Crossroads
Transforming Health Care Delivery with
  Informatics: A perspective from the
Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH)
       Henry C. Chueh, MD, MS
Coming up...

Introduce the problem
Suggest a theme to solutions to the problem
Provide a brief description of MGH
Describe our path through stories about tools
Revisit the theme
One Day in the Life of a PCP
            Hours needed to manage 2,500 patients...



                                 6.0


                                                                10.6


                                     7.4


        Chronic disease (10 Dx)                               Prevention                     Free
 Yarnall KS, et al. Primary care: is there enough time for prevention? Am J Public Health 2003; 93:635
            Ostbye T, et al. Is there time for management of patients with chronic diseases
                                in primary care? Ann Fam Med 2005; 3:209
“Computerized clinical information systems
 will help physicians close this quality gap
   by performing many of the repetitive,
 protocol-driven tasks.” (McDonald, conveyed by the
                "the burden of harm 1976)
                   collective impact of all of our health
                          care quality problems is
“The current care staggering" (Chassen et al., 1998)
                     systems cannot do the
job...trying harder will not work...changing
       care systems will.” (IOM, 2001)
             "Our recovery plan will invest in electronic
           health records and new technology that will
             reduce errors, bring down costs, ensure
           privacy, and save lives." (Obama, Feb 2009)
supply
Lack of time   Flawed process




demand
CDSS
MGH Primary Care
                                                                        (at MGH)
                                                                           IMA
                                                                          WHA
                                  Everett                Revere (2)       BMG
            MGH West
                                                                           MWI
                                  Charlestown
                                                Chelsea (2)
                                                                       (near MGH)
                                                                        Downtown
                                                                       Beacon Hill
                                                                         MGMG
                                                                      Senior Health
                                                                        Back Bay
                                                                         NECHC



MDs = 178   •    FTEs = 101   •   Practices = 15        •     Patients = 155,590
IT infrastructure at MGH

 Online registration and scheduling
 Outpatient electronic health records and e-prescribing
 Clinical data repository for results and reports
 Inpatient provider order entry
 Patient portal
Information “push”
Decision support in diabetes
                                               Visit
      (A1C, SBP, LDL)
                                                            patient
              1         info
                                          primary care provider




                                     nd
                                  me
                                  om
                               rec



       2    info
                                 nurse care manager

                   Modest improvements in process outcomes only
Patients don’t always come in for clinic visits.

Clinic visits are busy.

Providers are good at deciding, but bad at doing.
Getting there from here


 Loyalty cohort: Connectedness
 FastTrack: Enhanced CDSS/SSCD outside visits
 ACCORD: Involving patients
Who are my patients?


Visit to registered PCP
Repeated visits to a specific practice
Age and home address as variables
Connection Status
  PCP connected         Practice connected     Not connected



                          6%


                  34%

                                    59%


                                             n = 155,590
MGH Preventive Metrics
                                  PCP Linked          Practice Linked


                  85
                              P<0.0001         P<0.0001            P<0.0001


                  68
 Percentage (%)




                  51


                  34


                  17


                   0
                       Mammography       Pap Test           CRC Screening
                       (n=35,865)        (n=65,860)         (n=37,605)
MGH Disease Metrics

                                PCP Linked         Practice Linked

                  90
                              P<0.0001          P<0.0001         P<0.0001

                  72
 Percentage (%)




                  54

                  36

                  18

                   0
                       Diabetes A1C      Diabetes LDL      CAD LDL
                       (n=9,632)         (n=9,632)         (n=6,612)
A patient-tailored information letter

A hard copy Rx, to be signed

Automatic electronic documentation

A 6-week reminder timer
Results
Breast cancer screening
     PCP/screened        Practice/screened
     Practice/overdue    PCP/overdue


                11%

           9%


          15%

                        64%
Mammography FastTrack
Decision support in breast
   cancer prevention
             population info
  patients                           primary care physician

                                         Outside the Visit



                action
                               care delegate
Mammography FastTrack:
6-month results
                                            Intervention        Control
                      30.0
                                                     P = 0.01
Completion rate (%)




                                P = 0.01
                      22.5
                                                                      P = 0.02

                      15.0


                       7.5


                        0
                             All Patients          MD-Linked       Practice-Linked
A Fragile Loop

                        Awareness of Issue


                                     Risk assessment

      Follow-up


                        ?
                                        Plan for care


        Complete care
Follow-up

1/3 have no system, <1/3 satisfied with system
Patients want communication
Lack of documentation
Lack of patient understanding
ACCORD
Ambulatory Care Compact to Organize Risk and Decision-making
ACCORD characteristics

