SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Road School
March 9, 2011
Session 6: Incorporating
Aesthetics into Your Bridge
Design
Bridge Aesthetics Fundamentals
Joseph Showers, PE
Chief Bridge Engineer
Denver, Colorado
What is Aesthetics?
• aesthetic (plural aesthetics)
– The study of art or beauty.
– That which appeals to the senses
– Concerned with beauty, artistic impact, or
appearance
• For purposes of this presentation,
aesthetics relates to visual perception
and the appearance of highway bridges
Questions
• Question 1:
– Do you think it is important to consider
aesthetics when designing a bridge?
• Yes
• Somewhat
• No
• Question 2:
– What percentage of construction costs
should be allocated to aesthetics?
• Less than 1%?
• Less than 5%?
• Less than 10%?
Scope: Workhorse Bridges
• There are over 600,000 bridges in the National
Bridge Inventory (NBI).
• Of these, approximately 98% have spans < 300 feet.
• This presentation addresses short and intermediate
span “Workhorse” bridges
Why care about bridge aesthetics?
• Considering the visual
implications of design
decisions is part of our
job.
– Many routine decisions
made during the design
of a bridge have
implications on the
appearance of bridges
– In many cases, the
visual implications of
bridge design decisions
are only discovered
when construction is
completed
“Adverse visual impacts are not consciously designed
into a project. They creep in when decisions are
made without considering visual consequences.”
Why care about bridge aesthetics?
Why care about bridge aesthetics?
• Public Perception
– Bridges are some of the largest scale and most
prominent structures in our landscape and
neighborhoods.
– Bridges have a long lifespan and are a legacy of
the times that created them
– Bridges are also major public works constructed
largely by public agencies and financed with
public money.
“Stark functionality is no longer enough. Americans have come to
expect more attractive designs in aspects of life: cell-phones, kitchens,
dentistry and televisions. Public demand for an aesthetically pleasing
built-environment is also growing and bridges are a part of that
environment.”
– Communication with state DOT bridge engineer
Perception
• Designers have been taught to see bridges as
orthogonal projections. However, bridges exist in a
three dimensional world
Elevation view of pier Oblique view of same pier
Perception
• What is the observer’s position, speed and distance?
Position (Viewpoint)
□ Beneath and traveling under the
bridge?
□ Above and traveling over the bridge
deck?
□ At eye level with the deck?
Speed
□ Pedestrian?
□ Bicyclist?
□ Motorist?
Distance
□ 10 to 20 feet?
□ 100 to 200 feet?
□ 100 to 200 yards?
Perception
• What is the source, quality, and orientation of light?
□ Daytime
■Shadows and light
■Orientation of the bridge relative to north (azimuth)?
■Time of day is the bridge being viewed?
■ Humidity / haze
■Distance from viewpoint
□ Night
■ Light source location and intensity
■Type of light source
Bridges and Buildings.
• The structure of a bridge is inseparable with its
function and provides the majority of its aesthetic
appeal
• Don’t try to make a bridge something that it is not.
Parking structure facade in urban area. Bridge functions almost always
preclude use of structural cameflogue.
Bridges and Buildings
“There are at least two ways not to design a bridge:
• to decide what it should look like and then work out how
to make it stand up and how to build it;
• to work out the most economical structural /
constructional solution and then decide how to make it
look nice.”
“The first is the architect’s pitfall, the second the
engineer’s. In each case, by the time the decision has
been made it is almost certainly too late to get it right.
All the important issues have to be kept in mind from
the start.”
UK Highways Agency, Design Manual for Roads and Bridges
12
The Ten Determinants of Appearance
1. Horizontal and Vertical Geometry
2. Superstructure Type
3. Pier / Support Placement / Span
Arrangement
4. Abutment Placement and Height
5. Superstructure Shape
6. Pier Shape
7. Abutment Shape
8. Color
9. Texture, Ornamentation and Details
10. Lighting, Signing and Landscaping
#1 Horizontal and Vertical Geometry
• Roadway geometry influences bridge geometry. The
roadway surface is the “roof” of the structure
• Horizontal and vertical clearance requirements
beneath the deck level also influence bridge
geometry
#1 Horizontal and Vertical Geometry
• Few bridges:
– Are located on straight alignments
– Have flat horizontal deck surfaces
– Have supports oriented at right angles to the
superstructure
– Have constant cross section widths
– Are located on a flat site
superelevation
Reverse horizontal
curvature
Variable deck
Skewed supports
Variable
deck width
Compound vertical
curvature
#1 Horizontal and Vertical Geometry
• Bridges close to the ground appear massive and
dark
• Think of the space beneath the bridge
Fremont Troll under the
Aurora Bridge in Seattle
Photo: raincity guide.com
#1 Horizontal and Vertical Geometry
• Wide overpass bridges and viaducts can be
perceived as barriers
• How does this influence the substructure design?
#1 Horizontal and Vertical Geometry
• Collaborate with design team members to achieve
the best possible geometry that accommodates both
functional and aesthetic objectives
Atypical pier cap is visually discordant
#2 Superstructure Type
• Bridges frame the landscape and become windows.
The shape of the “window frames” influences our
perception
“Buildings contain space. It flows through bridges.” WJR Smythe
#2 Superstructure Type
Early 20th century truss bridge
• Bridge types are
representative of
their times and
evolve in parallel
with construction
and materials
Photo: Oklahoma DOT
Mid 20th century simple span steel girder “interstate” bridge
technology, and
the marketplace.
#2 Superstructure Type
• At this point in time, economy dictates that the majority of
workhorse bridges are constant depth girder type
structures assembled from standard structural
components and systems
#2 Superstructure Type
• Variable depth superstructures provide visual interest
Combination of variable depth superstructure and
massive abutments creates a community portal
#2 Superstructure Type
• Rigid frames and slant leg frames can create
gateways and portals
http://www.hpcbridgeviews.com/images/colorado-
RichmondHill.jpg
#2 Superstructure Type
• Combining multiple superstructure types can result in
visual discord and a lack of integrity
Combination of cast in place concrete, steel and precast
concrete superstructures on one elevated interchange
#2 Superstructure Type
• Consistent superstructure type can visually unify a
complex arrangement of bridges
Steel box girder bridge type used in four level system interchange
#2 Superstructure Type
• The bridge type should be appropriate to its scale
Is a through arch bridge with hangers and floorbeams required to
span less than 100 feet?
#3 Pier and Span Arrangement
• Structure depths are proportional to spans
• Shorter spans with thin superstructures may visually
emphasize the substructure
Shallow slab bridge depth relative to height above grade
results in slender superstructure appearance
#3 Pier and Span Arrangement
• Longer girder spans have deeper superstructures,
which become dominant visual features
Deep structure relative to height above grade
results in a massive superstructure appearance
#4 Abutment Placement and Height
• Tall abutments visually anchor a bridge to the ground
