Story of two siblings with
“Chubby Cheeks”
Dept. of Pediatric Gastroenterology
SGPGIMS, Lucknow
Chubby cheeks – cute babies?
GSD
workup
negative

Exposure to
fruit juices
Affected SIB

Neonatal
cholestasis
TB:7.4
DB:3.8
AST:321
ALT: 138
T. Prot:3.9
Alb: 2.0
ALP:1672
GGT:66

Resolved
by 5mo

Sep 2008 (3mo)

Acute
encephalopathy

Liver biopsy:
early cirrhosis
macrovesicular
steatosis

Urine
NGRS
+
High
AFP

ABG/ Blood sugar/
U. ketones/ Lactate
All normal !
Ammonia :119
(Normal:11-47)

GAL1PUT &
Epimerase
normal

Persisting:
Doll like facies
Organomegaly
AST/ALT: 253/180
T. Prot/ Alb: 4.0/1.8
ALP:1297

Urine
Succinylacetone
normal
Apr 2009 (10mo)
Differential Diagnosis
Hereditary Fructose
Intolerance
Differential Diagnosis
GSD - IV

Fanconi
Bickel
syndrome
(GSD with RTA)
Doll Like facies…
What is it ?
Transient
neonatal
cholestasis

Affected sib
with downhill
course

Hyperammonemia
(encephalopathy)
Steatosis &
cirrhosis on
biopsy

Doll like
facies

Citrin
deficiency
Fischers ratio
(BCAA/ArAA)
=2.18
Citrin deficiency
<2.5

Caveat:
Test done during
asymptomatic
phase, not during
crisis!
Lost to follow up

Urine metabolic screen
Sweat chloride
Plasma Chitotriosidase
Sphingomyelinase
Beta-glucosidase
Beta-galactosidase

Apr 2009 (10mo)

normal
AST/ALT: 163/84
T. protein:5.9
Albumin: 2.9
ALP:913
GGT:138
CK: 24
Lipid profile: normal

Persisting:
Doll like facies
Organomegaly
Growth failure

Jan 2012 (3 ½ yrs)
Preference to protein rich foods, loves milk – parents reluctant!
Urine NGRS
+

GSD
workup
negative

High
AFP

H/O Transient
neonatal
cholestasis
(not worked up
anywhere)

SGPGI

GAL1PUT& Epimerase
normal
Urine Succinylacetone normal

Liver biopsy not possible - coagulopathy
Bone Marrow : normal

Failure to thrive
Organomegaly

TB/DB: 0.5/0.1
AST/ALT: 128/60
T. Prot/ Alb: 4.6/2.0
ALP:1505
GGT: 148
INR:1.6
Oct ‘08 (~3yrs)

Craving for protein rich food
Aversion to carbohydrates/ juices
TB/DB: 0.7/0.2
AST/ALT: 156/78
T. Prot/ Alb: 5.4/1.7
ALP:930
INR:1.8
Jan ‘09
Liver failure!

Transient neonatal cholestasis
Urine for metabolic screen
Sphingomyelinase
Beta-glucosidase
Beta-galactosidase

normal

Liver
Transplant
D
E
A
T
H

Recurrent encephalopathy
Off and on ascites
TB/DB: 0.7/0.2
AST/ALT: 156/78
T. Prot/ Alb: 5.4/1.7
ALP:930
INR:1.8

TB/DB: 2.0/1.3
AST/ALT: 121/77
T. Prot/ Alb: 4.5/1.5
ALP:684 GGT:88
INR: 2.3

TB/DB: 14.0/8.8
AST/ALT: 225/73
T. Prot/ Alb: 5.5/1.6
ALP:515
INR: 4.4

Jan ‘09

Dec ‘09 (~4yr)

Apr ‘10 (4 ½ yr)
SLC25A13 gene testing and
mutational analysis not available
Citrin deficiency

Autosomal
Recessive
Carrier frequency of gene mutation
China (1/79)
Taiwan (1/98)
Korea (1/50)
Japan (1/69)

Frequency of homozygous mutation for
SLC25A13 gene :
1:20,000-34,000 (East Asia)
Mol Genet Metab. 2009 Jan;96(1):44-9.

