SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Statistical Issues of Meta-Analysis Practices  in Drug-Eluting Stent Data Hsini Terry Liao, PhD  Boston Scientific Corporation Contact: terry.liao@bsci.com Presented to Joint Statistical Meetings  August 5, 2010
Outlines ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Motivation ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Systematic Reviews ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Statistical Issues in Practices ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Fixed vs. Random Effects ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Fixed vs. Random Effects (Cont’d) Weights Comparison ,[object Object],[object Object]
Randomized vs. observational studies ,[object Object],[object Object]
RCT vs. Registry * H2H: PES vs. Olimus by RCTs and Registries (Paper in Progress)
Measures of Heterogeneity ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Forest Plots Also Important! ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],1 1 2 2 0.5 0.5
Covariates Adjustment ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Meta-regression in DES Data ,[object Object],0 6 12 18 24 30 36 42 48 54 60
Measures of Effect Sizes ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Comparison of  Odds vs. Risk 5.0 4.0 3.0 2.0 1.0 0.0
Strategies for Zero Events ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Simulation (Unstra : DisZero : Correct) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Biasness
True Treatment Effect Coverage
Statistical Posterior Power
Time-to-Event  Kaplan-Meier Curves ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Final Thoughts ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
References ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

More Related Content

What's hot

Metaanalysis copy
Metaanalysis    copyMetaanalysis    copy
Metaanalysis copy
Amandeep Kaur
 
Intent-to-Treat (ITT) Analysis in Randomized Clinical Trials
Intent-to-Treat (ITT) Analysis in Randomized Clinical TrialsIntent-to-Treat (ITT) Analysis in Randomized Clinical Trials
Intent-to-Treat (ITT) Analysis in Randomized Clinical Trials
Mike LaValley
 
演講-Meta analysis in medical research-張偉豪
演講-Meta analysis in medical research-張偉豪演講-Meta analysis in medical research-張偉豪
演講-Meta analysis in medical research-張偉豪
Beckett Hsieh
 
Statistics in meta analysis
Statistics in meta analysisStatistics in meta analysis
Statistics in meta analysis
Dr Shri Sangle
 
Meta analysis
Meta analysisMeta analysis
Meta analysis
Bhaswat Chakraborty
 
2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session1_salanti
2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session1_salanti2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session1_salanti
2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session1_salanti
rgveroniki
 
2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session4_harbord
2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session4_harbord2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session4_harbord
2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session4_harbord
rgveroniki
 
Meta analysis
Meta analysisMeta analysis
Meta analysis
Dinesh Chaurasiya
 
META ANALYSIS
META ANALYSISMETA ANALYSIS
META ANALYSIS
MAHESWARI JAIKUMAR
 
Network meta-analysis & models for inconsistency
Network meta-analysis & models for inconsistencyNetwork meta-analysis & models for inconsistency
Network meta-analysis & models for inconsistency
cheweb1
 
2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session3_higgins
2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session3_higgins2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session3_higgins
2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session3_higgins
rgveroniki
 
Meta analysis: Mega-silly or mega-useful?
Meta analysis: Mega-silly or mega-useful?Meta analysis: Mega-silly or mega-useful?
Meta analysis: Mega-silly or mega-useful?
Daniel Quintana
 
Meta analysis ppt
Meta analysis pptMeta analysis ppt
Meta analysis ppt
SKVA
 
Biostatistics in cancer RCTs
Biostatistics in cancer RCTsBiostatistics in cancer RCTs
Biostatistics in cancer RCTs
Bhaswat Chakraborty
 
Baker esni handouts slides
Baker esni handouts slidesBaker esni handouts slides
Baker esni handouts slides
BartsMSBlog
 
Inferential statistics
Inferential statisticsInferential statistics
Inferential statistics
Ashok Kulkarni
 
Meta analysis
Meta analysisMeta analysis
Meta analysis
Vishal Ramteke
 
2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session2_dias
2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session2_dias2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session2_dias
2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session2_dias
rgveroniki
 
Choosing statistical tests
Choosing statistical testsChoosing statistical tests
Choosing statistical tests
Akiode Noah
 
Repeated events analyses
Repeated events analysesRepeated events analyses
Repeated events analyses
Mike LaValley
 

What's hot (20)

