SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Confessions of a Capital Junkie
April 29, 2015
An insider perspective on the cure for the industry's
value-destroying addiction to capital
Safe Harbor Statement
2April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie
This document contains forward-looking statements. These
statements may include terms such as “may”, “will”, “expect”,
“could”, “should”, “intend”, “estimate”, “anticipate”, “believe”,
“remain”, “on track”, “design”, “target”, “objective”, “goal”,
“forecast”, “projection”, “outlook”, “prospects”, “plan”,
“intend”, or similar terms. Forward-looking statements are
not guarantees of future performance. Rather, they are
based on the Group’s current expectations and projections
about future events and, by their nature, are subject to
inherent risks and uncertainties. They relate to events and
depend on circumstances that may or may not occur or exist
in the future and, as such, undue reliance should not be
placed on them. Actual results may differ materially from
those expressed in such statements as a result of a variety
of factors, including: the future capital expenditures and
research and development expenses of the Group and the
industry, potential benefits from industry consolidation;
developments in global financial markets and general
economic and other conditions; changes in demand for
automotive products, which is highly cyclical; the high level of
competition in the automotive industry; the Group’s ability to
realize anticipated benefits from any business combinations,
joint venture arrangements and other strategic alliances; the
Group’s ability to integrate its operations; the Group’s ability
to access funding to execute the Group’s business plan and
improve the Group’s business, financial condition and results
of operations; operating expenditures including in relation
to vehicle and powertrain development and compliance
with regulations; exchange rate fluctuations, interest rate
changes, credit risk and other market risks; our ability to
achieve the benefits expected from any capital optimzation
plans; and other risks and uncertainties.
Any forward-looking statements contained in this
document speak only as of the date of this document and
the Company does not undertake any obligation to update
or revise publicly forward-looking statements. Further
information concerning the Group and its businesses,
including factors that could materially affect the
Company’s financial results, is included in the Company’s
reports and filings with the U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission, the AFM and CONSOB.
Purpose of the pitch
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 3
 Goal is to provide clarity on two issues that have been raised
publicly by FCA
● Industry has not earned its cost of capital over a cycle
● Consolidation is the key to remedying the problem
 What this is not about
● An excuse for FCA’s current ranking in the automotive food chain
● Putting FCA up for sale
● A revision to our 5 year plan (which remains a firm commitment)
● A matter of life or death for FCA
● SM’s final big deal
 What this is about
● Dispassionate look at the industry from the outside using
insider knowledge
● It is about choosing between mediocrity or fundamentally changing
the paradigm for the industry
Before we get into this, we should be reminded that …
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie
“Everyone is entitled to his
own opinion, but not to his
own facts.”
Daniel Patrick Moynihan
(Former US Senator and Ambassador to the UN)
4
Auto industry’s capex and R&D requirements have
grown significantly over the past years …
April 29, 2015 5Confessions of a Capital Junkie
Top OEMs1—Total capex + R&D spending over last 5 years (€bn)2
CAGR:
Mainstream OEMs: ~12%
Premium OEMs: ~10%
Mainstream OEMs Premium OEMs
Source: Company annual reports
1 Includes mainstream OEMs: FCA, Ford, General Motors, Honda, Hyundai, Kia, Nissan, PSA, Renault, Toyota, Volkswagen. Premium OEMs: BMW, Daimler Cars
2 Translated at constant 2010 exchange rates (average January to December 2010)
64
78
91
99
104
12
14
17
19
18
76
91
107
117
122
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
... and going forward, new technological challenges
will continue to raise the bar on capital requirements
6April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie
Forces at work increasing capital requirements—Selected examples
Auto OEMs
Emissions
regulations
Safety regulations
Car connectivity
and autonomy
 Tighter emissions
regulations
 Costly new powertrains
 Weight-saving
technologies
 Stricter regulations
and customer focus
on safety
 Adoption of state-of-the-
art safety technologies
across markets
 New infotainment
services
 Customer expectations
on connected cars
 Autonomous drive push
Regulatory-driven Customer-driven
Product development costs are consuming value at
a much faster rate than in other industries …
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 7
Time to reinvest enterprise value1 in product development (capital and R&D)2
1 Industrial activities only. Including pension liabilities
2 Calculated as 3-year average of the annual ratio between enterprise value (for the period 2012–2014) and capital expenditures plus R&D expenses
3 Based on the reference sample
Source: Company annual reports
~
~
1.3
2.6 3.1 3.2 3.4 3.4 3.6 3.8 4.0
5.0
7.8 8.5
OEM3
FCA
OEM1
OEM9
OEM10
OEM5
PremiumOEM
OEM7
OEM2
OEM8
OEM6
OEM4
7
13
18
19
20
23
28
36
Oil&Gas
Telecommunication
Pharma
Aerospace&
Defence
Chemicals
Packaging
materials
Buildingmaterials
Consumer&Retail
Average
across
industries3:
~20 years
~
~
~
~
~
Auto
industry
average:
~4.1 years
~
Average number of yearsAverage number of years
... and high operational leverage amplifies profitability
swings across the cycle ...
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 8
1 EBIT defined as Industrial reported EBIT plus income from equity accounted investments and excludes goodwill impairment. EBIT as per accounting principles adopted by
each company
2 Mainstream OEMs include: FCA, Ford, General Motors, Honda, Hyundai, Kia, Nissan, PSA, Renault, Toyota, Volkswagen
Source: Company annual reports
EBIT Margin1 of Auto OEMs vs other sectors (%)
2
(3%)
8%
19%
30%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Aerospace & Defence Building materials Chemicals Consumer products Packaging
Pharmaceuticals Telecommunications Premium OEM Mainstream OEMs
… resulting in structurally low and volatile returns
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 9
1 ROIC calculated as [Industrial reported EBIT x (1-taxes) + income from equity accounted investments] / Industrial Net Invested capital. Assumed a normalized tax rate equal
to 30%. EBIT excludes goodwill impairment. Industrial Net Invested capital is defined as industrial Trade Working Capital + Industrial PP&E + Industrial Intangibles
(excl. Goodwill) + Book Value of equity accounted investments + operating cash for OEMs (assumed at 12.5% of industrial sales). EBIT as per accounting principles
adopted by each company
2 Mainstream OEMs include: FCA, Ford, General Motors, Honda, Hyundai, Kia, Nissan, PSA, Renault, Toyota, Volkswagen
ROIC1 of Auto OEMs vs other sectors (%)
2
(10%)
0
10%
20%
30%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Aerospace & defence Building materials Chemicals Consumer Packaging materials
Pharma Telecommunications Premium OEM Mainstream OEMs
Consensus
WACC: ~9%
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie
Typical vehicle development costs
1 Chart scale based on mid-point of range shown
New vehicle program—development
costs split1
10
Why did this happen? OEMs spend vast amounts of capital to develop
proprietary components, many not really discernible to customers
45–50%
50–55%
Differentiating
products/
technologies
Products/technologies
“undiscernible to
customer”, potentially
overlapping with competitors
Vehicle R&D
~40%
Vehicle Tooling
~35%
Powetrain/
R&D
~15%
Powetrain
Tooling
~5%
Other
~5%
One industry solution focuses on reducing the
number of active platforms and increasing scale …
Confessions of a Capital Junkie
SOURCE: IHS
1 Adjusted to include only platforms with at least 2,000 cars manufactured in a given year
2 Including FCA, Ford, GM, Honda, Hyundai, PSA, Renault/Nissan, Suzuki, Toyota, Volkswagen
Active platforms by OEM1
Average across top 10 global OEMs
2004
-20%
20142009
Number of top hats by platform2
Average across top 10 global OEMs
2004
2.5
3.3
+30%
20142009
2.6
11
"More of our components will be common, and more of our vehicles will be on global architectures"
Dan Akerson, GM (2011)
"I'm really proud to say that we've reduced that number down to 12 global platforms. In 2016 we'll reduce that down to a
further nine global platforms, and our team is working towards a further consolidation of that to get down to a long-term target
now of eight global platforms […] that obviously yields tremendous benefits for us as an enterprise”
Raj Nair, Ford Group Vice President-Global Product Development (2015)
22
21
18
April 29, 2015
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie
Source: IHS—Global 2018 Sales database as of April 2015, Toyota global newsroom
12
C-CUV
(2016)
Polo
(2016)
Golf
SportVan
Passat
Touran Jetta
(2016)
Tiguan
(2016)
CC
(2017)
B-CUV
(2016)
C-MPV
(2017)
C-CUV
(2016)
Q1
(2016)
A3
Q3
(2018)
Superb
Yeti
(2017)
LeonLamando Scirocco
(2018)
B-CUV
(2018)
MQB
ARCHITECTURE
Golf Spacefox
(2018)
Fox
(2017)
Voyage
(2018)
A1
(2018)
Octavia Ibiza
(2016)
TT
Crossblue Crossblue
coupe (2018)
Sagitar
(2017)
Golf
SportWagen
MC-M
ARCHITECTURE
MebiusWish
Voxy
Venza
Sienna
SAI
RAV4
Prius
Alpha
(Prius V)
Prius
Mirai
Highlander
Harrier
Estima