and strongly frame the landscape backdrop
Bridge with tall
abutments serving as a
gateway into residential
development
#4 Abutment Placement and Height
• Short abutments increase transparency
• Reduced abutment mass reduces the bridge’s visual
“frame” effect
Short abutments increase
span and provide views of
the backdrop, but result little
natural light penetrates to
areas near abutments.
#4 Abutment Placement and Height
• Mid-height abutments also provide a strong anchor
while providing more visual transparency
• Trade-off of longer spans versus shorter abutments.
Abutment locations distant from
shoulders reduce massive appearance
and increases visual transparency
relative to tall abutments.
#5 Superstructure Shape
1920s and 1930s era
bridges
• The superstructure fascia is a major visual feature
• Deep relief, shadows, and ornamentation were historically
used on prominent bridges to provide for visual interest
#5 Superstructure Shape
• Most contemporary bridges
have overhangs
• Wide overhangs place the
fascia in shadow and make the
bridge appear more slender
Photo: Portland Cement Association
#5 Superstructure Shape
• Contemporary bridges are often constant depth
superstructures with little ornamentation
• Reliance on horizontal layers to provide for visual
interest
Uninterrupted fascia emphasizes horizontal lines
#5 Superstructure Shape
• Many bridges use cantilevered pier caps with
cantilevered caps.
• Recessed columns in shadow emphasize horizontal
structure lines
Gateway viaduct combines modified precast concrete fascia
girder with urban streetscape elements.
#5 Superstructure Shape
• Flat fascia surfaces result in a more massive
appearance relative to layered surfaces
http://en.structurae.de/
#5 Superstructure Shape
• Accentuating vertical elements and interrupting
horizontal lines is an alternative strategy
Columns projecting from fascia visually interrupt spans.
Art deco detailing also provides visual interest
#6 Pier Shape
• “Framed” piers with multiple columns and drop pier
cap are the most common pier type
#6 Pier Shape
• Single column hammerhead piers increase
transparency, particularly on skewed crossings
Slender pier caps emphasize superstructure and result in a
more transparent structure
#6 Pier Shape
• Wide column spacing may make sense on urban
bridges to provide for more reflected light and an
open appearance
Post tensioned pier caps allow for longer cap beam spans. Reflected light
and unobstructed sight lines makes the under-bridge space more inviting
#6 Pier Shape
• Proportions of framed piers need to be carefully considered
Pier cap appears to be far
too massive relative to the
columns that support it
Cantilevers appear out of
proportion to total cap width
#6 Pier Shape
• Wall type piers offer a wide range of visual
expression
#6 Pier Shape
• Integral pier caps result in continuity and minimize
substructure mass
#6 Pier Shape
• Combining pier types and shapes results in visual
discord. Be consistent
#7 Abutment Shape
• Articulated tall abutments with wrap around wing
walls visually anchor the bridge ends and define a
portal
#7 Abutment Shape
• Front faces of abutment walls may provide
opportunities
Urban bridge with pedestrian
traffic beneath. Articulated
abutment surface and ceramic
tile on abutment face provide
visual interest
Gateway bridge
incorporates pilasters into
abutment face. Strong
shadows break up wide
abutment surface
#7 Abutment Shape
• Consider proportions and scale of
abutments and how they relate to
the superstructure
Abutment pilasters define the ends of the
crossing and provide human scale
features for pedestrians. Scale of
pilasters is appropriate
• Is relatively inexpensive
• Is subjective
• Is much more complex than most people
realize
#8 Color
#8 Color
• Issues to consider
– Durability and maintenance of coatings
– Graffiti resistance
– Application over large areas /uniformity
– Appearance during different seasons
– Site Physical Context
• Vegetation and soils /rocks in rural
environments
• Building materials in urban environments
#8 Color
• Blend with the environment
• Contrast with the environment
#8 Color
• Color has a cultural dimension
New Mexico bridges
#8 Color
• Color can influence our perceptions
“Purple People
Bridge”
“Big Mac”
#9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details
• Values and attitudes related to ornamented bridges
have changed over time
Photos: Wikimedia
Photo: Carnegie Library,
Wikimedia
#9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details
• During the late 20th century, the prevailing approach
was to eliminate ornament. “Form follows function”
also accommodated need for economy and rapid
construction.
Photos: infrastructurist.com
#9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details
• Avoid using structural forms as ornament
Decorative arches attached to conventional highway overpass bridges as
ornament. These arches obviously do not support these bridges
#9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details
• Avoid using false structural
members to mimic structure
Decorative truss members attached to
conventional prestressed girder bridge
to create landmark bridge. Have long
term maintenance requirements been
considered?
#9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details
• Consider proportions and scale of ornament, and
how it relates to the bridge structure
Brick parapet and ornamental lighting overwhelms the simple concrete
bridge beneath. Is this a bridge or a wall with openings?
#9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details
• Be careful in using formliners
Formliner pattern suggests an
unstable detail in masonry
construction
Photo: Federal Highway Administration
Would a fieldstone wall span this
road?
#9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details
• Pilasters or monuments visually define the ends of
bridges or mark one’s position within the bridge
length
Photo:
Historicbridges.org
#10 Lighting, Signing and Landscaping
• Emotional Impact of Good Lighting
Before After
#10 Lighting, Signing and Landscaping
• Lighting Considerations
– Maintenance
– Lamping and Energy
– Physical Constraints
– Color Rendering
– Wildlife Concerns
– Light Pollution
#10 Lighting, Signing and Landscaping
• Terracing and landscaping visually softens the
connection between a bridge and its site
#10 Lighting, Signing and Landscaping
• An alternative approach is use landscaping to a
reinforce a strong visual “anchor” at the bridge ends
Bridge Aesthetics Sourcebook
• “Practical Ideas for Short and Medium Span
Bridges” Draft developed by AFF10(2) on March
2009
• http://bridgeaesthetics.org/
• Endorsed by AASHTO SCOBS in 2010
• “AASHTO Bridge Aesthetics Sourcebook, First
Edition”
How much does it cost?
 “It is unwise to pay too much. But it is worse to pay too
little. There is hardly anything in the world that can’t be
made a little worse and to sell a little cheaper” - John
Ruskin
 “At the opposite extreme, increasing project costs
does not necessarily result in a better design. A
common idea.. is that a bridge which is attractive in
68
appearance must be more expensive than one which is
not. There is no evidence that this is so. In fact, a
good looking bridge is likely to have had more thought
devoted to all aspects of its design; it will probably be
more fully an integrated design and could even cost
less to build.” - WJR Smyth
Thank You
POLL RESULTS OF NEW
JERSEY ENGINEERS
Who cares about bridge aesthetics?
Who cares about bridge aesthetics?

