Autoimmune Inner Ear
Disease(AIED)
Dr. JINU V IYPE
3RD YEAR PG
DEPARTMENT OF ENT
References:
• Cummings otorhinolaryngology 6th edition
• Ballenger's otorhinolaryngology – 16th edition
• Diseases of ear 6th edition – Harold ludman
• Scott brown 8th edition
• Historically the inner ear has been regarded
as an immunoprivileged site,
separated by the blood labyrinthine
barrier.
• Immunoglobulins (predominantly IgG)
are found in the perilymph at a fraction of
their serum concentrations.
• Endolymphatic sac
is thought to be the
likely site for
immune processing
due to the presence
of lymphocytes in the
perisaccular tissues.
Definition:
• The term autoimmune inner ear disease (AIED) refers to a
group of diseases in which hearing loss or vestibular
dysfunction results from an immune-mediated process.
Primary Secondary
pathology restricted multi-systemic autoimmune diseases
to the cochlea and inner ear
vestibular organs Cogan syndrome, Wegener
granulomatosis , SLE
• AIED was first described by McCabe1 in 1979 as
B/L SNHL that progressed over weeks to months
and was responsive to immunosuppressive agents/
steroids.
• Rare disorder in both its primary and secondary
forms-
<1% of hearing impairment or dizziness.
• Female
• Ages of 20 and 50 years.
There are several theories that
propose- cause of AIED
• In1980s -the inner ear
was capable of
mounting a locally
mediated immune
response via
endolymphatic sac
appears to be critical to
the formation of this
immune response
Cells that mediate this
response appear to
gain access to the
perilymphatic space
(scala tympani) via the
spiral modiolar vein.
The inflammatory
cascade that results
can cause decreased
function secondary to
loss of sensory cells,
fibrosis, and
eventually
osteoneogenesis
within the cochlea.
• Vasculitis within the labyrinthine
vasculature, including the stria
vascularis, is a likely mechanism of
pathogenesis, particularly in cases of
systemic vasculitides.
• A cochlear neuritis could, theoretically,
result in pathology that responds to
immunosuppressive treatment.
• Harris et al used bovine inner-ear extract as
antigen in Western blot assays and detected
antibody to a 68 kDa antigen in 35% of
patients with progressive SNHL.
• Inner ear-specific highly inducible heat shock
protein 70 (hsp70).
– hsp70 antibodies are elevated in autoimmune
SNHL
– presence of antibodies to hsp70 found in AIED
• Damage to the inner ear results in the release of
cytokines which trigger immune reactions.
– TNF-alpha, IL-1A, NFkB and IkBa have all been
found in the cochlea.
• Activation of cochlear nuclear factor kappa B
(NFКB)
• The inner ear may share common antigens with
potentially harmful substances and T-cells and
antibodies may damage the inner ear when trying
to fight these antigens.
• COCH5B2 has been proposed as a target antigen.
• Most recent study found the incidence of anti
type II collagen antibodies to be very low and
disputed it as a cause of AIED.
CLINICAL PRESENTATION
• The clinical hallmark of AIED is bilateral SNHL
that progresses over weeks to months.
• Aural fullness
• Tinnitus
• Vestibular symptoms = ataxia
imbalance
positional or episodic vertigo
motion intolerance
• Patients with primary AIED will rarely have
significant findings on clinical examination.
• In cases of secondary AIED, systemic
manifestations of the underlying autoimmune
disease
middle ear effusion (WG)
cough (WG);
skin lesions,
chondritis,
chronic sinusitis
visual loss (Cogan or Susac syndrome).
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
1. SSNHL
AIED SSNHL
Hearing loss
progresses over weeks
to months
Sudden and not
progressively
occur with unilateral
hearing loss,
eventually both ears
are involved
uniformly unilateral
LABORATORY TESTING
• The lymphocyte migration inhibition assay
• lymphocyte transformation test
-are of historic interest.
• Anti–HSP(heat shock protein )-70
• Serum tumor necrosis factor (TNF) levels.
an elevated TNF in a patient who comes in with
hearing loss strongly supports a diagnosis of an
immune-related hearing loss
low sensitivity precludes its use as a screening test.
