation or How We Eliminated Manual EBS R12.2 Upgrades and Beca...ennVee TechnoGroup Inc
ennVee's presentation from the 2018 Great Lakes Oracle Conference in Cleveland, Ohio. Session hosted by Joe Bong (Vice President) and Veera Venugopal (Head of Delivery). Topics include automation best practices for upgrading to Oracle E-Business Suite (EBS) R12.2, and the "Voice of the Customer"; a collection of hundreds of survey responses from IT leaders that have or plan to upgrade to R12.2, top challenges, objectives, and timelines, etc.
2. 2
Presenter
• Randy Conley is DCS/ SIS/ APC Implementation Supervisor for TOTAL’s
Port Arthur Texas refinery. He is currently architect for PAR’s multiyear
refinery-wide DCS and SIS migration projects. He also supervises the
advanced control group. Randy’s previous employers include Profimatics
and CITGO’s Lake Charles Louisiana refinery.
• Randy is a Registered Professional Engineer (PE), Project Management
Professional (PMP) and TOTAL’s AFPM Decision-Support committee
member. He holds BS and MS degrees in Chemical Engineering from
Lamar University.
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
3. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
TOTAL – Port Arthur Refinery (PAR)
• PAR is a 174MBPD transportation fuels, merchant refinery
• The site began in the 1920s as an Atlantic Refining oil terminal. The terminal
shipped crude oil from the nearby Spindletop oil field to Atlantic’s New
Jersey refinery
• PAR has operated as a fuels refinery since 1936
• The site has been owned and operated by Atlantic (1920s), ARCO (1938),
BP (1969), FINA (1973) and TOTAL (1999)
• Major processing units include an FCC, Reformer, and Delayed Coker
• Most products are shipped east of the Rockies via pipeline
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
4. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
What I will cover
• Program Background
• Selling the Program
• Project Staffing
• Handling Scope Discovery Items &
Discrepancies
• Current Program Status
More detail is available in the
Hydrocarbon Processing article (“DCS
Migration: Lessons learned”, Jan 2015,
pp. 75-80.
For other control migration issues, I
recommend…
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
5. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Control System Migrations
• Published in 2013 – Daniel Roessler
– Project Justification/FEL (Front End
Loading)
– Bid Specification/ Vendor Selection
– Scope, Schedule, Budget
– Project Staffing/Training
– Progress Monitoring/ Change Orders
– High-Risk Areas/Cutovers
– Project Closeout/Lifecycle
Management
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
6. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Program Background
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
7. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Where We Were
• Our DCS (Distributed Control System) migration program began in 2005
• Existing Honeywell TDC-2000 DCS systems were at/ over capacity
• 80% TDC-2000, 20% TDC-3000
• 8 Data Hiways, 2 LCNs (Local Control Networks), 18,000 I/O
(Inputs/Outputs)
• Manufacturer announced a 2016 TDC-2000 end of support
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
18,000
20,000
1982
1983
1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
Year Installed
Points
TDC-3000
TDC-2000
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
8. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Program Plan
• Eight project steps were planned – one per Data Hiway
– Modernizing by Hiway allowed us to apply lessons-learned to future
steps
– Program steps were ordered according to system capacity, equipment
age and maintenance history
– Schedule was to begin a new step every 12 months to distribute capital
commitments and comply with Honeywell’s 2016 end-of-support date
– Each step took 18-24 months to complete, resulting in overlap
• Hot cutover (HCO) at Junction Box was our chosen approach
Month
Issue RFP, Select Contractor
Front End Loading
Project Kick-Off
Field Engineering
DCS Engineering
Factory Acceptance Test
Site Acceptance Test
Hot Cutover
Construction
Demolition
2421 22 2319 201 2 3 4 131211109 185 6 7 8 17161514
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
9. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Hot Cutover (HCO)
• Pros
– Minimize risk of upset (one loop at a time)
– Easier operator transition to new system
– No critical path or start-up issues for
turnaround
– Schedule is decoupled from turnaround
• Cons
– Requires footprint and electrical power
sufficient to handle both systems
– If required, RIE (Remote Inst Encl) adds $1M
– HCO somewhat complicates field-input
wiring
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
10. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Developing the Scope
• Used industry contacts to get recommendations for MAC (Main
Automation Contractors)
• Narrowed list of 12 recommended MACs to 5
• Awarded an FEL (Front End Loading) study (±10%) to three MACs
• Used FEL results to prepare the capital request for the first step
• Presented factored total program estimate in first-step management
review
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
11. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Selling the Program
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
12. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Our Audience
• Senior management (Houston/ Paris)
• Information needs are different than for a technical presentation
– Stakes are higher - $77M multiyear program
– Avoid unnecessary acronyms – use terms familiar to the audience
– Use common language – money (you need it, they control it)
