This study investigated the effectiveness of a genre-based approach to teaching summary writing to 41 Taiwanese university students. Students took a pre-test where they summarized The Adventures of Tom Sawyer before a 7-week instruction. After instruction, which included analyzing the narrative structure and modeling summaries, students took a post-test summarizing the same text. Statistical analysis found the genre-based approach improved students' overall summarization performance, especially in content and organization compared to vocabulary and language use.
Argument Writing In Academic Written English ILisa Garcia
This study measured the effectiveness of classroom instruction on argument writing in English. Students took a pre-test before instruction and a post-test after to assess their ability to write arguments. The results showed that most students improved, with the average score increasing from 10.4 to 12.6. However, some students scored lower or the same on the post-test. The study also found that there was great variability in students' abilities both before and after instruction. While the instruction seemed to help most students, the author notes limitations of using a pre-test/post-test design to fully capture its effects.
This document summarizes the strategies used by four instructors to teach close reading skills to 120 students in a large lecture literature course at the University of Michigan. They aimed to make students active learners by regularly practicing close readings through online quizzes, in-class activities, and writing assignments. Formative assessments of students' long-answer quiz responses showed that students improved in their ability to closely analyze texts and develop original interpretations over the course of the semester. The instructors concluded their collaborative teaching approach was effective for developing undergraduates' fundamental literary analysis skills in a large lecture format.
Introduction
Summary of the article/Dissertation
Critical Review on the Research
Organization, arguments and evidences in each part:
Abstract and Introduction
Literature review
Methodology
Results
and mechanics
Conclusion
evaluate existing methodological approaches
inconsistencies in results
The document provides examples of assessment tasks that can be used in classrooms to evaluate students' understanding and skills. These include performances, exhibitions, interviews, debates, presentations, journals, logs, notes, graphic organizers, and more. The tasks are meant to allow students to demonstrate skills like using disciplinary language, applying ideas to new situations, and teaching ideas to others. Selection of assessment tasks should consider whether students can show complex thinking and learning in interactive ways.
Qualities of a good essay: an assessment of the writings of Nigerian undergra...SubmissionResearchpa
This document analyzes four essays written by Nigerian undergraduates to assess their abilities in employing key qualities of a good essay. The qualities examined were clarity, economy, simplicity, and unity. Four topics representing different essay types were assigned, and the best essay from each topic/department was selected for analysis based on the qualities. It was found that the selected essays demonstrated abilities in producing readable prose, though some room for improvement remained. Scores on the qualities ranged from 74-90%. The document discusses the qualities and provides examples from the essays to illustrate strengths and weaknesses in employing the qualities.
Adopting An SFL Approach To Teaching L2 Writing Through The Teaching Learning...Mary Calkins
This document summarizes a study that applied a Systemic Functional Linguistics (SFL) model to explore how 27 first-year Japanese university students improved their writing of analytical exposition essays during a 15-week English course using the Teaching Learning Cycle (TLC) approach. The study assessed students' understanding of metafunctions (ideational, experiential, and textual meanings) and linguistic resources in their pre- and post-essays. The results demonstrated that applying an SFL framework for writing assessment can explicitly examine students' improvements in understanding the target genre of essay writing.
This paper aims at taking university-level EFL students with an intermediate ability in English as a foreign language from paragraph writing to essay writing. The main idea in this paper is to propose the essay writing skills of EFL students. It proposes writing component that provides a complete picture of developing an essay writing process for EFL students at tertiary level. It also, reveals the objectives of essay writing, the contents, the theoretical aspects, practical aspects, the academic writing layout, and finally, the suggested writing textbooks.
Teaching learning skills at post secondary level - from critique to pedagogic...The Free School
This document provides a summary of the rationale and curriculum design for a postgraduate unit titled "Teaching learning skills at post-secondary level". The unit is designed for instructors who teach in multidisciplinary learning skills units (MLSUs). There is currently no comprehensive literature that guides MLSU instructors. The curriculum aims to fill this gap by exploring best practices through case studies of Australian tertiary institutions. A critical review of the literature is provided. The curriculum design incorporates spiral sequencing of core texts, formative assessment with early feedback, and encourages critical thinking to maximize learning outcomes.
Argument Writing In Academic Written English ILisa Garcia
This study measured the effectiveness of classroom instruction on argument writing in English. Students took a pre-test before instruction and a post-test after to assess their ability to write arguments. The results showed that most students improved, with the average score increasing from 10.4 to 12.6. However, some students scored lower or the same on the post-test. The study also found that there was great variability in students' abilities both before and after instruction. While the instruction seemed to help most students, the author notes limitations of using a pre-test/post-test design to fully capture its effects.
This document summarizes the strategies used by four instructors to teach close reading skills to 120 students in a large lecture literature course at the University of Michigan. They aimed to make students active learners by regularly practicing close readings through online quizzes, in-class activities, and writing assignments. Formative assessments of students' long-answer quiz responses showed that students improved in their ability to closely analyze texts and develop original interpretations over the course of the semester. The instructors concluded their collaborative teaching approach was effective for developing undergraduates' fundamental literary analysis skills in a large lecture format.
Introduction
Summary of the article/Dissertation
Critical Review on the Research
Organization, arguments and evidences in each part:
Abstract and Introduction
Literature review
Methodology
Results
and mechanics
Conclusion
evaluate existing methodological approaches
inconsistencies in results
The document provides examples of assessment tasks that can be used in classrooms to evaluate students' understanding and skills. These include performances, exhibitions, interviews, debates, presentations, journals, logs, notes, graphic organizers, and more. The tasks are meant to allow students to demonstrate skills like using disciplinary language, applying ideas to new situations, and teaching ideas to others. Selection of assessment tasks should consider whether students can show complex thinking and learning in interactive ways.
Qualities of a good essay: an assessment of the writings of Nigerian undergra...SubmissionResearchpa
This document analyzes four essays written by Nigerian undergraduates to assess their abilities in employing key qualities of a good essay. The qualities examined were clarity, economy, simplicity, and unity. Four topics representing different essay types were assigned, and the best essay from each topic/department was selected for analysis based on the qualities. It was found that the selected essays demonstrated abilities in producing readable prose, though some room for improvement remained. Scores on the qualities ranged from 74-90%. The document discusses the qualities and provides examples from the essays to illustrate strengths and weaknesses in employing the qualities.
Adopting An SFL Approach To Teaching L2 Writing Through The Teaching Learning...Mary Calkins
This document summarizes a study that applied a Systemic Functional Linguistics (SFL) model to explore how 27 first-year Japanese university students improved their writing of analytical exposition essays during a 15-week English course using the Teaching Learning Cycle (TLC) approach. The study assessed students' understanding of metafunctions (ideational, experiential, and textual meanings) and linguistic resources in their pre- and post-essays. The results demonstrated that applying an SFL framework for writing assessment can explicitly examine students' improvements in understanding the target genre of essay writing.
This paper aims at taking university-level EFL students with an intermediate ability in English as a foreign language from paragraph writing to essay writing. The main idea in this paper is to propose the essay writing skills of EFL students. It proposes writing component that provides a complete picture of developing an essay writing process for EFL students at tertiary level. It also, reveals the objectives of essay writing, the contents, the theoretical aspects, practical aspects, the academic writing layout, and finally, the suggested writing textbooks.
