A nationally known consultant, Terry "TJ" Young, provides insight into best practices with regard to Reclaimed Asphalt Pavement (RAP) management at an asphalt plant. Presentation delivered Oct. 13, 2021 at the CalAPA Fall Asphalt Pavement Conference in Sacramento.
3. • Has moved from Strategic Advantage …to a
Strategic Necessity for the producer
• The greater percentage your recycling
capability, the better your strategic positioning
• Need to be able to recycle effectively to the
highest RAP % the mix quality / mix
characteristics / plant equipment allows
Why Recycle? Why RAP?
4. What we will discuss …
• Stockpiling RAP
• Crushing and Sizing RAP
• What Kinds of Crushers Work Best
• The Need for Testing…
• Feeding RAP into the Plant
• “Limits to RAP”
5. Stockpiling RAP
Original Best Mgt. Practices
• Stockpile known RAP sources – process and
stockpile separately – ID - design JMF to pile
(Requires large stockpile area – But some sources do not yield
enough RAP to stockpile separately! – Although some states do
require state owned RAP in a separate pile …)
6. Processing RAP
Best Management Practices
• Crushing/screening, together with loader
blending, makes homogenous RAP product
from a pile of different RAP sources
(Unexpected originally,
but now time-proven)
(Really!)
8. Stockpiling RAP
Best Management Practices
• RAP stockpiles don’t drain – it is there forever
– keep water from accumulating by how you
stockpile material
9. RAMPS allow more material in smaller footprint
AND seal the material from moisture accumulation
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15. Processing RAP
Best Management Practices
• “Working the face” - loader or trackhoe
blending the feed stock - is typical for making
a homogenous product from “different source”
stockpiles
16. Processing RAP
Best Management Practices
• And reducing to 3/8”, 5/8” or 1/2” minus is
typical so RAP can be used in “all mixes”
… (and target size is locale specific)
17.
18. Processing RAP
Best Management Practices
• Making two RAP products – splitting on 3/8”,
5/8” or 1/2” is typical
– Coarse product
– Fine product
– Helps control gradation
of fines in final mix
– Provides faster heat
transfer for higher
RAP %’s and more
effective drying
19. Processing RAP
Best Management Practices
• “Fractionating”
– Started with commercial
mixes to eliminate
“oversize” rock in mixes
20. Processing RAP
Best Management Practices
• “Fractionating”…
– Started with commercial
mixes to eliminate
“oversize” rock in mixes
– Now used to control the
–200 fraction and fine
aggregate (voids)
in the final mix
21. Processing RAP
Best Management Practices
• “Fractionating”…
– Started with commercial
mixes to eliminate
“oversize” rock in mixes
– Now used to control the
–200 fraction and fine
aggregate (voids)
in the final mix
– Can aid in the design
of produce-able mixes
(AC, gradation, heat xfr)
22. Processing RAP
“Fractionating”
3/8”(1/4) x 0”
High -200s
High AC%
Fast Heat XFR
5/8”(1/2) x 3/8”(1/4)
Lower -200s
Lower AC%
Ave Heat XFR
3/4”(5/8) +
No -200s?
Very Low AC%
Slow Heat XFR
23. Processing RAP
“Fractionating”
3/8”(1/4) x 0”
High -200s
High AC%
Fast Heat XFR
5/8”(1/2) x 3/8”(1/4)
Lower -200s
Lower AC%
Ave Heat XFR
3/4”(5/8) +
No -200s?
Very Low AC%
Slow Heat XFR
May Help You to Control
the Design, Quality,
and “Produce-Ability”
of Your Final Mix
for Higher RAP %
24. Processing RAP
Crushing and Screening RAP
• Impact crushers have highest reduction ratio
• Impact crushers break particle bonds easier
• Jaw/Roll combination crushers are second
most popular choice (getting harder to find used
plants once cheap + sometimes used to reduce fines)
25. Processing RAP
Crushing and Screening RAP
• Feed and primary/secondary breaking
curtains affect throughput and gradation
• “High” and “Low” bars help improve
throughput and produce uniform gradation
26. Processing RAP
Crushing and Screening RAP
• Remember to work face with loader or hoe
while feeding the crusher to help produce a
uniform final product (KEY)
27. Processing RAP
Crushing and Screening RAP
• OK to stack material – typically will not compact
(At least not too much! Depends on AC% and age…)
(Slight amount of moisture reduces dust and aids in
removal later, but too much reduces tph and raises
drying costs)
28. Processing RAP
Crushing and Screening RAP
• OK to stack material – typically will not compact
(At least not too much! Depends on AC% and age…)
(Proper stacking techniques minimize segregation!)
(This influences your final AC content and gradation)
29. Processing RAP
Stockpiling and Handling
• Stockpile finished RAP so that water drains
“off” stockpile … don’t create “valleys” where
moisture can accumulate in finished piles
30.
31. Processing RAP
Stockpiling and Handling
• Covering at crushing can lower moisture %,
which lowers fuel cost and raises RAP %
(Many producers process as they use or cover
stockpile with a tarp or shed or both)
32. Stockpiling and Feeding RAP
Best Management Practices
Unique Characteristics to RAP:
• Does not drain - retains moisture
• Forms a “crust” on the surface from
absorbing radiant heat from sun
• Crust, however, easily broken with loader
33. Stockpiling and Feeding RAP
Best Management Practices
• Do not dig into “new crust” or dry area of RAP
pile after rain to reduce moisture!