Additionally, the level of TNF was not found to correlate
with treatment response with corticosteroids.
• complete blood count with differential
• erythrocyte sedimentation rate
• C-reactive protein
• rheumatoid factor
• antinuclear antibodies
• antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies(ANCA)
• anti–double-stranded DNA antibodies,
• anti-SSA/B antibodies,
• antiphospholipid antibodies,
• complement levels,
• thyroid-stimulating hormone and free thyroxine
levels.
• Otosyphilis must be ruled out with a test for
tertiary syphilis
–fluorescent treponemal antibody absorption
test
–micro-hemagglutination assay.
TREATMENT OF PRIMARY
AUTOIMMUNE INNER EAR
DISEASE
• Corticosteroids (prednisone or dexamethasone)
remain the standard of care for patients with
primary AIED.
• for adults consists of a therapeutic trial of
prednisone 1 mg/kg/day for 4 weeks and
must be started as soon as possible, because
irreversible damage can occur within 3 months
of onset.
• Patients who do respond are tapered slowly over
4 weeks to a maintenance dose of 10 to 20
mg/day.
• Relapse of symptoms-
restarted with high-dose steroids for 4
weeks.
• Side effect:
– Hyperglycemia, hypertension, Gastritis, weight gain,
pancreatitis, osteroporosis, opportunistic infection
INTRATYMPANIC CORTICOSTEROIDS
• Gaining popularity as a treatment for SSNHL.
Advantage
• Reduction in systemic corticosteroid side effects.
• IT steroids very rarely cause changes in serum glucose levels in
patients with diabetes.
• Given to patients with cataracts, myasthenia gravis
and glaucoma.
• The most frequently administered IT steroids are
DEXAMETHASONE- 10–24 mg/mL
SOLUMEDROL (methyl prednisolone sodium
succinate)- 30–40 mg/mL
Higher concentrations
may have better outcomes.
Use of facilitator
• Improved transport across the round window
membrane-histamine and hyaluronic acid.
Frequency and injection technique
• via a spinal needle on a syringe, through a
grommet or myringotomy,
• via a MicroWick or microcatheter
• hydrogel applications
• nanoparticles.
• Transtympanic needle or grommets are the
most frequently used
METHOTREXATE
• use methotrexate as a first-line prednisone-
sparing treatment.
• oral dose 7.5 to 20 mg weekly with folic acid
• Patients with severe hearing losses
• positive 68 kD Western blots
• Non responsiveness to prednisone or MTX
therapy
should be given to a trial of cyclophosphamide
CYCLOPHOSPHAMIDE
• Low-dose cyclophosphamide with low-dose
prednisolone as a test treatment for AIED for
3 weeks
• Cyclophosphamide was discontinued first
• steroids were tapered as long as hearing was
maintained.
Side effects
– Infection
– Myelosuppression
– Hemorrhagic cystitis
– Infertility
– Malignancy.
oral doses of 1 to 2 mg per day taken each
morning with liberal amounts of fluid
ETANERCEPT
• An antibody to TNF,
an important
inflammatory mediator
throughout the body
found at high levels in
the spiral ligament
fibrocytes when they
are stimulated by
inflammatory cytokines.
• Etanercept has proven to
be both safe and
relatively effective for
patients with
rheumatoid arthritis,
and several small,
studies have
demonstrated return of
hearing and a positive
safety profile in AIED
patients.
• Animal studies have
supported its use as
well, with reduced
cochlear inflammation
and improved hearing
reported.
OTHER TREATMENTS
• Mycophenolate mofetil - inhibits both T- and
B-cell synthesis, is well tolerated, and has a
favorable toxicity profile.
• Systemic administration of medications-
blood-cochlea barrier limits the amount of a
drug that can be delivered to the inner ear
doses that are systemically toxic may be
required to achieve therapeutic
concentrations at the site of interest.
• Plasmapheresis has also been shown to
improve hearing in some patients with
AIED.