Teaching learning skills at post secondary level - from critique to pedagogic...The Free School
This document provides a summary of the rationale and curriculum design for a postgraduate unit titled "Teaching learning skills at post-secondary level". The unit is designed for instructors who teach in multidisciplinary learning skills units (MLSUs). There is currently no comprehensive literature that guides MLSU instructors. The curriculum aims to fill this gap by exploring best practices through case studies of Australian tertiary institutions. A critical review of the literature is provided. The curriculum design incorporates spiral sequencing of core texts, formative assessment with early feedback, and encourages critical thinking to maximize learning outcomes.
A Genre-Based Approach To Preparing For IELTS And TOEFL Essay Writing TasksMary Calkins
This document proposes adopting a genre-based approach to teaching essay writing for the IELTS and TOEFL tests. Recent test results show writing is the lowest scoring section, especially for Asian learners. A genre-based methodology is presented that involves building context, modeling exemplar texts, jointly constructing essays, and independent writing practice. This approach aims to not only help learners achieve satisfactory test scores, but develop abilities to communicate effectively using various genres in future contexts. The proposed genre teaching cycle scaffolds learning and empowers students through collaborative and independent practice.
The document discusses principles and strategies for teaching English learners. It outlines six key principles for developing instruction for ELs, noting that all principles should be incorporated. It emphasizes that instruction should take into account students' English proficiency levels and prior experiences. Teachers must be attentive to student differences and design instruction accordingly. Short videos can be used for close reading to engage students in analyzing details, patterns and developing understandings of texts. Providing structured routines for close reading can help students develop independence in reading.
This document summarizes Amy Hoopingarner's course project on creating an effective literacy environment for beginning readers from pre-K to 3rd grade. It includes two lesson plans that focus on the interactive, critical, and response perspectives. The first lesson plan centers on the interactive perspective and has students read the book "National Geographic Readers: Titanic." It assesses students through a K-W-L chart, vocabulary and inferencing activity, and having students write the main idea and summarize the book. The project provides strategies for selecting texts, understanding students as literacy learners, and engaging students through different perspectives to improve their reading abilities.
The document describes an experiment using the Jeremiadic approach to teach English based on a short story. It involves 3 stages: text explanation, where students discuss the story; text examination, where they explore language skills and make connections to other knowledge; and text expectation, where they identify moral values from the story. Based on student feedback, the approach helped improve language skills and engage with course competencies by discussing, questioning, analyzing and applying values from the text. The author concludes the approach helped meet curriculum goals but more experiments are needed with different texts.
This document discusses making reading more communicative in language classes. It proposes using pre-reading, during reading, and post-reading activities to integrate reading with other skills. Examples of activities provided include read-to-act, read-to-debate, and read-to-interview. The goal is to make reading more engaging and stimulate practice of all four language skills.
Employing Social Media in Text-Based InstructionAJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT:Text-Based Instruction was first introduced over two decades ago but still has relevance for
language teaching today. However, the texts typically used in this approach are of a literary or academic nature
rather than texts that are motivating and more immediately relevant to learners’ lives. This paper proposes the
use of social media platforms, in particular Instagram, as a way to make the utilization of Text-Based Instruction
more meaningful to students.
KEYWORDS –genre theory, whole texts, Text-Based Instruction, English language learning, contemporary
texts
This study investigates pragmatic and discourse transfer in the compliment response strategies used by Vietnamese learners of English when communicating with Australians. The study uses a new methodology called "Naturalized Role-play" to examine how compliment response strategies are combined in Vietnamese, Australian English, and the interlanguage of Vietnamese learners. This is the first study to analyze compliment responses in both Vietnamese and Australian English, as well as pragmatic and discourse transfer between the two languages. The results provide new insights into cross-cultural differences in politeness strategies and how first language and cultural influences may affect second language use through pragmatic and discourse transfer.
This document discusses making reading more communicative in language classes. It defines communicative language teaching and describes several pre-, during, and post-reading activities that integrate the four skills of listening, speaking, reading, and writing. These include information transfer activities, opinion sharing, debates, role plays based on texts, and group discussions about what was read. The goal is to make reading purposeful and engage students in meaningful communication about texts.
This document discusses making reading more communicative in language classes. It defines communicative language teaching and describes several pre-, during, and post-reading activities that integrate the four language skills. These include information transfer activities, opinion sharing, debates, role plays based on texts, and discussions about what was read. The goal is to make reading purposeful and engage students in meaningful interaction through and about texts.
A Comparative Study of American English File and New Headway English CourseAJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: Textbooks play an essential role in the language learning process. The difficulty is that among a wide range of textbooks in the market,there are a lot ofoptions which make the process of book selection even harder. Therefore, book evaluation is a vital process, and it has great impact on the process of learning and teaching. In order to evaluate ELT textbooks, theorists and writers have offered different kinds of evaluative frameworks based on a number of principles and criteria. To this end, two EFL textbooks namely New Headway English Courseand American English File which are commonly taught in language institutes in Iranwere selected for evaluation by seeking the teachers’ viewpoints on the effectiveness of the two textbooks. Twenty ELT teachers helped the researcher rate the evaluative checklists. A modified version of [1] teacher textbook evaluation form was used to collect data.The results indicated that the differences between the two textbooks were not significant in four features including practical considerations, layout and design, activities, and skills, but they proved to be different in some other features including language type as well as subject and content.
An Analysis Of Discourse Markers In Academic Report Writing Pedagogical Impl...Brooke Heidt
This document discusses discourse markers and their importance in academic report writing. It begins by defining academic report writing and its purpose of investigating and presenting facts for a professional audience. The document then discusses discourse/discourse analysis, which examines how components of language cohere to effectively communicate. Finally, the document emphasizes the need for teaching and proper use of discourse markers to enhance coherence and effectiveness in academic report writing.
The document provides guidance for developing effective tests of literature. It recommends that tests include a balanced variety of question types, use authentic texts, provide linguistic support when needed, and encourage the transfer of skills to unfamiliar texts. Good test questions meet student levels, give abstract concepts a practical focus, encourage identification with texts, and include motivating classroom activities.
The document provides an overview and theoretical background of the Academic Phrasebank resource. It describes the resource as a compilation of commonly used phrasal elements in academic English organized according to the main sections of a research paper. The phrases are derived from authentic academic sources and are intended to help academic writers, particularly non-native English speakers, with organizing their writing and incorporating appropriate phrasing. Guidelines are provided on when it is acceptable to reuse phrases from the resource in one's own academic writing.
A Genre Analysis Study Of Iranian EFL Learners Master Theses With A Focus On...Jennifer Daniel
This document summarizes a study that analyzed the rhetorical structure of introduction sections in 40 master's theses written by Iranian EFL students. The study found that most of the rhetorical structures and moves approved by experts in the field occurred at a high frequency in the theses introductions. Understanding genre and rhetorical structures is important for academic writing. The results may help improve teaching of academic writing and help students structure their theses introductions according to conventions.
An Exploratory Study Of Organizational Problems Faced By Pakistani Student Wr...Sandra Valenzuela
This document summarizes a study that explored the organizational problems faced by Pakistani student writers with learning difficulties in writing English essays. The study used questionnaires and interviews of 100 student writers and 5 of their teachers. It found that students struggled with writing introductions, thesis statements, topic sentences, conclusions, and transitioning ideas. Teachers reported students had difficulty with thesis statements, topic sentences, and sequencing ideas. The study discussed psychological, social and educational factors that contributed to these issues, such as lack of motivation, confidence and writing anxiety among students.
The article examines the beliefs and practices of four experienced university teachers in teaching English as a foreign language (EFL) writing in China. It analyzes data collected over two semesters, including classroom observations, interviews, and course materials. The teachers' beliefs and practices in teaching writing are explored, as well as factors that contribute to how their beliefs and practices developed.
