CRITICAL
THINKING
T O O L S F O R T A K I N G C H A R G E O F
y 0 l l R L E A R N I N G A N D Y O U R L I F E
T H I R D e d i t i o n
Richard Paul
Foundation for Critical Thinking
Linda Elder
Foundat ion for Critical Thinking
PEARSON
Boston Columbus Indianapolis New York San Francisco Upper Saddle River
Amsterdam Cape Town Dubai London Madrid Milan Munich Paris Montreal Toronto
Delhi Mexico City Sao Paulo Sydney H o n g Kong Seoul Singapore Taipei T o k y o
C H A P T E H 2
EXHIBIT 2.1 Most people have lived their entire lives as unreflective thinkers.
To develop as thinkers requires commitment to daily practice.
S T A G E S OF C R I T I C A L T H I N K I N G D E V E L O P M E N T
/
Accomplished Thinker
(Intellectual skills
and virtues have
become second
nature in our lives)
/
Advanced Thinker
( W e are committed to lifelong
practice and are beginning to
internalize intellectual virtues)
/
Practicing Thinker
( W e regularly practice a n d
advance accordingly)
/
Beginning Thinker
(We try to improve but
without regular practice)
/
Challenged Thinker
(We are faced with significant
problems in our thinking)
Unreflective Thinker
( W e are unaware of significant
problems in our thinking)
If we aspire to develop as thinkers, the stages all of us go through are:
Stage 1 T h e Unreflective Thinker (we are unaware of significant problems in
o u r thinking)
Stage 2 T h e Challenged Thinker (we become aware of problems in our
thinking)
Stage 3 T h e Beginning Thinker (we try t o improve but w i t h o u t regular
practice)
Stage 4 T h e Practicing Thinker (we recognize the necessity of regular practice)
Stage 5 T h e Advanced Thinker (we advance in accordance with o u r practice)
Stage 6 T h e Accomplished Thinker (skilled and insightful thinking become
second nature to us)
STAGE 1: THE UNREFLECTIVE THINKER
Are you an unreflective thinker? We all are born—and most of us die—as largely
unreflective thinkers, fundamentally unaware of the role that thinking is playing in
o u r lives. At this Unreflective Thinker stage, we have n o useful conception of what
t h i n k i n g entails. For example, as unreflective thinkers, we don't notice that we
are continually m a k i n g assumptions, f o r m i n g concepts, drawing inferences, and
t h i n k i n g within points of view. At this stage, we don't know how to analyze and
assess o u r thinking. We don't know how to determine whether o u r p u r p o s e s are
clearly formulated, o u r assumptions justified, our conclusions logically drawn. We
are unaware of intellectual traits and so are not striving to e m b o d y them.
At this stage, many problems in our lives are caused by p o o r thinking, but
we are unaware of this. We don't question o u r beliefs or our decisions. We lack
intellectual standards a n d have no idea what such standards m i g h t be. We lack the
intellectual traits but are not aware that we lack t.
CRITICAL THINKING T O O L S FOR T A K I N G C H A R G E .docxfaithxdunce63732
CRITICAL
THINKING
T O O L S FOR T A K I N G C H A R G E OF
y 0 l l R L E A R N I N G AND Y O U R L IFE
T H I R D e d i t i o n
Richard Paul
Foundation for Critical Thinking
Linda Elder
Foundat ion for Critical Thinking
PEARSON
Boston Columbus Indianapolis New York San Francisco Upper Saddle River
Amsterdam Cape Town Dubai London Madrid Milan Munich Paris Montreal Toronto
Delhi Mexico City Sao Paulo Sydney Hong Kong Seoul Singapore Taipei Tokyo
C H A P T E H 2
EXHIBIT 2.1 Most people have lived their entire lives as unreflective thinkers.
To develop as thinkers requires commitment to daily practice.
STAGES OF CRITICAL THINKING DEVELOPMENT
/
Accomplished Thinker
(Intellectual skills
and virtues have
become second
nature in our lives)
/
Advanced Thinker
(We are committed to lifelong
practice and are beginning to
internalize intellectual virtues)
/
Practicing Thinker
(We regularly practice and
advance accordingly)
/
Beginning Thinker
(We try to improve but
without regular practice)
/
Challenged Thinker
(We are faced with significant
problems in our thinking)
Unreflective Thinker
(We are unaware of significant
problems in our thinking)
If we aspire to develop as thinkers, the stages all of us go through are:
Stage 1 The Unreflective Thinker (we are unaware of significant problems in
our thinking)
Stage 2 The Challenged Thinker (we become aware of problems in our
thinking)
Stage 3 The Beginning Thinker (we try to improve but without regular
practice)
Stage 4 The Practicing Thinker (we recognize the necessity of regular practice)
Stage 5 The Advanced Thinker (we advance in accordance with our practice)
Stage 6 The Accomplished Thinker (skilled and insightful thinking become
second nature to us)
STAGE 1: THE UNREFLECTIVE THINKER
Are you an unreflective thinker? We all are born—and most of us die—as largely
unreflective thinkers, fundamentally unaware of the role that thinking is playing in
our lives. At this Unreflective Thinker stage, we have no useful conception of what
thinking entails. For example, as unreflective thinkers, we don't notice that we
are continually making assumptions, forming concepts, drawing inferences, and
thinking within points of view. At this stage, we don't know how to analyze and
assess our thinking. We don't know how to determine whether our purposes are
clearly formulated, our assumptions justified, our conclusions logically drawn. We
are unaware of intellectual traits and so are not striving to embody them.
At this stage, many problems in our lives are caused by poor thinking, but
we are unaware of this. We don't question our beliefs or our decisions. We lack
intellectual standards and have no idea what such standards might be. We lack the
intellectual traits but are not aware that we lack them. We unconsciously deceive
ourselves in many ways. We create and maintain pleasant illusions. Because our
beliefs seem reasona.
The Importance of Aggressive Perceptions to Success in Life and BusinessSKYLINEEFC
The document discusses how perceptions can cultivate success habits. It provides a list of perceptions that individuals should develop, including perceiving core values, a positive attitude, willingness to learn, loyalty, integrity, professionalism, listening skills, reliability, sensitivity, adaptability, flexibility, patience, purpose, self-starting attitude, interpersonal sensitivity, and self-confidence. Developing these perceptions through one's thinking and understanding can initiate productive choices and lead to personal and professional success.
EFC - The Importance of Aggressive Perceptions to Success in Life and BusinessSKYLINEEFC
The document discusses how perceptions can cultivate success habits. It provides examples of positive perceptions to develop, such as having a positive attitude, willingness to learn, loyalty, integrity, and time management skills. The document encourages selecting a few perceptions to focus on developing over the next few weeks by writing out plans to implement them in order to see an increase in effectiveness.
This document provides information about using code words as part of positive change hypnosis. It explains that code words act as a shortcut to recall motivations, goals, and behaviors when trying to make meaningful changes. The technique involves writing a statement linking a code word to concepts and ideas related to one's goals, and then using self-hypnosis or relaxation to program the subconscious mind to associate the code word with the full statement. Saying the code word daily helps maintain focus on commitments and reinforce positive change. An example code word statement for weight loss is also provided.
MIND IS LIKE A RESTLESS MONKEY WHICH WANDERS WITHOUT BEING STABLE AND AS STRONG AS AN INTOXICATED ELEPHANT.
- esay way to control mind and attain EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE
Self learning module on Positive thinkingliteonmobile
This document provides tips for developing a positive attitude and practicing positive thinking. It discusses how negative self-talk can be overcome by recognizing it and replacing negative thoughts with positive spins. Some ways to learn positive thinking mentioned are periodically evaluating thoughts for negativity and finding ways to put a positive spin on them. The document also lists 8 ways to create a positive attitude, such as remembering one's own power, embracing life, controlling reactions, and believing one is enough. Practicing positive thinking can benefit one's health, according to research.
This document provides tips for developing a positive attitude and practicing positive thinking. It discusses how negative self-talk can be overcome by recognizing it and replacing those thoughts with more rational, positive perspectives. Specific strategies mentioned include focusing on the positive aspects of a situation, challenging negative thoughts with logic, evaluating thoughts for positivity, and reminding yourself of past successes. Maintaining an optimistic outlook can provide mental and physical health benefits according to research.
Seven habits of highly effective peoples - Gerhardtgenesissathish
The document provides an overview of leadership qualities and strategies for career success based on Stephen Covey's Seven Habits of Highly Effective People. It discusses the importance of understanding the big picture, empowering and developing people, and adapting to different situations. It also covers personal leadership through strategic planning, mentors, and continuous self-improvement. Teamwork, culture, and the four levels of leadership are examined. Finally, the seven habits are summarized with a focus on being proactive, beginning with the end in mind, and putting first things first.
CRITICAL THINKING T O O L S FOR T A K I N G C H A R G E .docxfaithxdunce63732
CRITICAL
THINKING
T O O L S FOR T A K I N G C H A R G E OF
y 0 l l R L E A R N I N G AND Y O U R L IFE
T H I R D e d i t i o n
Richard Paul
Foundation for Critical Thinking
Linda Elder
Foundat ion for Critical Thinking
PEARSON
Boston Columbus Indianapolis New York San Francisco Upper Saddle River
Amsterdam Cape Town Dubai London Madrid Milan Munich Paris Montreal Toronto
Delhi Mexico City Sao Paulo Sydney Hong Kong Seoul Singapore Taipei Tokyo
C H A P T E H 2
EXHIBIT 2.1 Most people have lived their entire lives as unreflective thinkers.
To develop as thinkers requires commitment to daily practice.
STAGES OF CRITICAL THINKING DEVELOPMENT
/
Accomplished Thinker
(Intellectual skills
and virtues have
become second
nature in our lives)
/
Advanced Thinker
(We are committed to lifelong
practice and are beginning to
internalize intellectual virtues)
/
Practicing Thinker
(We regularly practice and
advance accordingly)
/
Beginning Thinker
(We try to improve but
without regular practice)
/
Challenged Thinker
(We are faced with significant
problems in our thinking)
Unreflective Thinker
(We are unaware of significant
problems in our thinking)
If we aspire to develop as thinkers, the stages all of us go through are:
Stage 1 The Unreflective Thinker (we are unaware of significant problems in
our thinking)
Stage 2 The Challenged Thinker (we become aware of problems in our
thinking)
Stage 3 The Beginning Thinker (we try to improve but without regular
practice)
Stage 4 The Practicing Thinker (we recognize the necessity of regular practice)
Stage 5 The Advanced Thinker (we advance in accordance with our practice)
Stage 6 The Accomplished Thinker (skilled and insightful thinking become
second nature to us)
STAGE 1: THE UNREFLECTIVE THINKER
Are you an unreflective thinker? We all are born—and most of us die—as largely
unreflective thinkers, fundamentally unaware of the role that thinking is playing in
our lives. At this Unreflective Thinker stage, we have no useful conception of what
thinking entails. For example, as unreflective thinkers, we don't notice that we
are continually making assumptions, forming concepts, drawing inferences, and
thinking within points of view. At this stage, we don't know how to analyze and
assess our thinking. We don't know how to determine whether our purposes are
clearly formulated, our assumptions justified, our conclusions logically drawn. We
are unaware of intellectual traits and so are not striving to embody them.
At this stage, many problems in our lives are caused by poor thinking, but
we are unaware of this. We don't question our beliefs or our decisions. We lack
intellectual standards and have no idea what such standards might be. We lack the
intellectual traits but are not aware that we lack them. We unconsciously deceive
ourselves in many ways. We create and maintain pleasant illusions. Because our
beliefs seem reasona.
The Importance of Aggressive Perceptions to Success in Life and BusinessSKYLINEEFC
The document discusses how perceptions can cultivate success habits. It provides a list of perceptions that individuals should develop, including perceiving core values, a positive attitude, willingness to learn, loyalty, integrity, professionalism, listening skills, reliability, sensitivity, adaptability, flexibility, patience, purpose, self-starting attitude, interpersonal sensitivity, and self-confidence. Developing these perceptions through one's thinking and understanding can initiate productive choices and lead to personal and professional success.
EFC - The Importance of Aggressive Perceptions to Success in Life and BusinessSKYLINEEFC
The document discusses how perceptions can cultivate success habits. It provides examples of positive perceptions to develop, such as having a positive attitude, willingness to learn, loyalty, integrity, and time management skills. The document encourages selecting a few perceptions to focus on developing over the next few weeks by writing out plans to implement them in order to see an increase in effectiveness.
This document provides information about using code words as part of positive change hypnosis. It explains that code words act as a shortcut to recall motivations, goals, and behaviors when trying to make meaningful changes. The technique involves writing a statement linking a code word to concepts and ideas related to one's goals, and then using self-hypnosis or relaxation to program the subconscious mind to associate the code word with the full statement. Saying the code word daily helps maintain focus on commitments and reinforce positive change. An example code word statement for weight loss is also provided.
MIND IS LIKE A RESTLESS MONKEY WHICH WANDERS WITHOUT BEING STABLE AND AS STRONG AS AN INTOXICATED ELEPHANT.
- esay way to control mind and attain EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE
Self learning module on Positive thinkingliteonmobile
This document provides tips for developing a positive attitude and practicing positive thinking. It discusses how negative self-talk can be overcome by recognizing it and replacing negative thoughts with positive spins. Some ways to learn positive thinking mentioned are periodically evaluating thoughts for negativity and finding ways to put a positive spin on them. The document also lists 8 ways to create a positive attitude, such as remembering one's own power, embracing life, controlling reactions, and believing one is enough. Practicing positive thinking can benefit one's health, according to research.
This document provides tips for developing a positive attitude and practicing positive thinking. It discusses how negative self-talk can be overcome by recognizing it and replacing those thoughts with more rational, positive perspectives. Specific strategies mentioned include focusing on the positive aspects of a situation, challenging negative thoughts with logic, evaluating thoughts for positivity, and reminding yourself of past successes. Maintaining an optimistic outlook can provide mental and physical health benefits according to research.
Seven habits of highly effective peoples - Gerhardtgenesissathish
The document provides an overview of leadership qualities and strategies for career success based on Stephen Covey's Seven Habits of Highly Effective People. It discusses the importance of understanding the big picture, empowering and developing people, and adapting to different situations. It also covers personal leadership through strategic planning, mentors, and continuous self-improvement. Teamwork, culture, and the four levels of leadership are examined. Finally, the seven habits are summarized with a focus on being proactive, beginning with the end in mind, and putting first things first.
The document provides an overview of leadership qualities and Stephen Covey's Seven Habits of Highly Effective People. It discusses that effective leadership requires understanding the big picture, empowering and developing teams, and adapting to different situations. It also outlines the seven habits which include being proactive, beginning with the end in mind, putting first things first, thinking win-win, seeking first to understand, synergizing, and sharpening the saw.
Self-esteem refers to how people feel about themselves and their level of competence. The document discusses that self-esteem determines how people interact with others and their goals, achievements, and satisfaction in life. Healthy self-esteem is related to traits like creativity, rationality, and honesty. The document provides tips for building self-esteem such as focusing on strengths, celebrating progress, and avoiding negative self-talk. Maintaining high self-esteem leads to benefits like confidence and respect for oneself and others.
What is thinking and difference between thinking and critical thinking, Characteristics, How critical thinking can be used for problem solving and the steps included, Attitude of Critical thinkers.
LAYWi roadmap - Success and Happiness in life!LAYWi
This document provides guidance on managing one's life through self-awareness and planning. It discusses the importance of understanding oneself, establishing life priorities and direction, and creating a vision or dream for the future. The document recommends evaluating where one currently stands versus their ideal situation, identifying any gaps, and making a plan to bridge those gaps over time through achievable goals and actions. Tools are presented to help with self-evaluation, defining priorities, and creating a customized plan to work towards one's vision of success and happiness.
Self awareness is a key skill for successful leaders. Self-aware teams make better decisions, collaborate more, and manage tensions and conflicts more effectively. Gustavo Razzetti, CEO of Liberationist shares the power of self-awareness and how it increases teamwork and collaboration.
The document outlines eight secrets to life and school success: 1) taking personal responsibility, 2) self-motivation through setting meaningful goals, 3) self-management including time management, 4) interdependence by reaching out to others, 5) lifelong learning through understanding one's learning style, 6) developing emotional intelligence, 7) believing in oneself, and 8) core beliefs and replacing self-defeating scripts. It emphasizes active learning, personal responsibility, valuing goals, managing time efficiently, and developing interpersonal skills for success.
The document outlines 6 stages of critical thinking development:
1) Unreflective thinker - People at this stage do not notice their assumptions and biases in thinking.
2) Challenged thinker - People become aware of problems in their thinking and lack of self-monitoring.
3) Practicing thinker - People recognize the need to systematically improve their thinking and develop awareness of better thinking habits.
