The changes that take place in India after the areas administered by the East India Company are assumed by the Crown. The army is restructured in an attempt to prevent future mutinies. A series of famines occurs and question arise about how to prevent or lessen their impact.
4. Victims of the Rebellion
• 2,392 recorded British soldiers
• 1000 to 1500 civilians
• Unknown number of Anglo-Indians, Christian
Indians, Indians who worked for the British
• 8,000 sepoys by one estimate
5. Fate of Bengal Regiments
Outcome
Mutinied 48
Disarmed or dispersed 23
Loyal 3
Loyal portions of regiments that were disbanded
or mutinied were joined into new regiments.
The 66th Goorkha Regiment became the 1st Goorkha
Regiment which survives as the 1 Gorkha Rifles of the
Indian Army.
6. Other areas
Madras
– One regiment refused to serve in Bengal
– No mutinies
Bombay
– Three regiments mutiny
7. Blame the Company
Sir Colin is Colin Campbell,
noted for the relief of the
British in Lucknow
An accompanying poem
blames the clerks of the
Company for interfering
with his campaign.
8. East India Company
Victim of the Rebellion
1858 Government of India act
– Territories in India to be vested in the Queen
– Secretary of State for India with 15 member council
– Crown appoints Governor-general
– Set up a civil service
– All property of the EIC transferred to the Crown
1873 Dissolution of the Company
9. Government of India Act 1858
• Single chain of command in Army
• Commitment to public works
• Restrict the powers and composition of the new
advisory Council of India
• New Secretary of State for India
– Governor-General (Viceroy)
10. Crown Prerogatives
• Crown to see all dispatches
relating to India
• All government proclamations in
India be made in Victoria's name
Punch, September 11, 1858
11. Victoria’s Proclamation
• Respect for treaties with local princes
• No extension of territories
• Equal protection of all religions
• Positions open to all qualified subjects
• Regard for customary land rights
• Clemency to all except those who killed British
• Promote Works of Public Utility and Improvement
13. The Most Exalted Order of the Star of
India
• Knighthood for Indian
princes and British
administrators in India
• Founded 1861 by
Victoria
– Include:
– Prince Albert
– Prince of Wales
14. Changes in Emphasis: Canals
• Before 1857
– Protect revenue producing lands
– Irrigation
• After 1857
– Transport
15. New India Army
• Retain separate Presidency armies under
Commander-in-Chief of Bengal Army
• Integrate European infantry into Royal Army
• Separate frontier forces
– Sindh Frontier Force: Punjab Frontier Force
• “Bombay system” [next week]
16. Composition of Infantry
Bengal Madras Bombay Other Total
1857
British 37,000
Native 112,100 42,400 33,900 198.400
1863
British 65,000
Native 49,000 34,000 29,000 28,000 140,000
Distribution estimated
1859 Peel report recommends 2:1 native to British in Bengal; 3:1 elsewhere
17. ‘White Mutiny’ in the European Army
• Sign on a wash house wall
"John Company is dead. We will not soldier fοr the
Queen.”
• Units at Dinapur mutiny
– Ringleader executed
– Others offered discharge
• May 24, 1859 Madras Fusiliers refuse to cheer on
Queen’s birthday
18. White mutineers
• Out of ~16,000
– 10,116 men returned home
– 2,809 re-enlisted in England
20. Rail System
1871
1850s: Connect ports
To 1869: Private firms with
public guarantees
1869 Some government
construction
After 1880 Government
ownership
22. 1881 India Factory Act
This act applied to factories using mechanical
powers, employing not less than 100 workers and
working for not more than 4 months in a year
• Prohibits employment of Children below 7 years
was prohibited
• Children, age of 7 to 12, limited to 9 hours/ day.
• Mid-day meal interval, four holidays/ month and
fencing of machinery in the factory also required.
24. India: Agriculture, Late 19th century
• Overall India produced a surplus of food
• Agrarian economy could be characterized as a
non-monetized exchange economy.
• For a large part of the population, food supply
depended on employment
• Crop failures were local
Ghose, Ajit Kumar. "Food supply and starvation: a study of famines with
reference to the Indian sub-continent." Oxford Economic Papers 34.2
(1982): 368-389
25. 1866 Orissa Famine
"Such visitations of providence as these no
government can do much either to prevent or
alleviate,"
“If I were to attempt to do this [regulate prices in
violation of the laws of economics] I should
consider myself no better than a dacoit or thief.”
