The document discusses testing patterns for Akka applications, outlining best practices for utilizing TestKit and actor systems. It includes examples of asynchronous tests and actor behavior, emphasizing the need for effective dependency injection and supervision strategies. The speaker also addresses the evolution of testing methods in programming, referencing TDD and encouraging a focus on reliable and maintainable code.

1. Reactive Amsterdam meetup 12.07.2016
Mike Kotsur
@sotomajor_ua
Actor testing patterns
with TestKit

2. • Testing
• Testing Akka applications
• Better testing Akka applications
• Testing Akka applications with less problems
Agenda

3. TDD

4. A provocative talk and blog
posts has led to a conversation
where we aim to understand
each others' views and
experiences.
http://martinfowler.com/articles/is-tdd-dead/
Is TDD dead?
M. Fowler
K. Beck
David Heinemeier
Hansson

5. Programmers at work maintaining a Ruby on Rails testless application
Eero Järnefelt, Oil on canvas, 1893

6. A test

7. An async test

8. An async test

9. • Retry the assertion many times;
• The worker tells when the work is done.
2 conceptual solutions

10. • Retry the assertion many times;
• The worker tells when the work is done.
2 conceptual solutions
questions
How many times?
How long to wait?

11. • Not just actors and messages!
• Willing to help you with the test kit.
So, what about Akka?

18. object IncrementorActorMessages {
case class Inc(i: Int)
}
class IncrementorActor extends Actor {
var sum: Int = 0
override def receive: Receive = {
case Inc(i) => sum = sum + i
}
}
// TODO: test this

19. class IncrementorActorTest
extends TestKit(ActorSystem("test-system")) {
// it(“should …”) { … }
}
// We need an actor system

20. it("should have sum = 0 by default") {
val actorRef = TestActorRef[IncrementorActor]
actorRef.underlyingActor.sum shouldEqual 0
}
// Uses the same thread
Has a real type!

21. it("should increment on new messages1") {
val actorRef = TestActorRef[IncrementorActor]
actorRef ! Inc(2)
actorRef.underlyingActor.sum shouldEqual 2
actorRef.underlyingActor.receive(Inc(3))
actorRef.underlyingActor.sum shouldEqual 5
}
it("should increment on new messages2") {
val actorRef = TestActorRef[IncrementorActor]
actorRef ! Inc(2)
actorRef.underlyingActor.sum shouldEqual 2
actorRef.underlyingActor.receive(Inc(3))
actorRef.underlyingActor.sum shouldEqual 5
}
// “Sending” messages
Style 1
Style 2

22. class LazyIncrementorActor extends Actor {
var sum: Int = 0
override def receive: Receive = {
case Inc(i) =>
Future {
Thread.sleep(100)
sum = sum + i
}
}
}

27. object IncrementorActorMessages {
case class Inc(i: Int)
case object Result
}
class IncrementorActor extends Actor {
var sum: Int = 0
override def receive: Receive = {
case Inc(i) => sum = sum + i
case Result => sender() ! sum
}
}
New message

28. // ... with ImplicitSender
it("should have sum = 0 by default") {
val actorRef = system
.actorOf(Props(classOf[IncrementorActor]))
actorRef ! Result
expectMsg(0)
}
TestKit trait

29. it("should increment on new messages") {
val actorRef = system
.actorOf(Props(classOf[IncrementorActor]))
actorRef ! Inc(2)
actorRef ! Result
expectMsg(2)
actorRef ! Inc(3)
actorRef ! Result
expectMsg(5)
}

30. TestKit

31. def expectMsg[T](d: Duration, msg: T): T
def expectMsgPF[T](d: Duration)
(pf:PartialFunction[Any, T]): T
def expectMsgClass[T](d: Duration, c: Class[T]): T
def expectNoMsg(d: Duration) // blocks
// expectMsg*