4) Advanced thinker - People have good command over biases and strive to be fair-minded, while identifying areas they can improve.
5) Accomplished thinker - People have taken charge of their thinking, regularly assessing to improve clarity and reduce biases.
6) The accomplished thinker
This document provides information about developing self-confidence. It begins with definitions of self-confidence and discusses the objectives of learning about self-confidence, which include evaluating current levels of self-confidence and exploring tools and strategies to develop it. The document then discusses characteristics of confident and unconfident people. It provides a self-confidence questionnaire, strategies for setting goals and stepping outside one's comfort zone. Assertive communication techniques are contrasted with passive and aggressive styles. The document concludes with discussing dealing with criticism and practical strategies for improving self-confidence like positive thinking and facing fears.
This document summarizes the key points from the first seven chapters of a book about breaking free from expectations and reclaiming your authentic self.
The chapters discuss identifying the expectations that may be holding you back, such as from parents, culture or your own beliefs. It explores having a "wake up call" realization that you're not living as you truly want. Making the courageous decision to change requires honesty, risk-taking and facing fears. Breaking free means stepping into uncharted territory and the unknown, which can be challenging but also liberating. Listen to your inner voice to stay grounded. Overcoming roadblocks, such as self-doubt or lack of support, requires resilience and a growth mindset
This document provides seven ways to gain self-knowledge and get to know yourself better. It discusses getting to know your personality, core values, and body. It also recommends journaling, identifying strengths and weaknesses, envisioning your life mission, and questioning automatic thoughts. The overall message is that practicing self-reflection through these various methods can help you develop a well-rounded understanding of who you are.
This document presents an ebook about developing coping skills for stress. It discusses how stress is an inevitable part of life today due to increased pressures and competition. When coping resources are inadequate, stressful events can lead to unhealthy outcomes like suicide. The ebook recommends becoming more knowledgeable about stress, understanding its effects, identifying stressors, anticipating stressful periods, and developing stress management techniques. It also discusses two models of how people think, feel and act in response to situations - reacting reflexively or responding thoughtfully. Developing skills like critical thinking, problem solving, communication, interpersonal skills, and self-regulation can help people better cope with stressful life events.
Seven Habits of Highly Effective PeopleTania Aslam
The document provides an overview of Stephen Covey's book "The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People". It discusses the book's introduction, structure, key principles and the seven habits which are: 1) Be Proactive, 2) Begin with the End in Mind, 3) Put First Things First, 4) Think Win-Win, 5) Seek First to Understand, Then to Be Understood, 6) Synergize, and 7) Sharpen the Saw. Each habit is explained in terms of its underlying principle and paradigm.
The document provides guidance on how to make positive changes in one's life and the world on Foundation Day. It recommends starting with changing one's mindset by identifying and replacing limiting beliefs. Examples of common limiting beliefs are given. The document also suggests setting goals based on one's values and creating a vision for how to live meaningfully. Making plans and getting feedback from others is advised to help achieve one's goals and objectives. The overall message is that small changes in oneself can make a big difference in the world.
The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People outlines seven principles to improve effectiveness. Habit 1 involves being proactive by responding to situations based on values rather than reacting emotionally. Habit 2 means beginning with the end in mind by envisioning the ideal future and working backwards. Habit 3, put first things first, prioritizes important goals and tasks. Habit 4 is think win-win, seeking mutual benefit in interactions. Habit 5 is to first seek to understand others before being understood. Habit 6, synergize, creates cooperation for greater collective results. Habit 7 involves self-renewal of skills, values, physical, and mental resources. Mastering these habits can help people achieve more in their personal
The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People outlines seven principles to improve effectiveness. Habit 1 involves being proactive by responding to situations based on values rather than reacting emotionally. Habit 2 means beginning with the end in mind by envisioning the ideal future and working backwards. Habit 3, put first things first, prioritizes important goals and tasks. Habit 4 is think win-win, seeking mutual benefit in interactions. Habit 5 is to first seek to understand others before being understood. Habit 6, synergize, creates cooperation for greater collective results. Habit 7 involves self-renewal of skills, values, physical, and mental resources. Mastering these habits can help people achieve more in their personal
This document provides an overview of a program aimed at transforming one's life from "frantic activity" to "being in action." It discusses concepts like quantum mechanics, principles for inventing a future like intention and visualization, and processes for materializing goals. The purpose is to alter one's experience of living so life occurs as a curriculum that magically clears things up through living. Key aspects involve observing oneself, choosing behavior over being run by thoughts, and standing in a creative place called "now what?" after examining what's happening and adding meaning.
This document discusses self-awareness, including its definition, importance, and how it can be measured and developed. Self-awareness involves being conscious of one's own personality, behaviors, and emotions. It allows for self-regulation and understanding of others. Developing self-awareness is important for goal-setting and personal growth. While increasing self-focus can lead to self-evaluation and potential stress, techniques like meditation, journaling, reframing thoughts, and positive thinking can help manage stress and develop deeper self-awareness.
Self-empowerment encourages developing skills and knowledge to overcome obstacles in life or work. It covers five areas: physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual empowerment. Being self-confident involves self-appreciation, vision, purpose, commitment, and contribution. Effective self-empowerment in social situations requires being genuine, a good listener, having a sense of humor, acts of kindness, nurturing relationships, and maintaining confidence and control over one's emotions. Internal change for self-empowerment starts with recognizing defects, committing to change, deciding on alternatives, and sticking to a schedule for change until new habits form.
The document discusses various aspects of thoughts and thinking patterns. It defines thought and describes the elements and types of thoughts, including reflective thought. It discusses developing thought awareness to recognize negative or unhealthy thinking patterns. Some common unhelpful thinking styles are identified, such as jumping to conclusions, catastrophizing, and overgeneralization. The document provides guidance on evaluating thoughts and addressing negative thoughts, including questioning the validity of negative thoughts, focusing on positive aspects, practicing self-compassion, and giving space for emotions.
Here are some examples of irrational ideas that can make us upset:
- If something goes wrong, it's a catastrophe.
- I must be loved and approved by everyone.
- Things must go the way I want them to, or else it's intolerable.
- People should always do the right thing, and they shouldn't make mistakes.
- My unhappiness is caused by outside things and events, not my own thoughts.
- I can't stand to feel anxious or unsure about anything.
- There's always a right and exact solution to problems, and I should quickly find it.
- It's awful and unacceptable when things are uncertain or unpredictable.
By identifying and challenging these types of
Assignment DetailsScenario You are member of a prisoner revie.docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Scenario:
You are member of a prisoner review board for a minimum-security facility in your state. Included among the inmates are a number of heroin addicts who were charged with possession crimes and some minor thefts through which they supported their habits.
Please include answers in your main post for the following questions:
What are the methods of treatment for heroin addiction?
What is the difference between heroin detoxification and heroin addiction treatment?
What is the best method for ensuring the heroin addict does not return to heroin abuse? Does long-term incarceration play a role?
.
Assignment DetailsScenario You are an investigator for Child .docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Scenario:
You are an investigator for Child Protective Services in your community. One of the most difficult aspects of interviewing is the interview of a suspected victim of child sexual abuse. Often, the first interviewers are detectives or investigators from the police department with little or no training for interviewing child sexual abuse victims. The Commander of the Sex Crimes Unit would like to you to identify errors in interviewing by police investigators when questioning child sex crime victims about the circumstances during the alleged offense(s). The psychopathology of the suspect and the victim are very important, but the victim can be misled unintentionally by police resulting in false or inaccurate complaint information.
The Commander of the Sex Crimes Unit would like you to outline and explain the specific areas to be avoided when questioning a child as a sex crime victim.
Specifically, he is concerned with the following:
The use of suggestive questions
The implication of confirmation by other people
Use of positive and negative consequences
Repetitious questioning
Inviting speculation
In a 3–5-page paper, address the specific concerns, and explain why it is preferable to have the child interviewed by a person with the qualifications to potentially testify as an expert witness in subsequent criminal trials
.
More Related Content
Similar to CRITICAL THINKING T O O L S F O R T A K I N G C H A R G .docx
The document provides an overview of leadership qualities and Stephen Covey's Seven Habits of Highly Effective People. It discusses that effective leadership requires understanding the big picture, empowering and developing teams, and adapting to different situations. It also outlines the seven habits which include being proactive, beginning with the end in mind, putting first things first, thinking win-win, seeking first to understand, synergizing, and sharpening the saw.
Self-esteem refers to how people feel about themselves and their level of competence. The document discusses that self-esteem determines how people interact with others and their goals, achievements, and satisfaction in life. Healthy self-esteem is related to traits like creativity, rationality, and honesty. The document provides tips for building self-esteem such as focusing on strengths, celebrating progress, and avoiding negative self-talk. Maintaining high self-esteem leads to benefits like confidence and respect for oneself and others.
What is thinking and difference between thinking and critical thinking, Characteristics, How critical thinking can be used for problem solving and the steps included, Attitude of Critical thinkers.
LAYWi roadmap - Success and Happiness in life!LAYWi
This document provides guidance on managing one's life through self-awareness and planning. It discusses the importance of understanding oneself, establishing life priorities and direction, and creating a vision or dream for the future. The document recommends evaluating where one currently stands versus their ideal situation, identifying any gaps, and making a plan to bridge those gaps over time through achievable goals and actions. Tools are presented to help with self-evaluation, defining priorities, and creating a customized plan to work towards one's vision of success and happiness.
Self awareness is a key skill for successful leaders. Self-aware teams make better decisions, collaborate more, and manage tensions and conflicts more effectively. Gustavo Razzetti, CEO of Liberationist shares the power of self-awareness and how it increases teamwork and collaboration.
The document outlines eight secrets to life and school success: 1) taking personal responsibility, 2) self-motivation through setting meaningful goals, 3) self-management including time management, 4) interdependence by reaching out to others, 5) lifelong learning through understanding one's learning style, 6) developing emotional intelligence, 7) believing in oneself, and 8) core beliefs and replacing self-defeating scripts. It emphasizes active learning, personal responsibility, valuing goals, managing time efficiently, and developing interpersonal skills for success.
The document outlines 6 stages of critical thinking development:
1) Unreflective thinker - People at this stage do not notice their assumptions and biases in thinking.
2) Challenged thinker - People become aware of problems in their thinking and lack of self-monitoring.
3) Practicing thinker - People recognize the need to systematically improve their thinking and develop awareness of better thinking habits.
4) Advanced thinker - People have good command over biases and strive to be fair-minded, while identifying areas they can improve.
5) Accomplished thinker - People have taken charge of their thinking, regularly assessing to improve clarity and reduce biases.
6) The accomplished thinker
This document provides information about developing self-confidence. It begins with definitions of self-confidence and discusses the objectives of learning about self-confidence, which include evaluating current levels of self-confidence and exploring tools and strategies to develop it. The document then discusses characteristics of confident and unconfident people. It provides a self-confidence questionnaire, strategies for setting goals and stepping outside one's comfort zone. Assertive communication techniques are contrasted with passive and aggressive styles. The document concludes with discussing dealing with criticism and practical strategies for improving self-confidence like positive thinking and facing fears.
This document summarizes the key points from the first seven chapters of a book about breaking free from expectations and reclaiming your authentic self.
The chapters discuss identifying the expectations that may be holding you back, such as from parents, culture or your own beliefs. It explores having a "wake up call" realization that you're not living as you truly want. Making the courageous decision to change requires honesty, risk-taking and facing fears. Breaking free means stepping into uncharted territory and the unknown, which can be challenging but also liberating. Listen to your inner voice to stay grounded. Overcoming roadblocks, such as self-doubt or lack of support, requires resilience and a growth mindset
This document provides seven ways to gain self-knowledge and get to know yourself better. It discusses getting to know your personality, core values, and body. It also recommends journaling, identifying strengths and weaknesses, envisioning your life mission, and questioning automatic thoughts. The overall message is that practicing self-reflection through these various methods can help you develop a well-rounded understanding of who you are.
This document presents an ebook about developing coping skills for stress. It discusses how stress is an inevitable part of life today due to increased pressures and competition. When coping resources are inadequate, stressful events can lead to unhealthy outcomes like suicide. The ebook recommends becoming more knowledgeable about stress, understanding its effects, identifying stressors, anticipating stressful periods, and developing stress management techniques. It also discusses two models of how people think, feel and act in response to situations - reacting reflexively or responding thoughtfully. Developing skills like critical thinking, problem solving, communication, interpersonal skills, and self-regulation can help people better cope with stressful life events.
Seven Habits of Highly Effective PeopleTania Aslam
The document provides an overview of Stephen Covey's book "The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People". It discusses the book's introduction, structure, key principles and the seven habits which are: 1) Be Proactive, 2) Begin with the End in Mind, 3) Put First Things First, 4) Think Win-Win, 5) Seek First to Understand, Then to Be Understood, 6) Synergize, and 7) Sharpen the Saw. Each habit is explained in terms of its underlying principle and paradigm.
The document provides guidance on how to make positive changes in one's life and the world on Foundation Day. It recommends starting with changing one's mindset by identifying and replacing limiting beliefs. Examples of common limiting beliefs are given. The document also suggests setting goals based on one's values and creating a vision for how to live meaningfully. Making plans and getting feedback from others is advised to help achieve one's goals and objectives. The overall message is that small changes in oneself can make a big difference in the world.
The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People outlines seven principles to improve effectiveness. Habit 1 involves being proactive by responding to situations based on values rather than reacting emotionally. Habit 2 means beginning with the end in mind by envisioning the ideal future and working backwards. Habit 3, put first things first, prioritizes important goals and tasks. Habit 4 is think win-win, seeking mutual benefit in interactions. Habit 5 is to first seek to understand others before being understood. Habit 6, synergize, creates cooperation for greater collective results. Habit 7 involves self-renewal of skills, values, physical, and mental resources. Mastering these habits can help people achieve more in their personal
The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People outlines seven principles to improve effectiveness. Habit 1 involves being proactive by responding to situations based on values rather than reacting emotionally. Habit 2 means beginning with the end in mind by envisioning the ideal future and working backwards. Habit 3, put first things first, prioritizes important goals and tasks. Habit 4 is think win-win, seeking mutual benefit in interactions. Habit 5 is to first seek to understand others before being understood. Habit 6, synergize, creates cooperation for greater collective results. Habit 7 involves self-renewal of skills, values, physical, and mental resources. Mastering these habits can help people achieve more in their personal
This document provides an overview of a program aimed at transforming one's life from "frantic activity" to "being in action." It discusses concepts like quantum mechanics, principles for inventing a future like intention and visualization, and processes for materializing goals. The purpose is to alter one's experience of living so life occurs as a curriculum that magically clears things up through living. Key aspects involve observing oneself, choosing behavior over being run by thoughts, and standing in a creative place called "now what?" after examining what's happening and adding meaning.
This document discusses self-awareness, including its definition, importance, and how it can be measured and developed. Self-awareness involves being conscious of one's own personality, behaviors, and emotions. It allows for self-regulation and understanding of others. Developing self-awareness is important for goal-setting and personal growth. While increasing self-focus can lead to self-evaluation and potential stress, techniques like meditation, journaling, reframing thoughts, and positive thinking can help manage stress and develop deeper self-awareness.
Self-empowerment encourages developing skills and knowledge to overcome obstacles in life or work. It covers five areas: physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual empowerment. Being self-confident involves self-appreciation, vision, purpose, commitment, and contribution. Effective self-empowerment in social situations requires being genuine, a good listener, having a sense of humor, acts of kindness, nurturing relationships, and maintaining confidence and control over one's emotions. Internal change for self-empowerment starts with recognizing defects, committing to change, deciding on alternatives, and sticking to a schedule for change until new habits form.
The document discusses various aspects of thoughts and thinking patterns. It defines thought and describes the elements and types of thoughts, including reflective thought. It discusses developing thought awareness to recognize negative or unhealthy thinking patterns. Some common unhelpful thinking styles are identified, such as jumping to conclusions, catastrophizing, and overgeneralization. The document provides guidance on evaluating thoughts and addressing negative thoughts, including questioning the validity of negative thoughts, focusing on positive aspects, practicing self-compassion, and giving space for emotions.
Here are some examples of irrational ideas that can make us upset:
- If something goes wrong, it's a catastrophe.
- I must be loved and approved by everyone.
- Things must go the way I want them to, or else it's intolerable.
- People should always do the right thing, and they shouldn't make mistakes.
- My unhappiness is caused by outside things and events, not my own thoughts.
- I can't stand to feel anxious or unsure about anything.
- There's always a right and exact solution to problems, and I should quickly find it.
- It's awful and unacceptable when things are uncertain or unpredictable.
By identifying and challenging these types of
Similar to CRITICAL THINKING T O O L S F O R T A K I N G C H A R G .docx (20)
Assignment DetailsScenario You are member of a prisoner revie.docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Scenario:
You are member of a prisoner review board for a minimum-security facility in your state. Included among the inmates are a number of heroin addicts who were charged with possession crimes and some minor thefts through which they supported their habits.
