Officers from a medium-sized police department participated in focus groups to identify problems in their patrol areas. There was little consistency across focus groups in the types of problems identified, their locations, or suggested solutions. However, officers were able to identify specific properties generating high levels of disorder-related calls. Solutions for complex area-wide problems tended to involve increased police presence, while crime prevention strategies targeted single-crime problems at specific sites.
BCJ 4101, Police and Community Relations 1 Course Lea.docxaryan532920
BCJ 4101, Police and Community Relations 1
Course Learning Outcomes for Unit V
Upon completion of this unit, students should be able to:
7. Analyze impediments to community policing.
7.1 Explore the challenges faced by law enforcement related to maintaining safe neighborhoods
and communities using community policing strategies.
8. Explain why CPTED (crime prevention through environmental design) and Weed and Seed programs
are important to neighborhood safety.
8.1 Discuss how CPTED is related to community policing strategies designed to maintain safe
neighborhoods and communities.
Reading Assignment
Chapter 9:
Early Experiments in Crime Prevention and the Evolution of Community Policing Strategies
Chapter 10:
Safe Neighborhoods and Communities: From Traffic Problems to Crime
Unit Lesson
In the late 1960s and early 1970s, crime prevention programs became popular. Such programs included
street lighting projects, security survey projects, neighborhood watch projects, and property identification
projects. The street lighting projects employed a strategy called crime prevention through environmental
design (CPTED). This strategy requires that the environment be designed in such a way to reduce and/or
eliminate the elements necessary for crime (e.g., motivated offender, suitable target, absence of a capable
guardian). Street lighting can be strategically placed in an environment to increase the visibility in that area.
Research has found that street lighting projects do not decrease crime rates; however, they do have a
positive impact on how secure community members feel. Property identification projects are designed to allow
community members to identify their property so that in the event that it is stolen it can be identified as that
community member’s property.
Similar to the street lighting projects research has not been able to demonstrate that property identification
projects have an effect on reducing crime in the entire community and/or increasing the apprehension of the
perpetrators of those crimes. Security surveys also take into consideration the design and place when
developing prevention strategies. Once elements of a location that put people at risk or create opportunities
for crime are identified, problem-solving strategies are implemented to develop a crime prevention program
for that environment.
Citizen patrol projects, citizen crime reporting, neighborhood or block programs, and special crime watch
programs (e.g., mobile crime watch, youth crime watch, business crime watch, apartment watch, realtor
watch, and carrier alert) are programs designed to directly involve the community in the crime prevention
process. Citizens actively patrol communities, eliminate environmental opportunities for crime, and/or inform
law enforcement about criminal activity in the community (Miller, Hess, & Orthmann, 2014).
Crime prevention programs have also been specifically designed ...
Community policing aims to build partnerships between police and communities to solve neighborhood problems. It stresses cooperation and collaboration over traditional reactive policing methods. While some research shows community policing can reduce crime and improve public perceptions of police, others note it may overstep civil liberties and disproportionately impact poor and minority communities. Effective strategies include problem-oriented policing, which systematically addresses the underlying causes of community issues.
Conduct an analysis of community policing/tutorialoutletWoodardz
This document discusses the evolution of community policing from traditional policing models. It analyzes community policing strategies including problem-oriented policing used in Newport News, Virginia. Problem-oriented policing focuses on recurring problems using the SARA model of scanning, analysis, response and assessment. The document also discusses how community policing strategies led to the CompStat model which focuses on using crime data and accountability to address problems proactively.
The document discusses the history and key concepts of community policing in the United States. It outlines how community policing emerged in response to rising crime rates and civil rights issues in the 1960s. This led to more research on policing strategies and greater emphasis on community engagement and problem-solving approaches. The core elements of community policing are defined as collaborative community partnerships, organizational transformation, and problem-solving processes. While community policing takes on different forms in different communities, the overall goal is to engage citizens as partners to jointly address public safety issues.
The document discusses the history and key concepts of community policing in the United States. It outlines how community policing emerged in response to rising crime rates and civil rights issues in the 1960s. This led to more research on policing strategies and greater emphasis on community engagement and problem-solving approaches. The core elements of community policing are defined as collaborative community partnerships, organizational transformation, and problem-solving processes. While community policing takes on different forms in different communities, the overall goal is to engage citizens as partners to jointly address public safety issues.
Community policing is a philosophy that promotes partnership between the police and the community. It focuses on problem-solving and addressing the root causes of crime, rather than just responding to incidents. Unlike traditional policing which is reactive, community policing proactively addresses disorder and involves the community in identifying and solving issues. It has evolved over time and relies on information sharing, communication, data analysis, and problem-solving to improve police effectiveness and community relations.
Directed patrol and hot spots policing strategies involve directing police resources to areas and times that experience high levels of crime, based on analysis of crime data and calls for service. Hot spots policing specifically targets a small number of addresses or locations that account for a disproportionate amount of crime and disorder. Directed patrol and hot spot strategies are considered proactive approaches that can produce more information for police and increase citizens' sense of police watchfulness.
BCJ 4101, Police and Community Relations 1 Course Lea.docxaryan532920
BCJ 4101, Police and Community Relations 1
Course Learning Outcomes for Unit V
Upon completion of this unit, students should be able to:
7. Analyze impediments to community policing.
7.1 Explore the challenges faced by law enforcement related to maintaining safe neighborhoods
and communities using community policing strategies.
8. Explain why CPTED (crime prevention through environmental design) and Weed and Seed programs
are important to neighborhood safety.
8.1 Discuss how CPTED is related to community policing strategies designed to maintain safe
neighborhoods and communities.
Reading Assignment
Chapter 9:
Early Experiments in Crime Prevention and the Evolution of Community Policing Strategies
Chapter 10:
Safe Neighborhoods and Communities: From Traffic Problems to Crime
Unit Lesson
In the late 1960s and early 1970s, crime prevention programs became popular. Such programs included
street lighting projects, security survey projects, neighborhood watch projects, and property identification
projects. The street lighting projects employed a strategy called crime prevention through environmental
design (CPTED). This strategy requires that the environment be designed in such a way to reduce and/or
eliminate the elements necessary for crime (e.g., motivated offender, suitable target, absence of a capable
guardian). Street lighting can be strategically placed in an environment to increase the visibility in that area.
Research has found that street lighting projects do not decrease crime rates; however, they do have a
positive impact on how secure community members feel. Property identification projects are designed to allow
community members to identify their property so that in the event that it is stolen it can be identified as that
community member’s property.
Similar to the street lighting projects research has not been able to demonstrate that property identification
projects have an effect on reducing crime in the entire community and/or increasing the apprehension of the
perpetrators of those crimes. Security surveys also take into consideration the design and place when
developing prevention strategies. Once elements of a location that put people at risk or create opportunities
for crime are identified, problem-solving strategies are implemented to develop a crime prevention program
for that environment.
Citizen patrol projects, citizen crime reporting, neighborhood or block programs, and special crime watch
programs (e.g., mobile crime watch, youth crime watch, business crime watch, apartment watch, realtor
watch, and carrier alert) are programs designed to directly involve the community in the crime prevention
process. Citizens actively patrol communities, eliminate environmental opportunities for crime, and/or inform
law enforcement about criminal activity in the community (Miller, Hess, & Orthmann, 2014).
Crime prevention programs have also been specifically designed ...
Community policing aims to build partnerships between police and communities to solve neighborhood problems. It stresses cooperation and collaboration over traditional reactive policing methods. While some research shows community policing can reduce crime and improve public perceptions of police, others note it may overstep civil liberties and disproportionately impact poor and minority communities. Effective strategies include problem-oriented policing, which systematically addresses the underlying causes of community issues.
Conduct an analysis of community policing/tutorialoutletWoodardz
This document discusses the evolution of community policing from traditional policing models. It analyzes community policing strategies including problem-oriented policing used in Newport News, Virginia. Problem-oriented policing focuses on recurring problems using the SARA model of scanning, analysis, response and assessment. The document also discusses how community policing strategies led to the CompStat model which focuses on using crime data and accountability to address problems proactively.
The document discusses the history and key concepts of community policing in the United States. It outlines how community policing emerged in response to rising crime rates and civil rights issues in the 1960s. This led to more research on policing strategies and greater emphasis on community engagement and problem-solving approaches. The core elements of community policing are defined as collaborative community partnerships, organizational transformation, and problem-solving processes. While community policing takes on different forms in different communities, the overall goal is to engage citizens as partners to jointly address public safety issues.
The document discusses the history and key concepts of community policing in the United States. It outlines how community policing emerged in response to rising crime rates and civil rights issues in the 1960s. This led to more research on policing strategies and greater emphasis on community engagement and problem-solving approaches. The core elements of community policing are defined as collaborative community partnerships, organizational transformation, and problem-solving processes. While community policing takes on different forms in different communities, the overall goal is to engage citizens as partners to jointly address public safety issues.
Community policing is a philosophy that promotes partnership between the police and the community. It focuses on problem-solving and addressing the root causes of crime, rather than just responding to incidents. Unlike traditional policing which is reactive, community policing proactively addresses disorder and involves the community in identifying and solving issues. It has evolved over time and relies on information sharing, communication, data analysis, and problem-solving to improve police effectiveness and community relations.
Directed patrol and hot spots policing strategies involve directing police resources to areas and times that experience high levels of crime, based on analysis of crime data and calls for service. Hot spots policing specifically targets a small number of addresses or locations that account for a disproportionate amount of crime and disorder. Directed patrol and hot spot strategies are considered proactive approaches that can produce more information for police and increase citizens' sense of police watchfulness.
Discussion 1In Chapter 7 of Crime Prevention, Robinson states th.docxduketjoy27252
Discussion 1
In Chapter 7 of Crime Prevention, Robinson states that "Rational choice and deterrence theories are two related theories that help understand why criminal justice – including crime control and crime prevention activities of police, courts, and corrections – should help us reduce crime in society" (2012). Answer one of the following questions:
THIS ASSIGNMENT HAS ALREADY BEEN DONE ABOVE. THE NEXT ASSIGNMENT YOU NEED TO DO IS PROVIDE FEEDBACK ON TWO CLASSMATES POSTS. THE LENGTH MUST BE 200 WORDS EACH POST. THERE ARE TWO FEEDBACKS YOU MUST DO. MUST BE POSITIVE FEEDBACK, PROPER GRAMMAR/SENTENCE STRUCTURE, AND ANY OUTSIDE SOURCES YOU USE THAT RELATES TO THE FEEBACK FROM THE STUDENT MUST BE PROPERLY CITED/SCHOLARY SOURCE.
Respond to at least two of your classmates’ posts.
Robinson discusses many theories in Chapters 3 through 7. Some of these theories are: Biological Theories, Psychological Theories, Integrated Theories, Social Learning Theories, Social Control Theories, Routine Activity Theories, Crime Pattern Theories, Anomie Theories, Strain Theories, Institutional Anomie Theories, Contextual anomie and strain theories, Cultural deviance or subcultural theories.
Select a theory other than rational choice or deterrence theories, and compare and/or contrast it to the post of your classmates’ and/or your instructor.
Does one of these theories clarify your understanding of the crime or criminal issue you intend to examine in your Final Project?
DISCUSSION RESPONSE FROM STUDENT ONE JAYMES W.
Rational choice theories are among the fastest growing theories in social science today. Many sociologists and political scientists defend the claim that rational choice theory can provide the basis for a unified and comprehensive theory of social behavior. What distinguishes rational choice theory from other forms of theory is that it denies the existence of any kinds of action other than the purely rational and calculative. All social action can be seen as rationally motivated, as instrumental action, however much of it may appear to be irrational or non-rational.
General deterrence strategies focus on future behaviors, preventing individuals from engaging in crime or deviant by impacting their rational decision making process. Specific deterrence focuses on punishing known deviants in order to prevent them from ever again violating the specific norms they have broken. Through the rational use of punishment as a negative sanction, problematic behavior can be cut down dramatically. Some examples are: shock sentencing, corporal punishment, mandatory arrests for certain behaviors.
Specific deterrence strategies, focuses on punishing known deviants in order to prevent them from ever again violating the specific norms they have broken. The concern here is that motives and rationales that lie behind the original behavior can, perhaps, never be delineated, but through the rational use of punishment as a negative sanction, problematic beh.
Community policing aims to increase public participation in crime prevention by focusing on problem-solving partnerships between police and the community, rather than just law enforcement and order maintenance. Studies have found mixed effects on crime reduction but benefits for public satisfaction and trust in police. This paper reviews different community policing strategies and their effectiveness. It finds that community policing generally improves citizen satisfaction and reduces perceptions of disorder, but does not significantly impact reported crime or fear of crime. Specific problem-solving approaches partnering with the public may be key to evaluating community policing's effectiveness.
Community Policing Essay examples
Community Policing Approach
Community Policing Essay
Community Policing Essay
Define Community Policing
Community Policing
Community Policing
Community Policing Papers
Essay on Community Policing
Philosophy Of Community Policing
Community Policing and Community Justice Essay
Essay about Community Policing
Community Policing: A Case Study
Community Policing Research Paper
Community Based Policing Essay
Community Policing Essay
Importance Of Community Policing
The Pros And Cons Of Community Policing
Community Policing Essay
The document discusses the evidence around police effectiveness in reducing crime trends. In the 1970s-1980s (the "bad"), studies generally found no effect of police strategies on crime rates. In the 1990s-2000s (the "good"), well-designed studies showed positive crime prevention outcomes from focused police strategies, but did not allow inferences about overall crime trends. The problem is that while recent studies show police can reduce crime locally, more research is needed to understand their influence on city- and nationwide crime rates over time. Large multi-city trials are needed to answer the "crime trends question."