Timothy Curnow And Anthony Liddicoat 2008Diana Quinn
The document discusses redesigning assessment in applied linguistics courses to better engage students in academic literacy. It proposes a model that conceptualizes what is being assessed, how it will be judged, how judgments will be validated, and how assessments will be elicited. For two courses, it redesigned assessments to have a clear link to learning goals, develop skills cumulatively, and integrate academic literacy with disciplinary content through tasks like analyzing research articles and language data. Initial outcomes suggest students felt more confident dealing with research and understood required writing types better.
This document summarizes a study that evaluated the "New Interchange" English textbook series based on feedback from 35 Iranian EFL teachers. The study found that while teachers generally found the series effective and suitable, it also had some weaknesses. Specifically, most teachers had similar positive opinions about the series' effectiveness, but results showed the series has issues that require teacher awareness and consideration. The study aimed to determine the pedagogical value and suitability of the widely-used New Interchange series from the perspective of Iranian EFL instructors.
This document summarizes a study where the author engaged English language learners in examining and discussing language teaching research articles during their lessons. The students compared their own language learning experiences to the findings in the research articles. This helped the author learn about the students' pride in their language learning knowledge, understanding of themselves as individuals in the learning process, and concern for how outside factors impact their learning. Most importantly, it showed how the students developed as reflective, critical thinkers about language learning by directly engaging with both the processes and products of research.
The document provides instructions for submitting a paper writing request to the website HelpWriting.net in 5 steps:
1. Create an account with a password and email.
2. Complete a 10-minute order form providing instructions, sources, deadline, and attach a sample work.
3. Writers will bid on the request and the customer will choose a writer based on qualifications.
4. The customer will receive the paper and authorize payment if satisfied or request revisions.
5. HelpWriting.net guarantees original, high-quality content and full refunds for plagiarism.
13 Original Colonies Essay. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
The document provides instructions for using a writing assistance website to have papers written. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with a password and email. 2) Complete a form with assignment details and attach samples. 3) Review bids from writers and select one. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment. 5) Request revisions until satisfied with the work. The purpose is to outline the process for having assignments written by third parties on the site.
More Related Content
Similar to A Genre-Based Approach To Teaching EFL Summary Writing
A Genre-Based Approach To Preparing For IELTS And TOEFL Essay Writing TasksMary Calkins
This document proposes adopting a genre-based approach to teaching essay writing for the IELTS and TOEFL tests. Recent test results show writing is the lowest scoring section, especially for Asian learners. A genre-based methodology is presented that involves building context, modeling exemplar texts, jointly constructing essays, and independent writing practice. This approach aims to not only help learners achieve satisfactory test scores, but develop abilities to communicate effectively using various genres in future contexts. The proposed genre teaching cycle scaffolds learning and empowers students through collaborative and independent practice.
The document discusses principles and strategies for teaching English learners. It outlines six key principles for developing instruction for ELs, noting that all principles should be incorporated. It emphasizes that instruction should take into account students' English proficiency levels and prior experiences. Teachers must be attentive to student differences and design instruction accordingly. Short videos can be used for close reading to engage students in analyzing details, patterns and developing understandings of texts. Providing structured routines for close reading can help students develop independence in reading.
This document summarizes Amy Hoopingarner's course project on creating an effective literacy environment for beginning readers from pre-K to 3rd grade. It includes two lesson plans that focus on the interactive, critical, and response perspectives. The first lesson plan centers on the interactive perspective and has students read the book "National Geographic Readers: Titanic." It assesses students through a K-W-L chart, vocabulary and inferencing activity, and having students write the main idea and summarize the book. The project provides strategies for selecting texts, understanding students as literacy learners, and engaging students through different perspectives to improve their reading abilities.
The document describes an experiment using the Jeremiadic approach to teach English based on a short story. It involves 3 stages: text explanation, where students discuss the story; text examination, where they explore language skills and make connections to other knowledge; and text expectation, where they identify moral values from the story. Based on student feedback, the approach helped improve language skills and engage with course competencies by discussing, questioning, analyzing and applying values from the text. The author concludes the approach helped meet curriculum goals but more experiments are needed with different texts.
This document discusses making reading more communicative in language classes. It proposes using pre-reading, during reading, and post-reading activities to integrate reading with other skills. Examples of activities provided include read-to-act, read-to-debate, and read-to-interview. The goal is to make reading more engaging and stimulate practice of all four language skills.
Employing Social Media in Text-Based InstructionAJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT:Text-Based Instruction was first introduced over two decades ago but still has relevance for
language teaching today. However, the texts typically used in this approach are of a literary or academic nature
rather than texts that are motivating and more immediately relevant to learners’ lives. This paper proposes the
use of social media platforms, in particular Instagram, as a way to make the utilization of Text-Based Instruction
more meaningful to students.
KEYWORDS –genre theory, whole texts, Text-Based Instruction, English language learning, contemporary
texts
This study investigates pragmatic and discourse transfer in the compliment response strategies used by Vietnamese learners of English when communicating with Australians. The study uses a new methodology called "Naturalized Role-play" to examine how compliment response strategies are combined in Vietnamese, Australian English, and the interlanguage of Vietnamese learners. This is the first study to analyze compliment responses in both Vietnamese and Australian English, as well as pragmatic and discourse transfer between the two languages. The results provide new insights into cross-cultural differences in politeness strategies and how first language and cultural influences may affect second language use through pragmatic and discourse transfer.
This document discusses making reading more communicative in language classes. It defines communicative language teaching and describes several pre-, during, and post-reading activities that integrate the four skills of listening, speaking, reading, and writing. These include information transfer activities, opinion sharing, debates, role plays based on texts, and group discussions about what was read. The goal is to make reading purposeful and engage students in meaningful communication about texts.
This document discusses making reading more communicative in language classes. It defines communicative language teaching and describes several pre-, during, and post-reading activities that integrate the four language skills. These include information transfer activities, opinion sharing, debates, role plays based on texts, and discussions about what was read. The goal is to make reading purposeful and engage students in meaningful interaction through and about texts.
A Comparative Study of American English File and New Headway English CourseAJHSSR Journal
ABSTRACT: Textbooks play an essential role in the language learning process. The difficulty is that among a wide range of textbooks in the market,there are a lot ofoptions which make the process of book selection even harder. Therefore, book evaluation is a vital process, and it has great impact on the process of learning and teaching. In order to evaluate ELT textbooks, theorists and writers have offered different kinds of evaluative frameworks based on a number of principles and criteria. To this end, two EFL textbooks namely New Headway English Courseand American English File which are commonly taught in language institutes in Iranwere selected for evaluation by seeking the teachers’ viewpoints on the effectiveness of the two textbooks. Twenty ELT teachers helped the researcher rate the evaluative checklists. A modified version of [1] teacher textbook evaluation form was used to collect data.The results indicated that the differences between the two textbooks were not significant in four features including practical considerations, layout and design, activities, and skills, but they proved to be different in some other features including language type as well as subject and content.
An Analysis Of Discourse Markers In Academic Report Writing Pedagogical Impl...Brooke Heidt
This document discusses discourse markers and their importance in academic report writing. It begins by defining academic report writing and its purpose of investigating and presenting facts for a professional audience. The document then discusses discourse/discourse analysis, which examines how components of language cohere to effectively communicate. Finally, the document emphasizes the need for teaching and proper use of discourse markers to enhance coherence and effectiveness in academic report writing.
The document provides guidance for developing effective tests of literature. It recommends that tests include a balanced variety of question types, use authentic texts, provide linguistic support when needed, and encourage the transfer of skills to unfamiliar texts. Good test questions meet student levels, give abstract concepts a practical focus, encourage identification with texts, and include motivating classroom activities.