Please include answers in your main post for the following questions:
What are the methods of treatment for heroin addiction?
What is the difference between heroin detoxification and heroin addiction treatment?
What is the best method for ensuring the heroin addict does not return to heroin abuse? Does long-term incarceration play a role?
.
Assignment DetailsScenario You are an investigator for Child .docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Scenario:
You are an investigator for Child Protective Services in your community. One of the most difficult aspects of interviewing is the interview of a suspected victim of child sexual abuse. Often, the first interviewers are detectives or investigators from the police department with little or no training for interviewing child sexual abuse victims. The Commander of the Sex Crimes Unit would like to you to identify errors in interviewing by police investigators when questioning child sex crime victims about the circumstances during the alleged offense(s). The psychopathology of the suspect and the victim are very important, but the victim can be misled unintentionally by police resulting in false or inaccurate complaint information.
The Commander of the Sex Crimes Unit would like you to outline and explain the specific areas to be avoided when questioning a child as a sex crime victim.
Specifically, he is concerned with the following:
The use of suggestive questions
The implication of confirmation by other people
Use of positive and negative consequences
Repetitious questioning
Inviting speculation
In a 3–5-page paper, address the specific concerns, and explain why it is preferable to have the child interviewed by a person with the qualifications to potentially testify as an expert witness in subsequent criminal trials
.
Assignment DetailsScenario You are a new patrol officer in a .docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Scenario:
You are a new patrol officer in a major metropolitan city in the center of the country. You have only been on patrol for about four weeks but notice that the officers with more time on the street have been making racially disparaging jokes about members of the poorer neighborhoods. What surprised you was the number of African-American and Hispanic officers who seemed to go along with the culture of racially biased comments. The community in which your precinct is located is crime-ridden and poor. It is largely African-American and Hispanic-American.
When you are on the street, you note that the tension between minority members of the community is very high and that it is even worse between minority officers and the minority community, who tend to view the minority officers as “race traitors.”
In addition, there are a number of combat veterans who have returned to the police department from Iraq and Afghanistan. These veterans have developed a prejudiced outlook towards the Muslim Community, which has a peaceful Mosque in the very center of the community.
Focus your discussion on the following:
Explain your viewpoint as to whether racism and religious bias are based on psychopathology of the officers or not.
.
Assignment DetailsScenario Generally, we have considered sexual.docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Scenario: Generally, we have considered sexual harassment actions or verbal abuse of women to be done by men. Over the past several decades, the culture of society has evolved. The diversity of sex and gender has erupted from male abuses of females based on their biology. Now, there are gender reassignments which allow for persons with the psychological inclination to be the gender other than what they were born as being possible. Further, there are a number of transgender persons who, while retaining their biological configuration, adopt the psyche and outward appearance through dress and mannerisms of what is considered to be the traditional opposite gender of their physiology.
Recently, a newly assigned outwardly female officer was found out by her teammates in a Special Weapons and Tactics (SWAT) unit to actually be a biological male. Several of the SWAT team members have come to you as the SWAT Command Leader and have voiced their concern because the transgender officer uses the ladies room, wears makeup, and dresses as a woman in her civilian attire at the end of the shift. The officers making the complaint are claiming that someone with a psychopathological problem should not be in the SWAT unit. You go to the Deputy Chief with their concerns and she tells you to prepare a briefing for the SWAT members concerning the requirements for SWAT team membership and that if an officer makes the grade, he or she has the opportunity to be a SWAT officer.
In a 3–5-page paper, you must explain to the officers, including those who complained as well as those who did not complain, that the department supports the assignment of the new officer and that according to law, she must be accepted as a valid member of the team so long as she is qualified. Further, explain that transphobia is not an acceptable attitude for members of the team and that any discriminatory action on the part of officers concerning the new officer would not be tolerated and would be met with appropriate disciplinary action.
.
Assignment DetailsPower’s on, Power’s Off!How convenient is.docxfaithxdunce63732
The document is an assignment detailing for a student to analyze and discuss issues related to electricity usage and power outages. It provides background information on generating electricity and its environmental impacts. It then presents two scenarios for the student to respond to - one where the power is out, and one where the power is on. For the power outage scenario, the student is asked to discuss inconveniences, concerns if the outage lasts 3+ days, and their preferred backup power source. For the power on scenario, the student must analyze behaviors to reduce heating/cooling costs, how switching to LEDs can save on lighting costs, and ways to reduce hot water usage.
Assignment DetailsIn 1908, playwright Israel Zangwill referred to .docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
In 1908, playwright Israel Zangwill referred to America as a
melting pot
. Zangwill’s concept of the United States as a country where people of all cultures and nations are free to come and contribute to a common American culture remains a popular concept—even more than a century after its introduction.
More recently, the concept of the American mosaic asserts that American society consist not of melting pot in which people and cultures mix together to form a larger American culture, but as a mosaic in which ethnic groups come to the United States and coexist with other groups but maintain significant cultural and social distinctions among themselves.
Post a discussion that explores these themes by demonstrating how various cultures and ethnicities have contributed to modern American history and culture. Select 1 ethnic group, and include the following in your discussion:
Part 1
Explain a specific contribution that this group made to American society or culture.
Part 2
Evaluate the concepts of the melting pot and the American mosaic.
Which concept more accurately reflects the experiences of the ethnic group you chose? Support your assertion.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Choose one (1) Native American tribe residing within the continental United States (Lower 48 states) at the time of first European contact. Research various aspects of the chosen tribe’s culture or history. Make sure ample historical records exist for the chosen tribe. Some tribes are not well-documented in the existing historical record.
Topics that
need
to be researched include but are not limited to:
Describing what is known of the tribe’s pre-Columbian history, including settlement dates and any known cultural details.
Describing the cultural and religious beliefs of the chosen tribe.
Describing the tribe’s history after contact, including major events and armed conflicts that may have been important to the history of the tribe in the present day.
Explaining the history of at least one historical figure of the chosen tribe and events surrounding that individual’s life
.
Assignment DetailsPart IRespond to the following.docxfaithxdunce63732
The document asks which crime data source provides the clearest and most helpful information between the Uniform Crime Report (UCR), National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS), and International Crime Victims Survey (ICVS). The UCR collects crime statistics from law enforcement agencies across the US, while the NCVS surveys individuals about crimes they have experienced directly. The ICVS surveys individuals across multiple countries about crimes.
Assignment DetailsPlease discuss the following in your main post.docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Please discuss the following in your main post:
Identify the classes of employees protected by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.
Why was Affirmative Action put into place?
Do you think Title VII and Affirmative Action are still necessary? Why or why not?
.
Assignment DetailsPennsylvania was the leader in sentencing and .docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Pennsylvania was the leader in sentencing and correctional reform in the early history of the United States. Discuss what groups were associated with this reform.
Why did they want the reform?
Examine whether it was successful and if the reform brought forth further changes.
What influences did the system have on the correctional system today?
What influences have changed? Why?
Use the Internet, library, and any other resources available to research your answer. Submit a 4–5-page paper (double-spaced) to your instructor. Support your reasoning with outside sources. Be sure to reference all sources using APA style.
The following will be the grading criteria for this assignment:
20%:
Discuss what groups were associated with this reform.
10%:
Why did they want the reform?
20%:
Examine whether it was successful and if the reform brought forth further changes.
25%:
What direct influences do you see from the Pennsylvania system in the correctional systems used today?
25%:
What influences have changed? Why?
.
Assignment DetailsPart IRespond to the followingReview .docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Part I
Respond to the following:
Review your course materials and the Internet to find information on the crime data sources available for different countries and the United States. Which of the following crime data sources provides the clearest and most helpful information, and why?
Uniform Crime Report (UCR)
National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS)
International Crime Victims Survey (ICVS)
United Nations Surveys on Crime Trends and Operations of Criminal Justice Systems (UN-CTS)
.
Assignment DetailsPart IRespond to the following questio.docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Part I
Respond to the following questions:
What examples of organized crime can you find in the United States?
What factors contribute to the existence of the criminal organizations you described?
Provide examples of the ways in which the U.S. criminal justice system is dealing with the types of organized crime that you found.
What law enforcement agencies are involved?
How do those law enforcement agencies work to control organized crime?
Part II
Suggestions for responding to peer posts:
Review peers’ posts that used examples of different types of organized crime than the ones that you found.
Were some of the factors that he or she believes contributed to these crimes the same? What different factors were mentioned?
Are the methods of dealing with this type of organized crime different from those devised to deal with the type of organized crime that you found?
.
Assignment DetailsPart IRespond to the following questions.docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Part I
Respond to the following questions:
What examples of organized crime can you find in the United States?
What factors contribute to the existence of the criminal organizations you described?
Provide examples of the ways in which the U.S. criminal justice system is dealing with the types of organized crime that you found.
What law enforcement agencies are involved?
How do those law enforcement agencies work to control organized crime?
.
Assignment DetailsOne thing that unites all humans—despite cultu.docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
One thing that unites all humans—despite culture or time period—is the desire to be happy. Since the beginning of Western philosophy, philosophers have been asking the question, “How can I find happiness?” In popular culture, there are articles in magazines, newspapers, and discussions on the Internet and television about the pursuit of happiness.
Part 1
What are some of the ways that people pursue happiness?
Do you believe that it can be obtained?
Discuss with others what you consider to be an impression of the state of happiness.
Part 2
Why do you think that people differ in their interpretations of happiness?
What do your reading sources say about this?
Have you changed your perception of happiness over the years?
Discuss with 2 or more classmates their interpretation of happiness.
For assistance with your assignment, please use your text, Web resources, and all course materials.
.
Assignment Details
MN551:
Develop cooperative relationships with clients when teaching concepts concerning pathological states to individuals and families
Select one of the case studies below, and include discussion of your strategy for winning the patients cooperation while teaching concepts concerning pathological states to them and their families.
Requirements
Make sure all of the topics in the case study have been addressed.
Cite at least three sources; journal articles, textbooks or evidenced-based websites to support the content.
All sources must be within five years.
Do not use .com, Wikipedia, or up-to-date, etc., for your sources.
Case Study 1
Concepts of Altered Health in Older Adults
Joseph P. is an 82-year-old male living at home. He is in overall good health and enjoys taking long walks as often as possible. During his walks, he likes to stop for a cold glass of fruit juice at the local cafeteria. On cold or rainy days, he rides a stationary bicycle at home for 30 minutes to “stay in good shape.”
What physiological factors would typically increase Joseph’s risk of falling while walking outdoors?
What are the common changes in blood pressure regulation that occurs with aging?
Joseph enjoys fruit juice when he walks. Considering the renal system in the older adult, why would dehydration be a particular concern?
Case Study 2
Structure and Function of the Kidney
Rivka is an active 21-year-old who decided to take a day off from her university classes. The weather was hot and the sun bright, so she decided to go down to the beach. When she arrived, she found a few people playing beach volleyball, and they asked if she wanted to join in. She put down her school bag and began to play. The others were well prepared for their day out and stopped throughout the game to have their power drinks and soda pop. Several hours after they began to play, however, Rivka was not feeling so good. She stopped sweating and was feeling dizzy. One player noted she had not taken a washroom break at all during the day. They found a shaded area for her, and one of the players shared his power drink with her. Rivka was thirstier than she realized and quickly finished the drink.
In pronounced dehydration, hypotension can occur. How would this affect the glomerular filtration rate of the kidney? What actions by the juxtaglomerular apparatus would occur to restore GFR?
What is the effect aldosterone has on the distal convoluted tubule? Why would the actions of aldosterone be useful to Rivka in her situation?
What does a specific gravity test measure? If someone tested the specific gravity of Rivka’s urine, what might it indicate?
Case Study 3
Disorders of Fluid and Electrolyte Balance
Amanda is an 18-year-old with anorexia nervosa. She was recently admitted to an eating disorders clinic with a BMI of 13.9, and although she was a voluntary patient, she was reluctant about the treatment. She was convinced she was overweigh.
Assignment DetailsInfluence ProcessesYou have been encourag.docxfaithxdunce63732
The document outlines an assignment to write an 8-10 page report comparing the influence processes of three leaders. The report must include: an introduction to influence processes; an explanation of the role of influence in leadership; a discussion of influence process types and factors; a methodology for selecting leaders; an analysis of the influence processes used by the three leaders; a discussion of the strengths and weaknesses of the leaders' influence processes relative to challenges; and a summary of key attributes of the leaders' influence processes for effecting organizational change. The report needs citations and references in APA style.
Assignment DetailsIn this assignment, you will identify and .docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
In this assignment, you will identify and select a historical or present-day terrorist group to describe and develop a group profile of. In 2–3 pages, address the following:
Identify and select a present-day or historical terrorist group. Identify the group’s underlying motivation, purpose, and objectives.
Develop the group’s profile by crafting a background and discussion on how your selected group was established, how it evolved, and how it ceased to exist, as applicable. If the group is still operating, outline how and why it continues to exist.
Develop and explore some potential counterterrorism or mitigative options. For a historical group, outline how the group was dealt with to the point that it no longer served as an influencing factor.
Be sure to reference all sources using APA style.
.
Assignment DetailsFinancial statements are the primary means of .docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Financial statements are the primary means of communicating financial information to users. It is important to have a firm understanding of the income statement, balance sheet, and statement of cash flows. Managers will make decisions daily that will have an effect on the elements of the accounting equation: Assets = Liabilities + Owners’ Equity. Managerial accounting reports use these same financial statements but also incorporate non-financial information that will assist internal users in making strategic and tactical decisions. For this reason, it is important for you to understand how decisions will affect the accounting equation.
The following spreadsheet is for Manhattan Family Dentistry on January 1 of the current year.
Complete the following balance sheet for Manhattan Family Dentistry on January 4 of the current year.
.
Assignment DetailsIn this assignment, you will identify a pr.docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
In this assignment, you will identify a present-day controversial issue, such as immigration, government encroachment on privacy, anti-capitalism, and so on. In 2–3 pages, address the following:
Identify and select a present-day issue that can potentially polarize a specific risk group.
Develop and explore the issue and why it can serve as a polarizing and divisive issue. Discuss how certain risk populations can become radicalized and justify the use of violence to elevate their position.
Place yourself in the role of a policy maker. What kind of legislation could you propose to address the social, political, or economic conditions you described above? How will your proposed solutions improve conditions for the specific risk group you identified?
Be sure to reference all sources using APA style.
.
Assignment DetailsHealth information technology (health IT) .docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Health information technology (health IT) makes it possible for health care providers to better manage patient care through secure use and sharing of health information. Health IT includes the use of electronic health records (EHRs) instead of paper medical records to maintain people's health information.
Share the EHR platform that your practice uses and discuss the challenges and barriers to electronic charting. Why have we moved from paper charting to EHR’s? What is meant by meaningful use regulations and why is this important to know when documenting in the EHR?
Please support your work with at least three evidence based practice resources that are less than 5 years old.
Written Paper (Microsoft Word doc): minimum 2000 words using 6th edition APA formatting
Please review the grading rubric under Course Resources in the Grading Rubric section.
.
Assignment DetailsDiscuss the followingWhat were some of .docxfaithxdunce63732
Assignment Details
Discuss the following:
What were some of the major criticisms that led some states to abandon the indeterminate sentence and parole?
Do you support abolition of indeterminate sentence and parole? Why or why not? Please support your position.
Be sure to cite all references in APA format.
.
Information and Communication Technology in EducationMJDuyan
(𝐓𝐋𝐄 𝟏𝟎𝟎) (𝐋𝐞𝐬𝐬𝐨𝐧 2)-𝐏𝐫𝐞𝐥𝐢𝐦𝐬
𝐄𝐱𝐩𝐥𝐚𝐢𝐧 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐈𝐂𝐓 𝐢𝐧 𝐞𝐝𝐮𝐜𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧:
Students will be able to explain the role and impact of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in education. They will understand how ICT tools, such as computers, the internet, and educational software, enhance learning and teaching processes. By exploring various ICT applications, students will recognize how these technologies facilitate access to information, improve communication, support collaboration, and enable personalized learning experiences.
𝐃𝐢𝐬𝐜𝐮𝐬𝐬 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐫𝐞𝐥𝐢𝐚𝐛𝐥𝐞 𝐬𝐨𝐮𝐫𝐜𝐞𝐬 𝐨𝐧 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐢𝐧𝐭𝐞𝐫𝐧𝐞𝐭:
-Students will be able to discuss what constitutes reliable sources on the internet. They will learn to identify key characteristics of trustworthy information, such as credibility, accuracy, and authority. By examining different types of online sources, students will develop skills to evaluate the reliability of websites and content, ensuring they can distinguish between reputable information and misinformation.