EVIDENCE-BASED POLICING 1Jervaughn F. ReidHelm School BetseyCalderon89
EVIDENCE-BASED POLICING 1
Jervaughn F. Reid
Helm School of Government, Liberty University
Evidence-Based Policing
Dr. Melvin Richards
May 19, 2021
Author Note
Jervaughn F. Reid
I do not have any conflict of interest to disclose.
Any communication about this article should be articulated to
Jervaughn F. Reid
Email: [email protected]
EVIDENCE-BASED POLICING 2
Abstract
There have been proposals to incorporate scientific evidence into police work. This paper will look
at evidence-based security, crime prevention, and problem-oriented policing in prosperous
countries. It is believed that some aspects have hindered the advancement of such a plan. Police
officers are not aware of evidence of crime-control techniques and tend not to use traditional or law
enforcement reactions. There is a limited knowledge base on which practitioners can develop
responses to crime problems, and researchers differ about what is helpful. While attempts to
incorporate research into the police system are welcome, caution will be taken against over-trust in
what can be achieved and provide advice to all who work to strengthen the evidence-based
process.
Keywords: Evidence-Based Policing, Criminal Justice and Problematic Police Forces.
EVIDENCE-BASED POLICING 3
Evidence-Based Policing
The use of data to support and guide policymaking has been among the recommended
approaches for the effective attainment of evidence-based policing (Greig-Midlane, 2019;
Farrington et al., 2019). Therefore, there should be a practical approach and techniques of
collecting and interpreting data/evidence at the disposal of the policymakers. Evidence is used to
decide if an offense has been perpetrated, suggest who may have committed it, and attempt to find
a point beyond reasonable suspicion in a court of law (Tewksbury, 2009). Mazzei & Roy (2017)
assert that policing will be more effective and provide long-lasting solutions with evidence.
Traditional practices that lack adequate systematic confirmation are subject to suspicion, according
to evidence-based policing. Evidence-based policing service starts with empirical assessments of
both proven and new methods and procedures. Several police innovations have emerged to include
evidence-based policy, such as the National Intelligence Model (NIM). This paper, however,
focuses on problematic police forces (POP). This is because POP has a more extended history than
NIM. Equally, more research has been carried out on problematic police forces than National
Intelligence Models partly because problematic police forces have a higher foreign profile than
National Intelligence Model in which the National Intelligence Model will eventually overlook.
Lastly, POPs are more committed to public treatment than National Intelligence Models. The
problem-oriented approach to policing and teamwork ostensibly includes identifying, executing,
and creating information to resolve real-world neighbor ...
Running heading LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSME.docxagnesdcarey33086
The document discusses conducting a needs assessment for the Lincoln, Nebraska Police Department. It identifies several needs, including bolstering community policing through proper training and resources. Crime analysis indicates high rates of violent crimes like assault and property crimes like theft. The assessment recommends reformulating the department's goals to include situational crime analysis, hybrid modeling by employing local civilians, and improving community competence to address issues like rape and burglary. An integrated approach utilizing technology, intelligence sharing, and public-private partnerships is needed to secure the city.
Running heading LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSME.docxrtodd599
Running heading: LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSMENT 1
LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSMENT 6
Lincoln, Nebraska Police Department Need Assessment
Student’s Name
Institutional Affiliation
Date
Lincoln, Nebraska Police Department Need Assessment
Introduction
In 1989, the Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies accredited the Police department. The police department focusses on ensuring consistency, fairness, and professionalism in the provision of the policing services. Due to the increase in the number of hacktivists, the department aims at bolstering the sector. Community policing is a fundamental role improved by proper training and allocation of the needed resources. The resources may be human, physical, and financial. This paper focusses on conducting a need assessment for Lincoln, Nebraska department based on the mentioned objectives.
Goals and vision of the department
For effective policing, there is a need to complement the common goals and vision. Cultural competence or community competence is essential in policing. The police service should be aware of the surrounding, which has proved to influence the behavior. Behavior affects the crime rate as criminals can effectively evaluate the environment for the assurance that will succeed. For example, drug peddlers associate littered streets and abandoned houses as the best environment for his business. Through cultural community competence, the department will be useful in curbing such crimes.
The police department needs to analyze crime factors. This has been an effective strategy in the prevention of situational crimes. The crimes include the prevention of robberies of banks and stores. The crime factors have been attributed to causing more trouble to the citizenry. The identification of the relationship between community issues and the physical surrounding calls for the systematic analysis of the environmental conditions. This analysis should be carried using questionnaires in the form of surveys, which are conducted by members of the public and or the police officers. This will also assist in understanding the community within.
Hybrid modeling as a strategy has been effective in boosting the security aspect of a different organization. The concept has been associated with “Hybrid blending,” whereby the respective society produces staff to act as volunteers in the police services (Fenner, 2014). In most cases, these staff will provide non-essential services. These individuals work together with the trained officers as they are trained too. In some cases, the officers can be deployed as police reservists.
Factors considered in the analysis
The needs of the community as far as policing is concerned is crucial in the provision of services. This is based on the issues bothering Lincoln society. Based on data obtained from the neighborhood scout, the crime rate is high in Lincoln. The safest areas inc.
Running heading LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSMEMalikPinckney86
Running heading: LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSMENT 1
LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSMENT 6
Lincoln, Nebraska Police Department Need Assessment
Student’s Name
Institutional Affiliation
Date
Lincoln, Nebraska Police Department Need Assessment
Introduction
In 1989, the Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies accredited the Police department. The police department focusses on ensuring consistency, fairness, and professionalism in the provision of the policing services. Due to the increase in the number of hacktivists, the department aims at bolstering the sector. Community policing is a fundamental role improved by proper training and allocation of the needed resources. The resources may be human, physical, and financial. This paper focusses on conducting a need assessment for Lincoln, Nebraska department based on the mentioned objectives.
Goals and vision of the department
For effective policing, there is a need to complement the common goals and vision. Cultural competence or community competence is essential in policing. The police service should be aware of the surrounding, which has proved to influence the behavior. Behavior affects the crime rate as criminals can effectively evaluate the environment for the assurance that will succeed. For example, drug peddlers associate littered streets and abandoned houses as the best environment for his business. Through cultural community competence, the department will be useful in curbing such crimes.
The police department needs to analyze crime factors. This has been an effective strategy in the prevention of situational crimes. The crimes include the prevention of robberies of banks and stores. The crime factors have been attributed to causing more trouble to the citizenry. The identification of the relationship between community issues and the physical surrounding calls for the systematic analysis of the environmental conditions. This analysis should be carried using questionnaires in the form of surveys, which are conducted by members of the public and or the police officers. This will also assist in understanding the community within.
Hybrid modeling as a strategy has been effective in boosting the security aspect of a different organization. The concept has been associated with “Hybrid blending,” whereby the respective society produces staff to act as volunteers in the police services (Fenner, 2014). In most cases, these staff will provide non-essential services. These individuals work together with the trained officers as they are trained too. In some cases, the officers can be deployed as police reservists.
Factors considered in the analysis
The needs of the community as far as policing is concerned is crucial in the provision of services. This is based on the issues bothering Lincoln society. Based on data obtained from the neighborhood scout, the crime rate is high in Lincoln. The safest areas inc ...
This chapter discusses innovations in policing strategies such as community policing, problem-oriented policing, and zero-tolerance policing. It outlines the characteristics and effectiveness of each approach based on case studies. Community policing aims to build partnerships between police and communities through consultation, collaboration, and citizen involvement. Problem-oriented policing uses the SARA model to systematically address the underlying causes of problems. Zero-tolerance policing aggressively enforces laws against minor crimes and disorder based on the broken windows theory. The chapter evaluates successes and challenges of implementing these new policing models.
Pulling Levers Policing
ADVOCATE
Introduction
Origins of “pulling levers”
1990s - Boston Gun Project
Policing intervention that combines
Traditional tactics with a strategic focus
Also, incorporates new tools
= strategy that appears both OLD and NEW
More importantly, pulling lever strategies have worked in many jurisdictions
Addressed serious crime problems
Innovative Strategy?
David Kennedy’s Argument:
Pulling Levers Framework
Empirical Evidence
Role of Officer Knowledge
Role of Deterrence
Role of Groups/Networks
Role of Traditional Enforcement
Role of Communication
Limitations
Pulling Levers
Pulling levers strategies (focused deterrence) seek to create a powerful deterrent to
Particular behavior by particular offenders
Deterrence is formed through the deployment of
Basic framework for Pulling Levers:
Specific identification of problem
Interagency enforcement group
Analysis of problem
Intervention
Joint response
Direct communication
Empirical Evidence
Available evaluations and site experience suggest strong effects on crime problems
Evaluations of Boston and Indianapolis
Pulling Levers strategy have some external validity
Basic PL framework successful on various gang structures
E.g., Neighborhood-based groups (Boston and Cincinnati), structured gangs (Chicago, Minneapolis, and Indianapolis), and West cost gangs (Stockton and Los Angeles)
However, the external validity of PL strategies are questionable with respect to the following:
Sustainability of intervention has failed in some cities/jurisdictions
E.g., Baltimore and San Francisco
Other crime problems
Less experience in using PL to tackle other crime problems
Has been used to address
Gang violence (gun assaults and gun homicides)
Drug dealing and drug markets
Domestic violence
Role of Officer Knowledge
Pulling Levers strategies are based on what law enforcement know
Officer knowledge is driven by experience
Chronic problems
People
Places
Street life
Role of Officer Knowledge
Value of frontline knowledge
Qualitative research can draw information out that is crucial to pulling levers strategies
How so???
Role of Deterrence
Pulling Levers strategies are deterrence strategies
Many CJ practitioners are skeptical of deterrence
Why???
Pulling Levers strategies seek to rehab basic deterrence
Focus on chronic offenders
Result = Changing offenders’ behavior without necessarily sending them to jail/prison
Role of Groups and Networks
Pulling levers strategies have focused on groups and networks
Why???
Groups of offenders (small % of population) are responsible for most homicides and other serious crimes
Groups and networks have received little attention from law enforcement
Why???
Legal definition
Variation in knowledge
Pulling Levers strategies can target and affect groups
Conspiracy case/RICO
Drug buys from each member
Identification and monitoring
Analysis of group codes and norms
Role of Traditional Enforcement
Law enforcement prefe ...
The document summarizes key aspects of police organization and functions. It discusses the typical hierarchical structure of police departments and how patrol officers spend most of their time handling calls rather than making arrests. It also describes the major purposes of patrol in deterring crime and maintaining order. Detectives focus on investigating crimes through interviewing witnesses and gathering evidence. Community policing aims to form bonds with communities through foot patrols. Problem-oriented policing addresses specific long-term problems through targeted strategies to eliminate them.
Smart policing emphasizes using data and analytics to improve policing strategies, making them more effective, efficient and economical through partnerships between law enforcement and researchers. The Smart Policing Initiative funds local police agencies to design and test evidence-based, data-driven approaches to address various crime problems. These agencies employ intelligence-led policing, problem-oriented policing, and predictive analytics to tackle issues like street crime, drug abuse, and traffic safety.
The document discusses police-community relationships in the United States. It defines community policing as an approach that engages the community as partners with law enforcement to address local crime and disorder issues. The goals of police-community partnerships are to reduce crime and improve public satisfaction. Common partnership programs include community policing, regional information sharing, and coordinated response teams. Effective partnerships require clearly defined, measurable goals and involve all stakeholders. Technology like websites and data sharing systems can help facilitate information exchange between police and communities.
Peelian Principle in a Data-Driven World, By The R Simmons groupRufus Simmons III,MBA
The document discusses how data-driven solutions can help law enforcement build partnerships with communities through engagement and crisis management. It outlines challenges such as ensuring solutions are not perceived as intrusive and building community trust. Key steps are to identify how solutions align with tactics and community needs, develop communication plans to inform and elicit input, and implement feedback loops to monitor effectiveness. The success of the Boston Police Department in using social media to engage residents and counter misinformation during the Boston Marathon bombing is provided as an example.
Peelian Principle in a Data-Driven World, by The R Simmons GroupThe R Simmons Group
The document discusses how data-driven solutions can help law enforcement build partnerships with communities through engagement and crisis management. It outlines challenges such as ensuring solutions are not perceived as intrusive and building community trust. The document recommends balancing inward-focused operational tools with outward-focused solutions that inform and elicit community input to improve lives. It provides examples of how departments have successfully used data-driven solutions like social media and crime analysis to engage with the public and manage crises. The document concludes by discussing the importance of a communication strategy to gain input from all levels when adopting new technologies.
Gun violence preventionpractices among local policein th.docxwhittemorelucilla
Gun violence prevention
practices among local police
in the United States
Christopher S. Koper
Department of Criminology, Law and Society, George Mason University,
Fairfax, Virginia, USA, and
Daniel J. Woods and Bruce E. Kubu
Police Executive Research Forum, Washington, District of Columbia, USA
Abstract
Purpose – The purpose of the study is to examine gun violence prevention practices among urban
police in the USA, assessing their scope, effectiveness, limitations, and impacts.
Design/methodology/approach – A national survey was conducted with police agencies serving
cities of 100,000 or more people.
Findings – Strategies used most frequently and rated as most effective include targeted efforts
focussed on high-risk places and groups, as well as multi-agency problem-solving efforts, particularly
those involving federal authorities. However, most agencies make limited use of proactive strategies to
reduce gun crime, and there are substantial gaps in the enforcement of many gun laws. Results also
suggest that gun crime is lower in places where police engage in more intensive gun-related
enforcement and prevention efforts.