Camry
Avensis
Avalon
Alphard ES
HS
NX
RX
Lavida
(2018)
… and some OEMs are trying larger scale
commonization across diverse brands …
“By the middle of 2020, we plan to expand TNGA (Toyota New Generation Architecture) to approximately half of the line-up […] —Traditionally we
have tended to focus on developing individual models and lacked the total alignment and consistency, which will change with a company-wide effort.”
Mitsuhisa Kato, Toyota Executive VP (2015)
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie
Successful Failed
13
… while others through one-off co-operations,
JVs and other equity tie-ups
One-off industrial
co-operations
Cross-shareholdings—
enabled co-operations Full integration
Expectedimpactatthetimeofthedeal
Low High
Low/negativeHigh
Level of integration
Long-term industrial
co-operations (JVs)
But all this has produced poor results so far,
as OEMs' returns and valuations are still depressed
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 14
2014 ROIC 2014 EV/EBITDA2
1 Mainstream OEMs include: FCA, Ford, General Motors, Hyundai, Honda, Kia, Nissan, PSA, Renault, Toyota, Volkswagen
2 Based on 2014 average enterprise value for the companies in the reference sample. EV including pension liabilities. EBITDA as per accounting principles adopted by
each company
4.0x
6.2x
6.8x
9.0x 9.1x
10.7x 11.0x 11.1x
13.0x
MainstreamOEMs
Oil&Gas
Telecommunications
AerospaceandDefence
Packagingmaterials
Chemicals
Buildingmaterials
Consumer&Retail
Pharma
7.8%
10%
11%
12%
13%
14%
16%
19%
22%
MainstreamOEMs
Oil&Gas
Telecommunications
Buildingmaterials
Chemicals
Packagingmaterials
AerospaceandDefence
Pharma
Consumer&Retail
1
1
Why haven’t these approaches provided
a significant lift to returns?
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie
 Large scale organic reduction in platforms
● Reluctance to replace old, less costly architectures
● Option available only to those OEMs with existing scale across platforms,
top hats and regions
● Requires strict discipline to avoid upward standardization/over engineering
● Lower risk in the short-term, BUT significantly slower execution,
entailing lower returns over an extended period
 OEM co-operations
● Most effective on single ventures, but with limited scope
● Usually involve non-core elements of portfolio
● Not a pervasive, substantive solution for any OEM
15
Why does industry consolidation matter?
16April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie
 High mortality rate caused by partial if non-existent integration
● Cultural divide (corporate and otherwise)
● Inequality of integrating parties
● Operating models radically different and never merged
● Insufficient sensitivity for brand differences
● Lack of respect/trust for one another
 Complexity proved to be too much of a stretch for leadership teams
BUT
 It enables
● Fast execution, enabling rapid scale gain
● Fostering step-change/best-of-best approach to modularity/ commonality
AND
 The potential savings are too large to ignore
The facts: Breaking down product development costs
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie
1 Includes mounts, fuel system, cooling and other minor components/systems
2 Average weighted on contribution to product development cost
E-MPV segment mainstream “all new” vehicle example
17
OEM B
OEM A
Potential
commonality
while
preserving
differentiation
17%
14%
38%
11%
2%
Steering
1%
Suspen-
sions/
wheels
4%
Brakes
1%
Power-
train
installation
systems1
7%
Upper-
body
exterior
Under-
body
Total
100%
Common
general
Assy/
Paint
InteriorsElectri-
cal/
Electronics/
Connectivity
5%
HVAC
~70% ~10% ~75% ~90% ~80% ~80% ~80% ~70%
Potential
commonality
up to
~45-50% of
total
development
cost2
Frame/chassis
Typical development cost for vehicle and platform (excluding powertrain)
% of total development costs
~30% 100%
Potential benefits up to €2 billion on vehicle investments
Powertrain portfolios show even higher duplications
across OEMs, both for engines …
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 18
Overlap with future FCA engine offering
1 High performance engines, limited productions, low volumes
Diesel
Engine lineup
Potential overlap with FCA
engine budget
Exotic engines1
GasHybrid
• Small (1.3-1.6L)
• Medium (2.0-2.3L)
• Large (3.0-6.0L)
• 3 Cylinder
• 4 Cylinder
• V6
• V8
• Mild (BSG)
• Full
Major global car OEMs benchmarked
Minor overlap
OEM 1 OEM 2
>90% ~50% >90%~90% >70%>60% >50%
OEM 4 OEM 7OEM 3 OEM 9OEM 6OEM 5
~90%
… and for transmissions
Confessions of a Capital Junkie 19April 29, 2015
Overlap with future FCA transmissions offering
Potential overlap with FCA
transmissions budget
~90% ~50% >90%~90% ~ 70%~ 80% ~ 50%
FWD
Transmissions lineup
RWD
• Manual 5 Speed
• Manual 6 Speed
• MTA
• DDCT
• Automatic 6 Speed
• Automatic 8/9 Speed
• CVT
• Manual 6 Speed
Major global car OEMs benchmarked
OEM 1 OEM 2 OEM 4 OEM 7OEM 3 OEM 9OEM 6
• Auto. LD, ≤7 Speeds
• Auto. LD, ≥8 Speeds
• Auto. HD, ≤7 Speeds (1000 Nm)
• Auto. HD, ≥8 Speeds (1000 Nm)
~60%
OEM 5
Potential elimination up to €1 billion in duplicated engines and transmissions spending per year
The facts: Sharing platform, vehicle and powertrain
development can yield significant savings
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 20
Illustrative investment for developing 2 full new vehicles
Indexed to 100, example mainstream B/C segment built on same platform
Total consolidated
investment
~60-80
~100~50 ~20-401
Vehicle and
platform A
Savings on total
investment
Total stand-alone
investments for A
and B
~50
Vehicle and
platform B
1 Estimate based on 40-80% saving on the second vehicle leveraging commonalities in product development. Example for mainstream B/C segment
estimated with same methodology as of case for E-MPV segment (45-50%)
2 Assuming a powertrain average lifecycle of 10 years. Tooling synergies not considered
~70-75
Total stand-alone
investments for A
and B
~100
Engine B
~50
Savings on base
development,
vehicle installation
~25-30
~50
Total consolidated
investment
Engine A
Illustrative investment for developing 2 new engines2
Indexed to 100, example for two 4-cylinder gasoline engines to be based on the same architecture
We believe large scale integrations are required to
unleash full potential
21April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie
Potential for capital rationalization across different types of co-operation
Share R&D
costs and tech
development
Optimize
tooling
investments
Maximize plant
utilization
Capture cross-
selling
opportunities
Capture other
opex
opportunities
Potential for
capital
rationalization
One-off technical co-
operation JVs
Cross-shareholding
enabled co-operations
Full
integration
Key
enabler:
Integrated
product
strategy
Key
enabler:
Integrated
industrial
footprint
strategy
Low High
Drivers for capital
rationalization
Potential synergies from consolidation of auto OEMs
would be ~70% driven by industrial rationale
22April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie
Estimated benefits from consolidation of auto OEMs1
1 FCA analysis of potential consolidation opportunities among top 10 global automotive OEMs
 Sharing platforms
development costs
 Leveraging
commonalities in
top-hat
development
 Avoiding budget
duplication for
powertrains
 Optimization of
manufacturing
investments and
production
allocation
Combinations of FCA with another large OEM would yield benefits of €2.5-4.5bn per year
Technology and
product development
(e.g. sharing component
development costs)
Cross-selling
~70%
~15%
Other opex
opportunities
(e.g. purchasing, SG&A)
~15%
Aerospace and Defence
Building materials
Chemicals
Oil & Gas
Packaging materials
Telecommunications
Pharma
Consumer & Retail
OEM 1
OEM 2
OEM 3
OEM 4
OEM 5
OEM 6
OEM 7
OEM 8
OEM 9
Premium OEM
OEM 10
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
0.0x 2.0x 4.0x 6.0x 8.0x 10.0x 12.0x 14.0x
Consolidation can support significant ROIC and
valuation improvement
April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie
1 Including pension liabilities. EBITDA as per accounting principles adopted by each company
ROIC FY 2014
EV/EBITDA1 2014
Auto industry WACC: ~9%
23
Status quo
Automotive
today
Consensus 2018
Consensus 2018
adjusted for
consolidation
Some conclusions
Confessions of a Capital Junkie
 Top OEMs spent over €100bn for product development in 2014 only,
>€2bn/week in product development and tooling costs, and poised to invest at
similar rates in the futures
 Historical returns have been broadly below cost of capital, even after the
restructuring of the US auto industry and NAFTA volumes at peak
 Single purpose projects, JVs and the like are helpful, but they are not enough
 Capital consumption rate by OEMs is unacceptable—it is duplicative, does not
deliver real value to consumers and is pure economic waste
 Consolidation carries executional risks BUT benefits are too large to ignore
● Up to €4.5bn per annum, ~70% of which is a reduction in investments and R&D
● Optimized industrial allocations, with no impact on number employed
● Distribution (dealer networks not merged) and brands untouched by consolidation
● An exceptional value creation opportunity for shareholders
 It is ultimately a matter of leadership style and capability…
24April 29, 2015
The Red Queen
Confessions of a Capital Junkie 25
“Well, in our country” said Alice,
still panting a little, “you’d
generally get to somewhere else
- if you ran very fast for a long
time as we’ve been doing.”
“A slow sort of country!” said the
Queen. “Now here you see it
takes all the running you can do
to keep in the same place. If
you want to get somewhere
else, you must run at least twice
as fast as that!”
L. Carroll
Through the Looking Glass
April 29, 2015
Confessions of Capital Junkie