– Anticipate questions, be prepared with answers – but don’t volunteer
info
– Speaking to persuade as well as inform
– Make no unsubstantiated claims
• Practice, practice, practice
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
13. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
PAR Uses the Dossier
• Dossier vetted by local management, delivered to senior management a
week in advance for review by their technical staff
• Pre-sell (answer corporate staff’s questions before formal review, if
possible)
• In-person or videoconference formal management presentation
• Executive Summary
– Two or three slides - summarize the dossier (some managers may not
read past the Executive Summary)
– Include scope, justification, project schedule
– Solid wrap-up/ conclusions
– Specific ±10% funding request
• Dossier Body:
– 7-12 slides
– Benefits (not features) – explain assumptionsPresented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
14. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Dossier
• Body (continued):
– Provide functional scope description (fit-for-purpose, not state-of-the-
art)
– Emphasize project results, not details
– Include a major milestone schedule
– Acknowledge lifecycle costs - framed in a positive manner
– Include resource demands as well as costs
– Focus on justifying the project
• Appendix – place supporting detail here –
use only to address questions
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
15. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Project Staffing
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
16. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Operations - key role in project
success
• Have a Console Operator (CO) assigned
early-on
– CO will sell other operators on project
• Determine cable-tray routing, RIE location
• Approve graphics updates
• Help develop operator training
• Develop hot cutover order/risk analysis
• Maintain operations punch-list
• Participate in FAT (factory acceptance
test), SAT (site acceptance test)
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
17. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Hot Cutover (HCO) team
• Two outside teams, each having
– Systems hardware specialist
– One TOTAL & two contract instrument technicians
– Shared outside operator
• Construction coordinator – directs both outside
teams
• Inside team (Central Control Room)
– DCS systems manager–directs inside activities
– Extra console operator
– Two contract configuration specialists
– Two MAC engineers
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
18. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
HCO Execution
• With daily HCO contractor cost approaching
$10,000 - important to be efficient
• Decide on cutover order
– Back to front of unit
– Simple to complex loops
– If HMI upgrade is part of the step, attempt to cut over all points on a
graphic before moving to next one
– If issue arises, skip that loop and come back
• Supply lunch for efficiency
• Schedule: Four-10 hour days, target 35 points/day cutover. Reserve
Fridays for rain-out and to address issues identified earlier in the week
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
19. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Handling Scope Discovery Items & Discrepancies
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
20. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Scope Discovery Items (Lessons Learned)
• First phase generated 170+ items not identified in the FEL
– Some are hardware-based
– Some are to meet PAR Engineering Standards
– Some to meet preferences/ best practices/ improve efficiency
• Supplied this list to MAC, FEL contractors for future steps
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
21. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Discrepancies found during HCO
• Develop an explicit plan and system to handle these before the HCO
• Don’t allow these discrepancies to slow down the HCO
– Log all discrepancies (loop sheet errors, range changes, questionable
configurations, graphic errors)
– A separate group addresses high priority issues immediately using
expedited MOC (Management of Change) process
– Hand-off other issues to process support engineer for later follow-up
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
22. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Current Program Status
• We have completed 4 of 9 steps, on schedule and within budget
• Fifth step approved April 2014
• With the TDC-2000 support extension to 2025, beginning in 2012,
we lengthened our program schedule by planning a new step every
18 months
• This extended schedule will complete our TDC-2000 conversion by
2025
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
23. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Recommendations
• Read the book “CONTROL SYSTEM MIGRATIONS”
• Choose your MAC and MAC Project Manager carefully – rely on
customer recommendations
• Develop detailed, comprehensive RFPs (Request for Proposals) for FEL
development and Detailed Design/Engineering/Commissioning.
Comprehensive RFPs will pay for themselves in reduced change orders
• Consider using a configuration/graphics specialty contractor - with their
own licensed DCS hardware and software – get maximum benefit from
new technology
• Maximize your local staff’s involvement for long-term success
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org
24. DCS MIGRATION:LESSONS LEARNED
Thank You
Presented at the 2015 Process Control and Safety Symposium
Houston, Texas, USA, 9-12 November 2015
Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved. www.isa.org