The document provides an overview and theoretical background of the Academic Phrasebank resource. It describes the resource as a compilation of commonly used phrasal elements in academic English organized according to the main sections of a research paper. The phrases are derived from authentic academic sources and are intended to help academic writers, particularly non-native English speakers, with organizing their writing and incorporating appropriate phrasing. Guidelines are provided on when it is acceptable to reuse phrases from the resource in one's own academic writing.
A Genre Analysis Study Of Iranian EFL Learners Master Theses With A Focus On...Jennifer Daniel
This document summarizes a study that analyzed the rhetorical structure of introduction sections in 40 master's theses written by Iranian EFL students. The study found that most of the rhetorical structures and moves approved by experts in the field occurred at a high frequency in the theses introductions. Understanding genre and rhetorical structures is important for academic writing. The results may help improve teaching of academic writing and help students structure their theses introductions according to conventions.
An Exploratory Study Of Organizational Problems Faced By Pakistani Student Wr...Sandra Valenzuela
This document summarizes a study that explored the organizational problems faced by Pakistani student writers with learning difficulties in writing English essays. The study used questionnaires and interviews of 100 student writers and 5 of their teachers. It found that students struggled with writing introductions, thesis statements, topic sentences, conclusions, and transitioning ideas. Teachers reported students had difficulty with thesis statements, topic sentences, and sequencing ideas. The study discussed psychological, social and educational factors that contributed to these issues, such as lack of motivation, confidence and writing anxiety among students.
The article examines the beliefs and practices of four experienced university teachers in teaching English as a foreign language (EFL) writing in China. It analyzes data collected over two semesters, including classroom observations, interviews, and course materials. The teachers' beliefs and practices in teaching writing are explored, as well as factors that contribute to how their beliefs and practices developed.
Timothy Curnow And Anthony Liddicoat 2008Diana Quinn
The document discusses redesigning assessment in applied linguistics courses to better engage students in academic literacy. It proposes a model that conceptualizes what is being assessed, how it will be judged, how judgments will be validated, and how assessments will be elicited. For two courses, it redesigned assessments to have a clear link to learning goals, develop skills cumulatively, and integrate academic literacy with disciplinary content through tasks like analyzing research articles and language data. Initial outcomes suggest students felt more confident dealing with research and understood required writing types better.
This document summarizes a study that evaluated the "New Interchange" English textbook series based on feedback from 35 Iranian EFL teachers. The study found that while teachers generally found the series effective and suitable, it also had some weaknesses. Specifically, most teachers had similar positive opinions about the series' effectiveness, but results showed the series has issues that require teacher awareness and consideration. The study aimed to determine the pedagogical value and suitability of the widely-used New Interchange series from the perspective of Iranian EFL instructors.
This document summarizes a study where the author engaged English language learners in examining and discussing language teaching research articles during their lessons. The students compared their own language learning experiences to the findings in the research articles. This helped the author learn about the students' pride in their language learning knowledge, understanding of themselves as individuals in the learning process, and concern for how outside factors impact their learning. Most importantly, it showed how the students developed as reflective, critical thinkers about language learning by directly engaging with both the processes and products of research.
Similar to A Genre-Based Approach To Teaching EFL Summary Writing (20)
The document provides instructions for submitting a paper writing request to the website HelpWriting.net in 5 steps:
1. Create an account with a password and email.
2. Complete a 10-minute order form providing instructions, sources, deadline, and attach a sample work.
3. Writers will bid on the request and the customer will choose a writer based on qualifications.
4. The customer will receive the paper and authorize payment if satisfied or request revisions.
5. HelpWriting.net guarantees original, high-quality content and full refunds for plagiarism.
13 Original Colonies Essay. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
The document provides instructions for using a writing assistance website to have papers written. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with a password and email. 2) Complete a form with assignment details and attach samples. 3) Review bids from writers and select one. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment. 5) Request revisions until satisfied with the work. The purpose is to outline the process for having assignments written by third parties on the site.
The document provides instructions for requesting writing help from the website HelpWriting.net. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with a password and email. 2) Complete a 10-minute order form providing instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and select one. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment. 5) Request revisions to ensure satisfaction, with the option of a full refund for plagiarized work.
4 Year Old Observation Essays. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
John Stuart Mill was a British philosopher born in 1806 in London. He was educated from a very young age by his father James Mill, a noted philosopher and economist who introduced him to the school of thought known as Utilitarianism. John Stuart studied languages, mathematics, science, and history extensively as a child, often tutoring his younger siblings as well. He was heavily influenced by his father's philosophies of scientific foundation for philosophy and humanist approach to politics and economics.
10 Lines Essay On Mahatma Gandhi In EnglishDarian Pruitt
This document provides instructions for requesting an assignment writing service from HelpWriting.net. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with a password and email. 2) Complete a 10-minute order form providing instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and choose one based on qualifications. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment if pleased. 5) Request revisions until fully satisfied, with a refund option for plagiarized content.
The document provides instructions for how to request and receive writing assistance from the HelpWriting.net website. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with a password and email. 2) Complete a 10-minute order form providing instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and choose one based on qualifications. 4) Receive the paper and authorize payment if satisfied. 5) Request revisions to ensure satisfaction, with the option of a full refund for plagiarized work.
This document outlines the steps to request writing assistance from HelpWriting.net. It explains that users must first create an account with a password and email. They can then submit a 'Write My Paper For Me' request by filling out a form with instructions, sources, and deadline. Writers will bid on the request, and the user can choose a writer based on qualifications. The writer will complete the paper and the user can request revisions until satisfied. HelpWriting.net promises original, high-quality work and refunds for plagiarized content.
500-700 Word Essay Example. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
The document discusses using the heat shock method to perform genetic transformation, which involves implanting a segment of DNA from one organism (a jellyfish) into another organism (E. coli bacteria) to make the recipient organism express the donor's genes. Specifically, it describes an experiment where heat shock was used to genetically transform a piece of DNA from a jellyfish into a sample of E. coli bacteria in order to observe the effects on the bacteria. The goal was to integrate the foreign jellyfish DNA into the E. coli genome and have the bacteria display characteristics specified by the new genetic material.
1. Social learning theory posits that violence is learned through observation and reinforcement. By witnessing violence, people learn aggressive behaviors which may be repeated, especially if rewarded.
2. Impulsivity and poor self-control have been linked to violence according to traits theories. Those with difficulties regulating emotions and impulses may act violently when angry or frustrated.
3. Attachment theory suggests that children who experience neglect, abuse or inconsistent caregiving are more likely to develop mental representations of relationships as distrustful and aggressive. This can influence the use of violence in future relationships.
The document provides instructions for requesting writing assistance from HelpWriting.net. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with a password and email. 2) Complete a 10-minute order form providing instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and choose one based on qualifications. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment if satisfied. 5) Request revisions to ensure satisfaction, with the option of a full refund for plagiarized work.
The document provides instructions for requesting a paper writing service from HelpWriting.net. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with valid email and password. 2) Complete a 10-minute order form providing instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and choose one based on qualifications. 4) Receive the paper and authorize payment if satisfied. 5) Request revisions to ensure satisfaction, with a refund offered for plagiarized content. The service aims to meet all student needs for original, high-quality assignments.
400 Words Essay On Security Threats In IndiaDarian Pruitt
This document provides instructions for requesting writing assistance from HelpWriting.net. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account with a password and email. 2) Complete a 10-minute order form providing instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and choose one based on qualifications. 4) Receive the paper and approve for payment or request revisions. 5) Request multiple revisions to ensure satisfaction, with a refund option for plagiarized content.