More Related Content

Similar to Bridge Asthetic Fundamentals.pptx

2013 11 21-walterdale_csce
2013 11 21-walterdale_csce2013 11 21-walterdale_csce
2013 11 21-walterdale_csce
DIALOGdesign
 
1.5 class a,b
1.5 class a,b1.5 class a,b
1.5 class a,b
Mani Das
 
module20120PPT.pdf
module20120PPT.pdfmodule20120PPT.pdf
module20120PPT.pdf
RakeshH21
 
Bandra worli bridge
Bandra worli bridgeBandra worli bridge
Bandra worli bridge
Aglaia Connect
 
Design of Foot Over Bridge
Design of Foot Over BridgeDesign of Foot Over Bridge
Design of Foot Over Bridge
jupallipavan2911
 
SynTerra / US Bridge Presentation (10 24 11)
SynTerra / US Bridge Presentation (10 24 11)SynTerra / US Bridge Presentation (10 24 11)
SynTerra / US Bridge Presentation (10 24 11)
dgonano
 
successful applications of project visualization
successful applications of project visualizationsuccessful applications of project visualization
successful applications of project visualization
Southern New England American Planning Association
 
Coronado Gateway Presentation
Coronado Gateway PresentationCoronado Gateway Presentation
Coronado Gateway Presentation
Crowdbrite
 
Airport Boulevard Railroad Grade Separation Project
Airport Boulevard Railroad Grade Separation ProjectAirport Boulevard Railroad Grade Separation Project
Airport Boulevard Railroad Grade Separation Project
American Society of Civil Engineers, Orange County Branch
 
Bridge architecture and economic sapn 1
Bridge architecture and economic sapn 1Bridge architecture and economic sapn 1
Bridge architecture and economic sapn 1
SaadKhot1
 
Bridge Engg1.ppt
Bridge Engg1.pptBridge Engg1.ppt
Bridge Engg1.ppt
PrashanthKumar491454
 
CHapter 1 introduction to bridge design eng
CHapter 1 introduction to bridge design engCHapter 1 introduction to bridge design eng
CHapter 1 introduction to bridge design eng
abdi beder
 
Bridge intr.ppt
Bridge intr.pptBridge intr.ppt
Bridge intr.ppt
MaheshKalyanshetti2
 
Coronado Gateway Workshop Presentation
Coronado Gateway Workshop PresentationCoronado Gateway Workshop Presentation
Coronado Gateway Workshop Presentation
Crowdbrite
 
Transportation engineering module 2 ppt.
Transportation engineering module 2 ppt.Transportation engineering module 2 ppt.
Transportation engineering module 2 ppt.
RAJENDRAKUMARSHETTAR
 
When Aesthetics Govern: Pedestrian Bridges and Architecturally Exposed Struct...
When Aesthetics Govern: Pedestrian Bridges and Architecturally Exposed Struct...When Aesthetics Govern: Pedestrian Bridges and Architecturally Exposed Struct...
When Aesthetics Govern: Pedestrian Bridges and Architecturally Exposed Struct...
Terri Meyer Boake
 
transportation
transportationtransportation
transportation
Navneet Singh
 
Bridge introduction
Bridge introductionBridge introduction
Bridge introduction
Patel Mitulkumar
 
Chapter 1 introductution to railway and permanent way
Chapter 1 introductution to railway and permanent wayChapter 1 introductution to railway and permanent way
Chapter 1 introductution to railway and permanent way
dhara dattani
 
Tom Saad of FHWA Chicago HS for Agricultural Sciences Shadow day 02-08-12
Tom Saad of FHWA   Chicago HS for Agricultural Sciences Shadow day 02-08-12Tom Saad of FHWA   Chicago HS for Agricultural Sciences Shadow day 02-08-12
Tom Saad of FHWA Chicago HS for Agricultural Sciences Shadow day 02-08-12
raymurphy9533
 

Similar to Bridge Asthetic Fundamentals.pptx (20)

2013 11 21-walterdale_csce
2013 11 21-walterdale_csce2013 11 21-walterdale_csce
2013 11 21-walterdale_csce
 
1.5 class a,b
1.5 class a,b1.5 class a,b
1.5 class a,b
 
module20120PPT.pdf
module20120PPT.pdfmodule20120PPT.pdf
module20120PPT.pdf
 
Bandra worli bridge
Bandra worli bridgeBandra worli bridge
Bandra worli bridge
 
Design of Foot Over Bridge
Design of Foot Over BridgeDesign of Foot Over Bridge
Design of Foot Over Bridge
 