Research limitations/implications – The survey focussed only on large US cities. Implementation
of the strategies could not be examined in detail, and assessments of the effectiveness of strategies
reflect the views of practitioners. There is a need for more in-depth research on gun-related
enforcement and prevention practices, their effectiveness, and the organizational and environmental
factors that facilitate or hinder them.
Practical implications – The study highlights strategies that should be given priority consideration
in policy decisions. The findings also suggest that police efforts to address gun crime can be enhanced
considerably – and that doing so may produce demonstrable reductions in gun crime. Further
examination of policy changes necessary to facilitate these efforts is warranted.
Originality/value – This study represents the first national survey of gun violence reduction efforts
by police in the USA.
Keywords Police, Firearms, Violence, Enforcement, Prevention, National, Survey, Urban,
Effectiveness, USA
Paper type Research paper
Introduction
Controlling gun crime continues to be a difficult challenge for policymakers and
practitioners in the USA. In 2010, there were nearly 10,000 murders with firearms in
the USA[1] and another 3,38,000 non-fatal violent crimes with guns (Truman, 2011).
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at
www.emeraldinsight.com/1363-951X.htm
Received 18 June 2012
Revised 25 September 2012
29 October 2012
Accepted 1 November 2012
Policing: An International Journal of
Police Strategies & Management
Vol. 36 No. 3, 2013
pp. 577-603
r Emerald Group Publishing Limited
1363-951X
DOI 10.1108/PIJPSM-06-2012-0052
This research was supported by funding from the Joyce Foundation and the Motorola
Foundation (the authors thank Chuck Wexler of the Polic ...
The Chief of Police announced the Violent Crime Review Team's summer plan to prevent and suppress crime through various community programs, increased police presence, and focusing enforcement efforts on high-crime areas. The plan includes youth programs, partnering with social services, addressing quality-of-life issues, monitoring parolees, gun interdiction, and coordinating prosecutions. The goal is to engage the community and reduce crime through prevention, intervention, and suppression strategies.
Crime Prevention and Control - 3 Different Approachesmattyp99
1) Three main strategies for social control and ensuring conformity are discussed: situational crime prevention, environmental crime prevention, and social/community crime prevention.
2) Situational crime prevention aims to reduce criminal opportunities through measures like target hardening and increased surveillance. Environmental crime prevention is based on the "broken windows" theory of remedying physical and social disorder.
3) Social/community crime prevention focuses on removing the root social conditions that can lead to offending, such as poverty, unemployment, and poor housing. It emphasizes longer-term solutions rather than just reducing criminal opportunities.
Community Policing And The Community Powerpointjclaytonjr
Community policing is a strategy that builds partnerships between law enforcement and communities to improve public safety. It involves problem-solving tactics like COPPS, POP, and SARA to address issues collaboratively. Patrols are designed to fit each community's needs through various methods like foot, vehicle, horse, and K-9 units. Community policing is supported by programs such as Neighborhood Watch, PAL, and DARE that educate the public and prevent crime. When implemented effectively through partnership and problem-solving, community policing improves communities by reducing crime and empowering residents.
The Pros And Cons Of Community Policing
Community Policing and Community Justice Essay
Community Policing Essay
Community Policing Essay
Essay on Community Policing
Community Policing Research Paper
Community Policing
Community Policing Essay
Essay on Community Oriented Policing (COP)
Community Policing
Philosophy Of Community Policing
Community Policing Research Paper
Community Policing Essay
Community Policing
Community Policing Papers
Community Policing Essay examples
Community Policing Essay
Community Policing: A Case Study
Essay about Community Policing
Community Based Policing Essay
The document provides instructions for a lab experiment to test the relationship between current, force, and length of a conductor wire by passing a current through a wire near magnets. Students are asked to measure the force on the wire for different currents and lengths to understand how force is affected by these variables based on the equation that force is directly proportional to the current and length of the wire and the magnetic field. The objective is to experimentally validate the theoretical relationship between these factors.
Want To Get More People To Support Live Music Start Concerts EarlierJasmine Dixon
The document discusses lucid dreaming, which is the ability to realize when one is dreaming and have control over their dreams. It notes that dreams provide an unlimited playground for the mind where anything can happen, but that people rarely realize the freedoms granted in dreams while having them. Lucid dreaming allows people to gain awareness and control within their dreams.
More Related Content
Similar to An Examination Of Police Officers Insights Into Problem Identification And Problem Solving
Discussion 1In Chapter 7 of Crime Prevention, Robinson states th.docxduketjoy27252
Discussion 1
In Chapter 7 of Crime Prevention, Robinson states that "Rational choice and deterrence theories are two related theories that help understand why criminal justice – including crime control and crime prevention activities of police, courts, and corrections – should help us reduce crime in society" (2012). Answer one of the following questions:
THIS ASSIGNMENT HAS ALREADY BEEN DONE ABOVE. THE NEXT ASSIGNMENT YOU NEED TO DO IS PROVIDE FEEDBACK ON TWO CLASSMATES POSTS. THE LENGTH MUST BE 200 WORDS EACH POST. THERE ARE TWO FEEDBACKS YOU MUST DO. MUST BE POSITIVE FEEDBACK, PROPER GRAMMAR/SENTENCE STRUCTURE, AND ANY OUTSIDE SOURCES YOU USE THAT RELATES TO THE FEEBACK FROM THE STUDENT MUST BE PROPERLY CITED/SCHOLARY SOURCE.
Respond to at least two of your classmates’ posts.
Robinson discusses many theories in Chapters 3 through 7. Some of these theories are: Biological Theories, Psychological Theories, Integrated Theories, Social Learning Theories, Social Control Theories, Routine Activity Theories, Crime Pattern Theories, Anomie Theories, Strain Theories, Institutional Anomie Theories, Contextual anomie and strain theories, Cultural deviance or subcultural theories.
Select a theory other than rational choice or deterrence theories, and compare and/or contrast it to the post of your classmates’ and/or your instructor.
Does one of these theories clarify your understanding of the crime or criminal issue you intend to examine in your Final Project?
DISCUSSION RESPONSE FROM STUDENT ONE JAYMES W.
Rational choice theories are among the fastest growing theories in social science today. Many sociologists and political scientists defend the claim that rational choice theory can provide the basis for a unified and comprehensive theory of social behavior. What distinguishes rational choice theory from other forms of theory is that it denies the existence of any kinds of action other than the purely rational and calculative. All social action can be seen as rationally motivated, as instrumental action, however much of it may appear to be irrational or non-rational.
General deterrence strategies focus on future behaviors, preventing individuals from engaging in crime or deviant by impacting their rational decision making process. Specific deterrence focuses on punishing known deviants in order to prevent them from ever again violating the specific norms they have broken. Through the rational use of punishment as a negative sanction, problematic behavior can be cut down dramatically. Some examples are: shock sentencing, corporal punishment, mandatory arrests for certain behaviors.
Specific deterrence strategies, focuses on punishing known deviants in order to prevent them from ever again violating the specific norms they have broken. The concern here is that motives and rationales that lie behind the original behavior can, perhaps, never be delineated, but through the rational use of punishment as a negative sanction, problematic beh.
Community policing aims to increase public participation in crime prevention by focusing on problem-solving partnerships between police and the community, rather than just law enforcement and order maintenance. Studies have found mixed effects on crime reduction but benefits for public satisfaction and trust in police. This paper reviews different community policing strategies and their effectiveness. It finds that community policing generally improves citizen satisfaction and reduces perceptions of disorder, but does not significantly impact reported crime or fear of crime. Specific problem-solving approaches partnering with the public may be key to evaluating community policing's effectiveness.
Community Policing Essay examples
Community Policing Approach
Community Policing Essay
Community Policing Essay
Define Community Policing
Community Policing
Community Policing
Community Policing Papers
Essay on Community Policing
Philosophy Of Community Policing
Community Policing and Community Justice Essay
Essay about Community Policing
Community Policing: A Case Study
Community Policing Research Paper
Community Based Policing Essay
Community Policing Essay
Importance Of Community Policing
The Pros And Cons Of Community Policing
Community Policing Essay
The document discusses the evidence around police effectiveness in reducing crime trends. In the 1970s-1980s (the "bad"), studies generally found no effect of police strategies on crime rates. In the 1990s-2000s (the "good"), well-designed studies showed positive crime prevention outcomes from focused police strategies, but did not allow inferences about overall crime trends. The problem is that while recent studies show police can reduce crime locally, more research is needed to understand their influence on city- and nationwide crime rates over time. Large multi-city trials are needed to answer the "crime trends question."
EVIDENCE-BASED POLICING 1Jervaughn F. ReidHelm School BetseyCalderon89
EVIDENCE-BASED POLICING 1
Jervaughn F. Reid
Helm School of Government, Liberty University
Evidence-Based Policing
Dr. Melvin Richards
May 19, 2021
Author Note
Jervaughn F. Reid
I do not have any conflict of interest to disclose.
Any communication about this article should be articulated to
Jervaughn F. Reid
Email: [email protected]
EVIDENCE-BASED POLICING 2
Abstract
There have been proposals to incorporate scientific evidence into police work. This paper will look
at evidence-based security, crime prevention, and problem-oriented policing in prosperous
countries. It is believed that some aspects have hindered the advancement of such a plan. Police
officers are not aware of evidence of crime-control techniques and tend not to use traditional or law
enforcement reactions. There is a limited knowledge base on which practitioners can develop
responses to crime problems, and researchers differ about what is helpful. While attempts to
incorporate research into the police system are welcome, caution will be taken against over-trust in
what can be achieved and provide advice to all who work to strengthen the evidence-based
process.
Keywords: Evidence-Based Policing, Criminal Justice and Problematic Police Forces.
EVIDENCE-BASED POLICING 3
Evidence-Based Policing
The use of data to support and guide policymaking has been among the recommended
approaches for the effective attainment of evidence-based policing (Greig-Midlane, 2019;
Farrington et al., 2019). Therefore, there should be a practical approach and techniques of
collecting and interpreting data/evidence at the disposal of the policymakers. Evidence is used to
decide if an offense has been perpetrated, suggest who may have committed it, and attempt to find
a point beyond reasonable suspicion in a court of law (Tewksbury, 2009). Mazzei & Roy (2017)
assert that policing will be more effective and provide long-lasting solutions with evidence.
Traditional practices that lack adequate systematic confirmation are subject to suspicion, according
to evidence-based policing. Evidence-based policing service starts with empirical assessments of
both proven and new methods and procedures. Several police innovations have emerged to include
evidence-based policy, such as the National Intelligence Model (NIM). This paper, however,
focuses on problematic police forces (POP). This is because POP has a more extended history than
NIM. Equally, more research has been carried out on problematic police forces than National
Intelligence Models partly because problematic police forces have a higher foreign profile than
National Intelligence Model in which the National Intelligence Model will eventually overlook.
Lastly, POPs are more committed to public treatment than National Intelligence Models. The
problem-oriented approach to policing and teamwork ostensibly includes identifying, executing,
and creating information to resolve real-world neighbor ...
Running heading LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSME.docxagnesdcarey33086
The document discusses conducting a needs assessment for the Lincoln, Nebraska Police Department. It identifies several needs, including bolstering community policing through proper training and resources. Crime analysis indicates high rates of violent crimes like assault and property crimes like theft. The assessment recommends reformulating the department's goals to include situational crime analysis, hybrid modeling by employing local civilians, and improving community competence to address issues like rape and burglary. An integrated approach utilizing technology, intelligence sharing, and public-private partnerships is needed to secure the city.
Running heading LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSME.docxrtodd599
Running heading: LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSMENT 1
LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSMENT 6
Lincoln, Nebraska Police Department Need Assessment
Student’s Name
Institutional Affiliation
Date
Lincoln, Nebraska Police Department Need Assessment
Introduction
In 1989, the Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies accredited the Police department. The police department focusses on ensuring consistency, fairness, and professionalism in the provision of the policing services. Due to the increase in the number of hacktivists, the department aims at bolstering the sector. Community policing is a fundamental role improved by proper training and allocation of the needed resources. The resources may be human, physical, and financial. This paper focusses on conducting a need assessment for Lincoln, Nebraska department based on the mentioned objectives.
Goals and vision of the department
For effective policing, there is a need to complement the common goals and vision. Cultural competence or community competence is essential in policing. The police service should be aware of the surrounding, which has proved to influence the behavior. Behavior affects the crime rate as criminals can effectively evaluate the environment for the assurance that will succeed. For example, drug peddlers associate littered streets and abandoned houses as the best environment for his business. Through cultural community competence, the department will be useful in curbing such crimes.
The police department needs to analyze crime factors. This has been an effective strategy in the prevention of situational crimes. The crimes include the prevention of robberies of banks and stores. The crime factors have been attributed to causing more trouble to the citizenry. The identification of the relationship between community issues and the physical surrounding calls for the systematic analysis of the environmental conditions. This analysis should be carried using questionnaires in the form of surveys, which are conducted by members of the public and or the police officers. This will also assist in understanding the community within.
Hybrid modeling as a strategy has been effective in boosting the security aspect of a different organization. The concept has been associated with “Hybrid blending,” whereby the respective society produces staff to act as volunteers in the police services (Fenner, 2014). In most cases, these staff will provide non-essential services. These individuals work together with the trained officers as they are trained too. In some cases, the officers can be deployed as police reservists.
