This document describes the case of two siblings who presented with chubby cheeks and were eventually diagnosed with Citrin deficiency. The older sibling had a more severe clinical course, initially presenting with transient neonatal cholestasis and later developing liver failure. Both siblings showed features of Citrin deficiency such as hypoproteinemia, doll-like facies, and abnormal liver function tests. The elder sibling ultimately died due to liver failure while the younger sibling recovered by 5 months of age, showing that Citrin deficiency can range from transient neonatal cholestasis to fatal liver disease.