SynTerra / US Bridge Presentation (10 24 11)
SynTerra / US Bridge Presentation (10 24 11)SynTerra / US Bridge Presentation (10 24 11)
SynTerra / US Bridge Presentation (10 24 11)
 
successful applications of project visualization
successful applications of project visualizationsuccessful applications of project visualization
successful applications of project visualization
 
Coronado Gateway Presentation
Coronado Gateway PresentationCoronado Gateway Presentation
Coronado Gateway Presentation
 
Airport Boulevard Railroad Grade Separation Project
Airport Boulevard Railroad Grade Separation ProjectAirport Boulevard Railroad Grade Separation Project
Airport Boulevard Railroad Grade Separation Project
 
Bridge architecture and economic sapn 1
Bridge architecture and economic sapn 1Bridge architecture and economic sapn 1
Bridge architecture and economic sapn 1
 
Bridge Engg1.ppt
Bridge Engg1.pptBridge Engg1.ppt
Bridge Engg1.ppt
 
CHapter 1 introduction to bridge design eng
CHapter 1 introduction to bridge design engCHapter 1 introduction to bridge design eng
CHapter 1 introduction to bridge design eng
 
Bridge intr.ppt
Bridge intr.pptBridge intr.ppt
Bridge intr.ppt
 
Coronado Gateway Workshop Presentation
Coronado Gateway Workshop PresentationCoronado Gateway Workshop Presentation
Coronado Gateway Workshop Presentation
 
Transportation engineering module 2 ppt.
Transportation engineering module 2 ppt.Transportation engineering module 2 ppt.
Transportation engineering module 2 ppt.
 
When Aesthetics Govern: Pedestrian Bridges and Architecturally Exposed Struct...
When Aesthetics Govern: Pedestrian Bridges and Architecturally Exposed Struct...When Aesthetics Govern: Pedestrian Bridges and Architecturally Exposed Struct...
When Aesthetics Govern: Pedestrian Bridges and Architecturally Exposed Struct...
 
transportation
transportationtransportation
transportation
 
Bridge introduction
Bridge introductionBridge introduction
Bridge introduction
 
Chapter 1 introductution to railway and permanent way
Chapter 1 introductution to railway and permanent wayChapter 1 introductution to railway and permanent way
Chapter 1 introductution to railway and permanent way
 
Tom Saad of FHWA Chicago HS for Agricultural Sciences Shadow day 02-08-12
Tom Saad of FHWA   Chicago HS for Agricultural Sciences Shadow day 02-08-12Tom Saad of FHWA   Chicago HS for Agricultural Sciences Shadow day 02-08-12
Tom Saad of FHWA Chicago HS for Agricultural Sciences Shadow day 02-08-12
 

More from ecep nurali

316823403-5-Hill-Roads-073-old-pptx (1).pptx
316823403-5-Hill-Roads-073-old-pptx (1).pptx316823403-5-Hill-Roads-073-old-pptx (1).pptx
316823403-5-Hill-Roads-073-old-pptx (1).pptx
ecep nurali
 
c951a_Modul_6_-_Pemel._Bang_Pelengkap_jalan.pdf
c951a_Modul_6_-_Pemel._Bang_Pelengkap_jalan.pdfc951a_Modul_6_-_Pemel._Bang_Pelengkap_jalan.pdf
c951a_Modul_6_-_Pemel._Bang_Pelengkap_jalan.pdf
ecep nurali
 
Design_Guidelines_and_Standard_Drawings.pdf
Design_Guidelines_and_Standard_Drawings.pdfDesign_Guidelines_and_Standard_Drawings.pdf
Design_Guidelines_and_Standard_Drawings.pdf
ecep nurali
 
180715749-4B-Creep-and-Shrinkage.pptx
180715749-4B-Creep-and-Shrinkage.pptx180715749-4B-Creep-and-Shrinkage.pptx
180715749-4B-Creep-and-Shrinkage.pptx
ecep nurali
 
Mekanika-Bahan.ppt
Mekanika-Bahan.pptMekanika-Bahan.ppt
Mekanika-Bahan.ppt
ecep nurali
 
440360496-TANK-CLEANING-pptx.pptx
440360496-TANK-CLEANING-pptx.pptx440360496-TANK-CLEANING-pptx.pptx
440360496-TANK-CLEANING-pptx.pptx
ecep nurali
 
Bridge engnineering
Bridge engnineeringBridge engnineering
Bridge engnineering
ecep nurali
 

More from ecep nurali (7)

316823403-5-Hill-Roads-073-old-pptx (1).pptx
316823403-5-Hill-Roads-073-old-pptx (1).pptx316823403-5-Hill-Roads-073-old-pptx (1).pptx
316823403-5-Hill-Roads-073-old-pptx (1).pptx
 
c951a_Modul_6_-_Pemel._Bang_Pelengkap_jalan.pdf
c951a_Modul_6_-_Pemel._Bang_Pelengkap_jalan.pdfc951a_Modul_6_-_Pemel._Bang_Pelengkap_jalan.pdf
c951a_Modul_6_-_Pemel._Bang_Pelengkap_jalan.pdf
 
Design_Guidelines_and_Standard_Drawings.pdf
Design_Guidelines_and_Standard_Drawings.pdfDesign_Guidelines_and_Standard_Drawings.pdf
Design_Guidelines_and_Standard_Drawings.pdf
 
180715749-4B-Creep-and-Shrinkage.pptx
180715749-4B-Creep-and-Shrinkage.pptx180715749-4B-Creep-and-Shrinkage.pptx
180715749-4B-Creep-and-Shrinkage.pptx
 
Mekanika-Bahan.ppt
Mekanika-Bahan.pptMekanika-Bahan.ppt
Mekanika-Bahan.ppt
 
440360496-TANK-CLEANING-pptx.pptx
440360496-TANK-CLEANING-pptx.pptx440360496-TANK-CLEANING-pptx.pptx
440360496-TANK-CLEANING-pptx.pptx
 