Factors considered in the analysis
The needs of the community as far as policing is concerned is crucial in the provision of services. This is based on the issues bothering Lincoln society. Based on data obtained from the neighborhood scout, the crime rate is high in Lincoln. The safest areas inc.
Running heading LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSMEMalikPinckney86
Running heading: LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSMENT 1
LINCOLN, NEBRASKA POLICE DEPARTMENT NEED ASSESSMENT 6
Lincoln, Nebraska Police Department Need Assessment
Student’s Name
Institutional Affiliation
Date
Lincoln, Nebraska Police Department Need Assessment
Introduction
In 1989, the Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies accredited the Police department. The police department focusses on ensuring consistency, fairness, and professionalism in the provision of the policing services. Due to the increase in the number of hacktivists, the department aims at bolstering the sector. Community policing is a fundamental role improved by proper training and allocation of the needed resources. The resources may be human, physical, and financial. This paper focusses on conducting a need assessment for Lincoln, Nebraska department based on the mentioned objectives.
Goals and vision of the department
For effective policing, there is a need to complement the common goals and vision. Cultural competence or community competence is essential in policing. The police service should be aware of the surrounding, which has proved to influence the behavior. Behavior affects the crime rate as criminals can effectively evaluate the environment for the assurance that will succeed. For example, drug peddlers associate littered streets and abandoned houses as the best environment for his business. Through cultural community competence, the department will be useful in curbing such crimes.
The police department needs to analyze crime factors. This has been an effective strategy in the prevention of situational crimes. The crimes include the prevention of robberies of banks and stores. The crime factors have been attributed to causing more trouble to the citizenry. The identification of the relationship between community issues and the physical surrounding calls for the systematic analysis of the environmental conditions. This analysis should be carried using questionnaires in the form of surveys, which are conducted by members of the public and or the police officers. This will also assist in understanding the community within.
Hybrid modeling as a strategy has been effective in boosting the security aspect of a different organization. The concept has been associated with “Hybrid blending,” whereby the respective society produces staff to act as volunteers in the police services (Fenner, 2014). In most cases, these staff will provide non-essential services. These individuals work together with the trained officers as they are trained too. In some cases, the officers can be deployed as police reservists.
Factors considered in the analysis
The needs of the community as far as policing is concerned is crucial in the provision of services. This is based on the issues bothering Lincoln society. Based on data obtained from the neighborhood scout, the crime rate is high in Lincoln. The safest areas inc ...
This chapter discusses innovations in policing strategies such as community policing, problem-oriented policing, and zero-tolerance policing. It outlines the characteristics and effectiveness of each approach based on case studies. Community policing aims to build partnerships between police and communities through consultation, collaboration, and citizen involvement. Problem-oriented policing uses the SARA model to systematically address the underlying causes of problems. Zero-tolerance policing aggressively enforces laws against minor crimes and disorder based on the broken windows theory. The chapter evaluates successes and challenges of implementing these new policing models.
Pulling Levers Policing
ADVOCATE
Introduction
Origins of “pulling levers”
1990s - Boston Gun Project
Policing intervention that combines
Traditional tactics with a strategic focus
Also, incorporates new tools
= strategy that appears both OLD and NEW
More importantly, pulling lever strategies have worked in many jurisdictions
Addressed serious crime problems
Innovative Strategy?
David Kennedy’s Argument:
Pulling Levers Framework
Empirical Evidence
Role of Officer Knowledge
Role of Deterrence
Role of Groups/Networks
Role of Traditional Enforcement
Role of Communication
Limitations
Pulling Levers
Pulling levers strategies (focused deterrence) seek to create a powerful deterrent to
Particular behavior by particular offenders
Deterrence is formed through the deployment of
Basic framework for Pulling Levers:
Specific identification of problem
Interagency enforcement group
Analysis of problem
Intervention
Joint response
Direct communication
Empirical Evidence
Available evaluations and site experience suggest strong effects on crime problems
Evaluations of Boston and Indianapolis
Pulling Levers strategy have some external validity
Basic PL framework successful on various gang structures
E.g., Neighborhood-based groups (Boston and Cincinnati), structured gangs (Chicago, Minneapolis, and Indianapolis), and West cost gangs (Stockton and Los Angeles)
However, the external validity of PL strategies are questionable with respect to the following:
Sustainability of intervention has failed in some cities/jurisdictions
E.g., Baltimore and San Francisco
Other crime problems
Less experience in using PL to tackle other crime problems
Has been used to address
Gang violence (gun assaults and gun homicides)
Drug dealing and drug markets
Domestic violence
Role of Officer Knowledge
Pulling Levers strategies are based on what law enforcement know
Officer knowledge is driven by experience
Chronic problems
People
Places
Street life
Role of Officer Knowledge
Value of frontline knowledge
Qualitative research can draw information out that is crucial to pulling levers strategies
How so???
Role of Deterrence
Pulling Levers strategies are deterrence strategies
Many CJ practitioners are skeptical of deterrence
Why???
Pulling Levers strategies seek to rehab basic deterrence
Focus on chronic offenders
Result = Changing offenders’ behavior without necessarily sending them to jail/prison
Role of Groups and Networks
Pulling levers strategies have focused on groups and networks
Why???
Groups of offenders (small % of population) are responsible for most homicides and other serious crimes
Groups and networks have received little attention from law enforcement
Why???
Legal definition
Variation in knowledge
Pulling Levers strategies can target and affect groups
Conspiracy case/RICO
Drug buys from each member
Identification and monitoring
Analysis of group codes and norms
Role of Traditional Enforcement
Law enforcement prefe ...
The document summarizes key aspects of police organization and functions. It discusses the typical hierarchical structure of police departments and how patrol officers spend most of their time handling calls rather than making arrests. It also describes the major purposes of patrol in deterring crime and maintaining order. Detectives focus on investigating crimes through interviewing witnesses and gathering evidence. Community policing aims to form bonds with communities through foot patrols. Problem-oriented policing addresses specific long-term problems through targeted strategies to eliminate them.
Smart policing emphasizes using data and analytics to improve policing strategies, making them more effective, efficient and economical through partnerships between law enforcement and researchers. The Smart Policing Initiative funds local police agencies to design and test evidence-based, data-driven approaches to address various crime problems. These agencies employ intelligence-led policing, problem-oriented policing, and predictive analytics to tackle issues like street crime, drug abuse, and traffic safety.
The document discusses police-community relationships in the United States. It defines community policing as an approach that engages the community as partners with law enforcement to address local crime and disorder issues. The goals of police-community partnerships are to reduce crime and improve public satisfaction. Common partnership programs include community policing, regional information sharing, and coordinated response teams. Effective partnerships require clearly defined, measurable goals and involve all stakeholders. Technology like websites and data sharing systems can help facilitate information exchange between police and communities.
Peelian Principle in a Data-Driven World, By The R Simmons groupRufus Simmons III,MBA
The document discusses how data-driven solutions can help law enforcement build partnerships with communities through engagement and crisis management. It outlines challenges such as ensuring solutions are not perceived as intrusive and building community trust. Key steps are to identify how solutions align with tactics and community needs, develop communication plans to inform and elicit input, and implement feedback loops to monitor effectiveness. The success of the Boston Police Department in using social media to engage residents and counter misinformation during the Boston Marathon bombing is provided as an example.
Peelian Principle in a Data-Driven World, by The R Simmons GroupThe R Simmons Group
The document discusses how data-driven solutions can help law enforcement build partnerships with communities through engagement and crisis management. It outlines challenges such as ensuring solutions are not perceived as intrusive and building community trust. The document recommends balancing inward-focused operational tools with outward-focused solutions that inform and elicit community input to improve lives. It provides examples of how departments have successfully used data-driven solutions like social media and crime analysis to engage with the public and manage crises. The document concludes by discussing the importance of a communication strategy to gain input from all levels when adopting new technologies.
Gun violence preventionpractices among local policein th.docxwhittemorelucilla
Gun violence prevention
practices among local police
in the United States
Christopher S. Koper
Department of Criminology, Law and Society, George Mason University,
Fairfax, Virginia, USA, and
Daniel J. Woods and Bruce E. Kubu
Police Executive Research Forum, Washington, District of Columbia, USA
Abstract
Purpose – The purpose of the study is to examine gun violence prevention practices among urban
police in the USA, assessing their scope, effectiveness, limitations, and impacts.
Design/methodology/approach – A national survey was conducted with police agencies serving
cities of 100,000 or more people.
Findings – Strategies used most frequently and rated as most effective include targeted efforts
focussed on high-risk places and groups, as well as multi-agency problem-solving efforts, particularly
those involving federal authorities. However, most agencies make limited use of proactive strategies to
reduce gun crime, and there are substantial gaps in the enforcement of many gun laws. Results also
suggest that gun crime is lower in places where police engage in more intensive gun-related
enforcement and prevention efforts.
Research limitations/implications – The survey focussed only on large US cities. Implementation
of the strategies could not be examined in detail, and assessments of the effectiveness of strategies
reflect the views of practitioners. There is a need for more in-depth research on gun-related
enforcement and prevention practices, their effectiveness, and the organizational and environmental
factors that facilitate or hinder them.
Practical implications – The study highlights strategies that should be given priority consideration
in policy decisions. The findings also suggest that police efforts to address gun crime can be enhanced
considerably – and that doing so may produce demonstrable reductions in gun crime. Further
examination of policy changes necessary to facilitate these efforts is warranted.
Originality/value – This study represents the first national survey of gun violence reduction efforts
by police in the USA.
Keywords Police, Firearms, Violence, Enforcement, Prevention, National, Survey, Urban,
Effectiveness, USA
Paper type Research paper
Introduction
Controlling gun crime continues to be a difficult challenge for policymakers and
practitioners in the USA. In 2010, there were nearly 10,000 murders with firearms in
the USA[1] and another 3,38,000 non-fatal violent crimes with guns (Truman, 2011).
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at
www.emeraldinsight.com/1363-951X.htm
Received 18 June 2012
Revised 25 September 2012
29 October 2012
Accepted 1 November 2012
Policing: An International Journal of
Police Strategies & Management
Vol. 36 No. 3, 2013
pp. 577-603
r Emerald Group Publishing Limited
1363-951X
DOI 10.1108/PIJPSM-06-2012-0052
This research was supported by funding from the Joyce Foundation and the Motorola
Foundation (the authors thank Chuck Wexler of the Polic ...
The Chief of Police announced the Violent Crime Review Team's summer plan to prevent and suppress crime through various community programs, increased police presence, and focusing enforcement efforts on high-crime areas. The plan includes youth programs, partnering with social services, addressing quality-of-life issues, monitoring parolees, gun interdiction, and coordinating prosecutions. The goal is to engage the community and reduce crime through prevention, intervention, and suppression strategies.
Crime Prevention and Control - 3 Different Approachesmattyp99
1) Three main strategies for social control and ensuring conformity are discussed: situational crime prevention, environmental crime prevention, and social/community crime prevention.
2) Situational crime prevention aims to reduce criminal opportunities through measures like target hardening and increased surveillance. Environmental crime prevention is based on the "broken windows" theory of remedying physical and social disorder.
3) Social/community crime prevention focuses on removing the root social conditions that can lead to offending, such as poverty, unemployment, and poor housing. It emphasizes longer-term solutions rather than just reducing criminal opportunities.
Community Policing And The Community Powerpointjclaytonjr
Community policing is a strategy that builds partnerships between law enforcement and communities to improve public safety. It involves problem-solving tactics like COPPS, POP, and SARA to address issues collaboratively. Patrols are designed to fit each community's needs through various methods like foot, vehicle, horse, and K-9 units. Community policing is supported by programs such as Neighborhood Watch, PAL, and DARE that educate the public and prevent crime. When implemented effectively through partnership and problem-solving, community policing improves communities by reducing crime and empowering residents.
The Pros And Cons Of Community Policing
Community Policing and Community Justice Essay
Community Policing Essay
Community Policing Essay
Essay on Community Policing
Community Policing Research Paper
Community Policing
Community Policing Essay
Essay on Community Oriented Policing (COP)
Community Policing
Philosophy Of Community Policing
Community Policing Research Paper
Community Policing Essay
Community Policing
Community Policing Papers
Community Policing Essay examples
Community Policing Essay
Community Policing: A Case Study
Essay about Community Policing
Community Based Policing Essay
Similar to An Examination Of Police Officers Insights Into Problem Identification And Problem Solving (20)
The document provides instructions for a lab experiment to test the relationship between current, force, and length of a conductor wire by passing a current through a wire near magnets. Students are asked to measure the force on the wire for different currents and lengths to understand how force is affected by these variables based on the equation that force is directly proportional to the current and length of the wire and the magnetic field. The objective is to experimentally validate the theoretical relationship between these factors.
Want To Get More People To Support Live Music Start Concerts EarlierJasmine Dixon
The document discusses lucid dreaming, which is the ability to realize when one is dreaming and have control over their dreams. It notes that dreams provide an unlimited playground for the mind where anything can happen, but that people rarely realize the freedoms granted in dreams while having them. Lucid dreaming allows people to gain awareness and control within their dreams.
Professional Essay Writers Online Story Of One Author Custom EssayJasmine Dixon
The document discusses getting a tattoo after surviving cancer. The author got their first tattoo at 18 of the phrase "I Win" along with their chemotherapy dates. They developed a close relationship with their tattoo artist but must hide their tattoo around important people and in future jobs. The essay will discuss the history of tattooing from ancient cultures to demonstrate its importance in society and changing views of tattoos in the workplace.