• Its use as an adjunct for patients who do
not respond to or are intolerant of
immunosuppression
SYSTEMIC
AUTOIMMUNE
DISEASES
ASSOCIATED
WITH HEARING
LOSS
COGAN SYNDROME
• It is an autoimmune
disease characterized by
nonsyphilitic ocular
keratitis
vestibulocochlear
dysfunction.
• an interval between the
onset of the ocular and
audiovestibular features
of less than 2 years.
• The cochleovestibular symptoms include
vertigo and tinnitus
– Vestibular symptoms generally have a sudden
onset and last for days
• Hearing loss sudden, bilateral, fluctuating, and
progressive, and is most often down-sloping
• Ocular symptoms result from interstitial
keratitis
– bilateral
– Pain
– scleral redness
– photophobia.
– Visual acuity is decreased secondary to corneal
clouding
• Diagnosis is based on clinical examination and
exclusion of other autoimmune diseases.
• Anti-HSP 70 antibodies may be a marker for
the autoimmune nature of the hearing loss.
• ANCA positivie
• Ocular manifestations are treated with topical
steroids
• Hearing improvement with systemic
steroids(~)
• Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada syndrome is similar to
Cogan syndrome
– also includes alopecia
– vitiligo
– meningeal findings.
It is thought to be secondary to melanocytic antigens.
Granulomatosis with polyangiitis
• Necrotizing granulomatous inflammation
usually involves the upper and lower
respiratory tracts.
• Conductive hearing loss caused by middle ear
inflammation, or eustachian tube dysfunction
• pulmonary granulomata
• necrotizing glomerulonephritis
• skin rashes, arthritis, neuropathies,
• CNS, heart and GI involvement can all occur.
• In the localized phase of the disease 50% are
ANCA negative
• when generalized disease is present 90% are
positive for PR3 ANCA.
Treatment:
• intensive treatment with high dose steroids,
cyclophosphamide,
• for severe cases with methotrexate
• rituximab in milder cases.
Systemic lupus erythematous (SLE)
• Systemic lupus erythematous (SLE) represents
a common autoimmune disease characterized
by excessive production of antinuclear
antibodies that can form immune complexes
in the
SUSAC SYNDROME
• Aka retinocochleocerebral vasculopathy, is
thought to be an AIED.
• It is also known as RED-M syndrome :-
– retinopathy,
– Encephalopathy
– deafness
– microangiopathy.
• The inner ear pathology results from cochlear end-
arteriole occlusion.
• Hearing loss generally fluctuates and is asymmetric;
it is worse in the low to middle
frequencies, which reflects the predominance of
arteriopathy at the cochlear apex.
• Vestibular symptoms may also be present, and this
indicates involvement of the labyrinth.
Treatment
• Immunosuppressive treatment regimens form the
foundation of treatment, and antiplatelet agents serve
as adjuvants.
Behçet’s disease
• Behcet’s disease (BD) is a multi-system
vasculitis characterized by recurrent oral and
genital ulceration, skin lesions, audiovestibular
involvement and ocular inflammation.
• Diagnostic criteria are based on recurrent oral ulcers
occurring three times in 12 months plus two of the
following:
• scarring recurrent genita ulcers
• ocular involvement (uveitis or retinal vasculitis)
• skin lesions (such as erythema nodosum,
pseudofolliculitis)
• positive pathergy test (skin reaction to needle
insertion).
• Audiovestibular involvement is frequent with
sensorineural hearing loss in 23–32% of
patients
• bilateral, affecting high frequencies- due to
vasculitis of vessels supplying the cochlea.
• Recurrent vertigo
SUMMARY
• AIED refers to a group of diseases in which hearing
loss or vestibular dysfunction results from an
immune-mediated process.
• It can be Primary & Secondary
• The clinical hallmark of AIED is bilateral,Aural
fullness, Tinnitus and Vestibular symptoms
• Differenciate from SSNHL
• Investigation
• Treatment – systemic steriods/ Intra tympanic
treatment
Thank you!!

Autoimmune inner ear disease(AIED)

  • 1.