Bridge engnineering
Bridge engnineeringBridge engnineering
Bridge engnineering
 

Recently uploaded

哪里办理(csu毕业证书)查尔斯特大学毕业证硕士学历原版一模一样
哪里办理(csu毕业证书)查尔斯特大学毕业证硕士学历原版一模一样哪里办理(csu毕业证书)查尔斯特大学毕业证硕士学历原版一模一样
哪里办理(csu毕业证书)查尔斯特大学毕业证硕士学历原版一模一样
insn4465
 
Certificates - Mahmoud Mohamed Moursi Ahmed
Certificates - Mahmoud Mohamed Moursi AhmedCertificates - Mahmoud Mohamed Moursi Ahmed
Certificates - Mahmoud Mohamed Moursi Ahmed
Mahmoud Morsy
 
BRAIN TUMOR DETECTION for seminar ppt.pdf
BRAIN TUMOR DETECTION for seminar ppt.pdfBRAIN TUMOR DETECTION for seminar ppt.pdf
BRAIN TUMOR DETECTION for seminar ppt.pdf
LAXMAREDDY22
 
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine LearningUnderstanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
SUTEJAS
 
CompEx~Manual~1210 (2).pdf COMPEX GAS AND VAPOURS
CompEx~Manual~1210 (2).pdf COMPEX GAS AND VAPOURSCompEx~Manual~1210 (2).pdf COMPEX GAS AND VAPOURS
CompEx~Manual~1210 (2).pdf COMPEX GAS AND VAPOURS
RamonNovais6
 
Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...
Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...
Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...
IJECEIAES
 
Optimizing Gradle Builds - Gradle DPE Tour Berlin 2024
Optimizing Gradle Builds - Gradle DPE Tour Berlin 2024Optimizing Gradle Builds - Gradle DPE Tour Berlin 2024
Optimizing Gradle Builds - Gradle DPE Tour Berlin 2024
Sinan KOZAK
 
NATURAL DEEP EUTECTIC SOLVENTS AS ANTI-FREEZING AGENT
NATURAL DEEP EUTECTIC SOLVENTS AS ANTI-FREEZING AGENTNATURAL DEEP EUTECTIC SOLVENTS AS ANTI-FREEZING AGENT
NATURAL DEEP EUTECTIC SOLVENTS AS ANTI-FREEZING AGENT
Addu25809
 
22CYT12-Unit-V-E Waste and its Management.ppt
22CYT12-Unit-V-E Waste and its Management.ppt22CYT12-Unit-V-E Waste and its Management.ppt
22CYT12-Unit-V-E Waste and its Management.ppt
KrishnaveniKrishnara1
 
Manufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptx
Manufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptxManufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptx
Manufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptx
Madan Karki
 
Use PyCharm for remote debugging of WSL on a Windo cf5c162d672e4e58b4dde5d797...
Use PyCharm for remote debugging of WSL on a Windo cf5c162d672e4e58b4dde5d797...Use PyCharm for remote debugging of WSL on a Windo cf5c162d672e4e58b4dde5d797...
Use PyCharm for remote debugging of WSL on a Windo cf5c162d672e4e58b4dde5d797...
shadow0702a
 
132/33KV substation case study Presentation
132/33KV substation case study Presentation132/33KV substation case study Presentation
132/33KV substation case study Presentation
kandramariana6
 
Electric vehicle and photovoltaic advanced roles in enhancing the financial p...
Electric vehicle and photovoltaic advanced roles in enhancing the financial p...Electric vehicle and photovoltaic advanced roles in enhancing the financial p...
Electric vehicle and photovoltaic advanced roles in enhancing the financial p...
IJECEIAES
 
Generative AI leverages algorithms to create various forms of content
Generative AI leverages algorithms to create various forms of contentGenerative AI leverages algorithms to create various forms of content
Generative AI leverages algorithms to create various forms of content
Hitesh Mohapatra
 
Textile Chemical Processing and Dyeing.pdf
Textile Chemical Processing and Dyeing.pdfTextile Chemical Processing and Dyeing.pdf
Textile Chemical Processing and Dyeing.pdf
NazakatAliKhoso2
 
International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...
International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...
International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...
gerogepatton
 
Introduction to AI Safety (public presentation).pptx
Introduction to AI Safety (public presentation).pptxIntroduction to AI Safety (public presentation).pptx
Introduction to AI Safety (public presentation).pptx
MiscAnnoy1
 
Hematology Analyzer Machine - Complete Blood Count
Hematology Analyzer Machine - Complete Blood CountHematology Analyzer Machine - Complete Blood Count
Hematology Analyzer Machine - Complete Blood Count
shahdabdulbaset
 
2008 BUILDING CONSTRUCTION Illustrated - Ching Chapter 02 The Building.pdf
2008 BUILDING CONSTRUCTION Illustrated - Ching Chapter 02 The Building.pdf2008 BUILDING CONSTRUCTION Illustrated - Ching Chapter 02 The Building.pdf
2008 BUILDING CONSTRUCTION Illustrated - Ching Chapter 02 The Building.pdf
Yasser Mahgoub
 
Casting-Defect-inSlab continuous casting.pdf
Casting-Defect-inSlab continuous casting.pdfCasting-Defect-inSlab continuous casting.pdf
Casting-Defect-inSlab continuous casting.pdf
zubairahmad848137
 

Recently uploaded (20)

哪里办理(csu毕业证书)查尔斯特大学毕业证硕士学历原版一模一样
哪里办理(csu毕业证书)查尔斯特大学毕业证硕士学历原版一模一样哪里办理(csu毕业证书)查尔斯特大学毕业证硕士学历原版一模一样
哪里办理(csu毕业证书)查尔斯特大学毕业证硕士学历原版一模一样
 
Certificates - Mahmoud Mohamed Moursi Ahmed
Certificates - Mahmoud Mohamed Moursi AhmedCertificates - Mahmoud Mohamed Moursi Ahmed
Certificates - Mahmoud Mohamed Moursi Ahmed
 
BRAIN TUMOR DETECTION for seminar ppt.pdf
BRAIN TUMOR DETECTION for seminar ppt.pdfBRAIN TUMOR DETECTION for seminar ppt.pdf
BRAIN TUMOR DETECTION for seminar ppt.pdf
 
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine LearningUnderstanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
Understanding Inductive Bias in Machine Learning
 
CompEx~Manual~1210 (2).pdf COMPEX GAS AND VAPOURS
CompEx~Manual~1210 (2).pdf COMPEX GAS AND VAPOURSCompEx~Manual~1210 (2).pdf COMPEX GAS AND VAPOURS
CompEx~Manual~1210 (2).pdf COMPEX GAS AND VAPOURS
 
Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...
Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...
Advanced control scheme of doubly fed induction generator for wind turbine us...
 