How To Format A College Essay A ComprehensiveJasmine Dixon
Teen suicide is often caused by mental health issues such as depression and anxiety, as well as stressors like academic pressure, family problems, and bullying. Relationship breakups and social isolation can also contribute to suicidal thoughts in teenagers. Underlying medical conditions may play a role as well, exacerbating mental health problems and making teens more vulnerable to suicidal ideation.
A Nature Walk A Descriptive Essay By Toni Seychelle - Hello PoetryJasmine Dixon
This document provides instructions for requesting paper writing assistance from a website. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with a password and email. 2) Complete a 10-minute order form providing instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and select one based on qualifications. 4) Receive the paper and authorize payment if pleased. 5) Request revisions until satisfied, with a refund option for plagiarism. The process aims to match clients with qualified writers and ensure paper quality and customer satisfaction.
How To Write An Essay Cover Page EasyBibJasmine Dixon
The document provides instructions for creating an account on the HelpWriting.net site in order to request that a writer complete an assignment. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with a password and email. 2) Complete a form with assignment details, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and choose one. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment. 5) Request revisions until satisfied. The site promises original, high-quality work or a full refund.
I apologize, upon reviewing the document further it does not appear to contain a full paper discussing social process theory. The introduction provided is incomplete and does not have any body paragraphs analyzing aspects of social process theory. As such, I do not feel comfortable providing a summary. For legal and ethical reasons, I cannot generate or modify full papers without the original author's consent. Please feel free to provide a more substantive document for me to summarize.
Halloween Bats Writing Paper Have Fun TeachingJasmine Dixon
The document provides instructions for requesting writing assistance from HelpWriting.net. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with a password and email. 2) Complete a 10-minute order form providing instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and select one based on qualifications. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment if satisfied. 5) Request revisions to ensure satisfaction, and HelpWriting.net offers refunds for plagiarized work.
How To Write A Movie Review Essay What IJasmine Dixon
The document provides instructions for a 5-step process to request an assignment be written by another writer through the HelpWriting.net website. The steps include 1) creating an account, 2) completing an order form with instructions and deadline, 3) reviewing bids from writers and selecting one, 4) ensuring the completed paper meets expectations, and 5) requesting revisions if needed and being assured of original, high-quality content.
Printable Stationary Paper Borders For Paper ChristmJasmine Dixon
The document summarizes the themes and plot of Giovanni Boccaccio's Decameron. It discusses how the story is set during the Black Death in Florence and follows 10 young Florentines who leave the city to escape the plague. To pass the time in the countryside, they agree to each tell one story per day, with a different person choosing the theme for that day's stories. This introduces multiple genres and allows Boccaccio to explore various topics and social issues through tales of love, betrayal, and more.
025 Theme Essay Example Literary Examples Samples Writing AnalysJasmine Dixon
This document provides a summary of the key differences and similarities between the Bauhaus and Minimalism art movements of the 20th century. Both movements departed from previous art that was symbolic or emotionally driven, instead focusing on simplification, functionality and industrial materials. Bauhaus emphasized design and functionality while Minimalism reduced art to its most basic forms. Overall the movements shared a rejection of ornamentation but differed in Bauhaus' focus on design and Minimalism's emphasis on reducing art to fundamental forms and concepts.
The document provides instructions for requesting an essay writing service from HelpWriting.net. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with a password and email. 2) Complete a 10-minute order form providing instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and choose one based on qualifications. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment if satisfied. 5) Request revisions to ensure satisfaction, and the company offers refunds for plagiarized work.
Describing A Person Paragraph. How To WriteJasmine Dixon
The document provides instructions for seeking writing help from HelpWriting.net. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account and provide contact details. 2) Complete an order form with instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and choose one based on qualifications. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment. 5) Request revisions until satisfied, with a refund option for plagiarized content.
Color Coded Ice Cream Writing Paper (Color BWJasmine Dixon
The passage discusses Susan B. Anthony's act of courage in daring to vote despite it being illegal for women at the time. It compares her act of civil disobedience to voting her right to that of Ana escaping a violent gang in her memoir. Both stories showcase courage but differ in tone - Ana's memoir has a darker, more violent mood while Susan B. Anthony's story has a more uplifting, determined mood as she fights for women's suffrage.
An ecotourism project analysis and evaluation framework for international dev...Jasmine Dixon
This document provides an overview of the book "Ecotourism and Conservation in the Americas". It discusses how ecotourism, when managed properly, can be environmentally, socially, and economically sustainable. The book contains chapters on various case studies of ecotourism projects in communities and protected areas throughout the Americas. It also includes chapters on educating tourists, evaluating ecotourism projects and initiatives, and setting standards for sustainable tourism certification programs. The overall work examines both the opportunities and challenges of using ecotourism to support conservation and local economic development.
Active Listening in Peer Interviews The Influence of Message Paraphrasing on...Jasmine Dixon
This document discusses research on active listening. It defines active listening as communicating nonverbal involvement, paraphrasing the speaker's message without judgment, and asking questions to encourage elaboration. The document reviews two bodies of research. First, it examines research showing active listening is a trainable skill that improves listening abilities for counselors, professionals, and laypeople. Second, it reviews research on the benefits of active listening, finding it may improve perceptions of effectiveness and confidence for the listener, but findings are unclear on benefits for recipients of active listening responses.
A statistical approach to term extraction.pdfJasmine Dixon
This document summarizes previous research on automatic term extraction from text. It discusses three main approaches: statistical approaches that are language-independent, symbolic/rule-based approaches that are language-specific, and hybrid approaches. Within statistical approaches, research has focused on identifying multi-word term units (unithood) and identifying terms representing domain concepts (termhood). Recent successful approaches use graphs of lexical co-occurrence to model term meanings and identify terms based on distributional behavior rather than form. The proposed approach in this paper is presented as a simpler statistical alternative that learns term patterns from examples.
This document provides an overview of the learning objectives and language skills covered in each unit of the Speakout Advanced Plus coursebook. It details the specific grammar, functions, vocabulary, and skills addressed in each unit and maps them to the Global Scale of English and Common European Framework of Reference. The course is designed to take learners from CEFR level A1 to C2 (22-88 on the GSE scale). Each lesson guides students towards 'Can Do' goals aligned with the GSE and CEFR.
A Study Of Artificial Intelligence And Machine Learning In Power SectorJasmine Dixon
This document discusses the application of artificial intelligence and machine learning in the power sector. It begins with an abstract that outlines challenges in the energy sector related to demand, efficiency, supply patterns, and lack of analytics. It then provides background on AI and discusses how technologies like smart grids, smart meters, and IoT devices can help improve power management, efficiency, and use of renewable energy when paired with data analytics techniques like machine learning. The document examines current and potential future applications of AI in areas like fault prediction, maintenance scheduling, and optimizing geothermal and hydropower plants. It concludes by stating that while advanced economies currently lead in AI applications for power, the technologies have potential to address energy access challenges in emerging markets as
Gender and Mental Health - Counselling and Family Therapy Applications and In...PsychoTech Services
A proprietary approach developed by bringing together the best of learning theories from Psychology, design principles from the world of visualization, and pedagogical methods from over a decade of training experience, that enables you to: Learn better, faster!
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
إضغ بين إيديكم من أقوى الملازم التي صممتها
ملزمة تشريح الجهاز الهيكلي (نظري 3)
💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
تتميز هذهِ الملزمة بعِدة مُميزات :
1- مُترجمة ترجمة تُناسب جميع المستويات
2- تحتوي على 78 رسم توضيحي لكل كلمة موجودة بالملزمة (لكل كلمة !!!!)
#فهم_ماكو_درخ
3- دقة الكتابة والصور عالية جداً جداً جداً
4- هُنالك بعض المعلومات تم توضيحها بشكل تفصيلي جداً (تُعتبر لدى الطالب أو الطالبة بإنها معلومات مُبهمة ومع ذلك تم توضيح هذهِ المعلومات المُبهمة بشكل تفصيلي جداً
5- الملزمة تشرح نفسها ب نفسها بس تكلك تعال اقراني
6- تحتوي الملزمة في اول سلايد على خارطة تتضمن جميع تفرُعات معلومات الجهاز الهيكلي المذكورة في هذهِ الملزمة
واخيراً هذهِ الملزمة حلالٌ عليكم وإتمنى منكم إن تدعولي بالخير والصحة والعافية فقط
كل التوفيق زملائي وزميلاتي ، زميلكم محمد الذهبي 💊💊
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Leveraging Generative AI to Drive Nonprofit InnovationTechSoup
In this webinar, participants learned how to utilize Generative AI to streamline operations and elevate member engagement. Amazon Web Service experts provided a customer specific use cases and dived into low/no-code tools that are quick and easy to deploy through Amazon Web Service (AWS.)
THE SACRIFICE HOW PRO-PALESTINE PROTESTS STUDENTS ARE SACRIFICING TO CHANGE T...indexPub
The recent surge in pro-Palestine student activism has prompted significant responses from universities, ranging from negotiations and divestment commitments to increased transparency about investments in companies supporting the war on Gaza. This activism has led to the cessation of student encampments but also highlighted the substantial sacrifices made by students, including academic disruptions and personal risks. The primary drivers of these protests are poor university administration, lack of transparency, and inadequate communication between officials and students. This study examines the profound emotional, psychological, and professional impacts on students engaged in pro-Palestine protests, focusing on Generation Z's (Gen-Z) activism dynamics. This paper explores the significant sacrifices made by these students and even the professors supporting the pro-Palestine movement, with a focus on recent global movements. Through an in-depth analysis of printed and electronic media, the study examines the impacts of these sacrifices on the academic and personal lives of those involved. The paper highlights examples from various universities, demonstrating student activism's long-term and short-term effects, including disciplinary actions, social backlash, and career implications. The researchers also explore the broader implications of student sacrifices. The findings reveal that these sacrifices are driven by a profound commitment to justice and human rights, and are influenced by the increasing availability of information, peer interactions, and personal convictions. The study also discusses the broader implications of this activism, comparing it to historical precedents and assessing its potential to influence policy and public opinion. The emotional and psychological toll on student activists is significant, but their sense of purpose and community support mitigates some of these challenges. However, the researchers call for acknowledging the broader Impact of these sacrifices on the future global movement of FreePalestine.
Beyond Degrees - Empowering the Workforce in the Context of Skills-First.pptxEduSkills OECD
Iván Bornacelly, Policy Analyst at the OECD Centre for Skills, OECD, presents at the webinar 'Tackling job market gaps with a skills-first approach' on 12 June 2024
This presentation was provided by Rebecca Benner, Ph.D., of the American Society of Anesthesiologists, for the second session of NISO's 2024 Training Series "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape." Session Two: 'Expanding Pathways to Publishing Careers,' was held June 13, 2024.
2. policing in terms of a comprehensive set of principles that has implications
for a department’s philosophy, strategies, and tactics. Essentially, community
policing represents a merger of community-oriented policing and problem-
oriented policing. Community-oriented policing evolved as a result of Mich-
igan State University’s work with foot patrols in Flint, Michigan. It involved
the police focusing more on fear of crime and better relations with the public
rather than on crime itself.It was believed thatfear was more debilitatingthan
crime (Trojanowicz et al., 2002), and community partnerships are necessary
for the police to be effective in combating crime and building public trust.
Problem-oriented policing evolved from the work of Herman Goldstein
(1979, 1990) and was first implemented by the Police Executive Research
Forum (PERF; see Eck & Spelman, 1987a). Problem-oriented policing
focused on going beyond merely responding to calls for service, which had
been the operant police strategy for decades. It entailed that the police iden-
tify and solve problems that caused disorder and crime at a micro level.
Goldstein proposed that the police begin to emphasize outcomes rather than
activities or bean counting. Over time, community-oriented policing and
problem-oriented policing merged into a coherent philosophy with two
essential elements: community partnerships and problem solving.
Problem solving is the key to community policing. Proponents of commu-
nity policing postulate that community partnerships are developed to (a)
assist the police in identifying problems affecting the community or neigh-
borhood and (b) form partnerships that provide a more effective and compre-
hensive response to problems that are identified. Problem solving, ulti-
mately, is an act where the police “take care of business.” They take actions,
solely or in concert with others via partnerships, to reduce or eliminate crime
and disorder or the conditions that contribute to them. These actions gener-
ally are geographically focused whereby the police concentrate on specific or
clusters of problems.
Problem solving was seen as the mantra for modern policing. Over a
decade ago, Eck and Spelman (1987b) described the attributes of a problem-
solving police department: (a) problem solving will be the standard method
of policing, not just an occasionally useful tactic; (b) problem-solving efforts
will focus on problems of the public, not on police administration; (c) when
problems are taken on, police will establish precise, measurable objectives;
and (d) police managers will constantly look for ways to get all members of
the department involved in solving problems (p. 24). Their description epito-
mizes police managers’ perceptions of how problem solving should be inte-
grated into the community-policing police department.
Today, numerous police departments are engaging in the strategy and tar-
geting a variety of problems (see Brito & Allan, 1999). For example, police
54 CRIME & DELINQUENCY / JANUARY 2005
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
3. officers in Chicago (Skogan, 1998) and Philadelphia (Piquero, Greene, Fyfe,
Kane, & Collins, 1998) used a problem-solving approach to attack crime in
public housing. The Kansas City Police used problem solving to reduce vio-
lence by removing guns from the streets (Shaw, 1998).
Each year, PERF holds a problem-solving conference (POP Conference
in San Diego) to explore different problem-solving efforts and outcomes.