(Remove “wet part” of open face
and set aside to dry)
(Keeps RAP % up, drying
costs down, and ensures
adequate drying and heating
of RAP)
34. Stockpiling and Feeding RAP
Best Management Practices
• “Breaker” or “Scalping Screen” helps keep
“crust” or re-agglomerated particles from mix
35. Stockpiling and Feeding RAP
Best Management Practices
• Can also install impact crusher into feed bin
and scalping screen circuit – downsize in
route to plant
(couple different
ways to do this)
36. • “Trickle feed” RAP bin when charging bin with
loader
(RAP more prone to bridge
than even fine aggregates)
(Ensures uniform and
consistent feed of RAP)
Stockpiling and Feeding RAP
Best Management Practices
37. • Unload RAP bin each night … and after 1-2
hours of down time?
(Helps keep feed uniform,
especially in humid
climates – depends
on RAP moisture)
Stockpiling and Feeding RAP
Best Management Practices
38. • Key for mix success = keep RAP feed uniform
(ensures consistency of final mix, especially with
drum-mix style plants)
(affects scale signal &
“hunting / seeking” blend)
(affects temp of final mix)
Stockpiling and Feeding RAP
Best Management Practices
39. Personally not a fan …
• Installing impact crushers into feed bin and
scalping screen circuit – downsize in route to
plant
– (can negatively consistency of mix, especially with
drum-mix style plants)
– (affects scale signal &
“hunting / seeking” blend)
– (affects temp of final mix)
41. 1. Heat Transfer Capability of the Machine
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
42. 1. Heat Transfer Capability of the Machine
2. Managing “Dust” in the Final Mix
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
43. 1. Heat Transfer Capability of the Machine
2. Managing “Dust” in the Final Mix
3. Binder Characteristics in the Final Mix
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
44. 1. Heat Transfer Capability of the Machine
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
45. 1. Heat Transfer Capability of the Machine
• Not all plants are created equal
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
46. 1. Heat Transfer Capability of the Machine
• Not all plants are created equal
• Length is your friend (length = time)
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
47. 1. Heat Transfer Capability of the Machine
• Not all plants are created equal
• Length is your friend (length = time)
• Longer heat transfer times = higher RAP
capability
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
48. Recycling with a Drum-
Mixer
Parallel-flow drum-mixers heat RAP
convectively with hot gases (50% possible)
Counter-flow drum-mixers heat RAP
conductively with super-heated virgin
aggregate (25-50% based on style/conditions)
RAP Enters
Here,
or Here
58. 1. Heat Transfer Capability of the Machine
• Not all plants are created equal
• Length is your friend (length = time)
• Longer heat transfer times = higher RAP
capability
• High RAP plants are now often a two
step process
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
59. 1. Heat Transfer Capability of the Machine
• Not all plants are created equal
• Length is your friend (length = time)
• Longer heat transfer times = higher RAP
capability
• High RAP plants are now often a two
step process
• Drying and heating in one device
• Mixing AC in another
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
61. Recycling with a Batch Plant
RAP is heated conductively with super-heated
virgin aggregate … and managing the steam
is key to successful high RAP ratio production
62. Using RAP in a Batch Plant
Two methods typical:
• Weigh Hopper / Weigh Batcher
• Bucket Elevator
(both rely on conductive heat transfer)
63. “Weigh Box” Batch Facility
Recycling Technique
RAP Bin Batch Steam
Release to
Emission
Control
Equipment
73. 2. Managing Dust in the Final Mix
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
74. 2. Managing Dust in the Final Mix
• Maintaining a proper dust/binder ratio
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
75. 2. Managing Dust in the Final Mix
• Maintaining a proper dust/binder ratio
• Dust in the RAP/RAS is “bound” and
can’t be “liberated”
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
76. 2. Managing Dust in the Final Mix
• Maintaining a proper dust/binder ratio
• Dust in the RAP/RAS is “bound” and
can’t be “liberated”
• Can manage the dust removed from
the virgin material (partial dust removal)
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
77. 2. Managing Dust in the Final Mix
• Maintaining a proper dust/binder ratio
• Dust in the RAP/RAS is “bound” and
can’t be “liberated”
• Can manage the dust removed from
the virgin material (partial dust removal)
• Several ways to do this …
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
86. 3. Managing Final Binder Characteristics
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
87. 3. Managing Final Binder Characteristics
• Rheology of the asphalt cement
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
88. 3. Managing Final Binder Characteristics
• Rheology of the asphalt cement
• Use of softer binders OR rejuvenating
agents (choices affected by local market
conditions + preferences)
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
92. 3. Managing Final Binder Characteristics
• Rheology of the asphalt cement
• Use of softer binders or rejuvenating
agents (choices affected by local market
conditions + preferences)
• Measuring recovered Performance Grade
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
93. 3. Managing Final Binder Characteristics
• Rheology of the asphalt cement
• Use of softer binders or rejuvenating
agents (choices affected by local market
conditions + preferences)
• Measuring recovered Performance Grade
• Measuring Delta Tc
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…
94. 3. Managing Final Binder Characteristics
• Rheology of the asphalt cement
• Use of softer binders or rejuvenating
agents (choices affected by local market
conditions + preferences)
• Measuring recovered Performance Grade
• Measuring Delta Tc
• Measuring with “mix performance tests”
The 3 “Limits” to High RAP Mixes…