A Visual Guide to 1 Samuel | A Tale of Two HeartsSteve Thomason
These slides walk through the story of 1 Samuel. Samuel is the last judge of Israel. The people reject God and want a king. Saul is anointed as the first king, but he is not a good king. David, the shepherd boy is anointed and Saul is envious of him. David shows honor while Saul continues to self destruct.
How to Download & Install Module From the Odoo App Store in Odoo 17Celine George
Custom modules offer the flexibility to extend Odoo's capabilities, address unique requirements, and optimize workflows to align seamlessly with your organization's processes. By leveraging custom modules, businesses can unlock greater efficiency, productivity, and innovation, empowering them to stay competitive in today's dynamic market landscape. In this tutorial, we'll guide you step by step on how to easily download and install modules from the Odoo App Store.
A Free 200-Page eBook ~ Brain and Mind Exercise.pptxOH TEIK BIN
(A Free eBook comprising 3 Sets of Presentation of a selection of Puzzles, Brain Teasers and Thinking Problems to exercise both the mind and the Right and Left Brain. To help keep the mind and brain fit and healthy. Good for both the young and old alike.
Answers are given for all the puzzles and problems.)
With Metta,
Bro. Oh Teik Bin 🙏🤓🤔🥰
Brand Guideline of Bashundhara A4 Paper - 2024khabri85
It outlines the basic identity elements such as symbol, logotype, colors, and typefaces. It provides examples of applying the identity to materials like letterhead, business cards, reports, folders, and websites.
Elevate Your Nonprofit's Online Presence_ A Guide to Effective SEO Strategies...TechSoup
Whether you're new to SEO or looking to refine your existing strategies, this webinar will provide you with actionable insights and practical tips to elevate your nonprofit's online presence.
Creative Restart 2024: Mike Martin - Finding a way around “no”Taste
Ideas that are good for business and good for the world that we live in, are what I’m passionate about.
Some ideas take a year to make, some take 8 years. I want to share two projects that best illustrate this and why it is never good to stop at “no”.
Accounting for Restricted Grants When and How To Record Properly
CRITICAL THINKING T O O L S F O R T A K I N G C H A R G .docx
1. CRITICAL
THINKING
T O O L S F O R T A K I N G C H A R G E O F
y 0 l l R L E A R N I N G A N D Y O U R L I F E
T H I R D e d i t i o n
Richard Paul
Foundation for Critical Thinking
Linda Elder
Foundat ion for Critical Thinking
PEARSON
Boston Columbus Indianapolis New York San Francisco Upper
Saddle River
Amsterdam Cape Town Dubai London Madrid Milan Munich
Paris Montreal Toronto
Delhi Mexico City Sao Paulo Sydney H o n g Kong Seoul
Singapore Taipei T o k y o
C H A P T E H 2
EXHIBIT 2.1 Most people have lived their entire lives as
unreflective thinkers.
To develop as thinkers requires commitment to daily practice.
2. S T A G E S OF C R I T I C A L T H I N K I N G D E V E L O
P M E N T
/
Accomplished Thinker
(Intellectual skills
and virtues have
become second
nature in our lives)
/
Advanced Thinker
( W e are committed to lifelong
practice and are beginning to
internalize intellectual virtues)
/
Practicing Thinker
( W e regularly practice a n d
advance accordingly)
/
Beginning Thinker
(We try to improve but
without regular practice)
/
Challenged Thinker
(We are faced with significant
3. problems in our thinking)
Unreflective Thinker
( W e are unaware of significant
problems in our thinking)
If we aspire to develop as thinkers, the stages all of us go
through are:
Stage 1 T h e Unreflective Thinker (we are unaware of
significant problems in
o u r thinking)
Stage 2 T h e Challenged Thinker (we become aware of
problems in our
thinking)
Stage 3 T h e Beginning Thinker (we try t o improve but w i t h
o u t regular
practice)
Stage 4 T h e Practicing Thinker (we recognize the necessity of
regular practice)
Stage 5 T h e Advanced Thinker (we advance in accordance
with o u r practice)
Stage 6 T h e Accomplished Thinker (skilled and insightful
thinking become
second nature to us)
STAGE 1: THE UNREFLECTIVE THINKER
Are you an unreflective thinker? We all are born—and most of
us die—as largely
4. unreflective thinkers, fundamentally unaware of the role that
thinking is playing in
o u r lives. At this Unreflective Thinker stage, we have n o
useful conception of what
t h i n k i n g entails. For example, as unreflective thinkers, we
don't notice that we
are continually m a k i n g assumptions, f o r m i n g concepts,
drawing inferences, and
t h i n k i n g within points of view. At this stage, we don't
know how to analyze and
assess o u r thinking. We don't know how to determine whether
o u r p u r p o s e s are
clearly formulated, o u r assumptions justified, our conclusions
logically drawn. We
are unaware of intellectual traits and so are not striving to e m b
o d y them.
At this stage, many problems in our lives are caused by p o o r
thinking, but
we are unaware of this. We don't question o u r beliefs or our
decisions. We lack
intellectual standards a n d have no idea what such standards m
i g h t be. We lack the
intellectual traits but are not aware that we lack them. We
unconsciously deceive
ourselves in many ways. We create and maintain pleasant
illusions. Because our
beliefs seem reasonable t o us, we believe them with
confidence. We walk a b o u t the
world with confidence that things really are the way they appear
to us. We judge
s o m e people to be " g o o d " and some to be " b a d . " We
approve of some actions and
disapprove of others. We make decisions, react to people, go o
u r way in life, and
d o not seriously question our thinking or its implications.
5. Although we don't realize it, our egocentric tendencies at this
stage play a
dominant role in o u r thinking. We lack t h e skills a n d the
motivation to notice
h o w self-centered and prejudiced we are, h o w often we
stereotype others, how fre-
quently we dismiss ideas irrationally simply because we don't w
a n t to c h a n g e o u r
behavior or our comfortable way of looking at things.
2.1 Think for Yours ̂
REFLECTING O N YOUR K N O W L E D G E OF T H I N K I
N G
M ight you be at the Unreflective Thinker stage of
development? Test yourself by writing your answers to the
following:
I. Describe the role that thinking is playing in your life. ( B e as
clear and as detailed as
you can.)
2 What was a recent assumption you made that you should not
have made?
3 What is a concept you recently formed that y o u previously
lacked?
4 List five inferences you made in the past hour.
5 Name and explain a point of view you sometimes use to guide
your thinking.
6, Briefly describe how you analyze and assess thinking.
Name some intellectual standards you use. Explain how y o u
apply them.
8. Explain the role of egocentric thinking in your life.
9. Explain what you are doing to try to embody one or two of
6. the intellectual traits.
If you h a d t r o u b l e with your responses in the T h i n k for
Yourself exercise
y o u may well be at t h e Unreflective T h i n k e r stage. If so,
you d o not need to
'apologize o r feel badly about it; most people are at this stage
and don't know
it. T r a d i t i o n a l s c h o o l i n g and t h e way children
typically are reared do not help
p e o p l e to b e c o m e skilled thinkers. O f t e n , parents a n
d teachers themselves are
unreflective thinkers. T h i s is the product of a vicious circle.
Unreflective per-
s o n s raise unreflective persons. O n c e you explicitly
recognize that you are at
this stage, however, you are ready to move to the next stage.
And when you
m o v e to the next stage, you may be close to breaking o u t of
the vicious cycle of
unreflectiveness. To d o so requires that we become honestly
reflective—that we
begin to notice some problems in o u r thinking, that we begin
to recognize that
o u r t h i n k i n g is o f t e n egocentric a n d irrational, that c
h a n g e s in o u r own t h i n k i n g
are essential.
Honest reflectiveness leads t o healthy motivation to change. It
is f u n c t i o n a l
a n d productive. You m u s t not only see problems in y o u r
thinking but also have
s o m e sense of how you might a d d r e s s those problems.
You must become rea-
7. sonably articulate a b o u t what you have to d o to improve.
Motivation is c r u c i a l .
W i t h o u t a drive to change, nothing much of significance
will h a p p e n .
STAGE 2: T H E C H A L L E N G E D THINKER
Are you ready to accept the challenge? We c a n n o t solve a
problem we d o not own
or deal with a condition we deny. W i t h o u t knowledge of o u
r ignorance, we c a n n o t
seek the knowledge we lack. Without knowledge of the skills
we need t o develop,
we will not develop them.
As we become aware that " n o r m a l " thinkers often think
poorly, we move i n t o
the second stage of critical thinking development, the
Challenged Thinker. We
begin to notice that we often
• make questionable assumptions;
m use false, incomplete, or misleading information;
• make inferences that d o not follow from the evidence we
have;
• fail to recognize important implications in our thought;
• fail to recognize problems we have;
• form faulty concepts;
• reason within prejudiced points of view; a n d
• think egocentrically and irrationally.
We move to the Challenged T h i n k e r stage when we become
a w a r e of t h e
way our thinking is shaping our lives, including the recognition
t h a t p r o b l e m s in
our thinking are causing problems in o u r lives. We begin to
recognize t h a t p o o r
8. thinking can be life-threatening, that it can lead literally to
death or p e r m a n e n t
T H E F I R S T F O U R S T A K E S o r D E V E L O P M E N
T
injury, t h a t it can h u r t others as well as ourselves. For
example, we might reflect
upon the t h i n k i n g of
• the teenager w h o thinks that smoking is sexy;
• the w o m a n w h o thinks that P a p smears are not important;
• the motorcyclist who r e a s o n s t h a t helmets o b s t r u c t
vision and, therefore,
riding w i t h o u t o n e is s a f e r ;
• the person w h o thinks he can drive safely while d r u n k ;
• the person w h o decides t o marry a self-centered person with
the t h o u g h t that
he or she will "change" a f t e r marriage.
We also recognize the difficulty involved in "improving" o u r
thinking. If you
are at this stage in your own thinking, you recognize that the
problem of changing
your habits of t h o u g h t is an i m p o r t a n t challenge
requiring extensive a n d difficult
changes in your n o r m a l routines.
Some signs of emerging reflectiveness are that
• you f i n d yourself striving t o analyze and assess
your.thinking;
9. • you find yourself working with the structures of mind that
create, or m a k e
possible, thinking (for example: concepts, assumptions,
inferences, implications,
points of view);
• you f i n d yourself thinking about the qualities t h a t make
thinking s o u n d —
clarity, accuracy, precision, relevance, logicalness—even
though you may
have only an initial grasp of how to achieve these qualities;
• you find yourself becoming interested in the role of self-
deception in thinking,
even though your understanding is relatively "abstract," a n d
you may not be
able t o offer many examples from your own life.
At this point in your development self-deception is a distinct
danger. M a n y resist
accepting the true nature of the challenge: that their own
thinking is a real and sig-
nificant problem in their life. If you do as many do, you will
revert to the Unreflective
Thinker stage. Your experience of thinking about your thinking
will fade, and your
usual habits of thought will remain as they are. For example,
you may find yourself
rationalizing in the following way: " My thinking is n o t that
bad. Actually, I've been
thinking well for quite a while. I question a lot of things. I'm
not prejudiced. Besides
that, I'm very critical. And I'm not nearly as self-deceived as
lots of people I know."
10. If you reason in this way, you are not alone; you're in the
majority. T h i s
view—"If everyone were t o think like me, this would be a fine
world"—is the
dominant one. Those who s h a r e this view range f r o m the
poorly schooled to the
highly schooled. There is no evidence to suggest that schooling
correlates with self-
reflectiveness. Indeed, many college graduates are intellectually
arrogant because of
their schooling. Unreflective people are found in all
socioeconomic classes and in-
clude psychologists, sociologists, philosophers, mathematicians,
doctors, senators,
judges, governors, district attorneys, lawyers, and. indeed,
people of all professions.
C H A P T E R 2
In short, absence of intellectual humility is c o m m o n a m o n
g all classes of peo-
ple in all w a l k s of life at all ages. It follows t h a t active o r
passive resistance t o the
challenge of critical t h i n k i n g is t h e c o m m o n rather t h
a n the rare case. W h e t h e r in
t h e form of a careless s h r u g or o u t r i g h t hostility, most
people reject the challenge
of critical t h i n k i n g . T h a t is why s o m e soul-searching
is i m p o r t a n t at this p o i n t in
t h e process.
.3 Think for Yourself
THE CHALLENGED THINKER STAGE
11. Work in groups of three. The person whose first name is earliest
in the alphabet will explain the second stage, that of the
Challenged Thinker, to the other two. answering
any questions they might have. Then the other two in the group
will add any features the first
student missed and elaborate on the points they think are most
important.
T O IDENTIFY PROBLEMS IN Y O U R T H I N K 1 N G
See whether you can identify any problems in your thinking.
The best way to do this is to analyze a behavior of yours that
somehow is creating problems, either for you or for
others. Look at your personal relationships, your study habits,
your interaction patterns.
How do you behave when you are upset? How do you act when
you don't get your way? Do
you expect more of others than you expect of yourself?
Consider these questions as start-
ing points for challenging yourself as a thinker. If you cannot
identify any problems in your
thinking, think again.
STAGE 3: THE BEGINNING THINKER
Are you willing to begin? When a p e r s o n actively decides t o
take u p the c h a l l e n g e
to grow and d e v e l o p as a thinker, h e o r she enters the
stage we call the B e g i n n i n g
Thinker. In t h i s stage of thinking, we begin to take t h i n k i
n g seriously. T h i s s t a g e
prepares us f o r t h e next stages, w i t h the u l t i m a t e goal
of explicit c o m m a n d of
thinking. It is a stage of dawning realizations and of d e v e l o
p i n g will p o w e r . It
is n o t a stage of self-condemnation b u t , rather, of e m e r g i
n g consciousness. It is
12. a n a l o g o u s t o t h e stage in which p e o p l e who are
alcoholics recognize and fully a c -
cept the fact t h a t they are alcoholics. I m a g i n e a n
alcoholic saying, "I am a n a l c o -
holic, a n d onlv I c a n d o s o m e t h i n g a b o u t it." N o w
imagine yourself saying, " I a m
a w e a k , undisciplined thinker, and o n l y I c a n d o s o m e t
h i n g a b o u t it."
Once p e o p l e recognize that t h e y a r e " a d d i c t e d " t o
p o o r t h i n k i n g , they m u s t
begin t o recognize the d e p t h and n a t u r e of t h e problem.
If w e are at the B e g i n n i n g
T h i n k e r stage' we should recognize t h a t our t h i n k i n g
is s o m e t i m e s egocentric. F o r
example, we m a y notice how little w e c o n s i d e r the needs
of o t h e r s a n d h o w m u c h
we focus on g e t t i n g what we personally w a n t . We may n
o t i c e h o w little we e n t e r
the point of view of o t h e r s and h o w m u c h we assume t h
e " c o r r e c t n e s s " of o u r
. thers to S
o w n . W e m a y e v e n s o m e t i m e s catch ourselves trying
t o dominate ( ,- o r tr.c
w h a t w e w a n t or. a l t e r n a t i v e l y , acting out t h e
role of submitting t o o t t i e 0 w"ttich
g a m s t h a t s u b m i s s i v e b e h a v i o r brings). We may
begin to notice t h e extern i
we c o n l o r m u n c r i t i c a l l y t o the thinking of others.
A s t h i n k e r s t h i n k i n g a b o u t thinking, we a r e
merely beginning to
13. • a n a l y z e the l o g i c of s i t u a t i o n s and problems;
• e x p r e s s clear a n d precise questions;
• c h e c k i n f o r m a t i o n f o r accuracy and relevance; ^
• d i s t i n g u i s h b e t w e e n raw information a n d s o m e o
n e ' s interpretation o 1 <
• r e c o g n i z e a s s u m p t i o n s guiding inferences: ^
• i d e n t i f y p r e j u d i c i a l a n d biased beliefs,
unjustifiable conclusions, misuse
w o r d s , a n d m i s s e d implications;
• n o t i c e when o u r viewpoint is biased by o u r selfish
interests. _
T h u s , as B e g i n n i n g T h i n k e r s , we are b e c o m i n
g a w a r e of h o w t o d e a l A V J ^
s t r u c t u r e s at work in t h o u g h t (purposes, q u e s t i o n
s , i n f o r m a t i o n , i n t e r p - ^ ^
etc.). We are b e g i n n i n g t o appreciate the value of
examining o u r t h i n king
of its clarity, accuracy, relevance, precision, logicalness.,
justifiability, ^
d e p t h , a n d fairness, but w e are still at a low level of
proficiency in these: ^
T h e y f e e l a w k w a r d t o us. We have t o force ourselves t
o think in discipnn ^
We a r e like beginners in ballet. We feel foolish a d o p t i n g
the b a s i c posi e V t o
d o n ' t lee! graceful; we s t u m b l e a n d make mistakes. N o
o n e would pay
watch us perform. We ourselves d o n ' t like w h a t we see in
the m i r r o r ot o ^ m U S t
T o reach this B e g i n n i n g T h i n k e r stage, o u r values m
u s t begin t o shitt. h i l l |
expl< the f o u n d a t i o n of o u r t h i n k i n g and discover h
14. o w we have c o m e ^
a n d believe as we do. Let us consider this goal in a little more
d e t a i l . K e ' .
o n s o m e of the m a j o r infiuences t h a t have s h a p e d
your t h i n k i n g ( a n d OU )•
1. You were born into a culture (e.g., European, American,
African, Asian).
