Department of Civil Engineering                                                                        NPIC




                          !0> viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg
        Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method


         CMBUkenHENnaMBIviFIkmøaMg b¤viFIPøicsIub‘IlIFI (force or flexibility method) edIm,IviFI truss Fñwm
nigeRKagminGackMNt;edaysþaTic. enAcugbBa©b;énemeronmanbgðajBIviFIsRmab;sg;ExST§iBlsRmab;
Fñwm b¤eRKagminGackMNt;edaysþaTic.

!0>!> rcnasm<½n§minkMNt;edaysþaTic (Statically indeterminate structures)
         rMlwkBIkfaxNÐ 2.4 eRKOgbgÁúMRKb;RbePTEdlRtUv)ancat;cMNat;fñak;CaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;eday
sþaTicenAeBlEdlcMnYnGBaØatEdlCakmøaMgRbtikmμ b¤kmøaMgkñúgelIsBIcMnYnsmIkarlMnwgEdlGacman
sRmab;karviPaKenaH. enAkñúgkfaxNÐenH eyIgnwgBiPakSaBIviFIénkareRbIeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt; nigviFImUl-
dæan cMnYnBIrEdleKRtUvkarviPaK. eyIgRtUvdwgfaeRKOgbgÁúMPaKeRcInEdlsikSaKNnasBVéf¶CaeRKOgbgÁúM
minkMNt;edaysþaTic. cMnYnminkMNt;GacekIneLIgedaysarkarbEnßmTMr b¤Ggát; b¤edayTMrg;TUeTArbs;
rcnasm<½n§. Ca]TahrN_ GKarebtugGarem:esÞIrEtTaMgGs;CaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTic edaysar
ssr nigFñwmRtUv)ancak;CaGgát;Cab;Rtg;tMN nigRtg;TMr.
KuNsm,tþi nigKuNvibtþi³ eTaHbICakarviPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicmanlkçN³sμúKsμajCagkar
viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;edaysþaTick¾eday k¾eKenAEteRCIserIsvasRmab;karsikSaKNnaEdr edaysarCaTU
eTAeKmanmUlehtuCaeRcIn. GVIEdlsMxan;CaeKKW sRmab;kardak;bnÞúkdUcKñakugRtaMgGtibrma nigPaBdab
sRmab;eRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicmantémøtUcCagsRmab;eRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;edaysþaTic. Ca]TahrN_
eRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTic ¬FñwmTMrbgÁúM¦ enAkñúgrUbTI 10-1a nwgrgnUvm:Um:g;Bt;Gti`brma M max =
 PL / 8 b:uEnþFñwmTMrsamBaØ ¬rUbTI 10-1b¦ nwgrgnUvm:Um:g;Bt;eTVdgeBalKW M max = PL / 4 . CalT§pl

FñwmTMrbgáb;manPaBdab;tUcCagbYndg nigmankugRtaMgBt;tUcCagBIrdgénFñwmTMrsamBaØenARtg;kNþal
ElVg.
         ehtupld¾sMxan;mYyeTotkñúgkareRCIserIseRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicKWedaysarvaGacEbg
EckbnÞúkrbs;vaeTATMrEdlmancMnYnelIs enAkñúgkrNIEdlmankarsikSaKNnamanlkçN³xusqÁg b¤k¾
kardak;bnÞúkelIsGacekItman. enAkñúgkrNITaMgenH rcnasm<½n§rkSasßirPaB nigkarBarkar)ak;rlM. va
manlkçN³sMxan;CaBiess enAeBlEdlbnÞúkxag dUcCabnÞúkxül; b¤bnÞúkrBa¢ÜydImanGMeBIelIeRKOgbgÁúM.
viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                           T.Chhay   -334
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                   viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

edIm,IbgðajBIlkçN³sMxan;enH cUrBicarNaFñwmTMrbgáb;enAkñúgrUbTI 10-1amþgeTot. enAeBlkmøaMg P
ekIneLIg sMPar³rbs;FñwmenARtg;CBa¢aMg nigenARtg;kNþalElVgcab;epþImeFVIkardl;tMbl;yal (yield)
ehIybegáIt)anCasnøak;)aøsÞic EdleFVIeGayFñwmdabdUckrNIFñwmEdltP¢ab;edaysnøak;enARtg;cMNuc
enaH. eTaHbICaPaBdabmantémøFMk¾eday EtCBa¢aMgnwgbegáItkmøaMgRbtikmμtamTisedk nigm:Um:g;Rbti-
kmμEdl nwgTb;FñwmBIkar)ak;TaMgRsug. enAkñúgkrNIFñwmTMrsamBaØ ¬rUbTI 10-1b¦ bnÞúkelIs P nigeFVI
eGaysnøak;)aøsÞicekItmanEtenARtg;kNþalElVgrbs;Fñwm ehIyedaysarPaBdabmantémøFM TMrnwgmin
begáItkmøaMgRbtikmμtamTisedk nigm:Um:g;RbtikmμEdlcaM)ac;sRmab;kar)ak;TaMgRsug.
         eTaHbICaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicGacRTbnÞúkCamYynwgGgát;esþIgCag nigmansßirPaBCag
ebIeRbobeFobnwgrcnasm<½n§kMNt;edaysþaTick¾eday k¾mankrNIxøHKuNsm,tþiTaMgenHGacCMnYseday
KuNvibtþivijEdr. eKRtUveRbobeFobtémøsMPar³EdlsnSMCamYynwgtémøbEnßmEdlcaM)ac;edIm,Isagsg;
rcnasm<½n§enaH edaysareBlxøHeKRtUvkarcMNayfvikarCaeRcInkñúgkarsagsg;TMr nigtMNrbs;eRKOgbgÁúM
minkMNt;edaysþaTicebIeRbobeFobeTAnwgrcnasm<½n§kMNt;edaysþaTic. EtGVIEdlsMxan;CagenH eday
sareRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicmankmøaMgRbtikmμEdlCaGBaØat enaHeKRtUvRby½tñkñúgkarkarBarsMrut
DIepr:g;Esülrbs;TMr BIeRBaHT§iBlenHnwgbegáItkugRtaMgxagkñúgenAkñúgeRKOgbgÁúM. Ca]TahrN_ Rbsin
ebICBa¢aMgenAcugmçagénFñwmTMrbgáb;enAkñúgrUbTI 10-1a Rsut ehIykugRtaMgnwgekItmanenAkñúgFñwmeday
sarkmøaMgEdlekItmanedaysarkMhUcRTg;RTayenH. mü:agvijeTot RbsinebIRtUv)anRTedayTMrsamBaØ
b¤Carcnasm<½n§kMNt;edaysþaTic ¬rUbTI 10-1b¦ enaHtMruténcugrbs;vanwgmineFVIeGayFñwmxUcRTg;RTay
ehIyvanwgmineFVIeGaymankugRtaMgekItmanenAkñúgFñwmeT. CaTUeTA RKb;kMhUcRTg;RTayTaMgGs;dUcCa
kMhUcRTg;RTayedaysarEdlbNþalBIbMlas;TIrbs;TMr b¤bMErbMrYlrbs;RbEvgrbs;Ggát;EdlbNþalBI
sItuNðPaB b¤edaysarkMhugqÁgkñúgkarplit nwgbegáItkugRtaMgbEnßmenAkñúgrcnasm<½n§ EdleKcaM)ac;RtUv
KitBicarNaenAeBlsikSaKNnaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTic.




viFIviPaK³ enAeBlviPaKrcnasm<½n§minkMNt;edaysþaTicTaMgGs; eKcaM)ac;RtUvbMeBjtMrUvkarlMnwg
(equilibrium) PaBRtUvKña (compatibility) nigTMnak;TMngkmøaMg nigbMlas;TI (force-displacement)

Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method               T.Chhay   -335
Department of Civil Engineering                                                                 NPIC



sRmab;rcnasm<½n§. lkçxNÐlMnwgRtUv)anbMeBjenAeBlEdlkmøaMgRbtikmμTb;rcnasm<½n§enAmYykEnøg
ehIylkçxNÐRtUvKñaRtUv)anbMeBjenAeBlEdlkMNat;Ggát;CaeRcInrbs;rcnasm<½n§eFVIkarCamYyKñaeday
minmankardac;xagkñúg b¤KgBIelIKña. tMrUvkarTMnak;TMngkmøaMg nigbMlas;TIGaRs½ynwgkareFVIkarrbs;
sMPar³ enAkñúgGtßbTenHeyIgsnμt;fasMPar³eFVIkarCalkçN³eGLasÞiclIenEG‘r. CaTUeTA eKmanviFIBIr
epSgKñaedIm,IbMeBjtMrUvkarTaMgenHenAeBlviPaKrcnasm<n§minkMNt;edaysþaTicKW viFIkmøaMg b¤viFIPøicsIu-
                                                         ½
b‘IlIFI (force or flexibility method) nigviFIbMlas;TI b¤viFIPaBrwgRkaj (displacement or stiffness
method).

viFIkmøaMg³ viFIenHRtUv)anbegáIteLIgCadMbUgedayecmkøWkm:akesVl (James Clerk Maxwell) enAkñúgqñaM
1864 nigeRkaymk viFIenHRtUv)anEksMrYleGaymanlkçN³l¥RbesIredayGUtUmr (Otto Mohr) nig
ehnrIcm‘uyeyeRbsøÚ (Heinrich Muller-Breslau). edaysarlkçxNÐRtUvKñabegáIteKalkarN_sRmab;
viFIenH eBlxøHeKGacehAvaCaviFIxMepFIb‘IlIFI (compatibility method) b¤viFIbMlas;TIzitezr (method
of consistent displacement). viFIenHRtUv)anbegáIteLIgedaykarsresrsmIkarEdlbMeBjlkçxNÐ

RtUvKña nigtMrUvkarénTMnak;TMngkmøaMg nigbMlas;TIsRmab;eRKOgbgÁúMedIm,IkMNt;kmøaMgEdlCaGBaØatelIs.
enAeBlEdleKkMNt;kmøaMgTaMgenHrYcehIy eKGackMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμEdlenAsl;edaybMeBjtMrUvkar
lkçxNÐlMnwg. eKalkarN_mUldæanEdlBak;B½n§nwgkarGnuvtþviFIenHmanlkçN³gayRsYlyl; nigman
lkçN³gayRsYlbegáIt ehIyvak¾RtUv)anelIkykmkBiPakSaenAkñúgCMBUkenHpgEdr.
viFIbMlas;TI³ viFIenHEp¥kelIkarsresrTMnak;TMngrvagkmøaMg nigbMlas;TIsRmab;Ggát;CadMbUg bnÞab;mk
Ep¥kelIkarsresrsmIkarlMnwgsRmab;eRKOgbgÁúM. enAkñúgkrNIenH GBaØatenAkñúgsmIkarKWbMlas;TI. enA
eBlEdleKTTYl)anbMlas;TI eKGackMNt;kmøaMgBIlkçxNÐRtUvKña nigsmIkarTMnak;TMngrvagbMlas;TI nig
kmøaMg. eyIgnwgsikSabec©keTsxøHEdleRbIedIm,IGnuvtþviFIbMlas;TIenAkñúgCMBUk11 nigCMBUk12. rUbmnþ
ma:RTIsénviFIenHmanbgðajenAkñúgCMBUk14/ 15 nig16.
          viFInImYy²énviFITaMgBIrEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-2 manKuNsm,tþi nigKuNvibtþiGaRs½yeTAnwg
ragFrNImaRtrbs;eRKOgbgÁúM nigdWeRkénPaBminkMNt;rbs;va.




viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                    T.Chhay   -336
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                     viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

!0>@> dMeNIrkarTUeTAkñúgkarviPaKedayviFIkmøaMg
          (Force method of analysis: general procedure)
         meFüa)ayd¾l¥bMputkñúgkarbgðajeKalkarN_Edl
Bak;B½n§nwgviFIkmøaMgKWBicarNaFñwmEdlbgðaj enAkñúgrUbTI
10-3a. RbsinebIeKKUrdüaRkamGgÁesrIrbs;va enaHvanwg
mankmøaMgRbtikmμEdlCaGBaØatcMnYcbYn ehIyedaysarEt
vaGacmansmIkarlMnwgcMnYnbIsRmab;karedaHRsay enaHFñwm
enHCarcnasm½<n§dWeRkTImYy. dUcenH eKcaM)ac;RtUvkarsmIkar
bEnßmcMnYnmYysRmab;edaHRsay. edIm,ITTYlsmIkarenH
eyIgnwgeRbIeKalkarN_tMrYtpl nigBicarNalkçN³RtUv
KñaénbMlas;TIenARtg;TMrmçag. eKGacviPaKFñwmenHeday
eRCIserIskmøaMgRbtikmμTMrmYyCaGBaØatelIs ehIydk
vaecjBIFñwmCabeNþaHGasnñ enaHFñwmenHnwgkøayCaeRKOg
bgÁúMkMNt;edaysþaTic nigmansßirPaB. FñwmenHeKeGay
eQμaHfaeRKOgbgÁúMbzm (primary structure). enATIenH
eyIgnwgykkmøaMgRbtikmμrbs;TMrkl;Rtg;cMNuc B ecj.
CalT§pl bnÞúk P nwgeFVIeGaycMNuc B pøas;TIcuHeRkam
edaybrimaN Δ B dUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-3b. b:uEnþ
edayviFItMrYtpl kmøaMgRbtikmμEdlCaGBaØatenARtg;cMNuc B eBalKW B y eFVIeGayFñwmenARtg;cMNuc B
pøas;TIeLIgelIedaybrimaN Δ'BB ¬rUbTI 10-3c¦. enATIenHGkSr B dMbUgsMedAelIcMNuc B EdlRtUv
karkMNt;PaBdab ehIyGkSr B TIBIrsMedAelIcMNuc B EdlkmøaMgRbtikmμEdlCaGBaØatmanGMeBI. eday
bMlas;TIviC¢manEdl)ansnμt;manGMeBIeLIgelI enaHBIrUbTI 10-3a rhUtdl;rUbTI 10-3c eyIgGac
sresrsmIkarRtUvKñaEdlcaM)ac;enARtg;TMrkl;Ca
(+ ↑)                            0 = −Δ B + Δ' BB
LÚveyIgsMKal;bMlas;TIenARtg;cMNuc B EdlbNþalBIbnÞúkÉktþaEdlmanGMeBItamTisrbs; B y eday
emKuNPøicsIub‘IlIFIlIenEG‘r (linear flexibility coefficient) f BB ¬rUbTI 10-3d¦. edaykareRbInimitþ
sBaØakñúgTMrg;RsedogKña f BB CaPaBdabenARtg;cMNuc B EdlbNþalBIbnÞúkÉktþaenARtg;cMNuc B .
edaysarsMPar³manlkçN³eGLasÞiclIenEG‘r kmøaMg B y EdlmanGMeBIIenARtg;cMNuc B ¬CMnYseGay
Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                 T.Chhay   -337
Department of Civil Engineering                                                                 NPIC



bnÞúkÉktþa¦ nwgeFVIeGaymankMeNInPaBdabsmamaRtnwg f BB . dUcenHeyIgGacsresr
                                  Δ' BB = B y f BB

BIkarsresrkúñgTMrg;EbbenH eyIgeXIjfaemKuN linear flexibility f BB manxñatKitCaPaBdabkñúgmYy
ÉktþakmøaMg eBalKW m / N b¤ mm / N .l. dUcenHeKGacsresrsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñaxagelIeday
eRbIGBaØat B y Ca
                                  0 = −Δ B + B y f BB

edayeRbIviFIénCMBUk8 nig9 b¤edayeRbItaragPaBdabenAkñúgCMBUk9 eKGacTTYl)anTMnak;TMngrvag
bMlas;TI nigkmøaMgsRmab;PaBdab Δ B ¬rUbTI 10-3b¦ nig flexibility coefficient f BB ¬rUbTI 10-
3d¦ ehIyeKGacedaHRsayrk B y )an Edl B y = Δ B / f BB . eRkayeBledaHRsayrkkmøaMgRbtikmμ
EdlCaGBaØatelIsrYcehIy eKGacedaHRsayrkkmøaMgRbtikmμbIeTotenARtg;CBa¢aMg A BIsmIkarlMnwg.
          dUcGVIEdl)anerobrab;BIxagedIm eKeRCIserIs
GBaØatelIsedayminRbkan;. ]TahrN_ eKGackMNt;
m:Um:g;enARtg;cMNuc A ¬rUbTI 10-4a¦ edaypÞal;eday
dklT§PaBrbs;FñwmedIm,ITb;Tl;nwgm:Um:g; Rtg; A ecj
eBalKWCMnYsTMrbgáb;edayTMrsnøak;. dUcbgðajenAkñúg
rUbTI 10-4b mMurgVilenARtg;cMNuc A EdlbNþalBI
bnÞúk P KW θ A ehIymMurgVilenARtg; A EdlbNþalBI
M A EdlCaGBaØatelIenARtg; A KW θ ' AA ¬rUbTI 10-

4c¦. RbsinebIeyIgkMNt;nimitþsBaØarbs; angular
flexibility coefficient Ca α AA Edlmann½yfamMu

rgVilenARtg;cMNuc A EdlekItBIm:Um:g;mYyÉktþaman
GMeBIenARtg;cMNuc A ¬rUbTI 10-4d¦ enaH
                     θ ' AA = M Aα AA
dUcenH angular flexibility coefficient manxñatKitCa
mMurgVilkñúgmYYyÉktþam:Um:g; dUcenHvamanxñat rad / N .m
b¤ rad / kN .m .l. dUcenHsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñasRmab;mMurgVilenARtg;cMNuc A tMrUveGay
( +)                 0 = θ A + M Aα AA
enAkñúgkrNIenH M A = −θ A / α AA mantémøGviC¢man mann½yfa M A manGMeBIpÞúynwgm:Um:g;mYyÉktþa.
viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                    T.Chhay   -338
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                                       viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

        ]TahrN_TIbIEdlbgðajBIkarGnuvtþénviFIkmøaMgRtUv
)aneGayenAkñúgrUbTI 10-5a. enATIenH FñwmCarcnasm<½n§
minkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTIBIr dUcenHeKRtUvkarsmIkar
lkçxNÐRtUvKñacMnYnBIrsRmab;eFVIkar edaHRsay. eyIgnwg
eRCIserIskmøaMgbBaÄrenARtg;TMr B nig C Ca GBaØatelIs.
eRkayeBldkGBaØatelIsecj FñwmkMNt;edaysþaTicman
PaBdabdUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-5b. kmøaMgEdlCa
GBaØatelIs nImYy²EdlRtUv)ansnμt;eGaymanGMeBIcuH
eRkameFVIeGayFñwmmanPaBdabdUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-5c
nig 10-5d erogKña. enATIenH eKkMNt; flexibility
coefficient * f BB nig f CB BIkmøaMgÉktþamanGMeBIenARtg;

cMNuc B ¬rUbTI 10-5e¦ ehIyeKkMNt; fCC nig f BC
BIkmøaMgÉktþamanGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc C ¬rUbTI 10-5f¦.
edayviFItMrYtpl smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñasRmab;PaBdabRtg;
cMNuc B nig C KW
(+ ↓)                 0 = Δ B + B y f BB + C y f BC

(+ ↓)                 0 = Δ C + B y f CB + C y f CC               (10-1)

eRkayeBlbegáItTMnak;TMngbnÞúk nigbMlas;TIedayeRbIviFI
enAkñúgCMBUk 8 nig9 eKGacedaHRsayRbB½n§smIkarenHedIm,I
rk B y nig C y .
         edaysarkarGnuvtþviFIkmøaMgRtUv)anbgðajtamry³]TahrN_ eyIgnwgBiPakSakarGnuvtþrbs;va
kñúgn½yTUeTA ehIybnÞab;mkeyIgnwgeRbIvaCamUldæansRmab;edaHRsaycMeNaTEdlTak;Tgnwg truss,
Fñwm nigeRKag. b:uEnþsRmab;krNITaMgGs;enH eyIgRtUvdwgfa edaysarviFIenHGaRs½ynwgkartMrYtplén
bMlas;TI eKcaM)ac;RtUveGaysMPar³enAEteFVIkarkñgEdneGLasÞiclIenEG‘renAeBlEdlvargbnÞúk. ehIy
                                               ú
eyIgk¾RtUvdwgEdrfa eKGackMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμ nigkmøaMgkñúgTaMgGs;enARtg;cMNucmYyenAkñúgeRKOgbgÁúM
edayyklT§PaBRTRTg;bnÞúkrbs;eRKOgbgÁúMecj ehIybnÞab;mksresrsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñaenARtg;
*
       CaPaBdabenARtg;cMNuc B EdlbNþalBIkmøaMgÉktþaenARtg;cMNuc B
    f BB                                                                   f CB   CaPaBdabenARtg;cMNuc C EdlbNþalBI
kmøaMgÉktþaenARtg;cMNuc B .
Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                                   T.Chhay   -339
Department of Civil Engineering                                                                                 NPIC



cMNucenaH ¬emIl]TahrN_ 10-5¦.

dMeNIrkarkñúgkarviPaK (Procedure for analysis)
      CMhanxageRkampþl;nUvviFITUeTAsRmab;kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμ b¤kmøaMgkñúgrbs;rcnasm<½n§minkMNt;
edaysþaTicedayeRbIviFIkmøaMg b¤viFIPøicsIub‘IlIFI.
eKalkarN_tMrYtpl
kMNt;cMnYndWeRkminkMNt; n rbs;rcnasm<½n§. bnÞab;mkkMNt;GBaØatelIs n CakmøaMg b¤Cam:Um:g;EdlRtUv
dkecjCabeNþaHGasnñBIrcnasm<½n§edIm,IeFVIeGayvaeTACaeRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;edaysþaTic nigmansßirPaB.
edayeRbIviFItMrYtpl KUreRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTic nigbgðajfavaesμIeTAnwges‘rIéneRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;
edaysþaTicEdlRtUvKña. rcnasm<½n§dMbUgCaeRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;edaysþaTicEdlRTbnÞúkxageRkAdUceRKOgbgÁúM
minkMNt;edaysþaTic ehIyrcnasm<½n§déTepSgeTotCarcnasm<½n§kMNt;edaysþaTicbEnßmeTAelIrcna
sm<½ndMbUg ehIyfaRTbnÞúk b¤m:Um:g;EdlCaGBaØatelIsdac;edayELkBIKña. ehIyKUrExSekageGLasÞic
enAelIrcnasm<½n§nImYy² nigbgðajnimitþsBaØabMlas;TI b¤nimitþsBaØamMurgVilrbs;kMlaMg b¤m:Um:g;EdlCa
GBaØatelIs.
smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña
sresrsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñasRmab;bMlas;TI nigmMurgVilenARtg;cMNucnImYy²EdlmankmøaMg b¤m:Um:g;
EdlCaGBaØatelIs. eKKYrsresrsmIkarTaMgenHedayeRbIGBaØatelIs nig flexibility coefficient Edl
RtUvKñarbs;vaEdl)anBIbnÞúkÉktþa b¤m:Um:gÉktþaEdlRtUvKñanwgkmøaMg b¤m:Um:g;elIs.
                                        ;
         kMNt;PaBdab nig flexibility coefficient TaMgGs;edayeRbItaragenAkñúgCMBUk9 b¤eRbIviFIenAkñúg
CMBUk8 b¤CMBUk9 . CMnYsTMnak;TMngrvagbMlas;TI nigkmøaMgeTAkñúgsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña ehIyedaHRsay
                    *


rkGBaØatelIs. RbsinebItémøCaelxrbs;GBaØatelIsGviC¢man vabgðajfaGBaØatelIsmanGMeBIpÞúyeTA
nwgkmøaMgÉktþa b¤m:Um:g;Éktþa.
smIkarlMnwg
sg;düaRkamGgÁesrIrbs;rcnasm<½n§. edaysareyIg)anKNnakmøaMg nig/b¤m:Um:g;EdlCaGBaØatelIsrYc
ehIy eyIgGackMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμEdlCaGBaØatEdlenAesssl;BIsmIkarlMnwg.
*
   eKesñIfa RbsinebIdüaRkam M / EI sRmab;FñwmmanlkçN³samBaØ eKGaceRbIRTwsIRkLaépÞm:Um:g; b¤viFIFñwmnimitþ. eKGackMNt;
FñwmEdlmandüaRkam M / EI sμúKsμajenARKb;cMNucenAelIrcnasm<½n§edayeRbIviFIEdl)anerobrab;sRmab;eRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;eday
sþaTic.
viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                                    T.Chhay   -340
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                    viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

         eyIgKYrdwgfa enAeBlEdleyIgTTYl)ankmøaMgRbtikmμTMrTaMgGs;rYcehIy eyIgGacsg;
düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nigdüaRkamm:Um:g; ehIyeyIgGackMNt;PaBdabenARKb;cMNucTaMgGs;enAelIeRKOg
bgÁúMedayeRbIviFIEdlmanerobrab;sRmab;rcnasm<½n§kMNt;edaysþaTic.

