The Power of Appreciative
Inquiry
Sridharan Vembu
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
To a hammer everything looks like a
nail...
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
The creators
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Co creator and Influencer
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
About “What is leadership”
Peter Druker  Leadership is about creation
of alignment of strengths in
ways that make a system’s
weakness irrelevant
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Appreciative Inquiry is…
David Cooperrider
 Cooperative co-evolutionary
search for the best in people,
their organizations,
communities and the world
around them. It involves
systematic discovery of what
gives “life” to an
organization or community
when it’s most effective, and
most capable in economics,
ecological and human terms
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Provides theories and tools for
Appreciative
Enquiry*
 Elevation of system
strengths
 Unification and configuration
of system strengths
 Magnification of system
strengths outward into
society
* - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Cooperrider#Appreciative_Inquiry
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Appreciate – to value, to recognize with gratitude, to
increase in value
Inquiry – to seek to understand through the asking of
questions
Appreciative Enquiry is..
https://www.scrumalliance.org/system/slides/92/original/Michael%20Fortunato_Appreciative%20Agile.pdf
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
5 Principles of Appreciative Inquiry
Constructionist Principle Simultaneity Principle Poetic Principle
Anticipatory Principle Positive Principle
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
The 4 D Cycle
Discover
Dream
Design
Destiny Affirmative
Topic Choice
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
In the very first question we
ask!!
Seeds of change
are…
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Let’s get into our
territory
The Agile World…
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
 What went well / What did not go well / Puzzles /
Possibly, few action Items!!
 Or Start / Stop / Continue
 How much time you usually spend on each category?
 We usually give it a quick pass to “What Went Well” and
focus more on “What didn’t go well” – right?
 Why?
Retrospective – a standard format
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
 Let’s cancel this iteration’s retrospective, as there are
no issues to discuss
 Only couple points on what went well, but 20 points
on what didn’t go well
 Team members harping on a specific problem more
than needed
 Maximum presence in a retrospective after an
“unsuccessful” iteration
Symptoms
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Questions are never neutral..
Problem Solving Mindset
 Why are you always late for
Stand-ups
 How come you missed such a
critical acceptance criteria (AC)
in your test scenario/plan?
 Why are you estimates always
off?
Appreciative Mindset
 Would you like to come up with
a better time that works for you
as well as the team?
 How do we collaborate better to
improve the effectiveness of the
test plan
 What additional help /
information do you need to
come up with better estimates?
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Write down one critical issue that you and your team
discussed in the most recent retrospective
Exercise
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Scenario 1: In a distributed, multi vendor agile program -
lack of capabilities and commitment from one of the
teams
Few Scenarios
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Scenario 2: In a program transition, lack of motivation
from both incoming and outgoing teams
Few Scenarios
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Scenario 3: Distributed Agile – quarterly prioritization
workshops – Team met the target in terms of total
Story points, but way too many scope changes –
unhappy PMO lead
Few Scenarios
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Scenario 4:
Project started in capped T&M Mode with 2 vendors (UX/UI,
backend development)
UX/UI vendor too costly, client asked other vendor to take over
UX/UI. 200% scope creep
No additional budget from client
Together with Business and PO, team did functional and technical
redesign, scope negotiations throughout execution phase
Delivered successfully on time, with ~10% extra budget
Extremely stressful execution phase
Conducted end-of-project Appreciative Inquiry.
Few Scenarios
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Few Scenarios
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Scenario 5:
Team was not motivated – did not find the project
interesting – no learning opportunities – customer
interactions were reluctant and looking for excuses
Absence of Product Owner from customer side –
chaotic environment – ever changing requirements –
loss of trust from both sides
Few Scenarios
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Using the 4 D Processes cycle, restate the same
problem statement in a way to create possibilities
Can you visualize a different outcome?
Exercise
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
 Not a replacement for Retrospective
 Appreciative Inquiry - It’s a journey, not a destination
 Works effectively when you do it in an “inside-out” fashion
 Need for incentivizing individuals would slowly fade away and
become irrelevant
 Anyone in the team can initiate, doesn’t necessarily have to wait
for SM or PM or some lead
 Don’t need to use the carrot and stick approach, ever
 Do not make it ceremonial – It has to be a behavioral change
 More religiously you practice in your project / at workplace, you
would see a positive change extending into your personal life as
well
Thoughts…
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
Thank You
Questions?
This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission

Appreciative Inquiry - An Overview

  • 1.
    The Power ofAppreciative Inquiry Sridharan Vembu This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 2.