2. You were born at s o m e point in time (in s o m e c e n t u r
y in s o m e year).
3. You were born in s o m e place (in t h e c o u n t r y , in the
city, in t h e North or
South. East or West). , , t
4. You were raised by p a r e n t s with p a r t i c u l a r beliefs (
a b o u t t h e f a m i l y - * ^
personal relationships, a b o u t marriage, a b o u t c h i l d h o
o d , a b o u t obe<
about religion, about politics, a b o u t s c h o o l i n g ) .
5. "You tormed various a s s o c i a t i o n s (largely b a s e d o
n w h o was a r o u n d y o u
associations with people with a viewpoint, values, a n d taboos).
old
1 you were to change a n y one of these i n f i u e n c e s , y o u
r belief s y s t e ™ fieids
b e different. Suppose vou h a d been b o r n in t h e M i d d l e
A g e s as a ser 1 in r e i '
of France. Can you see that if you were, virtually all y o u r
beliefs w o u l d be ^ &
See whether you can p e r f o r m similar reflective e x p e r i m
e n t s of y o u r
ample, imagine other changes in these influences a n d t h e n
imaginative
15. some of t h e beliefs you likely w o u l d have with the b e l i e f
s you actually d o have. You
will begin t o a p p r e c i a t e how m u c h you, a n d every o t
h e r h u m a n , are a p r o d u c t o f
influences over which you. a n d they, had little or n o c o n t r
o l . Neither y o u n o r they
directed t h e s e influences. Their effects, clearly, were b o t h
g o o d and b a d .
For e x a m p l e , a s s u m e that m a n y of these influences e
n g e n d e r e d false beliefs in
us. It follows that o u r minds r i g h t now h a r b o r false
beliefs, a n d we a r e acting o n
t h e m . Yet, notice t h a t the mind h a s no mechanism f o r
screening out false beliefs.
We all c a r r y a r o u n d in our m i n d s prejudices from o u r
culture, f r o m where we were
b o r n and raised, f r o m o u r p a r e n t s , and f r o m our f r i
e n d s a n d associates. F i n d i n g
ways to l o c a t e those flawed beliefs and replace t h e m with
m o r e reasonable beliefs
is part of t h e a g e n d a of critical thinking. Another way to l
o o k at the forces, ratio-
nal and i r r a t i o n a l , t h a t have s h a p e d our m i n d s is
in t e r m s ot m o d e s of influence."
2 . 4 Think for Yourself
PUT T I N G YOURSELF I N A N O T H E R PLACE IN TIME
Imagine yourself in another place in time. Choose a different
century, perhaps a different
country, a different gender, a different socioeconomic group—
in any case, an altogether dif-
16. ferent set of circumstances in which you might have lived.
Complete the following:
1. The time within which I am imagining that! live is...
2. The details of the situation are (be specific).. •
3 If I had lived in this place in time. I most likely would hold
the following beliefs (about
religion, my country, sexual conventions and taboos, gender
issues, relationships, people
of different races, etc. Again, be specific)...
For e x a m p l e , we think within a variety of domains:
sociological, philosophi-
cal, ethical, intellectual, a n t h r o p o l o g i c a l , ideological,
political, economic, histori-
cal, biological, theological, and psychological. We ended up
with our p a r t i c u l a r
beliefs b e c a u s e we were influenced t o do s o in the
following ways:
• Sociological: O u r minds are i n f l u e n c e d by the social
groups to which we
belong.
• Philosophical: Our minds a r e influenced by o u r personal
philosophy.
• Ethical: O u r m i n d s are influenced by the extent to which
we behave in accor-
dance w i t h our obligations a n d the way we define our
obligations.
• Intellectual: Our minds are i n f l u e n c e d by the ideas we
hold, by the m a n n e r in
which we reason a n d deal w i t h a b s t r a c t i o n s and
17. abstract systems.
• Anthropological: O u r minds a r e influenced by cultural
practices, mores, a n d
taboos.
• Ideological and political: O u r m i n d s a r e influenced by
the structure of power
and its use by interest groups a r o u n d us.
• E c o n o m i c : O u r m i n d s are i n f l u e n c e d by the e c
o n o m i c conditions u n d e r which
w e live.
• H i s t o r i c a l : O u r m i n d s are i n f l u e n c e d by o u r
history and by the way we te
o u r history.
• Biological; Our minds are influenced by o u r biology and
neurology.
• T h e o l o g i c a l : O u r m i n d s are influenced by our
religious beliefs and attitudes.
• P s y c h o l o g i c a l : O u r m i n d s a r e influenced by our
personality a n d personal
psychology.
R e f l e c t i o n s such a s these s h o u l d awaken in us a s e n
s e of how little we really
k n o w a b o u t o u r own minds. W i t h i n each of o u r m i n
d s is a largely u n e x p t
w o r l d , an i n n e r world that has b e e n taking shape f o r t
h e whole ol our lives,
inner world is the most i m p o r t a n t f a c t about us because
18. it is where we h o -
m i n e s o u r joy a n d f r u s t r a t i o n . It l i m i t s what we
can see a n d imagine It tug S
w h a t we d o see. It c a n drive us crazy. It c a n provide u s
with solace, p e a c ,
tranquility. If we can appreciate t h e s e facts a b o u t us, we
will find the m o t i v
t o take c h a r g e of o u r thinking, t o b e s o m e t h i n g m o
r e t h a n clay m the h a
others, to b e c o m e , in fact, the r u l i n g force in o u r own
lives.
2 . 5 Think for
1 i-UNG T H I N K E R S T A G E .
Work in groups of three. The person whose first name is last in
the alphabet will explain the third stage, that of the Beginning
Thinker, to the other two. answering ai y q u e ^
tions they might have. Then the other two in the group will add
any features the hrs
missed and elaborate on the points they think are most
important.
L e t s n o w consider t w o lurking traps t h a t c a n derail the
b e g i n n i n g t h i n k e r .
Trap # 1: T h e t e m p t a t i o n of dogmatic absolutism^-
believing that ^ u t h i s
acquired n o t through reasoning and i n q u i r y but, rather, t h
r o u g h s o m e p •
t e r m i n e d , nonintellectual f a i t h .
Trap # 2 : The t e m p t a t i o n of subjective relativism—
believing t h a t t h e r e a r e n o
intellectual standards by which t o judge a n y t h i n g a s true o
r false.
19. B o t h traps promise us easy answers. To a d v a n c e as a b e g
i n n i n g thinker a n d not
fall into o n e o r the other of these t r a p s requires d e v e l o
p i n g confidence in t eas
a way of a c q u i r i n g sound knowledge and i n s i g h t . T h
e t w o traps a r e m i r r o r m g _
of each o t h e r . If we become either a dogmatic absolutist or a
subjective reiau ,
we lose o u r motivation t o develop as a critical thinker. A s a d
o g m a t i c a r s o i ,
we end u p following wherever o u r "faith " l e a d s us. A s a
subjective relati
will come t o believe that everyone automatically a c q u i r e s
"his o r her ov l
3 6 CHAPTER 2
in s o m e inexplicable subjective way. In b o t h cases, t h e r e
is n o real p l a c e for the
intellectual work a n d discipline of critical thinking. Both
render critical thinking
s u p e r f l u o u s and free us from any intellectual
responsibility. "
If w e avoid these traps, if we recognize how we have been
shaped bv forces
beyond o u r control, if we discover that skills are available to
help us t a k e charge
of o u r m i n d s , if we develop s o m e initial confidence in
reason, if we d e v e l o p some
intellectual humility and perseverance, we are ready t o begin
creating a genuine
f o u n d a t i o n on which we can rebuild o u r identity a n d
character as t h i n k e r s and
20. p e r s o n s of integrity.
T h e key question is how? H o w exactly c a n we d o this? We
shall f o c u s on this
q u e s t i o n f o r the rest of this c h a p t e r . In a sense, it is
the m o s t vital g o a l of the
entire b o o k .
2.6,2.7 Think for Yourself
D I S C U S S A B S O L U T I S M A N D SUBJECTIVE
RELATIVISM
Work in groups of three. The person whose first name is second
in the alphabet will explain the distinction between absolutism
and subjective relativism to the other two,
answering any questions they might have. Then the other two in
the group will add any features
the first student missed and elaborate on the points they think
are most important
B E G I N N I N G T O D E V E L O P A S A T H I N K E R
Make a list of some things you can do to begin your
development as a disciplined thinker. Review Chapter I for
ideas. Then answer this question: What do you think the
benefits
would be if you were to take this list seriously?
STAGE 4: THE PRACTICING THINKER
G o o d t h i n k i n g c a n b e p r a c t i c e d l i k e b a s k e t b
a l l , t e n n i s , o r b a l l e t . T h e o n l y w a y t o
m o v e f r o m Beginning T h i n k e r t o P r a c t i c i n g T h i
n k e r is t o c o m m i t yourself t o daily
practice in thinking well and design your o w n plan for
practice. When you d o so,
21. you become what we call a P r a c t i c i n g Thinker.
There are many ways t o design practice regimens, s o m e b e t
t e r than o t h e r s for
you. For example, you might g l a n c e t h r o u g h some of t h
e o t h e r c h a p t e r s of this
b o o k . E a c h provides suggestions f o r improving your t h i
n k i n g . You can use any of
these suggestions as a starting p o i n t .
You m i g h t review the T h i n k f o r Yourself activities. You
m i g h t study the ele-
m e n t s of t h o u g h t , t h e s t a n d a r d s f o r t h o u g h t ,
and t h e t r a i t s of mind. You might
analyze C h a p t e r 10, o n problem-solving, a n d C h a p t e r
17, o n strategic thinking.
T h i n k of it this way: Everything y o u read in this b o o k r e
p r e s e n t s a resource for
you t o use in devising a systematic p l a n for i m p r o v i n g y
o u r t h i n k i n g . As you move
T U B F I R S T F i n R S T A C E S OF D I V K U H ' M E N T
through the b o o k , routinely ask yourself: What am I learning
in this section or
chapter that I can actively incorporate into daily practice?
If you are like m o s t people, you can discover some practical
starting pomts.
T h e challenge will be in following t h r o u g h on any that you
find. This is the chal-
lenge in most areas of skill development: People do n o t
usually follow through.
They do n o t establish habits of regular practice. They are
22. discouraged by the
strain and a w k w a r d n e s s of early a t t e m p t s t o
perform well.
To develop as a thinker, you m u s t work o u t a plan that will
work for you, one
you can live with, o n e that won't b u r n you o u t or
overwhelm you. Ultimately, suc-
cess comes t o those w h o are persistent and w h o figure o u t
strategies for themselves.
Still, at this stage, you probably don't know for sure what will
work for you,
only what seems like it might. You have to field-test your ideas.
To be realistic, you
should expect to experiment with a variety of plans before you
find one that moves
you forward as a thinker.
G u a r d against discouragement. You can best avoid
discouragement by rec-
ognizing f r o m the outset that you are engaged in a process of
trial and error.
Prepare yourself for temporary failure. Understand success as
the willingness to
work through a variety of relative failures. The logic is
analogous to trying on
clothes. M a n y that you try might n o t fit o r look good on
you, but you plod on
anyway with the confidence that eventually you will find
something that iits and
l o o k s good o n you.
Consider another analogy: If you want t o become skilled at
tennis, you im-
prove not by expecting yourself t o begin as a n expert player, t
23. o win every game
you play, or by mastering new strokes with little practice.
Rather, you improve
when you develop a plan you can modify as you see what
improves your game.
Today, you might decide to work on keeping your eye on the
ball. Tomorrow-, you
might coordinate watching the ball with following t h r o u g h
as you swing. Every
day, you rethink your strategies for improvement. Development
of the h u m a n
m i n d is parallel to the development of the h u m a n body. G o
o d theory, good prac-
tice, and good feedback are essential.
A "GAME PLAN" FOR IMPROVEMENT
AS you begin to take your thinking seriously, think a b o u t
what you can do consistently t o improve your thinking.
Because excellence in t h i n k i n g requires a variety of
independent skills and t r a i t s that w o r k together, you
can choose t o work on a range of critical t h i n k i n g skills at
any given point m time.
T h e key is t o focus on fundamentals and m a k e sure you
don't try t o do t o o m u c h .
Choose your point of attack, but limit it. If you overdo it, you
probably will give
u p entirely, b u t if you d o n ' t focus on fundamentals, you
will never have t h e m as a
foundation in your thought.
Start slowly and emphasize f u n d a m e n t a l s . The race is w
o n by the t o r t o i s e ,
n o t by the hare. Be a wise turtle. The solid, steady steps you t
a k e every day will
determine where you ultimately end up.
24. C H A P T E R 2
A GAME PLAN FOR )EVISING E PL N
We have put together a few ideas to stimulate your thought
about a gan plan. There is nothing magical a b o u t o u r ideas;
no one of them is essei tial. Nevertheless, each represents a
plausible point of attack, o n e wa
to begin to d o something plausible to improve thinking in a
regular way. A l t h o u g
you probably can't do all of these at the same time, we
recommend an a p p r o a c
in which you experiment with all of them. You can add any
others you find in th
b o o k or come u p with yourself. A f t e r you familiarize
yourself with some of th
options, we explain how this game plan works.
1. Use "wasted" time. All h u m a n s waste s o m e time. N o o
n e uses all of his or he
time productively or even pleasurably. Sometimes we j u m p
from one diversion t
a n o t h e r without enjoying any of them or b e c o m e
irritated about matters beyon
o u r control. Sometimes we fail t o plan well, causing negative
consequences thr
we easily could have avoided such as spending time
unnecessarily trapped in trafifi
a l t h o u g h we could have left a half hour earlier and avoided
the rush. Sometime
we worry unproductively, spend time regretting what is past, or
j u s t stare b l a n k l
into space.
25. T h e key is that the time is "spent," and if we had thought
about it and considere
our options, we would n o t have deliberately spent our time in
that way. So o u r ide
is this: Take advantage of the time you normally waste by
practicing good t h i n k i n
during that interval. For example, instead of sitting in front of
the TV at the end o
the day, flicking from channel to channel in a vain search for a
program worth watch
ing, spend that time, or at least part of it, thinking back over
your day and eval uatin
your strengths and weaknesses. You might ask yourself
questions like these:
• When did I d o my w o r s t thinking today?
• When did I do my best thinking?
• W h a t did I actually t h i n k about today?
• Did I figure out anything?
• Did I allow any negative thinking to f r u s t r a t e me
unnecessarily?
• If I had to repeat today, what would I do differently? Why?
• Did I do anything t o d a y to further my long-term goals?
• Did I act in accordance with my own expressed values?
• If I were to spend every day this way for 10 years, would I, at
the e n d , h a v e
accomplished something worthy of that time?
Taking a little time with each question is i m p o r t a n t . It
would be useful to r e v i e
these questions periodically, perhaps weekly, t o write your
answers in a j o u r n a
and, in so doing, keep a record of how your t h i n k i n g is
developing.
26. 2. Handle a problem a day. At the beginning of each day
(perhaps driving t o worl
or going to school), choose a problem to work on when you
have free m o m e n t s
Figure out the logic of the problem by identifying its elements.
Systematically thinl
T H E FI K S T FO U R ST A G E S OF DFAP.OI-.MENT
through the questions: What exactly is the problem? How can I
put it into the form
of a question? (See C h a p t e r 10 for a template you might
use.)
3. Internalize intellectual standards. Each week, study and
actively bring into
your thinking one of the universal intellectual standards
presented in Chapter 5.
Focus o n e week on clarity, the next o n accuracy, and so on.
For example, if you are
focusing on clarity for the week, try t o notice when you are
being unclear in com-
municating with others. Notice when others are unclear in what
they are saying.
When you read, notice whether you are clear a b o u t what you
are reading. When
you write a paragraph for class, ask yourself whether you are
clear about what you
are trying to say and in conveying your t h o u g h t s in writing.
In d o i n g this, you will practice f o u r techniques of
clarification: (1) stating
what you are saying with some c o n s i d e r a t i o n given to y
o u r choice of words,
27. (2) elaborating on your meaning in o t h e r words, (3) giving
examples of w h a t
you m e a n from experiences you have h a d , and (4) using
analogies, metaphors,
pictures, or d i a g r a m s t o illustrate what you m e a n . In
clarifying thinking, you
should state, elaborate, illustrate, a n d exemplify your points,
and you will regu-
larly ask others t o d o the same.