More Related Content

What's hot

Making a business plan
Making a business planMaking a business plan
Making a business planJatindra Malik
 
Cat Coffee Shop-WPS Office.pdf
Cat Coffee Shop-WPS Office.pdfCat Coffee Shop-WPS Office.pdf
Cat Coffee Shop-WPS Office.pdf
MARVINMASANGCAY
 
Successful filipino entrepreneurs
Successful filipino entrepreneursSuccessful filipino entrepreneurs
Successful filipino entrepreneurs
NeilfieOrit2
 
Spa business plan example rose
Spa business plan example   roseSpa business plan example   rose
Spa business plan example rose
Rosmanurasitah Abd rahim
 
SLk-UCSP-Week-2.docx
SLk-UCSP-Week-2.docxSLk-UCSP-Week-2.docx
SLk-UCSP-Week-2.docx
NioArthSoriano2
 
Module 2 Entrepreneurship Development
Module 2 Entrepreneurship DevelopmentModule 2 Entrepreneurship Development
Module 2 Entrepreneurship Development
Bibin Xavier
 
St. Peter Life Plan Brand Management
St. Peter Life Plan Brand ManagementSt. Peter Life Plan Brand Management
St. Peter Life Plan Brand Management
Jun Sollestre
 
business plan for Start Up template
business plan for Start Up template business plan for Start Up template
business plan for Start Up template
josefboediarto
 
Project study on establishing lending business
Project study on establishing lending businessProject study on establishing lending business
Project study on establishing lending businessReymar27
 
Marketing plan PDF report
Marketing plan PDF reportMarketing plan PDF report
Marketing plan PDF report
Shubham Parsekar
 
Relevance of the Course.pdf
Relevance of the Course.pdfRelevance of the Course.pdf
Relevance of the Course.pdf
Vince Marko Saño
 
4 m's of production
4 m's of production 4 m's of production
4 m's of production
Robert Counts
 
Site location, map reading and lot plotting,
Site location, map reading and lot plotting, Site location, map reading and lot plotting,
Site location, map reading and lot plotting,
Gus Agosto
 
Manila Comprehensive Land Use Plan
Manila Comprehensive Land Use PlanManila Comprehensive Land Use Plan
Manila Comprehensive Land Use Plan
Jeannifer Villanueva
 
THE DISCIPLINE OF SOCIAL WORK
THE DISCIPLINE OF SOCIAL WORKTHE DISCIPLINE OF SOCIAL WORK
THE DISCIPLINE OF SOCIAL WORK
Miss Ivy
 
Business Proposal for Soft Line Cafe to operate at Al Yamamah University
Business Proposal for Soft Line Cafe to operate at Al Yamamah UniversityBusiness Proposal for Soft Line Cafe to operate at Al Yamamah University
Business Proposal for Soft Line Cafe to operate at Al Yamamah University
Naja Faysal
 
Asian Corner-Asian Street Food Takeaway Business Plan
Asian Corner-Asian Street Food Takeaway Business PlanAsian Corner-Asian Street Food Takeaway Business Plan
Asian Corner-Asian Street Food Takeaway Business Plan百惠 谢
 

What's hot (20)

Making a business plan
Making a business planMaking a business plan
Making a business plan
 
Cat Coffee Shop-WPS Office.pdf
Cat Coffee Shop-WPS Office.pdfCat Coffee Shop-WPS Office.pdf
Cat Coffee Shop-WPS Office.pdf
 
DANKIE BRIEF
DANKIE BRIEFDANKIE BRIEF
DANKIE BRIEF
 
Successful filipino entrepreneurs
Successful filipino entrepreneursSuccessful filipino entrepreneurs
Successful filipino entrepreneurs
 
Spa business plan example rose
Spa business plan example   roseSpa business plan example   rose
Spa business plan example rose
 
SLk-UCSP-Week-2.docx
SLk-UCSP-Week-2.docxSLk-UCSP-Week-2.docx
SLk-UCSP-Week-2.docx
 
Feasibility study(technical aspect)
Feasibility study(technical aspect)Feasibility study(technical aspect)
Feasibility study(technical aspect)
 
Module 2 Entrepreneurship Development
Module 2 Entrepreneurship DevelopmentModule 2 Entrepreneurship Development
Module 2 Entrepreneurship Development
 
St. Peter Life Plan Brand Management
St. Peter Life Plan Brand ManagementSt. Peter Life Plan Brand Management
St. Peter Life Plan Brand Management
 
business plan for Start Up template
business plan for Start Up template business plan for Start Up template
business plan for Start Up template
 
Project study on establishing lending business
Project study on establishing lending businessProject study on establishing lending business
Project study on establishing lending business
 
Certificate of Achievement Team Building
Certificate of Achievement Team BuildingCertificate of Achievement Team Building
Certificate of Achievement Team Building
 
Marketing plan PDF report
Marketing plan PDF reportMarketing plan PDF report
Marketing plan PDF report
 
Relevance of the Course.pdf
Relevance of the Course.pdfRelevance of the Course.pdf
Relevance of the Course.pdf
 
4 m's of production
4 m's of production 4 m's of production
4 m's of production
 
Site location, map reading and lot plotting,
Site location, map reading and lot plotting, Site location, map reading and lot plotting,
Site location, map reading and lot plotting,
 
Manila Comprehensive Land Use Plan
Manila Comprehensive Land Use PlanManila Comprehensive Land Use Plan
Manila Comprehensive Land Use Plan
 
THE DISCIPLINE OF SOCIAL WORK
THE DISCIPLINE OF SOCIAL WORKTHE DISCIPLINE OF SOCIAL WORK
THE DISCIPLINE OF SOCIAL WORK
 
Business Proposal for Soft Line Cafe to operate at Al Yamamah University
Business Proposal for Soft Line Cafe to operate at Al Yamamah UniversityBusiness Proposal for Soft Line Cafe to operate at Al Yamamah University
Business Proposal for Soft Line Cafe to operate at Al Yamamah University
 
Asian Corner-Asian Street Food Takeaway Business Plan
Asian Corner-Asian Street Food Takeaway Business PlanAsian Corner-Asian Street Food Takeaway Business Plan
Asian Corner-Asian Street Food Takeaway Business Plan
 

Viewers also liked

2010 Mercedes-Benz GLK350 CPO
2010 Mercedes-Benz GLK350 CPO2010 Mercedes-Benz GLK350 CPO
2010 Mercedes-Benz GLK350 CPO
Stradablog
 
Global Auto Executive Survey 2016
Global Auto Executive Survey 2016Global Auto Executive Survey 2016
Global Auto Executive Survey 2016
Stradablog
 
Canadian Brand Telemetry Report
Canadian Brand Telemetry ReportCanadian Brand Telemetry Report
Canadian Brand Telemetry Report
Stradablog
 
Its The Experience
Its The ExperienceIts The Experience
Its The Experience
Stradablog
 
2012 Ford F150
2012 Ford F1502012 Ford F150
2012 Ford F150
Stradablog
 
Profile Maj 2011 Feb9
Profile Maj 2011 Feb9Profile Maj 2011 Feb9
Profile Maj 2011 Feb9
azaharij
 
2013 Infiniti JX35
2013 Infiniti JX352013 Infiniti JX35
2013 Infiniti JX35
Stradablog
 
2015 Ram Big Horn
2015 Ram Big Horn2015 Ram Big Horn
2015 Ram Big HornStradablog
 
2015 Camaro SS Convertible
2015 Camaro SS Convertible2015 Camaro SS Convertible
2015 Camaro SS Convertible
Stradablog
 
Marketing The Mercedes Way
Marketing The Mercedes WayMarketing The Mercedes Way
Marketing The Mercedes Way
Stradablog
 
Biotecnologia reproductiva (trabajo)
Biotecnologia reproductiva (trabajo)Biotecnologia reproductiva (trabajo)
Biotecnologia reproductiva (trabajo)
Victor Rios
 
