CYBER HARASSMENT


                          Bennet Kelley ‘89
     Georgetown University Law Center Reunion Weekend
Cyber
Harassment by
the Numbers
PERPETRATOR
  VICTIMS                 63.3% men
                        (where known)               DURATION
  72.5% women                                      Avg. – 2 Years
                       Half have no prior
44% 18-30 yrs old   relationship with victim
                      71% - no offline threats




                                            Source: HaltAbuse.org
Forms of Harassment

 Abusive Emails/IMs             Chat Room and Blog
                                  Posts
 Computer Attacks –
                                   Cyber smears (e.g.,
    viruses, hacking                Skanks in NYC)
   Crowding Out Benign            Disclosure of Private Facts
    Content                         (or photos)
   Cyber squatting or use of      Use/misuse of victim’s
                                    content
    identity
   Cyber Bullying
   Identity Theft
Remedies
             • Trespass
             • Fraud
Common       • Defamation
             • Invasion of Privacy/Infliction of Emotional Distress
  Law

             • Trademark/Copyright
  General    • Wire Fraud, RICO
 Statutory
 Authority

             • Anti-Cybersquatting Protection Act
             • Computer Fraud & Abuse Act
 Internet    • Identity Theft Enforcement and Restitution Act
  Crimes

             • Federal Laws Limited in Scope
             • State Cyber-Stalking and Cyber-Harassment Laws
Harassment
   Laws
Selected Federal Criminal Laws
  18 USC § 875 – prohibits       Violence Against Women
   threats to “injure the          Act Amendments (18 USC
   person” or “injure the          § 2261A) - prohibits acts
   property or reputation”         or course of conduct “with
     No private action            the intent to kill, injure,
                                   harass,” that causes
                                   “substantial emotional
  47 U.S.C. § 223 – prohibits     distress” or reasonable fear
   anonymous use of email to       of death or “serious bodily
   “annoy, abuse, harass, or       injury” to victim, family,
   threaten” (does not apply       spouse or intimate partner.
   to chat board posting)           Increased penalties for
     No private action              violating restraining order
                                    Only applies to interstate
                                     conduct
State Cyber Harassment Laws




Source: Congressional Research Service
State Cyber Stalking Laws




Source: Congressional Research Service
US v. Lori Drew
Or How a Missouri Mom Got a Trip to Disneyland
Misdemeanor Conviction Reversed
Misdemeanor Conviction Reversed
Civil v. Criminal Sanctions

 Criminal Law generally for acts offensive to
  society as a whole
   Remedy – Fine and Imprisonment
 Civil Law for remedying wrongs between
  individuals
   Remedy - Damages
 What happens when individuals cannot afford
  litigation?
  
Coach Thompson’s Garage
                                           GRRR




  IS IT SPEECH?                 IS IT A CRIME?

  IS PROPERTY DAMAGED?
  IS IT OFFENSIVE TO SOCIETY AS A WHOLE?
Coach Thompson’s Computer Screen
                                          ii sum valde
                                           iratus iam




 IS IT SPEECH?                IS IT A CRIME?

 IS PROPERTY DAMAGED?
 IS IT OFFENSIVE TO SOCIETY AS A WHOLE?
Criminal Defamation Laws




Source: First Amendment Center, Media Law Resource Center
Forgotten but not Gone




Source: Media Law Resource Center
First Amendment Issues




Source: Media Law Resource Center
Tips/Resources

 “Googling” Yourself    Use Social
   Contact Info          Networking Privacy
                          Tools
 Segregate Email
  Addresses              IC3.gov
 Key Word Alerts        HaltAbuse.org
 Trademark or Domain
  Monitor Services
Bennet Kelley
                                Bennet Kelley founded the Internet Law Center in 2007 after a
                                decade of activity in many of the hottest internet issues including
                                behavioral targeting, cyber squatting, net neutrality, privacy, spam
                                and spyware. Prior to launching the Internet Law Center, Bennet
                                worked in-house with companies such as ETM Entertainment
                                Network, SpeedyClick.com, Hi-Speed Media and ValueClick.

                                Bennet is Co-Chair of the California Bar's Cyberspace Committee
                                and has played a leading role in shaping Internet law and policy.
                                Bennet testified before the California Senate Business &
                                Professions Committee on its landmark 2003 spam legislation and
                                was praised by the House Energy & Commerce Committee for his
bkelley@internetlawcenter.net   contributions to federal spyware legislation. He also launched an
                                initiative through the Cyberspace Committee to develop a
                                cyberspace primer for incoming state legislators.

                                In addition, Bennet has extensive political experience that includes
                                serving as National Co-Chair of the Democratic National
                                Committee's Saxophone Club (its young professional fundraising
                                and outreach arm) during the Clinton era and being an award
                                winning political columnist for Huffington Post.
The Internet Law Center is dedicated to helping
                                         businesses navigate the evolving legal standards for
                                         today’s digital economy, while also contributing to the
                                         development of the policies of tomorrow. The firm
                                         serves a diverse client base that includes startups and
 WE KNOW THE INTERNET                    public companies both online and offline across North
                                         America and Asia.

Internet Law Center                      The professionals of the Internet Law Center possess
100 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 950            years of practical experience as lawyers and
Santa Monica, CA 90401
www.internetlawcenter.net                entrepreneurs with internet companies and have played
                                         a leading role in shaping Internet law and policy. This
Santa Monica Washington South Carolina
                                         unprecedented combination of business, legal and
                                         policy experience makes the Internet Law Center
                                         uniquely qualified to provide the professional advice
                                         needed to address emerging issues of internet law in
                                         an uncertain economy.