Optimizing Gradle Builds - Gradle DPE Tour Berlin 2024
Optimizing Gradle Builds - Gradle DPE Tour Berlin 2024Optimizing Gradle Builds - Gradle DPE Tour Berlin 2024
Optimizing Gradle Builds - Gradle DPE Tour Berlin 2024
 
NATURAL DEEP EUTECTIC SOLVENTS AS ANTI-FREEZING AGENT
NATURAL DEEP EUTECTIC SOLVENTS AS ANTI-FREEZING AGENTNATURAL DEEP EUTECTIC SOLVENTS AS ANTI-FREEZING AGENT
NATURAL DEEP EUTECTIC SOLVENTS AS ANTI-FREEZING AGENT
 
22CYT12-Unit-V-E Waste and its Management.ppt
22CYT12-Unit-V-E Waste and its Management.ppt22CYT12-Unit-V-E Waste and its Management.ppt
22CYT12-Unit-V-E Waste and its Management.ppt
 
Manufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptx
Manufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptxManufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptx
Manufacturing Process of molasses based distillery ppt.pptx
 
Use PyCharm for remote debugging of WSL on a Windo cf5c162d672e4e58b4dde5d797...
Use PyCharm for remote debugging of WSL on a Windo cf5c162d672e4e58b4dde5d797...Use PyCharm for remote debugging of WSL on a Windo cf5c162d672e4e58b4dde5d797...
Use PyCharm for remote debugging of WSL on a Windo cf5c162d672e4e58b4dde5d797...
 
132/33KV substation case study Presentation
132/33KV substation case study Presentation132/33KV substation case study Presentation
132/33KV substation case study Presentation
 
Electric vehicle and photovoltaic advanced roles in enhancing the financial p...
Electric vehicle and photovoltaic advanced roles in enhancing the financial p...Electric vehicle and photovoltaic advanced roles in enhancing the financial p...
Electric vehicle and photovoltaic advanced roles in enhancing the financial p...
 
Generative AI leverages algorithms to create various forms of content
Generative AI leverages algorithms to create various forms of contentGenerative AI leverages algorithms to create various forms of content
Generative AI leverages algorithms to create various forms of content
 
Textile Chemical Processing and Dyeing.pdf
Textile Chemical Processing and Dyeing.pdfTextile Chemical Processing and Dyeing.pdf
Textile Chemical Processing and Dyeing.pdf
 
International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...
International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...
International Conference on NLP, Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning an...
 
Introduction to AI Safety (public presentation).pptx
Introduction to AI Safety (public presentation).pptxIntroduction to AI Safety (public presentation).pptx
Introduction to AI Safety (public presentation).pptx
 
Hematology Analyzer Machine - Complete Blood Count
Hematology Analyzer Machine - Complete Blood CountHematology Analyzer Machine - Complete Blood Count
Hematology Analyzer Machine - Complete Blood Count
 
2008 BUILDING CONSTRUCTION Illustrated - Ching Chapter 02 The Building.pdf
2008 BUILDING CONSTRUCTION Illustrated - Ching Chapter 02 The Building.pdf2008 BUILDING CONSTRUCTION Illustrated - Ching Chapter 02 The Building.pdf
2008 BUILDING CONSTRUCTION Illustrated - Ching Chapter 02 The Building.pdf
 
Casting-Defect-inSlab continuous casting.pdf
Casting-Defect-inSlab continuous casting.pdfCasting-Defect-inSlab continuous casting.pdf
Casting-Defect-inSlab continuous casting.pdf
 