23 March 1940 Essay In English. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
The document discusses beech forest ecosystems. It describes their main characteristics and distribution pre-human and currently. Beech forests support diverse vegetation structures and native fauna. Environmental factors like altitude, latitude, rainfall and soil drainage affect beech forest composition. Human activity also impacts ecological processes and species composition within beech forests. Specific examples of New Zealand beech species and their typical environments are provided.
The document outlines a 5 step process for getting writing assistance from HelpWriting.net, including registering for an account, submitting a request form with instructions and deadline, reviewing writer bids and qualifications to select a writer, receiving the completed paper, and having the option to request revisions until satisfied. The service aims to match clients with qualified writers and ensure high quality, original content through a bidding system and refund policy for plagiarized work.
60 All Free Essays. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
The document provides instructions for using a writing assistance service, outlining a 5-step process: 1) Create an account; 2) Submit a request with instructions and deadline; 3) Review bids from writers and select one; 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment; 5) Request revisions to ensure satisfaction, with a refund offered for plagiarized work.
25 Word Essay. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
The document discusses comparing American zoos and aquariums. It notes that over 140 million people in North America visit zoos annually, more than various sports combined. However, some believe zoos and aquariums are unethical. It provides background on the issues, noting zoos aim to educate the public and conserve species, while critics argue animals are not suited to captivity and their needs cannot be met. The document examines both perspectives on the ethics of zoos and aquariums.
How To Write Paper Presentation. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
The document provides instructions for creating a paper writing request on the HelpWriting.net site in 5 steps: 1) Create an account with an email and password. 2) Complete a 10-minute order form with instructions, sources, and deadline. 3) Review bids from writers and choose one based on qualifications. 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment if satisfied. 5) Request revisions to ensure satisfaction, with a refund option for plagiarized content.
History Essay - Writing Portfolio. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
This document provides instructions for submitting an assignment request and receiving writing assistance from the HelpWriting.net website. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account; 2) Complete a request form with instructions and deadline; 3) Review bids from writers and select one; 4) Review the completed paper and authorize payment; 5) Request revisions to ensure satisfaction. It emphasizes that original, high-quality content will be provided and work can be revised until the customer is fully satisfied.
How Long Should A Introduction Paragraph Be.Darian Pruitt
The passage discusses how the Great Depression and harsh weather conditions during the 1930s caused extreme hardship for many Americans, especially migrant farmers. The Great Depression led to bankruptcies and destitution as farmers struggled to survive. Photographer Dorothea Lange documented the struggles of migrant farmers through her photos from this era.
Research Paper Writing Service. Online assignment writing service.Darian Pruitt
The document discusses research paper writing services provided by HelpWriting.net. It outlines a 5-step process: 1) Create an account; 2) Complete an order form with instructions and deadline; 3) Writers bid on the request and one is chosen; 4) The paper is written and revisions can be requested; 5) High-quality, original content is guaranteed or a full refund is offered. The service aims to fully meet customer needs through this process.
How Barcodes Can Be Leveraged Within Odoo 17Celine George
In this presentation, we will explore how barcodes can be leveraged within Odoo 17 to streamline our manufacturing processes. We will cover the configuration steps, how to utilize barcodes in different manufacturing scenarios, and the overall benefits of implementing this technology.
This presentation was provided by Rebecca Benner, Ph.D., of the American Society of Anesthesiologists, for the second session of NISO's 2024 Training Series "DEIA in the Scholarly Landscape." Session Two: 'Expanding Pathways to Publishing Careers,' was held June 13, 2024.
Level 3 NCEA - NZ: A Nation In the Making 1872 - 1900 SML.pptHenry Hollis
The History of NZ 1870-1900.
Making of a Nation.
From the NZ Wars to Liberals,
Richard Seddon, George Grey,
Social Laboratory, New Zealand,
Confiscations, Kotahitanga, Kingitanga, Parliament, Suffrage, Repudiation, Economic Change, Agriculture, Gold Mining, Timber, Flax, Sheep, Dairying,
Leveraging Generative AI to Drive Nonprofit InnovationTechSoup
In this webinar, participants learned how to utilize Generative AI to streamline operations and elevate member engagement. Amazon Web Service experts provided a customer specific use cases and dived into low/no-code tools that are quick and easy to deploy through Amazon Web Service (AWS.)
Philippine Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) CurriculumMJDuyan
(𝐓𝐋𝐄 𝟏𝟎𝟎) (𝐋𝐞𝐬𝐬𝐨𝐧 𝟏)-𝐏𝐫𝐞𝐥𝐢𝐦𝐬
𝐃𝐢𝐬𝐜𝐮𝐬𝐬 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐄𝐏𝐏 𝐂𝐮𝐫𝐫𝐢𝐜𝐮𝐥𝐮𝐦 𝐢𝐧 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐏𝐡𝐢𝐥𝐢𝐩𝐩𝐢𝐧𝐞𝐬:
- Understand the goals and objectives of the Edukasyong Pantahanan at Pangkabuhayan (EPP) curriculum, recognizing its importance in fostering practical life skills and values among students. Students will also be able to identify the key components and subjects covered, such as agriculture, home economics, industrial arts, and information and communication technology.
𝐄𝐱𝐩𝐥𝐚𝐢𝐧 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐍𝐚𝐭𝐮𝐫𝐞 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐒𝐜𝐨𝐩𝐞 𝐨𝐟 𝐚𝐧 𝐄𝐧𝐭𝐫𝐞𝐩𝐫𝐞𝐧𝐞𝐮𝐫:
-Define entrepreneurship, distinguishing it from general business activities by emphasizing its focus on innovation, risk-taking, and value creation. Students will describe the characteristics and traits of successful entrepreneurs, including their roles and responsibilities, and discuss the broader economic and social impacts of entrepreneurial activities on both local and global scales.
Temple of Asclepius in Thrace. Excavation resultsKrassimira Luka
The temple and the sanctuary around were dedicated to Asklepios Zmidrenus. This name has been known since 1875 when an inscription dedicated to him was discovered in Rome. The inscription is dated in 227 AD and was left by soldiers originating from the city of Philippopolis (modern Plovdiv).
Elevate Your Nonprofit's Online Presence_ A Guide to Effective SEO Strategies...TechSoup
Whether you're new to SEO or looking to refine your existing strategies, this webinar will provide you with actionable insights and practical tips to elevate your nonprofit's online presence.
Elevate Your Nonprofit's Online Presence_ A Guide to Effective SEO Strategies...
A Genre-Based Approach To Teaching EFL Summary Writing
1. A genre-based approach to teaching
EFL summary writing
Yuan-Shan Chen and Shao-Wen Su
This study utilizes a pre-test/post-test assessment to investigate the instructional
efficacy of a genre-based approach to teaching summary writing. Forty-one EFL
university students in Taiwan were asked before and after the instruction to
summarize a simplified version of The Adventures of Tom Sawyer in
a maximum of 500 words. All the students’ summaries on the pre- and post-tests
were evaluated against content, organization, vocabulary, and language use. The
statistical results showed that such an approach was effective in improving
students’ overall summarization performance of a narrative source text and that
the students benefited to a greater extent in content and organization than in
vocabulary and language use. The results were also supported by the students’
interview comments.
Introduction It has long been recognized that reading and writing are closely related
(Krashen 1984). Reading-to-write tasks have been extensively observed in
many university settings. One such task, summarization, is defined as ‘the
process of synthesizing and organizing individual idea units into
a summary or organized series of related general ideas’ (Irwin 1986: 5). To
write a good summary, one needs to be able to
n understand the text
n select the most important information
n delete the minor and redundant details
n combine similar ideas into categories
n write in his/her own words (Casazza 1993).