Automotive Revolution Perspective Towards 2030
Automotive Revolution Perspective Towards 2030Automotive Revolution Perspective Towards 2030
Automotive Revolution Perspective Towards 2030
Stradablog
 
Highly Automated Driving
Highly Automated DrivingHighly Automated Driving
Highly Automated Driving
Stradablog
 
Disrupt Yourself
Disrupt YourselfDisrupt Yourself
Disrupt Yourself
Stradablog
 
Canadian Sales First Half 2016
Canadian Sales First Half 2016Canadian Sales First Half 2016
Canadian Sales First Half 2016
Stradablog
 
Digital Reroutes The Auto Purchase Journey
Digital Reroutes The Auto Purchase JourneyDigital Reroutes The Auto Purchase Journey
Digital Reroutes The Auto Purchase Journey
Stradablog
 
The Future of Mobility
The Future of MobilityThe Future of Mobility
The Future of Mobility
Stradablog
 

Viewers also liked (17)

2010 Mercedes-Benz GLK350 CPO
2010 Mercedes-Benz GLK350 CPO2010 Mercedes-Benz GLK350 CPO
2010 Mercedes-Benz GLK350 CPO
 
Global Auto Executive Survey 2016
Global Auto Executive Survey 2016Global Auto Executive Survey 2016
Global Auto Executive Survey 2016
 
Canadian Brand Telemetry Report
Canadian Brand Telemetry ReportCanadian Brand Telemetry Report
Canadian Brand Telemetry Report
 
Its The Experience
Its The ExperienceIts The Experience
Its The Experience
 
2012 Ford F150
2012 Ford F1502012 Ford F150
2012 Ford F150
 
Profile Maj 2011 Feb9
Profile Maj 2011 Feb9Profile Maj 2011 Feb9
Profile Maj 2011 Feb9
 
2013 Infiniti JX35
2013 Infiniti JX352013 Infiniti JX35
2013 Infiniti JX35
 
2015 Ram Big Horn
2015 Ram Big Horn2015 Ram Big Horn
2015 Ram Big Horn
 
2015 Camaro SS Convertible
2015 Camaro SS Convertible2015 Camaro SS Convertible
2015 Camaro SS Convertible
 
Marketing The Mercedes Way
Marketing The Mercedes WayMarketing The Mercedes Way
Marketing The Mercedes Way
 
Biotecnologia reproductiva (trabajo)
Biotecnologia reproductiva (trabajo)Biotecnologia reproductiva (trabajo)
Biotecnologia reproductiva (trabajo)
 
Automotive Revolution Perspective Towards 2030
Automotive Revolution Perspective Towards 2030Automotive Revolution Perspective Towards 2030
Automotive Revolution Perspective Towards 2030
 
Highly Automated Driving
Highly Automated DrivingHighly Automated Driving
Highly Automated Driving
 
Disrupt Yourself
Disrupt YourselfDisrupt Yourself
Disrupt Yourself
 
Canadian Sales First Half 2016
Canadian Sales First Half 2016Canadian Sales First Half 2016
Canadian Sales First Half 2016
 
Digital Reroutes The Auto Purchase Journey
Digital Reroutes The Auto Purchase JourneyDigital Reroutes The Auto Purchase Journey
Digital Reroutes The Auto Purchase Journey
 
The Future of Mobility
The Future of MobilityThe Future of Mobility
The Future of Mobility
 

Similar to Confessions of Capital Junkie

3M Company at J.P. Morgan Aviation, Transportation and Industrials Conference...
3M Company at J.P. Morgan Aviation, Transportation and Industrials Conference...3M Company at J.P. Morgan Aviation, Transportation and Industrials Conference...
3M Company at J.P. Morgan Aviation, Transportation and Industrials Conference...
Investors_3M
 
3M Company JP Morgan Conference
3M Company JP Morgan Conference3M Company JP Morgan Conference
3M Company JP Morgan Conference
Investors_3M
 
Lkq jp-morgan-auto-conference-2018-investor-presentation
Lkq jp-morgan-auto-conference-2018-investor-presentationLkq jp-morgan-auto-conference-2018-investor-presentation
Lkq jp-morgan-auto-conference-2018-investor-presentation
corporationlkq
 
3M Company at Bank of America Merrill Lynch Global Industrials & EU Autos Con...
3M Company at Bank of America Merrill Lynch Global Industrials & EU Autos Con...3M Company at Bank of America Merrill Lynch Global Industrials & EU Autos Con...
3M Company at Bank of America Merrill Lynch Global Industrials & EU Autos Con...
Investors_3M
 
Toronto presentation sep 2013 final_v001_d730n6
Toronto presentation sep 2013 final_v001_d730n6Toronto presentation sep 2013 final_v001_d730n6
Toronto presentation sep 2013 final_v001_d730n6FinningInternational
 
Ifc investor-presentation-(november-2016)
Ifc investor-presentation-(november-2016)Ifc investor-presentation-(november-2016)
Ifc investor-presentation-(november-2016)
Intact
 
Jaguar land-rover-acquisition-part-1
Jaguar land-rover-acquisition-part-1Jaguar land-rover-acquisition-part-1
Jaguar land-rover-acquisition-part-1
Akshay Hakay
 
Automotive Repair and Maintenance Services Market to Reach US$ 750 Bn by 2026
Automotive Repair and Maintenance Services Market to Reach US$ 750 Bn by 2026Automotive Repair and Maintenance Services Market to Reach US$ 750 Bn by 2026
Automotive Repair and Maintenance Services Market to Reach US$ 750 Bn by 2026
Ankush Nikam
 
Passenger Cars After Market Global Market Report 2021: COVID-19 Growth And Ch...
Passenger Cars After Market Global Market Report 2021: COVID-19 Growth And Ch...Passenger Cars After Market Global Market Report 2021: COVID-19 Growth And Ch...
Passenger Cars After Market Global Market Report 2021: COVID-19 Growth And Ch...
Sreeramakrishna B
 
Ford Motors Case Analysis
Ford Motors Case AnalysisFord Motors Case Analysis
Ford Motors Case AnalysisWilliam Duncan
 
January 2020 vwag_investor_roadshow
January 2020 vwag_investor_roadshowJanuary 2020 vwag_investor_roadshow
January 2020 vwag_investor_roadshow
Maurizio Buso
 
Netsol technologies Investor Presentation 2021
Netsol technologies Investor Presentation 2021Netsol technologies Investor Presentation 2021
Netsol technologies Investor Presentation 2021
RedChip Companies, Inc.
 
Ifc investor-presentation-(september-2016)
Ifc investor-presentation-(september-2016)Ifc investor-presentation-(september-2016)
Ifc investor-presentation-(september-2016)
Intact
 
Oxford Brookes ACCA applied account RAP THESIS (OBU) The Business and finan...
  Oxford Brookes ACCA applied account RAP THESIS (OBU) The Business and finan...  Oxford Brookes ACCA applied account RAP THESIS (OBU) The Business and finan...
Oxford Brookes ACCA applied account RAP THESIS (OBU) The Business and finan...
Academic Mania
 
Imperial Capital - Daimler - Final
Imperial Capital - Daimler - FinalImperial Capital - Daimler - Final
Imperial Capital - Daimler - FinalIgor Kalota
 
Ifc investor-presentation-(august-2016)
Ifc investor-presentation-(august-2016)Ifc investor-presentation-(august-2016)
Ifc investor-presentation-(august-2016)
Intact
 
Investor Presentation June 2016
Investor Presentation June 2016Investor Presentation June 2016
Investor Presentation June 2016
Intact
 
Coronavirus Impact Assessment And Mitigation Strategies In Automobile Industr...
Coronavirus Impact Assessment And Mitigation Strategies In Automobile Industr...Coronavirus Impact Assessment And Mitigation Strategies In Automobile Industr...
Coronavirus Impact Assessment And Mitigation Strategies In Automobile Industr...
SlideTeam
 

Similar to Confessions of Capital Junkie (20)

3M Company at J.P. Morgan Aviation, Transportation and Industrials Conference...
3M Company at J.P. Morgan Aviation, Transportation and Industrials Conference...3M Company at J.P. Morgan Aviation, Transportation and Industrials Conference...
3M Company at J.P. Morgan Aviation, Transportation and Industrials Conference...
 
3M Company JP Morgan Conference
3M Company JP Morgan Conference3M Company JP Morgan Conference
3M Company JP Morgan Conference
 
Lkq jp-morgan-auto-conference-2018-investor-presentation
Lkq jp-morgan-auto-conference-2018-investor-presentationLkq jp-morgan-auto-conference-2018-investor-presentation
Lkq jp-morgan-auto-conference-2018-investor-presentation
 
Research report
Research reportResearch report
Research report
 
3M Company at Bank of America Merrill Lynch Global Industrials & EU Autos Con...
3M Company at Bank of America Merrill Lynch Global Industrials & EU Autos Con...3M Company at Bank of America Merrill Lynch Global Industrials & EU Autos Con...
3M Company at Bank of America Merrill Lynch Global Industrials & EU Autos Con...
 