Bridge Asthetic Fundamentals.pptx

  • 1. Road School March 9, 2011 Session 6: Incorporating Aesthetics into Your Bridge Design Bridge Aesthetics Fundamentals Joseph Showers, PE Chief Bridge Engineer Denver, Colorado
  • 2. What is Aesthetics? • aesthetic (plural aesthetics) – The study of art or beauty. – That which appeals to the senses – Concerned with beauty, artistic impact, or appearance • For purposes of this presentation, aesthetics relates to visual perception and the appearance of highway bridges
  • 3. Questions • Question 1: – Do you think it is important to consider aesthetics when designing a bridge? • Yes • Somewhat • No • Question 2: – What percentage of construction costs should be allocated to aesthetics? • Less than 1%? • Less than 5%? • Less than 10%?
  • 4. Scope: Workhorse Bridges • There are over 600,000 bridges in the National Bridge Inventory (NBI). • Of these, approximately 98% have spans < 300 feet. • This presentation addresses short and intermediate span “Workhorse” bridges
  • 5. Why care about bridge aesthetics? • Considering the visual implications of design decisions is part of our job. – Many routine decisions made during the design of a bridge have implications on the appearance of bridges – In many cases, the visual implications of bridge design decisions are only discovered when construction is completed
  • 6. “Adverse visual impacts are not consciously designed into a project. They creep in when decisions are made without considering visual consequences.” Why care about bridge aesthetics?
  • 7. Why care about bridge aesthetics? • Public Perception – Bridges are some of the largest scale and most prominent structures in our landscape and neighborhoods. – Bridges have a long lifespan and are a legacy of the times that created them – Bridges are also major public works constructed largely by public agencies and financed with public money. “Stark functionality is no longer enough. Americans have come to expect more attractive designs in aspects of life: cell-phones, kitchens, dentistry and televisions. Public demand for an aesthetically pleasing built-environment is also growing and bridges are a part of that environment.” – Communication with state DOT bridge engineer
  • 8. Perception • Designers have been taught to see bridges as orthogonal projections. However, bridges exist in a three dimensional world Elevation view of pier Oblique view of same pier
  • 9. Perception • What is the observer’s position, speed and distance? Position (Viewpoint) □ Beneath and traveling under the bridge? □ Above and traveling over the bridge deck? □ At eye level with the deck? Speed □ Pedestrian? □ Bicyclist? □ Motorist? Distance □ 10 to 20 feet? □ 100 to 200 feet? □ 100 to 200 yards?
  • 10. Perception • What is the source, quality, and orientation of light? □ Daytime ■Shadows and light ■Orientation of the bridge relative to north (azimuth)? ■Time of day is the bridge being viewed? ■ Humidity / haze ■Distance from viewpoint □ Night ■ Light source location and intensity ■Type of light source
  • 11. Bridges and Buildings. • The structure of a bridge is inseparable with its function and provides the majority of its aesthetic appeal • Don’t try to make a bridge something that it is not. Parking structure facade in urban area. Bridge functions almost always preclude use of structural cameflogue.
  • 12. Bridges and Buildings “There are at least two ways not to design a bridge: • to decide what it should look like and then work out how to make it stand up and how to build it; • to work out the most economical structural / constructional solution and then decide how to make it look nice.” “The first is the architect’s pitfall, the second the engineer’s. In each case, by the time the decision has been made it is almost certainly too late to get it right. All the important issues have to be kept in mind from the start.” UK Highways Agency, Design Manual for Roads and Bridges 12
  • 13. The Ten Determinants of Appearance 1. Horizontal and Vertical Geometry 2. Superstructure Type 3. Pier / Support Placement / Span Arrangement 4. Abutment Placement and Height 5. Superstructure Shape 6. Pier Shape 7. Abutment Shape 8. Color 9. Texture, Ornamentation and Details 10. Lighting, Signing and Landscaping
  • 14. #1 Horizontal and Vertical Geometry • Roadway geometry influences bridge geometry. The roadway surface is the “roof” of the structure • Horizontal and vertical clearance requirements beneath the deck level also influence bridge geometry
  • 15. #1 Horizontal and Vertical Geometry • Few bridges: – Are located on straight alignments – Have flat horizontal deck surfaces – Have supports oriented at right angles to the superstructure – Have constant cross section widths – Are located on a flat site superelevation Reverse horizontal curvature Variable deck Skewed supports Variable deck width Compound vertical curvature
  • 16. #1 Horizontal and Vertical Geometry • Bridges close to the ground appear massive and dark • Think of the space beneath the bridge Fremont Troll under the Aurora Bridge in Seattle Photo: raincity guide.com
  • 17. #1 Horizontal and Vertical Geometry • Wide overpass bridges and viaducts can be perceived as barriers • How does this influence the substructure design?
  • 18. #1 Horizontal and Vertical Geometry • Collaborate with design team members to achieve the best possible geometry that accommodates both functional and aesthetic objectives Atypical pier cap is visually discordant
  • 19. #2 Superstructure Type • Bridges frame the landscape and become windows. The shape of the “window frames” influences our perception “Buildings contain space. It flows through bridges.” WJR Smythe
  • 20. #2 Superstructure Type Early 20th century truss bridge • Bridge types are representative of their times and evolve in parallel with construction and materials Photo: Oklahoma DOT Mid 20th century simple span steel girder “interstate” bridge technology, and the marketplace.
  • 21. #2 Superstructure Type • At this point in time, economy dictates that the majority of workhorse bridges are constant depth girder type structures assembled from standard structural components and systems
  • 22. #2 Superstructure Type • Variable depth superstructures provide visual interest Combination of variable depth superstructure and massive abutments creates a community portal
  • 23. #2 Superstructure Type • Rigid frames and slant leg frames can create gateways and portals http://www.hpcbridgeviews.com/images/colorado- RichmondHill.jpg
  • 24. #2 Superstructure Type • Combining multiple superstructure types can result in visual discord and a lack of integrity Combination of cast in place concrete, steel and precast concrete superstructures on one elevated interchange
  • 25. #2 Superstructure Type • Consistent superstructure type can visually unify a complex arrangement of bridges Steel box girder bridge type used in four level system interchange
  • 26. #2 Superstructure Type • The bridge type should be appropriate to its scale Is a through arch bridge with hangers and floorbeams required to span less than 100 feet?
  • 27. #3 Pier and Span Arrangement • Structure depths are proportional to spans • Shorter spans with thin superstructures may visually emphasize the substructure Shallow slab bridge depth relative to height above grade results in slender superstructure appearance
  • 28. #3 Pier and Span Arrangement • Longer girder spans have deeper superstructures, which become dominant visual features Deep structure relative to height above grade results in a massive superstructure appearance
  • 29. #4 Abutment Placement and Height • Tall abutments visually anchor a bridge to the ground and strongly frame the landscape backdrop Bridge with tall abutments serving as a gateway into residential development