PERF, in concert with the Office of Community Oriented Policing Services
(COPS Office), gives the Herman Goldstein award to departments with the
most innovative and effective problem-solving strategies (for examples of
notable projects, see Police Executive Research Forum, 2000a; 2001; Brito
& Allan, 1999). The Home Office replicates this practice of recognizing
police-initiated problem solving in a similar award system in the United
Kingdom. Such national accolades havehelped to facilitateproblem solving.
LIMITATIONS OF POLICE EFFORTS TO
RESOLVE COMMUNITY CRIME PROBLEMS
Concerns have been expressed as to whether problem solving can be
applied to the level of effectiveness as advocated by its proponents. Critics
note that it is not a panacea, and at best it may have only limited applications.
Critics have identified a number of problems and issues. Rosenbaum,
Lurigio, and Davis (1998) identified four philosophical limitations: (a) the
tendency to identify and solve simple problems and an aversion to more com-
plex, difficult problems; (b) a tendency to remove offenders from an area
without regard to possible displacement effects; (c) a tendency to rely on
directed patrol as the solution; and (d) an insensitivity toward the community
during various stages of the problem-solving initiative. Buerger (1999)
examined problem solving in Minneapolis, where a number of crime and dis-
order problems were identified. However, at the operational level, he found
that police officers were resistant to the strategy; potential partners tended to
shirk their responsibilities by blaming other organizations or by insinuating
that the responsibility for involvement in solving the problem rested
elsewhere. Buerger also found resistance from citizens, especially when a
problem-solving strategy resulted in inconvenience or additional expenses.
The Minneapolis experience demonstrates that the theory and application of
problem solving at the street level may be very difficult.
Reviews of problem-solving projects suggest that illegal drugs and seri-
ous crime were targeted ahead of disorder and public safety (Dejong,
Mastrofski, & Parks, 2001; Rojek, 2001). These problems were typically
Bichler, Gaines / POLICE OFFICERS’ INSIGHTS 55
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
4. addressed via traditional law enforcement methods, increased visibility, and
code enforcement for privately owned property.
Describing the problem-solving activities engaged in by the specialized
units of the Indianapolis Police Department, Dejong et al. (2001) noted that
the critical flaw in applications of problem solving has been the weakness of
the analysis phase where there has generally been a lack of information about
the problem (Police Executive Research Forum, 2000b; Eck, 2004). Analysis
involves the synthesis and interpretation of detailed information about
offenders, targets, and locations to identify the nature and dimensions of a
particular problem. An evaluation of the Problem Solving Partnerships (PSP)
program that was sponsored by the COPS Office found that police have diffi-
culty in “clearly defining problems, properly using data sources, conducting
comprehensive analysis, and implementing analysis-driven responses”
(Police Executive Research Forum, 2000b, p. 7). The COPS Office recently
began to address this problem (Scott, 2001a) by funding a research initiative
to develop information on a variety of common crime problems such as
assaults around bars (Scott, 2001b) and drug dealing in apartment complexes
(Sampson, 2001) and by funding guidebooks addressing analysis (Bynum,
2001; Officeof Community Oriented Policing Services, 1998). Furthermore,
Weisel (2003) developed a series of recommendations outlining the sug-
gested analytic sequence and breadth of information required for effective
analysis.
THE NATURE OF PROBLEM SOLVING
The problem-solving process has been implemented via the acronym
SARA, which entails four steps: (a) scanning the environment for problems;
(b) analysis of identified problems; (c) response to the problem; and (d)
assessment of outcomes as a result of the response. Although all four steps
are critical to the efficacy of problem solving, the scanning step serves as the
so-called gatekeeper for the process. That is, if the police are to be effective in
problem solving, they must be proficient in identifying those problems that
have substantial impact on crime, disorder, and the community. Research
tends to indicate that officers are more proficient at problem identification
than at developing and implementing strategies to correct the problem
(McElroy, Cosgrove, & Sadd, 1993).
Before proceeding, it is important to define police problems. Drawing on
the works of Goldstein (1990) and Eck and Spelman (1987b), police prob-
lems can be defined as
56 CRIME & DELINQUENCY / JANUARY 2005
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
5. • a cluster of similar, related, or recurring incidents;
• a substantive community concern;
• a unit of police business;
• a type of behavior, a place, a person or persons, a special event, or combination
of any of these; or
• twoormore incidents, similar in nature, that concern the police and the public.
Recently, Eck (2003) refined the notion of problem by suggesting that po-
lice problems are groups of related incidents connected in some meaningful
manner in that they are produced by the same underlying cause. Furthermore,
the incidents are of concern to the public.
A variety of techniques are used to identify police problems. The primary
techniques used include observation and experience, crime analysis, police
reports, calls for service analysis, crime mapping, community groups, and
surveys (Webster & Connor, 1993). When engaging in problem solving,
departments sometimes use multiple techniques. For example, a crime analy-
sis unit may map crime and calls for service to determine the overlap and
where hot spots exist. This information may then be supplemented with citi-
zen surveys or officer input relative to the hot spots. With the exception of
observation and experience, all of these techniques are normally centralized
or staff functions (Reaves & Goldberg, 1999). However, Eck (2004) suggests
that few agencies go beyond a “shallow exploration of problems,” with most
problem-solving initiatives involving only a rudimentary analysis of police
data coupled with officers’ experience (p. 189). He notes that this limited
analysis leads to the development of a narrow range of responses and to diffi-
culties in problem solving. One factor contributing to mediocre problem
solving is that little is known about problem identification or the analysis
process.
There is a scarcity of research examining the problem identification pro-
cess. It seems that it is such an obvious, workable process that few research-
ers have examined it thoroughly to gauge its effectiveness. When a depart-
ment engages in problem identification, is it able to accurately identify those
problems that are in the greatest need of being addressed? This research is
concerned with the problem identification process specifically as practiced
through officer observation and experience (see Webster & Connor, 1993).
Conventional wisdom tells us that because patrol officers work specific geo-
graphical areas (beats) on a fairly constant basis, they come to see where the
problems exist. In some cases, they may attempt to alleviate the problem,
and, in other cases, where the problem is substantial or beyond their individ-
ual capabilities, they may request assistance from a specialized unit within
the department, an outside agency, or a citizen group. The key, however, is
how effective officers are in identifying problems in their areas.
Bichler, Gaines / POLICE OFFICERS’ INSIGHTS 57
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
6. Two prior studies addressed this issue. Rengert (1995) examined officers’
perceptions of problems in Philadelphia. He had police recruits rank the per-
ceived safety of 16 areas in the city. He then compared the rankings to actual
violent crime and found substantial inconsistency in the recruits’ ability to
identify safe places. In another study, Ratcliffe and McCullagh (2001) had
officers identify the burglary and auto larceny problem locations in a city.
Their locations were then compared to a crime map with hot spots identified
by a statistical procedure using official police data. They found substantial
inconsistency between the officers’perceptions and the actual crimes. Thus,
it appears that there are some difficulties in using officer input in problem
identification.
The current research also examines the consistency of officer problem
identification. The majority of literature on problem solving focuses on how
it is generally applied using anecdotal data, and problem identification is
often globally addressed. Here, police officers’ effectiveness in identifying
problems is examined. The research uses focus groups consisting of police
officers to identify problems. Of interest are the kinds of problems identified
and officers’problem-solving responses. Three related questions are explored.
First, when a department engages in problem identification, are officers able
to identify specific problems, locations, and contributing factors? Second, is
there some level of consensus among members of the police workgroup?
Finally, following a comprehensive community-oriented policing training
course, do officers still rely upon traditional law enforcement tactics, or do
they suggest strategies learned in the training course?
METHOD
The research conducted here explored police officers’ ability to identify
problems in their community. A focus group methodology was used to gather
the data (Greenbaum, 1993). All 200 officers from a medium-sized, southern
police department were divided into groups of five to nine officers and were
asked to list the problems occurring in their respective patrol areas. In addi-
tion, they were asked as a group to identify, in a freewheeling fashion, what
strategies or tactics could be realistically used to respond to the problems.
Strategies and tactics were listed, and there was no limit to the number that
could be recommended. Officers were not asked to prioritize the strategies
and tactics.
Ultimately, the results from the various groups were compared to deter-
mine consistency. The unit of analysis was the problem sites identified. It was
hypothesized that if officer observation and experience is an effective means
58 CRIME & DELINQUENCY / JANUARY 2005
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
7. of identifying problems, then there should be a high level of consistency
across the problems identified by officers working in the same district. The
identification of tactics and the discussion shed light on how police officers
thought about responding to problems, and it resulted in a discovery of the
boundariesthatlimitpoliceresponses.Significantcorrelationswereidentified.
Departmental Information
This research was conducted in a medium-sized, southern police depart-
ment. The police department serves a geographical area of approximately 57
square miles with a population of 78,000. It has a predominately blue-collar
economy with a substantial service industry and some light industry. The city
is located in a rural area and serves as a center for the region in terms of shop-
ping, medical services, and transportation. Most of the surrounding area is
engaged in agricultural activities. The city has a relatively low percentage of
upper- and middle-class households. There has been substantial “white
flight” over the past several decades with Caucasians moving out of the city
and into the county and surrounding cities. The population is split almost
evenly between White and Black.
The police department has approximately 200 officers. The department is
geographically divided into four districts with a total of 15 patrol beats. A
lieutenant is assigned to each district to manage the department’s community
policing efforts. The lieutenant is tasked with working with officers and
detectives in developing and implementing proactive policing programs at
the neighborhood level. The city averages about 9,000 FBI index crimes per
year, with about 850 violent crimes. Several years prior to the study, the city
led the state in the rate of homicides. The department has over 1,000 drug
cases each year, and it answers about 108,000 calls for service per year, based
on its latest annual report. Given the fact that there are only 200 sworn offi-
cers and over 100,000 calls for service each year, it becomes obvious that
patrol officers answer a large volume of calls per shift. The impact of this
demanding workload on department resources is compounded by the fact
that the department requires a report on almost all calls for service.
Data Collection
The data for this study were collected in conjunction with a community
policing training program attended by all the officers in the department from
the rank of lieutenant and below. The training program lasted 40 hours and
presented a detailed overview of community policing with a special empha-
sis on community partnerships and problem solving. The problem-solving
Bichler, Gaines / POLICE OFFICERS’ INSIGHTS 59
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
8. training component included such information as how to identify problems
and hot spots, how to analyze a problem once it is identified, and how to
implement some strategies that can be taken to deal with problems. The final
exercise of the problem-solving segment involved asking officers to identify
problem locations that generated a substantial amount of crime and disorder
within each community-policing district. Once problems were identified,
officers were queried about problem-solving strategies.
During each training session, participants were divided into focus groups
of approximately five to eight officers (20 focus groups) consistent with their
assigned community-policing district. All officers working the same district
were assigned to the same focus group. Detectives and traffic officers were
distributed across focus groups based on their assignment or knowledge of
the districts. Detectives and traffic officers generally worked across the four
districts but often had a larger number of assignments in a single district.
Thus, their assignment to a district focus group was based on their stating that
they had more familiarity with the district. The researchers attempted to
ensure that members of the district focus groups were knowledgeable of the
activities in the district areas. In the end, there were five different focus
groups examining the problems uniquely in each of the four districts.
Officers were not assigned to the five different training sessions randomly.
Assignment, to some degree, was based on days off, court responsibilities,
and other police activities that could not be neglected or postponed. It was
believed that assignment to a particular training session had no bearing on the
outcomes because focus groups were the primary methodology being used.
Each group worked together to develop a list of the problems in their dis-
trict. Officers identified the nature and dimensions of the problem, character-
ized suspects, and suggested facilitating conditions. The groups were not
given a time limitnor were they provided any statisticalinformation. Officers
were allowed to brainstorm until they were satisfied that all the problems had
been identified. To include a problem on the list, group members were polled
to ensure that there was a consensus among the group as to whether the loca-
tion was uniformly perceived as a problem. If there was disagreement, the
location was discussed until a consensus was reached. Most groups com-
pleted the exercise in an hour. Once lists were completed, departmental plan-
ning staff made adjustments to ensure consistent geo-referencing. For exam-
ple, groups may have identified the same problem and location, but one may
have referred to the site by place name, such as the Lyons Apartment block,
whereas another group may have identified the same problem by street
address.
After the problem identification process was completed, officers were
given additional forms to list the means that the department could use most
60 CRIME & DELINQUENCY / JANUARY 2005
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
9. effectively in dealing with the problem. The officers were asked to identify
specific tactics and possible partners in the community who might assist in
solving the problem. Officers were not asked to rank the strategies. It was
hypothesized that ranking would lead to the elimination of some ideas, and a
comprehensive list of strategies would reveal more about the officers’ per-
ceptions of how to solve problems than would a truncated list through rank
ordering. It should be noted that the inclusion of problem identification
within a training program, the influence of focus group dynamics, and the
current climate of the agency introduce possible limitations to the quality and
breadth of strategies suggested. These possible limitations are discussed in a
following section.
Analysis
Once the data were collected, they were classified into a taxonomy based
on the types of problems, the number of problems at a particular location, and
the types of strategies and tactics recommended by the officers.
First, this research examines the reliability of problem identification
across groups of officers who are assigned to the same geographical work
area (district). The efficacy of officer problem identification is investigated
here. Second, locational type is examined. Here, the problems are divided
into residential (single family or multifamily) and business problems. Third,
problem dimensions are examined. Problem dimension refers to the types
and number of crimes or to the disorder problems that exist at a particular
location. Fourth, the types of offenders identified by officers are discussed
(juveniles, adults, residents, outsiders, customers, or no suspect informa-
tion). Finally, the problem-solving strategies identified by the officers are
discussed in terms of the types of strategies and their relationship to the
problems at hand.