Toronto presentation sep 2013 final_v001_d730n6
Toronto presentation sep 2013 final_v001_d730n6Toronto presentation sep 2013 final_v001_d730n6
Toronto presentation sep 2013 final_v001_d730n6
 
Ifc investor-presentation-(november-2016)
Ifc investor-presentation-(november-2016)Ifc investor-presentation-(november-2016)
Ifc investor-presentation-(november-2016)
 
firm analysis
firm analysisfirm analysis
firm analysis
 
Jaguar land-rover-acquisition-part-1
Jaguar land-rover-acquisition-part-1Jaguar land-rover-acquisition-part-1
Jaguar land-rover-acquisition-part-1
 
Automotive Repair and Maintenance Services Market to Reach US$ 750 Bn by 2026
Automotive Repair and Maintenance Services Market to Reach US$ 750 Bn by 2026Automotive Repair and Maintenance Services Market to Reach US$ 750 Bn by 2026
Automotive Repair and Maintenance Services Market to Reach US$ 750 Bn by 2026
 
Passenger Cars After Market Global Market Report 2021: COVID-19 Growth And Ch...
Passenger Cars After Market Global Market Report 2021: COVID-19 Growth And Ch...Passenger Cars After Market Global Market Report 2021: COVID-19 Growth And Ch...
Passenger Cars After Market Global Market Report 2021: COVID-19 Growth And Ch...
 
Ford Motors Case Analysis
Ford Motors Case AnalysisFord Motors Case Analysis
Ford Motors Case Analysis
 
January 2020 vwag_investor_roadshow
January 2020 vwag_investor_roadshowJanuary 2020 vwag_investor_roadshow
January 2020 vwag_investor_roadshow
 
Netsol technologies Investor Presentation 2021
Netsol technologies Investor Presentation 2021Netsol technologies Investor Presentation 2021
Netsol technologies Investor Presentation 2021
 
Ifc investor-presentation-(september-2016)
Ifc investor-presentation-(september-2016)Ifc investor-presentation-(september-2016)
Ifc investor-presentation-(september-2016)
 
Oxford Brookes ACCA applied account RAP THESIS (OBU) The Business and finan...
  Oxford Brookes ACCA applied account RAP THESIS (OBU) The Business and finan...  Oxford Brookes ACCA applied account RAP THESIS (OBU) The Business and finan...
Oxford Brookes ACCA applied account RAP THESIS (OBU) The Business and finan...
 
Imperial Capital - Daimler - Final
Imperial Capital - Daimler - FinalImperial Capital - Daimler - Final
Imperial Capital - Daimler - Final
 
Ifc investor-presentation-(august-2016)
Ifc investor-presentation-(august-2016)Ifc investor-presentation-(august-2016)
Ifc investor-presentation-(august-2016)
 
Investor Presentation June 2016
Investor Presentation June 2016Investor Presentation June 2016
Investor Presentation June 2016
 
Coronavirus Impact Assessment And Mitigation Strategies In Automobile Industr...
Coronavirus Impact Assessment And Mitigation Strategies In Automobile Industr...Coronavirus Impact Assessment And Mitigation Strategies In Automobile Industr...
Coronavirus Impact Assessment And Mitigation Strategies In Automobile Industr...
 

More from Stradablog

Canadian Sales 2016
Canadian Sales 2016Canadian Sales 2016
Canadian Sales 2016
Stradablog
 
Cars Online Trend Study 2016
Cars Online Trend Study 2016Cars Online Trend Study 2016
Cars Online Trend Study 2016
Stradablog
 
2017 Honda Ridgeline
2017 Honda Ridgeline2017 Honda Ridgeline
2017 Honda Ridgeline
Stradablog
 
2017 Subaru WRX STi
2017 Subaru WRX STi2017 Subaru WRX STi
2017 Subaru WRX STi
Stradablog
 
Forks In The Road
Forks In The RoadForks In The Road
Forks In The Road
Stradablog
 
Canadian Sales Three Quarter 2016
Canadian Sales Three Quarter 2016Canadian Sales Three Quarter 2016
Canadian Sales Three Quarter 2016
Stradablog
 
Automated Vehicles
Automated VehiclesAutomated Vehicles
Automated Vehicles
Stradablog
 
2016 Cadillac CT6
2016 Cadillac CT62016 Cadillac CT6
2016 Cadillac CT6
Stradablog
 
2016 Chevrolet Malibu
2016 Chevrolet Malibu2016 Chevrolet Malibu
2016 Chevrolet Malibu
Stradablog
 
2016 Toyota Prius V
2016 Toyota Prius V2016 Toyota Prius V
2016 Toyota Prius V
Stradablog
 
2016 Canadian CEO Outlook
2016 Canadian CEO Outlook2016 Canadian CEO Outlook
2016 Canadian CEO Outlook
Stradablog
 
2016 Toyota Tacoma
2016 Toyota Tacoma2016 Toyota Tacoma
2016 Toyota Tacoma
Stradablog
 
2016 Honda Civic
2016 Honda Civic2016 Honda Civic
2016 Honda Civic
Stradablog
 
Market Metrics April 2016
Market Metrics April 2016Market Metrics April 2016
Market Metrics April 2016
Stradablog
 
Canadian Sales First Quarter 2016
Canadian Sales First Quarter 2016Canadian Sales First Quarter 2016
Canadian Sales First Quarter 2016
Stradablog
 
2016 Chevrolet Colorado
2016 Chevrolet Colorado2016 Chevrolet Colorado
2016 Chevrolet Colorado
Stradablog
 
Attention is a Currency
Attention is a CurrencyAttention is a Currency
Attention is a Currency
Stradablog
 
Creeping Auto Loans
Creeping Auto LoansCreeping Auto Loans
Creeping Auto Loans
Stradablog
 
Market Metrics - January 2016
Market Metrics - January 2016Market Metrics - January 2016
Market Metrics - January 2016
Stradablog
 
Disruptive Trends That Will Transform The Automotive Industry
Disruptive Trends That Will Transform The Automotive IndustryDisruptive Trends That Will Transform The Automotive Industry
Disruptive Trends That Will Transform The Automotive Industry
Stradablog
 

More from Stradablog (20)

Canadian Sales 2016
Canadian Sales 2016Canadian Sales 2016
Canadian Sales 2016
 
Cars Online Trend Study 2016
Cars Online Trend Study 2016Cars Online Trend Study 2016
Cars Online Trend Study 2016
 
2017 Honda Ridgeline
2017 Honda Ridgeline2017 Honda Ridgeline
2017 Honda Ridgeline
 
2017 Subaru WRX STi
2017 Subaru WRX STi2017 Subaru WRX STi
2017 Subaru WRX STi
 
Forks In The Road
Forks In The RoadForks In The Road
Forks In The Road
 
Canadian Sales Three Quarter 2016
Canadian Sales Three Quarter 2016Canadian Sales Three Quarter 2016
Canadian Sales Three Quarter 2016
 
Automated Vehicles
Automated VehiclesAutomated Vehicles
Automated Vehicles
 
2016 Cadillac CT6
2016 Cadillac CT62016 Cadillac CT6
2016 Cadillac CT6
 
2016 Chevrolet Malibu
2016 Chevrolet Malibu2016 Chevrolet Malibu
2016 Chevrolet Malibu
 
2016 Toyota Prius V
2016 Toyota Prius V2016 Toyota Prius V
2016 Toyota Prius V
 
2016 Canadian CEO Outlook
2016 Canadian CEO Outlook2016 Canadian CEO Outlook
2016 Canadian CEO Outlook
 
2016 Toyota Tacoma
2016 Toyota Tacoma2016 Toyota Tacoma
2016 Toyota Tacoma
 
2016 Honda Civic
2016 Honda Civic2016 Honda Civic
2016 Honda Civic
 
Market Metrics April 2016
Market Metrics April 2016Market Metrics April 2016
Market Metrics April 2016
 
Canadian Sales First Quarter 2016
Canadian Sales First Quarter 2016Canadian Sales First Quarter 2016
Canadian Sales First Quarter 2016
 
2016 Chevrolet Colorado
2016 Chevrolet Colorado2016 Chevrolet Colorado
2016 Chevrolet Colorado
 
Attention is a Currency
Attention is a CurrencyAttention is a Currency
Attention is a Currency
 
Creeping Auto Loans
Creeping Auto LoansCreeping Auto Loans
Creeping Auto Loans
 
Market Metrics - January 2016
Market Metrics - January 2016Market Metrics - January 2016
Market Metrics - January 2016
 
Disruptive Trends That Will Transform The Automotive Industry
Disruptive Trends That Will Transform The Automotive IndustryDisruptive Trends That Will Transform The Automotive Industry
Disruptive Trends That Will Transform The Automotive Industry
 