Metaanalysis copy
Metaanalysis    copyMetaanalysis    copy
Metaanalysis copy
 
Intent-to-Treat (ITT) Analysis in Randomized Clinical Trials
Intent-to-Treat (ITT) Analysis in Randomized Clinical TrialsIntent-to-Treat (ITT) Analysis in Randomized Clinical Trials
Intent-to-Treat (ITT) Analysis in Randomized Clinical Trials
 
演講-Meta analysis in medical research-張偉豪
演講-Meta analysis in medical research-張偉豪演講-Meta analysis in medical research-張偉豪
演講-Meta analysis in medical research-張偉豪
 
Statistics in meta analysis
Statistics in meta analysisStatistics in meta analysis
Statistics in meta analysis
 
Meta analysis
Meta analysisMeta analysis
Meta analysis
 
2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session1_salanti
2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session1_salanti2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session1_salanti
2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session1_salanti
 
2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session4_harbord
2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session4_harbord2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session4_harbord
2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session4_harbord
 
Meta analysis
Meta analysisMeta analysis
Meta analysis
 
META ANALYSIS
META ANALYSISMETA ANALYSIS
META ANALYSIS
 
Network meta-analysis & models for inconsistency
Network meta-analysis & models for inconsistencyNetwork meta-analysis & models for inconsistency
Network meta-analysis & models for inconsistency
 
2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session3_higgins
2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session3_higgins2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session3_higgins
2010 smg training_cardiff_day1_session3_higgins
 
Meta analysis: Mega-silly or mega-useful?
Meta analysis: Mega-silly or mega-useful?Meta analysis: Mega-silly or mega-useful?
Meta analysis: Mega-silly or mega-useful?
 
Meta analysis ppt
Meta analysis pptMeta analysis ppt
Meta analysis ppt
 
Biostatistics in cancer RCTs
Biostatistics in cancer RCTsBiostatistics in cancer RCTs
Biostatistics in cancer RCTs
 
Baker esni handouts slides
Baker esni handouts slidesBaker esni handouts slides
Baker esni handouts slides
 
Inferential statistics
Inferential statisticsInferential statistics
Inferential statistics
 
Meta analysis
Meta analysisMeta analysis
Meta analysis
 
2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session2_dias
2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session2_dias2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session2_dias
2010 smg training_cardiff_day2_session2_dias
 
Choosing statistical tests
Choosing statistical testsChoosing statistical tests
Choosing statistical tests
 
Repeated events analyses
Repeated events analysesRepeated events analyses
Repeated events analyses
 

Similar to 2010 JSM - Meta Stat Issue Medical Devices

Analytic Methods and Issues in CER from Observational Data
Analytic Methods and Issues in CER from Observational DataAnalytic Methods and Issues in CER from Observational Data
Analytic Methods and Issues in CER from Observational Data
CTSI at UCSF
 
The SPSS-effect on medical research
The SPSS-effect on medical researchThe SPSS-effect on medical research
The SPSS-effect on medical research
Jonas Ranstam PhD
 
Copenhagen 2008
Copenhagen 2008Copenhagen 2008
Copenhagen 2008
Jonas Ranstam PhD
 
Quantitative Synthesis I
Quantitative Synthesis IQuantitative Synthesis I
Quantitative Synthesis I
Effective Health Care Program
 
Biostatistics clinical research & trials
Biostatistics clinical research & trialsBiostatistics clinical research & trials
Biostatistics clinical research & trials
eclinicaltools
 
PMED: APPM Workshop: Overview of Methods for Subgroup Identification in Clini...
PMED: APPM Workshop: Overview of Methods for Subgroup Identification in Clini...PMED: APPM Workshop: Overview of Methods for Subgroup Identification in Clini...
PMED: APPM Workshop: Overview of Methods for Subgroup Identification in Clini...
The Statistical and Applied Mathematical Sciences Institute
 
Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...
Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...
Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...
cambridgeWD
 
Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...
Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...
Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...
cambridgeWD
 
Copenhagen 23.10.2008
Copenhagen 23.10.2008Copenhagen 23.10.2008
Copenhagen 23.10.2008
Jonas Ranstam PhD
 
Nuts & Bolts of Systematic Reviews, Meta-analyses & Network Meta-analyses
Nuts & Bolts of Systematic Reviews, Meta-analyses & Network Meta-analysesNuts & Bolts of Systematic Reviews, Meta-analyses & Network Meta-analyses
Nuts & Bolts of Systematic Reviews, Meta-analyses & Network Meta-analyses
OARSI
 