In Taiwan, much attention has been paid in recent years to student
summarization tasks. First, almost all university students in Taiwan need to
pass a large-scale, standardized test to graduate. These proficiency tests
generally involve a writing section. Second, according to the Ministry of
Education, there have been about 25,000–30,000 Taiwanese students
pursuing their graduate studies in the United States. Before they enter US
graduate institutes, they need to take the new TOEFL test, part of which
requires testees to summarize a short source text. Finally, writing research
indicates that when asked to summarize a lengthy academic text, L2
learners tend to copy from source texts—an act considered as plagiarism
(Keck 2006; Yu 2009). Taiwanese students, of course, are no exception.
Although researchers such as Casazza (op.cit.) proposed models of direct
instruction to teach summary writing to college students, the target
184 ELT Journal Volume 66/2 April 2012; doi:10.1093/elt/ccr061
ª
ª The Author 2011. Published by Oxford University Press; all rights reserved.
Advance Access publication September 7, 2011
at
Fudan
University
on
March
25,
2012
http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/
Downloaded
from
2. audience is basically L1, rather than L2 writers. More importantly, these
models fail to distinguish the discoursal features of narrative, expository,
and argumentative source texts, which have been demonstrated to have
differential effects on students’ summarization performance (Yu op.cit.).
Seen in this light, a genre-based approach provides another alternative for
writing teachers to enhance students’ summarization abilities. It may be
worth clarifying what is meant by ‘genre’ before such an approach is
introduced. Hyland (2007) sees genre as a group of texts which share
similar discoursal features that are easily identifiable by members of
a community. Sidaway (2006) used the term ‘The magnificent seven’ to
categorize genre into
n recount
n narrative
n explanation
n information report
n procedure
n discussion
n exposition.
Each genre may present itself in various text forms. For example, a film
review can be categorized as an exposition. On the other hand, a narrative
may be found in email messages, newspaper articles, novels, and so forth.
Drawing on Halliday’s (1994) Systemic Functional Linguistics, a genre-
based approach to teaching L2 writing focuses on the conventions of
a particular text type and attempts to help students understand why they are
writing a text (purpose), who they are writing for (audience), and how to
write a text (organization) (Widodo 2006). Hyland (op.cit.) argues that
genre-based writing instruction places considerable emphasis on
scaffolding (or teacher-supported learning) and collaboration (or peer
interaction). He suggests that the teaching–learning cycle of a genre-based
approach involves five major stages, which are
1 setting the context: to explore the purposes and setting in which a given
genre is normally applied;
2 modelling: to analyse the key discoursal features of a sample text of the
genre;
3 joint construction: to provide teacher-guided activities to reinforce the
organizational pattern and grammatical features of the genre;
4 independent construction: to withdraw teacher support gradually and to
monitor independent writing; and
5 comparing: to associate what has been learnt from the given genre with
other genres to identify particular social purposes.
Empirical studies (for example Kongpetch 2006; Cheng 2008) have shown
that a genre-based approach can enhance students’ abilities in constructing
narrative, expository, and argumentative essays. It is therefore assumed that
such an approach might similarly benefit students’ summarization
performance in relation to narrative, expository, and argumentative source
texts. If students have an explicit understanding of how a source text is
structured, it should be easier for them to distinguish between major and
minor points and to synthesize ideas in a more effective way.
A genre-based approach to teaching EFL summary writing 185
at
Fudan
University
on
March
25,
2012
http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/
Downloaded
from
3. To test this assumption, a seven-week lesson plan based on Hyland’s first
four stages was designed for a class of 41 university sophomores. We did not
include the last stage—comparing—in our lesson plan because only after
the students have acquired at least some genres would it be worthwhile
comparing and contrasting other genres. In this study, we limited our scope
to examining the instructional effectiveness of a genre-based approach to
teaching summarization of a narrative source text, so we set out to answer
two research questions:
1 Does a genre-based writing instruction enhance students’ overall
summarization performance?
2 If the answer to research Question 1 is positive, in what aspect(s) does
a genre-based writing instruction benefit students’ summarization
performance?
The study Forty-onestudents(30femalesand11males)participatedinthisstudy.Allof
them were English majors taking a required course entitled ‘Intermediate
writing’ at a university of technology in central Taiwan. Prior to this course,
they had taken ‘Beginning writing’, which focused on sentence and
paragraph writing rather than essay writing. On average, their English
proficiency was at an intermediate level.
This study used a test/retest design. The major source of data was the
summaries produced by the students on two occasions: prior to instruction
in the second week(pre-test) and after instruction in the seventh week(post-
test). The entire experiment took 14 hours, with two class hours per week.
The classroom activities are described below:
Week 1: reading the
book
In the first week of the semester, all the students were required to read The
Adventures of Tom Sawyer. This book was selected from the Oxford
Bookworms series, which offers graded reading at seven levels (Starter to
Stage 6). The Adventures of Tom Sawyer is at the Stage 1 level, which contains
400 headwords. We decided on this book because it has a well-structured
organization, clear narrative timeline, and low lexical diversity, which are
believed to make the summarization task easier for students (Yu op.cit.).
Week 2: writing the
summary
In the second week, all the students were asked to write a summary of this
book in class with a maximum of 500 words.
Week 3: setting the
context
Our aim here was to teach the students the structure of the prototypical
narrative genre, also known as ‘story grammar’. It generally involves six
elements, which include setting, initiating event, internal response,
attempt, consequence, and reaction (Stein and Glenn 1979). To illustrate
these elements, we presented a 30-minute video made up of film clips from
one of the world’s most popular stories, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone
by J. K. Rowling. Having watched the video, we conducted a class discussion
to answer the following questions relating to these six elements:
Setting Where does the story take place? When does the story take
place? Who is the main character? What is the main
characterlike?Whoisanotherimportantcharacter?Whatis
this other character like?
186 Yuan-Shan Chen and Shao-Wen Su
at
Fudan
University
on
March
25,
2012
http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/
Downloaded
from
4. Initiating event What is the major problem the main character
confronts?
Internal response What is the main character’s reaction to the major
problem?
Attempt How does the main character attempt to solve the
major problem?
Consequence Does the main character solve the problem? Is there
any unexpected result in the story?
Reaction What is the main character’s response to the
consequence?
Weeks 4 and 5:
modelling
The purpose of this instructional activity was to explicitly teach the students
how to write a summary of a narrative text. First, we analysed the
introductory,body,and concluding paragraphs,eachofwhich was equipped
with appropriate story grammar features. For the introductory paragraph,
we instructed our students to begin with ‘the hook’, followed by the
background information, and the thesis statement. The hook is usually
a simple statement or a question to attract the audience’s attention to read
the summary. The background information, similar to the setting element
of a storygrammar, orients the audienceto the characters, time, and place of
the story. Finally, the thesis statement tells what the story is about and
prepares the audience for the story that follows.
For the body paragraph, we instructed the students to identify the major
problem the main character encounters (initiating event), to ignore the
minor andunimportant events, todescribethe maincharacter’s reactionsto
the problem (internal response), and to indicate the main character’s course
of action to solve the problem (attempt). For the concluding paragraph, we
told the students to describe the outcome of the event (consequence) and
a response of the main character to such an outcome (reaction). In addition,
the students were asked to end their summaries with the lesson or theme
shown in the story.