4. Keep an intellectual journal. Each week, write o u t a certain
number of journal
entries. U s e the following f o r m a t for each important event
you write about:
• Describe only situations that are emotionally significant t o
you (situations you
care deeply about).
• Describe only o n e situation at a time.
• Describe (and keep this separate) how you behaved in the
situation, being
specific and exact. (What did you say? What did you do? How
did you react?)
• Analyze, in the light of what you have written, what precisely
was going on in
the situation; dig beneath the surface.
• Assess the implications of your analysis. (What did you learn
about yourself?
What would you do differently if you could relive the
situation?)
5. Practice intellectual strategies. C h o o s e a strategy f r o m
28. Chapter 16 on s t r a -
tegic thinking. While using that strategy, record your
observations in a j o u r n a l ,
including what you are learning about yourself a n d how you
can use the strategy
to improve your thinking.
6. Reshape your character. Each m o n t h , choose one
intellectual trait to strive
for. tocusing on how you can develop that trait in yourself. For
example, if c o n -
centrating on intellectual humility, begin t o notice when you
admit you are w r o n g .
Notice when you refuse to admit you are wrong, even in the
face of glaring evi-
dence that you are truly wrong. Notice when you become
defensive when a n o t h e r
person tries to point out a deficiency in your work or your
thinking. Notice w h e n
your arrogance keeps you f r o m learning, when you say to
yourself, tor example,
"1 already know everything 1 need t o know a b o u t this
subject " or, "1 know a s
much as h e does. W h o does he think he is. forcing his
opinions onto m e ? "
o CHAPTER 2
7. Deal with your ego. Daily, begin t o observe your egocentric
thinking in action
by c o n t e m p l a t i n g questions like these: As I reflect u p o
n my behavior today, did
I ever become irritable over small things? Did 1 d o or say
anything irrational t o get
29. my way? Did I try to impose my will upon others? Did I ever
fail to speak my mind
when I felt strongly about something and then later feel
resentment?
O n c e you identify egocentric thinking in o p e r a t i o n , you
can work to replace it
with m o r e rational thought through systematic reflection.
What would a rational
person feel in this or that situation? What would a rational
person do? How does
that c o m p a r e with what you did? (Hint: If you find that you
continually conclude
that a rational person w o u l d behave just as you behaved, you
probably are en-
gaging in self-deception.) (See C h a p t e r II for more ways to
identify egocentric
thinking.)
8. Redefine the way you see things. We live in a world, both
personal and social,
in which every situation is defined; it is given a f u n d a m e n t
a l meaning. How a situ-
ation is defined determines how we feel about it, how we act in
it, and what im-
plications it has for us. Virtually every situation, however, can
be defined in m o r e
than o n e way. T h i s fact carries with it tremendous
opportunities for all of us to
make o u r life m o r e of what we want it to be. In principle, it
lies within your power
to m a k e your life much h a p p i e r and more fulfilling than it
is.
M a n y of the negative definitions we apply to situations in our
lives could, in
30. principle, be transformed into positive definitions. As a result,
we can gain when
otherwise we would have lost. We can be happy when otherwise
we would have
been sad. We can be fulfilled when otherwise we would have
been f r u s t r a t e d . In
this g a m e plan, we practice redefining the way we see things,
turning negatives into
positives, dead-ends into new beginnings, mistakes into
opportunities to learn. Fo
make this game plan practical, we should create some specific
guidelines for o u r -
selves. For example, we might make ourselves a list of five to
ten recurring negative
situations in which we feel frustrated, angry, unhappy, or
worried. We then c o u l d
identify the definition in each case that is at the root of the
negative e m o t i o n .
Next, we would choose a plausible alternative definition for
each and plan for o u r
new responses as well as o u r new emotions.
Suppose you have a roommate w h o gets on your nerves by
continually telling
you a b o u t all the insignificant events in his or her life. Your
present definition of
the situation is, "What a bore! How am I going t o last a whole
semester listening to
that brainless soap opera?" Your response might be: "Since I
have to d o a required
research project for my introduction to psychology class, I will
focus my project on
the psychology of my roommate." Now, instead of passively
listening to the daily
blow-by-blow description of your roommate s day, you actively
question him o r her
31. to gather information you can use in your psychology paper.
Because you are now
directing the conversation, your roommate is not able to bore
you with the details
of his or her day, and you transform your interactions into a
learning experience.
A n o t h e r possibility is to redefine an "impossibly difficult
class" into a "chal-
lenge to figure out new fundamental concepts and a new way of
thinking." For
example: You redefine your initial approach to a member of the
other sex not in
terms of the definition, "His/her response will determine
whether I am an attractive
T u t : F I R S T F O U R S T A C K S O F D E V E L O P M E
N T
person," but, instead, in terms of the definition, "Let me test to
see if this person is
initially drawn t o me, given the way he or she perceives me."
With the first definition in m i n d , you feel personally p u t
down if the person
is not interested in you. With the second definition, you
explicitly recognize that
people initially respond not to the way a stranger is but, rather,
to the way the per-
son subjectively looks to the other. You therefore do not
perceive someone's failure
to show interest in you as a defect in you.
9. Get in touch with your emotions. Whenever you feel some
32. negative e m o t i o n ,
systematically ask yourself, " W h a t , exactly, is the t h i n k i
n g that leads t o this
emotion? H o w might this thinking be flawed? What a m I
assuming? Should I be
making these a s s u m p t i o n s ? What i n f o r m a t i o n is
my t h i n k i n g based on? Is t h a t
i n f o r m a t i o n reliable?" a n d so on. (See Chapters 3 and
16.)
10. Analyze group influences on your life. Closely analyze t h e
behavior that is e n -
couraged a n d discouraged in the g r o u p s to which you
belong. For a given g r o u p ,
what are you required or expected t o believe? What are you " f
o r b i d d e n " to d o ?
If you conclude that your group does not require you t o believe
anything or h a s
no taboos, you c a n conclude that you have not deeply analyzed
that group. T o
gain insight into the process of socialization a n d g r o u p
membership, review a n
introductory text in sociology. (See C h a p t e r 11.)
Integrating Strategies One by One
When designing strategies, the key point is to engage in an
experiment. You are t e s t -
ing strategies in your personal life, integrating them, and
building on them in light o f
your actual experience. All strategies have advantages and
disadvantages. One p l a u -
sible way to do this is to work with all the strategies on the
following list in any order.
1. Use "wasted" time.
2. Handle a problem a day.
33. 3. Internalize intellectual standards.
4. Keep an intellectual j o u r n a l .
5. Practice intellectual strategies.
6. Reshape your character.
7. Deal with your ego.
8. Redefine the way you see things.
9. Get in touch with your emotions.
10. Analyze g r o u p infiuences on your life.
As you design strategies to improve the quality of your iife,
suppose you find
the strategy "Redefine the way you see things" to be intuitive t
o you. Therefore, it's
a good strategy to begin with. A s you focus intently on this
idea and apply it in y o u r
life, you begin to notice social definitions within groups. You
begin t o recognize
12 C H A P T E R 2
how your behavior is shaped and controlled by g r o u p
definitions. You begin to see
how you a n d others uncritically accept group d e f i n i t i o n
s rather than creating your
own definitions. Notice the definitions embedded in the
following statements.
1. " T m giving a party"
2. "We're going t o have a meeting."
3. "Why don't you run for electionf
4. " T h e funeral is Tuesday."
5. "Jack is an acquaintance, n o t really a friend."
34. When you internalize this idea, you begin to see how important
and pervasive
social definitions are. When you more insightful a b o u t social
definitions, you can
redefine situations in ways t h a t run contrary to c o m m o n l
y accepted social defi-
nitions. You then see how redefining situations a n d
relationships enables you to
"get in t o u c h with your emotions." You recognize t h a t the
way you define things
generates the emotions you feel. When you think y o u are
threatened (you define
a situation as "threatening"), you feel fear. On the o n e hand, if
you define a situ-
ation as a "failure," you might feel depressed. On t h e other
hand, if you define
that same situation as " a lesson o r an o p p o r t u n i t y t o
learn," you feel empowered
to learn. When you recognize the control you are capable of
exercising, the two
strategies begin to work together and reinforce e a c h other.
You then might begin to integrate Strategy 10 ("Analyze group
influences on
your life") with the two strategies you have already
internalized. One of the main
ways in which groups control us is by controlling t h e
definitions they allow us to
use. When a group defines some things as "cool" a n d some as
"dumb," members
of the g r o u p try to a p p e a r " c o o l " and n o t " d u m b . "
When the boss of a business
says, " T h a t makes a lot of sense," his subordinates know they
are not to say, "No,
it is ridiculous." They know this because defining s o m e o n e
as the " b o s s " gives him
35. or her special privileges to define situations and relationships.
As a developing
thinker, you begin to decide which groups you allow to
influence your thinking
and which group influences you reject.
You now have three interwoven strategies: You "redefine the
way you see
things," "get in touch with your emotions," and "analyze group
influences on your
life." The three strategies are integrated into one. A t this point,
you can experi-
ment with any of the o t h e r strategies (which follow), looking
for opportunities to
integrate them into your thinking and your life.
• Use wasted time.
• Handle a problem a day.
• Internalize intellectual standards.
• Keep an intellectual j o u r n a l .
• Practice intellectual strategies.
• Reshape your character.
• Deal with your ego.
CRITICAL
THINKING
T O O L S F O R T A K I N G C H A R G E O F
y 0 l l R L E A R N I N G A N D Y O U R L I F E
T H I R D e d i t i o n
Richard Paul
36. Foundation for Critical Thinking
Linda Elder
Foundat ion for Critical Thinking
PEARSON
Boston Columbus Indianapolis New York San Francisco Upper
Saddle River
Amsterdam Cape Town Dubai London Madrid Milan Munich
Paris Montreal Toronto
Delhi Mexico City Sao Paulo Sydney H o n g Kong Seoul
Singapore Taipei T o k y o
C H A P T E H 2
EXHIBIT 2.1 Most people have lived their entire lives as
unreflective thinkers.
To develop as thinkers requires commitment to daily practice.
S T A G E S OF C R I T I C A L T H I N K I N G D E V E L O
P M E N T
/
Accomplished Thinker
(Intellectual skills
and virtues have
become second
nature in our lives)
37. /
Advanced Thinker
( W e are committed to lifelong
practice and are beginning to
internalize intellectual virtues)
/
Practicing Thinker
( W e regularly practice a n d
advance accordingly)
/
Beginning Thinker
(We try to improve but
without regular practice)
/
Challenged Thinker
(We are faced with significant
problems in our thinking)
Unreflective Thinker
( W e are unaware of significant
problems in our thinking)
If we aspire to develop as thinkers, the stages all of us go
through are:
Stage 1 T h e Unreflective Thinker (we are unaware of
significant problems in
o u r thinking)
38. Stage 2 T h e Challenged Thinker (we become aware of
problems in our
thinking)
Stage 3 T h e Beginning Thinker (we try t o improve but w i t h
o u t regular
practice)
Stage 4 T h e Practicing Thinker (we recognize the necessity of
regular practice)
Stage 5 T h e Advanced Thinker (we advance in accordance
with o u r practice)
Stage 6 T h e Accomplished Thinker (skilled and insightful
thinking become
second nature to us)
STAGE 1: THE UNREFLECTIVE THINKER
Are you an unreflective thinker? We all are born—and most of
us die—as largely
unreflective thinkers, fundamentally unaware of the role that
thinking is playing in
o u r lives. At this Unreflective Thinker stage, we have n o
useful conception of what
t h i n k i n g entails. For example, as unreflective thinkers, we
don't notice that we
are continually m a k i n g assumptions, f o r m i n g concepts,
drawing inferences, and
t h i n k i n g within points of view. At this stage, we don't
know how to analyze and
assess o u r thinking. We don't know how to determine whether
o u r p u r p o s e s are
clearly formulated, o u r assumptions justified, our conclusions
39. logically drawn. We
are unaware of intellectual traits and so are not striving to e m b
o d y them.
At this stage, many problems in our lives are caused by p o o r
thinking, but
we are unaware of this. We don't question o u r beliefs or our
decisions. We lack
intellectual standards a n d have no idea what such standards m
i g h t be. We lack the
intellectual traits but are not aware that we lack them. We
unconsciously deceive
ourselves in many ways. We create and maintain pleasant
illusions. Because our
beliefs seem reasonable t o us, we believe them with
confidence. We walk a b o u t the
world with confidence that things really are the way they appear
to us. We judge
s o m e people to be " g o o d " and some to be " b a d . " We
approve of some actions and
disapprove of others. We make decisions, react to people, go o
u r way in life, and
d o not seriously question our thinking or its implications.
Although we don't realize it, our egocentric tendencies at this
stage play a
dominant role in o u r thinking. We lack t h e skills a n d the
motivation to notice
h o w self-centered and prejudiced we are, h o w often we
stereotype others, how fre-
quently we dismiss ideas irrationally simply because we don't w
a n t to c h a n g e o u r
behavior or our comfortable way of looking at things.
2.1 Think for Yours ̂
REFLECTING O N YOUR K N O W L E D G E OF T H I N K I
40. N G
M ight you be at the Unreflective Thinker stage of
development? Test yourself by writing your answers to the
following:
I. Describe the role that thinking is playing in your life. ( B e as
clear and as detailed as
you can.)
2 What was a recent assumption you made that you should not
have made?
3 What is a concept you recently formed that y o u previously
lacked?
4 List five inferences you made in the past hour.
5 Name and explain a point of view you sometimes use to guide
your thinking.
6, Briefly describe how you analyze and assess thinking.
Name some intellectual standards you use. Explain how y o u
apply them.
8. Explain the role of egocentric thinking in your life.
9. Explain what you are doing to try to embody one or two of
the intellectual traits.
If you h a d t r o u b l e with your responses in the T h i n k for
Yourself exercise
y o u may well be at t h e Unreflective T h i n k e r stage. If so,
you d o not need to
'apologize o r feel badly about it; most people are at this stage
and don't know
it. T r a d i t i o n a l s c h o o l i n g and t h e way children
typically are reared do not help
p e o p l e to b e c o m e skilled thinkers. O f t e n , parents a n
41. d teachers themselves are
unreflective thinkers. T h i s is the product of a vicious circle.
Unreflective per-
s o n s raise unreflective persons. O n c e you explicitly
recognize that you are at
this stage, however, you are ready to move to the next stage.
And when you
m o v e to the next stage, you may be close to breaking o u t of
the vicious cycle of
unreflectiveness. To d o so requires that we become honestly
reflective—that we
begin to notice some problems in o u r thinking, that we begin
to recognize that
o u r t h i n k i n g is o f t e n egocentric a n d irrational, that c
h a n g e s in o u r own t h i n k i n g
are essential.
Honest reflectiveness leads t o healthy motivation to change. It
is f u n c t i o n a l
a n d productive. You m u s t not only see problems in y o u r
thinking but also have
s o m e sense of how you might a d d r e s s those problems.
You must become rea-
sonably articulate a b o u t what you have to d o to improve.
Motivation is c r u c i a l .
W i t h o u t a drive to change, nothing much of significance
will h a p p e n .
STAGE 2: T H E C H A L L E N G E D THINKER
Are you ready to accept the challenge? We c a n n o t solve a
problem we d o not own
or deal with a condition we deny. W i t h o u t knowledge of o u
r ignorance, we c a n n o t
seek the knowledge we lack. Without knowledge of the skills
we need t o develop,
we will not develop them.
42. As we become aware that " n o r m a l " thinkers often think
poorly, we move i n t o
the second stage of critical thinking development, the
Challenged Thinker. We
begin to notice that we often
• make questionable assumptions;
m use false, incomplete, or misleading information;
• make inferences that d o not follow from the evidence we
have;
• fail to recognize important implications in our thought;
• fail to recognize problems we have;
• form faulty concepts;
• reason within prejudiced points of view; a n d
• think egocentrically and irrationally.
We move to the Challenged T h i n k e r stage when we become
a w a r e of t h e
way our thinking is shaping our lives, including the recognition
t h a t p r o b l e m s in
our thinking are causing problems in o u r lives. We begin to
recognize t h a t p o o r
thinking can be life-threatening, that it can lead literally to
death or p e r m a n e n t
T H E F I R S T F O U R S T A K E S o r D E V E L O P M E N
T
injury, t h a t it can h u r t others as well as ourselves. For
example, we might reflect
upon the t h i n k i n g of
• the teenager w h o thinks that smoking is sexy;
43. • the w o m a n w h o thinks that P a p smears are not important;
• the motorcyclist who r e a s o n s t h a t helmets o b s t r u c t
vision and, therefore,
riding w i t h o u t o n e is s a f e r ;
• the person w h o thinks he can drive safely while d r u n k ;
• the person w h o decides t o marry a self-centered person with
the t h o u g h t that
he or she will "change" a f t e r marriage.