!0>#> RTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUkrbs;m:akSEvl c,ab;ebFI
         Maxwell’s theorem of reciprocal displacement; Betti’s law
         enAeBlEdlm:akSEvl)anbegáItviFIkmøaMg Kat;k¾)anpSBVpSayRTwsþIEdlTak;TgeTAnwgeTAnwg
flexibility coefficient énBIrcMNucenAelIrcnasm<½n§eGLasÞicEdlmandUcCa truss, Fñwm b¤eRKag. eK

GacehARTwsþIenHfaRTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUk EdleBaldUcteTA³ bMlas;TIrbs;cMNuc B enAelIeRKOgbgÁúM
EdlbNþalBIbnÞúkÉktþaEdlmanGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc A esμIeTAnwgbMlas;TIrbs;cMNuc A enAeBlEdl
bnÞúkÉktþamanGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc B eBalKW f BA = f AB .
         eKbkRsayRTwsþIenHedayRsYledayeRbIeKalkarN_kmμnþnimitþ. Ca]TahrN_ BicarNaFñwmenA
kñúgrUbTI 10-6. enAeBlbnÞúkÉktþaBitmanGMeBIenARtg; A snμt;fam:Um:g;Bt;enAkñúgFñwmtameday m A .
edIm,IkMNt; flexibility coefficient enARtg; B eBalKW f BA eKRtUvdak;bnÞúkÉktþanimitþenARtg;cMNuc B
¬rUbTI 10-7¦ ehIyeKkMNt;m:Um:t;Bt; mB . edayGnuvtþsmIkar 9-18 eyIg)an
                                   mB m A
                       f BA = ∫           dx
                                    EI
         dUcKña RbsinebIeKkMNt; flexibility coefficient f AB enAeBlkmøaMgÉktþaBitmanGMeBIenARtg;
cMNuc B ¬rUbTI10-7¦ enaH mB Cam:Um:gBt;enAkñúgFñwmEdlbNþalBIkmøaMgÉktþaBit. mü:agvijeTot m A
Cam:Um:g;Bt;EdlbNþalBIkmøaMgÉktþanimitþenARtg;cMNuc A ¬rUbTI 10-6¦. dUcenH
                                   m A mB
                       f AB = ∫           dx
                                     EI




       GaMgetRkalTaMgBIrpþl;nUvlT§pldUcKñaEdlRtUvnwgBMenalrbs;RTwsþI. RTwsþIenHk¾GacGnuvtþ
sRmab;mMurgVilersIuRbUkEdr EdlRTwsþIenHeBaldUcteTA³ mMurgVilenARtg;cMNuc B enAelIeRKOgbgÁúMEdl
bNþalBIm:Um:g;ÉktþaEdlmanGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc A esμInwgmMurgVIlenARtg;cMNuc A enAeBlm:Um;g;manGMeBI
enARtg;cMNuc B . elIsBIenH edayeRbIkmøaMg nigm:Um:g;ÉktþaEdlGnuvtþenAelIrcnasm<½n§Rtg;cMNucdac;
Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                T.Chhay   -341
Department of Civil Engineering                                                             NPIC



edayELkBIKña eyIgk¾GaceBaldUcteTA³ mMurgVilKitCara:düg;enARtg;cMNuc B enAelIrcnasm<½n§Edl
bNþalBIbnÞúkÉktþaEdlmanGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc A esμInwgbMlas;TIenARtg;cMNuc A enAeBlm:Um:g;Éktþa
manGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc B .
         Cavi)akénRTwsþIenH eKGacsnSMsMéckargar)anxøHenAeBlGnuvtþviFIkmøaMgedIm,IedaHRsaycMeNaT
Edlrcnasm<½n§Carcnasm<<½n§minkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTIBIr b¤eRcInCagenH. ]TahrN_ eKRtUvkarkMNt;
flexibility coefficient EtmYyb:ueNÑaHkñúgcMeNam f BC nig f CB enAkñúgsmIkar 10-1 edaysar f BC

= f CB . elIsBIenH eKGaceRbIRTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUkenAkñúgkarkarviPaKrcnasm<½n§ nigsRmab;sg;ExS

T§iBledayeRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyeyeRbsøÚ ¬emIlkfaxNÐ 10.10¦.
         enAeBleKeFIVeGayRTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUkmanTMrg;kan;EtTUeTA eKeGayeQμaHvafac,ab;ebFI.
c,ab;enHeBaly:agsegçbfa³ kmμnþnimitþ δU AB eFVIedayRbB½n§kmøaMg ∑ PB CamYynwgbMlas;TIEdlbNþal
BIRbB½n§kmøaMg ∑ PA esμIeTAnwgkmμnþnimitþ δU BA EdlbNþalBIkmøaMg ∑ PA enAeBlrcnasm<½n§xUcRTg;
RTayedaysarRbB½n§kmøaMg ∑ PB . eKGacniyaymü:ageTotfa δU AB = δU BA . karbkRsaynUv
BMenalenHmanlkçN³dUcKñanwgkarbkRsayRTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUkxagelI.

!0>$> karviPaKFñwmtamviFIkmøaMg (Force method of analysis: Beams)
         viFIkmøaMgEdlGnuvtþeTAelIFñwmRtUv)anerobrab;enAkñúgkfaxNÐ 10-2. edayGnuvtþtamkarerob
rab;BIdMeNIrkarviFIEdlmanEcgenAkñúgkfaxNÐ 10-2 eyIgnwgbgðajBI]TahrN_CaeRcInEdlENnaMBIkar
Gnuvtþbec©keTsenH.

]TarhN_ 10-1³ kMNt;RbtikmμTMrenARtg;TMrkl; B rbs;FñwmEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-8a. EI Ca
témøefr.




viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                T.Chhay   -342
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                               viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

dMeNaHRsay³
eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ tamkarGegát FñwmCaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTImYy. eKnwgyk B y Ca
GBaØatelIs dUcenHeKGackMNt;kmøaMgenHedaypÞal;. rUbTI 10-8b bgðajBIkarGnuvtþéneKalkarN_
tMrYtpl. cMNaMfa karykGBaØatelIsecjTamTareGayykTMrkl; b¤karTb;rbs;FñwmtamTis By ecj.
enATIenH eyIgsnμt;fa B y eFVIGMeBIeTAelIFñwmedaymanTisedAeLIgelI.
smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ edayykbMlas;TIviC¢manmanTisedAeLIgelI ¬rUbTI 10-8b¦ eyIg)an
(+ ↑)                 0 = −Δ B + B y f BB                                                          (1)

eKGacTTYl)antY Δ B nig f BB edaygayedayeRbItaragenAkñúCMBUk9. cMNaMfa Δ B = ΔC + θC (6m)
dUcenH
                           P(L / 2)3 P(L / 2)2 ⎛ L ⎞
                      ΔB =          +          ⎜ ⎟
                             3EI       2 EI ⎝ 2 ⎠

                            =
                                (50kN )(6m )3 + (50kN )(6m )2 (6m ) = 9000kN .m3 ↓
                                     3EI                     3EI              EI
                                 PL3 1(12m )   576m33
                       f BB =        =       =       ↑
                                 3EI   3EI       EI
edayCMnYslT§plTaMgenHeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) eyIg)an
(+ ↑)                 0=−
                                9000      ⎛ 576 ⎞
                                     + By ⎜     ⎟                     B y = 15.6kN
                                 EI       ⎝ EI ⎠
RbsinebIeKdak;kmøaMgRbtikmμenHeTAelIdüaRkamGgÁesrIrbs;Fñwm eKGacTTYlkmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg; A
BIsmIkarlMnwgbI ¬rUbTI 10-8c¦.
      eRkayeBlkMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTaMgGs; eKGacsg;düaRkamm:Um:g;dUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-8d.

]TarhN_ 10-2³ kMNt;m:Um:g;enARtg;CBa¢aMgbgáb;sRmab;FñwmEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-9a. EI Ca
témøefr.
dMeNaHRsay³
eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ eyIgnwgyk M A CaGBaØatelIs edaysareyIgGackMNt;m:Um:g;enHedaypÞal;.
rUbTI 10-8b bgðajBIkarGnuvtþéneKalkarN_tMrYtpl. enATIenH eyIgdklT§PaBrbs;FñwmTb;Tl;nwg
m:Um:g;enARtg;TMr A . eyIgsnμt;fa M A eFVIGMeBIRcasRTnicnaLika.
smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ edayykmMurgVilviC¢manvilRcasRTnicnaLika ¬rUbTI 10-9b¦ eyIg)an
( +)                  0 = θ A + M Aα AA                                                            (1)
eKGackMNt;tY θ A nig α AA BItaragenAkñúgtaragkñúgCMBUk9. eyIg)an
Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                           T.Chhay   -343
Department of Civil Engineering                                                           NPIC


                             ML 30kN .m(3m ) 15kN .m 2
                     θA =        =              =
                            6 EI       6 EI       EI
                              ML 1(3m ) 1m
                     α AA   =      =       =
                              3EI    3EI     EI
edayCMnYseTAkñúgsmIkar (1) eyIg)an
                                       15      ⎛ 1 ⎞
( +)                              0=      + M A⎜ ⎟       M A = -15kN.m
                                       EI      ⎝ EI ⎠
sBaØaGviC¢manbgðajfa M A eFVIGMeBIpÞúyeTAnwgGVIEdl)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-9b. enAeBleyIgdak;
kmøaMgRbtikmμenHeTAelIFñwm eyIgGackMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμdéTeTotBIsmIkarlMnwg ¬rUbTI 10-9c¦.
düaRkamm:Um:g;RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-9d.




]TarhN_ 10-3³ sg;düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nigdüaRkamm:Um:gsRmab;FñwmEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-
                                                   ;
10a. TMr B mansMrut 40mm . yk E = 200GPa / I = 500(106 )mm4 .
dMeNaHRsay³
eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ tamkarGegát FñwmenHCaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTImYy. eyIgeRCIs
erIsTMrkNþal B CaGBaØatelIs dUcenHeyIgRtUvdkTMrkl;enARtg; B ecj ¬rUbTI 10-10b¦. enATIenH
eyIgsnμt;fa B y manTisedAcuHeRkam.
smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ eyagtamcMNuc B enAkñúgrUbTI 10-10b nigedayeRbIxñatEm:Rt eyIg)an
(+ ↓)                0.04 = Δ B + B y f BB                                      (1)


viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                              T.Chhay   -344
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                               viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa




enATIenHeyIgnwgeRbIviFIFñwmRtUvKñaedIm,IKNna Δ B nig f BB edaysardüaRkamm:Um:g;pSMeLIgedaybnÞat;
Rtg;. sRmab; Δ B epÞógpÞat;karKNnaEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-10c. cMNaMfa
   + ∑ M B' = 0                             − M B' +
                                                       800
                                                           (2.667 ) − 1000 (8) = 0
                                                        EI             EI
                                                       5866.67 5867
                                            M B'    =−          =
                                                          EI        EI
epÞógpÞat;karKNnaenAkñúgrUbTI 10-10d sRmab;karKNna f BB . cMNaMfa
   + ∑ M B' = 0                             − mB ' +
                                                     16
                                                        (2.667 ) − 16 (8) = 0
                                                     EI            EI
                                                     85.33 85.33
                                            mB ' = −       =
                                                      EI       EI
edayCMnYslT§plTaMgenHeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) eyIg)an
                                 5866.67      ⎛ 85.33 ⎞
                      0.04 =             + By ⎜       ⎟
                                   EI         ⎝ EI ⎠


Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                           T.Chhay   -345
Department of Civil Engineering                                                                    NPIC



edayCMnYs E nig I Caelx eyIg)an
               (0.04m )(200)(106 )kN / m 2 ][500(106 )(10−12 )m 4 ] = 5866.67 + B y (85.33)
                       [
                     B y = −21.875kN

smIkarlMnwg³ sBaØaGviC¢manbgðajfa By eFVIGMeBIelIFñwmedaymanTisedAeLIgelI. BIdüaRkamGgÁesrI
EdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-10e eyIg)an
   +∑MA = 0                       − 100(4) + 21.875(8) + C y (16) = 0

                                  C y = 14.06kN

+ ↑ ∑ Fy = 0                      Ay − 100 + 21.875 + 14.06 = 0

                                  Ay = 64.06kN

edayeRbIlT§plTaMgenH epÞógpÞat;düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nigdüaRkamm:Um:g;Bt;EdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-
10f.

]TarhN_ 10-4³ sg;düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nigdüaRkamm:Um:g;sRmab;FñwmEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-
11a. EI mantémøefr. ecalT§iBlrbs;kmøaMgtamG½kS.




viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                       T.Chhay   -346
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                                   viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

dMeNaHRsay³
eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ edaysareyIgecalbnÞúktamG½kS FñwmCarcnasm<½n§minkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTI
mYy. eyIgKitm:Um:g;cugTaMgBIrenARtg;cMNuc A nig B CaGBaØatelIs. eKRtUvdklT§PaBrbs;FñwmEdlTb;
Tl;nwgm:Um:g; edayCMnYsTMrsnøak;enARtg;cMNuc A nigTMrkl;enARtg;cMNuc B . eKalkarN_tMrYtplEdl
GnuvtþeTAelIFñwmRtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-11b.
smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ eyagtamcMNuc A nigcMNuc B ¬rUbTI 10-11b¦ tMrUveGay
( +)                  0 = θ A + M Aα AA + M Bα AB                                                                  (1)
( +)                  0 = θ B + M Aα BA + M Bα BB                                                                  (2)
eyIgGackMNt;mMurgVilEdlRtUvkar nig angular flexibility coefficient edayeRbItaragenAkñúgCMBUk 9.
eyIg)an
                               3wL3 3(30 )(6 )3 151.9
                      θA =           =         =
                              128 EI   128 EI    EI
                              7 wL3 7(30 )(6 )3 118.1
                      θB =           =         =
                             384 EI    384 EI    EI
                               ML 1(6) 2
                      α AA   =      =    =
                               3EI 3EI EI
                               ML 1(6) 2
                      α BB   =      =    =
                               3EI 3EI EI
                                ML 1(6)     1
                      α AB   =      =    =
                               6 EI 6 EI EI
cMNaMfa α AB = α BA CalkçN³sMxan;rbs;RTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUkrbs;m:akSEvl.
edayCMnYsTinñn½yxagelIeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) nig (2) eyIg)an
                         151.9      ⎛ 2 ⎞     ⎛ 1 ⎞
                      0=       + M A⎜ ⎟ + M B ⎜ ⎟
                          EI        ⎝ EI ⎠    ⎝ EI ⎠
                         118.1      ⎛ 1 ⎞     ⎛ 2 ⎞
                      0=       + M A⎜ ⎟ + M B ⎜ ⎟
                          EI        ⎝ EI ⎠    ⎝ EI ⎠
edaysMrYl EI nigedayedaHRsayRbB½n§smIkarTaMgenH eyIg)an
                      M A = −61.9kN .m                                M B = −28.1kN .m
edayeRbIlT§plTaMgenH eyIgGackMNt;kmøaMgkat;xagcugFñwm ¬rUbTI 10-11c¦ ehIyeyIgGacsg;
düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nigdüaRkamm:Um:g;.

]TarhN_ 10-5³ kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMrsRmab;FñwmEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-12a. EI mantémø
efr.
Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                               T.Chhay   -347
Department of Civil Engineering                                                               NPIC




dMeNaHRsay³
eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ edaykarGegát FñwmenHCaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTImYy. enATIenH
eyIgnwgeRCIserIsm:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;TMr B CaGBaØatelIs. Cavi)ak eyIgnwgkat;FñwmenHedaydac;ecjBIKña
ehIydak;TMrsnøak; b¤TMrkl;enARtg;cMNuc B edIm,IdklT§PaBrbs;FñwmEdlTb;Tl;nwgm:Um:g;enARtg;cMNuc
enH ¬rUbTI 10-12b¦. eKeGaym:Um:g;Bt;manGMeBIelIFñwmenAkñúgrUbTI 10-12c.
smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ BIrUbTI 10-12a eyIgtMrUveGay
( +)                 0 = θ B + M Bα BB
Edl            θ B = θ ' B +θ "B
nig            α BB = α ' BB +α "BB
eKGackMNt;mMurgVil nig angular flexibility coefficient BItaragenAkñúgCMBUk 9 Edl
                               wL3    2(3.6 )3 3.888kN .m 2
                     θ 'B =         =         =
                              24 EI    24 EI       EI
                              PL2 2.5(3)2 1.406kN .m 2
                     θ "B =        =         =
                             16 EI   16 EI        EI
                              ML 1(3.6 ) 1.2m
                     α ' BB =      =       =
                              3EI    3EI       EI


viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                  T.Chhay   -348
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa
                             ML 1(3) 1m
                      α "BB =     =    =
                             3EI 3EI EI
                      3.888kN .m 2 1.406kN .m 2     ⎛ 1.2m 1m ⎞
dUcenH                    EI
                                  +
                                       EI
                                                + MB⎜
                                                    ⎝ EI
                                                          +    ⎟=0
                                                            EI ⎠

                      M B = −2.406kN .m
sBaØadkbgðajfa M B eFVIGMeBItamTisedApÞúyeTAnwgkarbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-12c. edayeRbIlT§pl
enH eyIgGackMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμdUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-12d. elIsBIenH düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nig
düaRkamm:Um:g;Bt;RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-12e.

!0>%> karviPaKeRKagtamviFIkmøaMg (Force method of analysis: Frames)
        viFIkmøaMgmanPaBgayRsYlkñúgkaredaHRsayeRKagminkMNt;edaysþaTicmYyCan; nigmanrag
FrNImaRtminFmμtadUcCa gabled frames. sRmab;edaHRsayeRKagminkMNt;eRcInCan; b¤eRKOgbgÁúMEdl
mandWeRkminkMNt;x<s; eKeRbIviFIsøÚbDIPøicsin ¬slope-deflection) b¤viFIEbgEckm:Um:g; (moment-
distribution) b¤viFIsÞIveNs (stiffness method) Edlnwgerobrab;enAkñúgemeronxagmux.

        ]TahrN_xageRkambgðajBIkarGnuvtþénviFIkmøaMgedayeRbIdMeNIrviFIdUcerobrab;enAkñúgkfaxNÐ
10-2.



]TarhN_ 10-6³ kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMrrbs;eRKagEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-13a. EI mantémø
efr.




Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method            T.Chhay   -349
Department of Civil Engineering                                                                       NPIC



dMeNaHRsay³
eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ edaykarGegát eRKagCarcnasm<½n§minkMNt;dWeRkTImYy. eyIgnwgeRCIserIskmøaMg
RbtikmμtamTisedkenARtg; B CaGBaØatelIs. dUcenH eyIgCMnYssnøak;enARtg; B edayTMrkl; edaysar
TMrkl;minTb;cMNuc B tamTisedk. dUcenHeKalkarN_tMrYtplEdlGnuvtþeTAelIeRKagRtUv)anbgðajenA
kñúgrUbTI 10-13b.
smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ eyagtamcMNuc B enAkñúgrUbTI 10-13b tMrUveGay
  +
(→)                  0 = Δ B + Bx f BB                                                      (1)
eKGackMNt;tY Δ B nig f BB edayeRbIviFIkmμnþnimitþ. kUGredaen x rbs;eRKag nigm:Um:g;Bt;RtUv)anbgðaj
enAkñúgrUbTI10-13c nig10-13d. eKcaM)ac;RtUveCIserIskUGredaen x1 nig x2 dUcKñasRmab;krNI
nImYy² ¬TaMgsRmab;bnÞúkBit nigsRmab;bnÞúknimitþ¦. ehIyTisedAviC¢masRmab; M nig m k¾RtUvEtdUcKña.
         sRmab; Δ B eyIgtMrUveGaybnÞúkBit ¬rUbTI 10-13c¦manGMeBIenAelIeRKag nigbnÞúkÉktþanimitþ
manGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc B ¬rUbTI 10-13d¦. dUcenH
                L Mm          5 (20 x1 − 4 x1 )(0.8 x1 )dx1
                                            2                 4 0(1x2 )dx2
          ΔB =     ∫0 dx =
                     EI      ∫0                     EI
                                                            +         ∫0   EI
                  166.7     166.7
                =       +0=
                   EI         EI
sRmab; f BB eyIgtMrUveGaybnÞúkÉktþaBit nigbnÞúkÉktþanimitþmanGeBIenARtg;cMNuc B ¬rUbTI 10-
13d¦. dUcenH
                                      5 (0.8 x1 ) dx1    4 (1x2 ) dx2
                                                 2               2
                        L   mm
           f BB = ∫            dx = ∫                 +∫
                     0      EI       0       EI         0      EI
                                    26.7 21.3 48.0
                                  =        +        =
                                      EI        EI     EI
edayCMnYsTinñn½yxagelIeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) nigedayedaHRsay eyIgTTYl)an
                166.7      ⎛ 48.0 ⎞
           0=         + Bx ⎜      ⎟                       Bx = −3.47kN
                 EI        ⎝ EI ⎠
smIkarlMnwg³ edaybgðaj Bx enAelIdüaRkamGgÁesrIrbs;eRKagedayeRbITisedARtwmRtUv ¬rUbTI 10-
13e¦ nigedayGnuvtþsmIkarlMnwg eyIgTTYl)an
 +
→ ∑ Fx = 0                        Ax − 3.47 = 0                             Ax = 3.47kN
     +∑MA = 0                     − 40(2.5) + B y (5) − 3.47(4) = 0         B y = 22.8kN

+ ↑ ∑ Fy = 0                      Ay − 40 + 22.8 = 0                        Ay = 17.2kN




viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                          T.Chhay   -350
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

]TarhN_ 10-7³ kMNt;m:Um:g;enARtg;TMrbgáb; A rbs;eRKagEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-14a. EI
mantémøefr.




dMeNaHRsay³
eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ eRKagenHCaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;dWeRkTImYy. eKGacTTYldMeNaHRsaysRmab;
M A edaypÞal;edayeRCIserIsvaCaGBaØatelIs. dUcenHeyIgGacdklT§PaBrbs;eRKagTb;Tl;nwgm:Um:g;

Rtg; A dUcenHeyIgGaceRbITMrsnøak;enARtg;cMNuc A . eKalkarN_tMrYlplEdlGnuvtþeTAelIeRKag
RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-14b.
smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ eyagtamcMNuc B enAkñúgrUbTI 10-14b tMrUveGay
( +)                  0 = θ A + M Aα AA                                             (1)

         dUc]TahrN_mun² eKGacKNna θ A nig α AA edayeRbIviFIkmμnþnimitþ. kUGredaen x rbs;eRKag
nigm:Um:g;Bt;RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-14c nig10-14d.
   sRmab;           θA         eyIgTamTarnUvkarGnuvtþrbs;bnÞúkBit      ¬rUbTI       10-14c¦
nigm:Um:g;ÉktþanimitþenARtg;cMNuc A ¬rUbTI 10-14d¦. dUcenH
Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method            T.Chhay   -351
Department of Civil Engineering                                                                                      NPIC


                                   MmθL
                      θA = ∑ ∫           dx
                                0 EI

                           =∫
                              2.4 (0.13 x1 )(1 − 0.278 x1 )dx1
                                                               +∫
                                                                                    (
                                                                 1.5 1.34 x2 − 0.75 x2 (0.222 x2 )dx2
                                                                                     2
                                                                                                      )
                              0                EI                0                 EI
                             0.209 0.124 0.333
                           =         +          =
                               EI        EI         EI
sRmab; α AA eyIgTamTarnUvkarGnuvtþrbs;m:Um:g;ÉktþaBit nigm:Um:g;ÉktþanimitþEdlmanGMeBIenARtg;
cMNuc A ¬rUbTI 10-14d¦. dUcenH
                                          L    mθ mθ
                      α AA = ∑ ∫                     dx
                                          0     EI

                             =∫
                                  2.4         (1 − 0.278 x2 )2 dx1 +    1. 5   (0.222 x2 )2 dx2
                                  0     EI                             ∫0               EI
                               1.155 0.555 1.21
                             =      +      =
                                 EI   EI     EI
edayCMnYslT§plTaMgenHeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) nigedayedaHRsayeyIgTTYl)an
                           0.333      ⎛ 1.21 ⎞
                      0=         + M A⎜      ⎟                                    M A = −0.275kN .m
                            EI        ⎝ EI ⎠
sBaØadkbgðajfa M A manGMeBItamTisedApÞúyeTAnwgGVIEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI10-14b.