                                         Sign up for Cyber Report – our award winning newsletter
                                         which was named one of the Top 100 Internet Law
                                         Resources and re-launches this fall.

Cyber Harassment

  • 1.
    CYBER HARASSMENT Bennet Kelley ‘89 Georgetown University Law Center Reunion Weekend
  • 2.
  • 3.
    PERPETRATOR VICTIMS 63.3% men (where known) DURATION 72.5% women Avg. – 2 Years Half have no prior 44% 18-30 yrs old relationship with victim 71% - no offline threats Source: HaltAbuse.org
  • 4.
    Forms of Harassment Abusive Emails/IMs  Chat Room and Blog Posts  Computer Attacks –  Cyber smears (e.g., viruses, hacking Skanks in NYC)  Crowding Out Benign  Disclosure of Private Facts Content (or photos)  Cyber squatting or use of  Use/misuse of victim’s content identity  Cyber Bullying  Identity Theft
  • 6.
    Remedies • Trespass • Fraud Common • Defamation • Invasion of Privacy/Infliction of Emotional Distress Law • Trademark/Copyright General • Wire Fraud, RICO Statutory Authority • Anti-Cybersquatting Protection Act • Computer Fraud & Abuse Act Internet • Identity Theft Enforcement and Restitution Act Crimes • Federal Laws Limited in Scope • State Cyber-Stalking and Cyber-Harassment Laws Harassment Laws
  • 7.
    Selected Federal CriminalLaws  18 USC § 875 – prohibits  Violence Against Women threats to “injure the Act Amendments (18 USC person” or “injure the § 2261A) - prohibits acts property or reputation” or course of conduct “with  No private action the intent to kill, injure, harass,” that causes “substantial emotional  47 U.S.C. § 223 – prohibits distress” or reasonable fear anonymous use of email to of death or “serious bodily “annoy, abuse, harass, or injury” to victim, family, threaten” (does not apply spouse or intimate partner. to chat board posting)  Increased penalties for  No private action violating restraining order  Only applies to interstate conduct
  • 8.
    State Cyber HarassmentLaws Source: Congressional Research Service
  • 9.
    State Cyber StalkingLaws Source: Congressional Research Service
  • 10.
    US v. LoriDrew Or How a Missouri Mom Got a Trip to Disneyland
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
    Civil v. CriminalSanctions  Criminal Law generally for acts offensive to society as a whole  Remedy – Fine and Imprisonment  Civil Law for remedying wrongs between individuals  Remedy - Damages  What happens when individuals cannot afford litigation? 
  • 14.
    Coach Thompson’s Garage GRRR IS IT SPEECH? IS IT A CRIME? IS PROPERTY DAMAGED? IS IT OFFENSIVE TO SOCIETY AS A WHOLE?
  • 15.
    Coach Thompson’s ComputerScreen ii sum valde iratus iam IS IT SPEECH? IS IT A CRIME? IS PROPERTY DAMAGED? IS IT OFFENSIVE TO SOCIETY AS A WHOLE?
  • 16.
    Criminal Defamation Laws Source:First Amendment Center, Media Law Resource Center
  • 17.
    Forgotten but notGone Source: Media Law Resource Center
  • 18.
    First Amendment Issues Source:Media Law Resource Center
  • 19.
    Tips/Resources  “Googling” Yourself  Use Social  Contact Info Networking Privacy Tools  Segregate Email Addresses  IC3.gov  Key Word Alerts  HaltAbuse.org  Trademark or Domain Monitor Services
  • 20.
    Bennet Kelley Bennet Kelley founded the Internet Law Center in 2007 after a decade of activity in many of the hottest internet issues including behavioral targeting, cyber squatting, net neutrality, privacy, spam and spyware. Prior to launching the Internet Law Center, Bennet worked in-house with companies such as ETM Entertainment Network, SpeedyClick.com, Hi-Speed Media and ValueClick. Bennet is Co-Chair of the California Bar's Cyberspace Committee and has played a leading role in shaping Internet law and policy. Bennet testified before the California Senate Business & Professions Committee on its landmark 2003 spam legislation and was praised by the House Energy & Commerce Committee for his bkelley@internetlawcenter.net contributions to federal spyware legislation. He also launched an initiative through the Cyberspace Committee to develop a cyberspace primer for incoming state legislators. In addition, Bennet has extensive political experience that includes serving as National Co-Chair of the Democratic National Committee's Saxophone Club (its young professional fundraising and outreach arm) during the Clinton era and being an award winning political columnist for Huffington Post.
  • 21.
    The Internet LawCenter is dedicated to helping businesses navigate the evolving legal standards for today’s digital economy, while also contributing to the development of the policies of tomorrow. The firm serves a diverse client base that includes startups and WE KNOW THE INTERNET public companies both online and offline across North America and Asia. Internet Law Center The professionals of the Internet Law Center possess 100 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 950 years of practical experience as lawyers and Santa Monica, CA 90401 www.internetlawcenter.net entrepreneurs with internet companies and have played a leading role in shaping Internet law and policy. This Santa Monica Washington South Carolina unprecedented combination of business, legal and policy experience makes the Internet Law Center uniquely qualified to provide the professional advice needed to address emerging issues of internet law in an uncertain economy. Sign up for Cyber Report – our award winning newsletter which was named one of the Top 100 Internet Law Resources and re-launches this fall.