  • 30. #4 Abutment Placement and Height • Short abutments increase transparency • Reduced abutment mass reduces the bridge’s visual “frame” effect Short abutments increase span and provide views of the backdrop, but result little natural light penetrates to areas near abutments.
  • 31. #4 Abutment Placement and Height • Mid-height abutments also provide a strong anchor while providing more visual transparency • Trade-off of longer spans versus shorter abutments. Abutment locations distant from shoulders reduce massive appearance and increases visual transparency relative to tall abutments.
  • 32. #5 Superstructure Shape 1920s and 1930s era bridges • The superstructure fascia is a major visual feature • Deep relief, shadows, and ornamentation were historically used on prominent bridges to provide for visual interest
  • 33. #5 Superstructure Shape • Most contemporary bridges have overhangs • Wide overhangs place the fascia in shadow and make the bridge appear more slender Photo: Portland Cement Association
  • 34. #5 Superstructure Shape • Contemporary bridges are often constant depth superstructures with little ornamentation • Reliance on horizontal layers to provide for visual interest Uninterrupted fascia emphasizes horizontal lines
  • 35. #5 Superstructure Shape • Many bridges use cantilevered pier caps with cantilevered caps. • Recessed columns in shadow emphasize horizontal structure lines Gateway viaduct combines modified precast concrete fascia girder with urban streetscape elements.
  • 36. #5 Superstructure Shape • Flat fascia surfaces result in a more massive appearance relative to layered surfaces http://en.structurae.de/
  • 37. #5 Superstructure Shape • Accentuating vertical elements and interrupting horizontal lines is an alternative strategy Columns projecting from fascia visually interrupt spans. Art deco detailing also provides visual interest
  • 38. #6 Pier Shape • “Framed” piers with multiple columns and drop pier cap are the most common pier type
  • 39. #6 Pier Shape • Single column hammerhead piers increase transparency, particularly on skewed crossings Slender pier caps emphasize superstructure and result in a more transparent structure
  • 40. #6 Pier Shape • Wide column spacing may make sense on urban bridges to provide for more reflected light and an open appearance Post tensioned pier caps allow for longer cap beam spans. Reflected light and unobstructed sight lines makes the under-bridge space more inviting
  • 41. #6 Pier Shape • Proportions of framed piers need to be carefully considered Pier cap appears to be far too massive relative to the columns that support it Cantilevers appear out of proportion to total cap width
  • 42. #6 Pier Shape • Wall type piers offer a wide range of visual expression
  • 43. #6 Pier Shape • Integral pier caps result in continuity and minimize substructure mass
  • 44. #6 Pier Shape • Combining pier types and shapes results in visual discord. Be consistent
  • 45. #7 Abutment Shape • Articulated tall abutments with wrap around wing walls visually anchor the bridge ends and define a portal
  • 46. #7 Abutment Shape • Front faces of abutment walls may provide opportunities Urban bridge with pedestrian traffic beneath. Articulated abutment surface and ceramic tile on abutment face provide visual interest Gateway bridge incorporates pilasters into abutment face. Strong shadows break up wide abutment surface
  • 47. #7 Abutment Shape • Consider proportions and scale of abutments and how they relate to the superstructure Abutment pilasters define the ends of the crossing and provide human scale features for pedestrians. Scale of pilasters is appropriate
  • 48. • Is relatively inexpensive • Is subjective • Is much more complex than most people realize #8 Color
  • 49. #8 Color • Issues to consider – Durability and maintenance of coatings – Graffiti resistance – Application over large areas /uniformity – Appearance during different seasons – Site Physical Context • Vegetation and soils /rocks in rural environments • Building materials in urban environments
  • 50. #8 Color • Blend with the environment • Contrast with the environment
  • 51. #8 Color • Color has a cultural dimension New Mexico bridges
  • 52. #8 Color • Color can influence our perceptions “Purple People Bridge” “Big Mac”
  • 53. #9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details • Values and attitudes related to ornamented bridges have changed over time Photos: Wikimedia Photo: Carnegie Library, Wikimedia
  • 54. #9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details • During the late 20th century, the prevailing approach was to eliminate ornament. “Form follows function” also accommodated need for economy and rapid construction. Photos: infrastructurist.com
  • 55. #9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details • Avoid using structural forms as ornament Decorative arches attached to conventional highway overpass bridges as ornament. These arches obviously do not support these bridges
  • 56. #9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details • Avoid using false structural members to mimic structure Decorative truss members attached to conventional prestressed girder bridge to create landmark bridge. Have long term maintenance requirements been considered?
  • 57. #9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details • Consider proportions and scale of ornament, and how it relates to the bridge structure Brick parapet and ornamental lighting overwhelms the simple concrete bridge beneath. Is this a bridge or a wall with openings?
  • 58. #9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details • Be careful in using formliners Formliner pattern suggests an unstable detail in masonry construction Photo: Federal Highway Administration Would a fieldstone wall span this road?
  • 59. #9 Texture, Ornamentation and Details • Pilasters or monuments visually define the ends of bridges or mark one’s position within the bridge length Photo: Historicbridges.org
  • 60. #10 Lighting, Signing and Landscaping • Emotional Impact of Good Lighting Before After
  • 61. #10 Lighting, Signing and Landscaping • Lighting Considerations – Maintenance – Lamping and Energy – Physical Constraints – Color Rendering – Wildlife Concerns – Light Pollution
  • 62. #10 Lighting, Signing and Landscaping • Terracing and landscaping visually softens the connection between a bridge and its site
  • 63. #10 Lighting, Signing and Landscaping • An alternative approach is use landscaping to a reinforce a strong visual “anchor” at the bridge ends
  • 64.
  • 65.
  • 66.
  • 67. Bridge Aesthetics Sourcebook • “Practical Ideas for Short and Medium Span Bridges” Draft developed by AFF10(2) on March 2009 • http://bridgeaesthetics.org/ • Endorsed by AASHTO SCOBS in 2010 • “AASHTO Bridge Aesthetics Sourcebook, First Edition”
  • 68. How much does it cost?  “It is unwise to pay too much. But it is worse to pay too little. There is hardly anything in the world that can’t be made a little worse and to sell a little cheaper” - John Ruskin  “At the opposite extreme, increasing project costs does not necessarily result in a better design. A common idea.. is that a bridge which is attractive in 68 appearance must be more expensive than one which is not. There is no evidence that this is so. In fact, a good looking bridge is likely to have had more thought devoted to all aspects of its design; it will probably be more fully an integrated design and could even cost less to build.” - WJR Smyth
  • 70. POLL RESULTS OF NEW JERSEY ENGINEERS
  • 71. Who cares about bridge aesthetics?
  • 72. Who cares about bridge aesthetics?