After that, we provided the students with three prize-winning summaries
from a national contest. These summaries were written for The Age of
Innocence, a reader also from the Oxford Bookworms series (Stage 5), and
they were rated as ‘excellent’, ‘very good’, and ‘good’, respectively. We
analysedthe genericstructuresand thegrammatical features ofthese works
to reinforce the students’ knowledge of the organization and language of an
effective summary of a narrative source text.
Week 6: joint
construction
In thisweek,weshifted our rolefrom authoritative figurestofacilitatorsand
cooperated with our students to summarize Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s
Stone. To begin with, we asked each student to contribute one sentence in
turn to compose the story while typing and projecting these sentences on to
a large computer screen for later discussion (drafting). Next, we reviewed
the generic structure of a narration and invited the students to comment on
global content and organization of the summary. They deleted redundant
information, added more details to the major events, and sequenced these
events in a correct time order (revising). Then, we encouraged our students
to check the spelling, punctuation, and grammatical errors. With our
A genre-based approach to teaching EFL summary writing 187
at
Fudan
University
on
March
25,
2012
http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/
Downloaded
from
5. assistance, they tried to use cohesive devices to mark shifts in events and to
modify the words to convey the intended meaning more precisely (editing).
Finally, the students completed the summary with a total of 435 words
(publishing).
Week 7: independent
construction
In the seventh week, we asked each student to again write a summary with
a maximum of 500 words about The Adventures of Tom Sawyer. The students
wrote the summaries independently within the two hours of class time.
They were allowed to consult the reader, if necessary, but prohibited from
referring to theirfirst draft produced in Week 2 and, most importantly, from
directlycopying words, phrases, orsentences from the book. The purpose of
this stage was to give the students an opportunity to practise their writing
skills and demonstrate their understanding of the summary of a narrative
genre.
After the instruction, the summaries collected on the pre- and post-tests
were assessed. A blind assessment mechanism was adopted so that any
identifying information, i.e. students’ names and numbers along with time
of production, was removed and the summaries were shuffled and
renumbered in a consistent way known only to our assistant to avoid
a possible bias against particular students. All the summaries produced by
the students were evaluated by the authors against rating scales adapted
from the ESL Composition Profile (Jacobs, Zinkgraf, Wormuth, Hartfiel,
and Hughey 1981):
Content Is there a clear understanding of the story?Are major and
minor points of the story distinguished?Does all
information (i.e. setting, initiating event, internal
response, attempt, consequence, and reaction) convey
a sense of completeness?
Organization Are there effective introductory, body, and concluding
paragraphs?
Is there a topic sentence and are there supporting details
in each paragraph?
Is the overall relationship of ideas between paragraphs
clearly indicated?
Vocabulary Is the choice of vocabulary accurate and effective enough
to convey the intended message?
Is there appropriate use of transitional markers between
ideas?
Language use Are the grammatical features (for example agreement,
tense, number, prepositions) correctly used?
Are the sentence constructions well-formed and
sufficiently varied to express the intended information?
On the rating scales, each component has 25 points, making a total of 100
points. The weight for each component is further broken down into
numerical ranges that correspond to four ability levels: ‘excellent to very
good’ (21–25 points), ‘good to average’ (16–20 points), ‘fair to poor’ (11–15
points), and ‘very poor’ (6–10 points). To ensure higher interrating
reliability, we first assessed two student samples and discussed the
188 Yuan-Shan Chen and Shao-Wen Su
at
Fudan
University
on
March
25,
2012
http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/
Downloaded
from
6. outcomes until a consensus on the rating was reached. During the actual
rating, we determined each component score within the range of
a particular ability level that best described a given work. The final score for
each component in each student work was the average of the two raters’
scores.Ifwediffered bymorethantenpointsinthetotalscores,wereviewed
the criteria again and discussed the differences until we reached close
agreement. Finally, we calculated the interrater reliability and ran statistical
analyses to examine if the students made any progress after the instruction.
In addition to student performance, we conducted a focus group interview
after the instruction with six volunteers recruited from the 41 students in
order to understand their perceptions of the summarization task before and
after the instruction. Considering the students’ linguistic proficiency, the
interview was conducted primarily in Chinese, with a little English. The
entire session lasted one hour. After that, the assistant helped transcribe
verbatim the video-taped protocol.
Results and
discussion
The Pearson Product–Moment Correlation analysis showed that the
interrater reliability coefficients were 0.85 on the pre-test and 0.88 on the
post-test, respectively. These values seem satisfactory since Politt (1991)
suggests that an interrater agreement value of 0.8 is adequate for a writing
test.
By means of paired sample t-test, a comparison of the overall score and
scores on each component pre- and post-instruction shows significant
overall improvement in the four components, while significance levels vary
from component to component, as presented in Table 1. The statistics
indicate that the score gains reached a significance level of P , 0.01, which
suggeststhat the genre-based approach had a positive effect on the students’
overall summarization performance where students made significant
progress in all four of the components investigated. However, the students
improved to a greater extent in content and organization than in vocabulary
and language use. The improvements in content and organization reached
significance levels of P , 0.01 (t ¼ –30.34, t ¼ –14.52), with the mean scores
rising by 5.39 and 4.7, respectively. The improvements in vocabulary and
language use, however, reached significance levels of P , 0.05 (t ¼ –2.04,
t ¼ –2.39), with the mean scores rising by only 0.17 and 0.16, respectively.
The pairwise comparisons have clearly shown that the students benefited
the greatest from the genre-based instruction in the aspect of content,
closely followed by organization, among all the four components.
Components Mean SD t df Significance (two tailed)
Pre Post Pre Post
Content 12.76 18.15 1.41 1.82 –30.34 40 0.000**
Organization 9.76 14.46 3.65 3.49 –14.52 40 0.000**
Vocabulary 9.80 9.97 2.79 2.69 –2.04 40 0.048*
Language use 10.46 10.62 3.36 3.36 –2.39 40 0.022*
Overall 42.78 53.13 7.25 7.21 –27.93 40 0.000**
table 1
Pre- and post-instruction
component scores
*P , 0.05; **P , 0.01.
A genre-based approach to teaching EFL summary writing 189
at
Fudan
University
on
March
25,
2012
http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/
Downloaded
from
7. The improvements in content and organization on the post-test could be
attributed to the focus of the instruction. During the treatment, we spent
alargeportionofclasstimediscussingthecharactersandeventsinthestory,
distinguishing the major and minor points of the story, analysing the
rhetorical structure of a narration, and incorporating the story grammar
features into introductory, body, and concluding paragraphs. In addition to
the statistical results, the student progress in these two components can be
further verified by analysing their summaries and interview comments. We
found that the students’ summaries produced on the pre-test indicated
unclear story lines with many digressions from the major events, as shown
in the following example:
. . . Tom didn’t like to go to school, but like adventures. He often go to do
excited things with his friend Huck. Huck has a violent father and always
gotdrunk.NobodylikedHuck.Hewasalwaysdirty.WhenTomand Huck
visitthegraveinthenight,theyseeInjunJoekillthedoctorbyaccident.At
first theyswearnottotellthetruth,butTomdoesnot careabout the honor
and his dangerous. He still insisted on appearing in court as a witness . . .
(Eva)
In this excerpt, the student writer digressed from Tom’s adventure and
begantodescribeindetailhisfriendHuck,whoinfactplaysalessimportant
role in the story. Such digressions could have been caused by the common
belief prior to the instruction that summary writing involved recalling
everything in the source text and writing it down in a shorter version, as
reportedbyfiveoutofthesixstudentsintheinterview.Thisexplainswhythe
students did poorly on the pre-test since they did not recognize the
importance of distinguishing between major and minor events in the story,
not to mention highlighting the major and setting the minor ones as
background information in their summaries.