32. def receiveN(n: Int, d: Duration): Seq[AnyRef]
def receiveWhile[T](max: Duration, idle: Duration, n: Int)
(pf: PartialFunction[Any, T]): Seq[T]
def fishForMessage(max: Duration, hint: String)
(pf: PartialFunction[Any, Boolean]): Any
// fishing*

33. def awaitCond(p: => Boolean, max: Duration, interval:
Duration)
def awaitAssert(a: => Any, max: Duration, interval: Duration)
// from ScalaTest
def eventually[T](fun: => T)
(implicit config: PatienceConfig): T
// await*

34. def ignoreMsg(pf: PartialFunction[AnyRef, Boolean])
def ignoreNoMsg()
// ignore*

35. val probe = TestProbe()
probe watch target
target ! PoisonPill
probe.expectTerminated(target)
// death watch
Somewhere in the app code

36. • context.actorOf()
• context.parent
• context.child(name)
Dependency injection

37. • Use props;
• Use childMaker: ActorRefFactory =>
ActorRef;
• Use a fabricated parent.
Dependency Injection

38. class MyActor extends Actor with ActorLogging {
override def receive: Receive = {
case DoSideEffect =>
log.info("Hello World!")
}
}
// event filter

39. // akka.loggers = ["akka.testkit.TestEventListener"]
EventFilter.info(
message = "Hello World!”, occurrences = 1
).intercept {
myActor ! DoSomething
}
// event filter

40. class MyActor extends Actor with ActorLogging {
override def supervisorStrategy: Unit =
OneForOneStrategy() {
case _: FatalException =>
SupervisorStrategy.Escalate
case _: ShitHappensException =>
SupervisorStrategy.Restart
}
}
// supervision

41. // unit-test style
val actorRef = TestActorRef[MyActor](MyActor.props())
val pf = actorRef.underlyingActor
.supervisorStrategy.decider
pf(new FatalException()) should be (Escalate)
pf(new ShitHappensException()) should be (Restart)
// supervision

42. // coding time

43. // better tests

44. flaky /ˈfleɪki/ adjective,
informal
(of a device or
software) prone to
break down; unreliable.

45. class MyActorTest
extends TestKit(ActorSystem("test-system"))
with FunSpecLike {
override protected def afterAll(): Unit = {
super.afterAll()
system.shutdown()
system.awaitTermination()
}
}
// shutting down the actor system

46. trait AkkaTestBase extends BeforeAndAfterAll
with FunSpecLike { this: TestKit with Suite =>
override protected def afterAll() {
super.afterAll()
system.shutdown()
system.awaitTermination()
}
}
// shutting down the actor system

47. akka.test.single-expect-default = 3 seconds
akka.test.timefactor = 10
// timeouts
import scala.concurrent.duration._
import akka.testkit._
10.milliseconds.dilated

48. class Settings(...) extends Extension {
object Jdbc {
val Driver = config.getString("app.jdbc.driver")
val Url = config.getString("app.jdbc.url")
}
}
// settings extension

49. // test
val config = ConfigFactory.parseString("""
app.jdbc.driver = "org.h2.Driver"
app.jdbc.url = "jdbc:h2:mem:repository"
""")
val system = ActorSystem("testsystem", config)
// app
class MyActor extends Actor {
val settings = Settings(context.system)
val connection = client.connect(
settings.Jdbc.Driver,
settings.Jdbc.Url
)
}
// settings extension

50. case class Identify(messageId: Any)
case class ActorIdentity(
correlationId: Any,
ref: Option[ActorRef]
)
// dynamic actors

51. // Beware of unique name lifecycles and scopes…

52. // Prefer checking messages over checking side-effects.

53. // Single responsibility principle.

54. // Run your tests on slow VM and different OS.

55. // Extract *all* timeouts into conf files. So that you can easily
override them
-Dakka.test.someImportantProperty=3000

56. // Don’t hesitate to rewrite a test, or the code.

57. // Don’t trust assertion errors, check logs.

58. // Base your decisions on historical data.

59. // QA?