    Autoimmune Inner Ear Disease(AIED) Dr.JINU V IYPE 3RD YEAR PG DEPARTMENT OF ENT
  • 2.
    References: • Cummings otorhinolaryngology6th edition • Ballenger's otorhinolaryngology – 16th edition • Diseases of ear 6th edition – Harold ludman • Scott brown 8th edition
  • 3.
    • Historically theinner ear has been regarded as an immunoprivileged site, separated by the blood labyrinthine barrier. • Immunoglobulins (predominantly IgG) are found in the perilymph at a fraction of their serum concentrations.
  • 4.
    • Endolymphatic sac isthought to be the likely site for immune processing due to the presence of lymphocytes in the perisaccular tissues.
  • 5.
    Definition: • The termautoimmune inner ear disease (AIED) refers to a group of diseases in which hearing loss or vestibular dysfunction results from an immune-mediated process. Primary Secondary pathology restricted multi-systemic autoimmune diseases to the cochlea and inner ear vestibular organs Cogan syndrome, Wegener granulomatosis , SLE
  • 6.
    • AIED wasfirst described by McCabe1 in 1979 as B/L SNHL that progressed over weeks to months and was responsive to immunosuppressive agents/ steroids. • Rare disorder in both its primary and secondary forms- <1% of hearing impairment or dizziness. • Female • Ages of 20 and 50 years.
  • 7.
    There are severaltheories that propose- cause of AIED • In1980s -the inner ear was capable of mounting a locally mediated immune response via endolymphatic sac appears to be critical to the formation of this immune response
  • 8.
    Cells that mediatethis response appear to gain access to the perilymphatic space (scala tympani) via the spiral modiolar vein. The inflammatory cascade that results can cause decreased function secondary to loss of sensory cells, fibrosis, and eventually osteoneogenesis within the cochlea.
  • 9.
    • Vasculitis withinthe labyrinthine vasculature, including the stria vascularis, is a likely mechanism of pathogenesis, particularly in cases of systemic vasculitides. • A cochlear neuritis could, theoretically, result in pathology that responds to immunosuppressive treatment.
  • 10.
    • Harris etal used bovine inner-ear extract as antigen in Western blot assays and detected antibody to a 68 kDa antigen in 35% of patients with progressive SNHL. • Inner ear-specific highly inducible heat shock protein 70 (hsp70). – hsp70 antibodies are elevated in autoimmune SNHL – presence of antibodies to hsp70 found in AIED
  • 11.
    • Damage tothe inner ear results in the release of cytokines which trigger immune reactions. – TNF-alpha, IL-1A, NFkB and IkBa have all been found in the cochlea. • Activation of cochlear nuclear factor kappa B (NFКB) • The inner ear may share common antigens with potentially harmful substances and T-cells and antibodies may damage the inner ear when trying to fight these antigens. • COCH5B2 has been proposed as a target antigen.
  • 12.
    • Most recentstudy found the incidence of anti type II collagen antibodies to be very low and disputed it as a cause of AIED.
  • 13.
    CLINICAL PRESENTATION • Theclinical hallmark of AIED is bilateral SNHL that progresses over weeks to months. • Aural fullness • Tinnitus • Vestibular symptoms = ataxia imbalance positional or episodic vertigo motion intolerance
  • 14.
    • Patients withprimary AIED will rarely have significant findings on clinical examination. • In cases of secondary AIED, systemic manifestations of the underlying autoimmune disease middle ear effusion (WG) cough (WG); skin lesions, chondritis, chronic sinusitis visual loss (Cogan or Susac syndrome).
  • 15.
    DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS 1. SSNHL AIEDSSNHL Hearing loss progresses over weeks to months Sudden and not progressively occur with unilateral hearing loss, eventually both ears are involved uniformly unilateral
  • 16.
    LABORATORY TESTING • Thelymphocyte migration inhibition assay • lymphocyte transformation test -are of historic interest. • Anti–HSP(heat shock protein )-70 • Serum tumor necrosis factor (TNF) levels. an elevated TNF in a patient who comes in with hearing loss strongly supports a diagnosis of an immune-related hearing loss low sensitivity precludes its use as a screening test. Additionally, the level of TNF was not found to correlate with treatment response with corticosteroids.