We also recognize the difficulty involved in "improving" o u r
thinking. If you
are at this stage in your own thinking, you recognize that the
problem of changing
your habits of t h o u g h t is an i m p o r t a n t challenge
requiring extensive a n d difficult
changes in your n o r m a l routines.
Some signs of emerging reflectiveness are that
• you f i n d yourself striving t o analyze and assess
your.thinking;
• you find yourself working with the structures of mind that
create, or m a k e
possible, thinking (for example: concepts, assumptions,
inferences, implications,
points of view);
• you f i n d yourself thinking about the qualities t h a t make
thinking s o u n d —
clarity, accuracy, precision, relevance, logicalness—even
though you may
have only an initial grasp of how to achieve these qualities;
44. • you find yourself becoming interested in the role of self-
deception in thinking,
even though your understanding is relatively "abstract," a n d
you may not be
able t o offer many examples from your own life.
At this point in your development self-deception is a distinct
danger. M a n y resist
accepting the true nature of the challenge: that their own
thinking is a real and sig-
nificant problem in their life. If you do as many do, you will
revert to the Unreflective
Thinker stage. Your experience of thinking about your thinking
will fade, and your
usual habits of thought will remain as they are. For example,
you may find yourself
rationalizing in the following way: " My thinking is n o t that
bad. Actually, I've been
thinking well for quite a while. I question a lot of things. I'm
not prejudiced. Besides
that, I'm very critical. And I'm not nearly as self-deceived as
lots of people I know."
If you reason in this way, you are not alone; you're in the
majority. T h i s
view—"If everyone were t o think like me, this would be a fine
world"—is the
dominant one. Those who s h a r e this view range f r o m the
poorly schooled to the
highly schooled. There is no evidence to suggest that schooling
correlates with self-
reflectiveness. Indeed, many college graduates are intellectually
arrogant because of
their schooling. Unreflective people are found in all
socioeconomic classes and in-
clude psychologists, sociologists, philosophers, mathematicians,
45. doctors, senators,
judges, governors, district attorneys, lawyers, and. indeed,
people of all professions.
C H A P T E R 2
In short, absence of intellectual humility is c o m m o n a m o n
g all classes of peo-
ple in all w a l k s of life at all ages. It follows t h a t active o r
passive resistance t o the
challenge of critical t h i n k i n g is t h e c o m m o n rather t h
a n the rare case. W h e t h e r in
t h e form of a careless s h r u g or o u t r i g h t hostility, most
people reject the challenge
of critical t h i n k i n g . T h a t is why s o m e soul-searching
is i m p o r t a n t at this p o i n t in
t h e process.
.3 Think for Yourself
THE CHALLENGED THINKER STAGE
Work in groups of three. The person whose first name is earliest
in the alphabet will explain the second stage, that of the
Challenged Thinker, to the other two. answering
any questions they might have. Then the other two in the group
will add any features the first
student missed and elaborate on the points they think are most
important.
T O IDENTIFY PROBLEMS IN Y O U R T H I N K 1 N G
See whether you can identify any problems in your thinking.
The best way to do this is to analyze a behavior of yours that
somehow is creating problems, either for you or for
46. others. Look at your personal relationships, your study habits,
your interaction patterns.
How do you behave when you are upset? How do you act when
you don't get your way? Do
you expect more of others than you expect of yourself?
Consider these questions as start-
ing points for challenging yourself as a thinker. If you cannot
identify any problems in your
thinking, think again.
STAGE 3: THE BEGINNING THINKER
Are you willing to begin? When a p e r s o n actively decides t o
take u p the c h a l l e n g e
to grow and d e v e l o p as a thinker, h e o r she enters the
stage we call the B e g i n n i n g
Thinker. In t h i s stage of thinking, we begin to take t h i n k i
n g seriously. T h i s s t a g e
prepares us f o r t h e next stages, w i t h the u l t i m a t e goal
of explicit c o m m a n d of
thinking. It is a stage of dawning realizations and of d e v e l o
p i n g will p o w e r . It
is n o t a stage of self-condemnation b u t , rather, of e m e r g i
n g consciousness. It is
a n a l o g o u s t o t h e stage in which p e o p l e who are
alcoholics recognize and fully a c -
cept the fact t h a t they are alcoholics. I m a g i n e a n
alcoholic saying, "I am a n a l c o -
holic, a n d onlv I c a n d o s o m e t h i n g a b o u t it." N o w
imagine yourself saying, " I a m
a w e a k , undisciplined thinker, and o n l y I c a n d o s o m e t
h i n g a b o u t it."
Once p e o p l e recognize that t h e y a r e " a d d i c t e d " t o
p o o r t h i n k i n g , they m u s t
begin t o recognize the d e p t h and n a t u r e of t h e problem.
If w e are at the B e g i n n i n g
47. T h i n k e r stage' we should recognize t h a t our t h i n k i n g
is s o m e t i m e s egocentric. F o r
example, we m a y notice how little w e c o n s i d e r the needs
of o t h e r s a n d h o w m u c h
we focus on g e t t i n g what we personally w a n t . We may n
o t i c e h o w little we e n t e r
the point of view of o t h e r s and h o w m u c h we assume t h
e " c o r r e c t n e s s " of o u r
. thers to S
o w n . W e m a y e v e n s o m e t i m e s catch ourselves trying
t o dominate ( ,- o r tr.c
w h a t w e w a n t or. a l t e r n a t i v e l y , acting out t h e
role of submitting t o o t t i e 0 w"ttich
g a m s t h a t s u b m i s s i v e b e h a v i o r brings). We may
begin to notice t h e extern i
we c o n l o r m u n c r i t i c a l l y t o the thinking of others.
A s t h i n k e r s t h i n k i n g a b o u t thinking, we a r e
merely beginning to
• a n a l y z e the l o g i c of s i t u a t i o n s and problems;
• e x p r e s s clear a n d precise questions;
• c h e c k i n f o r m a t i o n f o r accuracy and relevance; ^
• d i s t i n g u i s h b e t w e e n raw information a n d s o m e o
n e ' s interpretation o 1 <
• r e c o g n i z e a s s u m p t i o n s guiding inferences: ^
• i d e n t i f y p r e j u d i c i a l a n d biased beliefs,
unjustifiable conclusions, misuse
w o r d s , a n d m i s s e d implications;
• n o t i c e when o u r viewpoint is biased by o u r selfish
interests. _
48. T h u s , as B e g i n n i n g T h i n k e r s , we are b e c o m i n
g a w a r e of h o w t o d e a l A V J ^
s t r u c t u r e s at work in t h o u g h t (purposes, q u e s t i o n
s , i n f o r m a t i o n , i n t e r p - ^ ^
etc.). We are b e g i n n i n g t o appreciate the value of
examining o u r t h i n king
of its clarity, accuracy, relevance, precision, logicalness.,
justifiability, ^
d e p t h , a n d fairness, but w e are still at a low level of
proficiency in these: ^
T h e y f e e l a w k w a r d t o us. We have t o force ourselves t
o think in discipnn ^
We a r e like beginners in ballet. We feel foolish a d o p t i n g
the b a s i c posi e V t o
d o n ' t lee! graceful; we s t u m b l e a n d make mistakes. N o
o n e would pay
watch us perform. We ourselves d o n ' t like w h a t we see in
the m i r r o r ot o ^ m U S t
T o reach this B e g i n n i n g T h i n k e r stage, o u r values m
u s t begin t o shitt. h i l l |
expl< the f o u n d a t i o n of o u r t h i n k i n g and discover h
o w we have c o m e ^
a n d believe as we do. Let us consider this goal in a little more
d e t a i l . K e ' .
o n s o m e of the m a j o r infiuences t h a t have s h a p e d
your t h i n k i n g ( a n d OU )•
1. You were born into a culture (e.g., European, American,
African, Asian).
2. You were born at s o m e point in time (in s o m e c e n t u r
y in s o m e year).
3. You were born in s o m e place (in t h e c o u n t r y , in the
city, in t h e North or
49. South. East or West). , , t
4. You were raised by p a r e n t s with p a r t i c u l a r beliefs (
a b o u t t h e f a m i l y - * ^
personal relationships, a b o u t marriage, a b o u t c h i l d h o
o d , a b o u t obe<
about religion, about politics, a b o u t s c h o o l i n g ) .
5. "You tormed various a s s o c i a t i o n s (largely b a s e d o
n w h o was a r o u n d y o u
associations with people with a viewpoint, values, a n d taboos).
old
1 you were to change a n y one of these i n f i u e n c e s , y o u
r belief s y s t e ™ fieids
b e different. Suppose vou h a d been b o r n in t h e M i d d l e
A g e s as a ser 1 in r e i '
of France. Can you see that if you were, virtually all y o u r
beliefs w o u l d be ^ &
See whether you can p e r f o r m similar reflective e x p e r i m
e n t s of y o u r
ample, imagine other changes in these influences a n d t h e n
imaginative
some of t h e beliefs you likely w o u l d have with the b e l i e f
s you actually d o have. You
will begin t o a p p r e c i a t e how m u c h you, a n d every o t
h e r h u m a n , are a p r o d u c t o f
influences over which you. a n d they, had little or n o c o n t r
o l . Neither y o u n o r they
directed t h e s e influences. Their effects, clearly, were b o t h
g o o d and b a d .
For e x a m p l e , a s s u m e that m a n y of these influences e
50. n g e n d e r e d false beliefs in
us. It follows that o u r minds r i g h t now h a r b o r false
beliefs, a n d we a r e acting o n
t h e m . Yet, notice t h a t the mind h a s no mechanism f o r
screening out false beliefs.
We all c a r r y a r o u n d in our m i n d s prejudices from o u r
culture, f r o m where we were
b o r n and raised, f r o m o u r p a r e n t s , and f r o m our f r i
e n d s a n d associates. F i n d i n g
ways to l o c a t e those flawed beliefs and replace t h e m with
m o r e reasonable beliefs
is part of t h e a g e n d a of critical thinking. Another way to l
o o k at the forces, ratio-
nal and i r r a t i o n a l , t h a t have s h a p e d our m i n d s is
in t e r m s ot m o d e s of influence."
2 . 4 Think for Yourself
PUT T I N G YOURSELF I N A N O T H E R PLACE IN TIME
Imagine yourself in another place in time. Choose a different
century, perhaps a different
country, a different gender, a different socioeconomic group—
in any case, an altogether dif-
ferent set of circumstances in which you might have lived.
Complete the following:
1. The time within which I am imagining that! live is...
2. The details of the situation are (be specific).. •
3 If I had lived in this place in time. I most likely would hold
the following beliefs (about
religion, my country, sexual conventions and taboos, gender
issues, relationships, people
of different races, etc. Again, be specific)...
For e x a m p l e , we think within a variety of domains:
51. sociological, philosophi-
cal, ethical, intellectual, a n t h r o p o l o g i c a l , ideological,
political, economic, histori-
cal, biological, theological, and psychological. We ended up
with our p a r t i c u l a r
beliefs b e c a u s e we were influenced t o do s o in the
following ways:
• Sociological: O u r minds are i n f l u e n c e d by the social
groups to which we
belong.
• Philosophical: Our minds a r e influenced by o u r personal
philosophy.
• Ethical: O u r m i n d s are influenced by the extent to which
we behave in accor-
dance w i t h our obligations a n d the way we define our
obligations.
• Intellectual: Our minds are i n f l u e n c e d by the ideas we
hold, by the m a n n e r in
which we reason a n d deal w i t h a b s t r a c t i o n s and
abstract systems.
• Anthropological: O u r minds a r e influenced by cultural
practices, mores, a n d
taboos.
• Ideological and political: O u r m i n d s a r e influenced by
the structure of power
and its use by interest groups a r o u n d us.
• E c o n o m i c : O u r m i n d s are i n f l u e n c e d by the e c
52. o n o m i c conditions u n d e r which
w e live.
• H i s t o r i c a l : O u r m i n d s are i n f l u e n c e d by o u r
history and by the way we te
o u r history.
• Biological; Our minds are influenced by o u r biology and
neurology.
• T h e o l o g i c a l : O u r m i n d s are influenced by our
religious beliefs and attitudes.
• P s y c h o l o g i c a l : O u r m i n d s a r e influenced by our
personality a n d personal
psychology.
R e f l e c t i o n s such a s these s h o u l d awaken in us a s e n
s e of how little we really
k n o w a b o u t o u r own minds. W i t h i n each of o u r m i n
d s is a largely u n e x p t
w o r l d , an i n n e r world that has b e e n taking shape f o r t
h e whole ol our lives,
inner world is the most i m p o r t a n t f a c t about us because
it is where we h o -
m i n e s o u r joy a n d f r u s t r a t i o n . It l i m i t s what we
can see a n d imagine It tug S
w h a t we d o see. It c a n drive us crazy. It c a n provide u s
with solace, p e a c ,
tranquility. If we can appreciate t h e s e facts a b o u t us, we
will find the m o t i v
t o take c h a r g e of o u r thinking, t o b e s o m e t h i n g m o
r e t h a n clay m the h a
others, to b e c o m e , in fact, the r u l i n g force in o u r own
lives.
2 . 5 Think for
53. 1 i-UNG T H I N K E R S T A G E .
Work in groups of three. The person whose first name is last in
the alphabet will explain the third stage, that of the Beginning
Thinker, to the other two. answering ai y q u e ^
tions they might have. Then the other two in the group will add
any features the hrs
missed and elaborate on the points they think are most
important.
L e t s n o w consider t w o lurking traps t h a t c a n derail the
b e g i n n i n g t h i n k e r .
Trap # 1: T h e t e m p t a t i o n of dogmatic absolutism^-
believing that ^ u t h i s
acquired n o t through reasoning and i n q u i r y but, rather, t h
r o u g h s o m e p •
t e r m i n e d , nonintellectual f a i t h .
Trap # 2 : The t e m p t a t i o n of subjective relativism—
believing t h a t t h e r e a r e n o
intellectual standards by which t o judge a n y t h i n g a s true o
r false.
B o t h traps promise us easy answers. To a d v a n c e as a b e g
i n n i n g thinker a n d not
fall into o n e o r the other of these t r a p s requires d e v e l o
p i n g confidence in t eas
a way of a c q u i r i n g sound knowledge and i n s i g h t . T h
e t w o traps a r e m i r r o r m g _
of each o t h e r . If we become either a dogmatic absolutist or a
subjective reiau ,
we lose o u r motivation t o develop as a critical thinker. A s a d
o g m a t i c a r s o i ,
we end u p following wherever o u r "faith " l e a d s us. A s a
subjective relati
will come t o believe that everyone automatically a c q u i r e s
54. "his o r her ov l
3 6 CHAPTER 2
in s o m e inexplicable subjective way. In b o t h cases, t h e r e
is n o real p l a c e for the
intellectual work a n d discipline of critical thinking. Both
render critical thinking
s u p e r f l u o u s and free us from any intellectual
responsibility. "
If w e avoid these traps, if we recognize how we have been
shaped bv forces
beyond o u r control, if we discover that skills are available to
help us t a k e charge
of o u r m i n d s , if we develop s o m e initial confidence in
reason, if we d e v e l o p some
intellectual humility and perseverance, we are ready t o begin
creating a genuine
f o u n d a t i o n on which we can rebuild o u r identity a n d
character as t h i n k e r s and
p e r s o n s of integrity.
T h e key question is how? H o w exactly c a n we d o this? We
shall f o c u s on this
q u e s t i o n f o r the rest of this c h a p t e r . In a sense, it is
the m o s t vital g o a l of the
entire b o o k .
2.6,2.7 Think for Yourself
D I S C U S S A B S O L U T I S M A N D SUBJECTIVE
RELATIVISM
55. Work in groups of three. The person whose first name is second
in the alphabet will explain the distinction between absolutism
and subjective relativism to the other two,
answering any questions they might have. Then the other two in
the group will add any features
the first student missed and elaborate on the points they think
are most important
B E G I N N I N G T O D E V E L O P A S A T H I N K E R
Make a list of some things you can do to begin your
development as a disciplined thinker. Review Chapter I for
ideas. Then answer this question: What do you think the
benefits
would be if you were to take this list seriously?
STAGE 4: THE PRACTICING THINKER
G o o d t h i n k i n g c a n b e p r a c t i c e d l i k e b a s k e t b
a l l , t e n n i s , o r b a l l e t . T h e o n l y w a y t o
m o v e f r o m Beginning T h i n k e r t o P r a c t i c i n g T h i
n k e r is t o c o m m i t yourself t o daily
practice in thinking well and design your o w n plan for
practice. When you d o so,
you become what we call a P r a c t i c i n g Thinker.