Pediatr Res 2004 Oct;56(4):608-14
Citrin deficiency

Chubby faces
Kobayashi et al Gene Reviews 2005
Recovery

ALF

Citrullinemia CLD
Type II

Chinese NICCD
cohort (n=26)

21 (81%) by 1 5 (19%) :
yr age
4 died, 1
LT

-

-

Retrospective
Japanese series
(n=75)

45 NICCD
30 new born
screening

2 (4.5%)
by 1yr

1 (2.2%) by
16yrs

-

Japanese NICCD
cohort (n=5)

4 recovered
by 1yr

1 LT by
2yr

-

-

Malaysian NICCD
cohort (n=11)

10 (91%)
recovery by
22mo

1 (9%)
died

Chinese
CLD (unknown
etiology) cases
(n=44)

-

-

-

21 patients
(~50%)
(20families)
Mutation+

Song et al ,Zhonghua Er Ke Za Zhi 2009 Aug;47(8):624-7.
Xing et al Zhonghua Xue Za Zhi.2010 Apr;27(2):180-5
Ohura et al J Inherit Metab Dis 2007 Apr;30(2):139-44
Chubby Index = (1+2)/3

Chen HW, JPGN 47:187–192, 2008

Controls (n=13)

Patients (n=5)

13.3
1.336
1.00
Can LFT predict?
Age: 93 days
DB:3.8
TB:7.4
AST:321
ALT: 138
ALP:1672
GGT:66
Chen HW, JPGN 47:187–192, 2008

2.3
0.5
Younger Sib
Total Protein/ Albumin Sep 08:
Total Protein/ Albumin Jan 09:
Total Protein/ Albumin April 09:
Total Protein/ Albumin Jan 12:

Unexplained
Hypoproteinemia!

3.9 / 2.0
4.3 / 2.1

4.0 / 1.8
5.9 / 2.9

Feature of citrin def.
Chen HW, JPGN 47:187–192, 2008

Elder sib Oct 08

Jan 09

Dec 09

Apr 10

AST
ALT
AST/ALT

128
60

156
78

225
97

2.1

2.0

121
77
1.57

ALP
T.Protein
Albumin

1505
4.6
2.0

930
5.4
1.7

684
4.5
1.5

2.3
505
5.5
1.6
Histopathology changes
Steatosis (2/3)

Neonatal Hepatitis like

FibrosisCirrhosis

>50% Citrin deficiency
(Taiwan series)

NASH
NAFLD

May persist
into adulthood

6% Neonatal cholestasis
(Chinese series)
12% Idiopathic neonatal hepatitis
(Japanese series)

Liver
failure
Journal of Pediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition Jun 2010

21%
diagnosed
NAFLD

19 patients with
Citrullinemia II

90% steatosis
79% fibrosis

Komatsu et al, J Hepatol 2008 Nov;49(5))

Fatty livers without obesity ! BMI <20
High serum Pancreatic secretory trypsin inhibitor (PSTI) >29ng/ml
……Pancreatitis (68%) !
Diagnosis
Citrulline level high
60-73% : NICCD
Japanese series
90%: new born
screening

Chen HW et al, JPGN 47:187–192, 2008
Kobayashi et al Gene Reviews 2005
Tazawa et al, Mol Genetic Metabol 2004;83(3):213-9
Caveats in diagnosis
Literature from Chinese/Japanese articles
Natural History is unclear
Misdiagnosis as Galactosemia and Tyrosinemia
(increase galactose and tyrosine in blood, galactosuria)
Plasma amino acids
Inconsistently and varied elevation
New born screen ineffective
Normal during asymptomatic phase,
GI bleed, high protein intake

Urine GCMS:
Various nonspecific
metabolites
Diet peculiarities
Urea Cycle
defects

Protein
aversion
“My son hates
rice and eats
only fish!”

“…. wants milk 24 x7 !!”
(Seen in Citrullinemia Type II)

Protein craving
Citrin deficiency

Carbohydrate
aversion
Diet recommendations
Protein : 15-20%
Fat : 50%
Carbohydrates: 30-35%
Milk : Protein (20%) Fat (50%) Carb (30%)

Avoid
High carbohydrate / Fructose
Glycerol for brain edema
Liver Transplant
Recurrent encephalopathy
Liver failure
Hepatocellular Carcinoma (5-8%)

Good outcome

Auxillary
Partial
Orthotropic

Kobayashi et al Gene Reviews 2005
Soo Kim, J Korean Surg Soc 2011;80:S51-54
Yazaki, Liver Transplantation, Vol 10, No 4 (April), 2004
All that glitters is not GOLD!
All Chubby cheeks are not GSD!

THANK YOU
Lipids
1)compensate for
energy
2) FA inhibit hepatic
glycolysis

Urea Cycle for
ureagenesis

Protein intake
More availability of aspartate through
aspargine and pyruvate from alanine

Chubby cheeks
Citrate –malate shuttle activated: Increase of
Glycerol 3 phosphate + breakdown of citrate
(Acetyl CoA +OAA)
Hypoproteinemia (subclinical edema)
Unexplained concepts
• Why majority outgrow the disease?
• Any additional factors for progression to
CLD/ALF ?
• Postulation for protein craving?

