CHEST WALL TOXICITY IN SABR : PREDICTORS AND CONTOURING OF CHEST WALL
1. Chest Wall Toxicity In Stereotactic Ablative Body Radiotherapy (SABR): Current Evidence Dr Vimoj J Nair SABR Fellow Dr Vimoj J. Nair, SABR Fellow, Department of Radiation Oncology, The Ottawa Hospital Cancer Centre, ON, Canada
4. Incidence of Chest wall Syndrome/Toxicity McKenna RJ, Houck W, Beeman Fuller C. Video-assisted thoracic surgery lobectomy: experience with 1,100 cases. The Annals of Thoracic Surgery, February 2006. 81(2):421-426. Modality Incidence Conventional radiotherapy 1-6% Hypofractionated RT [Overgaard et al] 19% SABR Severe chest wall pain 5-33% rib fractures – 2-21% Thoracotomy ~30-50%, VATS None / mild 63% Severe 6%
5.
6. Spectrum of CW toxicity CTCAE v 3.0 Grade Short name 1 2 3 4 5 Pain Mild pain not interfering with function Moderate pain, pain or analgesics interfering with function, but not with ADL Severe pain, pain or analgesics severely interfering with ADL Disabling - Fracture Asymptomatic, radiographic findings only (e.g. Asymptomatic rib fracture on plain x-ray, pelvic insufficinecy, fracture on MRI, etc) Symptomatic, but not displaced; immobilization indicated Symptomatic and displaced or open wound with bone exposure; operative intervention indicated Disabling, amputation indicated Death
7.
8.
9. Studies on chest wall toxicity in SABR CW2cm correlated with toxicity Studies Pros/Retro N chest wall {CW} lesion definition Chest wall Contouring criteria Dose fractionation Median f/u {mths} Chest wall [Toxicity Pain and Fracture] rates Median Time of toxicity {mths} 1 Dunlap et al, Virginia/Colorado, ASTRO 2008, IJROBP 2010 Retro 60 < 2.5 cm from CW OR Dmax >20 Gy CW 3cm 60 Gy/30Fr 11 21% pain and 8% fractures 7.1 2 Voroney et al, Alberta,/PMH J Thor Oncol 2009 Retro 42 NA NA 54-60 Gy /3 Fr NA 21% rib #, 26% CW pain 1.5 to 5% rib . 17 3 Petterssen et al, Sweden, Radiother Oncol, 2009 Retro 33 NA Individual Ribs 45Gy/3Fr 29 13 rib fractures 8.8 4 Welsh et al , MDACC, Astro 2009, IJROBP 2010 Retro 265 (268 TX) NA All soft tissue minus lungs 50Gy/4Fr 10.3 22% pain, 3% fractures 6 5 Stephans et al , Cleveland, IJROBP 2011 Retro 134 NA Unspecified arc of tissues 60Gy/3 18.8 7% chest wall toxicity ; # not reported 8.8 6 Andolino et al, Indiana, IJROBP 2011 Retro 347 [203 CW] CW within ≥ 50% isodose CW3cm + ribs separately 54-60 Gy/ 2-5 Fr 19 CW 21%, NCW 3.5% 10% CW required Prescription 8 7 Mutter et al, MSKCC, NY, 2011 Pros 126 NA CW2cm, CW 3cm compared; 1.2 cm sup/inf 40-60Gy/3-5Fr 16 4% rib #, 51% grade 2 pain 9