ABCDs of Website Evaluation
Name of site:
What does the URL tell you? http://www.domainname.com/subject/folder/htm
E.g. http://www.aip.org/history/climate/pdf/20ctrend.pdf
Protocol: http://
Domain: www.aip.org (look up domain; watch for type of domain)
Directory: history
File: climate
Filetype: pdf
Title of file: 20ctrend.pdf
ABCDs Consider using this site if: Question this site if:
Analysis of URL of site:  You search for the domain and determine
it is for a valid reliable organization or
person. Use
http://www.gleanwhois.org/
 The type of domain is more reliable:
 .gov (government)
 .edu (college or university)
 .org (organization; check and determine if
the organization is reliable)
 .com (commercial; someone paid for this)
 .net (network)
 .k12 (school; may be a grade 5 student)
 About.com, yahoo, etc. (personal)
 Has a country code you are unfamiliar
with; not “.ca”
 Blog, wiki, or social media site that are
not edited
A
Authorship
Who created this site?
 Author is an expert in the field or subject
(do a search for the author and
organization)
 Organization is governmental or non-
profit and is a respected organization in
this field.
 No author is identified
 Author does not have relevant
qualifications
 Organization has commercial interest in
this subject
B
Bias
What is the purpose of this site?
 Accurate Information (check that same
info is on another site)
 The person is an expert on the topic; from
the perspective
 You need a counterpoint to support a
counter-argument
 It is a scholarly article and has cited
sources
 Promotes one point of view without
support
 Only personal interest or opinion is
represented
 Advertising prevalent
 Entertainment site
C
Content
How accurate or trustworthy is
this page?
Is it at my reading level?
 Source is a scholarly journal; peer-
reviewed or edited source
 This page or site has a works cited list or
bibliography
 Information is consistent with other
sources
 It is at a reading level I can understand
 Editing needed. Mistakes in spelling or
grammar throughout this site
 This page or site has no works cited list
or bibliography
 Information is not consistent with other
sources
 This site is too difficult for me to read
with understanding
 Not all aspects of the topic are covered
D
Date
Is the information current
enough?
When was this page created or
updated?
 This is a continuously updated page or site
 Links to information work
 You can find a date updated or posted
 This site was last updated more than a
year ago
 Links to other information are broken
Evaluation complete
 I am comfortable that the information on
this site is reliable
 I probably should not use this site for
academic work

Abc ds webevaluation1

  • 1.
    ABCDs of WebsiteEvaluation Name of site: What does the URL tell you? http://www.domainname.com/subject/folder/htm E.g. http://www.aip.org/history/climate/pdf/20ctrend.pdf Protocol: http:// Domain: www.aip.org (look up domain; watch for type of domain) Directory: history File: climate Filetype: pdf Title of file: 20ctrend.pdf ABCDs Consider using this site if: Question this site if: Analysis of URL of site:  You search for the domain and determine it is for a valid reliable organization or person. Use http://www.gleanwhois.org/  The type of domain is more reliable:  .gov (government)  .edu (college or university)  .org (organization; check and determine if the organization is reliable)  .com (commercial; someone paid for this)  .net (network)  .k12 (school; may be a grade 5 student)  About.com, yahoo, etc. (personal)  Has a country code you are unfamiliar with; not “.ca”  Blog, wiki, or social media site that are not edited A Authorship Who created this site?  Author is an expert in the field or subject (do a search for the author and organization)  Organization is governmental or non- profit and is a respected organization in this field.  No author is identified  Author does not have relevant qualifications  Organization has commercial interest in this subject B Bias What is the purpose of this site?  Accurate Information (check that same info is on another site)  The person is an expert on the topic; from the perspective  You need a counterpoint to support a counter-argument  It is a scholarly article and has cited sources  Promotes one point of view without support  Only personal interest or opinion is represented  Advertising prevalent  Entertainment site C Content How accurate or trustworthy is this page? Is it at my reading level?  Source is a scholarly journal; peer- reviewed or edited source  This page or site has a works cited list or bibliography  Information is consistent with other sources  It is at a reading level I can understand  Editing needed. Mistakes in spelling or grammar throughout this site  This page or site has no works cited list or bibliography  Information is not consistent with other sources  This site is too difficult for me to read with understanding  Not all aspects of the topic are covered D Date Is the information current enough? When was this page created or updated?  This is a continuously updated page or site  Links to information work  You can find a date updated or posted  This site was last updated more than a year ago  Links to other information are broken
  • 2.
    Evaluation complete  Iam comfortable that the information on this site is reliable  I probably should not use this site for academic work