  • 17.
    • complete bloodcount with differential • erythrocyte sedimentation rate • C-reactive protein • rheumatoid factor • antinuclear antibodies • antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies(ANCA) • anti–double-stranded DNA antibodies, • anti-SSA/B antibodies, • antiphospholipid antibodies, • complement levels, • thyroid-stimulating hormone and free thyroxine levels.
  • 18.
    • Otosyphilis mustbe ruled out with a test for tertiary syphilis –fluorescent treponemal antibody absorption test –micro-hemagglutination assay.
  • 19.
    TREATMENT OF PRIMARY AUTOIMMUNEINNER EAR DISEASE • Corticosteroids (prednisone or dexamethasone) remain the standard of care for patients with primary AIED. • for adults consists of a therapeutic trial of prednisone 1 mg/kg/day for 4 weeks and must be started as soon as possible, because irreversible damage can occur within 3 months of onset.
  • 20.
    • Patients whodo respond are tapered slowly over 4 weeks to a maintenance dose of 10 to 20 mg/day. • Relapse of symptoms- restarted with high-dose steroids for 4 weeks. • Side effect: – Hyperglycemia, hypertension, Gastritis, weight gain, pancreatitis, osteroporosis, opportunistic infection
  • 21.
    INTRATYMPANIC CORTICOSTEROIDS • Gainingpopularity as a treatment for SSNHL. Advantage • Reduction in systemic corticosteroid side effects. • IT steroids very rarely cause changes in serum glucose levels in patients with diabetes.
  • 22.
    • Given topatients with cataracts, myasthenia gravis and glaucoma. • The most frequently administered IT steroids are DEXAMETHASONE- 10–24 mg/mL SOLUMEDROL (methyl prednisolone sodium succinate)- 30–40 mg/mL Higher concentrations may have better outcomes.
  • 23.
    Use of facilitator •Improved transport across the round window membrane-histamine and hyaluronic acid.
  • 24.
    Frequency and injectiontechnique • via a spinal needle on a syringe, through a grommet or myringotomy, • via a MicroWick or microcatheter • hydrogel applications • nanoparticles. • Transtympanic needle or grommets are the most frequently used
  • 25.
    METHOTREXATE • use methotrexateas a first-line prednisone- sparing treatment. • oral dose 7.5 to 20 mg weekly with folic acid
  • 26.
    • Patients withsevere hearing losses • positive 68 kD Western blots • Non responsiveness to prednisone or MTX therapy should be given to a trial of cyclophosphamide
  • 27.
    CYCLOPHOSPHAMIDE • Low-dose cyclophosphamidewith low-dose prednisolone as a test treatment for AIED for 3 weeks • Cyclophosphamide was discontinued first • steroids were tapered as long as hearing was maintained.
  • 28.
    Side effects – Infection –Myelosuppression – Hemorrhagic cystitis – Infertility – Malignancy. oral doses of 1 to 2 mg per day taken each morning with liberal amounts of fluid
  • 29.
    ETANERCEPT • An antibodyto TNF, an important inflammatory mediator throughout the body found at high levels in the spiral ligament fibrocytes when they are stimulated by inflammatory cytokines.
  • 30.
    • Etanercept hasproven to be both safe and relatively effective for patients with rheumatoid arthritis, and several small, studies have demonstrated return of hearing and a positive safety profile in AIED patients. • Animal studies have supported its use as well, with reduced cochlear inflammation and improved hearing reported.
  • 31.
    OTHER TREATMENTS • Mycophenolatemofetil - inhibits both T- and B-cell synthesis, is well tolerated, and has a favorable toxicity profile. • Systemic administration of medications- blood-cochlea barrier limits the amount of a drug that can be delivered to the inner ear doses that are systemically toxic may be required to achieve therapeutic concentrations at the site of interest.
  • 32.
    • Plasmapheresis hasalso been shown to improve hearing in some patients with AIED. • Its use as an adjunct for patients who do not respond to or are intolerant of immunosuppression
  • 33.