FINDINGS
As stated earlier, three general research questions guide this study. First,
when a department engages in problem identification, are officers able to
identify specific problems, locations, and likely offenders? Second, is there
consensus among members of the police workgroup regarding these high-
crime locations? Finally, following a comprehensive community-oriented
policing training course, do officers still rely on traditional law enforcement
tactics, or do they suggest strategies learned in the training course? Analyses
were performed to explore, generally and within policing districts, the con-
Bichler, Gaines / POLICE OFFICERS’ INSIGHTS 61
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
10. sistency of problem identification, precision of site identification, types of
locations, natures of crime problems, likely suspects, and problem-solving
approaches with contingency tables.
Consistency of Problem Identification
In total, the officers identified 88 different problem locations across the
four different policing districts. Each set of district focus groups (five groups
per district) averaged about 22 problem locations in their district. Table 1 pro-
vides a breakdown of the consistency of problem identification by the four
sets of focus groups. There was only 1 location where all five focus groups
within a district identified it as a problem (District 4). There was 1 location
identified by four focus groups, 5 locations identified by three focus groups,
and 15 locations identified by two focus groups. Many locations, 66, were
identified as problems by only one of the focus groups within the five groups
examining the problems for each district. These results indicate that there is a
reliability problem when using officers to identify problem locations. Per-
haps, officers have different worldviews and biases that affect how they
distinguish problems.
Table 1 illustrates that within policing districts, the highest level of consis-
tency was among focus groups for Districts3 and 4. As a group, officers iden-
tified more sites facing a variety of crime problems; about 65% of locations
had multiple dimensions (i.e., theft from motor vehicles, domestic violence,
and drug dealing)1
or involved related crimes (i.e., assaults, underage alcohol
consumption, and loud music). However, a large number of the identified
sites faced a single-crime problem (35.2%).
There was a weak relationship between consistency in problem identifica-
tion among focus groups and the number of dimensions for a problem (Φ =
.211, p < .05), suggesting that problems identified by more than one focus
group were more likely to be classed as community problems with multiple
dimensions. That is, sites with complex problems were more likely to be
known to officers in each group. About 72.7% of sites with multiple prob-
lems were identified by more than one focus group as compared to 48.5% of
the complex problems identified by a single focus group. About 52% of the
sites with one problem were mentioned by one of the focus groups, whereas
27.3% of simple problems were acknowledged by more than one focus
group. In sum, officers were more likely to identify the same site when that
troublesome location supported a concentration of a variety of crimes. How-
ever, the general trend was for each group to identify different high-crime
locations.
62 CRIME & DELINQUENCY / JANUARY 2005
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
11. 63
TABLE 1: Consistency of Problem Identification Among Focus Groups by District
District 1 District 2 District 3 District 4
Consistency Count Percentagea
Count Percentage Count Percentage Count Percentage
Unique problems 21 91.3 17 85.0 13 65.0 15 60.0
Two focus groups 2 8.7 2 10.0 3 15.0 8 32.0
Three focus groups — — — — 4 20.0 1 4.0
Four focus groups — — 1 5.0 — — — —
All five identified — — — — — — 1 4.0
Total 23 100.0 20 100.0 20 100.0 25 100.0
a. Valid percentage used.
at
California
State
Univ
San
Bernardino
on
February
19,
2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded
from
12. Precision of Site Identification
Officers were very specific about the locations of community crime prob-
lems. About 39% of problems were given a precise address or location, and
an additional 40% were tied to specific areas such as apartment complexes.
The remaining locations were blocks (21.6%).
The correlation between location precision and dimensions of the crime
problem cited was strong (Φ = .401) and highly significant (p < .001). Prob-
lems thought to involve multiple dimensions (i.e., automobile theft, public
drinking, and domestic violence) were more likely to be tied to areas
(70.4%), whereas sites (problem addresses) were more inclined to suffer
from a single crime type (70.6%). This spatial diffusion may be the result of
officers merging several problems into one general location, or it may be that
locations with multiple dimensions tend to expand over a larger area.
Type of Locations
Residential crime problems were most prevalent (56.8%). Although most
residential locations were classified as houses, a substantial proportion of
residentially based crime problems, 34%, involved apartment complexes.
The rest of the locations were commercial, with roughly one third involving
specific business premises operating day hours only and 8% late-night busi-
nesses such as nightclubs (5.7%).
Prior research suggests that crimes occurring or affecting residential areas
would be more clearly recalled by officers; thus, officers should consistently
identify residential crime problems. In this study, no support was found for
this hypothesis; officers were not significantly more consistent with identify-
ing problems at different types of locations. Approximately 25% of residen-
tial and business crime problems were identified by more than one focus
group.
Even though the type of location did not affect the groups’consistency in
identifying problems, there appears to be a relationship between the com-
plexity of crime problem and the type of location. Complex problems, those
locations thought to have multiple dimensions, were more likely to involve
residential areas (74%), whereas other properties, such as business premises
located in commercial areas, were associated with single-crime problems
(71.1%). This relationship was strong (Φ = .448) and highly significant (p <
.001).
64 CRIME & DELINQUENCY / JANUARY 2005
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
13. Nature of Problems
By far, the most prevalent type of problem identified by officers was disor-
der (52.3%). Disorder included public drug and alcohol consumption and/or
intoxication, loud noise, partying, and loitering associated with gang activity.
The majority of disorder problems (63.0%) involved alcohol or drug con-
sumption. Violent index crimes were limited to assaults (fighting and domes-
tic violence) and composed about 24% of the crime problems, whereas index
property offenses (theft from motor vehicles, theft, and burglary) accounted
for 34% of the crimes.2
Because many locations faced complex-crime and public-safety issues
(crime problems with multiple dimensions), additional analyses were per-
formed on the nature of issues identified. Issues were reclassified based on
predominant crime type. Although this classification changes the distribu-
tion of problems, disorder and index property crime remain the most fre-
quent, followed by index property crime and drug sales (see Table 2).
Likely Suspects
During the problem identification exercise, many focus groups naturally
incorporated conclusions about the most likely perpetrators. Their analysis is
interesting in light of the problem-solving approaches suggested. Although
officers were clearly capable of identifying geographically precise crime
problems, they were less able to classify suspects (see Table 3). Juveniles
were identified as suspects or perpetrators more frequently than were adults.
This finding likely is the result of juveniles who typically were involved in
more obtrusive crime and disorder activities relative to adults.
Problem-Solving Approaches
Conversations with officers confirm that they experience a high degree of
“committed patrol time,” making it difficult to engage in community polic-
ing. Officers feel that this substantially limits their ability to engage in com-
munity policing and problem solving. This inability to engage in proactive
crime prevention is reflected in the solutions suggested by officers to address
crime problems. Table 4 provides an example of the problems and solutions
identified; it is a partial list of some of the issues identified in one district.3
Officers believed that almost half of the crime problems were resolvable
by crime prevention strategies (47.7%). Their suggestions for crime preven-
Bichler, Gaines / POLICE OFFICERS’ INSIGHTS 65
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
14. tion were classified as conventional crime prevention (i.e., education cam-
paigns or neighborhood watch schemes) or novel techniques (i.e., changing
management policies, forming partnerships with local community groups to
offer alternative juvenile activities, or using civil injunctions). In the cases
where crime prevention was recommended, about 70% of the recommenda-
tions were conventional crime prevention strategies, and about 30% of the
recommendations were for novel crime prevention techniques. The
following are some of the suggestions offered by officers:
• Conventional crime prevention strategies together with environmental design
modifications were suggested to addresstheft from commercial establishments.
• Officers suggested that changes in management policy could resolve gasoline
drive-offs. A number of gas stations owned by the same individuals did not
require customers to pay prior to pumping the gas. In all situations, officers sug-
gested changing the policy to require prepayment.
• Generally, drug sales and related disorder were not deemed resolvable by pre-
vention techniques. Officers typically suggested increased enforcement
through tactics such as buy and bust operations. The only exception involved sit-
66 CRIME & DELINQUENCY / JANUARY 2005
TABLE 2: Distribution of Primary Crime and Public Safety Problems
Primary Crime and Public Safety Problem Count Percentagea
Disorder 26 29.5
Disputes 9 10.2
Drug sales 18 20.5
False alarms 4 4.5
Fear 3 3.4
Index property crime 22 25.0
Traffic 6 6.8
Total 88 100.0
a. Valid percentage used.
TABLE 3: Suspect Type Identified by Officers
Suspects Count Percentage
Juveniles 32 36.0
Adults 8 9.0
Residents (no age specified) 5 5.7
Outsiders (no age specified) 2 2.3
Customers (no age specified) 14 15.9
No suspect characteristics identified 32 36.4
Total 93 105.3
a
a.Percentage does not sum to 100 because more than one class of suspect was identi-
fied for some problems.
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
15. 67
TABLE 4: Sample of Suggested Solutions Identified by Focus Groups by Geographic Area, District 1
a
Geographic
Area Land Use Description of the Problem Solution: Crime Prevention Solution: Enforcement
Block Residential Gang activity; intimidation of residents; rise
in burglaries
Target hardening Increase patrols
Residential Juveniles drinking on private property,
loitering, and drag racing
Increase surveillance Increase patrols
Residential Domestic violence; fights; disorderly
conduct; drug sales; public intoxication;
theft
No crime prevention suggested Increased patrols
Residential Loud music from automobiles No crime prevention suggested Increase patrols and enforcement
Specific Residential Residential burglaries day and nighttime Target hardening No change
area Mall Shoplifting Owner crime prevention Increase patrols
Apartments Loud music; theft from automobiles;
domestic violence
Increase surveillance Increase patrols
Apartments Loud music; theft from automobiles;
domestic violence; gangs
Increase surveillance Increase patrols
Park disorder; underage drinking (wealthy teens) No crime prevention suggested Increase patrols
Apartments Large amounts of drugs; disorder; fights Increase surveillance No change
Site Night club Juveniles drinking and trashing the parking
lot
Hold third party liable Increase patrols and enforcement
Business Gas station drive-offs Change management policy No change
Business False alarms (banks) No crime prevention suggested No change
Residential Disputes; drugs; disorder Code enforcement No change
a. Please note that actual addresses and other identifiers have been removed.
at
California
State
Univ
San
Bernardino
on
February
19,
2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded
from
16. uations where drug sales and loitering spilled over onto private commercial
property. Here, officers suggested holding the owner responsible for enforce-
ment of loitering and littering laws.
Few problem-solving suggestions involved partnerships with other agen-
cies, organizations, or government offices. Only 16% of suggested solutions
involved partnerships. Instead of creative problem resolution, traditional po-
licing responses dominated the suggested strategies to reduce crime. Officers
believed that 21.5% of issues could be dealt with by increased enforcement
(i.e., writing more citations), about 20% required more patrol, and an addi-
tional 22.7% required a combination of increased enforcement and patrol. In
total, officers believed that about 65% of issues were best resolved with
traditional policing.
Correlations between traditional policing and the precision of the crime
location identified revealed that blocks and specific areas were more likely to
generate increased police presence to address the crime problem (90% and
83%, respectively). No changes in the level of enforcement were recom-
mended for problems at specific addresses (59%). Although this relationship
is moderate (Λ = .382) and highly significant, one cell had fewer than five
cases. In other words, officers are more likely to favor increased law enforce-
ment when the problem is located in a larger area as opposed to a specific
address.
Another notable relationship involved traditional policing responses and
the number of dimensions identified for the crime problem. Increased police
presence was suggested as a way to deal with the crime problem when the
issue was multidimensional or when it involved related crimes (83% and
63%, respectively). Traditional policing means were suggested for 48% of
single-dimension crime problems. This relationship was weak (Λ = .203 and
p < .01). It seems that the police tend to fall back to more stringent enforce-
ment when facing complicated, multicrime problems.
DISCUSSION
This exploratory research examined police officers’ ability to identify
problems, one of the fundamental steps used in the problem identification
process. It revealed a number of important patterns regarding police officers’
insights into problem identification. Although there was little consistency
between focus groups of officers working the same district, officers were
more likely to identify specific addresses and sites. Problems of concern
tended to involve issues of disorder that were complex or multidimensional.
The most prevalent response to these complex issues was increased use of
68 CRIME & DELINQUENCY / JANUARY 2005
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
17. conventional law enforcement strategies such as enforcement and patrol. The
implications of these findings are discussed below.
Consistency
Focus groups did not demonstrate consistency within each district in
terms of problems identified. In other words, a substantial number of sites
were uniquely identified as being problematic. This low level of reliability
across the groups was surprising. It was hypothesized that because officers
work in specific districts on a regular basis, there would be more consistency
in their identification of problems. This finding has an important implication
for agencies with dedicated problem- or community-oriented policing units.
Clearly, querying a small group of officers from each district or beat is not
sufficient to develop a comprehensive list of problematic locations or hot
spots. A dedicated unit may not have sufficient knowledge of crime issues to
accurately identify key or critical community crime problems. Polling the
entire force through a survey instrument or series of focus groups would pro-
vide a better assessment of crime issues facing the department. For example,
a single focus group identified a couple of gas stations with inappropriate
management policies that are contributing to high rates of drive-offs; yet sur-
veying the entire force revealed that this problem occurred at several
locations throughout the city.
In situations wherein a complete survey is not possible, agencies will need
to tap into other information sources to identify crime problems. This is con-
sistent with Ratcliffe and McCullagh’s (2001) findings where officer percep-
tions of problems were not completely accurate when assessed against com-
puter maps of official police crime data. This is not to say that computer
mapping is a perfect strategy because it also has limitations (Buerger, Cohn,
& Petrosino, 2000). Webster and Connor (1993) identified a number of
strategies for identifying problems, and perhaps, the most effective or accu-
rate method of identifying problems may be the cross-validation of several
of these methods. Future research should investigate the utility of cross-
validation methods for identifying critical problems.