Test of significance
Test of significanceTest of significance
Test of significance
Dr Bushra Jabeen
 
PS.Observational.SAS_Y.Duan
PS.Observational.SAS_Y.DuanPS.Observational.SAS_Y.Duan
PS.Observational.SAS_Y.Duan
"Yinghui "Delian"" Duan, PhD, MS
 
Quantitative Synthesis I Quiz
Quantitative Synthesis I QuizQuantitative Synthesis I Quiz
Quantitative Synthesis I Quiz
Effective Health Care Program
 
Practical Methods To Overcome Sample Size Challenges
Practical Methods To Overcome Sample Size ChallengesPractical Methods To Overcome Sample Size Challenges
Practical Methods To Overcome Sample Size Challenges
nQuery
 
UAB Pulmonary board review study design and statistical principles
UAB Pulmonary board review study  design and statistical principles UAB Pulmonary board review study  design and statistical principles
UAB Pulmonary board review study design and statistical principles
Terry Shaneyfelt
 
Choosing appropriate statistical test RSS6 2104
Choosing appropriate statistical test RSS6 2104Choosing appropriate statistical test RSS6 2104
Choosing appropriate statistical test RSS6 2104
RSS6
 
Non Parametric Tests
Non Parametric TestsNon Parametric Tests
Non Parametric Tests
Zarrin Ansari
 
2014-10-22 EUGM | WEI | Moving Beyond the Comfort Zone in Practicing Translat...
2014-10-22 EUGM | WEI | Moving Beyond the Comfort Zone in Practicing Translat...2014-10-22 EUGM | WEI | Moving Beyond the Comfort Zone in Practicing Translat...
2014-10-22 EUGM | WEI | Moving Beyond the Comfort Zone in Practicing Translat...
Cytel USA
 
Measurement and Modeling Issues with Adherence to Pharmacotherapy
Measurement and Modeling Issues with Adherence to PharmacotherapyMeasurement and Modeling Issues with Adherence to Pharmacotherapy
Measurement and Modeling Issues with Adherence to Pharmacotherapy
M. Christopher Roebuck
 
Clinical trial bms clinical trials methodology 17012018
Clinical trial bms   clinical trials methodology 17012018Clinical trial bms   clinical trials methodology 17012018
Clinical trial bms clinical trials methodology 17012018
SoM
 

Similar to 2010 JSM - Meta Stat Issue Medical Devices (20)

Analytic Methods and Issues in CER from Observational Data
Analytic Methods and Issues in CER from Observational DataAnalytic Methods and Issues in CER from Observational Data
Analytic Methods and Issues in CER from Observational Data
 
The SPSS-effect on medical research
The SPSS-effect on medical researchThe SPSS-effect on medical research
The SPSS-effect on medical research
 
Copenhagen 2008
Copenhagen 2008Copenhagen 2008
Copenhagen 2008
 
Quantitative Synthesis I
Quantitative Synthesis IQuantitative Synthesis I
Quantitative Synthesis I
 
Biostatistics clinical research & trials
Biostatistics clinical research & trialsBiostatistics clinical research & trials
Biostatistics clinical research & trials
 
PMED: APPM Workshop: Overview of Methods for Subgroup Identification in Clini...
PMED: APPM Workshop: Overview of Methods for Subgroup Identification in Clini...PMED: APPM Workshop: Overview of Methods for Subgroup Identification in Clini...
PMED: APPM Workshop: Overview of Methods for Subgroup Identification in Clini...
 
Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...
Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...
Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...
 
Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...
Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...
Clinical Trials Versus Health Outcomes Research: SAS/STAT Versus SAS Enterpri...
 
Copenhagen 23.10.2008
Copenhagen 23.10.2008Copenhagen 23.10.2008
Copenhagen 23.10.2008
 
Nuts & Bolts of Systematic Reviews, Meta-analyses & Network Meta-analyses
Nuts & Bolts of Systematic Reviews, Meta-analyses & Network Meta-analysesNuts & Bolts of Systematic Reviews, Meta-analyses & Network Meta-analyses
Nuts & Bolts of Systematic Reviews, Meta-analyses & Network Meta-analyses
 
Test of significance
Test of significanceTest of significance
Test of significance
 
PS.Observational.SAS_Y.Duan
PS.Observational.SAS_Y.DuanPS.Observational.SAS_Y.Duan
PS.Observational.SAS_Y.Duan
 