!0>^> karviPaK truss tamviFIkmøaMg (Force method of analysis: Trusses)
        CaTUeTA eKGackMNt;dWeRkminkMNt;rbs; truss edaykarGegát b:uEnþRbsinebIeKmankarlM)ak
kñúgkareFVIEbbenH eKGaceRbIsmIkar 3-1 (b + r > 2 j ) . enATIenH GBaØatRtUv)ansMEdgedaycMnYnkmøaMg
r)ar (b) bUknwgkmøaMgRbtikmμTMr (r ) ehIycMnYnsmIkarlMnwgEdlGacmanKW (2 j ) edaysareKGac
sresrsmIkarBIrsRmab;tMN ( j ) nImYy².
        viFIkmøaMgCaviFImYyEdlmanlkçN³smRsbkñúgkarviPaK truss minkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTImYy
b¤TIBIr. ]TahrN_xageRkambgðajBIkarGnuvtþrbs;vFIenHedayeRbIdMeNIrkarviPaKEdlerobrab;enAkñúg
                                                     i
kfaxNÐ 10-2.

]TarhN_ 10-8³ kMNt;kmøaMgenAkñúgGgát; AC rbs; truss EdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-15a. EI
mantémøefrsRmab;RKb;Ggát;TaMgGs;.
dMeNaHRsay³
eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ tamkarGegát truss enHCaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTImYy . edaysar                 *



*
    edayGnuvtþsmIkar (3-1) b + r > 2 j b¤ 6 + 3 > 2(4) / 9 > 8 / 9 − 8 = 1
viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                                         T.Chhay   -352
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                 viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

eKkMNt;kmøaMgenAkñúgGgát; AC edayeRCIserIsvaCaGBaØatelIs. eKRtUvkat;Ggát;enHedIm,IkMueGayvaman
kmøaMg ehtudUcenHehIy truss enHkøayCarcnasm<½n§kMNt;edaysþaTic nigmansßirPaB. eKalkarN_
tMrYtEdlGnuvtþeTAelI truss RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-15b.




smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ edayeyageTAtamGgát; AC enAkñúgrUbTI 10-15b eyIgtMrUveGaybMlas;TI
Δ AC EdlekIteLIgenAxagcugGgát;Edlkat; AC EdlbNþalBIbnÞúk 2kN bUknwgbMlas;TI FAC f ACAC

EdlbNþalBIkmøaMgEdlCaGBaØatelIsEdlmanGMeBIEtÉgesμIsUnü enaH
                      0 = Δ AC + FAC f ACAC                                          (1)
enATIenH flexibility coefficient f ACAC CabMlas;TIenARtg;cMNuccugkMNt;Ggát;Edlkat;rbs; AC Edl
bNþalBIbnÞúkÉktþaBitEdlmanGMeBIenARtg;cugEdlrgkarkat;énGgát; AC . tYr f ACAC nig Δ AC RtUv
)ankMNt;edayeRbIviFIkmμnþnimitþ. karviPaKkmøaMgedayeRbIviFItMNRtUv)ansegçbenAkñúgrUbTI 10-15c
nig 10-15d.
        sRmab; Δ AC eyIgtMrUveGaymankarGnuvtþénkmøaMgBit 2kN ¬rUbTI 10-15c¦ nigkmøaMgÉktþa
nimitþmanGMeBIenARtg;cugrgkarkat;énGgát; AC ¬rUbTI 10-15d¦. dUcenH
Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method             T.Chhay   -353
Department of Civil Engineering                                                                              NPIC


                                 nNL
                     Δ AC = ∑
                                  AE
                                ⎡ (− 0.8)(2)(2.4) ⎤ ⎡ (− 0.6 )(0 )(1.8)⎤ ⎡ (− 0.6)(1.5)(1.8) ⎤
                             = 2⎢                 ⎥+⎢                  ⎥+⎢                   ⎥
                                ⎣        AE       ⎦ ⎣       AE         ⎦ ⎣       AE          ⎦
                                 ⎡ (1)(− 2.5)(3)⎤ ⎡ (1)(0)(3) ⎤
                               +⎢               ⎥ + ⎢ AE ⎥
                                 ⎣      AE      ⎦ ⎣           ⎦
                                 16.8
                             =−
                                  AE
sRmab; f ACAC eyIgtMrUveGaymankarGnuvtþkmøaMgÉktþaBit nigkmøaMgÉktþanimitþenARtg;cugkMNt;Edl
rgkarkat;énGgát; AC ¬rUbTI 10-15d¦. dUcenH
                                      n2 L
                      f ACAC = ∑
                                       AE
                                     ⎡ (− 0.8)2 (2.4) ⎤    ⎡ (− 0.6)2 (1.8) ⎤ ⎡ (1)2 (3) ⎤
                                  = 2⎢                ⎥ + 2⎢                ⎥+⎢          ⎥
                                     ⎢
                                     ⎣      AE        ⎥
                                                      ⎦    ⎢
                                                           ⎣      AE        ⎥ ⎢ AE ⎥
                                                                            ⎦ ⎣          ⎦
                                    10.37
                                  =
                                     AE
edayCMnYsTinñn½yTaMgenHeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) nigedayedaHRsay eyIg)an
                             16.8 10.37
                     0=−         +      FAC
                              AE   AE
                     FAC = 1.62kN (T )
edaysarlT§plCaelxmantémøviC¢man enaH AC rgkmøaMgTajdUckarsnμt; ¬rUbTI 10-15b¦. eday
eRbIlT§plenH eyIgGackkMNt;kmøaMgenAkñúgGgát;déTedayeRbIviFItMN nigsmIkarlMnwg.

]TarhN_ 10-9³ kMNt;kmøaMgenAkñúgGgát;nImYy²én truss EdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-16a Rbsin
ebIeKeRbIekALak;enAelIGgát; AC edIm,IeFVIeGayGgát;enHxøICagGgát;                   BD    RbEvg 12.5mm . Ggát;
nImYy²manmuxkat; 125mm2 nig E = 200GPa .
dMeNaHRsay³
eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ Truss enHmanragFrNImaRtdUcnwg truss enAkñúg]TahrN_ 10-8. edaysareK
eFVIeGayGgát; AC rYjxøI eyIgnwgeRCIserIsvaCaGBaØatelIs ¬rUbTI 10-16b¦.
smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ edaysarminmanbnÞúkxageRkAmanGMeBIelIeRKOgbgÁúM (truss) edIm dUcenHvamin
manbMlas;TIenAcenøaHcugkMNat;rgkarkat;rbs;Ggát;edaysarbnÞúkeT eBalKW Δ AC = 0 . Flexibility
coefficient f ACAC RtUv)ankMNt;rUcehIyenAkñúg]TahrN_ 10-8 dUcenH
                                    10.37
                      f ACAC =
                                     AE

viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                                 T.Chhay   -354
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                         viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa




edaysnμt;brimaNrYjxøIrbs;Ggát;mantémøviC¢man dUcenHsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñasRmab;Ggát;KW
                                            10.37
                      0.0125m = 0 +               FAC
                                             AE
edaydwgfa        f ACAC    CabMlas;TIkñúgmYyÉktþakmøaMg eyIg)an
                                                        10.37 m
                      0.0125m = 0 +
                                            (125mm )(200kN / mm ) F
                                                        2             2   AC


dUcenH         FAC = 30.14kN = 30.1kN (T )

edaysarminmankmøaMgxageRkAmanGMeBIelI truss kmøaMgRbtikmμTMresμIsUnü. dUcenH edayeRbI                    FAC

nigedayviPaK truss edayviFItMN eyIgTTYl)anlT§pldUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-16c.

!0>&> eRKOgbgÁúMkMub:UsIut (Composite structures)
        eRKOgbgÁúMkMub:UsIutpSMeLIgedayGgát;xøHEdlrgEtnwgkmøaMgtamG½kS xN³Ggát;déTeTotrgkar
Bt;. RbsinebIvaCarcnasm<½n§minkMNt;edaysþaTic viFIkmøaMgmanlkçN³gayRsYlkñúgkareRbIsRmab;
viPaKva. ]TahrN_xageRkambgðajBIdMeNIrkarviPaKeRKOgbgÁúMEbbenH.

]TarhN_ 10-10³ FñwmEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-17a RtUv)anRTedayTMrsnøak;enARtg;cMNuc A
nigP¢ab;eTAnwgr)arBIrEdlmanTMrsnøak;enARtg;cMNuc B . kMNt;kmøaMgenAkñúgGgát; BD . yk
E = 200GPa / I = 300( 6 )mm 4 sRmab;Fñwm nig A = 1800mm 2 sRmab;r)ardéTeTot .
                        10



Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                     T.Chhay   -355
Department of Civil Engineering                                                                     NPIC




dMeNaHRsay³
eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ tamkarGegát FñwmCaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTImYy. sRmab;karedaH
Rsay eKeRCIserIskmøaMgenAkñúgGgát; BD CaGBaØatelIs. dUcenH eKRtUvkat;Ggát;enHedIm,IlubbM)at;
lT§PaBTb;Tl;kmøaMgrbs;va. eKalkarN_tMrYtplEdlGnuvtþeTAelIeRKOgbgÁúMRtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI
¬rUbTI 10-17b¦.
smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ edayeyagtambMlas;TIénGgát; BD Edlrgkarkat; ¬rUbTI 10-17b¦ eyIg
tMrUveGay
                     0 = Δ BD + FBD f BDBD                                                (1)
eyIgGaceRbIviFIkmμnþnimitþedIm,IKNna Δ BD nig       f BDBD   . karviPaKkmøaMgEdlcaM)ac;RtUv)anbgðajenA
kñúgrUbTI 10-17c nig10-17d.

viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                        T.Chhay   -356
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                                       viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

        sRmab; Δ BD eyIgtMrUveGaymankarGnuvtþkmøaMgBit ¬rUbTI 10-17c¦ nigkmøaMgnimitþÉktþa
GnuvtþenARtg;cugrgkarkat;rbs;Ggát; BD ¬rUbTI 10-17d¦. enATIenH eyIgnwgBicarNaEtfamBlbMEr
bMrYlrageFobEdlbNþalBIkarBt; nigbNþalBIkmøaMgtamG½kSenAkñúgFñwmEtb:ueNÑaH. dUcenH
                        Mm
                        L            nNL
           Δ BD = ∫          dx + ∑
                    0 EI              AE

                   =∫
                            (                 )                           (
                      3 30 x − 3.33 x (0 )dx (− 69.3)(− 0.816 ) 1.8 / cos 30 o
                                     3
                                             +                                 +
                                                                                         )          (
                                                                                 (0)(1) 1.8 / cos 45o                    )
                     0           EI                        AE                             AE
                          117.5
                   =0+              + 0 = 0.0003264m = 0.326mm
                         1800(20)
       sRmab; f BDBD eyIgtMrUveGaymankarGnuvtþrbs;bnÞúkBitÉktþa nigbnÞúkÉktþanimitþenARtg;cug
kMNat;Ggát;rgkarkat;rbs;Ggát; BD ¬rUbTI 10-17d¦. dUcenH
                            L   m 2 dx    n2 L
            f BDBD = ∫                 +∑
                            0    EI       AE

                      =∫
                            3   (0)2 dx + (− 0.816)2 (1.8 / cos 30o ) + (1)2 (1.8 / cos 45o )
                            0
                           EI                 AE                                 AE
                      =
                          3.93
                                 ( )
                        1800(200 )
                                   = 1.092 10 − 5 m / kN

edayCMnYsTinñn½yEdl)anrkBIxagelIeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) eyIg)an
           0 = Δ BD + FBD f BDBD

           0 = 0.0003264 + FBD (1.092 ) 10 −5       ( )
           FBD = −29.9kN = 29.9kN (C )
edayeRbIlT§plTaMgenH KUrdüaRkamGgÁesrIsRmab;Fñwm ehIybgðaj                                      FBC = 44.9kN (C )             /
 Ax = 1.31kN nig Ay = 30.0kN .



!0>*> kMNt;sMKal;bEnßmelIkarviPaKtamviFIkmøaMg
(Additional remarks on the force method of analysis)
       enAeBlenHedaysareKalKMniténviFIkmøaMgRtUv)anGPivDÄ eyIgnwgbnþeFVIeGaykarGnuvtþrbs;va
manlkçN³TUeTA ehIyeyIgnwgBiPakSaBIplRbeyaCn_rbs;va.
       enAeBlKNna flexibility coefficient fij b¤ αij sRmab;rcnasm<½n§ eKRtUvcMNaMfavaGaRs½y
Et nwglkçN³sMPar³ niglkçN³FrNImaRtrbs;Ggát; nigminGaRs½ynwgkardak;bnÞúkelIeRKOgbgÁúMdMbUg
(primary structure) eT. dUcenH enAeBlEdltémøTaMgenHRtUv)anKNna eKGaceRbIvaedIm,IKNna

kmøaMgsRmab;RKb;kardak;bnÞúkTaMgGs;.
Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                                     T.Chhay   -357
Department of Civil Engineering                                                                                            NPIC



            sRmab;rcnasm<½n§EdlmanGBaØat Rn elIscMnYn n eyIgGacsresrsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñacMnYn
n    Edl
                      Δ1 + f11R1 + f12 R2 + L + f1n Rn = 0
                      Δ 2 + f 21R1 + f 22 R2 + L + f 2n Rn = 0
                                                           M
                      Δ n + f n1R1 + f n 2 R2 + L + f nn Rn = 0
enATIenH bMlas;TI Δ1 / >>>/ Δ n bNþalmkBIbnÞúkBitEdlmanGMeBIenAelI primary structure nigbNþalBI
sMrutrbs;TMr b¤bNþalBIbMErbMrYlsItuNðPaB b¤kMhusqÁgkñúgkarplitGgát;. edIm,IsMrYldl;karKNna
rcnasm<½n§EdlmandWeRkminkMNt;x<s; eKGacsresrsmIkarxagelICaragm:aRTIsdUcxageRkam
                      ⎡ f11 f12     L f1n ⎤ ⎧ R1 ⎫     ⎧ Δ1 ⎫
                      ⎢f                   ⎥⎪R ⎪
                                    L f 2n ⎥ ⎪ 2 ⎪     ⎪Δ ⎪
                      ⎢ 21 f 22                        ⎪ 2⎪
                                             ⎨ ⎬    = −⎨ ⎬                                                       (10-2)
                      ⎢             M      ⎥⎪ M ⎪      ⎪ M ⎪
                      ⎢                    ⎥⎪ ⎪        ⎪Δ n ⎪
                      ⎣ f1n f 2 n   L f nn ⎦ ⎩ Rn ⎭    ⎩ ⎭
b¤                    f R = −Δ

         CaBiess eKRtUvcMNaMfa fij = f ji ( f12 = f 21, etc.) tamRTwsþIm:akSEvlénbMlas;TIrIsIuRbUk
¬b¤c,ab;ebFI¦. dUcenH flexibility matrix Cam:aRTIssIuemRTI ehIyTMrg;enHmanRbeyaCn_enAeBledaH
RsaysMnMusmIkarlIenEG‘rFM² dUcenAkñúgkrNIrcnasm<½n§EdlmandWeRkminkMNt;x<s;.
         enAkñúgCMBUkenH eyIg)ankMNt; flexibility coefficient edayeRbIviFIkmμnþnimitþ edaysarvaGnuvtþ
eTAelIeRKOgbgÁúMTaMgmUl. b:uEnþ eKGacTTYlemKuNsRmab;Ggát;nImYy²sRmab;eRKOgbgÁúMTaMgmUleday
eRbIsmIkarbMElg (transformation equation) edIm,ITTYltémøTaMgenH sRmab;eRKOgbgÁúMTaMgmUl. viFIenH
RtUv)anerobrab;enAkñúgesovePAEdlniyayGMBIkarviPaKeRKOgbgÁúMedaym:aRTIs nigminRtUv)anerobrab;enA
kñúgesovePAenHeT*.
         eTaHbIkarlMGitsRmab;karGnuvtþviFIkmøaMgedayeRbIviFIkMuBüÚT½rk¾minRtUv)anelIkykmkniyayenA
kñúgesovePAenHk¾eday k¾eyIgGaceFIVkarGegátTUeTA nigeFVImUlvicarenAeBleRbIviFIenHedIm,IedaHRsaycM-
eNaTEdlmandWeRkminkMNt;x<s;. Tak;TgnwgbBaðaenH edIm,ITTYl)andMeNaHRsaykan;EtsuRkiteKRtUv
eGay flexibility coefficient EdlenAEk,rGgát;RTUgrbs;m:aRTIs f FMCag flexibility coefficient
EdlenAq¶ay. edIm,ITTYl)anEbbenH eKRtUvBicarNakñúgkareRCIserIs primary structure. edIm,IsMrYl
kúñgkarKNna fij eKENnaMeGayeRCIserIs primary structure y:agNaeGayvaCaeRKOgbgÁúMsIuemRTI.
kareFVIEbbenHnwgeGayeyIgTTYl)an flexibility coefficient xøHdUcKña b¤k¾GacesμIsUnü. cugeRkay rUb
*
    emIl H.C. Martin, Introduction to Matrix Methods of Structural Analysis, McGraw-Hill, New York Ca]TahrN_.
viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                                               T.Chhay   -358
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                     viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

ragxUcRTg;RTayrbs; primary structure nwgRsedognwgrUbragxUcRTg;RTayrbs;rcnasm<½n§Cak;Esþg.
RbsinebIeKGaceFVIEbbenH)anEmn enaHeKRtUvkarEksMrYlGBaØatEtbnþicbnÞÜcb:ueNÑaHeTAelI primary
structure EdleFVIeGayeKTTYl)anlT§plEdl)anBIsmIkar 10-2 kan;EtsuRkit.



!0>(> eRKOgbgÁúMsIuemRTI (Symmetric structures)
        karviPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;lMdab;x<s;k¾dUckarviPaKeRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;edaysþaTic GñksikSaKNna
RtUvdwgfaeRKOgbgÁúMenaHCaeRKOgbgÁúMEdlmanTMr b¤bnÞksIuemRTI b¤minsIuemRTI. kñúgn½yTUeTA eKGaccat;cM-
                                                    ú
Nat;eRKOgbgÁúMCaeRKOgbgÁúMsIuemRTIRbsinebIkmøaMgkñúg nigPaBdabrbs;vamanlkçN³qøúHKñaeFobnwgG½kS
kNþalrbs;va. CaTUeTA PaBsIuemRTITamTareGaysMPar³ ragFrNImaRt TMr nigbnÞúkRtUvEtdUcKñaenAsg
xageRKOgbgÁúM. b:uEnþ vaminEmnTal;EtdUecñaHTaMgGs;eT. cMNaMfa sRmab;sßirPaBtamTisedk eKRtUvkar
TMr snøak;edIm,IRTFñwm nig truss ¬rUbTI 10-18a nig 10-18b¦. enATIenH kmøaMgRbtikmμtamTisedk
enA Rtg;snøak;esμIsUnü dUcenHrcnasm<½n§enHnwgmankmøaMgkñúg nigPaBdabqøúHKña. CalT§pl eKGaccat;
cMNat;fñak;vaCarcnasm<½n§sIuemRTI. eKRtUvdwgfavaminEmnCakrNIsRmab;eRKageT ¬rUbTI 10-
18c¦Rbsin ebIeKCMnYsTMrbgáb;enARtg;cMNuc A edayTMrsnøak; enaHrUbragdab nigkmøaMgkñúgenAxagsþaM
nigxageqVg nwgmindUcKñaeT.




         enAeBlxøH eRKOgbgÁúMsIuemRTIRTbnÞúkminsIuemRTI dUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-19. kñúgkrNIrcna
sm<½n§manlkçN³sIuemRTI nigbnÞúkrbs;vamanlkçN³sIuemRTI b¤minsIuemRTI enaHeKnwgeFVIkarviPaKeRKOg
bgÁúMEtmYykMNat;b:ueNÑaH edaysarlT§pldUcKña b¤pÞúyKñanwgekItmanEtenAelIrcnasm<½n§mYykMNat;.
Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                 T.Chhay   -359
Department of Civil Engineering                                                              NPIC




RbsinebIrcnasm<½n§sIuemRTIrgbnÞúkminsIuemRTI
enaHeKRtUvbMElgvaeGayeTACabgÁúMbnÞúksIuem-
RTI nigbgÁúMbnÞúkminsIuemRTI. edIm,IeFVI EbbenH
dMbUgeKRtUvEckbnÞúknwgBIr bnÞab;mkeTot eK
dak;eGayvamanlkçN³sIuemRTI nigminsIuemRTI.
Ca]TahrN_ eKRtUvEckbnÞúk enAelIFñwmkñúgrUb
TI 10-20a nwgBIr rYcdak;eGayva qøúHKñaeFob
nwgG½kSsIuemRTI. bnÞab;mkeKTTYl)anbgÁúM
bnÞúksIuemRTI nigminsIuemRTI dUcbgðajenAkñúg
rUbTI 10-20b. enAeBlEdleKbUkbgÁúMbnÞúk
TaMgBIrenHbBa©ÚlKña eKnwgTTYl)anbnÞúkedIm.
eKGaceFVIkarviPaKrcnasm<½n§dac;edayELk
eTAelIbgÁúMbnÞúksIuemRTI nigbgÁúMbnÞúkminsIuemRTI
ehIyeKRtUveFVIplbUkénlT§pl TaMgenHedIm,ITTYl)anlkçN³eFVIkaredImrbs; rcnasm<½n.

!0>!0> ExST§iBlsRmab;FñwmminkMNt;edaysþaTic
(Influence lines for statically indeterminate beams)
          enAkñúgkfaxNÐ 6-3 eyIg)ansikSarYcmkehIyBIkareRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,IKUrExS
T§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgRbtikmμ kmøaMgkat; nigm:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;cMNucmYyenAelIFñwmkMNt;edaysþaTic. enA
kñúgkfaxNÐenH eyIgnwgBnøatviFIenH nigeRbIvasRmab;FñwmminkMNt;edaysþaTic.
          rMlwkfa sRmab;Fñwm eKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚeBalfaExST§iBlsRmab;GnuKmn_ ¬kmøaMgRbtikmμ
kmøaMgkat; b¤m:Um:g;Bt;¦ manrUbragdabrbs;FñwmmanlkçN³dUcKñaenAeBlFñwmrgGMeBIedayGnuKmn_RtUvKña.
edIm,IKUrrUbragdabeGay)anRtwmRtUv eKRtUvdklT§PaBTb;Tl;nwgkarGnuvtþrbs;GnuKmn_ enaHFñwmGacdab
viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                 T.Chhay   -360
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                  viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

enAeBlGnuKmn_manGMeBIelIFñwm. sRmab;FñwmkMNt;edaysþaTic rUbragdab ¬b¤ExST§iBl¦ Caes‘rIénkM-
Nat;bnÞat;Rtg;. sRmab;FñwmminkMNt;edaysþaTic ExST§iBlnwgmanlkçN³CaExSekag. eyIgnwgsikSa
BI sMNg;énRbePT nImYy²rbs;ExST§iBlTaMgbiI ¬kmøaMgRbtikmμ kmøaMgkat; nigm:Um:g;Bt;¦ sRmab;rcna
sm<½n§minkMNt;edaysþaTic. enAkñúgkrNInImYy² eyIgnwgbgðajBIPaBeRbIkar)anéneKalkarN_
m‘uyey:eRbsøÚ edayeRbIRTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUkrbs;m:akSEvl.
RbtikmμenARtg;cMNucA³ edIm,IkMNt;ExST§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;cMNuc A enAkñúgrUbTI 10-
21a eKdak;bnÞúkÉktþaenAelIFñwmRtg;cMNucbnþbnÞab; ehIyenARtg;cMNucnImYy²eKRtUvkMNt;kmøaMg
RbtikmμenARtg;cMNuc A . düaRkaménlT§plTaMgenHCaExST§Bl. Ca]TahrN_ enAeBlbnÞúkenARtg;
cMNuc D ¬rUbTI 10-21a¦ eKGackMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;cMNuc A EdlCaGredaenrbs;ExST§iBl
enARtg; D edayeRbIviFIkmøaMg. edIm,IeFIVy:agenH eKRtUvGnuvtþeKalkarN_tMrYtpldUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI
10-21a rhUtdl;rUbTI 10-21c. dUcenH smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñasRmab;cMNuc A KW 0 = f AD + Ay f AA
b¤ Ay = − f AD / f AA b:uEnþtamRTwsþIbMlas;TIersIiuRbUkrbs;m:akSEvl f AD = − f DA ¬rUbTI 10-21d¦
dUcenHeyIgk¾GackMNt; Ay ¬b¤Gredaenrbs;ExST§iBlenARtg;cMNuc D ¦ edayeRbIsmIkar
                            ⎛ 1 ⎞
                            ⎜ f ⎟ f DA
                       Ay = ⎜    ⎟
                            ⎝ AA ⎠
         edayeFVIkareRbobeFob eKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚtMrUveGayykTMrenARtg; A ecj ehIyGnuvtþ
bnÞúkÉktþabBaÄrenARtg;cMNucenaH. ExSekagPaBdabEdlTTYl)an ¬rUbTI 10-21d¦ manTMrg;dUcKñanwg
rUbragrbs;ExST§iBlsRmab; Ay . b:uEnþ BIsmIkarxagelIeyIgeXIjfaemKuNmaRtdæan (scale factor) KW
1 / f AA .




Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method              T.Chhay   -361
Department of Civil Engineering                                                                NPIC



kmøaMgkat;enARtg; E³ RbsinebIeKRtUvkarkMNt;
ExST§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc E rbs;
FñwmenA kñúgrUbTI 10-22a tameKalkarN_
m‘uyey:eRbsøÚ eKRtUvkat;FñwmRtg;cMNucenaH ehIy
s‘k sliding device enARtg;cMNucenaH ¬rUbTI
10-22b¦. ]bkrN_enHnwgbBa¢Únm:Um:g;Bt; nig
kmøaMgEkg b:uEnþminbBa¢ÚnkmøaMgkat;eT. enAeBl
Fñwm dabedaysarkmøaMgkat;ÉktþaviC¢manEdlman
GMeBIenARtg;cMNuc E mMurgVilenAsgxag]bkrN_
mantémødUcKña        ehIyExSekagPaBdabCaExS
T§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc E rUbTI
10-22c. edayGnuvtþviFIeKalsRmab;sg;ExST§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc E enaHeKcaM)ac;
GnuvtþkmøaMgÉktþaenARtg;cMNucnImYy² dUcCacMNuc D ehIykMNt;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc E ¬rUbTI
10-22a¦. témø VE CaGredaenrbs;ExST§iBlenARtg;cMNuc D . edayeRbIviFIkmøaMg nigRTwsþIbMlas;TI
ersIuRbUkrbs;m:akSEvl ¬dUckrNIelIkmun¦ eyIgTTYl)an
                          ⎛ 1        ⎞
                     VE = ⎜
                          ⎜f         ⎟ f DE
                                     ⎟
                          ⎝ EE       ⎠
kmøaMgkat;ÉktþaviC¢manEdlGnuvtþeTAelIFñwmenARtg;cMNuc E ¬rUbTI 10-22c¦ nwgeFVIeGayFñwmdabkñúg
TMrg;CaExST§iBl sRmab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc E . enATIenHemKuNmaRtdæanKW (1 / f EE ) .
m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg; E³ eKGackMNt;ExST§iBlsRmab;m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;cMNuc E enAkñúgrUbTI 10-23a
edayCMnYssnøak;enARtg;cMNucenaH edaysartMNEbbenHbBa¢ÚnkmøaMgEkg nigkmøaMgkat; b:uEnþminGacTb;
Tl; nwgm:Um:g;)an ¬rUbTI 10-23b¦. edayGnuvtþm:Um:g;ÉktþaviC¢man enaHFñwmnwgdabdUcTItaMgbnÞat;dac;²
¬rUb TI 10-23c¦ Edlpþl;nUvExST§iBl. edayeRbIviFIkmøaMg nigRTwsþIersIuRbUkrbs;m:akSEvl eyIgGac
bgðajfa³
                          ⎛ 1 ⎞
                          ⎜ α ⎟ f DE
                     ME = ⎜    ⎟
                          ⎝ AA ⎠
emKuNmaRtdæanenATIenHKW (1/ α EE ) .


viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                   T.Chhay   -362
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                    viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa




dMeNIrkarkñúgkarviPaK (Procedure for analysis)
       CMhanxageRkampþl;nUvviFIsRmab;sg;ExST§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgRbtikmμ kmøaMgkat; nigm:Um:g;Bt;enA
Rtg;cMNucmYyenAelIFñwmedayeRbIbec©keTsm‘uyey:eRbsøÚ.
ragExSekagT§iBl
RbsinebIeKcg;kMNt;ExST§iBlrbs;cMNucmYyenAelIFñwm eKRtUvdklT§PaBTb;Tl;rbs;FñwmeTAnwgGnuKmn_
rbs;ExST§iBl edayCMnYsmkvijnUvtMN. RbsinebI GnuKmn_CakmøaMgRbtikmμbBaÄr eRbI vertical roller
guide, RbsinebIGnuKmn_CakmøaMgkat; eRbI sliding device, RbsinebIGnuKmn_Cam:Um:g;Bt; eRbIsnøak;. dak;

bnÞúkÉktþaenARtg;tMNedayeGayvamanGMeBIelIFñwmkñúgTisedAviC¢man. sg;ExSekagPaBdabrbs;Fñwm.
ExSekagenHCarUbragrbs;ExST§iBlsRmab;Fñwm.
témøExSekagT§iBl
RbsinebIeKRtUvkarkMNt;témøCaelxrbs;ExST§iBl eKRtUvKNnabMlas;TIéncMNucbnþbnÞab;tambeNþay
Fñwm enAeBlEdlFñwmrgbnÞúkÉktþaEdlmanGMeBIenARtg;tMNEdl)aneBalBIxagelI. EcktémøénbMlas;
TInImYy²edaybMlas;TIEdl)ankMNt;enARtg;cMNucEdlbnÞúkÉktþamanGMeBI. edayGnuvtþemKuNmaRt-
dæan eKnwgTTYl)antémøEdlCaGredaenrbs;ExST§iBl.

!0>!!> eKalkarN_mu‘yeyeRbsøÚsRmab;eRKag (Qualitative influence line for frames)
        eKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚCaviFIy:agelOnkñúgkarsg;ragTUeTArbs;ExST§iBlsRmab;eRKagsMNg;.
enAeBlEdleKsÁal;ragExST§iBl eKGackMNt;TItaMgrbs;bnÞúkGefrEdleFVIeGaymanT§iBlénGnuKmn_
¬kmøaMgRbtikmμ kmøaMgkat; b¤m:Um:g;Bt;¦ FMCageKenAelIeRKagPøam². Ca]TahrN_ rUbragrbs;ExST§iBl
sRmab;m:Um:g;viC¢manenARtg;cMNuckNþal I rbs;r:t FG rbs;eRKagenAkñúgrUbTI 10-24a Edlbgðaj
edaybnÞat;dac;. dUcenH eKGacdak;bnÞúkrayesμIEtenAelIr:t AB / CD nig FG edIm,IeFVIeGaym:Um:g;viC¢-
manenARtg;cMNuc I FMCageK. CamYynwgeRKagrgbnÞúkEbbenH ¬rUbTI 10-24b¦ eKGacviPaKeRKagedIm,I
KNnam:Um:g;eRKaHfñak;enARtg;cMNuc I .
Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                T.Chhay   -363
Department of Civil Engineering                                                            NPIC




]TarhN_ 10-11³ sg;ExST§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgRbtikmμbBaÄrenARtg;cMNuc A sRmab;FñwmenAkñúgrUbTI
10-25a. EI Catémøefr. sg;tMélCaelxral; 2m .




dMeNaHRsay³
yklT§PaBrbs;FñwmTb;Tl;nwgkmøaMgRbtikmμ Ay . eKGaceFVIvaeTA)anedayeRbI vertical roller device
EdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25b. edayGnuvtþbnÞúkÉktþabBaÄrenARtg;cMNuc A eKTTYl)anrUbragExS
T§iBldUceXIjenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25c.
        edIm,IkMNt;Gredaenrbs;ExST§iBl eyIgnwgeRbIviFIFñwmnimitþ (conjugate beam method).
kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;cMNuc A nigcMNuc B enAelIFñwmBit enAeBlrgbnÞúkÉktþaenARtg;cMNuc A RtUv)an
viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                               T.Chhay   -364
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                                  viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

bgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25b. FñwmnimitþEdlRtUvKñaRtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25d. cMNaMfaTMrenA
Rtg; A' enAEtrkSadUcTMrenARtg; A enAkñúgrUbTI 10-25b BIeRBaH vertical roller device enAelIFñwm
nimitþTb;Tl;m:Um:g; b:uEnþminTb;Tl;kmøaMgkat; EdlRtUvKñaeTAnwgbMlas;TI b:uEnþminEmnmMurgVilenARtg;TMr A
énFñwmBit ¬rUbTI 10-25c¦. kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMrrbs;FñwmnimitþRtUv)anKNna nigRtUv)anbgðajenA
kñúgrUbTI 10-25d. bMlas;TIéncMNucenAelIFñwmBit ¬rUbTI 10-25b¦ k¾RtUv)anKNna.
          sRmab; B' edaysarminmanm:Um:g;Bt;enAelIFñwmnimitþRtg;cMNuc B' ¬rUbTI 10-25d¦ enaH
                                 Δ B = M B' = 0
           sRmab; D' / rUbTI 10-25e
           ∑ M D' = 0            Δ D = M D' =
                                                     18
                                                        (2) − 1 ⎛ 2 ⎞(2)⎛ 2 ⎞ = 34.67
                                                                ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟
                                                     EI       2 ⎝ EI ⎠ ⎝ 3 ⎠     EI
           sRmab; C ' / rUbTI 10-25f
           ∑ M C' = 0            ΔC = M C' =
                                                    18
                                                       (4) − 1 ⎛ 4 ⎞(4)⎛ 4 ⎞ = 61.33
                                                               ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟
                                                    EI       2 ⎝ EI ⎠ ⎝ 3 ⎠     EI
           sRmab; A' / rUbTI 10-25d
                                                    72
                                 Δ A = M A' =
                                                    EI
edaysarkmøaMgbBaÄr 1kN manGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc A enAelIFñwmenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25a eFVIeGayman
kmøaMgRbtikmμ 1kN enARtg;cMNuc A . bMlas;TIenARtg;cMNuc A ¬ Δ A = 72 / EI ¦ KYrRtUvnwgtémø 1
sRmab;GredaenExST§iBlenARtg;cMNuc A . dUcenH edayEckbMlas;TIEdl)anKNnaedayemKuNenH
eyigTTYl)an
                                                     x                    Ay
                                                     A                    1
                                                    C                   0.852
                                                    D                   0.481
                                                     B                    0



           düaRkaméntémøTaMgenHCaExST§iBlEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25g.

]TarhN_ 10-12³ sg;ExST§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc D sRmab;FñwmenAkñúgrUbTI 10-
26a. EI Catémøefr. sg;tMélCaelxral; 3m .

Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                              T.Chhay   -365
Department of Civil Engineering                                                            NPIC




dMeNaHRsay³
yklT§PaBrbs;FñwmTb;Tl;nwgkmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc D . eKGaceFVIvaeTA)anedayeRbI roller device
EdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-26b. edayGnuvtþbnÞúkkmøaMgkat;ÉktþaenARtg;cMNuc D eKTTYl)anrUbrag
ExST§iBldUceXIjenAkñúgrUbTI 10-26c.
        kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg; A / B nig C enAelIFñwmBit enAeBlrgkmøaMgkat;ÉktþaenARtg;cMNuc D
RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-26b. FñwmnimitþEdlRtUvKñaRtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-26d. enATIenH
viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                               T.Chhay   -366
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                                      viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

eKRtUvGnuvtþm:Um:g; M D' enARtg;cMNuc D' edIm,IeFVIeGaym:Um:g;Bt;epSgKñaenAxageqVg nigxagsþaMcMNuc D' .
m:Um:g;Bt;TaMgenHRtUvKñanwgbMlas;TIxageqVg nigxagsþaMéncMNuc D enAelIFñwmBit ¬rUbTI 10-26c¦.
kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr A' / B' / C ' nigm:Um:g; M D' enAelIFñwmnimitþRtUv)anKNna nigRtUv)anbgðaj
enAkñúgrUbTI 10-26e. cUrepÞógpÞat;karKNnaeLIgvij.
         edaysarPaBdac;énm:Um:g;enARtg;cMNuc D' eKRtUvKNnam:Um:g;Bt;EdlenAxagsþaM nigxageqVg
cMNuc D' bnþic. sRmab;enAxageqVgcMNuc D' ¬rUbTI 10-26f¦ eyIg)an
∑ M D' L = 0                     Δ DL = M D' L =
                                                         4.5
                                                             (1) − 30 (3) = − 85.5
                                                         EI        EI          EI
enAxagsþaMgcMNuc D' ¬rUbTI 10-26g¦ eyIgman
∑ M D' R = 0                     Δ DR = M D' R =
                                                         4.5
                                                             (1) − 30 (3) + 144 = 58.5
                                                         EI        EI        EI    EI
BIrUbTI 10-26e
                                 Δ A = M A' = 0                       Δ B = M B' = 0     ΔC = M C' = 0
sMrab;cMNuc E ¬rUbTI10-26b¦ edayeRbIviFImuxkat;enARtg;cMNuc E' EdlRtUvKñaenAelIFñwmnimitþ ¬rUbTI
10-26h¦ eyIgman
∑ M E' = 0                       Δ E = M E' =
                                                    4.5
                                                        (1) − 6 (3) = − 13.5
                                                    EI        EI         EI
eKTTYl)anGredaenrbs;ExST§iBledayEcktémøxagelInwgemKuNmaRtdæan                             M D ' = 144 / EI      . eyIg
man
                                                     x                          VD
                                                   A                             0
                                                   DL                        − 0.594
                                                   DR                         0.406
                                                   B                             0
                                                   E                         − 0.0938
                                                   C                             0



düaRkaméntMélTaMgenHCaExST§iBlEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-26i.

]TarhN_ 10-13³ sg;ExST§iBlsRmab;m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;cMNuc D sRmab;FñwmenAkñúgrUbTI 10-27a.
EI   Catémøefr. sg;tMélCaelxral; 3m .

Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                                  T.Chhay   -367
Department of Civil Engineering                                                                         NPIC




dMeNaHRsay³
eKdak;snøak;enARtg;cMNuc D edIm,IdklT§PaBrbs;FñwmEdlTb;Tl;nwgm:Um:g;enARtg;cMNucenH ¬rUbTI 10-
27b¦. edaydak;m:Um:g;ÉktþaviC¢manenARtg; D eyIgTTYl)anExST§iBldUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-27c.
       kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;cMNuc A / B nig C enAelIFñwmBit enAeBlrgm:Um:g;enARtg;cMNuc D RtUv
)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-27b. FñwmnimitþRtUvKña nigkmøaMgRbtikmμrbs;vaRtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-
27d. eKesñIeGayepÞógpÞat;kmøaMgRbtikmμenAkñúgkrNITaMgBIr. BIrUbTI 10-27d cMNaMfa
                     Δ A = M A' = 0                   Δ B = M B' = 0         ΔC = M C' = 0
sRmab;cMNuc D' / rUbTI 10-27e
∑ M D' = 0                        Δ D = M D' =
                                                    1.5
                                                        (1) + 6 (3) = 19.5
                                                    EI        EI       EI
sRmab;cMNuc E ' / rUbTI 10-27f
∑ M E' = 0                        Δ E = M E' =
                                                    1.5
                                                        (1) − 2 (3) = 4.5
                                                    EI        EI      EI




viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg                                            T.Chhay   -368
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                          viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

bMlas;TImMu (angular displacement) α DD enARtg; D énFñwmBitenAkñúgrUbTI 10-27c RtUv)ankMNt;
edaykmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg; D' enAelIFñwmnimitþ. edIm,ITTYl)anGredaenrbs;ExST§iBl eKEcktémø
Edl)anKNnaxagelICamYynwgemKuN D' y = 16 / EI Edl
                                                     x                 MD
                                                    A                    0
                                                    D                  1.219
                                                    B                    0
                                                    E                 − 0.281
                                                    C                    0


           düaRkaméntMélTaMgenHCaExST§iBlEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-27g.




Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method                      T.Chhay   -369
Department of Civil Engineering                                                              NPIC



                                            cMeNaT
!0>!> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr nigbnÞab;mk !0>%> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr A nig B .
sg;düaRkamm:Um:g;sMrab;Fñwm. snμt;faTMrenA A Ca EI CatMélefr.
TMrbgáb; nigTMr B CaTMrkl;. EI CatMélefr.



!0>@> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr. snμt;faTMr    !0>^> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr bnÞab;mk
enA A CaTMrbgáb; nigTMr B CaTMrkl;. yk E =        sg;düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nigdüaRkamm:Um;g;Bt;.
200GPa . m:Um:g;niclPaBsMrab;kMNat;Ggát;          EI CatMélefr.

nImYy²RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUb.



                                             !0>&> FñwmRtUv)anRTedayTMrsnøak;enARtg;cMNuc
!0>#> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr A / B nig A RTedayrWus½rEdlmankMraj (stiffness) k enA
C bnÞab;mksg;düaRkamkMlaMgkat; nigm:Um:g;Bt; Rtg; B nigRTedayTMrkl;enARtg;cMNu C . kMNt;
sMrab;Fñwm. EI CatMélefr.                    kmøaMgrWus½rGnuvtþeTAelIFñwm. EI CatMélefr.



!0>$> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr A nigTMr B . !0>*> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr. snμt; B CaTMr
snμt;TMrenARtg;cMNuc A Gnuvtþm:Um:g;Bt;eTAelIFñwm. snøak; ehIy A nig C CaTMrkl;. EI CatMélefr.
EI CatMélefr.




                                                  !0>(> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr bnÞab;mk
                                                 sg;düaRkamm:Um;g;Bt;. snμt; A CaTMrsnøak; ehIy
cMeNaT                                                                            T.Chhay   -370
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                 viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

B   nig C CaTMrkl;. EI CatMélefr.



!0>!0> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr. snμt;TMr A CaTMr
snøak; ehIy B nig C CaTMrkl;. EI CatMélefr. !0>!$> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMrenAelIFñwm. CBa¢aMg
                                               enARtg;cMNuc A cl½teLIgelI 30mm . snμt;
                                               fa A CaTMrsnøak; ehIyTMr B nig C CaTMrkl; .
                                               yk E = 200GPa nig I = 90(106 )mm4 .

!0>!!> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr. snμt;TMr A CaTMr
snøak; ehIy B nig C CaTMrkl;. EI CatMélefr.


                                             !0>!%> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr bnÞab;sg;düaRkam
!0>!@> kMNt;PaBdabenARtg;cug B rbs;r)arEdk. m:Um:g;. snμt;faTMr A CaTMrsnøak; ehIy B nig C
rWus½rmankMraj k = 2 N / mm . r)arEdkmanTTwg CaTMr. EI mantémøefr.
5mm nigkMBs; 10mm . ehIy cUrsg;düaRkam

kmøaMgkat; nigm:Um:g;Bt;sMrab;r)arEdkenH. yk
 E = 200GPa .




                                                !0>!^> sg;düaRkamm:Um:g;sMrab;Fñwm. EI mantémø
                                                efr. snμt;faTMr A CaTMrbgáb; ehIy B nig C Ca
!0>!#> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr bnÞab;mksg; TMr.
düaRkamm:Um:g;. m:Um:g;niclPaBsMrab;kMNat;Ggát;
nImYy²RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUb. snμt;fa A nig
C CaTMrkl; nig B CaTMrsnøak;. yk E =

200GPa .
Problems                                                                        T.Chhay   -371
Department of Civil Engineering                                                             NPIC



!0>!&> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMrbgáb;    A     !0>@!> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr bnÞab;mksg;
nig B . EI mantMélefr.                            düaRkamm:Um:g;sMrab;Ggát;nImYy². snμt; A nig
                                                  B CaTMrsnøak; ehIytMNenARtg;cMNuc C CatMN

                                                  bgáb;. EI mantMélefr.


!0>!*> sg;düaRkamm:Um:g;Bt;sMrab;FñwmTMrbgáb;.
EI mantMélefr.




                                               !0>@@> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr bnÞab;mksg;
                                               düaRkamm:Um:g;sMrab;Ggát;nImYy². EI mantMél
!0>!(> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr.     EI   mantMél efr.
efr.




                                               !0>@#> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr bnÞab;mksg;
!0>@0> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr.     EI   mantMél düaRkamm:Um:g;sMrab;Ggát;nImYy². EI mantMél
efr.                                           efr.




cMeNaT                                                                           T.Chhay   -372
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

!0>@$> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr RbsinebITMrRtg; C   !0>@&> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgGgát;nImYy²rbs; truss .
RtUv)anrujeLIgelI 4mm . yk E = 200GPa            RkLaépÞmuxkat;rbs;Ggát;nImYy²RtUv)anbgðaj
/ I = 250(106 )mm4 .                             enAkñúgrUb. yk E = 200GPa . snμt;Ggát;
                                                 RtUv)antP¢ab;edaysnøak;.




!0>@%> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr A nig D . m:Um:g;
niclPaBrbs;kMNat;Ggát;RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUb.
yk E = 200GPa .                                !0>@*> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgGgát;nImYy²rbs; truss
                                               EdltP¢ab;edaytMNsnøak;. EA mantMélefr.




!0>@^> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgGgát;nImYy²rbs; truss . !0>@(> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;Ggát;         HG        rbs;
RkLaépÞmuxkat;rbs;Ggát;nImYy²RtUv)anbgðaj truss . EA mantMélefr.
enAkñúgrUb. snμt;Ggát;RtUv)antP¢ab;edaysnøak;.
yk E = 200GPa .



                                                 !0>#0> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;Ggát; HB rbs; truss
                                                 éncMeNaT !0>@(. EA mantMélefr.
Problems                                                                       T.Chhay   -373
Department of Civil Engineering                                                           NPIC



!0>#!> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;Ggát; HG . EA man
tMélefr.




!0>#@> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;Ggát;   BE   .   EA

mantMélefr.                                     !0>#%> eRKOgbgÁúMRTbnÞúkdUcbgðajenAkñúgrUb.
                                                cUrsg;düaRkamm:Um:g;Bt;sMrab;FñwmnImYy². yk
                                                I = 100(10 6 )mm 4 sMrab;Fñwm nig A = 200mm 2

                                                énsMrab;Edkr)ar. Ggát;TaMgGs;eFVIGMBIEdkEdl
                                                man E = 200GPa .

!0>##> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;Ggát; DF én truss .
EA mantMélefr.




                                             !0>#^> eKeRbI queen-post trussed beam edIm,I
                                             RTbnÞúkrayesμI 60kN / m . kMNt;kmøaMgEdlekIt
!0>#$> eKBüÜrcugFñwmkugs‘uledayEdkr)ar AC mankñúgr)arEdkTaMgR)aM. eKminKitkMras;rbs;Fñwm
EdlmanGgát;p©it 25mm . ehIyFñwmenHmanTMr nigsnμt;faGgát; truss RtUv)antP¢ab;eTAnwgFñwm
bgáb;enARtg;cMNuc B . kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;Edk edaytMNsnøak;. ehIyminKitT§iBlkmøaMgsgát;
r)arEdlbNþalBIbnÞúkrayesμI 60kN / m . E = tamG½kS nigkmøaMgkat;enAkñúgFñwm. RkLaépÞ
200GPa sMrab;Fñwm nigEdkr)ar.                muxkat;rbs;Edkr)arnImYy²KW 1800mm2 ehIy
                                             sMrab;Fñwm I = 235(106 )mm 4 . yk E =
cMeNaT                                                                         T.Chhay   -374
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                               viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

200GPa     .                                   kat;enAkñúgFñwm. Fñwm I b = 200(106 )mm4 ehIy
                                               sMrab;Edkr)arnImYy² A = 100mm 2 . yk
                                               E = 200GPa .




!0>#&> eKeRbI king-post trussed beam edIm,I
RTbnÞúkcMNuc 200kN EdlmanGMeBIenAkNþal
ElVg. kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;r)arEdkTaMgbI. Edk
r)arnImYy²manRkLaépÞmuxkat; 1250mm 2 .
snμt;faBYkvaRtUv)antP¢ab;edaytMNsnøak;. eK
minKitkMras;rbs;Fñwm nigT§iBlkmøaMgsgát; tam
G½kSenAkñúgFñwmeT. yk E = 200GPa sMrab;Fñwm !0>$!> sg;ExST§iBlsMrab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;
nigEdkr)ar. ehIy I AB = 150(106 )mm 4 .       cMNuc C . bgðajCatémøelxral; 5m . snμt; TMr
                                              B CaTMrkl;. EI mantémøefr.




                                               !0>$@> sg;ExST§iBlsMrab;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;
!0>#*> kMNt;m:Um:g;GtibrmaenAkñúgFñwmén        cMNuc C . bgðajCatémøelxral; 5m . EI man
cMeNaT !0>#&.                                  témøefr.
!0>#(> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr C . EI
mantMélefrsMrab;FñwmTaMgBIr.
                                               !0>$#> sg;ExST§iBlsMrab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;
                                               cMNuc B . bgðajCatémøelxral; 5m . snμt;TMr
                                               enARtg; A CaTMrkl; nig C CaTMrbgáb;. EI man
                                               témøefr.
!0>$0> eKRTFñwmkugs‘ul AB CamYynwgEdkr)ar
bEnßmcMnYnBIr.     kMNt;kmøaMgenAkñúgEdkr)ar
nImYy². eKminKitkmøaMgsgát;tamG½kS nigkmøaMg
Problems                                                                      T.Chhay   -375
Department of Civil Engineering                                                             NPIC



!0>$$> sg;ExST§iBlsMrab;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;    bnÞúkGefrrayesμIEdleFVIeGayekItmanGnuKmn_
cMNuc A éncMeNaT !0>$#.                          viC¢manGtibrma. snμt;faFñwmmanTMrbgáb;enARtg;
!0>$%> KUrRBagnUvExST§iBlsMrab;m:Um:g;Bt;enA    cMNuc F .
Rtg;cMNuc D edayeRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚ.
kMNt;m:Um:g;viC¢manGtibrmaenARtg;cMNuc D Edl
bNþalBIbnÞúkGefrrayesμI 5kN / m . EI man
témøefr. snμt; A CaTMrsnøak; ehIy B nig C        !0>$(> eRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,Isg;rag
CaTMrkl;.                                        TUeTAénExST§iBlsMrab; (a) m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;
                                                 cMNuc A nig (b) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc B .