    To a hammereverything looks like a nail... This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 3.
    The creators This presentationis copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 4.
    Co creator andInfluencer This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 5.
    About “What isleadership” Peter Druker  Leadership is about creation of alignment of strengths in ways that make a system’s weakness irrelevant This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 6.
    Appreciative Inquiry is… DavidCooperrider  Cooperative co-evolutionary search for the best in people, their organizations, communities and the world around them. It involves systematic discovery of what gives “life” to an organization or community when it’s most effective, and most capable in economics, ecological and human terms This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 7.
    Provides theories andtools for Appreciative Enquiry*  Elevation of system strengths  Unification and configuration of system strengths  Magnification of system strengths outward into society * - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Cooperrider#Appreciative_Inquiry This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 8.
    Appreciate – tovalue, to recognize with gratitude, to increase in value Inquiry – to seek to understand through the asking of questions Appreciative Enquiry is.. https://www.scrumalliance.org/system/slides/92/original/Michael%20Fortunato_Appreciative%20Agile.pdf This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 9.
    5 Principles ofAppreciative Inquiry Constructionist Principle Simultaneity Principle Poetic Principle Anticipatory Principle Positive Principle This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 10.
    The 4 DCycle Discover Dream Design Destiny Affirmative Topic Choice This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 11.
    In the veryfirst question we ask!! Seeds of change are… This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 12.
    Let’s get intoour territory The Agile World… This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 13.
     What wentwell / What did not go well / Puzzles / Possibly, few action Items!!  Or Start / Stop / Continue  How much time you usually spend on each category?  We usually give it a quick pass to “What Went Well” and focus more on “What didn’t go well” – right?  Why? Retrospective – a standard format This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 14.
     Let’s cancelthis iteration’s retrospective, as there are no issues to discuss  Only couple points on what went well, but 20 points on what didn’t go well  Team members harping on a specific problem more than needed  Maximum presence in a retrospective after an “unsuccessful” iteration Symptoms This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 15.
    Questions are neverneutral.. Problem Solving Mindset  Why are you always late for Stand-ups  How come you missed such a critical acceptance criteria (AC) in your test scenario/plan?  Why are you estimates always off? Appreciative Mindset  Would you like to come up with a better time that works for you as well as the team?  How do we collaborate better to improve the effectiveness of the test plan  What additional help / information do you need to come up with better estimates? This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 16.
    Write down onecritical issue that you and your team discussed in the most recent retrospective Exercise This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 17.
    Scenario 1: Ina distributed, multi vendor agile program - lack of capabilities and commitment from one of the teams Few Scenarios This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 18.
    Scenario 2: Ina program transition, lack of motivation from both incoming and outgoing teams Few Scenarios This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 19.
    Scenario 3: DistributedAgile – quarterly prioritization workshops – Team met the target in terms of total Story points, but way too many scope changes – unhappy PMO lead Few Scenarios This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 20.
    Scenario 4: Project startedin capped T&M Mode with 2 vendors (UX/UI, backend development) UX/UI vendor too costly, client asked other vendor to take over UX/UI. 200% scope creep No additional budget from client Together with Business and PO, team did functional and technical redesign, scope negotiations throughout execution phase Delivered successfully on time, with ~10% extra budget Extremely stressful execution phase Conducted end-of-project Appreciative Inquiry. Few Scenarios This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 21.
    Few Scenarios This presentationis copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 22.
    Scenario 5: Team wasnot motivated – did not find the project interesting – no learning opportunities – customer interactions were reluctant and looking for excuses Absence of Product Owner from customer side – chaotic environment – ever changing requirements – loss of trust from both sides Few Scenarios This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 23.
    Using the 4D Processes cycle, restate the same problem statement in a way to create possibilities Can you visualize a different outcome? Exercise This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 24.
     Not areplacement for Retrospective  Appreciative Inquiry - It’s a journey, not a destination  Works effectively when you do it in an “inside-out” fashion  Need for incentivizing individuals would slowly fade away and become irrelevant  Anyone in the team can initiate, doesn’t necessarily have to wait for SM or PM or some lead  Don’t need to use the carrot and stick approach, ever  Do not make it ceremonial – It has to be a behavioral change  More religiously you practice in your project / at workplace, you would see a positive change extending into your personal life as well Thoughts… This presentation is copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission
  • 25.
    Thank You Questions? This presentationis copyrighted to Sridharan Vembu of ThoughtWorks Technologies Pvt. Ltd. No copy or use of this presentation should occur without prior permission