Quantitative Synthesis I Quiz
Quantitative Synthesis I QuizQuantitative Synthesis I Quiz
Quantitative Synthesis I Quiz
 
Practical Methods To Overcome Sample Size Challenges
Practical Methods To Overcome Sample Size ChallengesPractical Methods To Overcome Sample Size Challenges
Practical Methods To Overcome Sample Size Challenges
 
UAB Pulmonary board review study design and statistical principles
UAB Pulmonary board review study  design and statistical principles UAB Pulmonary board review study  design and statistical principles
UAB Pulmonary board review study design and statistical principles
 
Choosing appropriate statistical test RSS6 2104
Choosing appropriate statistical test RSS6 2104Choosing appropriate statistical test RSS6 2104
Choosing appropriate statistical test RSS6 2104
 
Non Parametric Tests
Non Parametric TestsNon Parametric Tests
Non Parametric Tests
 
2014-10-22 EUGM | WEI | Moving Beyond the Comfort Zone in Practicing Translat...
2014-10-22 EUGM | WEI | Moving Beyond the Comfort Zone in Practicing Translat...2014-10-22 EUGM | WEI | Moving Beyond the Comfort Zone in Practicing Translat...
2014-10-22 EUGM | WEI | Moving Beyond the Comfort Zone in Practicing Translat...
 
Measurement and Modeling Issues with Adherence to Pharmacotherapy
Measurement and Modeling Issues with Adherence to PharmacotherapyMeasurement and Modeling Issues with Adherence to Pharmacotherapy
Measurement and Modeling Issues with Adherence to Pharmacotherapy
 
Clinical trial bms clinical trials methodology 17012018
Clinical trial bms   clinical trials methodology 17012018Clinical trial bms   clinical trials methodology 17012018
Clinical trial bms clinical trials methodology 17012018
 

More from Terry Liao

2011 JSM - Meta Rare Event Performance Goal in Medical Device Studies
2011 JSM - Meta Rare Event Performance Goal in Medical Device Studies2011 JSM - Meta Rare Event Performance Goal in Medical Device Studies
2011 JSM - Meta Rare Event Performance Goal in Medical Device Studies
Terry Liao
 
2011 JSM - Good Statistical Practices
2011 JSM - Good Statistical Practices2011 JSM - Good Statistical Practices
2011 JSM - Good Statistical Practices
Terry Liao
 
2010 FDA/Industry Statistics Workshop
2010 FDA/Industry Statistics Workshop2010 FDA/Industry Statistics Workshop
2010 FDA/Industry Statistics Workshop
Terry Liao
 
2010 ACC i2 Summit
2010 ACC i2 Summit2010 ACC i2 Summit
2010 ACC i2 Summit
Terry Liao
 
2009 JSM - Meta Time to Event Data
2009 JSM - Meta Time to Event Data2009 JSM - Meta Time to Event Data
2009 JSM - Meta Time to Event Data
Terry Liao
 
2008 JSM - Meta Study Data vs Patient Data
2008 JSM - Meta Study Data vs Patient Data2008 JSM - Meta Study Data vs Patient Data
2008 JSM - Meta Study Data vs Patient Data
Terry Liao
 

More from Terry Liao (6)

2011 JSM - Meta Rare Event Performance Goal in Medical Device Studies
2011 JSM - Meta Rare Event Performance Goal in Medical Device Studies2011 JSM - Meta Rare Event Performance Goal in Medical Device Studies
2011 JSM - Meta Rare Event Performance Goal in Medical Device Studies
 
2011 JSM - Good Statistical Practices
2011 JSM - Good Statistical Practices2011 JSM - Good Statistical Practices
2011 JSM - Good Statistical Practices
 
2010 FDA/Industry Statistics Workshop
2010 FDA/Industry Statistics Workshop2010 FDA/Industry Statistics Workshop
2010 FDA/Industry Statistics Workshop
 
2010 ACC i2 Summit
2010 ACC i2 Summit2010 ACC i2 Summit
2010 ACC i2 Summit
 
2009 JSM - Meta Time to Event Data
2009 JSM - Meta Time to Event Data2009 JSM - Meta Time to Event Data
2009 JSM - Meta Time to Event Data
 
2008 JSM - Meta Study Data vs Patient Data
2008 JSM - Meta Study Data vs Patient Data2008 JSM - Meta Study Data vs Patient Data
2008 JSM - Meta Study Data vs Patient Data
 

2010 JSM - Meta Stat Issue Medical Devices