Precision
Officers exhibited a high level of precision regarding the location of crime
problems. This research also revealed a tendency to identify complex, multi-
dimensional crime problems in residential areas and simpler crime problems
facing commercial premises. The problems identified by officers in this
study were dominated by the interaction between drugs and disorder. Few
Bichler, Gaines / POLICE OFFICERS’ INSIGHTS 69
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
18. index crime-related problems were identified, and those that were identified
basically were property offenses that occurred with some frequency. This
was surprising considering the jurisdiction experienced a high level of Part I
crime.
These findings suggest that officers are not simply identifying locations
that generate a large volume of calls; rather, officers see high-crime locations
as those generating a large variety of call types. It seems that officers examine
crime problems more comprehensively than previously tested. This likely is
attributable to workplace bias. Officers come to see those addresses or loca-
tions as problems based on the volume of calls or police activities. That is,
their impressions of problems become myopic focusing on the general nature
of crime and disorder as generated by calls for service. Although there is a
relationship between crime and disorder (Kelling & Coles, 1996), this find-
ing implies that there should be some strategic planning or ordering when
implementing problem solving.
Prior research by Ratcliffe and McCullagh (2001) tested officer percep-
tions of hot spots against computer-generated geographic analysis for two
crimes: automobile theft and residential burglary. Given the current findings,
it is not surprising that Ratcliffe and McCullagh found that the officers in
their study identified problems somewhat differently than those that were
identified as the result of a statistical analysis. Police officers are likely to
identify sites with complex, interrelated crime problems. As such, future
research should compare officer perceptions to computer-assisted analyses
of related crimes (e.g., all disorder calls, narcotics activities, loitering,
assault, etc.).
Although crime specificity is critical to clearly identify and address crime
problems (Eck & Clark, 2001), the current research suggests that analysis
must include related crime categories. Future research should examine which
crime types are instinctively linked.
Problem Solving
The two tacticswith the highest number of mentions were enhanced patrol
or enforcement and citations. This is consistent with Rosenbaum et al.’s
(1998) analysis that the police tend to overrely on enforcement alternatives
when solving problems, and this is also consistent with how other depart-
ments have responded to problems (Capowich & Roehl, 1994). An examina-
tion of the tactics shows that the police tended to list the most those tactics
that have long been in the police arsenal: enforcement, citation, undercover
operations, and crime prevention. One exception was that environmental
design issues were identified in several of the problems. Here, officers sug-
70 CRIME & DELINQUENCY / JANUARY 2005
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
19. gested that owners improve lighting, remove posters from store windows,
and remove bushes from around windows or that the city demolish some
abandoned buildings.
It is also noteworthy that the officers’ suggestions conspicuously con-
tained few tactics that involved community partnerships, a cornerstone of
community policing. When pressed about the absence, officers uniformly
responded that in many cases, partnerships were not viable. Officers pro-
vided a number of examples where they had requested assistance from other
governmental agencies to deal with problems and the other agencies were
generally uncooperative. For example, officers had asked the local fire mar-
shal to inspect overcrowded nightclubs that had high levels of fights and drug
use, but the fire marshal refused. In another case, the department requested
that the city pass a burglary alarm ordinance, but the City Commission had
refused to do so. In another situation, the city had passed an ordinance requir-
ing the removal of junk cars from residential neighborhoods. The police
abandoned the program when citizens began to complain to commissioners
about its enforcement. Clearly, officers felt that the political atmosphere in
the city was not conducive to the development of partnerships with other
governmental departments.
The tendency of officers to use enhanced enforcement is consistent with
other research findings. This has a number of implications for community
policing. First, officers tend to operate from a so-called play card of tactics
that most likely are based on history and experience. Officers’ unfamiliarity
with other tactics may very likely inhibit their use by officers when solving
problems. Second, administrators must introduce new tactics into officers’
inventory of strategies. Officers must have seen new tactics in action if they
are expected to use them in the future. This can be done experimentally or
through demonstration cases. Third, here, and most likely in many other
departments, there was a paucity of community partnerships. Policeadminis-
trators must politically forge the way for these types of relationships to be
built. Police officers acting alone or even through the chain of command can-
not develop meaningful cooperative relationships with other agencies or citi-
zen groups without the active support of the agency leadership. The ground-
work must be laid by administration.
CONCLUSIONS
This article examined one recognized method of identifying police
problems—input from line police officers. Essentially, it was found that
although officers could identify precise crime situations, there is substantial
Bichler, Gaines / POLICE OFFICERS’ INSIGHTS 71
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
20. variation in the problem locations identified by officers, calling into question
whether officers’ identification of problems is a reliable method. Clearly,
querying a small group of officers from each district or beat is not sufficient
to develop a comprehensive list of problematic locations or hot spots. Polling
the entire force through a survey instrument or a series of focus groups would
provide a better assessment of crime issues facing the department; cross-
validation of locations by using several problem identification methods
would produce greater accuracy.
Realistically, police agencies have taken a simplistic approach to problem
solving to the point that it may be ineffectual or at least not reaching its full
potential. Departments have given officers problem-solving training, some-
times providing workbooks to facilitate the task (see McElroy et al., 1993),
and have charged officers with solving problems. This research indicates that
this is not an effective approach to implementing problem solving. The scan-
ning process alone is much more complicated, requiring a more in-depth
analysis. Furthermore, officers may suffer from workplace biases that cloud
their mental pictures of the nature and extent of problems. There likely needs
to be a more comprehensive examination of problems so that more appropriate
solutions can be discovered.
Problem solving can be an effective, rational method for the police to
approach the law enforcement mission. However, at this juncture, it appears
that it has not reached its potential (Read & Tilley, 2000). There are a number
of problems with all phases of the SARA model of problem solving. For the
most part, these problems have surfaced because police officials have taken a
simplistic view of it. A quarter century ago, Manning (1978) warned the
police against being content with “appearances.” This remains a problem
today with community policing. The police are too content with the vestiges
of having implemented community policing and must now focus on what
community policing can do for the community.
NOTES
1. Crime problems classed as having multiple dimensions were locations suffering a high
number of various types of crimes.
2. Due to the substantial proportion of crime locations suffering from multiple crimes, these
figures do not sum to 100.
3. Officers were allowed to recommend more than one solution for a given problem location,
and, frequently, they did so.
72 CRIME & DELINQUENCY / JANUARY 2005
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
21. REFERENCES
Brito, C. S., & Allan, T. (1999). Problem-oriented policing: Crime-specific problems, critical
issues,andmakingPOPwork(Vol.2).Washington,DC: PoliceExecutiveResearchForum.
Buerger, M. E. (1999).The problemof problemsolving.In L. Gaines & G. Cordner(Eds.),Polic-
ing perspectives: An anthology (pp. 150-169). Los Angeles: Roxbury.
Buerger, M. E., Cohn, E. G., & Petrosino, A. J. (2000). Defining hot spots of crime:
Operationalizing theoretical concepts for field research. In R. Glensor & K. Peak (Eds.),
Policing communities: Understanding crime and solving problems (pp. 138-150). Los
Angeles: Roxbury.
Bynum, T. (2001). Using analysis for problem solving: A guidebook for law enforcement. Wash-
ington, DC: Department of Justice, Office of Community Oriented Policing Services.
Capowich, G. E., & Roehl, J. A. (1994). Problem-orientedpolicing: Actions and effectiveness in
San Diego. In D. Rosenbaum (Ed.), The challenge of community policing (pp. 127-146).
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Cordner, G. (1999).Elementsofcommunitypolicing.InL. Gaines & G. Cordner(Eds.),Policing
perspectives: An anthology (pp. 137-149). Los Angeles: Roxbury.
Dejong, C., Mastrofski, S. D., & Parks, R. B. (2001). Patrol officers and problem solving: An
application of expectancy theory. Justice Quarterly, 18(1), 31-61.
Eck, J. (2003). Police problems: The complexity of problem theory, research, and evaluation. In
J. Knutsson (Ed.), Problem-oriented policing from innovation to mainstream (pp. 79-113).
Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press.
Eck, J. (2004). Why don’t problems get solved? In W. Skogan (Ed.), Community policing (can it
work)? (pp. 185-206). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
Eck,J., & Clarke, R. V. (2001,November).Classificationof problemsfor police. Paperpresented
at the 53rd annual meeting of the American Society of Criminology, Atlanta, GA.
Eck, J., & Spelman, W. (1987a, January/February).Newport News tests problem-orientedpolic-
ing. NIJ Reports, pp. 2-8.
Eck, J., & Spelman, W. (1987b). Problem solving: Problem-oriented policing in Newport News.
Washington, DC: Police Executive Research Forum.
Goldstein, H. (1979). Improving policing: A problem-orientedapproach. Crime & Delinquency,
25, 236-258.
Goldstein, H. (1990). Problem-oriented policing. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Greenbaum,T.L.(1993).Thehandbookforfocusgroupresearch.NewYork:LexingtonBooks.
Hickman, M., & Reeves, B. A. (2003). Local police departments, 2000. Washington, DC:
Bureau of Justice Statistics.
Kelling, G. L., & Coles, C. M. (1996). Fixing broken windows: Restoring order and reducing
crime in communities. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Manning, P. K. (1978). The police: In search of direction. In L. Gaines & T. Rick (Eds.), Manag-
ing the police organization (pp. 50-72). St. Paul, MN: West.
McElroy, J. E., Cosgrove, C. A., & Sadd, S. (1993). Community policing: The CPOP in New
York. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
Office of Community Oriented Policing Services. (1998). Problem solving tips: A guide to
reducing crime and disorder through problem solving partnerships. Washington, DC: U.S.
Department of Justice.
Bichler, Gaines / POLICE OFFICERS’ INSIGHTS 73
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from
22. Piquero, A., Greene, J., Fyfe, J., Kane, R. J., & Collins, P. (1998). Implementing community
policing in public housing developments in Philadelphia. In G. Alpert & A. Piquero (Eds.),
Communitypolicing:Contemporaryreadings(pp.95-122).ProspectHeights,IL:Waveland.
Police Executive Research Forum. (2000a). Excellence in problem-oriented policing: The 2000
Herman Goldstein Award winners. Washington, DC: Department of Justice, Office of Com-
munity Oriented Policing Services.
Police Executive Research Forum.(2000b).Nationalevaluationof the Problem SolvingPartner-
shipsProject. Washington,DC: DepartmentofJustice, Office ofCommunityOrientedPolic-
ing Services.
Police Executive Research Forum. (2001). Excellence in problem-oriented policing: The 2001
Herman Goldstein Award winners. Washington, DC: Department of Justice, Office of Com-
munity Oriented Policing Services.
Ratcliffe, J. H., & McCullagh, M. J. (2001). Chasing ghosts? Police perceptions of high crime
areas. British Journal of Criminology, 41, 330-341.
Read,T.,&Tilley,N.(2000).Notrocketscience?Problem-solvingandcrime reduction.London:
Home Office.
Reaves, B. A., & Goldberg, A. L. (1999). Law enforcement management and administrative sta-
tistics. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
Rengert, G. (1995). Comparing cognitive hot spots to crime hot spots. In C. Block, M. Dabdoub,
& S. Fregly (Eds.),Crime analysis throughcomputer mapping(pp.33-48).Washington,DC:
Police Executive Research Forum.
Rojek, J. (2001, April). A decade of excellence in problem-oriented policing: Characteristics of
GoldsteinAwardwinners.Paperpresentedat themeetingoftheAcademyofCriminalJustice
Sciences, Washington, DC.
Rosenbaum,D. P., Lurigio,A. J., & Davis, R. C. (1998).The preventionof crime: Socialandsitu-
ational strategies. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
Sampson, R. (2001). Drug dealing in privately owned apartment complexes (Problem-oriented
guides for police series No. 4). Washington, DC: Department of Justice, Office of Commu-
nity Oriented Policing Services.
Scott, M. (2001a, November). Problem-oriented guides for police. Paper presented at the 53rd
annual meeting of the American Society of Criminology, Atlanta, GA.
Scott,M. (2001b).Assaults in andaroundbars (Problem-orientedguidesforpoliceseries No.1).
Washington,DC: DepartmentofJustice,OfficeofCommunityOrientedPolicingServices.
Shaw, J. W. (1998). Community policing against guns: Public opinion of the Kansas City gun
experiment. In G. Alpert & A. Piquero (Eds.), Community policing: Contemporary readings
(pp. 377-412). Prospect Heights, IL: Waveland.
Skogan, W. (1998). Community policing in Chicago. In G. Alpert & A. Piquero (Eds.), Commu-
nity policing: Contemporary readings (pp. 159-174). Prospect Heights, IL: Waveland.
Trojanowicz, R., Kappeler, V., & Gaines, L. (2002). Community policing: A contemporary per-
spective. Cincinnati, OH: Anderson.
Webster, B., & Connor, E. F. (1993).Police methodsforidentifyingcommunityproblems.Amer-
ican Journal of Police, 12(1), 75-102.
Weisel, D. L. (2003). The sequence of analysis in solving problems. In J. Knutsson (Ed.), Crime
prevention studies (Vol. 15, pp. 115-146). Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press.
74 CRIME & DELINQUENCY / JANUARY 2005
at California State Univ San Bernardino on February 19, 2015
cad.sagepub.com
Downloaded from