Cecil Beacon, Governor of Bengal
26. Famine Relief − Orissa
Response
• Reduce taxes and military
spending
• Reject irrigation projects
Late response
• Import 10,000 tons of rice
• Import 40,000 tons in
anticipation of 1867
– Half unused
Results
• 4 to 5 million deaths in a
population of 47 million
• Cost 9.5 million rupees
28. Bihar (and Bengal) Famine of 1873-4
• Sir Richard Temple imports rice from
Burma
• Work made available to build roads and
in Burma to build a railroad
• More rice imported than is needed
• Temple is criticized for his excess
expenditure. Leads to future caution
• Government of India accuses Madras of
doing too much.
29. Great Famine of 1876–78
• (also the Southern India famine of 1876–78 or
the Madras famine of 1877)
• Affected area 670,000 square kilometres
(257,000 sq mi)
• 5.5 million deaths out of population of 58.5
million
30. Drought and its Consequences
• Madras rainfall
– Average 27,6 inches
– 1876 rainfall 6.3 inches
• Many areas unaffected
• Overall effect
– Lack of money
– Lack of work
– Not lack of food
33. Relief camps
• Workers given “Temple wage”
– A pound of grain plus one anna (1/16 of a rupee)
(1 ¼ d)
• Later increased by efforts of Dr. Cornish to 1 ½
pound supplemented by protein
34. India’s Nero
• Weeklong feast for 68,000
officials and maharajas to
celebrate the newly
acclaimed Empress of India
• 100,000 peasants die in the
period according to a British
journalist
Lord Edward Robert
Bulwer-Lytton
35. Relief
• Relief in India 2% of amount spent on poor in Britain
• Work camps but strict rules for relief
– Strikes
– Should relief be given to men who refused to work?
“We say that human life shall be saved at any cost and
effort’; and íf ít is asked what ‘the general principles are by
which the District officers should be guided in refusing the
aid needed to preserve life, the reply must be that there
are no such principles, and that there are no circumstances
¡n which such aid can be refused.”
36. Effects
• About 5.5 million deaths
• Two phases
I. Main causes of death were cholera, dysentery and
smallpox triggered by migration, unsanitary
conditions and close contact in camps and relief
works, and consumption of decayed foods.
II. Malaria on return of monsoons
37. Monthly total of deaths by cause, Madras 1876–8.
Source: Annual Reports of the Sanitary Commissioner of Madras, 1876–8
39. Some views in official London
"[E]very benevolent attempt made to mitigate the
effects of famine and defective sanitation serves but to
enhance the evils resulting from overpopulation”
Sir Evelyn Baring, finance minister
“80% of the famine mortality were drawn from the
poorest 20% of the population …. Thus, if the
government spent more of its revenue on famine relief,
an even larger proportion of the population would
become penurious.”
1881 Report
40. Famine Commission
• Examine roles of
– Early provision of relief employment
– Irrigation
– Transport and communications
– Improvement in agriculture
• Conclusion in dissent
“The complete break-down that occurred in the last famine
was but a repetition, on a larger scale, of the failure which
has characterized the administration of every Indian famine
in this century, with the single exception of that in 1874.”
41. English Ideologies
• Laissez-Faire economics
• Malthusian population theory
• Social Darwinism
• Fear of the slippery slope of welfare dependence
Adopted by some
contemporary
Indian sources.
42. Principles for relief
• Employment for able-bodied at sufficient wages
• ‘Gratuitous relief’ to those unable to work
• Landowners: Suspension of land taxes
• Need to have a surplus in good years of
£1,500,000 to prepare for the inevitable
reoccurrence of famines and £500,000 for other
contingencies
43. Recommendations
• Famine Insurance Fund
• Budget of 500,000 pounds for railway
construction and general public works. 250,000
pounds for irrigation projects
• Strengthen department of meteorology
• Storage (but caution about spoilage)
• Famine code for uniformity
44. Famine Code of 1883
• Subsequent codes of 1897 and 1900,
• Public policy for
(1) the transportation of grain to areas under famine
conditions, provision of food in exchange for work
relief to the able-bodied;
(2) Guidelines for famine relief;
(3) The construction of protective railways, and
(4) the further expansion of irrigation works
45. Indian Civil Service
1853 Government of India Act replaced nomination
with an open competitive exam for entry into the
Company training college at Halleybury
1858 Direct entry into ICS by competion
• Expectation that top positions would go to best
graduates of Cambridge and Oxford
• Opposition to exam: Positions should go to
English gentlemen
46. Satyendranath Tagore (1842-1923)
• Early education at home
including Sanskrit and
English
• Higher education at Hindu
School of Calcutta
• 1857 Passed exam at
University of Calcutta
47. Satyendranath Tagore
• 1862 Goes to England to take the competitive
exam
• Passes and is hired in 1864
• Authorities lower the weight of Sanskrit and
Arabic in scoring the exam
• Satyendranath becomes a judge, writer and
advocate of the emancipation of women