Recently uploaded

5 Red Flags Your VW Camshaft Position Sensor Might Be Failing
5 Red Flags Your VW Camshaft Position Sensor Might Be Failing5 Red Flags Your VW Camshaft Position Sensor Might Be Failing
5 Red Flags Your VW Camshaft Position Sensor Might Be Failing
Fifth Gear Automotive Cross Roads
 
一比一原版(AIS毕业证)奥克兰商学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(AIS毕业证)奥克兰商学院毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版(AIS毕业证)奥克兰商学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(AIS毕业证)奥克兰商学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
eygkup
 
What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5
What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5
What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5
European Service Center
 
One compartment Model Deliverdddddded.pdf
One compartment Model Deliverdddddded.pdfOne compartment Model Deliverdddddded.pdf
One compartment Model Deliverdddddded.pdf
RehanRustam2
 
Why Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release Commands
Why Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release CommandsWhy Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release Commands
Why Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release Commands
Dart Auto
 
Bài tập - Tiếng anh 11 Global Success UNIT 1 - Bản HS.doc
Bài tập - Tiếng anh 11 Global Success UNIT 1 - Bản HS.docBài tập - Tiếng anh 11 Global Success UNIT 1 - Bản HS.doc
Bài tập - Tiếng anh 11 Global Success UNIT 1 - Bản HS.doc
daothibichhang1
 
Hero Glamour Xtec Brochure | Hero MotoCorp
Hero Glamour Xtec Brochure | Hero MotoCorpHero Glamour Xtec Brochure | Hero MotoCorp
Hero Glamour Xtec Brochure | Hero MotoCorp
Hero MotoCorp
 
一比一原版(AUT毕业证)奥克兰理工大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(AUT毕业证)奥克兰理工大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版(AUT毕业证)奥克兰理工大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(AUT毕业证)奥克兰理工大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
mymwpc
 
What Could Cause The Headlights On Your Porsche 911 To Stop Working
What Could Cause The Headlights On Your Porsche 911 To Stop WorkingWhat Could Cause The Headlights On Your Porsche 911 To Stop Working
What Could Cause The Headlights On Your Porsche 911 To Stop Working
Lancer Service
 
Antique Plastic Traders Company Profile
Antique Plastic Traders Company ProfileAntique Plastic Traders Company Profile
Antique Plastic Traders Company Profile
Antique Plastic Traders
 
Empowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs Consulting SMEs.pptx
Empowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs  Consulting SMEs.pptxEmpowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs  Consulting SMEs.pptx
Empowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs Consulting SMEs.pptx
Precious Mvulane CA (SA),RA
 
Statistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptx
Statistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptxStatistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptx
Statistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptx
coc7987515756
 
Wondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to Tell
Wondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to TellWondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to Tell
Wondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to Tell
Vic Auto Collision & Repair
 
TRANSFORMER OIL classifications and specifications
TRANSFORMER OIL classifications and specificationsTRANSFORMER OIL classifications and specifications
TRANSFORMER OIL classifications and specifications
vishnup11
 
一比一原版(OP毕业证)奥塔哥理工学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(OP毕业证)奥塔哥理工学院毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版(OP毕业证)奥塔哥理工学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(OP毕业证)奥塔哥理工学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
mymwpc
 
AadiShakti Projects ( Asp Cranes ) Raipur
AadiShakti Projects ( Asp Cranes ) RaipurAadiShakti Projects ( Asp Cranes ) Raipur
AadiShakti Projects ( Asp Cranes ) Raipur
AadiShakti Projects
 
What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...
What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...
What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...
Autohaus Service and Sales
 
欧洲杯比赛投注官网-欧洲杯比赛投注官网网站-欧洲杯比赛投注官网|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】
欧洲杯比赛投注官网-欧洲杯比赛投注官网网站-欧洲杯比赛投注官网|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】欧洲杯比赛投注官网-欧洲杯比赛投注官网网站-欧洲杯比赛投注官网|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】
欧洲杯比赛投注官网-欧洲杯比赛投注官网网站-欧洲杯比赛投注官网|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】
ahmedendrise81
 
Digital Fleet Management - Why Your Business Need It?
Digital Fleet Management - Why Your Business Need It?Digital Fleet Management - Why Your Business Need It?
Digital Fleet Management - Why Your Business Need It?
jennifermiller8137
 
TRAINEES-RECORD-BOOK- electronics and electrical
TRAINEES-RECORD-BOOK- electronics and electricalTRAINEES-RECORD-BOOK- electronics and electrical
TRAINEES-RECORD-BOOK- electronics and electrical
JohnCarloPajarilloKa
 

Recently uploaded (20)

5 Red Flags Your VW Camshaft Position Sensor Might Be Failing
5 Red Flags Your VW Camshaft Position Sensor Might Be Failing5 Red Flags Your VW Camshaft Position Sensor Might Be Failing
5 Red Flags Your VW Camshaft Position Sensor Might Be Failing
 
一比一原版(AIS毕业证)奥克兰商学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(AIS毕业证)奥克兰商学院毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版(AIS毕业证)奥克兰商学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(AIS毕业证)奥克兰商学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
 
What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5
What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5
What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5
 
One compartment Model Deliverdddddded.pdf
One compartment Model Deliverdddddded.pdfOne compartment Model Deliverdddddded.pdf
One compartment Model Deliverdddddded.pdf
 
Why Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release Commands
Why Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release CommandsWhy Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release Commands
Why Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release Commands
 
Bài tập - Tiếng anh 11 Global Success UNIT 1 - Bản HS.doc
Bài tập - Tiếng anh 11 Global Success UNIT 1 - Bản HS.docBài tập - Tiếng anh 11 Global Success UNIT 1 - Bản HS.doc
Bài tập - Tiếng anh 11 Global Success UNIT 1 - Bản HS.doc
 
Hero Glamour Xtec Brochure | Hero MotoCorp
Hero Glamour Xtec Brochure | Hero MotoCorpHero Glamour Xtec Brochure | Hero MotoCorp
Hero Glamour Xtec Brochure | Hero MotoCorp
 
一比一原版(AUT毕业证)奥克兰理工大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(AUT毕业证)奥克兰理工大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版(AUT毕业证)奥克兰理工大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(AUT毕业证)奥克兰理工大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
 
What Could Cause The Headlights On Your Porsche 911 To Stop Working
What Could Cause The Headlights On Your Porsche 911 To Stop WorkingWhat Could Cause The Headlights On Your Porsche 911 To Stop Working
What Could Cause The Headlights On Your Porsche 911 To Stop Working
 
Antique Plastic Traders Company Profile
Antique Plastic Traders Company ProfileAntique Plastic Traders Company Profile
Antique Plastic Traders Company Profile
 
Empowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs Consulting SMEs.pptx
Empowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs  Consulting SMEs.pptxEmpowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs  Consulting SMEs.pptx
Empowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs Consulting SMEs.pptx
 
Statistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptx
Statistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptxStatistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptx
Statistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptx
 
Wondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to Tell
Wondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to TellWondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to Tell
Wondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to Tell
 
TRANSFORMER OIL classifications and specifications
TRANSFORMER OIL classifications and specificationsTRANSFORMER OIL classifications and specifications
TRANSFORMER OIL classifications and specifications
 
一比一原版(OP毕业证)奥塔哥理工学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(OP毕业证)奥塔哥理工学院毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版(OP毕业证)奥塔哥理工学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版(OP毕业证)奥塔哥理工学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
 
AadiShakti Projects ( Asp Cranes ) Raipur
AadiShakti Projects ( Asp Cranes ) RaipurAadiShakti Projects ( Asp Cranes ) Raipur
AadiShakti Projects ( Asp Cranes ) Raipur
 
What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...
What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...
What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...
 
欧洲杯比赛投注官网-欧洲杯比赛投注官网网站-欧洲杯比赛投注官网|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】
欧洲杯比赛投注官网-欧洲杯比赛投注官网网站-欧洲杯比赛投注官网|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】欧洲杯比赛投注官网-欧洲杯比赛投注官网网站-欧洲杯比赛投注官网|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】
欧洲杯比赛投注官网-欧洲杯比赛投注官网网站-欧洲杯比赛投注官网|【​网址​🎉ac123.net🎉​】
 
Digital Fleet Management - Why Your Business Need It?
Digital Fleet Management - Why Your Business Need It?Digital Fleet Management - Why Your Business Need It?
Digital Fleet Management - Why Your Business Need It?
 