CITRIN DEFICIENCY

  • 1.
    Story of twosiblings with “Chubby Cheeks” Dept. of Pediatric Gastroenterology SGPGIMS, Lucknow
  • 2.
    Chubby cheeks –cute babies?
  • 3.
    GSD workup negative Exposure to fruit juices AffectedSIB Neonatal cholestasis TB:7.4 DB:3.8 AST:321 ALT: 138 T. Prot:3.9 Alb: 2.0 ALP:1672 GGT:66 Resolved by 5mo Sep 2008 (3mo) Acute encephalopathy Liver biopsy: early cirrhosis macrovesicular steatosis Urine NGRS + High AFP ABG/ Blood sugar/ U. ketones/ Lactate All normal ! Ammonia :119 (Normal:11-47) GAL1PUT & Epimerase normal Persisting: Doll like facies Organomegaly AST/ALT: 253/180 T. Prot/ Alb: 4.0/1.8 ALP:1297 Urine Succinylacetone normal Apr 2009 (10mo)
  • 4.
  • 5.
    Differential Diagnosis GSD -IV Fanconi Bickel syndrome (GSD with RTA)
  • 6.
    Doll Like facies… Whatis it ? Transient neonatal cholestasis Affected sib with downhill course Hyperammonemia (encephalopathy) Steatosis & cirrhosis on biopsy Doll like facies Citrin deficiency
  • 7.
    Fischers ratio (BCAA/ArAA) =2.18 Citrin deficiency <2.5 Caveat: Testdone during asymptomatic phase, not during crisis!
  • 8.
    Lost to followup Urine metabolic screen Sweat chloride Plasma Chitotriosidase Sphingomyelinase Beta-glucosidase Beta-galactosidase Apr 2009 (10mo) normal AST/ALT: 163/84 T. protein:5.9 Albumin: 2.9 ALP:913 GGT:138 CK: 24 Lipid profile: normal Persisting: Doll like facies Organomegaly Growth failure Jan 2012 (3 ½ yrs)
  • 9.
    Preference to proteinrich foods, loves milk – parents reluctant!
  • 10.
    Urine NGRS + GSD workup negative High AFP H/O Transient neonatal cholestasis (notworked up anywhere) SGPGI GAL1PUT& Epimerase normal Urine Succinylacetone normal Liver biopsy not possible - coagulopathy Bone Marrow : normal Failure to thrive Organomegaly TB/DB: 0.5/0.1 AST/ALT: 128/60 T. Prot/ Alb: 4.6/2.0 ALP:1505 GGT: 148 INR:1.6 Oct ‘08 (~3yrs) Craving for protein rich food Aversion to carbohydrates/ juices TB/DB: 0.7/0.2 AST/ALT: 156/78 T. Prot/ Alb: 5.4/1.7 ALP:930 INR:1.8 Jan ‘09
  • 11.
    Liver failure! Transient neonatalcholestasis Urine for metabolic screen Sphingomyelinase Beta-glucosidase Beta-galactosidase normal Liver Transplant D E A T H Recurrent encephalopathy Off and on ascites TB/DB: 0.7/0.2 AST/ALT: 156/78 T. Prot/ Alb: 5.4/1.7 ALP:930 INR:1.8 TB/DB: 2.0/1.3 AST/ALT: 121/77 T. Prot/ Alb: 4.5/1.5 ALP:684 GGT:88 INR: 2.3 TB/DB: 14.0/8.8 AST/ALT: 225/73 T. Prot/ Alb: 5.5/1.6 ALP:515 INR: 4.4 Jan ‘09 Dec ‘09 (~4yr) Apr ‘10 (4 ½ yr)
  • 12.
    SLC25A13 gene testingand mutational analysis not available
  • 13.
  • 14.
    Carrier frequency ofgene mutation China (1/79) Taiwan (1/98) Korea (1/50) Japan (1/69) Frequency of homozygous mutation for SLC25A13 gene : 1:20,000-34,000 (East Asia) Mol Genet Metab. 2009 Jan;96(1):44-9. Pediatr Res 2004 Oct;56(4):608-14
  • 15.
  • 16.
    Recovery ALF Citrullinemia CLD Type II ChineseNICCD cohort (n=26) 21 (81%) by 1 5 (19%) : yr age 4 died, 1 LT - - Retrospective Japanese series (n=75) 45 NICCD 30 new born screening 2 (4.5%) by 1yr 1 (2.2%) by 16yrs - Japanese NICCD cohort (n=5) 4 recovered by 1yr 1 LT by 2yr - - Malaysian NICCD cohort (n=11) 10 (91%) recovery by 22mo 1 (9%) died Chinese CLD (unknown etiology) cases (n=44) - - - 21 patients (~50%) (20families) Mutation+ Song et al ,Zhonghua Er Ke Za Zhi 2009 Aug;47(8):624-7. Xing et al Zhonghua Xue Za Zhi.2010 Apr;27(2):180-5 Ohura et al J Inherit Metab Dis 2007 Apr;30(2):139-44