48. Examination
• First part based on liberal University education
• Second part, following a probationary period, on
law and Indian languages
49. 1863 Exam
• Tagore places 43rd out of 189 competitors; 6th in
second exam
375
375
Editor's Notes
The memorial tablets in All Souls’ Church, Cawnpore, record ‘more than a thousand Christian souls’ who were killed, but these also include some 200 officers and men. Seventy-seven were killed at Jhansi, at least fifty in Delhi, and thirty-one at Meerut. During the four and a half month long siege of the British Residency at Lucknow about 167 died of illness or malnutrition, or were killed by the mutineers
There are thus several reasons why, by the 1860s, Victoria thought of herself as Empress of India. Partly it was due to the influence of Albert, anxious to find in an Indian empire something that allowed him a larger role as consort. Partly it was due to the influence of Conser- vative politicians, determined that Victoria use her royal prerogative to reverse Whig policies in India, especially in military affairs But above all, Victoria's delusion of imperial power- if that is indeed what it was- rested on her prolonged and involved contact with the affairs of the Indian princely states during the 1840s and 1850s. This was both prac- tical-she possessed an intimate knowledge of Indian strategic military issues-but also personal-in that she exoticized her Indian subjects in the same way that she was to cultivate a Scottish Highland identity in later years
Taylor, Miles. "Queen Victoria and India, 1837-61." Victorian Studies 46.2 (2004): 264-274.
Arnstein, Walter. "The Warrior Queen: Reflections on Victoria and Her World." Albion (1998): 1-28.
Martial Race Theory
Roberts boldly asserted that ‘no comparison can be made between the martial values of a regiment recruited amongst the Ghurkhas of Nepal or the warlike races of Northern India (Punjab and NWFP), and those recruited from the effeminate peoples of the South’
Raw untrained recruits many from Ireland
If net earnings as a proportion of capital
outlay yielded less than the guaranteed return of 5 percent in any year, the Government
compensated the company the difference up to 5 percent. Such guarantee payments were
treated as debt. When annual net earnings exceeded the guaranteed level, the company was
required to repay any past guarantee payments by transferring half of their surplus profits
over 5 percent to the Government. After all past guarantee payments were paid off, the
company received the entire surplus profits
About 12 rupees to a pound
The Queen, represented by the Viceroy Lord Lytton, sent a telegram on 1stJanuary 1877, which read: We, Victoria, by the grace of God, Empress of India, and through our Viceroy, to all our officers, civil and military, and to all princes, chiefs, and peoples now at Delhi assembled, send our Royal and Imperial greeting, and assure them of the deep interest and earnest affection with which we regard the people of our Indian Empire. We have witnessed with heartfelt satisfaction the reception they have accorded to our beloved son, and have been touched by their loyalty and attachment to our House and Throne.We trust the present occasion may tend to unite in bonds of yet closer affection ourselves and our subjects, that from the highest to the humblest all may feel that under our rule the great principles of liberty, equity and justice are secured to them, and that to promote their happiness, to add to their prosperity, and advance their welfare, are the ever-present aims and objects of our Empire.
In Bombay these tests
drove large numbers of relíef-workers to strike, and the ques-
tion arose whether relíef should be given to men who could,
but would not, work. T his was decided by the Government
of India as follows: ‘We say that human life shall be saved at
any cost and elïort’; and íf ít is asked what ‘the general prín-
ciples are by which the District officers should bc guíded in
tefusing the aid needed to preserve life, the reply must be that
Fear that famine relief would lead to general relief. Salisbury and Disraeli also opposed spending for relief.
Compton, John M. "Open Competition and the Indian Civil Service, 1854-1876." The English Historical Review 83.327 (1968): 265-284.
Treveleyan wrote: the worst imputations against them [the competitioners] are that they are not fond of society & field sports, & that their manners are not good. It is not denied that, as a Class, they are cultivated thoughtful, intelligent
Halleybury College closed in January 1858. In 1862, a public school that retained close links with the EIC opened on the site.
Compton, John Michael. "Indians and the Indian Civil Service, 1853–1879: A Study in National Agitation and Imperial Embarrassment." Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society 99.2 (1967): 99-113.
Vasunia, Phiroze. "Greek, Latin and the Indian civil service." The Cambridge Classical Journal 51 (2005): 35-71.
Latin and Greek counted 750 each Argue that Latin and Greek trianing more rigorous thatn Sanskiit and Arabic.
Less than a dozen Indian natives hired before 1897