There are many ways t o design practice regimens, s o m e b e t
t e r than o t h e r s for
you. For example, you might g l a n c e t h r o u g h some of t h
e o t h e r c h a p t e r s of this
b o o k . E a c h provides suggestions f o r improving your t h i
n k i n g . You can use any of
these suggestions as a starting p o i n t .
You m i g h t review the T h i n k f o r Yourself activities. You
m i g h t study the ele-
m e n t s of t h o u g h t , t h e s t a n d a r d s f o r t h o u g h t ,
56. and t h e t r a i t s of mind. You might
analyze C h a p t e r 10, o n problem-solving, a n d C h a p t e r
17, o n strategic thinking.
T h i n k of it this way: Everything y o u read in this b o o k r e
p r e s e n t s a resource for
you t o use in devising a systematic p l a n for i m p r o v i n g y
o u r t h i n k i n g . As you move
T U B F I R S T F i n R S T A C E S OF D I V K U H ' M E N T
through the b o o k , routinely ask yourself: What am I learning
in this section or
chapter that I can actively incorporate into daily practice?
If you are like m o s t people, you can discover some practical
starting pomts.
T h e challenge will be in following t h r o u g h on any that you
find. This is the chal-
lenge in most areas of skill development: People do n o t
usually follow through.
They do n o t establish habits of regular practice. They are
discouraged by the
strain and a w k w a r d n e s s of early a t t e m p t s t o
perform well.
To develop as a thinker, you m u s t work o u t a plan that will
work for you, one
you can live with, o n e that won't b u r n you o u t or
overwhelm you. Ultimately, suc-
cess comes t o those w h o are persistent and w h o figure o u t
strategies for themselves.
Still, at this stage, you probably don't know for sure what will
work for you,
57. only what seems like it might. You have to field-test your ideas.
To be realistic, you
should expect to experiment with a variety of plans before you
find one that moves
you forward as a thinker.
G u a r d against discouragement. You can best avoid
discouragement by rec-
ognizing f r o m the outset that you are engaged in a process of
trial and error.
Prepare yourself for temporary failure. Understand success as
the willingness to
work through a variety of relative failures. The logic is
analogous to trying on
clothes. M a n y that you try might n o t fit o r look good on
you, but you plod on
anyway with the confidence that eventually you will find
something that iits and
l o o k s good o n you.
Consider another analogy: If you want t o become skilled at
tennis, you im-
prove not by expecting yourself t o begin as a n expert player, t
o win every game
you play, or by mastering new strokes with little practice.
Rather, you improve
when you develop a plan you can modify as you see what
improves your game.
Today, you might decide to work on keeping your eye on the
ball. Tomorrow-, you
might coordinate watching the ball with following t h r o u g h
as you swing. Every
day, you rethink your strategies for improvement. Development
of the h u m a n
m i n d is parallel to the development of the h u m a n body. G o
o d theory, good prac-
58. tice, and good feedback are essential.
A "GAME PLAN" FOR IMPROVEMENT
AS you begin to take your thinking seriously, think a b o u t
what you can do consistently t o improve your thinking.
Because excellence in t h i n k i n g requires a variety of
independent skills and t r a i t s that w o r k together, you
can choose t o work on a range of critical t h i n k i n g skills at
any given point m time.
T h e key is t o focus on fundamentals and m a k e sure you
don't try t o do t o o m u c h .
Choose your point of attack, but limit it. If you overdo it, you
probably will give
u p entirely, b u t if you d o n ' t focus on fundamentals, you
will never have t h e m as a
foundation in your thought.
Start slowly and emphasize f u n d a m e n t a l s . The race is w
o n by the t o r t o i s e ,
n o t by the hare. Be a wise turtle. The solid, steady steps you t
a k e every day will
determine where you ultimately end up.
C H A P T E R 2
A GAME PLAN FOR )EVISING E PL N
We have put together a few ideas to stimulate your thought
about a gan plan. There is nothing magical a b o u t o u r ideas;
no one of them is essei tial. Nevertheless, each represents a
plausible point of attack, o n e wa
to begin to d o something plausible to improve thinking in a
regular way. A l t h o u g
59. you probably can't do all of these at the same time, we
recommend an a p p r o a c
in which you experiment with all of them. You can add any
others you find in th
b o o k or come u p with yourself. A f t e r you familiarize
yourself with some of th
options, we explain how this game plan works.
1. Use "wasted" time. All h u m a n s waste s o m e time. N o o
n e uses all of his or he
time productively or even pleasurably. Sometimes we j u m p
from one diversion t
a n o t h e r without enjoying any of them or b e c o m e
irritated about matters beyon
o u r control. Sometimes we fail t o plan well, causing negative
consequences thr
we easily could have avoided such as spending time
unnecessarily trapped in trafifi
a l t h o u g h we could have left a half hour earlier and avoided
the rush. Sometime
we worry unproductively, spend time regretting what is past, or
j u s t stare b l a n k l
into space.
T h e key is that the time is "spent," and if we had thought
about it and considere
our options, we would n o t have deliberately spent our time in
that way. So o u r ide
is this: Take advantage of the time you normally waste by
practicing good t h i n k i n
during that interval. For example, instead of sitting in front of
the TV at the end o
the day, flicking from channel to channel in a vain search for a
program worth watch
ing, spend that time, or at least part of it, thinking back over
your day and eval uatin
60. your strengths and weaknesses. You might ask yourself
questions like these:
• When did I d o my w o r s t thinking today?
• When did I do my best thinking?
• W h a t did I actually t h i n k about today?
• Did I figure out anything?
• Did I allow any negative thinking to f r u s t r a t e me
unnecessarily?
• If I had to repeat today, what would I do differently? Why?
• Did I do anything t o d a y to further my long-term goals?
• Did I act in accordance with my own expressed values?
• If I were to spend every day this way for 10 years, would I, at
the e n d , h a v e
accomplished something worthy of that time?
Taking a little time with each question is i m p o r t a n t . It
would be useful to r e v i e
these questions periodically, perhaps weekly, t o write your
answers in a j o u r n a
and, in so doing, keep a record of how your t h i n k i n g is
developing.
2. Handle a problem a day. At the beginning of each day
(perhaps driving t o worl
or going to school), choose a problem to work on when you
have free m o m e n t s
Figure out the logic of the problem by identifying its elements.
Systematically thinl
T H E FI K S T FO U R ST A G E S OF DFAP.OI-.MENT
through the questions: What exactly is the problem? How can I
put it into the form
61. of a question? (See C h a p t e r 10 for a template you might
use.)
3. Internalize intellectual standards. Each week, study and
actively bring into
your thinking one of the universal intellectual standards
presented in Chapter 5.
Focus o n e week on clarity, the next o n accuracy, and so on.
For example, if you are
focusing on clarity for the week, try t o notice when you are
being unclear in com-
municating with others. Notice when others are unclear in what
they are saying.
When you read, notice whether you are clear a b o u t what you
are reading. When
you write a paragraph for class, ask yourself whether you are
clear about what you
are trying to say and in conveying your t h o u g h t s in writing.
In d o i n g this, you will practice f o u r techniques of
clarification: (1) stating
what you are saying with some c o n s i d e r a t i o n given to y
o u r choice of words,
(2) elaborating on your meaning in o t h e r words, (3) giving
examples of w h a t
you m e a n from experiences you have h a d , and (4) using
analogies, metaphors,
pictures, or d i a g r a m s t o illustrate what you m e a n . In
clarifying thinking, you
should state, elaborate, illustrate, a n d exemplify your points,
and you will regu-
larly ask others t o d o the same.
4. Keep an intellectual journal. Each week, write o u t a certain
number of journal
entries. U s e the following f o r m a t for each important event
62. you write about:
• Describe only situations that are emotionally significant t o
you (situations you
care deeply about).
• Describe only o n e situation at a time.
• Describe (and keep this separate) how you behaved in the
situation, being
specific and exact. (What did you say? What did you do? How
did you react?)
• Analyze, in the light of what you have written, what precisely
was going on in
the situation; dig beneath the surface.
• Assess the implications of your analysis. (What did you learn
about yourself?
What would you do differently if you could relive the
situation?)
5. Practice intellectual strategies. C h o o s e a strategy f r o m
Chapter 16 on s t r a -
tegic thinking. While using that strategy, record your
observations in a j o u r n a l ,
including what you are learning about yourself a n d how you
can use the strategy
to improve your thinking.
6. Reshape your character. Each m o n t h , choose one
intellectual trait to strive
for. tocusing on how you can develop that trait in yourself. For
example, if c o n -
centrating on intellectual humility, begin t o notice when you
admit you are w r o n g .
63. Notice when you refuse to admit you are wrong, even in the
face of glaring evi-
dence that you are truly wrong. Notice when you become
defensive when a n o t h e r
person tries to point out a deficiency in your work or your
thinking. Notice w h e n
your arrogance keeps you f r o m learning, when you say to
yourself, tor example,
"1 already know everything 1 need t o know a b o u t this
subject " or, "1 know a s
much as h e does. W h o does he think he is. forcing his
opinions onto m e ? "
o CHAPTER 2
7. Deal with your ego. Daily, begin t o observe your egocentric
thinking in action
by c o n t e m p l a t i n g questions like these: As I reflect u p o
n my behavior today, did
I ever become irritable over small things? Did 1 d o or say
anything irrational t o get
my way? Did I try to impose my will upon others? Did I ever
fail to speak my mind
when I felt strongly about something and then later feel
resentment?
O n c e you identify egocentric thinking in o p e r a t i o n , you
can work to replace it
with m o r e rational thought through systematic reflection.
What would a rational
person feel in this or that situation? What would a rational
person do? How does
that c o m p a r e with what you did? (Hint: If you find that you
continually conclude
64. that a rational person w o u l d behave just as you behaved, you
probably are en-
gaging in self-deception.) (See C h a p t e r II for more ways to
identify egocentric
thinking.)
8. Redefine the way you see things. We live in a world, both
personal and social,
in which every situation is defined; it is given a f u n d a m e n t
a l meaning. How a situ-
ation is defined determines how we feel about it, how we act in
it, and what im-
plications it has for us. Virtually every situation, however, can
be defined in m o r e
than o n e way. T h i s fact carries with it tremendous
opportunities for all of us to
make o u r life m o r e of what we want it to be. In principle, it
lies within your power
to m a k e your life much h a p p i e r and more fulfilling than it
is.
M a n y of the negative definitions we apply to situations in our
lives could, in
principle, be transformed into positive definitions. As a result,
we can gain when
otherwise we would have lost. We can be happy when otherwise
we would have
been sad. We can be fulfilled when otherwise we would have
been f r u s t r a t e d . In
this g a m e plan, we practice redefining the way we see things,
turning negatives into
positives, dead-ends into new beginnings, mistakes into
opportunities to learn. Fo
make this game plan practical, we should create some specific
guidelines for o u r -
selves. For example, we might make ourselves a list of five to
65. ten recurring negative
situations in which we feel frustrated, angry, unhappy, or
worried. We then c o u l d
identify the definition in each case that is at the root of the
negative e m o t i o n .
Next, we would choose a plausible alternative definition for
each and plan for o u r
new responses as well as o u r new emotions.
Suppose you have a roommate w h o gets on your nerves by
continually telling
you a b o u t all the insignificant events in his or her life. Your
present definition of
the situation is, "What a bore! How am I going t o last a whole
semester listening to
that brainless soap opera?" Your response might be: "Since I
have to d o a required
research project for my introduction to psychology class, I will
focus my project on
the psychology of my roommate." Now, instead of passively
listening to the daily
blow-by-blow description of your roommate s day, you actively
question him o r her
to gather information you can use in your psychology paper.
Because you are now
directing the conversation, your roommate is not able to bore
you with the details
of his or her day, and you transform your interactions into a
learning experience.
A n o t h e r possibility is to redefine an "impossibly difficult
class" into a "chal-
lenge to figure out new fundamental concepts and a new way of
thinking." For
example: You redefine your initial approach to a member of the
other sex not in
66. terms of the definition, "His/her response will determine
whether I am an attractive
T u t : F I R S T F O U R S T A C K S O F D E V E L O P M E
N T
person," but, instead, in terms of the definition, "Let me test to
see if this person is
initially drawn t o me, given the way he or she perceives me."
With the first definition in m i n d , you feel personally p u t
down if the person
is not interested in you. With the second definition, you
explicitly recognize that
people initially respond not to the way a stranger is but, rather,
to the way the per-
son subjectively looks to the other. You therefore do not
perceive someone's failure
to show interest in you as a defect in you.
9. Get in touch with your emotions. Whenever you feel some
negative e m o t i o n ,
systematically ask yourself, " W h a t , exactly, is the t h i n k i
n g that leads t o this
emotion? H o w might this thinking be flawed? What a m I
assuming? Should I be
making these a s s u m p t i o n s ? What i n f o r m a t i o n is
my t h i n k i n g based on? Is t h a t
i n f o r m a t i o n reliable?" a n d so on. (See Chapters 3 and
16.)
10. Analyze group influences on your life. Closely analyze t h e
behavior that is e n -
couraged a n d discouraged in the g r o u p s to which you
67. belong. For a given g r o u p ,
what are you required or expected t o believe? What are you " f
o r b i d d e n " to d o ?
If you conclude that your group does not require you t o believe
anything or h a s
no taboos, you c a n conclude that you have not deeply analyzed
that group. T o
gain insight into the process of socialization a n d g r o u p
membership, review a n
introductory text in sociology. (See C h a p t e r 11.)
Integrating Strategies One by One
When designing strategies, the key point is to engage in an
experiment. You are t e s t -
ing strategies in your personal life, integrating them, and
building on them in light o f
your actual experience. All strategies have advantages and
disadvantages. One p l a u -
sible way to do this is to work with all the strategies on the
following list in any order.
1. Use "wasted" time.
2. Handle a problem a day.
3. Internalize intellectual standards.
4. Keep an intellectual j o u r n a l .
5. Practice intellectual strategies.
6. Reshape your character.
7. Deal with your ego.
8. Redefine the way you see things.
9. Get in touch with your emotions.
10. Analyze g r o u p infiuences on your life.
As you design strategies to improve the quality of your iife,
suppose you find
the strategy "Redefine the way you see things" to be intuitive t
68. o you. Therefore, it's
a good strategy to begin with. A s you focus intently on this
idea and apply it in y o u r
life, you begin to notice social definitions within groups. You
begin t o recognize
12 C H A P T E R 2
how your behavior is shaped and controlled by g r o u p
definitions. You begin to see
how you a n d others uncritically accept group d e f i n i t i o n
s rather than creating your
own definitions. Notice the definitions embedded in the
following statements.
1. " T m giving a party"
2. "We're going t o have a meeting."
3. "Why don't you run for electionf
4. " T h e funeral is Tuesday."
5. "Jack is an acquaintance, n o t really a friend."
When you internalize this idea, you begin to see how important
and pervasive
social definitions are. When you more insightful a b o u t social
definitions, you can
redefine situations in ways t h a t run contrary to c o m m o n l
y accepted social defi-
nitions. You then see how redefining situations a n d
relationships enables you to
"get in t o u c h with your emotions." You recognize t h a t the
way you define things
generates the emotions you feel. When you think y o u are
threatened (you define
a situation as "threatening"), you feel fear. On the o n e hand, if
69. you define a situ-
ation as a "failure," you might feel depressed. On t h e other
hand, if you define
that same situation as " a lesson o r an o p p o r t u n i t y t o
learn," you feel empowered
to learn. When you recognize the control you are capable of
exercising, the two
strategies begin to work together and reinforce e a c h other.
You then might begin to integrate Strategy 10 ("Analyze group
influences on
your life") with the two strategies you have already
internalized. One of the main
ways in which groups control us is by controlling t h e
definitions they allow us to
use. When a group defines some things as "cool" a n d some as
"dumb," members
of the g r o u p try to a p p e a r " c o o l " and n o t " d u m b . "
When the boss of a business
says, " T h a t makes a lot of sense," his subordinates know they
are not to say, "No,
it is ridiculous." They know this because defining s o m e o n e
as the " b o s s " gives him
or her special privileges to define situations and relationships.
As a developing
thinker, you begin to decide which groups you allow to
influence your thinking
and which group influences you reject.
You now have three interwoven strategies: You "redefine the
way you see
things," "get in touch with your emotions," and "analyze group
influences on your
life." The three strategies are integrated into one. A t this point,
you can experi-
ment with any of the o t h e r strategies (which follow), looking
70. for opportunities to
integrate them into your thinking and your life.
• Use wasted time.
• Handle a problem a day.
• Internalize intellectual standards.
• Keep an intellectual j o u r n a l .
• Practice intellectual strategies.
• Reshape your character.
• Deal with your ego.