  • 17.
    Chubby Index =(1+2)/3 Chen HW, JPGN 47:187–192, 2008 Controls (n=13) Patients (n=5) 13.3 1.336 1.00
  • 18.
    Can LFT predict? Age:93 days DB:3.8 TB:7.4 AST:321 ALT: 138 ALP:1672 GGT:66 Chen HW, JPGN 47:187–192, 2008 2.3 0.5
  • 19.
    Younger Sib Total Protein/Albumin Sep 08: Total Protein/ Albumin Jan 09: Total Protein/ Albumin April 09: Total Protein/ Albumin Jan 12: Unexplained Hypoproteinemia! 3.9 / 2.0 4.3 / 2.1 4.0 / 1.8 5.9 / 2.9 Feature of citrin def. Chen HW, JPGN 47:187–192, 2008 Elder sib Oct 08 Jan 09 Dec 09 Apr 10 AST ALT AST/ALT 128 60 156 78 225 97 2.1 2.0 121 77 1.57 ALP T.Protein Albumin 1505 4.6 2.0 930 5.4 1.7 684 4.5 1.5 2.3 505 5.5 1.6
  • 20.
    Histopathology changes Steatosis (2/3) NeonatalHepatitis like FibrosisCirrhosis >50% Citrin deficiency (Taiwan series) NASH NAFLD May persist into adulthood 6% Neonatal cholestasis (Chinese series) 12% Idiopathic neonatal hepatitis (Japanese series) Liver failure
  • 21.
    Journal of PediatricGastroenterology and Nutrition Jun 2010 21% diagnosed NAFLD 19 patients with Citrullinemia II 90% steatosis 79% fibrosis Komatsu et al, J Hepatol 2008 Nov;49(5)) Fatty livers without obesity ! BMI <20 High serum Pancreatic secretory trypsin inhibitor (PSTI) >29ng/ml ……Pancreatitis (68%) !
  • 22.
    Diagnosis Citrulline level high 60-73%: NICCD Japanese series 90%: new born screening Chen HW et al, JPGN 47:187–192, 2008 Kobayashi et al Gene Reviews 2005 Tazawa et al, Mol Genetic Metabol 2004;83(3):213-9
  • 23.
    Caveats in diagnosis Literaturefrom Chinese/Japanese articles Natural History is unclear Misdiagnosis as Galactosemia and Tyrosinemia (increase galactose and tyrosine in blood, galactosuria) Plasma amino acids Inconsistently and varied elevation New born screen ineffective Normal during asymptomatic phase, GI bleed, high protein intake Urine GCMS: Various nonspecific metabolites
  • 24.
    Diet peculiarities Urea Cycle defects Protein aversion “Myson hates rice and eats only fish!” “…. wants milk 24 x7 !!” (Seen in Citrullinemia Type II) Protein craving Citrin deficiency Carbohydrate aversion
  • 25.
    Diet recommendations Protein :15-20% Fat : 50% Carbohydrates: 30-35% Milk : Protein (20%) Fat (50%) Carb (30%) Avoid High carbohydrate / Fructose Glycerol for brain edema
  • 26.
    Liver Transplant Recurrent encephalopathy Liverfailure Hepatocellular Carcinoma (5-8%) Good outcome Auxillary Partial Orthotropic Kobayashi et al Gene Reviews 2005 Soo Kim, J Korean Surg Soc 2011;80:S51-54 Yazaki, Liver Transplantation, Vol 10, No 4 (April), 2004
  • 27.
    All that glittersis not GOLD! All Chubby cheeks are not GSD! THANK YOU
  • 29.
    Lipids 1)compensate for energy 2) FAinhibit hepatic glycolysis Urea Cycle for ureagenesis Protein intake More availability of aspartate through aspargine and pyruvate from alanine Chubby cheeks Citrate –malate shuttle activated: Increase of Glycerol 3 phosphate + breakdown of citrate (Acetyl CoA +OAA) Hypoproteinemia (subclinical edema)
  • 30.
    Unexplained concepts • Whymajority outgrow the disease? • Any additional factors for progression to CLD/ALF ? • Postulation for protein craving?