TRAINEES-RECORD-BOOK- electronics and electrical
TRAINEES-RECORD-BOOK- electronics and electricalTRAINEES-RECORD-BOOK- electronics and electrical
TRAINEES-RECORD-BOOK- electronics and electrical
 

Confessions of Capital Junkie

  • 1. Confessions of a Capital Junkie April 29, 2015 An insider perspective on the cure for the industry's value-destroying addiction to capital
  • 2. Safe Harbor Statement 2April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie This document contains forward-looking statements. These statements may include terms such as “may”, “will”, “expect”, “could”, “should”, “intend”, “estimate”, “anticipate”, “believe”, “remain”, “on track”, “design”, “target”, “objective”, “goal”, “forecast”, “projection”, “outlook”, “prospects”, “plan”, “intend”, or similar terms. Forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance. Rather, they are based on the Group’s current expectations and projections about future events and, by their nature, are subject to inherent risks and uncertainties. They relate to events and depend on circumstances that may or may not occur or exist in the future and, as such, undue reliance should not be placed on them. Actual results may differ materially from those expressed in such statements as a result of a variety of factors, including: the future capital expenditures and research and development expenses of the Group and the industry, potential benefits from industry consolidation; developments in global financial markets and general economic and other conditions; changes in demand for automotive products, which is highly cyclical; the high level of competition in the automotive industry; the Group’s ability to realize anticipated benefits from any business combinations, joint venture arrangements and other strategic alliances; the Group’s ability to integrate its operations; the Group’s ability to access funding to execute the Group’s business plan and improve the Group’s business, financial condition and results of operations; operating expenditures including in relation to vehicle and powertrain development and compliance with regulations; exchange rate fluctuations, interest rate changes, credit risk and other market risks; our ability to achieve the benefits expected from any capital optimzation plans; and other risks and uncertainties. Any forward-looking statements contained in this document speak only as of the date of this document and the Company does not undertake any obligation to update or revise publicly forward-looking statements. Further information concerning the Group and its businesses, including factors that could materially affect the Company’s financial results, is included in the Company’s reports and filings with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, the AFM and CONSOB.
  • 3. Purpose of the pitch April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 3  Goal is to provide clarity on two issues that have been raised publicly by FCA ● Industry has not earned its cost of capital over a cycle ● Consolidation is the key to remedying the problem  What this is not about ● An excuse for FCA’s current ranking in the automotive food chain ● Putting FCA up for sale ● A revision to our 5 year plan (which remains a firm commitment) ● A matter of life or death for FCA ● SM’s final big deal  What this is about ● Dispassionate look at the industry from the outside using insider knowledge ● It is about choosing between mediocrity or fundamentally changing the paradigm for the industry
  • 4. Before we get into this, we should be reminded that … April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie “Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not to his own facts.” Daniel Patrick Moynihan (Former US Senator and Ambassador to the UN) 4
  • 5. Auto industry’s capex and R&D requirements have grown significantly over the past years … April 29, 2015 5Confessions of a Capital Junkie Top OEMs1—Total capex + R&D spending over last 5 years (€bn)2 CAGR: Mainstream OEMs: ~12% Premium OEMs: ~10% Mainstream OEMs Premium OEMs Source: Company annual reports 1 Includes mainstream OEMs: FCA, Ford, General Motors, Honda, Hyundai, Kia, Nissan, PSA, Renault, Toyota, Volkswagen. Premium OEMs: BMW, Daimler Cars 2 Translated at constant 2010 exchange rates (average January to December 2010) 64 78 91 99 104 12 14 17 19 18 76 91 107 117 122 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
  • 6. ... and going forward, new technological challenges will continue to raise the bar on capital requirements 6April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie Forces at work increasing capital requirements—Selected examples Auto OEMs Emissions regulations Safety regulations Car connectivity and autonomy  Tighter emissions regulations  Costly new powertrains  Weight-saving technologies  Stricter regulations and customer focus on safety  Adoption of state-of-the- art safety technologies across markets  New infotainment services  Customer expectations on connected cars  Autonomous drive push Regulatory-driven Customer-driven
  • 7. Product development costs are consuming value at a much faster rate than in other industries … April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 7 Time to reinvest enterprise value1 in product development (capital and R&D)2 1 Industrial activities only. Including pension liabilities 2 Calculated as 3-year average of the annual ratio between enterprise value (for the period 2012–2014) and capital expenditures plus R&D expenses 3 Based on the reference sample Source: Company annual reports ~ ~ 1.3 2.6 3.1 3.2 3.4 3.4 3.6 3.8 4.0 5.0 7.8 8.5 OEM3 FCA OEM1 OEM9 OEM10 OEM5 PremiumOEM OEM7 OEM2 OEM8 OEM6 OEM4 7 13 18 19 20 23 28 36 Oil&Gas Telecommunication Pharma Aerospace& Defence Chemicals Packaging materials Buildingmaterials Consumer&Retail Average across industries3: ~20 years ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Auto industry average: ~4.1 years ~ Average number of yearsAverage number of years
  • 8. ... and high operational leverage amplifies profitability swings across the cycle ... April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 8 1 EBIT defined as Industrial reported EBIT plus income from equity accounted investments and excludes goodwill impairment. EBIT as per accounting principles adopted by each company 2 Mainstream OEMs include: FCA, Ford, General Motors, Honda, Hyundai, Kia, Nissan, PSA, Renault, Toyota, Volkswagen Source: Company annual reports EBIT Margin1 of Auto OEMs vs other sectors (%) 2 (3%) 8% 19% 30% 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Aerospace & Defence Building materials Chemicals Consumer products Packaging Pharmaceuticals Telecommunications Premium OEM Mainstream OEMs
  • 9. … resulting in structurally low and volatile returns April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 9 1 ROIC calculated as [Industrial reported EBIT x (1-taxes) + income from equity accounted investments] / Industrial Net Invested capital. Assumed a normalized tax rate equal to 30%. EBIT excludes goodwill impairment. Industrial Net Invested capital is defined as industrial Trade Working Capital + Industrial PP&E + Industrial Intangibles (excl. Goodwill) + Book Value of equity accounted investments + operating cash for OEMs (assumed at 12.5% of industrial sales). EBIT as per accounting principles adopted by each company 2 Mainstream OEMs include: FCA, Ford, General Motors, Honda, Hyundai, Kia, Nissan, PSA, Renault, Toyota, Volkswagen ROIC1 of Auto OEMs vs other sectors (%) 2 (10%) 0 10% 20% 30% 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Aerospace & defence Building materials Chemicals Consumer Packaging materials Pharma Telecommunications Premium OEM Mainstream OEMs Consensus WACC: ~9%
  • 10. April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie Typical vehicle development costs 1 Chart scale based on mid-point of range shown New vehicle program—development costs split1 10 Why did this happen? OEMs spend vast amounts of capital to develop proprietary components, many not really discernible to customers 45–50% 50–55% Differentiating products/ technologies Products/technologies “undiscernible to customer”, potentially overlapping with competitors Vehicle R&D ~40% Vehicle Tooling ~35% Powetrain/ R&D ~15% Powetrain Tooling ~5% Other ~5%
  • 11. One industry solution focuses on reducing the number of active platforms and increasing scale … Confessions of a Capital Junkie SOURCE: IHS 1 Adjusted to include only platforms with at least 2,000 cars manufactured in a given year 2 Including FCA, Ford, GM, Honda, Hyundai, PSA, Renault/Nissan, Suzuki, Toyota, Volkswagen Active platforms by OEM1 Average across top 10 global OEMs 2004 -20% 20142009 Number of top hats by platform2 Average across top 10 global OEMs 2004 2.5 3.3 +30% 20142009 2.6 11 "More of our components will be common, and more of our vehicles will be on global architectures" Dan Akerson, GM (2011) "I'm really proud to say that we've reduced that number down to 12 global platforms. In 2016 we'll reduce that down to a further nine global platforms, and our team is working towards a further consolidation of that to get down to a long-term target now of eight global platforms […] that obviously yields tremendous benefits for us as an enterprise” Raj Nair, Ford Group Vice President-Global Product Development (2015) 22 21 18 April 29, 2015