After the instruction, the students were found to structure their summaries
more effectively. On the post-test, the majority of the students summarized
the story by focusing on the major events: how Tom and his friend Huck
become witnesses of Injun Joe’s killing of Doctor Robinson and imputing
the crime to Muff Potter getting very drunk in the graveyard (initiating
event), how Tom struggles in his heart whether to tell the truth that Injun
Joe, rather than Muff Potter, is the real murderer (internal response), how
Tom plucks up the courage to testify for Muff Potter at the trial (attempt),
how Injun Joe escapes from the court, hides treasure under the cross in
a cave, and later dies in the cave (consequence), and how Tom and Huck
decide to find the treasure after Injun Joes is dead and become the richest
people in St Petersburg (reaction).
When it comes to vocabulary and language use, the slight improvements in
these two components could have been a result of insufficient instructional
time spent on developing the students’ linguistic proficiency. As Ortega
(2003) argues, it generally takes up to 12 months of instruction to develop
college students’ vocabulary complexity and grammatical accuracy.
Therefore, even though we discussed the use of time adverbs, past time
clauses,timeconnectors,andwordusageinclass,thestudentsdidnotmake
as much progress in vocabulary and language use as they did in content and
organization. Although the total number of errors made by the students
190 Yuan-Shan Chen and Shao-Wen Su
at
Fudan
University
on
March
25,
2012
http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/
Downloaded
from
8. decreased from 586 on the pre-test to 551 on the post-test, the major sources
of errors on these two occasions were very similar, including verb tense
inconsistency (for example ‘Tom and Huck appeared in court and testify
against Injun Joe.’), wrong word forms (for example ‘Tom became wealth
after he found the treasure.’), and sentence fragments (for example
‘Because Tom did not want to go to school.’). Table 2 shows the raw
frequencies and percentages of different error types:
Errors Verb tense (%) Word forms (%) Fragments (%) Others (%) Total (%)
Pre-test 251 (42.83) 222 (37.88) 70 (11.95) 43 (7.34) 586 (100)
Post-test 214 (38.84) 225 (40.83) 83 (15.07) 29 (5.26) 551 (100)
table 2
Raw frequencies and
percentages of pre- and
post-instruction
component errors
Our interview data also echo what the statistical results have shown that
the areas of vocabulary and language use were still the two biggest obstacles
for students to surmount when constructing the summaries on the
post-test. For example, the translated interview comment made by Peter
indicates,
I think I learned a lot from this class . . . What I liked most about the
instruction was the paragraphing which featured story grammar
elements. Now I know what is a summary and how to write it better . . .
But I still found it difficult to express what I intended to say. Finding the
appropriate word was hard, and I often struggled with my grammar . . .
That’s my biggest problem.
One might not find Peter’s recount of failing to master vocabulary and
language use surprising. As it takes longer for students to develop language
proficiency, it would be impractical to expect them to make much progress
within a seven-week period.
Conclusion This empirical study contributes to a genre-based approach to teaching EFL
writing, while proving it to be a feasible and effective model to enhance
students’ summarization performanceof a narrative sourcetext. During the
instruction, we introduced an explicit genre template and used guided
practice to scaffold our students’ understanding. We also introduced the
lexical and grammatical patterns that were directly relevant to this genre
type. Then we helped the students learn more effectively through
collaborative work and gradually removed support to foster their growth as
independent writers.
This study reveals that such an approach enhances L2 learners’ writing
abilities in content, organization,vocabulary, and language use.Moreover, it
confers more benefits to the students in terms of content development and
rhetorical organization than linguistic accuracy and lexical diversity. When
generalizing the findings of the present study, however, one should use
caution since assessment tools and genre types are crucial variables that
may lead to different results. With the genre-based approach in vogue in L2
writing instruction, it is suggested that greater efforts be put forward by
practitioner-researchers with an interest in teaching EFL writing to
investigate the strengths and weaknesses of genre-based instruction in
A genre-based approach to teaching EFL summary writing 191
at
Fudan
University
on
March
25,
2012
http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/
Downloaded
from
9. order to probe further into how to maximize the effectiveness of this
kind of instruction.
Final revised version received June 2011
References
Casazza, M. E. 1993. ‘Using a model of direct
instruction to teach summary writing in a college
reading class’. Journal of Reading 37/3: 202–8.
Cheng, F. W. 2008. ‘Scaffolding language,
scaffolding writing: a genre approach to teaching
narrative writing’. Asian EFL Journal 10/2: 167–91.
Halliday, M. A. K. 1994. An Introduction to
Functional Grammar. (Second edition). London:
Edward Arnold.
Hyland,K.2007.‘Genrepedagogy:language,literacy
and L2 writing instruction’. Journal of Second
Language Writing 16/3: 148–64.
Irwin, J. 1986. Teaching Reading Comprehension
Processes. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Jacobs, H. J., S. A. Zinkgraf, D. R. Wormuth, V. F.
Hartfiel, and J. B. Hughey. 1981. Testing ESL
Composition: A Practical Approach. Rowley, MA:
Newbury House.
Keck, C. 2006. ‘The use of paraphrase in summary
writing: a comparisonofL1and L2writers’.Journal of
Second Language Writing 15/4: 261–78.
Kongpetch, S. 2006. ‘Using a genre-based approach
to teach writing to Thai students: a case study’.
Prospect 21/2: 3–33.
Krashen, S. D. 1984. Writing: Research, Theory, and
Application. Oxford: Pergamon.
Ortega, L. 2003. ‘Syntactic complexity measures and
their relationship to L2 proficiency: a research
synthesis of college-level L2 writing’. Applied
Linguistics 24/4: 492–518.
Politt, A. 1991. ‘Giving students a sporting chance:
assessment by counting and by judging’ in
C. Alderson and B. North (eds.). Language Testing in
the 1990s. London: Macmillan.
Sidaway, R. 2006. ‘The genre-based approach to
teach writing’. In English! Spring issue: 24–7.
Available at http://www.britishcouncil.org/portugal-
ie2006s-richard-sidaway.pdf(accessed inMay2011).
Stein, N. L. and C. G. Glenn. 1979. ‘An analysis of
story comprehension in elementary school children’
in R. Freedle (ed.). Multidisciplinary Approaches to
Discourse Comprehension. Hillsdale, NJ: Ablex.
Widodo, H. P. 2006. ‘Designing a genre-based
lesson plan for an academic writing course’. English
Teaching: Practice and Critique 5/3: 173–99.
Yu, G. 2009. ‘The shifting sands in the effects of
source text summarizability on summary writing’.
Assessing Writing 14/2: 116–37.
The authors
Yuan-Shan Chen has been involved in language
teaching for many years. She received her PhD in
TESOL from National Taiwan Normal University.
Her research interests primarily lie in the areas of
interlanguage pragmatics and L2 writing research.
She teaches as an associate professor at the
Department of Applied English, National Chin-Yi
University of Technology, Taiwan.
Email: yuanshan@ncut.edu.tw
Shao-Wen Su received her PhD degree in Education
from the University of Newcastle, Australia, an MA
in English Literature and Language, and a BA in
Foreign Literature and Languages, Taiwan. She has
published mainly in the areas of English writing,
English literature, and ESP instructions as well as
curriculum design and evaluation. She teaches as an
associate professor at the Department of Applied
English, National Chin-Yi University of Technology,
Taiwan.
Email: shaowen@ncut.edu.tw
192 Yuan-Shan Chen and Shao-Wen Su
at
Fudan
University
on
March
25,
2012
http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/
Downloaded
from