!0>$^> KUrRBagnUvExST§iBlsMrab;kmøaMgkat;enA
Rtg;cMNuc B . RbsinebIFñwmenHrgbnÞúkGefrray
                                                 !0>%0> eRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,Isg;rag
esμI 6kN / m cUrkMNt;kmøaMgkat;viC¢manGtibrma
                                                 TUeTAénExST§iBlsMrab; (a) m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;
enARtg;cMNuc B . snμt; A CaTMrsnøak;. EI man
                                                 cMNuc A nig (b) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc B .
témøefr.



!0>$&> KUrRBagnUvExST§iBlsMrab;m:Um:g;Bt;enA
Rtg;cMNuc B éncMeNaT !0>$^. RbsinebIFñwmenH
                                                 !0>%!> eRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,Isg;rag
rgbnÞúkGefrray esμI 6kN / m cUrkMNt;m:Um:g;Bt;
                                                 TUeTAénExST§iBlsMrab; (a) m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;
viC¢manGtibrma enARtg;cMNuc B . snμt; A Ca
                                                 cMNuc A nig (b) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc B .
TMrsnøak;. EI man témøefr.
!0>$*> KUrRBagnUvExST§iBlsMrab; (a) kmøaMg
RbtikmμbBaÄrenARtg;cMNuc C (b) m:Um:g;Bt;enA
Rtg;cMNuc B nig (c) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc E .
enAkñúgkrNInImYy² cUrbgðajTItaMgEdlRtUvdak;
cMeNaT                                                                           T.Chhay   -376
mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil                                                viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa

!0>%@> eRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,Isg;rag   !0>%$> eRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,Isg;rag
TUeTAénExST§iBlsMrab; (a) m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;    TUeTAénExST§iBlsMrab; (a) m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;
cMNuc A nig (b) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc B .      cMNuc A nig (b) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc B .




!0>%#> eRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,Isg;rag
TUeTAénExST§iBlsMrab; (a) m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;
cMNuc A nig (b) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc B .




Problems                                                                       T.Chhay   -377

10. analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method

  • 1.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC !0> viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method CMBUkenHENnaMBIviFIkmøaMg b¤viFIPøicsIub‘IlIFI (force or flexibility method) edIm,IviFI truss Fñwm nigeRKagminGackMNt;edaysþaTic. enAcugbBa©b;énemeronmanbgðajBIviFIsRmab;sg;ExST§iBlsRmab; Fñwm b¤eRKagminGackMNt;edaysþaTic. !0>!> rcnasm<½n§minkMNt;edaysþaTic (Statically indeterminate structures) rMlwkBIkfaxNÐ 2.4 eRKOgbgÁúMRKb;RbePTEdlRtUv)ancat;cMNat;fñak;CaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;eday sþaTicenAeBlEdlcMnYnGBaØatEdlCakmøaMgRbtikmμ b¤kmøaMgkñúgelIsBIcMnYnsmIkarlMnwgEdlGacman sRmab;karviPaKenaH. enAkñúgkfaxNÐenH eyIgnwgBiPakSaBIviFIénkareRbIeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt; nigviFImUl- dæan cMnYnBIrEdleKRtUvkarviPaK. eyIgRtUvdwgfaeRKOgbgÁúMPaKeRcInEdlsikSaKNnasBVéf¶CaeRKOgbgÁúM minkMNt;edaysþaTic. cMnYnminkMNt;GacekIneLIgedaysarkarbEnßmTMr b¤Ggát; b¤edayTMrg;TUeTArbs; rcnasm<½n§. Ca]TahrN_ GKarebtugGarem:esÞIrEtTaMgGs;CaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTic edaysar ssr nigFñwmRtUv)ancak;CaGgát;Cab;Rtg;tMN nigRtg;TMr. KuNsm,tþi nigKuNvibtþi³ eTaHbICakarviPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicmanlkçN³sμúKsμajCagkar viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;edaysþaTick¾eday k¾eKenAEteRCIserIsvasRmab;karsikSaKNnaEdr edaysarCaTU eTAeKmanmUlehtuCaeRcIn. GVIEdlsMxan;CaeKKW sRmab;kardak;bnÞúkdUcKñakugRtaMgGtibrma nigPaBdab sRmab;eRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicmantémøtUcCagsRmab;eRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;edaysþaTic. Ca]TahrN_ eRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTic ¬FñwmTMrbgÁúM¦ enAkñúgrUbTI 10-1a nwgrgnUvm:Um:g;Bt;Gti`brma M max = PL / 8 b:uEnþFñwmTMrsamBaØ ¬rUbTI 10-1b¦ nwgrgnUvm:Um:g;Bt;eTVdgeBalKW M max = PL / 4 . CalT§pl FñwmTMrbgáb;manPaBdab;tUcCagbYndg nigmankugRtaMgBt;tUcCagBIrdgénFñwmTMrsamBaØenARtg;kNþal ElVg. ehtupld¾sMxan;mYyeTotkñúgkareRCIserIseRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicKWedaysarvaGacEbg EckbnÞúkrbs;vaeTATMrEdlmancMnYnelIs enAkñúgkrNIEdlmankarsikSaKNnamanlkçN³xusqÁg b¤k¾ kardak;bnÞúkelIsGacekItman. enAkñúgkrNITaMgenH rcnasm<½n§rkSasßirPaB nigkarBarkar)ak;rlM. va manlkçN³sMxan;CaBiess enAeBlEdlbnÞúkxag dUcCabnÞúkxül; b¤bnÞúkrBa¢ÜydImanGMeBIelIeRKOgbgÁúM. viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -334
  • 2.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa edIm,IbgðajBIlkçN³sMxan;enH cUrBicarNaFñwmTMrbgáb;enAkñúgrUbTI 10-1amþgeTot. enAeBlkmøaMg P ekIneLIg sMPar³rbs;FñwmenARtg;CBa¢aMg nigenARtg;kNþalElVgcab;epþImeFVIkardl;tMbl;yal (yield) ehIybegáIt)anCasnøak;)aøsÞic EdleFVIeGayFñwmdabdUckrNIFñwmEdltP¢ab;edaysnøak;enARtg;cMNuc enaH. eTaHbICaPaBdabmantémøFMk¾eday EtCBa¢aMgnwgbegáItkmøaMgRbtikmμtamTisedk nigm:Um:g;Rbti- kmμEdl nwgTb;FñwmBIkar)ak;TaMgRsug. enAkñúgkrNIFñwmTMrsamBaØ ¬rUbTI 10-1b¦ bnÞúkelIs P nigeFVI eGaysnøak;)aøsÞicekItmanEtenARtg;kNþalElVgrbs;Fñwm ehIyedaysarPaBdabmantémøFM TMrnwgmin begáItkmøaMgRbtikmμtamTisedk nigm:Um:g;RbtikmμEdlcaM)ac;sRmab;kar)ak;TaMgRsug. eTaHbICaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicGacRTbnÞúkCamYynwgGgát;esþIgCag nigmansßirPaBCag ebIeRbobeFobnwgrcnasm<½n§kMNt;edaysþaTick¾eday k¾mankrNIxøHKuNsm,tþiTaMgenHGacCMnYseday KuNvibtþivijEdr. eKRtUveRbobeFobtémøsMPar³EdlsnSMCamYynwgtémøbEnßmEdlcaM)ac;edIm,Isagsg; rcnasm<½n§enaH edaysareBlxøHeKRtUvkarcMNayfvikarCaeRcInkñúgkarsagsg;TMr nigtMNrbs;eRKOgbgÁúM minkMNt;edaysþaTicebIeRbobeFobeTAnwgrcnasm<½n§kMNt;edaysþaTic. EtGVIEdlsMxan;CagenH eday sareRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicmankmøaMgRbtikmμEdlCaGBaØat enaHeKRtUvRby½tñkñúgkarkarBarsMrut DIepr:g;Esülrbs;TMr BIeRBaHT§iBlenHnwgbegáItkugRtaMgxagkñúgenAkñúgeRKOgbgÁúM. Ca]TahrN_ Rbsin ebICBa¢aMgenAcugmçagénFñwmTMrbgáb;enAkñúgrUbTI 10-1a Rsut ehIykugRtaMgnwgekItmanenAkñúgFñwmeday sarkmøaMgEdlekItmanedaysarkMhUcRTg;RTayenH. mü:agvijeTot RbsinebIRtUv)anRTedayTMrsamBaØ b¤Carcnasm<½n§kMNt;edaysþaTic ¬rUbTI 10-1b¦ enaHtMruténcugrbs;vanwgmineFVIeGayFñwmxUcRTg;RTay ehIyvanwgmineFVIeGaymankugRtaMgekItmanenAkñúgFñwmeT. CaTUeTA RKb;kMhUcRTg;RTayTaMgGs;dUcCa kMhUcRTg;RTayedaysarEdlbNþalBIbMlas;TIrbs;TMr b¤bMErbMrYlrbs;RbEvgrbs;Ggát;EdlbNþalBI sItuNðPaB b¤edaysarkMhugqÁgkñúgkarplit nwgbegáItkugRtaMgbEnßmenAkñúgrcnasm<½n§ EdleKcaM)ac;RtUv KitBicarNaenAeBlsikSaKNnaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTic. viFIviPaK³ enAeBlviPaKrcnasm<½n§minkMNt;edaysþaTicTaMgGs; eKcaM)ac;RtUvbMeBjtMrUvkarlMnwg (equilibrium) PaBRtUvKña (compatibility) nigTMnak;TMngkmøaMg nigbMlas;TI (force-displacement) Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -335
  • 3.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC sRmab;rcnasm<½n§. lkçxNÐlMnwgRtUv)anbMeBjenAeBlEdlkmøaMgRbtikmμTb;rcnasm<½n§enAmYykEnøg ehIylkçxNÐRtUvKñaRtUv)anbMeBjenAeBlEdlkMNat;Ggát;CaeRcInrbs;rcnasm<½n§eFVIkarCamYyKñaeday minmankardac;xagkñúg b¤KgBIelIKña. tMrUvkarTMnak;TMngkmøaMg nigbMlas;TIGaRs½ynwgkareFVIkarrbs; sMPar³ enAkñúgGtßbTenHeyIgsnμt;fasMPar³eFVIkarCalkçN³eGLasÞiclIenEG‘r. CaTUeTA eKmanviFIBIr epSgKñaedIm,IbMeBjtMrUvkarTaMgenHenAeBlviPaKrcnasm<n§minkMNt;edaysþaTicKW viFIkmøaMg b¤viFIPøicsIu- ½ b‘IlIFI (force or flexibility method) nigviFIbMlas;TI b¤viFIPaBrwgRkaj (displacement or stiffness method). viFIkmøaMg³ viFIenHRtUv)anbegáIteLIgCadMbUgedayecmkøWkm:akesVl (James Clerk Maxwell) enAkñúgqñaM 1864 nigeRkaymk viFIenHRtUv)anEksMrYleGaymanlkçN³l¥RbesIredayGUtUmr (Otto Mohr) nig ehnrIcm‘uyeyeRbsøÚ (Heinrich Muller-Breslau). edaysarlkçxNÐRtUvKñabegáIteKalkarN_sRmab; viFIenH eBlxøHeKGacehAvaCaviFIxMepFIb‘IlIFI (compatibility method) b¤viFIbMlas;TIzitezr (method of consistent displacement). viFIenHRtUv)anbegáIteLIgedaykarsresrsmIkarEdlbMeBjlkçxNÐ RtUvKña nigtMrUvkarénTMnak;TMngkmøaMg nigbMlas;TIsRmab;eRKOgbgÁúMedIm,IkMNt;kmøaMgEdlCaGBaØatelIs. enAeBlEdleKkMNt;kmøaMgTaMgenHrYcehIy eKGackMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμEdlenAsl;edaybMeBjtMrUvkar lkçxNÐlMnwg. eKalkarN_mUldæanEdlBak;B½n§nwgkarGnuvtþviFIenHmanlkçN³gayRsYlyl; nigman lkçN³gayRsYlbegáIt ehIyvak¾RtUv)anelIkykmkBiPakSaenAkñúgCMBUkenHpgEdr. viFIbMlas;TI³ viFIenHEp¥kelIkarsresrTMnak;TMngrvagkmøaMg nigbMlas;TIsRmab;Ggát;CadMbUg bnÞab;mk Ep¥kelIkarsresrsmIkarlMnwgsRmab;eRKOgbgÁúM. enAkñúgkrNIenH GBaØatenAkñúgsmIkarKWbMlas;TI. enA eBlEdleKTTYl)anbMlas;TI eKGackMNt;kmøaMgBIlkçxNÐRtUvKña nigsmIkarTMnak;TMngrvagbMlas;TI nig kmøaMg. eyIgnwgsikSabec©keTsxøHEdleRbIedIm,IGnuvtþviFIbMlas;TIenAkñúgCMBUk11 nigCMBUk12. rUbmnþ ma:RTIsénviFIenHmanbgðajenAkñúgCMBUk14/ 15 nig16. viFInImYy²énviFITaMgBIrEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-2 manKuNsm,tþi nigKuNvibtþiGaRs½yeTAnwg ragFrNImaRtrbs;eRKOgbgÁúM nigdWeRkénPaBminkMNt;rbs;va. viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -336
  • 4.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa !0>@> dMeNIrkarTUeTAkñúgkarviPaKedayviFIkmøaMg (Force method of analysis: general procedure) meFüa)ayd¾l¥bMputkñúgkarbgðajeKalkarN_Edl Bak;B½n§nwgviFIkmøaMgKWBicarNaFñwmEdlbgðaj enAkñúgrUbTI 10-3a. RbsinebIeKKUrdüaRkamGgÁesrIrbs;va enaHvanwg mankmøaMgRbtikmμEdlCaGBaØatcMnYcbYn ehIyedaysarEt vaGacmansmIkarlMnwgcMnYnbIsRmab;karedaHRsay enaHFñwm enHCarcnasm½<n§dWeRkTImYy. dUcenH eKcaM)ac;RtUvkarsmIkar bEnßmcMnYnmYysRmab;edaHRsay. edIm,ITTYlsmIkarenH eyIgnwgeRbIeKalkarN_tMrYtpl nigBicarNalkçN³RtUv KñaénbMlas;TIenARtg;TMrmçag. eKGacviPaKFñwmenHeday eRCIserIskmøaMgRbtikmμTMrmYyCaGBaØatelIs ehIydk vaecjBIFñwmCabeNþaHGasnñ enaHFñwmenHnwgkøayCaeRKOg bgÁúMkMNt;edaysþaTic nigmansßirPaB. FñwmenHeKeGay eQμaHfaeRKOgbgÁúMbzm (primary structure). enATIenH eyIgnwgykkmøaMgRbtikmμrbs;TMrkl;Rtg;cMNuc B ecj. CalT§pl bnÞúk P nwgeFVIeGaycMNuc B pøas;TIcuHeRkam edaybrimaN Δ B dUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-3b. b:uEnþ edayviFItMrYtpl kmøaMgRbtikmμEdlCaGBaØatenARtg;cMNuc B eBalKW B y eFVIeGayFñwmenARtg;cMNuc B pøas;TIeLIgelIedaybrimaN Δ'BB ¬rUbTI 10-3c¦. enATIenHGkSr B dMbUgsMedAelIcMNuc B EdlRtUv karkMNt;PaBdab ehIyGkSr B TIBIrsMedAelIcMNuc B EdlkmøaMgRbtikmμEdlCaGBaØatmanGMeBI. eday bMlas;TIviC¢manEdl)ansnμt;manGMeBIeLIgelI enaHBIrUbTI 10-3a rhUtdl;rUbTI 10-3c eyIgGac sresrsmIkarRtUvKñaEdlcaM)ac;enARtg;TMrkl;Ca (+ ↑) 0 = −Δ B + Δ' BB LÚveyIgsMKal;bMlas;TIenARtg;cMNuc B EdlbNþalBIbnÞúkÉktþaEdlmanGMeBItamTisrbs; B y eday emKuNPøicsIub‘IlIFIlIenEG‘r (linear flexibility coefficient) f BB ¬rUbTI 10-3d¦. edaykareRbInimitþ sBaØakñúgTMrg;RsedogKña f BB CaPaBdabenARtg;cMNuc B EdlbNþalBIbnÞúkÉktþaenARtg;cMNuc B . edaysarsMPar³manlkçN³eGLasÞiclIenEG‘r kmøaMg B y EdlmanGMeBIIenARtg;cMNuc B ¬CMnYseGay Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -337
  • 5.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC bnÞúkÉktþa¦ nwgeFVIeGaymankMeNInPaBdabsmamaRtnwg f BB . dUcenHeyIgGacsresr Δ' BB = B y f BB BIkarsresrkúñgTMrg;EbbenH eyIgeXIjfaemKuN linear flexibility f BB manxñatKitCaPaBdabkñúgmYy ÉktþakmøaMg eBalKW m / N b¤ mm / N .l. dUcenHeKGacsresrsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñaxagelIeday eRbIGBaØat B y Ca 0 = −Δ B + B y f BB edayeRbIviFIénCMBUk8 nig9 b¤edayeRbItaragPaBdabenAkñúgCMBUk9 eKGacTTYl)anTMnak;TMngrvag bMlas;TI nigkmøaMgsRmab;PaBdab Δ B ¬rUbTI 10-3b¦ nig flexibility coefficient f BB ¬rUbTI 10- 3d¦ ehIyeKGacedaHRsayrk B y )an Edl B y = Δ B / f BB . eRkayeBledaHRsayrkkmøaMgRbtikmμ EdlCaGBaØatelIsrYcehIy eKGacedaHRsayrkkmøaMgRbtikmμbIeTotenARtg;CBa¢aMg A BIsmIkarlMnwg. dUcGVIEdl)anerobrab;BIxagedIm eKeRCIserIs GBaØatelIsedayminRbkan;. ]TahrN_ eKGackMNt; m:Um:g;enARtg;cMNuc A ¬rUbTI 10-4a¦ edaypÞal;eday dklT§PaBrbs;FñwmedIm,ITb;Tl;nwgm:Um:g; Rtg; A ecj eBalKWCMnYsTMrbgáb;edayTMrsnøak;. dUcbgðajenAkñúg rUbTI 10-4b mMurgVilenARtg;cMNuc A EdlbNþalBI bnÞúk P KW θ A ehIymMurgVilenARtg; A EdlbNþalBI M A EdlCaGBaØatelIenARtg; A KW θ ' AA ¬rUbTI 10- 4c¦. RbsinebIeyIgkMNt;nimitþsBaØarbs; angular flexibility coefficient Ca α AA Edlmann½yfamMu rgVilenARtg;cMNuc A EdlekItBIm:Um:g;mYyÉktþaman GMeBIenARtg;cMNuc A ¬rUbTI 10-4d¦ enaH θ ' AA = M Aα AA dUcenH angular flexibility coefficient manxñatKitCa mMurgVilkñúgmYYyÉktþam:Um:g; dUcenHvamanxñat rad / N .m b¤ rad / kN .m .l. dUcenHsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñasRmab;mMurgVilenARtg;cMNuc A tMrUveGay ( +) 0 = θ A + M Aα AA enAkñúgkrNIenH M A = −θ A / α AA mantémøGviC¢man mann½yfa M A manGMeBIpÞúynwgm:Um:g;mYyÉktþa. viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -338
  • 6.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa ]TahrN_TIbIEdlbgðajBIkarGnuvtþénviFIkmøaMgRtUv )aneGayenAkñúgrUbTI 10-5a. enATIenH FñwmCarcnasm<½n§ minkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTIBIr dUcenHeKRtUvkarsmIkar lkçxNÐRtUvKñacMnYnBIrsRmab;eFVIkar edaHRsay. eyIgnwg eRCIserIskmøaMgbBaÄrenARtg;TMr B nig C Ca GBaØatelIs. eRkayeBldkGBaØatelIsecj FñwmkMNt;edaysþaTicman PaBdabdUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-5b. kmøaMgEdlCa GBaØatelIs nImYy²EdlRtUv)ansnμt;eGaymanGMeBIcuH eRkameFVIeGayFñwmmanPaBdabdUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-5c nig 10-5d erogKña. enATIenH eKkMNt; flexibility coefficient * f BB nig f CB BIkmøaMgÉktþamanGMeBIenARtg; cMNuc B ¬rUbTI 10-5e¦ ehIyeKkMNt; fCC nig f BC BIkmøaMgÉktþamanGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc C ¬rUbTI 10-5f¦. edayviFItMrYtpl smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñasRmab;PaBdabRtg; cMNuc B nig C KW (+ ↓) 0 = Δ B + B y f BB + C y f BC (+ ↓) 0 = Δ C + B y f CB + C y f CC (10-1) eRkayeBlbegáItTMnak;TMngbnÞúk nigbMlas;TIedayeRbIviFI enAkñúgCMBUk 8 nig9 eKGacedaHRsayRbB½n§smIkarenHedIm,I rk B y nig C y . edaysarkarGnuvtþviFIkmøaMgRtUv)anbgðajtamry³]TahrN_ eyIgnwgBiPakSakarGnuvtþrbs;va kñúgn½yTUeTA ehIybnÞab;mkeyIgnwgeRbIvaCamUldæansRmab;edaHRsaycMeNaTEdlTak;Tgnwg truss, Fñwm nigeRKag. b:uEnþsRmab;krNITaMgGs;enH eyIgRtUvdwgfa edaysarviFIenHGaRs½ynwgkartMrYtplén bMlas;TI eKcaM)ac;RtUveGaysMPar³enAEteFVIkarkñgEdneGLasÞiclIenEG‘renAeBlEdlvargbnÞúk. ehIy ú eyIgk¾RtUvdwgEdrfa eKGackMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμ nigkmøaMgkñúgTaMgGs;enARtg;cMNucmYyenAkñúgeRKOgbgÁúM edayyklT§PaBRTRTg;bnÞúkrbs;eRKOgbgÁúMecj ehIybnÞab;mksresrsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñaenARtg; * CaPaBdabenARtg;cMNuc B EdlbNþalBIkmøaMgÉktþaenARtg;cMNuc B f BB f CB CaPaBdabenARtg;cMNuc C EdlbNþalBI kmøaMgÉktþaenARtg;cMNuc B . Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -339
  • 7.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC cMNucenaH ¬emIl]TahrN_ 10-5¦. dMeNIrkarkñúgkarviPaK (Procedure for analysis) CMhanxageRkampþl;nUvviFITUeTAsRmab;kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμ b¤kmøaMgkñúgrbs;rcnasm<½n§minkMNt; edaysþaTicedayeRbIviFIkmøaMg b¤viFIPøicsIub‘IlIFI. eKalkarN_tMrYtpl kMNt;cMnYndWeRkminkMNt; n rbs;rcnasm<½n§. bnÞab;mkkMNt;GBaØatelIs n CakmøaMg b¤Cam:Um:g;EdlRtUv dkecjCabeNþaHGasnñBIrcnasm<½n§edIm,IeFVIeGayvaeTACaeRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;edaysþaTic nigmansßirPaB. edayeRbIviFItMrYtpl KUreRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTic nigbgðajfavaesμIeTAnwges‘rIéneRKOgbgÁúMkMNt; edaysþaTicEdlRtUvKña. rcnasm<½n§dMbUgCaeRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;edaysþaTicEdlRTbnÞúkxageRkAdUceRKOgbgÁúM minkMNt;edaysþaTic ehIyrcnasm<½n§déTepSgeTotCarcnasm<½n§kMNt;edaysþaTicbEnßmeTAelIrcna sm<½ndMbUg ehIyfaRTbnÞúk b¤m:Um:g;EdlCaGBaØatelIsdac;edayELkBIKña. ehIyKUrExSekageGLasÞic enAelIrcnasm<½n§nImYy² nigbgðajnimitþsBaØabMlas;TI b¤nimitþsBaØamMurgVilrbs;kMlaMg b¤m:Um:g;EdlCa GBaØatelIs. smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña sresrsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñasRmab;bMlas;TI nigmMurgVilenARtg;cMNucnImYy²EdlmankmøaMg b¤m:Um:g; EdlCaGBaØatelIs. eKKYrsresrsmIkarTaMgenHedayeRbIGBaØatelIs nig flexibility coefficient Edl RtUvKñarbs;vaEdl)anBIbnÞúkÉktþa b¤m:Um:gÉktþaEdlRtUvKñanwgkmøaMg b¤m:Um:g;elIs. ; kMNt;PaBdab nig flexibility coefficient TaMgGs;edayeRbItaragenAkñúgCMBUk9 b¤eRbIviFIenAkñúg CMBUk8 b¤CMBUk9 . CMnYsTMnak;TMngrvagbMlas;TI nigkmøaMgeTAkñúgsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña ehIyedaHRsay * rkGBaØatelIs. RbsinebItémøCaelxrbs;GBaØatelIsGviC¢man vabgðajfaGBaØatelIsmanGMeBIpÞúyeTA nwgkmøaMgÉktþa b¤m:Um:g;Éktþa. smIkarlMnwg sg;düaRkamGgÁesrIrbs;rcnasm<½n§. edaysareyIg)anKNnakmøaMg nig/b¤m:Um:g;EdlCaGBaØatelIsrYc ehIy eyIgGackMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμEdlCaGBaØatEdlenAesssl;BIsmIkarlMnwg. * eKesñIfa RbsinebIdüaRkam M / EI sRmab;FñwmmanlkçN³samBaØ eKGaceRbIRTwsIRkLaépÞm:Um:g; b¤viFIFñwmnimitþ. eKGackMNt; FñwmEdlmandüaRkam M / EI sμúKsμajenARKb;cMNucenAelIrcnasm<½n§edayeRbIviFIEdl)anerobrab;sRmab;eRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;eday sþaTic. viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -340
  • 8.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa eyIgKYrdwgfa enAeBlEdleyIgTTYl)ankmøaMgRbtikmμTMrTaMgGs;rYcehIy eyIgGacsg; düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nigdüaRkamm:Um:g; ehIyeyIgGackMNt;PaBdabenARKb;cMNucTaMgGs;enAelIeRKOg bgÁúMedayeRbIviFIEdlmanerobrab;sRmab;rcnasm<½n§kMNt;edaysþaTic. !0>#> RTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUkrbs;m:akSEvl c,ab;ebFI Maxwell’s theorem of reciprocal displacement; Betti’s law enAeBlEdlm:akSEvl)anbegáItviFIkmøaMg Kat;k¾)anpSBVpSayRTwsþIEdlTak;TgeTAnwgeTAnwg flexibility coefficient énBIrcMNucenAelIrcnasm<½n§eGLasÞicEdlmandUcCa truss, Fñwm b¤eRKag. eK GacehARTwsþIenHfaRTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUk EdleBaldUcteTA³ bMlas;TIrbs;cMNuc B enAelIeRKOgbgÁúM EdlbNþalBIbnÞúkÉktþaEdlmanGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc A esμIeTAnwgbMlas;TIrbs;cMNuc A enAeBlEdl bnÞúkÉktþamanGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc B eBalKW f BA = f AB . eKbkRsayRTwsþIenHedayRsYledayeRbIeKalkarN_kmμnþnimitþ. Ca]TahrN_ BicarNaFñwmenA kñúgrUbTI 10-6. enAeBlbnÞúkÉktþaBitmanGMeBIenARtg; A snμt;fam:Um:g;Bt;enAkñúgFñwmtameday m A . edIm,IkMNt; flexibility coefficient enARtg; B eBalKW f BA eKRtUvdak;bnÞúkÉktþanimitþenARtg;cMNuc B ¬rUbTI 10-7¦ ehIyeKkMNt;m:Um:t;Bt; mB . edayGnuvtþsmIkar 9-18 eyIg)an mB m A f BA = ∫ dx EI dUcKña RbsinebIeKkMNt; flexibility coefficient f AB enAeBlkmøaMgÉktþaBitmanGMeBIenARtg; cMNuc B ¬rUbTI10-7¦ enaH mB Cam:Um:gBt;enAkñúgFñwmEdlbNþalBIkmøaMgÉktþaBit. mü:agvijeTot m A Cam:Um:g;Bt;EdlbNþalBIkmøaMgÉktþanimitþenARtg;cMNuc A ¬rUbTI 10-6¦. dUcenH m A mB f AB = ∫ dx EI GaMgetRkalTaMgBIrpþl;nUvlT§pldUcKñaEdlRtUvnwgBMenalrbs;RTwsþI. RTwsþIenHk¾GacGnuvtþ sRmab;mMurgVilersIuRbUkEdr EdlRTwsþIenHeBaldUcteTA³ mMurgVilenARtg;cMNuc B enAelIeRKOgbgÁúMEdl bNþalBIm:Um:g;ÉktþaEdlmanGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc A esμInwgmMurgVIlenARtg;cMNuc A enAeBlm:Um;g;manGMeBI enARtg;cMNuc B . elIsBIenH edayeRbIkmøaMg nigm:Um:g;ÉktþaEdlGnuvtþenAelIrcnasm<½n§Rtg;cMNucdac; Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -341
  • 9.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC edayELkBIKña eyIgk¾GaceBaldUcteTA³ mMurgVilKitCara:düg;enARtg;cMNuc B enAelIrcnasm<½n§Edl bNþalBIbnÞúkÉktþaEdlmanGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc A esμInwgbMlas;TIenARtg;cMNuc A enAeBlm:Um:g;Éktþa manGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc B . Cavi)akénRTwsþIenH eKGacsnSMsMéckargar)anxøHenAeBlGnuvtþviFIkmøaMgedIm,IedaHRsaycMeNaT Edlrcnasm<½n§Carcnasm<<½n§minkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTIBIr b¤eRcInCagenH. ]TahrN_ eKRtUvkarkMNt; flexibility coefficient EtmYyb:ueNÑaHkñúgcMeNam f BC nig f CB enAkñúgsmIkar 10-1 edaysar f BC = f CB . elIsBIenH eKGaceRbIRTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUkenAkñúgkarkarviPaKrcnasm<½n§ nigsRmab;sg;ExS T§iBledayeRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyeyeRbsøÚ ¬emIlkfaxNÐ 10.10¦. enAeBleKeFIVeGayRTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUkmanTMrg;kan;EtTUeTA eKeGayeQμaHvafac,ab;ebFI. c,ab;enHeBaly:agsegçbfa³ kmμnþnimitþ δU AB eFVIedayRbB½n§kmøaMg ∑ PB CamYynwgbMlas;TIEdlbNþal BIRbB½n§kmøaMg ∑ PA esμIeTAnwgkmμnþnimitþ δU BA EdlbNþalBIkmøaMg ∑ PA enAeBlrcnasm<½n§xUcRTg; RTayedaysarRbB½n§kmøaMg ∑ PB . eKGacniyaymü:ageTotfa δU AB = δU BA . karbkRsaynUv BMenalenHmanlkçN³dUcKñanwgkarbkRsayRTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUkxagelI. !0>$> karviPaKFñwmtamviFIkmøaMg (Force method of analysis: Beams) viFIkmøaMgEdlGnuvtþeTAelIFñwmRtUv)anerobrab;enAkñúgkfaxNÐ 10-2. edayGnuvtþtamkarerob rab;BIdMeNIrkarviFIEdlmanEcgenAkñúgkfaxNÐ 10-2 eyIgnwgbgðajBI]TahrN_CaeRcInEdlENnaMBIkar Gnuvtþbec©keTsenH. ]TarhN_ 10-1³ kMNt;RbtikmμTMrenARtg;TMrkl; B rbs;FñwmEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-8a. EI Ca témøefr. viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -342
  • 10.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa dMeNaHRsay³ eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ tamkarGegát FñwmCaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTImYy. eKnwgyk B y Ca GBaØatelIs dUcenHeKGackMNt;kmøaMgenHedaypÞal;. rUbTI 10-8b bgðajBIkarGnuvtþéneKalkarN_ tMrYtpl. cMNaMfa karykGBaØatelIsecjTamTareGayykTMrkl; b¤karTb;rbs;FñwmtamTis By ecj. enATIenH eyIgsnμt;fa B y eFVIGMeBIeTAelIFñwmedaymanTisedAeLIgelI. smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ edayykbMlas;TIviC¢manmanTisedAeLIgelI ¬rUbTI 10-8b¦ eyIg)an (+ ↑) 0 = −Δ B + B y f BB (1) eKGacTTYl)antY Δ B nig f BB edaygayedayeRbItaragenAkñúCMBUk9. cMNaMfa Δ B = ΔC + θC (6m) dUcenH P(L / 2)3 P(L / 2)2 ⎛ L ⎞ ΔB = + ⎜ ⎟ 3EI 2 EI ⎝ 2 ⎠ = (50kN )(6m )3 + (50kN )(6m )2 (6m ) = 9000kN .m3 ↓ 3EI 3EI EI PL3 1(12m ) 576m33 f BB = = = ↑ 3EI 3EI EI edayCMnYslT§plTaMgenHeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) eyIg)an (+ ↑) 0=− 9000 ⎛ 576 ⎞ + By ⎜ ⎟ B y = 15.6kN EI ⎝ EI ⎠ RbsinebIeKdak;kmøaMgRbtikmμenHeTAelIdüaRkamGgÁesrIrbs;Fñwm eKGacTTYlkmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg; A BIsmIkarlMnwgbI ¬rUbTI 10-8c¦. eRkayeBlkMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTaMgGs; eKGacsg;düaRkamm:Um:g;dUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-8d. ]TarhN_ 10-2³ kMNt;m:Um:g;enARtg;CBa¢aMgbgáb;sRmab;FñwmEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-9a. EI Ca témøefr. dMeNaHRsay³ eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ eyIgnwgyk M A CaGBaØatelIs edaysareyIgGackMNt;m:Um:g;enHedaypÞal;. rUbTI 10-8b bgðajBIkarGnuvtþéneKalkarN_tMrYtpl. enATIenH eyIgdklT§PaBrbs;FñwmTb;Tl;nwg m:Um:g;enARtg;TMr A . eyIgsnμt;fa M A eFVIGMeBIRcasRTnicnaLika. smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ edayykmMurgVilviC¢manvilRcasRTnicnaLika ¬rUbTI 10-9b¦ eyIg)an ( +) 0 = θ A + M Aα AA (1) eKGackMNt;tY θ A nig α AA BItaragenAkñúgtaragkñúgCMBUk9. eyIg)an Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -343
  • 11.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC ML 30kN .m(3m ) 15kN .m 2 θA = = = 6 EI 6 EI EI ML 1(3m ) 1m α AA = = = 3EI 3EI EI edayCMnYseTAkñúgsmIkar (1) eyIg)an 15 ⎛ 1 ⎞ ( +) 0= + M A⎜ ⎟ M A = -15kN.m EI ⎝ EI ⎠ sBaØaGviC¢manbgðajfa M A eFVIGMeBIpÞúyeTAnwgGVIEdl)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-9b. enAeBleyIgdak; kmøaMgRbtikmμenHeTAelIFñwm eyIgGackMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμdéTeTotBIsmIkarlMnwg ¬rUbTI 10-9c¦. düaRkamm:Um:g;RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-9d. ]TarhN_ 10-3³ sg;düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nigdüaRkamm:Um:gsRmab;FñwmEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10- ; 10a. TMr B mansMrut 40mm . yk E = 200GPa / I = 500(106 )mm4 . dMeNaHRsay³ eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ tamkarGegát FñwmenHCaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTImYy. eyIgeRCIs erIsTMrkNþal B CaGBaØatelIs dUcenHeyIgRtUvdkTMrkl;enARtg; B ecj ¬rUbTI 10-10b¦. enATIenH eyIgsnμt;fa B y manTisedAcuHeRkam. smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ eyagtamcMNuc B enAkñúgrUbTI 10-10b nigedayeRbIxñatEm:Rt eyIg)an (+ ↓) 0.04 = Δ B + B y f BB (1) viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -344