  • 34.
    COGAN SYNDROME • Itis an autoimmune disease characterized by nonsyphilitic ocular keratitis vestibulocochlear dysfunction. • an interval between the onset of the ocular and audiovestibular features of less than 2 years.
  • 35.
    • The cochleovestibularsymptoms include vertigo and tinnitus – Vestibular symptoms generally have a sudden onset and last for days • Hearing loss sudden, bilateral, fluctuating, and progressive, and is most often down-sloping
  • 36.
    • Ocular symptomsresult from interstitial keratitis – bilateral – Pain – scleral redness – photophobia. – Visual acuity is decreased secondary to corneal clouding
  • 37.
    • Diagnosis isbased on clinical examination and exclusion of other autoimmune diseases. • Anti-HSP 70 antibodies may be a marker for the autoimmune nature of the hearing loss. • ANCA positivie • Ocular manifestations are treated with topical steroids • Hearing improvement with systemic steroids(~)
  • 38.
    • Vogt-Koyanagi-Harada syndromeis similar to Cogan syndrome – also includes alopecia – vitiligo – meningeal findings. It is thought to be secondary to melanocytic antigens.
  • 39.
    Granulomatosis with polyangiitis •Necrotizing granulomatous inflammation usually involves the upper and lower respiratory tracts.
  • 40.
    • Conductive hearingloss caused by middle ear inflammation, or eustachian tube dysfunction • pulmonary granulomata • necrotizing glomerulonephritis • skin rashes, arthritis, neuropathies, • CNS, heart and GI involvement can all occur.
  • 41.
    • In thelocalized phase of the disease 50% are ANCA negative • when generalized disease is present 90% are positive for PR3 ANCA. Treatment: • intensive treatment with high dose steroids, cyclophosphamide, • for severe cases with methotrexate • rituximab in milder cases.
  • 42.
    Systemic lupus erythematous(SLE) • Systemic lupus erythematous (SLE) represents a common autoimmune disease characterized by excessive production of antinuclear antibodies that can form immune complexes in the
  • 44.
    SUSAC SYNDROME • Akaretinocochleocerebral vasculopathy, is thought to be an AIED. • It is also known as RED-M syndrome :- – retinopathy, – Encephalopathy – deafness – microangiopathy.
  • 45.
    • The innerear pathology results from cochlear end- arteriole occlusion. • Hearing loss generally fluctuates and is asymmetric; it is worse in the low to middle frequencies, which reflects the predominance of arteriopathy at the cochlear apex. • Vestibular symptoms may also be present, and this indicates involvement of the labyrinth.
  • 46.
    Treatment • Immunosuppressive treatmentregimens form the foundation of treatment, and antiplatelet agents serve as adjuvants.
  • 47.
    Behçet’s disease • Behcet’sdisease (BD) is a multi-system vasculitis characterized by recurrent oral and genital ulceration, skin lesions, audiovestibular involvement and ocular inflammation.
  • 48.
    • Diagnostic criteriaare based on recurrent oral ulcers occurring three times in 12 months plus two of the following: • scarring recurrent genita ulcers • ocular involvement (uveitis or retinal vasculitis) • skin lesions (such as erythema nodosum, pseudofolliculitis) • positive pathergy test (skin reaction to needle insertion).
  • 49.
    • Audiovestibular involvementis frequent with sensorineural hearing loss in 23–32% of patients • bilateral, affecting high frequencies- due to vasculitis of vessels supplying the cochlea. • Recurrent vertigo
  • 50.
    SUMMARY • AIED refersto a group of diseases in which hearing loss or vestibular dysfunction results from an immune-mediated process. • It can be Primary & Secondary • The clinical hallmark of AIED is bilateral,Aural fullness, Tinnitus and Vestibular symptoms • Differenciate from SSNHL • Investigation • Treatment – systemic steriods/ Intra tympanic treatment
  • 51.

Editor's Notes

  • #26 Inhibtion of nucleotide synthesis prevents cell division.
  • #28 Alkalyting agent