  • 12. April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie Source: IHS—Global 2018 Sales database as of April 2015, Toyota global newsroom 12 C-CUV (2016) Polo (2016) Golf SportVan Passat Touran Jetta (2016) Tiguan (2016) CC (2017) B-CUV (2016) C-MPV (2017) C-CUV (2016) Q1 (2016) A3 Q3 (2018) Superb Yeti (2017) LeonLamando Scirocco (2018) B-CUV (2018) MQB ARCHITECTURE Golf Spacefox (2018) Fox (2017) Voyage (2018) A1 (2018) Octavia Ibiza (2016) TT Crossblue Crossblue coupe (2018) Sagitar (2017) Golf SportWagen MC-M ARCHITECTURE MebiusWish Voxy Venza Sienna SAI RAV4 Prius Alpha (Prius V) Prius Mirai Highlander Harrier Estima Camry Avensis Avalon Alphard ES HS NX RX Lavida (2018) … and some OEMs are trying larger scale commonization across diverse brands … “By the middle of 2020, we plan to expand TNGA (Toyota New Generation Architecture) to approximately half of the line-up […] —Traditionally we have tended to focus on developing individual models and lacked the total alignment and consistency, which will change with a company-wide effort.” Mitsuhisa Kato, Toyota Executive VP (2015)
  • 13. April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie Successful Failed 13 … while others through one-off co-operations, JVs and other equity tie-ups One-off industrial co-operations Cross-shareholdings— enabled co-operations Full integration Expectedimpactatthetimeofthedeal Low High Low/negativeHigh Level of integration Long-term industrial co-operations (JVs)
  • 14. But all this has produced poor results so far, as OEMs' returns and valuations are still depressed April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 14 2014 ROIC 2014 EV/EBITDA2 1 Mainstream OEMs include: FCA, Ford, General Motors, Hyundai, Honda, Kia, Nissan, PSA, Renault, Toyota, Volkswagen 2 Based on 2014 average enterprise value for the companies in the reference sample. EV including pension liabilities. EBITDA as per accounting principles adopted by each company 4.0x 6.2x 6.8x 9.0x 9.1x 10.7x 11.0x 11.1x 13.0x MainstreamOEMs Oil&Gas Telecommunications AerospaceandDefence Packagingmaterials Chemicals Buildingmaterials Consumer&Retail Pharma 7.8% 10% 11% 12% 13% 14% 16% 19% 22% MainstreamOEMs Oil&Gas Telecommunications Buildingmaterials Chemicals Packagingmaterials AerospaceandDefence Pharma Consumer&Retail 1 1
  • 15. Why haven’t these approaches provided a significant lift to returns? April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie  Large scale organic reduction in platforms ● Reluctance to replace old, less costly architectures ● Option available only to those OEMs with existing scale across platforms, top hats and regions ● Requires strict discipline to avoid upward standardization/over engineering ● Lower risk in the short-term, BUT significantly slower execution, entailing lower returns over an extended period  OEM co-operations ● Most effective on single ventures, but with limited scope ● Usually involve non-core elements of portfolio ● Not a pervasive, substantive solution for any OEM 15
  • 16. Why does industry consolidation matter? 16April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie  High mortality rate caused by partial if non-existent integration ● Cultural divide (corporate and otherwise) ● Inequality of integrating parties ● Operating models radically different and never merged ● Insufficient sensitivity for brand differences ● Lack of respect/trust for one another  Complexity proved to be too much of a stretch for leadership teams BUT  It enables ● Fast execution, enabling rapid scale gain ● Fostering step-change/best-of-best approach to modularity/ commonality AND  The potential savings are too large to ignore
  • 17. The facts: Breaking down product development costs April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 1 Includes mounts, fuel system, cooling and other minor components/systems 2 Average weighted on contribution to product development cost E-MPV segment mainstream “all new” vehicle example 17 OEM B OEM A Potential commonality while preserving differentiation 17% 14% 38% 11% 2% Steering 1% Suspen- sions/ wheels 4% Brakes 1% Power- train installation systems1 7% Upper- body exterior Under- body Total 100% Common general Assy/ Paint InteriorsElectri- cal/ Electronics/ Connectivity 5% HVAC ~70% ~10% ~75% ~90% ~80% ~80% ~80% ~70% Potential commonality up to ~45-50% of total development cost2 Frame/chassis Typical development cost for vehicle and platform (excluding powertrain) % of total development costs ~30% 100% Potential benefits up to €2 billion on vehicle investments
  • 18. Powertrain portfolios show even higher duplications across OEMs, both for engines … April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 18 Overlap with future FCA engine offering 1 High performance engines, limited productions, low volumes Diesel Engine lineup Potential overlap with FCA engine budget Exotic engines1 GasHybrid • Small (1.3-1.6L) • Medium (2.0-2.3L) • Large (3.0-6.0L) • 3 Cylinder • 4 Cylinder • V6 • V8 • Mild (BSG) • Full Major global car OEMs benchmarked Minor overlap OEM 1 OEM 2 >90% ~50% >90%~90% >70%>60% >50% OEM 4 OEM 7OEM 3 OEM 9OEM 6OEM 5 ~90%
  • 19. … and for transmissions Confessions of a Capital Junkie 19April 29, 2015 Overlap with future FCA transmissions offering Potential overlap with FCA transmissions budget ~90% ~50% >90%~90% ~ 70%~ 80% ~ 50% FWD Transmissions lineup RWD • Manual 5 Speed • Manual 6 Speed • MTA • DDCT • Automatic 6 Speed • Automatic 8/9 Speed • CVT • Manual 6 Speed Major global car OEMs benchmarked OEM 1 OEM 2 OEM 4 OEM 7OEM 3 OEM 9OEM 6 • Auto. LD, ≤7 Speeds • Auto. LD, ≥8 Speeds • Auto. HD, ≤7 Speeds (1000 Nm) • Auto. HD, ≥8 Speeds (1000 Nm) ~60% OEM 5 Potential elimination up to €1 billion in duplicated engines and transmissions spending per year
  • 20. The facts: Sharing platform, vehicle and powertrain development can yield significant savings April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 20 Illustrative investment for developing 2 full new vehicles Indexed to 100, example mainstream B/C segment built on same platform Total consolidated investment ~60-80 ~100~50 ~20-401 Vehicle and platform A Savings on total investment Total stand-alone investments for A and B ~50 Vehicle and platform B 1 Estimate based on 40-80% saving on the second vehicle leveraging commonalities in product development. Example for mainstream B/C segment estimated with same methodology as of case for E-MPV segment (45-50%) 2 Assuming a powertrain average lifecycle of 10 years. Tooling synergies not considered ~70-75 Total stand-alone investments for A and B ~100 Engine B ~50 Savings on base development, vehicle installation ~25-30 ~50 Total consolidated investment Engine A Illustrative investment for developing 2 new engines2 Indexed to 100, example for two 4-cylinder gasoline engines to be based on the same architecture
  • 21. We believe large scale integrations are required to unleash full potential 21April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie Potential for capital rationalization across different types of co-operation Share R&D costs and tech development Optimize tooling investments Maximize plant utilization Capture cross- selling opportunities Capture other opex opportunities Potential for capital rationalization One-off technical co- operation JVs Cross-shareholding enabled co-operations Full integration Key enabler: Integrated product strategy Key enabler: Integrated industrial footprint strategy Low High Drivers for capital rationalization
  • 22. Potential synergies from consolidation of auto OEMs would be ~70% driven by industrial rationale 22April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie Estimated benefits from consolidation of auto OEMs1 1 FCA analysis of potential consolidation opportunities among top 10 global automotive OEMs  Sharing platforms development costs  Leveraging commonalities in top-hat development  Avoiding budget duplication for powertrains  Optimization of manufacturing investments and production allocation Combinations of FCA with another large OEM would yield benefits of €2.5-4.5bn per year Technology and product development (e.g. sharing component development costs) Cross-selling ~70% ~15% Other opex opportunities (e.g. purchasing, SG&A) ~15%
  • 23. Aerospace and Defence Building materials Chemicals Oil & Gas Packaging materials Telecommunications Pharma Consumer & Retail OEM 1 OEM 2 OEM 3 OEM 4 OEM 5 OEM 6 OEM 7 OEM 8 OEM 9 Premium OEM OEM 10 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 0.0x 2.0x 4.0x 6.0x 8.0x 10.0x 12.0x 14.0x Consolidation can support significant ROIC and valuation improvement April 29, 2015Confessions of a Capital Junkie 1 Including pension liabilities. EBITDA as per accounting principles adopted by each company ROIC FY 2014 EV/EBITDA1 2014 Auto industry WACC: ~9% 23 Status quo Automotive today Consensus 2018 Consensus 2018 adjusted for consolidation
  • 24. Some conclusions Confessions of a Capital Junkie  Top OEMs spent over €100bn for product development in 2014 only, >€2bn/week in product development and tooling costs, and poised to invest at similar rates in the futures  Historical returns have been broadly below cost of capital, even after the restructuring of the US auto industry and NAFTA volumes at peak  Single purpose projects, JVs and the like are helpful, but they are not enough  Capital consumption rate by OEMs is unacceptable—it is duplicative, does not deliver real value to consumers and is pure economic waste  Consolidation carries executional risks BUT benefits are too large to ignore ● Up to €4.5bn per annum, ~70% of which is a reduction in investments and R&D ● Optimized industrial allocations, with no impact on number employed ● Distribution (dealer networks not merged) and brands untouched by consolidation ● An exceptional value creation opportunity for shareholders  It is ultimately a matter of leadership style and capability… 24April 29, 2015
  • 25. The Red Queen Confessions of a Capital Junkie 25 “Well, in our country” said Alice, still panting a little, “you’d generally get to somewhere else - if you ran very fast for a long time as we’ve been doing.” “A slow sort of country!” said the Queen. “Now here you see it takes all the running you can do to keep in the same place. If you want to get somewhere else, you must run at least twice as fast as that!” L. Carroll Through the Looking Glass April 29, 2015