  • 12.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa enATIenHeyIgnwgeRbIviFIFñwmRtUvKñaedIm,IKNna Δ B nig f BB edaysardüaRkamm:Um:g;pSMeLIgedaybnÞat; Rtg;. sRmab; Δ B epÞógpÞat;karKNnaEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-10c. cMNaMfa + ∑ M B' = 0 − M B' + 800 (2.667 ) − 1000 (8) = 0 EI EI 5866.67 5867 M B' =− = EI EI epÞógpÞat;karKNnaenAkñúgrUbTI 10-10d sRmab;karKNna f BB . cMNaMfa + ∑ M B' = 0 − mB ' + 16 (2.667 ) − 16 (8) = 0 EI EI 85.33 85.33 mB ' = − = EI EI edayCMnYslT§plTaMgenHeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) eyIg)an 5866.67 ⎛ 85.33 ⎞ 0.04 = + By ⎜ ⎟ EI ⎝ EI ⎠ Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -345
  • 13.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC edayCMnYs E nig I Caelx eyIg)an (0.04m )(200)(106 )kN / m 2 ][500(106 )(10−12 )m 4 ] = 5866.67 + B y (85.33) [ B y = −21.875kN smIkarlMnwg³ sBaØaGviC¢manbgðajfa By eFVIGMeBIelIFñwmedaymanTisedAeLIgelI. BIdüaRkamGgÁesrI EdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-10e eyIg)an +∑MA = 0 − 100(4) + 21.875(8) + C y (16) = 0 C y = 14.06kN + ↑ ∑ Fy = 0 Ay − 100 + 21.875 + 14.06 = 0 Ay = 64.06kN edayeRbIlT§plTaMgenH epÞógpÞat;düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nigdüaRkamm:Um:g;Bt;EdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10- 10f. ]TarhN_ 10-4³ sg;düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nigdüaRkamm:Um:g;sRmab;FñwmEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10- 11a. EI mantémøefr. ecalT§iBlrbs;kmøaMgtamG½kS. viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -346
  • 14.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa dMeNaHRsay³ eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ edaysareyIgecalbnÞúktamG½kS FñwmCarcnasm<½n§minkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTI mYy. eyIgKitm:Um:g;cugTaMgBIrenARtg;cMNuc A nig B CaGBaØatelIs. eKRtUvdklT§PaBrbs;FñwmEdlTb; Tl;nwgm:Um:g; edayCMnYsTMrsnøak;enARtg;cMNuc A nigTMrkl;enARtg;cMNuc B . eKalkarN_tMrYtplEdl GnuvtþeTAelIFñwmRtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-11b. smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ eyagtamcMNuc A nigcMNuc B ¬rUbTI 10-11b¦ tMrUveGay ( +) 0 = θ A + M Aα AA + M Bα AB (1) ( +) 0 = θ B + M Aα BA + M Bα BB (2) eyIgGackMNt;mMurgVilEdlRtUvkar nig angular flexibility coefficient edayeRbItaragenAkñúgCMBUk 9. eyIg)an 3wL3 3(30 )(6 )3 151.9 θA = = = 128 EI 128 EI EI 7 wL3 7(30 )(6 )3 118.1 θB = = = 384 EI 384 EI EI ML 1(6) 2 α AA = = = 3EI 3EI EI ML 1(6) 2 α BB = = = 3EI 3EI EI ML 1(6) 1 α AB = = = 6 EI 6 EI EI cMNaMfa α AB = α BA CalkçN³sMxan;rbs;RTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUkrbs;m:akSEvl. edayCMnYsTinñn½yxagelIeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) nig (2) eyIg)an 151.9 ⎛ 2 ⎞ ⎛ 1 ⎞ 0= + M A⎜ ⎟ + M B ⎜ ⎟ EI ⎝ EI ⎠ ⎝ EI ⎠ 118.1 ⎛ 1 ⎞ ⎛ 2 ⎞ 0= + M A⎜ ⎟ + M B ⎜ ⎟ EI ⎝ EI ⎠ ⎝ EI ⎠ edaysMrYl EI nigedayedaHRsayRbB½n§smIkarTaMgenH eyIg)an M A = −61.9kN .m M B = −28.1kN .m edayeRbIlT§plTaMgenH eyIgGackMNt;kmøaMgkat;xagcugFñwm ¬rUbTI 10-11c¦ ehIyeyIgGacsg; düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nigdüaRkamm:Um:g;. ]TarhN_ 10-5³ kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMrsRmab;FñwmEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-12a. EI mantémø efr. Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -347
  • 15.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC dMeNaHRsay³ eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ edaykarGegát FñwmenHCaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTImYy. enATIenH eyIgnwgeRCIserIsm:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;TMr B CaGBaØatelIs. Cavi)ak eyIgnwgkat;FñwmenHedaydac;ecjBIKña ehIydak;TMrsnøak; b¤TMrkl;enARtg;cMNuc B edIm,IdklT§PaBrbs;FñwmEdlTb;Tl;nwgm:Um:g;enARtg;cMNuc enH ¬rUbTI 10-12b¦. eKeGaym:Um:g;Bt;manGMeBIelIFñwmenAkñúgrUbTI 10-12c. smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ BIrUbTI 10-12a eyIgtMrUveGay ( +) 0 = θ B + M Bα BB Edl θ B = θ ' B +θ "B nig α BB = α ' BB +α "BB eKGackMNt;mMurgVil nig angular flexibility coefficient BItaragenAkñúgCMBUk 9 Edl wL3 2(3.6 )3 3.888kN .m 2 θ 'B = = = 24 EI 24 EI EI PL2 2.5(3)2 1.406kN .m 2 θ "B = = = 16 EI 16 EI EI ML 1(3.6 ) 1.2m α ' BB = = = 3EI 3EI EI viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -348
  • 16.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa ML 1(3) 1m α "BB = = = 3EI 3EI EI 3.888kN .m 2 1.406kN .m 2 ⎛ 1.2m 1m ⎞ dUcenH EI + EI + MB⎜ ⎝ EI + ⎟=0 EI ⎠ M B = −2.406kN .m sBaØadkbgðajfa M B eFVIGMeBItamTisedApÞúyeTAnwgkarbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-12c. edayeRbIlT§pl enH eyIgGackMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμdUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-12d. elIsBIenH düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nig düaRkamm:Um:g;Bt;RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-12e. !0>%> karviPaKeRKagtamviFIkmøaMg (Force method of analysis: Frames) viFIkmøaMgmanPaBgayRsYlkñúgkaredaHRsayeRKagminkMNt;edaysþaTicmYyCan; nigmanrag FrNImaRtminFmμtadUcCa gabled frames. sRmab;edaHRsayeRKagminkMNt;eRcInCan; b¤eRKOgbgÁúMEdl mandWeRkminkMNt;x<s; eKeRbIviFIsøÚbDIPøicsin ¬slope-deflection) b¤viFIEbgEckm:Um:g; (moment- distribution) b¤viFIsÞIveNs (stiffness method) Edlnwgerobrab;enAkñúgemeronxagmux. ]TahrN_xageRkambgðajBIkarGnuvtþénviFIkmøaMgedayeRbIdMeNIrviFIdUcerobrab;enAkñúgkfaxNÐ 10-2. ]TarhN_ 10-6³ kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMrrbs;eRKagEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-13a. EI mantémø efr. Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -349
  • 17.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC dMeNaHRsay³ eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ edaykarGegát eRKagCarcnasm<½n§minkMNt;dWeRkTImYy. eyIgnwgeRCIserIskmøaMg RbtikmμtamTisedkenARtg; B CaGBaØatelIs. dUcenH eyIgCMnYssnøak;enARtg; B edayTMrkl; edaysar TMrkl;minTb;cMNuc B tamTisedk. dUcenHeKalkarN_tMrYtplEdlGnuvtþeTAelIeRKagRtUv)anbgðajenA kñúgrUbTI 10-13b. smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ eyagtamcMNuc B enAkñúgrUbTI 10-13b tMrUveGay + (→) 0 = Δ B + Bx f BB (1) eKGackMNt;tY Δ B nig f BB edayeRbIviFIkmμnþnimitþ. kUGredaen x rbs;eRKag nigm:Um:g;Bt;RtUv)anbgðaj enAkñúgrUbTI10-13c nig10-13d. eKcaM)ac;RtUveCIserIskUGredaen x1 nig x2 dUcKñasRmab;krNI nImYy² ¬TaMgsRmab;bnÞúkBit nigsRmab;bnÞúknimitþ¦. ehIyTisedAviC¢masRmab; M nig m k¾RtUvEtdUcKña. sRmab; Δ B eyIgtMrUveGaybnÞúkBit ¬rUbTI 10-13c¦manGMeBIenAelIeRKag nigbnÞúkÉktþanimitþ manGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc B ¬rUbTI 10-13d¦. dUcenH L Mm 5 (20 x1 − 4 x1 )(0.8 x1 )dx1 2 4 0(1x2 )dx2 ΔB = ∫0 dx = EI ∫0 EI + ∫0 EI 166.7 166.7 = +0= EI EI sRmab; f BB eyIgtMrUveGaybnÞúkÉktþaBit nigbnÞúkÉktþanimitþmanGeBIenARtg;cMNuc B ¬rUbTI 10- 13d¦. dUcenH 5 (0.8 x1 ) dx1 4 (1x2 ) dx2 2 2 L mm f BB = ∫ dx = ∫ +∫ 0 EI 0 EI 0 EI 26.7 21.3 48.0 = + = EI EI EI edayCMnYsTinñn½yxagelIeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) nigedayedaHRsay eyIgTTYl)an 166.7 ⎛ 48.0 ⎞ 0= + Bx ⎜ ⎟ Bx = −3.47kN EI ⎝ EI ⎠ smIkarlMnwg³ edaybgðaj Bx enAelIdüaRkamGgÁesrIrbs;eRKagedayeRbITisedARtwmRtUv ¬rUbTI 10- 13e¦ nigedayGnuvtþsmIkarlMnwg eyIgTTYl)an + → ∑ Fx = 0 Ax − 3.47 = 0 Ax = 3.47kN +∑MA = 0 − 40(2.5) + B y (5) − 3.47(4) = 0 B y = 22.8kN + ↑ ∑ Fy = 0 Ay − 40 + 22.8 = 0 Ay = 17.2kN viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -350
  • 18.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa ]TarhN_ 10-7³ kMNt;m:Um:g;enARtg;TMrbgáb; A rbs;eRKagEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-14a. EI mantémøefr. dMeNaHRsay³ eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ eRKagenHCaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;dWeRkTImYy. eKGacTTYldMeNaHRsaysRmab; M A edaypÞal;edayeRCIserIsvaCaGBaØatelIs. dUcenHeyIgGacdklT§PaBrbs;eRKagTb;Tl;nwgm:Um:g; Rtg; A dUcenHeyIgGaceRbITMrsnøak;enARtg;cMNuc A . eKalkarN_tMrYlplEdlGnuvtþeTAelIeRKag RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-14b. smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ eyagtamcMNuc B enAkñúgrUbTI 10-14b tMrUveGay ( +) 0 = θ A + M Aα AA (1) dUc]TahrN_mun² eKGacKNna θ A nig α AA edayeRbIviFIkmμnþnimitþ. kUGredaen x rbs;eRKag nigm:Um:g;Bt;RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-14c nig10-14d. sRmab; θA eyIgTamTarnUvkarGnuvtþrbs;bnÞúkBit ¬rUbTI 10-14c¦ nigm:Um:g;ÉktþanimitþenARtg;cMNuc A ¬rUbTI 10-14d¦. dUcenH Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -351
  • 19.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC MmθL θA = ∑ ∫ dx 0 EI =∫ 2.4 (0.13 x1 )(1 − 0.278 x1 )dx1 +∫ ( 1.5 1.34 x2 − 0.75 x2 (0.222 x2 )dx2 2 ) 0 EI 0 EI 0.209 0.124 0.333 = + = EI EI EI sRmab; α AA eyIgTamTarnUvkarGnuvtþrbs;m:Um:g;ÉktþaBit nigm:Um:g;ÉktþanimitþEdlmanGMeBIenARtg; cMNuc A ¬rUbTI 10-14d¦. dUcenH L mθ mθ α AA = ∑ ∫ dx 0 EI =∫ 2.4 (1 − 0.278 x2 )2 dx1 + 1. 5 (0.222 x2 )2 dx2 0 EI ∫0 EI 1.155 0.555 1.21 = + = EI EI EI edayCMnYslT§plTaMgenHeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) nigedayedaHRsayeyIgTTYl)an 0.333 ⎛ 1.21 ⎞ 0= + M A⎜ ⎟ M A = −0.275kN .m EI ⎝ EI ⎠ sBaØadkbgðajfa M A manGMeBItamTisedApÞúyeTAnwgGVIEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI10-14b. !0>^> karviPaK truss tamviFIkmøaMg (Force method of analysis: Trusses) CaTUeTA eKGackMNt;dWeRkminkMNt;rbs; truss edaykarGegát b:uEnþRbsinebIeKmankarlM)ak kñúgkareFVIEbbenH eKGaceRbIsmIkar 3-1 (b + r > 2 j ) . enATIenH GBaØatRtUv)ansMEdgedaycMnYnkmøaMg r)ar (b) bUknwgkmøaMgRbtikmμTMr (r ) ehIycMnYnsmIkarlMnwgEdlGacmanKW (2 j ) edaysareKGac sresrsmIkarBIrsRmab;tMN ( j ) nImYy². viFIkmøaMgCaviFImYyEdlmanlkçN³smRsbkñúgkarviPaK truss minkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTImYy b¤TIBIr. ]TahrN_xageRkambgðajBIkarGnuvtþrbs;vFIenHedayeRbIdMeNIrkarviPaKEdlerobrab;enAkñúg i kfaxNÐ 10-2. ]TarhN_ 10-8³ kMNt;kmøaMgenAkñúgGgát; AC rbs; truss EdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-15a. EI mantémøefrsRmab;RKb;Ggát;TaMgGs;. dMeNaHRsay³ eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ tamkarGegát truss enHCaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTImYy . edaysar * * edayGnuvtþsmIkar (3-1) b + r > 2 j b¤ 6 + 3 > 2(4) / 9 > 8 / 9 − 8 = 1 viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -352
  • 20.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa eKkMNt;kmøaMgenAkñúgGgát; AC edayeRCIserIsvaCaGBaØatelIs. eKRtUvkat;Ggát;enHedIm,IkMueGayvaman kmøaMg ehtudUcenHehIy truss enHkøayCarcnasm<½n§kMNt;edaysþaTic nigmansßirPaB. eKalkarN_ tMrYtEdlGnuvtþeTAelI truss RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-15b. smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ edayeyageTAtamGgát; AC enAkñúgrUbTI 10-15b eyIgtMrUveGaybMlas;TI Δ AC EdlekIteLIgenAxagcugGgát;Edlkat; AC EdlbNþalBIbnÞúk 2kN bUknwgbMlas;TI FAC f ACAC EdlbNþalBIkmøaMgEdlCaGBaØatelIsEdlmanGMeBIEtÉgesμIsUnü enaH 0 = Δ AC + FAC f ACAC (1) enATIenH flexibility coefficient f ACAC CabMlas;TIenARtg;cMNuccugkMNt;Ggát;Edlkat;rbs; AC Edl bNþalBIbnÞúkÉktþaBitEdlmanGMeBIenARtg;cugEdlrgkarkat;énGgát; AC . tYr f ACAC nig Δ AC RtUv )ankMNt;edayeRbIviFIkmμnþnimitþ. karviPaKkmøaMgedayeRbIviFItMNRtUv)ansegçbenAkñúgrUbTI 10-15c nig 10-15d. sRmab; Δ AC eyIgtMrUveGaymankarGnuvtþénkmøaMgBit 2kN ¬rUbTI 10-15c¦ nigkmøaMgÉktþa nimitþmanGMeBIenARtg;cugrgkarkat;énGgát; AC ¬rUbTI 10-15d¦. dUcenH Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -353
  • 21.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC nNL Δ AC = ∑ AE ⎡ (− 0.8)(2)(2.4) ⎤ ⎡ (− 0.6 )(0 )(1.8)⎤ ⎡ (− 0.6)(1.5)(1.8) ⎤ = 2⎢ ⎥+⎢ ⎥+⎢ ⎥ ⎣ AE ⎦ ⎣ AE ⎦ ⎣ AE ⎦ ⎡ (1)(− 2.5)(3)⎤ ⎡ (1)(0)(3) ⎤ +⎢ ⎥ + ⎢ AE ⎥ ⎣ AE ⎦ ⎣ ⎦ 16.8 =− AE sRmab; f ACAC eyIgtMrUveGaymankarGnuvtþkmøaMgÉktþaBit nigkmøaMgÉktþanimitþenARtg;cugkMNt;Edl rgkarkat;énGgát; AC ¬rUbTI 10-15d¦. dUcenH n2 L f ACAC = ∑ AE ⎡ (− 0.8)2 (2.4) ⎤ ⎡ (− 0.6)2 (1.8) ⎤ ⎡ (1)2 (3) ⎤ = 2⎢ ⎥ + 2⎢ ⎥+⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎣ AE ⎥ ⎦ ⎢ ⎣ AE ⎥ ⎢ AE ⎥ ⎦ ⎣ ⎦ 10.37 = AE edayCMnYsTinñn½yTaMgenHeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) nigedayedaHRsay eyIg)an 16.8 10.37 0=− + FAC AE AE FAC = 1.62kN (T ) edaysarlT§plCaelxmantémøviC¢man enaH AC rgkmøaMgTajdUckarsnμt; ¬rUbTI 10-15b¦. eday eRbIlT§plenH eyIgGackkMNt;kmøaMgenAkñúgGgát;déTedayeRbIviFItMN nigsmIkarlMnwg. ]TarhN_ 10-9³ kMNt;kmøaMgenAkñúgGgát;nImYy²én truss EdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-16a Rbsin ebIeKeRbIekALak;enAelIGgát; AC edIm,IeFVIeGayGgát;enHxøICagGgát; BD RbEvg 12.5mm . Ggát; nImYy²manmuxkat; 125mm2 nig E = 200GPa . dMeNaHRsay³ eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ Truss enHmanragFrNImaRtdUcnwg truss enAkñúg]TahrN_ 10-8. edaysareK eFVIeGayGgát; AC rYjxøI eyIgnwgeRCIserIsvaCaGBaØatelIs ¬rUbTI 10-16b¦. smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ edaysarminmanbnÞúkxageRkAmanGMeBIelIeRKOgbgÁúM (truss) edIm dUcenHvamin manbMlas;TIenAcenøaHcugkMNat;rgkarkat;rbs;Ggát;edaysarbnÞúkeT eBalKW Δ AC = 0 . Flexibility coefficient f ACAC RtUv)ankMNt;rUcehIyenAkñúg]TahrN_ 10-8 dUcenH 10.37 f ACAC = AE viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -354
  • 22.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa edaysnμt;brimaNrYjxøIrbs;Ggát;mantémøviC¢man dUcenHsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñasRmab;Ggát;KW 10.37 0.0125m = 0 + FAC AE edaydwgfa f ACAC CabMlas;TIkñúgmYyÉktþakmøaMg eyIg)an 10.37 m 0.0125m = 0 + (125mm )(200kN / mm ) F 2 2 AC dUcenH FAC = 30.14kN = 30.1kN (T ) edaysarminmankmøaMgxageRkAmanGMeBIelI truss kmøaMgRbtikmμTMresμIsUnü. dUcenH edayeRbI FAC nigedayviPaK truss edayviFItMN eyIgTTYl)anlT§pldUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-16c. !0>&> eRKOgbgÁúMkMub:UsIut (Composite structures) eRKOgbgÁúMkMub:UsIutpSMeLIgedayGgát;xøHEdlrgEtnwgkmøaMgtamG½kS xN³Ggát;déTeTotrgkar Bt;. RbsinebIvaCarcnasm<½n§minkMNt;edaysþaTic viFIkmøaMgmanlkçN³gayRsYlkñúgkareRbIsRmab; viPaKva. ]TahrN_xageRkambgðajBIdMeNIrkarviPaKeRKOgbgÁúMEbbenH. ]TarhN_ 10-10³ FñwmEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-17a RtUv)anRTedayTMrsnøak;enARtg;cMNuc A nigP¢ab;eTAnwgr)arBIrEdlmanTMrsnøak;enARtg;cMNuc B . kMNt;kmøaMgenAkñúgGgát; BD . yk E = 200GPa / I = 300( 6 )mm 4 sRmab;Fñwm nig A = 1800mm 2 sRmab;r)ardéTeTot . 10 Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -355
  • 23.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC dMeNaHRsay³ eKalkarN_tMrYtpl³ tamkarGegát FñwmCaeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;edaysþaTicdWeRkTImYy. sRmab;karedaH Rsay eKeRCIserIskmøaMgenAkñúgGgát; BD CaGBaØatelIs. dUcenH eKRtUvkat;Ggát;enHedIm,IlubbM)at; lT§PaBTb;Tl;kmøaMgrbs;va. eKalkarN_tMrYtplEdlGnuvtþeTAelIeRKOgbgÁúMRtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI ¬rUbTI 10-17b¦. smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKña³ edayeyagtambMlas;TIénGgát; BD Edlrgkarkat; ¬rUbTI 10-17b¦ eyIg tMrUveGay 0 = Δ BD + FBD f BDBD (1) eyIgGaceRbIviFIkmμnþnimitþedIm,IKNna Δ BD nig f BDBD . karviPaKkmøaMgEdlcaM)ac;RtUv)anbgðajenA kñúgrUbTI 10-17c nig10-17d. viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -356
  • 24.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa sRmab; Δ BD eyIgtMrUveGaymankarGnuvtþkmøaMgBit ¬rUbTI 10-17c¦ nigkmøaMgnimitþÉktþa GnuvtþenARtg;cugrgkarkat;rbs;Ggát; BD ¬rUbTI 10-17d¦. enATIenH eyIgnwgBicarNaEtfamBlbMEr bMrYlrageFobEdlbNþalBIkarBt; nigbNþalBIkmøaMgtamG½kSenAkñúgFñwmEtb:ueNÑaH. dUcenH Mm L nNL Δ BD = ∫ dx + ∑ 0 EI AE =∫ ( ) ( 3 30 x − 3.33 x (0 )dx (− 69.3)(− 0.816 ) 1.8 / cos 30 o 3 + + ) ( (0)(1) 1.8 / cos 45o ) 0 EI AE AE 117.5 =0+ + 0 = 0.0003264m = 0.326mm 1800(20) sRmab; f BDBD eyIgtMrUveGaymankarGnuvtþrbs;bnÞúkBitÉktþa nigbnÞúkÉktþanimitþenARtg;cug kMNat;Ggát;rgkarkat;rbs;Ggát; BD ¬rUbTI 10-17d¦. dUcenH L m 2 dx n2 L f BDBD = ∫ +∑ 0 EI AE =∫ 3 (0)2 dx + (− 0.816)2 (1.8 / cos 30o ) + (1)2 (1.8 / cos 45o ) 0 EI AE AE = 3.93 ( ) 1800(200 ) = 1.092 10 − 5 m / kN edayCMnYsTinñn½yEdl)anrkBIxagelIeTAkñúgsmIkar (1) eyIg)an 0 = Δ BD + FBD f BDBD 0 = 0.0003264 + FBD (1.092 ) 10 −5 ( ) FBD = −29.9kN = 29.9kN (C ) edayeRbIlT§plTaMgenH KUrdüaRkamGgÁesrIsRmab;Fñwm ehIybgðaj FBC = 44.9kN (C ) / Ax = 1.31kN nig Ay = 30.0kN . !0>*> kMNt;sMKal;bEnßmelIkarviPaKtamviFIkmøaMg (Additional remarks on the force method of analysis) enAeBlenHedaysareKalKMniténviFIkmøaMgRtUv)anGPivDÄ eyIgnwgbnþeFVIeGaykarGnuvtþrbs;va manlkçN³TUeTA ehIyeyIgnwgBiPakSaBIplRbeyaCn_rbs;va. enAeBlKNna flexibility coefficient fij b¤ αij sRmab;rcnasm<½n§ eKRtUvcMNaMfavaGaRs½y Et nwglkçN³sMPar³ niglkçN³FrNImaRtrbs;Ggát; nigminGaRs½ynwgkardak;bnÞúkelIeRKOgbgÁúMdMbUg (primary structure) eT. dUcenH enAeBlEdltémøTaMgenHRtUv)anKNna eKGaceRbIvaedIm,IKNna kmøaMgsRmab;RKb;kardak;bnÞúkTaMgGs;. Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -357
  • 25.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC sRmab;rcnasm<½n§EdlmanGBaØat Rn elIscMnYn n eyIgGacsresrsmIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñacMnYn n Edl Δ1 + f11R1 + f12 R2 + L + f1n Rn = 0 Δ 2 + f 21R1 + f 22 R2 + L + f 2n Rn = 0 M Δ n + f n1R1 + f n 2 R2 + L + f nn Rn = 0 enATIenH bMlas;TI Δ1 / >>>/ Δ n bNþalmkBIbnÞúkBitEdlmanGMeBIenAelI primary structure nigbNþalBI sMrutrbs;TMr b¤bNþalBIbMErbMrYlsItuNðPaB b¤kMhusqÁgkñúgkarplitGgát;. edIm,IsMrYldl;karKNna rcnasm<½n§EdlmandWeRkminkMNt;x<s; eKGacsresrsmIkarxagelICaragm:aRTIsdUcxageRkam ⎡ f11 f12 L f1n ⎤ ⎧ R1 ⎫ ⎧ Δ1 ⎫ ⎢f ⎥⎪R ⎪ L f 2n ⎥ ⎪ 2 ⎪ ⎪Δ ⎪ ⎢ 21 f 22 ⎪ 2⎪ ⎨ ⎬ = −⎨ ⎬ (10-2) ⎢ M ⎥⎪ M ⎪ ⎪ M ⎪ ⎢ ⎥⎪ ⎪ ⎪Δ n ⎪ ⎣ f1n f 2 n L f nn ⎦ ⎩ Rn ⎭ ⎩ ⎭ b¤ f R = −Δ CaBiess eKRtUvcMNaMfa fij = f ji ( f12 = f 21, etc.) tamRTwsþIm:akSEvlénbMlas;TIrIsIuRbUk ¬b¤c,ab;ebFI¦. dUcenH flexibility matrix Cam:aRTIssIuemRTI ehIyTMrg;enHmanRbeyaCn_enAeBledaH RsaysMnMusmIkarlIenEG‘rFM² dUcenAkñúgkrNIrcnasm<½n§EdlmandWeRkminkMNt;x<s;. enAkñúgCMBUkenH eyIg)ankMNt; flexibility coefficient edayeRbIviFIkmμnþnimitþ edaysarvaGnuvtþ eTAelIeRKOgbgÁúMTaMgmUl. b:uEnþ eKGacTTYlemKuNsRmab;Ggát;nImYy²sRmab;eRKOgbgÁúMTaMgmUleday eRbIsmIkarbMElg (transformation equation) edIm,ITTYltémøTaMgenH sRmab;eRKOgbgÁúMTaMgmUl. viFIenH RtUv)anerobrab;enAkñúgesovePAEdlniyayGMBIkarviPaKeRKOgbgÁúMedaym:aRTIs nigminRtUv)anerobrab;enA kñúgesovePAenHeT*. eTaHbIkarlMGitsRmab;karGnuvtþviFIkmøaMgedayeRbIviFIkMuBüÚT½rk¾minRtUv)anelIkykmkniyayenA kñúgesovePAenHk¾eday k¾eyIgGaceFIVkarGegátTUeTA nigeFVImUlvicarenAeBleRbIviFIenHedIm,IedaHRsaycM- eNaTEdlmandWeRkminkMNt;x<s;. Tak;TgnwgbBaðaenH edIm,ITTYl)andMeNaHRsaykan;EtsuRkiteKRtUv eGay flexibility coefficient EdlenAEk,rGgát;RTUgrbs;m:aRTIs f FMCag flexibility coefficient EdlenAq¶ay. edIm,ITTYl)anEbbenH eKRtUvBicarNakñúgkareRCIserIs primary structure. edIm,IsMrYl kúñgkarKNna fij eKENnaMeGayeRCIserIs primary structure y:agNaeGayvaCaeRKOgbgÁúMsIuemRTI. kareFVIEbbenHnwgeGayeyIgTTYl)an flexibility coefficient xøHdUcKña b¤k¾GacesμIsUnü. cugeRkay rUb * emIl H.C. Martin, Introduction to Matrix Methods of Structural Analysis, McGraw-Hill, New York Ca]TahrN_. viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -358
  • 26.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa ragxUcRTg;RTayrbs; primary structure nwgRsedognwgrUbragxUcRTg;RTayrbs;rcnasm<½n§Cak;Esþg. RbsinebIeKGaceFVIEbbenH)anEmn enaHeKRtUvkarEksMrYlGBaØatEtbnþicbnÞÜcb:ueNÑaHeTAelI primary structure EdleFVIeGayeKTTYl)anlT§plEdl)anBIsmIkar 10-2 kan;EtsuRkit. !0>(> eRKOgbgÁúMsIuemRTI (Symmetric structures) karviPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminkMNt;lMdab;x<s;k¾dUckarviPaKeRKOgbgÁúMkMNt;edaysþaTic GñksikSaKNna RtUvdwgfaeRKOgbgÁúMenaHCaeRKOgbgÁúMEdlmanTMr b¤bnÞksIuemRTI b¤minsIuemRTI. kñúgn½yTUeTA eKGaccat;cM- ú Nat;eRKOgbgÁúMCaeRKOgbgÁúMsIuemRTIRbsinebIkmøaMgkñúg nigPaBdabrbs;vamanlkçN³qøúHKñaeFobnwgG½kS kNþalrbs;va. CaTUeTA PaBsIuemRTITamTareGaysMPar³ ragFrNImaRt TMr nigbnÞúkRtUvEtdUcKñaenAsg xageRKOgbgÁúM. b:uEnþ vaminEmnTal;EtdUecñaHTaMgGs;eT. cMNaMfa sRmab;sßirPaBtamTisedk eKRtUvkar TMr snøak;edIm,IRTFñwm nig truss ¬rUbTI 10-18a nig 10-18b¦. enATIenH kmøaMgRbtikmμtamTisedk enA Rtg;snøak;esμIsUnü dUcenHrcnasm<½n§enHnwgmankmøaMgkñúg nigPaBdabqøúHKña. CalT§pl eKGaccat; cMNat;fñak;vaCarcnasm<½n§sIuemRTI. eKRtUvdwgfavaminEmnCakrNIsRmab;eRKageT ¬rUbTI 10- 18c¦Rbsin ebIeKCMnYsTMrbgáb;enARtg;cMNuc A edayTMrsnøak; enaHrUbragdab nigkmøaMgkñúgenAxagsþaM nigxageqVg nwgmindUcKñaeT. enAeBlxøH eRKOgbgÁúMsIuemRTIRTbnÞúkminsIuemRTI dUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-19. kñúgkrNIrcna sm<½n§manlkçN³sIuemRTI nigbnÞúkrbs;vamanlkçN³sIuemRTI b¤minsIuemRTI enaHeKnwgeFVIkarviPaKeRKOg bgÁúMEtmYykMNat;b:ueNÑaH edaysarlT§pldUcKña b¤pÞúyKñanwgekItmanEtenAelIrcnasm<½n§mYykMNat;. Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -359