Patient-Provider preferences
Explicit agreement with documentation
Fail-safe monitoring
High visibility
CDSS
SSCD
challenges. tools.
    Continuous, not visit-based


                          Population-based




Patient-provider preferences

CrossRoads

  • 1.
    Crossroads Transforming Health CareDelivery with Informatics: A perspective from the Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) Henry C. Chueh, MD, MS
  • 2.
    Coming up... Introduce theproblem Suggest a theme to solutions to the problem Provide a brief description of MGH Describe our path through stories about tools Revisit the theme
  • 3.
    One Day inthe Life of a PCP Hours needed to manage 2,500 patients... 6.0 10.6 7.4 Chronic disease (10 Dx) Prevention Free Yarnall KS, et al. Primary care: is there enough time for prevention? Am J Public Health 2003; 93:635 Ostbye T, et al. Is there time for management of patients with chronic diseases in primary care? Ann Fam Med 2005; 3:209
  • 4.
    “Computerized clinical informationsystems will help physicians close this quality gap by performing many of the repetitive, protocol-driven tasks.” (McDonald, conveyed by the "the burden of harm 1976) collective impact of all of our health care quality problems is “The current care staggering" (Chassen et al., 1998) systems cannot do the job...trying harder will not work...changing care systems will.” (IOM, 2001) "Our recovery plan will invest in electronic health records and new technology that will reduce errors, bring down costs, ensure privacy, and save lives." (Obama, Feb 2009)
  • 6.
    supply Lack of time Flawed process demand
  • 8.
  • 10.
    MGH Primary Care (at MGH) IMA WHA Everett Revere (2) BMG MGH West MWI Charlestown Chelsea (2) (near MGH) Downtown Beacon Hill MGMG Senior Health Back Bay NECHC MDs = 178 • FTEs = 101 • Practices = 15 • Patients = 155,590
  • 11.
    IT infrastructure atMGH Online registration and scheduling Outpatient electronic health records and e-prescribing Clinical data repository for results and reports Inpatient provider order entry Patient portal
  • 13.
    Information “push” Decision supportin diabetes Visit (A1C, SBP, LDL) patient 1 info primary care provider nd me om rec 2 info nurse care manager Modest improvements in process outcomes only
  • 14.
    Patients don’t alwayscome in for clinic visits. Clinic visits are busy. Providers are good at deciding, but bad at doing.
  • 15.
    Getting there fromhere Loyalty cohort: Connectedness FastTrack: Enhanced CDSS/SSCD outside visits ACCORD: Involving patients
  • 16.
    Who are mypatients? Visit to registered PCP Repeated visits to a specific practice Age and home address as variables
  • 17.
    Connection Status PCP connected Practice connected Not connected 6% 34% 59% n = 155,590
  • 18.
    MGH Preventive Metrics PCP Linked Practice Linked 85 P<0.0001 P<0.0001 P<0.0001 68 Percentage (%) 51 34 17 0 Mammography Pap Test CRC Screening (n=35,865) (n=65,860) (n=37,605)
  • 19.
    MGH Disease Metrics PCP Linked Practice Linked 90 P<0.0001 P<0.0001 P<0.0001 72 Percentage (%) 54 36 18 0 Diabetes A1C Diabetes LDL CAD LDL (n=9,632) (n=9,632) (n=6,612)
  • 21.
    A patient-tailored informationletter A hard copy Rx, to be signed Automatic electronic documentation A 6-week reminder timer
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Breast cancer screening PCP/screened Practice/screened Practice/overdue PCP/overdue 11% 9% 15% 64%
  • 24.
    Mammography FastTrack Decision supportin breast cancer prevention population info patients primary care physician Outside the Visit action care delegate
  • 25.
    Mammography FastTrack: 6-month results Intervention Control 30.0 P = 0.01 Completion rate (%) P = 0.01 22.5 P = 0.02 15.0 7.5 0 All Patients MD-Linked Practice-Linked
  • 27.
    A Fragile Loop Awareness of Issue Risk assessment Follow-up ? Plan for care Complete care
  • 28.
    Follow-up 1/3 have nosystem, <1/3 satisfied with system Patients want communication Lack of documentation Lack of patient understanding
  • 29.
    ACCORD Ambulatory Care Compactto Organize Risk and Decision-making
  • 33.
    ACCORD characteristics Patient-Provider preferences Explicitagreement with documentation Fail-safe monitoring High visibility
  • 34.
  • 35.
    challenges. tools. Continuous, not visit-based Population-based Patient-provider preferences