  • 27.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC RbsinebIrcnasm<½n§sIuemRTIrgbnÞúkminsIuemRTI enaHeKRtUvbMElgvaeGayeTACabgÁúMbnÞúksIuem- RTI nigbgÁúMbnÞúkminsIuemRTI. edIm,IeFVI EbbenH dMbUgeKRtUvEckbnÞúknwgBIr bnÞab;mkeTot eK dak;eGayvamanlkçN³sIuemRTI nigminsIuemRTI. Ca]TahrN_ eKRtUvEckbnÞúk enAelIFñwmkñúgrUb TI 10-20a nwgBIr rYcdak;eGayva qøúHKñaeFob nwgG½kSsIuemRTI. bnÞab;mkeKTTYl)anbgÁúM bnÞúksIuemRTI nigminsIuemRTI dUcbgðajenAkñúg rUbTI 10-20b. enAeBlEdleKbUkbgÁúMbnÞúk TaMgBIrenHbBa©ÚlKña eKnwgTTYl)anbnÞúkedIm. eKGaceFVIkarviPaKrcnasm<½n§dac;edayELk eTAelIbgÁúMbnÞúksIuemRTI nigbgÁúMbnÞúkminsIuemRTI ehIyeKRtUveFVIplbUkénlT§pl TaMgenHedIm,ITTYl)anlkçN³eFVIkaredImrbs; rcnasm<½n. !0>!0> ExST§iBlsRmab;FñwmminkMNt;edaysþaTic (Influence lines for statically indeterminate beams) enAkñúgkfaxNÐ 6-3 eyIg)ansikSarYcmkehIyBIkareRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,IKUrExS T§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgRbtikmμ kmøaMgkat; nigm:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;cMNucmYyenAelIFñwmkMNt;edaysþaTic. enA kñúgkfaxNÐenH eyIgnwgBnøatviFIenH nigeRbIvasRmab;FñwmminkMNt;edaysþaTic. rMlwkfa sRmab;Fñwm eKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚeBalfaExST§iBlsRmab;GnuKmn_ ¬kmøaMgRbtikmμ kmøaMgkat; b¤m:Um:g;Bt;¦ manrUbragdabrbs;FñwmmanlkçN³dUcKñaenAeBlFñwmrgGMeBIedayGnuKmn_RtUvKña. edIm,IKUrrUbragdabeGay)anRtwmRtUv eKRtUvdklT§PaBTb;Tl;nwgkarGnuvtþrbs;GnuKmn_ enaHFñwmGacdab viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -360
  • 28.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa enAeBlGnuKmn_manGMeBIelIFñwm. sRmab;FñwmkMNt;edaysþaTic rUbragdab ¬b¤ExST§iBl¦ Caes‘rIénkM- Nat;bnÞat;Rtg;. sRmab;FñwmminkMNt;edaysþaTic ExST§iBlnwgmanlkçN³CaExSekag. eyIgnwgsikSa BI sMNg;énRbePT nImYy²rbs;ExST§iBlTaMgbiI ¬kmøaMgRbtikmμ kmøaMgkat; nigm:Um:g;Bt;¦ sRmab;rcna sm<½n§minkMNt;edaysþaTic. enAkñúgkrNInImYy² eyIgnwgbgðajBIPaBeRbIkar)anéneKalkarN_ m‘uyey:eRbsøÚ edayeRbIRTwsþIbMlas;TIersIuRbUkrbs;m:akSEvl. RbtikmμenARtg;cMNucA³ edIm,IkMNt;ExST§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;cMNuc A enAkñúgrUbTI 10- 21a eKdak;bnÞúkÉktþaenAelIFñwmRtg;cMNucbnþbnÞab; ehIyenARtg;cMNucnImYy²eKRtUvkMNt;kmøaMg RbtikmμenARtg;cMNuc A . düaRkaménlT§plTaMgenHCaExST§Bl. Ca]TahrN_ enAeBlbnÞúkenARtg; cMNuc D ¬rUbTI 10-21a¦ eKGackMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;cMNuc A EdlCaGredaenrbs;ExST§iBl enARtg; D edayeRbIviFIkmøaMg. edIm,IeFIVy:agenH eKRtUvGnuvtþeKalkarN_tMrYtpldUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-21a rhUtdl;rUbTI 10-21c. dUcenH smIkarlkçxNÐRtUvKñasRmab;cMNuc A KW 0 = f AD + Ay f AA b¤ Ay = − f AD / f AA b:uEnþtamRTwsþIbMlas;TIersIiuRbUkrbs;m:akSEvl f AD = − f DA ¬rUbTI 10-21d¦ dUcenHeyIgk¾GackMNt; Ay ¬b¤Gredaenrbs;ExST§iBlenARtg;cMNuc D ¦ edayeRbIsmIkar ⎛ 1 ⎞ ⎜ f ⎟ f DA Ay = ⎜ ⎟ ⎝ AA ⎠ edayeFVIkareRbobeFob eKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚtMrUveGayykTMrenARtg; A ecj ehIyGnuvtþ bnÞúkÉktþabBaÄrenARtg;cMNucenaH. ExSekagPaBdabEdlTTYl)an ¬rUbTI 10-21d¦ manTMrg;dUcKñanwg rUbragrbs;ExST§iBlsRmab; Ay . b:uEnþ BIsmIkarxagelIeyIgeXIjfaemKuNmaRtdæan (scale factor) KW 1 / f AA . Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -361
  • 29.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC kmøaMgkat;enARtg; E³ RbsinebIeKRtUvkarkMNt; ExST§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc E rbs; FñwmenA kñúgrUbTI 10-22a tameKalkarN_ m‘uyey:eRbsøÚ eKRtUvkat;FñwmRtg;cMNucenaH ehIy s‘k sliding device enARtg;cMNucenaH ¬rUbTI 10-22b¦. ]bkrN_enHnwgbBa¢Únm:Um:g;Bt; nig kmøaMgEkg b:uEnþminbBa¢ÚnkmøaMgkat;eT. enAeBl Fñwm dabedaysarkmøaMgkat;ÉktþaviC¢manEdlman GMeBIenARtg;cMNuc E mMurgVilenAsgxag]bkrN_ mantémødUcKña ehIyExSekagPaBdabCaExS T§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc E rUbTI 10-22c. edayGnuvtþviFIeKalsRmab;sg;ExST§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc E enaHeKcaM)ac; GnuvtþkmøaMgÉktþaenARtg;cMNucnImYy² dUcCacMNuc D ehIykMNt;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc E ¬rUbTI 10-22a¦. témø VE CaGredaenrbs;ExST§iBlenARtg;cMNuc D . edayeRbIviFIkmøaMg nigRTwsþIbMlas;TI ersIuRbUkrbs;m:akSEvl ¬dUckrNIelIkmun¦ eyIgTTYl)an ⎛ 1 ⎞ VE = ⎜ ⎜f ⎟ f DE ⎟ ⎝ EE ⎠ kmøaMgkat;ÉktþaviC¢manEdlGnuvtþeTAelIFñwmenARtg;cMNuc E ¬rUbTI 10-22c¦ nwgeFVIeGayFñwmdabkñúg TMrg;CaExST§iBl sRmab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc E . enATIenHemKuNmaRtdæanKW (1 / f EE ) . m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg; E³ eKGackMNt;ExST§iBlsRmab;m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;cMNuc E enAkñúgrUbTI 10-23a edayCMnYssnøak;enARtg;cMNucenaH edaysartMNEbbenHbBa¢ÚnkmøaMgEkg nigkmøaMgkat; b:uEnþminGacTb; Tl; nwgm:Um:g;)an ¬rUbTI 10-23b¦. edayGnuvtþm:Um:g;ÉktþaviC¢man enaHFñwmnwgdabdUcTItaMgbnÞat;dac;² ¬rUb TI 10-23c¦ Edlpþl;nUvExST§iBl. edayeRbIviFIkmøaMg nigRTwsþIersIuRbUkrbs;m:akSEvl eyIgGac bgðajfa³ ⎛ 1 ⎞ ⎜ α ⎟ f DE ME = ⎜ ⎟ ⎝ AA ⎠ emKuNmaRtdæanenATIenHKW (1/ α EE ) . viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -362
  • 30.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa dMeNIrkarkñúgkarviPaK (Procedure for analysis) CMhanxageRkampþl;nUvviFIsRmab;sg;ExST§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgRbtikmμ kmøaMgkat; nigm:Um:g;Bt;enA Rtg;cMNucmYyenAelIFñwmedayeRbIbec©keTsm‘uyey:eRbsøÚ. ragExSekagT§iBl RbsinebIeKcg;kMNt;ExST§iBlrbs;cMNucmYyenAelIFñwm eKRtUvdklT§PaBTb;Tl;rbs;FñwmeTAnwgGnuKmn_ rbs;ExST§iBl edayCMnYsmkvijnUvtMN. RbsinebI GnuKmn_CakmøaMgRbtikmμbBaÄr eRbI vertical roller guide, RbsinebIGnuKmn_CakmøaMgkat; eRbI sliding device, RbsinebIGnuKmn_Cam:Um:g;Bt; eRbIsnøak;. dak; bnÞúkÉktþaenARtg;tMNedayeGayvamanGMeBIelIFñwmkñúgTisedAviC¢man. sg;ExSekagPaBdabrbs;Fñwm. ExSekagenHCarUbragrbs;ExST§iBlsRmab;Fñwm. témøExSekagT§iBl RbsinebIeKRtUvkarkMNt;témøCaelxrbs;ExST§iBl eKRtUvKNnabMlas;TIéncMNucbnþbnÞab;tambeNþay Fñwm enAeBlEdlFñwmrgbnÞúkÉktþaEdlmanGMeBIenARtg;tMNEdl)aneBalBIxagelI. EcktémøénbMlas; TInImYy²edaybMlas;TIEdl)ankMNt;enARtg;cMNucEdlbnÞúkÉktþamanGMeBI. edayGnuvtþemKuNmaRt- dæan eKnwgTTYl)antémøEdlCaGredaenrbs;ExST§iBl. !0>!!> eKalkarN_mu‘yeyeRbsøÚsRmab;eRKag (Qualitative influence line for frames) eKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚCaviFIy:agelOnkñúgkarsg;ragTUeTArbs;ExST§iBlsRmab;eRKagsMNg;. enAeBlEdleKsÁal;ragExST§iBl eKGackMNt;TItaMgrbs;bnÞúkGefrEdleFVIeGaymanT§iBlénGnuKmn_ ¬kmøaMgRbtikmμ kmøaMgkat; b¤m:Um:g;Bt;¦ FMCageKenAelIeRKagPøam². Ca]TahrN_ rUbragrbs;ExST§iBl sRmab;m:Um:g;viC¢manenARtg;cMNuckNþal I rbs;r:t FG rbs;eRKagenAkñúgrUbTI 10-24a Edlbgðaj edaybnÞat;dac;. dUcenH eKGacdak;bnÞúkrayesμIEtenAelIr:t AB / CD nig FG edIm,IeFVIeGaym:Um:g;viC¢- manenARtg;cMNuc I FMCageK. CamYynwgeRKagrgbnÞúkEbbenH ¬rUbTI 10-24b¦ eKGacviPaKeRKagedIm,I KNnam:Um:g;eRKaHfñak;enARtg;cMNuc I . Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -363
  • 31.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC ]TarhN_ 10-11³ sg;ExST§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgRbtikmμbBaÄrenARtg;cMNuc A sRmab;FñwmenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25a. EI Catémøefr. sg;tMélCaelxral; 2m . dMeNaHRsay³ yklT§PaBrbs;FñwmTb;Tl;nwgkmøaMgRbtikmμ Ay . eKGaceFVIvaeTA)anedayeRbI vertical roller device EdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25b. edayGnuvtþbnÞúkÉktþabBaÄrenARtg;cMNuc A eKTTYl)anrUbragExS T§iBldUceXIjenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25c. edIm,IkMNt;Gredaenrbs;ExST§iBl eyIgnwgeRbIviFIFñwmnimitþ (conjugate beam method). kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;cMNuc A nigcMNuc B enAelIFñwmBit enAeBlrgbnÞúkÉktþaenARtg;cMNuc A RtUv)an viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -364
  • 32.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa bgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25b. FñwmnimitþEdlRtUvKñaRtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25d. cMNaMfaTMrenA Rtg; A' enAEtrkSadUcTMrenARtg; A enAkñúgrUbTI 10-25b BIeRBaH vertical roller device enAelIFñwm nimitþTb;Tl;m:Um:g; b:uEnþminTb;Tl;kmøaMgkat; EdlRtUvKñaeTAnwgbMlas;TI b:uEnþminEmnmMurgVilenARtg;TMr A énFñwmBit ¬rUbTI 10-25c¦. kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMrrbs;FñwmnimitþRtUv)anKNna nigRtUv)anbgðajenA kñúgrUbTI 10-25d. bMlas;TIéncMNucenAelIFñwmBit ¬rUbTI 10-25b¦ k¾RtUv)anKNna. sRmab; B' edaysarminmanm:Um:g;Bt;enAelIFñwmnimitþRtg;cMNuc B' ¬rUbTI 10-25d¦ enaH Δ B = M B' = 0 sRmab; D' / rUbTI 10-25e ∑ M D' = 0 Δ D = M D' = 18 (2) − 1 ⎛ 2 ⎞(2)⎛ 2 ⎞ = 34.67 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ EI 2 ⎝ EI ⎠ ⎝ 3 ⎠ EI sRmab; C ' / rUbTI 10-25f ∑ M C' = 0 ΔC = M C' = 18 (4) − 1 ⎛ 4 ⎞(4)⎛ 4 ⎞ = 61.33 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ EI 2 ⎝ EI ⎠ ⎝ 3 ⎠ EI sRmab; A' / rUbTI 10-25d 72 Δ A = M A' = EI edaysarkmøaMgbBaÄr 1kN manGMeBIenARtg;cMNuc A enAelIFñwmenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25a eFVIeGayman kmøaMgRbtikmμ 1kN enARtg;cMNuc A . bMlas;TIenARtg;cMNuc A ¬ Δ A = 72 / EI ¦ KYrRtUvnwgtémø 1 sRmab;GredaenExST§iBlenARtg;cMNuc A . dUcenH edayEckbMlas;TIEdl)anKNnaedayemKuNenH eyigTTYl)an x Ay A 1 C 0.852 D 0.481 B 0 düaRkaméntémøTaMgenHCaExST§iBlEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-25g. ]TarhN_ 10-12³ sg;ExST§iBlsRmab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc D sRmab;FñwmenAkñúgrUbTI 10- 26a. EI Catémøefr. sg;tMélCaelxral; 3m . Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -365
  • 33.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC dMeNaHRsay³ yklT§PaBrbs;FñwmTb;Tl;nwgkmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc D . eKGaceFVIvaeTA)anedayeRbI roller device EdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-26b. edayGnuvtþbnÞúkkmøaMgkat;ÉktþaenARtg;cMNuc D eKTTYl)anrUbrag ExST§iBldUceXIjenAkñúgrUbTI 10-26c. kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg; A / B nig C enAelIFñwmBit enAeBlrgkmøaMgkat;ÉktþaenARtg;cMNuc D RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-26b. FñwmnimitþEdlRtUvKñaRtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-26d. enATIenH viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -366
  • 34.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa eKRtUvGnuvtþm:Um:g; M D' enARtg;cMNuc D' edIm,IeFVIeGaym:Um:g;Bt;epSgKñaenAxageqVg nigxagsþaMcMNuc D' . m:Um:g;Bt;TaMgenHRtUvKñanwgbMlas;TIxageqVg nigxagsþaMéncMNuc D enAelIFñwmBit ¬rUbTI 10-26c¦. kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr A' / B' / C ' nigm:Um:g; M D' enAelIFñwmnimitþRtUv)anKNna nigRtUv)anbgðaj enAkñúgrUbTI 10-26e. cUrepÞógpÞat;karKNnaeLIgvij. edaysarPaBdac;énm:Um:g;enARtg;cMNuc D' eKRtUvKNnam:Um:g;Bt;EdlenAxagsþaM nigxageqVg cMNuc D' bnþic. sRmab;enAxageqVgcMNuc D' ¬rUbTI 10-26f¦ eyIg)an ∑ M D' L = 0 Δ DL = M D' L = 4.5 (1) − 30 (3) = − 85.5 EI EI EI enAxagsþaMgcMNuc D' ¬rUbTI 10-26g¦ eyIgman ∑ M D' R = 0 Δ DR = M D' R = 4.5 (1) − 30 (3) + 144 = 58.5 EI EI EI EI BIrUbTI 10-26e Δ A = M A' = 0 Δ B = M B' = 0 ΔC = M C' = 0 sMrab;cMNuc E ¬rUbTI10-26b¦ edayeRbIviFImuxkat;enARtg;cMNuc E' EdlRtUvKñaenAelIFñwmnimitþ ¬rUbTI 10-26h¦ eyIgman ∑ M E' = 0 Δ E = M E' = 4.5 (1) − 6 (3) = − 13.5 EI EI EI eKTTYl)anGredaenrbs;ExST§iBledayEcktémøxagelInwgemKuNmaRtdæan M D ' = 144 / EI . eyIg man x VD A 0 DL − 0.594 DR 0.406 B 0 E − 0.0938 C 0 düaRkaméntMélTaMgenHCaExST§iBlEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-26i. ]TarhN_ 10-13³ sg;ExST§iBlsRmab;m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg;cMNuc D sRmab;FñwmenAkñúgrUbTI 10-27a. EI Catémøefr. sg;tMélCaelxral; 3m . Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -367
  • 35.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC dMeNaHRsay³ eKdak;snøak;enARtg;cMNuc D edIm,IdklT§PaBrbs;FñwmEdlTb;Tl;nwgm:Um:g;enARtg;cMNucenH ¬rUbTI 10- 27b¦. edaydak;m:Um:g;ÉktþaviC¢manenARtg; D eyIgTTYl)anExST§iBldUcbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-27c. kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;cMNuc A / B nig C enAelIFñwmBit enAeBlrgm:Um:g;enARtg;cMNuc D RtUv )anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-27b. FñwmnimitþRtUvKña nigkmøaMgRbtikmμrbs;vaRtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10- 27d. eKesñIeGayepÞógpÞat;kmøaMgRbtikmμenAkñúgkrNITaMgBIr. BIrUbTI 10-27d cMNaMfa Δ A = M A' = 0 Δ B = M B' = 0 ΔC = M C' = 0 sRmab;cMNuc D' / rUbTI 10-27e ∑ M D' = 0 Δ D = M D' = 1.5 (1) + 6 (3) = 19.5 EI EI EI sRmab;cMNuc E ' / rUbTI 10-27f ∑ M E' = 0 Δ E = M E' = 1.5 (1) − 2 (3) = 4.5 EI EI EI viPaKeRKOgbgÁúMminGackMNt;edaysþaTictamviFIkmøaMg T.Chhay -368
  • 36.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa bMlas;TImMu (angular displacement) α DD enARtg; D énFñwmBitenAkñúgrUbTI 10-27c RtUv)ankMNt; edaykmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg; D' enAelIFñwmnimitþ. edIm,ITTYl)anGredaenrbs;ExST§iBl eKEcktémø Edl)anKNnaxagelICamYynwgemKuN D' y = 16 / EI Edl x MD A 0 D 1.219 B 0 E − 0.281 C 0 düaRkaméntMélTaMgenHCaExST§iBlEdlbgðajenAkñúgrUbTI 10-27g. Analysis of statically indeterminate structures by the force method T.Chhay -369
  • 37.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC cMeNaT !0>!> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr nigbnÞab;mk !0>%> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr A nig B . sg;düaRkamm:Um:g;sMrab;Fñwm. snμt;faTMrenA A Ca EI CatMélefr. TMrbgáb; nigTMr B CaTMrkl;. EI CatMélefr. !0>@> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr. snμt;faTMr !0>^> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr bnÞab;mk enA A CaTMrbgáb; nigTMr B CaTMrkl;. yk E = sg;düaRkamkmøaMgkat; nigdüaRkamm:Um;g;Bt;. 200GPa . m:Um:g;niclPaBsMrab;kMNat;Ggát; EI CatMélefr. nImYy²RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUb. !0>&> FñwmRtUv)anRTedayTMrsnøak;enARtg;cMNuc !0>#> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr A / B nig A RTedayrWus½rEdlmankMraj (stiffness) k enA C bnÞab;mksg;düaRkamkMlaMgkat; nigm:Um:g;Bt; Rtg; B nigRTedayTMrkl;enARtg;cMNu C . kMNt; sMrab;Fñwm. EI CatMélefr. kmøaMgrWus½rGnuvtþeTAelIFñwm. EI CatMélefr. !0>$> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr A nigTMr B . !0>*> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr. snμt; B CaTMr snμt;TMrenARtg;cMNuc A Gnuvtþm:Um:g;Bt;eTAelIFñwm. snøak; ehIy A nig C CaTMrkl;. EI CatMélefr. EI CatMélefr. !0>(> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr bnÞab;mk sg;düaRkamm:Um;g;Bt;. snμt; A CaTMrsnøak; ehIy cMeNaT T.Chhay -370
  • 38.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa B nig C CaTMrkl;. EI CatMélefr. !0>!0> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr. snμt;TMr A CaTMr snøak; ehIy B nig C CaTMrkl;. EI CatMélefr. !0>!$> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMrenAelIFñwm. CBa¢aMg enARtg;cMNuc A cl½teLIgelI 30mm . snμt; fa A CaTMrsnøak; ehIyTMr B nig C CaTMrkl; . yk E = 200GPa nig I = 90(106 )mm4 . !0>!!> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr. snμt;TMr A CaTMr snøak; ehIy B nig C CaTMrkl;. EI CatMélefr. !0>!%> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr bnÞab;sg;düaRkam !0>!@> kMNt;PaBdabenARtg;cug B rbs;r)arEdk. m:Um:g;. snμt;faTMr A CaTMrsnøak; ehIy B nig C rWus½rmankMraj k = 2 N / mm . r)arEdkmanTTwg CaTMr. EI mantémøefr. 5mm nigkMBs; 10mm . ehIy cUrsg;düaRkam kmøaMgkat; nigm:Um:g;Bt;sMrab;r)arEdkenH. yk E = 200GPa . !0>!^> sg;düaRkamm:Um:g;sMrab;Fñwm. EI mantémø efr. snμt;faTMr A CaTMrbgáb; ehIy B nig C Ca !0>!#> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr bnÞab;mksg; TMr. düaRkamm:Um:g;. m:Um:g;niclPaBsMrab;kMNat;Ggát; nImYy²RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUb. snμt;fa A nig C CaTMrkl; nig B CaTMrsnøak;. yk E = 200GPa . Problems T.Chhay -371
  • 39.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC !0>!&> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMrbgáb; A !0>@!> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr bnÞab;mksg; nig B . EI mantMélefr. düaRkamm:Um:g;sMrab;Ggát;nImYy². snμt; A nig B CaTMrsnøak; ehIytMNenARtg;cMNuc C CatMN bgáb;. EI mantMélefr. !0>!*> sg;düaRkamm:Um:g;Bt;sMrab;FñwmTMrbgáb;. EI mantMélefr. !0>@@> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr bnÞab;mksg; düaRkamm:Um:g;sMrab;Ggát;nImYy². EI mantMél !0>!(> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr. EI mantMél efr. efr. !0>@#> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr bnÞab;mksg; !0>@0> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr. EI mantMél düaRkamm:Um:g;sMrab;Ggát;nImYy². EI mantMél efr. efr. cMeNaT T.Chhay -372
  • 40.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa !0>@$> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr RbsinebITMrRtg; C !0>@&> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgGgát;nImYy²rbs; truss . RtUv)anrujeLIgelI 4mm . yk E = 200GPa RkLaépÞmuxkat;rbs;Ggát;nImYy²RtUv)anbgðaj / I = 250(106 )mm4 . enAkñúgrUb. yk E = 200GPa . snμt;Ggát; RtUv)antP¢ab;edaysnøak;. !0>@%> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμTMr A nig D . m:Um:g; niclPaBrbs;kMNat;Ggát;RtUv)anbgðajenAkñúgrUb. yk E = 200GPa . !0>@*> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgGgát;nImYy²rbs; truss EdltP¢ab;edaytMNsnøak;. EA mantMélefr. !0>@^> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgGgát;nImYy²rbs; truss . !0>@(> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;Ggát; HG rbs; RkLaépÞmuxkat;rbs;Ggát;nImYy²RtUv)anbgðaj truss . EA mantMélefr. enAkñúgrUb. snμt;Ggát;RtUv)antP¢ab;edaysnøak;. yk E = 200GPa . !0>#0> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;Ggát; HB rbs; truss éncMeNaT !0>@(. EA mantMélefr. Problems T.Chhay -373
  • 41.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC !0>#!> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;Ggát; HG . EA man tMélefr. !0>#@> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;Ggát; BE . EA mantMélefr. !0>#%> eRKOgbgÁúMRTbnÞúkdUcbgðajenAkñúgrUb. cUrsg;düaRkamm:Um:g;Bt;sMrab;FñwmnImYy². yk I = 100(10 6 )mm 4 sMrab;Fñwm nig A = 200mm 2 énsMrab;Edkr)ar. Ggát;TaMgGs;eFVIGMBIEdkEdl man E = 200GPa . !0>##> kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;Ggát; DF én truss . EA mantMélefr. !0>#^> eKeRbI queen-post trussed beam edIm,I RTbnÞúkrayesμI 60kN / m . kMNt;kmøaMgEdlekIt !0>#$> eKBüÜrcugFñwmkugs‘uledayEdkr)ar AC mankñúgr)arEdkTaMgR)aM. eKminKitkMras;rbs;Fñwm EdlmanGgát;p©it 25mm . ehIyFñwmenHmanTMr nigsnμt;faGgát; truss RtUv)antP¢ab;eTAnwgFñwm bgáb;enARtg;cMNuc B . kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;Edk edaytMNsnøak;. ehIyminKitT§iBlkmøaMgsgát; r)arEdlbNþalBIbnÞúkrayesμI 60kN / m . E = tamG½kS nigkmøaMgkat;enAkñúgFñwm. RkLaépÞ 200GPa sMrab;Fñwm nigEdkr)ar. muxkat;rbs;Edkr)arnImYy²KW 1800mm2 ehIy sMrab;Fñwm I = 235(106 )mm 4 . yk E = cMeNaT T.Chhay -374
  • 42.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa 200GPa . kat;enAkñúgFñwm. Fñwm I b = 200(106 )mm4 ehIy sMrab;Edkr)arnImYy² A = 100mm 2 . yk E = 200GPa . !0>#&> eKeRbI king-post trussed beam edIm,I RTbnÞúkcMNuc 200kN EdlmanGMeBIenAkNþal ElVg. kMNt;kmøaMgkñúgrbs;r)arEdkTaMgbI. Edk r)arnImYy²manRkLaépÞmuxkat; 1250mm 2 . snμt;faBYkvaRtUv)antP¢ab;edaytMNsnøak;. eK minKitkMras;rbs;Fñwm nigT§iBlkmøaMgsgát; tam G½kSenAkñúgFñwmeT. yk E = 200GPa sMrab;Fñwm !0>$!> sg;ExST§iBlsMrab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg; nigEdkr)ar. ehIy I AB = 150(106 )mm 4 . cMNuc C . bgðajCatémøelxral; 5m . snμt; TMr B CaTMrkl;. EI mantémøefr. !0>$@> sg;ExST§iBlsMrab;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg; !0>#*> kMNt;m:Um:g;GtibrmaenAkñúgFñwmén cMNuc C . bgðajCatémøelxral; 5m . EI man cMeNaT !0>#&. témøefr. !0>#(> kMNt;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg;TMr C . EI mantMélefrsMrab;FñwmTaMgBIr. !0>$#> sg;ExST§iBlsMrab;kmøaMgkat;enARtg; cMNuc B . bgðajCatémøelxral; 5m . snμt;TMr enARtg; A CaTMrkl; nig C CaTMrbgáb;. EI man témøefr. !0>$0> eKRTFñwmkugs‘ul AB CamYynwgEdkr)ar bEnßmcMnYnBIr. kMNt;kmøaMgenAkñúgEdkr)ar nImYy². eKminKitkmøaMgsgát;tamG½kS nigkmøaMg Problems T.Chhay -375
  • 43.
    Department of CivilEngineering NPIC !0>$$> sg;ExST§iBlsMrab;kmøaMgRbtikmμenARtg; bnÞúkGefrrayesμIEdleFVIeGayekItmanGnuKmn_ cMNuc A éncMeNaT !0>$#. viC¢manGtibrma. snμt;faFñwmmanTMrbgáb;enARtg; !0>$%> KUrRBagnUvExST§iBlsMrab;m:Um:g;Bt;enA cMNuc F . Rtg;cMNuc D edayeRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚ. kMNt;m:Um:g;viC¢manGtibrmaenARtg;cMNuc D Edl bNþalBIbnÞúkGefrrayesμI 5kN / m . EI man témøefr. snμt; A CaTMrsnøak; ehIy B nig C !0>$(> eRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,Isg;rag CaTMrkl;. TUeTAénExST§iBlsMrab; (a) m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg; cMNuc A nig (b) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc B . !0>$^> KUrRBagnUvExST§iBlsMrab;kmøaMgkat;enA Rtg;cMNuc B . RbsinebIFñwmenHrgbnÞúkGefrray !0>%0> eRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,Isg;rag esμI 6kN / m cUrkMNt;kmøaMgkat;viC¢manGtibrma TUeTAénExST§iBlsMrab; (a) m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg; enARtg;cMNuc B . snμt; A CaTMrsnøak;. EI man cMNuc A nig (b) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc B . témøefr. !0>$&> KUrRBagnUvExST§iBlsMrab;m:Um:g;Bt;enA Rtg;cMNuc B éncMeNaT !0>$^. RbsinebIFñwmenH !0>%!> eRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,Isg;rag rgbnÞúkGefrray esμI 6kN / m cUrkMNt;m:Um:g;Bt; TUeTAénExST§iBlsMrab; (a) m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg; viC¢manGtibrma enARtg;cMNuc B . snμt; A Ca cMNuc A nig (b) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc B . TMrsnøak;. EI man témøefr. !0>$*> KUrRBagnUvExST§iBlsMrab; (a) kmøaMg RbtikmμbBaÄrenARtg;cMNuc C (b) m:Um:g;Bt;enA Rtg;cMNuc B nig (c) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc E . enAkñúgkrNInImYy² cUrbgðajTItaMgEdlRtUvdak; cMeNaT T.Chhay -376
  • 44.
    mhaviTüal½ysMNg;sIuvil viTüasßanCatiBhubec©keTskm<úCa !0>%@> eRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,Isg;rag !0>%$> eRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,Isg;rag TUeTAénExST§iBlsMrab; (a) m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg; TUeTAénExST§iBlsMrab; (a) m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg; cMNuc A nig (b) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc B . cMNuc A nig (b) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc B . !0>%#> eRbIeKalkarN_m‘uyey:eRbsøÚedIm,Isg;rag TUeTAénExST§iBlsMrab; (a) m:Um:g;Bt;enARtg; cMNuc A nig (b) kmøaMgkat;enARtg;cMNuc B . Problems T.Chhay -377